The Riding Horse From The Barn At Adler Ranch : Mahogany Bay Tennessee Walker

[@jwfanatic]

I love using this horse until the end of the game because it fits so well "This ones ok, but aint no Boadeciea." It makes the end where Arthur whispers "Thank you" into his horses ear hit so much harder because it shows the development of his bond with the horse

[@hrdman2luv]

I always set it free on the plains and take a nag into the last 2 missions.

[@CrystalSanchez094]

the fact that this horse didn't even spook or flinch during shootouts makes it all the more reason that it's one of the few horses suited for Arthur

[@shadowheart-e7l]

This horse is one of a kind, I really loved it because it's the first horse Arthur gets in the game. And also love the unique coat.

[@HighClassMortal]

I remember one time i was riding around New Elizabeth and I ran into a huge grizzly. Literally ran into it. I got scared and kinda just sat there waiting for my horse to buck me off but he didnt. In my panic I ran back into the bear snd he still didnt buck me off. Best horse ever. I love him. Bravest horse in the game. He's trampled through packs of wolves for arthur. They're the perfect pair.

[@odog575]

The warped brindle thoroughbred from that ambush is a greatly underrated horse.

[@avapictures0]

I like Buell too, has one of the prettiest coats and comes from one of the best side missions in the game and actually has a great backstory. He's worth keeping till the end. I also like the gigantic shire that Hosea gives you in chapter 2.

[@RockworthRDR2]

Understood, but to my knowledge you can’t get buell until chapter 6. So a very large portion of the game is played without him. He’s definitely a good horse though.

[@avapictures0]

@@RockworthRDR2 Good point.

[@earnem4175]

Another Buell Stan. Just please stop talking about Buell, the White Arabian takes the stake for the most beautiful horse, and the Mahogany Bay Tennesee Walker is more suited for the life of Crime. Since it was an O'driscolls steed to begin with. And you acquire it from the beginning.

[@montv291]

I mean, the white arabian looks ok. It would look a lot cooler if it wasn't basically the size of a pony. I only ever break that horse when I'm already in that area and need a second horse to carry back pelts. Gets sold immediately after.

[@leonievw2466]

​@@earnem4175I find the arabians the ugliest in the game. The black one is allright... I would take this TW over an Arab everyday

[@nightwolf9375]

I have this horse stabled on my Arthur freeroam save after selling it immediately on most of my playthroughs, but I just love my Chestnut Pinto Kentucky Saddler too much to use any other horse for too long. It might not be the best horse but it’s one of the most beautiful horse coats imo.

[@RockworthRDR2]

That’s what I like to hear. That’s what it’s about, enjoying the game and enjoying whatever horse suits your interest, regardless of stats or popularity. The chestnut pinto coat stands out, catches your attention every time.

[@SupaMan2122]

We need more stables Oerthur!

[@playboieric]

Can’t go wrong with the black shire too

[@RockworthRDR2]

Facts. I made a video about the black shire. Check it out kzbin.info/www/bejne/gKG9YoSAoLqEl6M

[@themagnus2919]

I'm a BIG fan of that horse.

[@ThorGodofThunder420]

Yeah I kept it my 2nd play through. It's hard to keep stable space though because I get a missouri foxtrotter & black Arabian in chapter 2, then dark bay turk in chapter 3, plus I have the ultimate edition horse which is one of my absolute favorite. Great stats. Reverse dapple black thoroughbred 🤤

[@playboieric]

@@ThorGodofThunder420 I too get the mft and turkoman form the braithewaites (butchered tf outta the spelling) but I’ve come to just keep the shire or the brown andalusian that’s a magnificent horse

[@Dustyphoto915]

Can’t go wrong but can go slow. 🙂

[@cesar7537]

today 31/12/23 i just finished the game... i'm not a horse knowledge man, but i kept this horse because i feel that he would trust me from the beggining of the story. i have never changed him, and i've never named him because i thought his name was "tennesee walker"... you guys have no idea how i cried when that thing happened, as while arthur thank him, i was like "shu shu shhhh boy... it's okay, easy, boy..." as if that was my own horse. i dont know if i'm mental, but that hitted me so damn bad...

[@RockworthRDR2]

Hey man, you played the game YOUR way. A lot of players got emotional lol. Kudos. Happy gaming.

[@JM-pm6gn]

How did you manage to keep that horse, after the mission in which Hosea makes you buy another horse?

[@AndreasMic]

Lol after finishing the game i started a new one and i stayed in chapter 2 so Arthur won't get TB and the horse won't die 😂

[@DJFrankeeTNT]

Arthur’s first bonding with a horse. I’ve played 5 times now and I promise the 6th time I’ll keep the horse because of your video 😊👍🏻

[@RockworthRDR2]

Wow, 5 times. Glad to hear. What horse did you use as your very first playthrough?

[@Random-km3iu]

​@@RockworthRDR2 I used this same horse

[@LethalSaliva]

I didn't know this horse is the only one of its color. When I first got this horse, I named him "Belonged to O'Driscoll." Then we both died together, and I ended up with a chesnut or gold palomino. Well I was disappointed, so I sold it.

[@themagnus2919]

The Black Shire horse Hosea gives you has far more potential gameplay wise. It can trample almost anything and anyone.

[@SupaMan2122]

Is that a unique color too

[@Clark42EoC]

My bro slammed head on into another rider and horse full speed last night by accident riding the black shire. The other horse and rider instantly died while my bro and the shire were fine.

[@rrrriiiisha]

My favorite horse breed in the game! I believe they are of true size, especially when you see how horses look next to men in the Yellowstone series. Other breeds in the game seem either too small (as if they were supposed to be ponies), or too large, unlike the draft horses. Therefore, my love in the game is given to Tennessee Walker horses and american standardbred. Thouroughbreds are beautiful, but they are giants 😂

[@RockworthRDR2]

Interesting point of view. Yes those two breeds look great, people usually don’t favor them in the game because of their average stats but i think it’s best to enjoy whatever horse you like regardless of stats or popularity. And those breeds get the job done just like others.

[@Clark42EoC]

Actually I went Deep dive into this and all the horses are insanely accurate to real world hand height. An Arabian is typically 14 to 15 hands tall while something like a shire can be up to 20 hands tall.

[@SuicidalH]

I love love love the coat on this horse, but I don't like smaller breeds. I decided to go with sooty buckskin dutch warmblood instead. It's the best looking horse imo. Also there's plenty of unique horses in this game. The raven black shire, Buell and numerous horses that can me only found in the wild.

[@RockworthRDR2]

Yes it has a nice distinctive coat. Well since you like bigger breeds, I made a video on the biggest breed ( the unique raven black)Check it out if you’re interested kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWG6fYSNqa2Brrs

[@G1NZOU]

I love the Sooty Buckskin, I just wish it was slightly faster, so I normally end up with the Dark Bay Turkoman, not as nice markings but still a beautiful colour. The Perlino Andalusian looks fantastic after the rain too.

[@jacobroden9718]

This is my favorite horse in the game. Iv had five playthroughs i lost it twice once fell off roanoak ridge and died. And another time caught fire and died just a few days ago. Its just a beautiful and unique horse. Now i have the black arabian from saint denis ferrier. Its just not the same without that horse in story... Also i wait till the epilogue to get buell.

[@RockworthRDR2]

Nice. Seem like you like the black coats on horses, I do as well. You went from extremely big to extremely small lol. What do you think about the black American standardbred?

[@bronzymcgrady1159]

I kept my Shire and my Tennessee walker, also got cerberus the turkoman. Got Buell for arthur and John, plus a dappled pinto missouri fox trotter as my temp horse since you can have 4 to 5 horses in story mode...all saved for arthur at chapter 6 before the gang breakup. In the epilogue john has Rachel, Buell, a dappled pinto missouri fox trotter, silver Turkoman and a murfree brood tennessee walker saved.

[@SupaMan2122]

Since I could only pick five I did Buell, Rachel , MFT, Turkoman, Brindle Thouroughbred

[@hrdman2luv]

I've tried them all. This horse is the best one.

[@riccouchman5604]

Definitely the horse with the most beautiful coat in the game in my opinion. Thanks for sharing, brother. And by the way, a lot of players tend to go for the supposed faster horses in the game. I have long found out that horse speed in the game is irrelevant; in all the stranger races and in the race against Dutch’s Count those races can be won with far slower horses. Furthermore, every horse in the game will at some point (even at full bonding) buck the rider off in an encounter with bear, wolf, cougar, or alligator 😬

[@RockworthRDR2]

Yeah the speed of a horse isn’t a game breaker at all, you can win races fairly easy just like you said. And yes, they will all buck you off. Some just waaay quicker than others

[@fortytwo4-2]

can confirm. My American Standardbred, Toasty was at max bonding w/ me the whole game and she still bucked me

[@agoodballet]

I’ve had several horses that wouldn’t buck me off, I’ve shot countless Cougar, Wolf, Bear and can ride through the swamps no problem. Like the video says it might have something to do with the individual player. My first couple play throughs I had horses that would buck me off and flee all the time and it was frustrating.

[@daswolffire6466]

​@agoodballet war horses like turkomans an Andalusians are a bit braver, especially when compared to Arabians

[@andand-yx7xt]

Depends on the breed. If you have something like thoroughbread than yes, but the hungarian halfbreed woud never buck you

[@bloodyrose8520]

I had this horse but it suddenly disappeared one day and was replaced with a brown horse,I even rode around looking for it for a long time,but to no avail.I now have a Hungarian Halfbred but miss my Tennessee walker a lot.

[@u_TurkeYT]

My headcanon is Silver Dapple Pinto from Albert Masson's mission is Arthur's official horse. Because that was the only horse that Arthur liked after Boadicea

[@Kvs-vf9nt]

Am I the only one that likes the wukd mustangs? They're good in gunfights.

[@RockworthRDR2]

No. I like them too

[@alswearengine4867]

Mustangs rule. It’s a shame we can’t get the buckskin coat in story mode.

[@iim4xii129]

I kept this horse with me up to the last mission. I called him Trampoline. I also kept the black Shire. I called him Cyrus. Had level 4 bonding on both.

[@Funnymonkey101]

How do you keep the horse? Everytime I come back from the Hosea mission after selling the black shire, the Adler ranch horse is gone

[@RockworthRDR2]

It’s at the stables.

[@Funnymonkey101]

@@RockworthRDR2 the horse you get at Adler ranch? I thought you leave it at camp after putting the saddle on the shire horse

[@Funnymonkey101]

@@RockworthRDR2 I tried putting the adler horse in the stables but they must not be available after the hosea mission.

[@RockworthRDR2]

Whatever the reason is you can't seem to locate the horse, just go to the stable and it should be there, unless you got the horse k!lled, etc

[@Th_Uslss_Indvdl]

I’ve used this horse in all of my playthroughs. However, I’m doing a playthrough right now where I want to do everything I can as Arthur, including filling up my compendium, and the horse is getting on my nerves when encountering predators.

[@AndreasMic]

I think Arthur's horse has to be thi silver pinto fox trotter! Think about it! The lady has it and it keeps dying on her so she is not taking good care of her! On the other hand on the photography mission the horse wouldn't let anyone ride it or get close to it besides Arthur! And also listen how Arthur talks about her when she sees her for the first time :) So in my mind she is Arthur's horse 🥰

[@skrillexplayzchannel7407]

I think arthur would also prefer dutch warmblood, silver Hungarian halfbred or shire horse in early chapter 2 when you go to stable with hosea in valentine, these are probably canon horses that arthur would likely prefer to ride if it's up to him

[@roberthuffmann8204]

Many times I e been tempted to keep this horse

[@heckyeah4826]

i love this horse!! i like the symmetry of starting and ending the game with him; i named him texas ranger

[@RockworthRDR2]

Good one. And yeah it just feels right keeping the horse, even if you stable it and dont use it as your main horse. But i do know that everybody view things differently

[@benne45635]

Ich habe meinen Samoa genannt, ich werde ihm bis zum Schluss treu bleiben und auf ihn Acht geben!🙂

[@rebeccawilliams4485]

i wish they had more stall space in story mode thats my only real issue with story mode as far as online gose they need to bring more of the horses from story mode to online mode they also need to fix the dang stable and hunting wagon issue other then all that i still love the game i play on xbox one

[@CipherNine]

Even though it’s stats aren’t impressive, I’ve edited its stats with mods to make it hold up with the rest of the gang horses. I wanted to make it competent but not overpowered. Now it’s my favorite!

[@Red_xcvii]

You know, it makes sense to keep this horse till the end. Boadecia dying or getting lost was the old ruthless Arthur dying. The Tennessee Walker, was the beginning of the new Arthur

[@AndreasMic]

I started a new playthrough and i saved the horse!! I can say that it is a great horse!! I will keep him and we will ride together on the final ride after selling all other horses! We started together so we will finish together :)

[@tioamaury1012]

Decent horse but i still prefer the silver daple pinto. You can get it as Arthur very easy by doing the mission i think it was called Arcadia for begginers, more specifically in part 3

[@robwatts5281]

I have to buy it but the Dark Bay Andalusian is always my go to… not too fast but awesome in a fight or hunting predators

[@RockworthRDR2]

War horses, great breed. But I have this thing where I avoid buying horses lol, unless it’s for the sake of me bringing you all content. Did you know you could get the other two coats (rose gray and perlino) for free? And they have better stats too. I’ll likely make a video about them at a later time.

[@robwatts5281]

@@RockworthRDR2 I know about the perilino and love it for it stats but it looks too similar to Dutches horse and I like the darker horses. I didn’t know you could get the other one for free. Would definitely watch a vid if you decide to make it!

[@RockworthRDR2]

@@robwatts5281 It’s good that you like what you like regardless of stats. The point is to enjoy the game, have fun and ride whatever horse suit your interests, like what you’re doing. So many players seem so mesmerized by Dutch’s horse, it’s nice knowing there are players who think outside of the norm.

[@robwatts5281]

@@RockworthRDR2 Ya, it’s pretty crazy. Most people just ride straight for the white Arabian. Good horse but too tiny. If I don’t use the Dark Bay Andalusian, I use the chocolate roan Dutch warmblood hack from the stables during the Hosea mission or find the prospector and get a sooty buckskin warmblood.

[@RockworthRDR2]

@@robwatts5281 Nice. You could also get one from the drunk man in Valentine. Mislead him and follow him, a sooty buckskin kicks him

[@scofield901]

I particularly like the dutch warmblood too, that we can buy in chapter 2 in Valentine's stable, and no other NPC rides it during the game

[@eyeslo4206]

Free sooty buckskin warmblood from the prospector npc. You can easily steal it while he's panning for gold. Not the fastest horse but I'm more concerned about my horse being brave. I've been surrounded by five wolves and not been thrown. Horse is a jumping fool too. Can't tell you how many times I thought I was about to ride her to certain death and she just jumped big boulders or landed what should have been a big fall off a ledge. I'm never getting off this horse.

[@Mahmood-v8n]

The mahogany bay Tennessee walker is my favourite horse in the game I never switch it for any other horse and I always named it Redemption and the black shire horse Hosea gives u I always name it Matthews as a honour to Hosea cuz he dies

[@gollygeewillickers]

Heres a tutorial on how to get the Silver Dapple Pinto Missouri Fox Trotter for Arthur!! The 3rd albert mason mission gives you the opportunity to get the silver dapple pinto Missouri Fox Trotter if you play it right.. First, you have to make sure you're tracking it in eagle eye when the cutscene where he snaps the photo is initiated. Immediately skip the cutscene as fast as you can, and re-enter eagle eye. The track should still be there for you to focus on, and once you are on its trail, you're gonna be in for the most stress inducing chase of your life. The tracking meter runs out quicker the faster you ride so you'll have to constantly go in and out of eagle eye to keep focused on the tracks. If you're lucky, youll finally catch up to it around Roanoke Ridge, cause its so thick with trees that the horse gets stuck around that area.. so when you finally see the SDP, theres only one way to mount it, the game will not allow you to rope it or mount it normally, you're gonna have to ride alongside it and wait for the 'Jump to Horse' prompt to pop up. Btw, this is VERY challenging to do but it is possible. Now, once you've jumped on its back and bonded with it, DO NOT get off the horse cause you wont be able to climb back on. Just ride him to the nearest stables and saddle him up, once thats done, save your game and reload it so then youll be able to mount him normally. There used to be a few loophole glitches for arthur to get that horse, but theyve all been patched... all but one. Hope this helps anyone who's looking for the rarest horse in the game!

[@RockworthRDR2]

I appreciate the info but I’m already familiar with obtaining that horse, it’s actually my personal main horse for Arthur lol. I don’t use the eagle eye method, and I don’t exploit a glitch to get it either. I get it during the mission you referred to. I’m definitely doing a video on it in the near future.

[@gollygeewillickers]

@@RockworthRDR2 I figured you'd be familiar with the method as well. I make it my main every playthrough too haha! I suppose saying it's a glitch is the wrong wording, but the game certainly doesn't intend for you to get him in a normal manner. Guess I'll have to watch your video on it cause that horse hauls ass and the only way I know where it's going is with eagle eye.

[@RockworthRDR2]

@@gollygeewillickers Lol it’s definitely a way without the eagle eye method. When I said I don’t use a glitch, I was referring to the method players use when they sh0ot the lady from a distance when she spawns with the Missouri fox trotter

[@G1NZOU]

I just got the Fox Trotter from that mission yesterday, first time I got one on a playthrough was the Biscuit glitch but they seem to have patched that one. The Albert Mason one there was a lot of frustration involved trying to get alongside if to jump on, even though I had an Arabian with good handling my horse would just decide to go the opposite way around a tree and move away from where the Fox Trotter was going. But it paid off, got it fed and stabled.

[@gollygeewillickers]

@@G1NZOU hell yeah way to go. Idk why but that horse really seems to match up nice with arthur.

[@raybandzz3582]

The Mustangs are a great horse I have the raven black shire boy named Sinful Saint and my Mustang girl named Shelby and she’s Grullo Dun

[@RockworthRDR2]

You ever managed to catch a tiger striped bay?

[@raybandzz3582]

@@RockworthRDR2 no I didn’t maybe I could catch one and hold it in the stable lol

[@raybandzz3582]

@@RockworthRDR2 the grullo dun almost looks silver

[@startRED]

I'm in doubt between this one and Buell, but I always use this one for Arthur and Buell for John, unfortunately there's no way to keep the first one in the epilogue :/

[@Lachausis]

Anyone knows how to keep it after Hosea's "Pursued by a Bruised Ego" mission?

[@Dustyphoto915]

It’s aiiiiight. So many great horses in this game.

[@RockworthRDR2]

Lol, indeed partner.

[@sethcaluag]

Can't go wrong with Winton Holmes' Bay Morgan too, i kept it after he died.

[@The_Real_Drink]

Recently, I started a new playthrough, and decided to keep this boy all the way to end. I named him Alexander, because, to me, it fit. It's a strong name, fit for a king.

[@GreenWolf2k]

I always keep this boah and name him Uno. He's a good horse. Though I never have used him throughout a whole playthrough. Maybe one day he'll be the one I ride with to the end.

[@charlie_rockabilly]

It is the second video that I see from this channel related to horses and I am surprised that nobody has asked it before, what is the name of the song? It's amazing

[@manz3x]

Nahhhh the chocolate roan Dutch warm blood is the PERFECT horse at max stats its a perfect mix of high health high stamina 7 speed it’s the second biggest horse in the game it’s brave as hell

[@chater60]

I still mainly use Hosea's Shire that he wanted me to sell

[@RockworthRDR2]

I made a video about the black shire kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWG6fYSNqa2Brrs

[@andand-yx7xt]

I usually use this horse until the horse shepherding mission with Albert Mason, then I get the Silver dapple pinto Fox trotter. I think its the best horse for Arthur considering he points at it like he is seeing a Ferrari. It also makes sense since Dutch and Hosea have Arabian and turkoman, then Arthur has a fox trotter

[@RockworthRDR2]

I agree. The silver dapple pinto is usually my main horse, I feel like it’s Arthur’s preferred “canon” horse once he acquires it because of how he reacts to it when he sees it, like you mentioned.

[@Jorja_47]

In my first play through i used it right until the end and cried when it died 😢

[@RockworthRDR2]

I understand. Good thing is you can always replay it and continue the experience. Now you just know what to expect

[@Jorja_47]

@@RockworthRDR2 before the last mission i now make sure to ride my horse around the map and give it all its treats

[@rdr.erased]

When I played for the first time I used that black raven shire till the end. And that on stable. He was mr adler horse or o"driscolls?

[@RockworthRDR2]

O’Driscolls

[@razeenab4549]

Can someone please help me 🙏🏻😭 how to keep it after hosea's mission please 🥺

[@RockworthRDR2]

It’s in the stable. Just go get it.

[@razeenab4549]

@@RockworthRDR2 thanks man appreciate it boah 🐴 🤠

[@kentarop]

I have a braithwaite turkoman, which i find very unique as it cant be obtained without glitches, and its very pretty to have a letter on a fine horse

[@RockworthRDR2]

The glitch is a good way to get the dark bay turkoman early, (Cerberus). I may be wrong but doesn’t the brand (letter) disappear once you “own” him?

[@kentarop]

@@RockworthRDR2 not for me, maybe for others

[@sandrabroders5615]

I took that horse 3 times. Sometimes the brand letter stays the whole chapter. Sometines it's gone after I made him mine. I love that this horse is really brave against predators

[@jonasmith7797]

1:46 I sure as hell wish it wasn’t exclusive to Arthur and you could buy it as John

[@RockworthRDR2]

Yeah unfortunately John can’t ride this horse

[@NateBelgarde-ui5pw]

I was doing a mission and I ran into another one of the exact same horse

[@Smokinroco]

It's a painted donkey 🫏.....

[@CoryLance]

I hated how slow it felt, and yes it’s braver than most fast horses but I’ll stick to a mustang if I want a medium speed brave horse

[@ExpectedBoy]

Aaaaaand another horse I sold and shouldn't have! 😂

[@4la0y93]

same here ☹️

[@LIrrazabal12345]

i love this horse but the small white spot on his back bothers me

[@roblopez9296]

If only you could keep this horse after the Hosea mission when he gives you the shire horse.

[@AndreasMic]

You do keep the horse after the mission! It will be in the stables after you buy the new horse and you will have 2 horses

[@Richtofen-gy9cj]

I'm trying to hold onto the Mahogany Bay Tennessee Walker and Raven Black Shire as long as possible but they're holding slots that could be filled by better horses

[@RockworthRDR2]

Lol, I get it. There are a lot of good horses in the game, enjoy as many as you please. Its about having fun and enjoying the experience. Im just here to showcase the value the game (and horses) have to offer. So if your Arthur desire ‘better’ horses by your standards, go for it.

[@Richtofen-gy9cj]

@@RockworthRDR2 My third horse is the Silver Dapple Pinto (Albert Mason method) and the fourth is the Perlino Andalusian, i would've liked the Strawberry Roan Ardennes more but the exploit doesn't work for me, might swap the Andalusian for the Braithwaite Turkoman later

[@Richtofen-gy9cj]

@@RockworthRDR2 I know, it's just knowing it's unique makes it painful to sell

[@RockworthRDR2]

⁠@@Richtofen-gy9cj you got a good lineup. I’m considering making a video about the strawberry roan glitch, it’s very wishy-washy to trigger but satisfying once you achieve it.

[@MeepmcarthurtheSECOND]

Got hit by a train 😂

[@irkjustice5600]

I don't remember where I found it, but I played through the game on a red Arabian.

[@RockworthRDR2]

They spawn at the west of Lake Owanjila

[@RockworthRDR2]

If you enjoy the video, please subscribe to the channel.

[@lynette50]

I usually unalive my walker right at start of chapter 2 after level 1 bonding with either a stolen or tamed wildie. You can then access the stables early. Just cant get the grooming brush until after Hosea mission

[@RockworthRDR2]

Is there a reason you’d rather do it that way instead of doing the Hosea mission? The mission is practically at the beginning of chapter 2 so it wouldn’t take that long to complete it

[@montv291]

​@RockworthRDR2 some people like to see how much of the game they can complete, while doing as little of the story missions as possible.

[@Celisar1]

There is no word as „to unalive“ and if you mean kill then just SAY it!

[@montv291]

@@Celisar1 why?

[@Ezekiel-Tamjidi]

Everyone knows his name is frank and he has telekinetic abilities that aid western Jesus

[@nathanaelharwood7512]

Admirable that some people keep the horse till Arthur’s death. Me personally I sell him and the Black Shire because I wanna get something better. I get the Dutch Warmblood after I sell the Shire in Valentine at the stable. If the Dutch Warmblood however doesn’t satisfy me, I get the striped thoroughbred from the lady that wants to race me. I kill her and take it. This Tennessee Walker is a good horse at the start of the game, but I like War and Race Horse Breeds the best.

[@RockworthRDR2]

That Dutch warmblood is very expensive at the beginning of the game, you must do a lot of grinding before the mission with Hosea. Good picks though, it’s about getting whatever horses you desire and just enjoying the game. And that thoroughbred is a very good horse.

[@nathanaelharwood7512]

@RockworthRDR2 ohh yeah, I do!! You can easily make $4,500 at the start of Chapter 2. You may not know about this, but there's a hidden gold bar in Rhodes. Edit: Arthur also said too that he did kind of liked that horse. So I can understand why some people want to keep him.

[@fortytwo4-2]

on my first playthrough, I named mine Bob. Unfortunately, I thought you had to get rid of him when you go to the stables with Hosea and was upset because I had fully bonded with him. Now on my third playthrough, I'm gonna try to keep him until the end and name him Billy in honor of Bob.

[@RockworthRDR2]

I think bob would appreciate that

[@aee14]

accidentally sold him 😢

[@RockworthRDR2]

It’s all good. I always say there are plenty horses to choose to bond with. But it’s always good to keep separate recent save files as you progress throughout the game to avoid these types of concerns

[@beastmaster6960]

I'm happy with my Arabians & fox trotter

[@RockworthRDR2]

Fair enough. Stay tuned

[@bigboygary4809]

i stabled it as soon as i could and have it as john

[@RockworthRDR2]

To my knowledge John doesn’t have access to Arthur’s stabled horses

[@Ashgza]

​@@RockworthRDR2it used to but I guess they removed it

[@cougarhunter8304]

Yeah its possible not a guarantee tho i got my favorite horse back as john as well i set john up with money i left at pig farm behind the painting on purpose for john 2k how i did it was at right before last mission i sold my horse to the stable at valentine and road a different one for last mission and as soon as john got to free roam went and got the money went to stable at valentine and the horse was still there you have to buy it as john the faster you get there the better the chances are its still there seams the horses do change with time that are at the stables now if i would of went to a different stable the horse would not be there because it wasn’t sold to them there aka why you can’t get Arthur’s stapled horses as john also i never stopped playing went from Arthur to John and got the horse so game never rebooted so weather that was a factor or not Maybe?

[@lobo2518]

i accidentally sold the horse but i was too far in the game to restart :C

[@tornYT]

Keep the one that Hamish gives you 😅

[@RockworthRDR2]

So wait all the way until chapter 6 to bond/keep a horse?…

[@tornYT]

@@RockworthRDR2 if you do extra missions like stranger missions yeah. But that was a stupid question to ask. If there was a way of getting to Hamish before chapter 6 that would be great 😊. But it’s nice to meet a fellow rdr2 content creator! 🤠 ♥️

[@MagnusArnason]

I didn’t like this horse because the coat is strange to me, looks kinda phallic on the right side of his behind. I prefer the all black American Standardbred that can be found in West Elisabeth, usually spawns below Whatson’s cabin

[@RockworthRDR2]

Lol! Really? I can’t see the phallic look you’re seeing. But yes, the black American standardbred has a beautiful full-black coat.

[@ngoanh6635]

Exclusive for Arthur? Shut up & take my money 🎉

[@dr.skulhamr3220]

But, but ... I only have room for 4 in my stables. I need the big black shire that josea gave me. He's too majestic to pass by. I need the black Arabian or the White Arabian. They are just too pretty and have great stats. I need the black and white Hungarian Halfbred that Arthur rides when he comes back from Guarma. I usually steal him from a campsite as early on as possible.

[@RockworthRDR2]

Well remember you can always have a temporary horse, so that makes 5 total

[@tyrannotherium7873]

That’s the only Tennessee walker I like other than that the rest of the Tennessee walkers are garbage especially the DLC one that came out in 2019 the Palomino.

[@matthewcbd2486]

I got the horse it gives you for free if you buy the most expensive edition luckily it was on sale for thirty dollars 😂 but the horse it gives you is semi retarded it's been a pain since I got it in chapter 1 and I've hitten More tree's in this playthrough then my other 6 lol it likes to scream for like 2 minutes after seeing a Snake but when I play I have the horse to the end unless it gets killed before that

[@RockworthRDR2]

Lol are you referring to the mahogany bay as being a pain or the free reverse dapple thoroughbred?

[@bagi4903]

SPOILER If you do the last story mission with this horse it's death is even sadder becuase it's the first one you got to bond with

[@maxxgrit2124]

Of I sell the black shire can I still get it?

[@RockworthRDR2]

I’m not sure if I understand what you’re asking exactly, but no if you sell the black shire it’s gone for good. kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWG6fYSNqa2Brrs You can find the other two shires in free roam pulling wagons, but there is only one black shire in the game

[@King-Bowser1]

Actually no, when you sell the black shire, you buy the new horse and finish the mission, the Walked will be in the stables after it, atleast that was the case for me

[@garethlombard9112]

It’s a good horse but is speed and acceleration is trash

[@montv291]

Sell it right away every time. Terrible horse imo. The Raven Black shire gets stabled, and this one gets sold.

[@RockworthRDR2]

Lol, fair enough. This is what it’s about, riding whatever horses are suitable for you and just enjoying the game and experience. Which horse(s) do you prefer?

[@montv291]

@RockworthRDR2 I just recently discovered the wild Andalusian. Amazing horse. Full health when fully bonded. It's a tad slow, but that's not a big deal to me. I think it's definitely the wild horse people should immediately go after instead of the white Arabian. I can't stand Arabians. I catch the Missouri Foxtrotter directly after the Albert Mason horse mission. I think it's the best all-round breed. I try to get a Murfree Tennessee Walker early. It surprisingly has great stats. Better than any other Walker. I love the Raven Black Shire. It helps me do Horseman 9 like it's nothing. I go back and forth with the Hungarian Halfbred. Good horse, but it's very bouncy. If stats didn't matter, I would always be riding a Buckskin American Standardbred. It's my favorite horse aesthetically. It fits Arthur perfectly. Beautiful and classic look. I wish it had 3/4 the stats of what the game considers the better horses.

[@FrankHavok316]

Mahogany Bay Tenessee is ok but... ain't no Boadicea

[@RockworthRDR2]

Lol facts

[@Larry2]

The best horse in the game is the Missouri Fox Trotter, not the pinto but the one with the medium brown coat. It is a larger horse than the pinto. I've never seen it in the wild nor have I found any npc's ridding one. I have played the game more times than I can count and there's no horse that will stack up to it. The one problem is, it seams the only way to get it (at least for me) is to use the stable glitch in Saint Denis before the day one patch. The way to do this is disconnect your internet, then you have the game free of any patches. Also all exploits are usable like all the money glitches etc. Once you have the horse and are a millionaire 😆, you can reconnect your internet and it will update the game but all the goodies you've gotten remain intact including the horse. Just know that in order to do this you have to reinstall the game from scratch.

[@ramzankadyrov6035]

Appaloosas are my favorite

[@RockworthRDR2]

Nice. They have very distinctive coats

[@DarknessDevil64]

Hello, what happens to Arthur's horses from stable after he die?? Can it John use it?? Also, the horse that we will be using from the last mission will also die right?

[@dpg5690]

this "4k" looks worse than native 1080p lol

[@RockworthRDR2]

Next time watch it with your eyes closed