The Rose say hiatus made them grow | Etalk Interview

[@anitaarfahsita]

The Rose deserve another interviewer :)

[@ticklish.tickles]

What woosung said about remembering the music even if you forget the artist felt touching. It's what artists do : create pieces that accompany us through certain periods in our lives. Some fans stay for the long run and some come in briefly, but the impact remains forever. I also think that to some people, the artist means more than the art itself and the feelings most often linger even if one doesn't follow the group anymore. Those memories stay a source of comfort.

[@mingiwon1304]

There's something wrong with people who always brings BTS into topic, it wasn't necessary. I totally agree with Woosung, it's not about "I'm wanna be a super star and everyone has to remember me" when an artist shares his/her art like they've done, it's more about I wanna share with you the essence, I want to give us the opportunity to enjoy together what we could make. That's a true artist, just like the rose as a group🌟

[@jonok42]

She was simply using BTS as an example and her question had nothing to do with them. Why do people need to find reasons to be upset about the phrasing of a question?

[@mikufan_1]

​@@jonok42 because there was no need to bring them up when this is clearly about them about The Rose. She could've simply asked what struggles they faced as a group whitout mentioning BTS I'm sure BTS has their own struggles and so does The Rose. But like this was clearly not about BTS so no need to bring them up, respect each group as their own individual. They're both great in their own ways I love them both. But if u invite a musician then talk about someone else, that just feels a little wrong.. Don't bring up other people's struggles just invalidate others because their struggles and hardships are just as important.

[@rebeccabeebe1]

​@@jonok42because she could of asked the question without mentioning BTS..it was unnecessary

[@evacaspers4053]

You also bring up BTS when it's not neccessary. You can just let it slide, right? The band does, too. For many people, BTS IS the first association with korean music. It is very likely, that many people who watch this interview are also interested in how BTS is gonna deal with the military and The Rose can actually contribute something for those, who are worried. The Rose already went and came back stronger, they are a good example. So why not just leave it at that?

[@konyakcharmyvlog9884]

Absolutely agree with you … I am BTS Army but this interview is all about The Rose .. instead of asking about them why bringing BTS ! I discovered The Rose when they came for lolla in Mumbai and they are really great Artist and i love their music .. song… lyrics .. voice etc and not forgetting they are beautiful human.They deserved all the respect & I genuinely respect and love for The Rose & Black Roses. I Rose you woosung ,Dojoon , Hajoon & Jaehyung🥀 New Black Rose 😍

[@WOOSUNGlifeline]

Black Roses will never forget The Rose or their music! Theyve created such a safe place for us and theyre always so genuine and real and have helped many of us in so many different ways! They will always be memorable! 🥀

[@Candyyisbac]

Yes this is so true the rose helped me when I was at my darkest times

[@mikufan_1]

I am an army and a black rose but what annoyed me the most in this interview was how she kept mentioning BTS when this interview was clearly about The Rose. Like WHYY, BTS is BTS AND THE ROSE IS THE ROSE STOP COMPARING AND BOTH ARE THEIR OWN GROUP SO RESPECT THAT. No need to bring up another group when the focus was on The Rose. I'm sure BTS have their own struggles as a group so does The Rose but that dosen't mean you can invalidate The Rose's struggles less. RESPECT BOTH GROUPS STOP COMPARING!!

[@juliecrawford4167]

agreed! im Army forever but i’m also a black rose the interview was suppose to be about them

[@ledanre3361]

Once you become a "Black Rose" you will forever cherish The Rose' especially their music.

[@ticklish.tickles]

5:02 his giggle was adorable

[@iwannabered9034]

Why does she mention Bts so often? While talking to The Rose, she should only focus on The Rose

[@nozi_ukhon]

I was also annoyed by this🤦🏻‍♀️ it makes no sense to talk about BTS, when the interview is about The Rose. I'm in both fandoms (army+black rose). After watching this I feel bad for BTS and for The Rose.

[@rebeccabeebe1]

I was also like tf? She could of asked those questions without mentioning BTS

[@EyelovemyCoton]

She’s a lousy interviewer! We should bombard her on her social media accounts why did she mentioned BTS during The Rose interview.

[@puteribatrisyia4390]

yeaaa sameee i was thought like that, likeee this is the rose i know they're in kpop but if you want to call them, promote them, can you just focus on their group only ? i was likee... what ?? hmbte no hate just likee,... yeaa yk what i mean

[@miniyogi8198]

Yeah same here,

[@tatokki0927]

When Woosung got Dojoon like "OOUUHHHH" for his statement about people might forget the Rose but not the music. PRECIOUS 🥹❤️

[@Eping2325]

I just recently discovered them and I’m soooo happy that I did!🥀🌹I love them sooo much ! I will never forget them! They are amazing, very talented individuals...Humble and kind human beings ♥️I’m sooo happy to be a part of the black roses!!! We Rose You! Be well!

[@Eping2325]

The Rose deserves much , much better recognition !!! They deserve more Success! N they are on their way there!♥️🖤🥀🌹

[@francisca.arayam]

I’m a new black rose 🥀 I’m so glad I could support these guys, I went to see them perform in Lollapalooza this year and they were my favorite performers of this year edition. I was so so happy, I will kept those memories in my heart and I won’t forget them, like how could I???

[@Jen.Blackrose]

I am very proud to belong to the BlackRoses Fandom, and happy to see all the goals and be part of this wonderful journey with The Rose, they deserve that and more. 🥀✨

[@theiaustria]

They sing beautifully. They also speak beautifully. I love them.

[@RoxyPeng]

*The Rose* ... Their songs always reach my heart, therefore the 4 will always be special and unique to me! My Fantastic 4... _WooSung, Park Dojoon, Hajoon, Jaehyeong_ ... My 4 Brilliant Roses!

[@jotapao]

❤🌹🇨🇴I am truly moved by the album "Heal". It has the power to heal and its beauty is undeniable. I had the privilege of attending their concert at "Estereo Picnic Colombia" and I am still in awe of their amazing talent. It's an experience I will never forget.❤los amo

[@annrey8281]

This band is so precious. Great young men. Great musicians.

[@noorzarur]

There was something off about this interview. Maybe because the presenter spoke more than the Rose! In any case I would love if both Hajoon and Jaehyeong would speak. I understand there is language barrier but they can speak in Korean and the other two can translate a bit for them. I have seen other interviews of them in English also, where they just don't talk. But they have beautiful personalities and so much to share. I feel bad for them. There are many other Korean bands, artists who do not speak English and they answer in Korean and someone (members or an interpretor) translates. I wish they can express themselves more. Love The Rose, they are my absolute favourite.

[@lindawee-henz9541]

The interviewer was more keen to listen to herself than to what The Rose had to say. It would have been more graceful to ask one open questions and have them share whatever comes to them.

[@Nekataite]

I think that I could never forget the rose .... It's like they are a part of me, They confort me when I needed the most, and bring so much reconfort through music. Even if I know that Woosung kinda feel inconfortable about the fact that we thanks the band for making such music., He always reference this to music not as the band but a thing that he might have forget it's that behind every songs they are humain being whose writing and expressed they own and relative's feelings . So yeah I thank you for the music that you made guys I thank you for having created a safe place for me through your music but also your personality. I will not forget you because you printed yourself in my history and in my heart.

[@iamkelyin]

wow, that was the first interview I watched where I felt uncomfortable for them... 😮‍💨Woosung and Dojoon were very polite, as always. I'm proud. 🥰

[@susiefoxlampkin3341]

Don't fret, you 4 and your music will never be forgotten!

[@cherylmarler1059]

The forgotten question should have been not asked. No one forgets a great band/music

[@purplestardust1405]

I was quite enjoying the interview until this first moment, so I'll try to say it nicely 4:27 'this issue has gotten a huge spotlight of the last of couple of weeks because another korean group of artist B T S have announced they will be serving in the military' No ma'am. This particular issue has always been in a spotlight as every korean man is obliged to perform military service. Either it's a common person, a celebrity, actor, kpop artist, professional sportsman and it has always been a bitter situation because there are always people who cherish for them who have to go to military. Mentioning this other artist was only unnecessary and disrespectful towards The Rose. 5:40 'were you ever at any point worried that the black roses would forget about the rose (...) I'm thinking about army you know will army remember B T S I mean yes obviously' . Woosung's reaction says it all. Why even imply such a thing? It was so unpleasant and harmful to hear especially after comparing to other fandom. I am Black Rose. Will I forget them or they music? Even if I'll get old enough to forget my own name I will remember The Rose because it's something remembered by my heart. Please be careful and more considerate in the future if you ever will get the opportunity to interview korean artists.

[@xhereel6516]

Mga talentadong silang mang aawit at napaka ganda ng mga kanta nila masarap sa tenga pakinggan GOD BLESS “ The Rose “ ❣️❣️❣️

[@usernamealltaken]

No worries "The Rose" cause the "New Black Roses" are on its way. It will bloom ever more. So much love to them. 🖤🖤🖤🖤

[@Paooli]

La verdad es que se volvieron una parte muy importante de mí, tanto como persona, como en mi camino musical. Me ayudaron a entender y ver las cosas de una forma diferente, a sanar junto a su música y sentir lo mágica que se puede volver. Estoy segura que jamás me voy a olvidar de ustedes y mucho menos de su música, los guardo en mi corazón para el resto de mi vida ❤️

[@vickiegibbons8765]

i love them explaining the meaning of their fans, Black Rose, i thought thats what it referred to but its nice to remind people as in Western culture, a Black Rose can be a negative symbal.

[@Fantastic418]

I kinda feel like being an artist is so passionate and exciting, I wander how they feel?

[@violleta.R]

The rose is perfect band....

[@isabellaadb]

5:54 that was pretty unnecessary, I’m sorry. “Of course army won’t forget bts but maybe your fans would forget about you” - that’s how that came across. They’re not less valuable as artists just because they’re not someone else. Bts aren’t the Beatles either, yet they hold their own, and so does The Rose. I understand the intent of the question, just wish it was done more respectfully to the people being interviewed.

[@rebeccabeebe1]

Yep 💯💯

[@lynnlee2282]

I agree, it was completely unnecessary bringing up BTS. Of all the interviews I seen I never seen questions mention BTS 😒

[@emiann5740]

I agree. I was wondering why she would say that. It’s one thing to bring up BTS, which wasn’t necessary, but to say of course Army won’t forget them. 🤦‍♀️

[@secretadmirer5006]

So rude of the interviewer - terrible!

[@LuckyPide]

I love them

[@wpjm60]

as army myself , im glad that im not the only one who felt uncomfortable . oh come on! that was unnecessary to mention other group here. you just have ONE JOB! so disappointed lainey!

[@lisaanderson5378]

One of my favorite groups 🫶💞

[@frontadoelisa037]

The Rose se a Convertido en un Fenómeno Musical Ustedes los Coreanos se deben Sentir muy Orgullosos de Ellos por Yebar el Nombre de Corea por todo lo Alto en el Mundo y Ustedes Tienen que Valorizarlos No Nada masss Son los bts.

[@melodysong9453]

The Rose 🌹🖤

[@mlart.10]

Happy for them ❤

[@Fantastic418]

This interview is terribly short, I need more of The Rose 🌹

[@aixarp]

más allá de las preguntas totalmente desubicadas de la entrevistadora, destaco las palabras correctas que tuvo Sammy. THE ROSE, TE AMO.

[@LMPZ23]

🇵🇾❤️🌹 the rose deserve everything good in the world

[@shawna2946]

The Rose is amazing 🌹🖤

[@debbien6704]

I love BTS but it was rude and unnecessary for the interviewer to keep bringing up BTS during an interview with The Rose.

[@dojoonloveu]

Que lindo verlos crecerrr

[@dojoonloveu]

We heal together ❤❤

[@guigarecomenda]

Eles são incríveis!!!

[@vero93]

Estamos muy orgullosos de the rose ❤ los amamos tanto y jamas nos olvidaríamos de su musica ni de ellos ❤

[@rebeccabeebe1]

You could of absolutely of asked those questions without bringing BTS into it...why do these interviewers always bring them up when interviewing other Korean artists..the comment about army obviously not forgetting BTS was also kind of rude assuming that army are the only fans who won't forget the artists while they are away.. seriously something wrong with western interviewer's

[@karolmsilvacampos94]

LOS AMAMOS

[@cmjaelee6114]

i dislike when interviewers always bring up BTS, like im pretty sure every korean artist know about BTS achievements. This interview is ABOUT the rose, its very unnecessary to mention BTS, and obv no hate to BTS but i dont think its right to mention them.

[@aminicodemus4686]

This is The Rose content. But why is she like that? I'm also an ARMY and a Black Rose, but the way she brought up BTS is not comfortable... Let us recognize The Rose individuality and talents.

[@yerisamamani2776]

Soy la única que pensó que Dojoon miraba para atrás para que los chicos hablen también pero ellos ni pio (? 🤣🤣🤣

[@therosesblackrose]

why does she keep bringing up bts!? like shes interviewing a completely different band

[@marianadumitrache3067]

Vă iubesc de mor și vă stau alături în carieră voastră vă încurajez să mergeți înainte .! Sunteți cei mai buni ce cei mai minunați. Voi ne colorați zilele și viața în roz ascultndu-va muzica și văzându-va energia ne dați curaj să mergem mai departe ❤💖💕💓💗💓💗💜🧡💛💚💙💗❤💘💋❤❤❤❤🌹🌹🌹🌹 România🇷🇴

[@Everythingnnothing_]

❤❤❤

[@puckleijen8236]

I love both the Rose and BTS, but whyy does she need to keep mention BTS in the interview???

[@dojoonloveu]

Losssss amooo

[@dorinaiosif4715]

International values

[@syidaahmadd]

PLEASE STOP MENTION ANOTHER GROUP IF YOU INTERVIEWING ANOTHER GROUP! PLEASE KEEP THAT IN UR MIND

[@indy4794]

💕

[@kittykook737]

Come on. So you guys want to create content to us that we’ll like, and then making us keep coming back to watch your content right? Well… what about then not disrespecting and comparing one group to another group? Even if not comparing then mentioning another group. You interview The Rose, then only talk about The Rose. It’s pretty simple. The bond between artists and fans are often really really close and filled with a lot of meaningful messages. When you speak with a group you should never begin talking about another artist. You’re simply giving of the intention of saying that one group is not meaningful enough, doesn’t matter and have less value just because another group of people in this whole world got more fame. It’s very unprofessional of your interviewer and as you might see here in the comment section, definitely didn’t make us, both as fans and viewers, very happy. Cause I can see I’m clearly not the only one here finding this uncomfortable. It would be nice if you didn’t do this to other people in the future too. Please get an interviewer that’s professional or tell them how to. I don’t know if it’s just me, but I feel like The Rose look a little shocked too. They’re ofc trying not to show it, as they’re very humble and kind humans. I’m so proud of them handling the situation so well as they always do. Also how funny is it that when the topic is changed to snacks and not about BTS they’re are less tense and smile more? No hate to BTS at all. It would just be pretty nice to not mention other people when ‘professionally’ interviewing one group of people. Remember they’re humans too, and it hurts to be compared all the time feeling like you’re not good enough, have to constantly live up to expectations of other people, having less value. It’s invalidating them. They’re each individual groups. Please be considerate of people and show respect. The interviewer is adult and I know all this as a 16 year old fyi. (And a little tip is if you want viewers back then maybe think about giving a small apology) The interviewer can talk about BTS in her free time when not being at work 🙃 Thanks to those who cared to read and I hope everyone including the interviewer have a good day/night ❤️

[@ElaineSilva-il8um]

☀️🌷🌷🌷

[@violleta.R]

How many black rose hereee.....

[@isabelsilvaserafim2923]

❤❤❤❤❤🌹🌹🌹🌹😘🇧🇷

[@oddinaryluna]

🖤🥀

[@svetlanayoushenko2185]

🎶❤❤❤ The Rose ❤❤❤ 🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺

[@minahcd6522]

Why bring BTS into this ? It's very disrespectful. The Rose will not been forgotten ♥️🖤

[@violleta.R]

Im black rose ..

[@klxmare]

Why is she bringing up BTS while doing an interview with another group? The first time she mentioned them it was okay, used as an example since they are globally known, but mentioning them again and comparing? It was so unprofessional and uncomfortable, even for us watching. You can see it all on Woosung's face.

[@manuelawunderlich6039]

I think it was a great Interview, she asked good questions and I don‘t mind that she mentioned bts

[@SuenosQuimeraMei]

i thought the questions and comments were very thoughtful and insightful, and then bts was brought up in a way it felt this interview served a purpose for *their* enlistment and not for the rose really. nothing against bts, it's just a shame the interview didn't really respect the artist in front of them as they should have.

[@julianasobreiraarguelho8428]

🖤🌹 Perfect 👏👏👏

[@dhftrn]

Please… NEVER COMPARES ANY GROUP TO BTS. Why you guys are so bts-centric? They are a BAND, not a Boygroup. Also, other groups has its own vision and mission to success. You can’t generalized that every group has same vision and mission with bts… The way you kept mentioning bts is pissed the fans off. Better to learn again how to interview someone PROPERLY and POLITELY next time.

[@jonok42]

She in no way compared them to BTS! She simply used BTS as an example about what happens to Korean male artists when they have to take such a long pause right in the middle of their careers. Don't make this about anything else. It wasn't anything more than drawing a parallel for example. The Rose understood what she was doing, and she only mentioned them twice.

[@dhftrn]

@@jonok42 maybe you wanna take a look on 5:54 when the interviewer said “army wouldnt forget about bts, but maybe your fans will forget about you” and reread again what you’ve wrote.

[@rebeccabeebe1]

​@@jonok42she basically said army can't forget about BTS but Black Roses might..like the Rose and their music is in some way less impactful because they are not as big as BTS.. it was disrespectful to both groups honestly I can't imagine BTS being okay with their name being brought up everytime someone interviews another Korean artist...

[@faribabahrami750]

Why does she mention other groups? This is unnecessary and disrespectful

[@jonok42]

It seemed to me that she was drawing a parallel between them to get her meaning across to them. She wasn't trying to be disrespectful, and they did not seem offended.

[@kiyokochanable]

.Nah bruh.. why you mentoning another's group name when EVERY male group has gone through the same???? lol I thought that was not a thing anymore but i guess not.

[@vero93]

Y realmente no veo la necesidad de estar mencionando a BTS tantas veces , no necesita ñba hacer tanta referencia 🙄

[@Carlos-qp1zi]

Could you not talk about BTS? How ridiculous while they are interviewing The Rose

[@Ansku7]

The mention of bts and army was sooo inappropriate and unnecessary. She made herself look very cheap. I love them both - the rose and bts, but jesus, thats just embarrassing for her.

[@violleta.R]

Why you not focus on THE ROSE....why you have to mention bts....im sorry...im ARMY n BLACK ROSE....but i dont like this woman....

[@Aces77777]

?who

[@Kikuvz]

Great interview it's just that I have always found kind of disrespectul bringing up other groups to compare, it's unnecesary. I like both but this is a space for The Rose, if you are going to have them, please treat them properly 🫶🌹

[@jonok42]

It would be rude if she were actually comparing the two groups. However, that is not at all what she did. She used BTS as an example to explain herself. Not to compare them to each other.

[@Kikuvz]

@@jonok42 You're right, in fact there is no need to bring them up when they know exactly what she was talking about. It's like, imagine your family asks you about how you're doing and they mention "As you know your cousin has been through this too" it's like: ª ok hehe sorry for the bad example