The RUIN DLC Girl is NOT Who We Thought?! | FNAF Security Breach Theory

[@RyeToast]

If you’re ever injured in an accident, you can check out Morgan & Morgan. You can submit a claim in 8 clicks or less without having to leave your couch. For more information, go to www.forthepeople.com/RyeToast --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Who do you think the girl in the Ruin poster is? Timestamps: 00:00 Preheating 01:06 What do we know about Security Breach RUIN? 02:29 Is Elizabeth Afton the girl in Security Breach RUIN? 04:39 Morgan and Morgan Ad 06:06 Is Charlotte Emily the girl in Security Breach RUIN? 07:43 Is Amelia from GGY the girl in Security Breach RUIN? 09:10 Is the Security Breach RUIN girl a new character? 10:12 The Security Breach RUIN girl is... 12:43 Cooling Off

[@juzox5161]

Probably just a rebuilt version of Susie, heck might be rebuilt versions of all the missing children

[@TheLogicist]

Seeing how Gregory seems to be a version of the crying child it's most likely that this girl would be some version of Elisabeth.

[@venomfan2020]

I'd very much prefer to Better Call Saul...

[@TheWholeEntireCake]

I’m injured

[@angusstuff]

I just assumed she was Susie because of the hair... and the more old-fashion style clothes

[@f1eo]

my mind is actually blown bcus narratively it would be really cool if it was susie. she has never been a significant character aside from being one of the first to die. i'd love for this to actually be spoken into reality

[@RyeToast]

Fingers crossed 🤞

[@anhurtorrez]

Actually in one of the Fazbear Frights there was a whole story about her, after she had died. So who's to say? This theory has merits, considering she was the only one they had a whole story about.

[@sixsense1436]

In all honestly, From FFPS she gets her own minigame, In UCN it's confirmed from her lines alone that she was the first one of the group to go and get stuffed and gets a bit of backstory with her dog in FFPS, She also gets a whole story dedicated to her and only her. I'd say she gets more screentime than any other kid like Fritz, Gabriel and Jeremy...like they bearly had anything. And i'm completely fine with that cuz Susie is really interesting to me, but to say she hasn't been singificant is not true at least to me.

[@f1eo]

@@sixsense1436 the one thing that i'd argue for why she isnt significant in the games is she doesnt get alot revealed from her. all we know about her is she was the first of 5 to be lured in the back and afton lured her into the back by gaslighting her into believing her dog was still alive. other than supposedly being freed from happiest day, she doesnt have much goin for her - especially since she had to watch everyone die in front of her.

[@AllMight6]

Clearly it’s Mike afton

[@furiousDevs]

Something I'm surprised no one is really talking about are ghosts in the FNAF universe. The character is in grayscale, which could be an artistic choice but it's also weird. The whole reason William became springtrap was because he got scared of the actual ghosts, who are in grayscale.

[@jk844100]

“Artistic choice” doesn’t mean “for no reason”, in fact it’s quite the opposite. “Artistic choices means selections made by theatre artists about situation, action, direction and design in order to convey meaning.” The very purpose of “artistic choice” is to convey meaning.

[@MissOnana]

@@jk844100 Not to be rude, but as an artist... Sometimes artistic choice really is just "it looked cool" and literally nothing more. Though I do personally agree that she's probably greyscale for a reason. I think it might be that one of the colors in her design gives her away, and that's why she's greyscale. So that the character isn't immediately obvious.

[@jk844100]

@@MissOnana what I quoted is the literal definition of “artistic choice”. You’re not being rude to me.

[@SkyBlew]

*This comment should be pinned!* 😆 You made a *REALLY GREAT* point about the ghosts thing! It's definitely a concept that we should look into more. Because like you said, William was scared of them.. Regardless of all the stuff he does with remnant etc, he still got afraid when the spirits actually came free, and *he could clearly see them...* 🤔

[@Nugget_Slh]

Weren't the gousts blue?

[@NightRaiderTea]

I think I can explain the greyscale from a game art standpoint, actually! When people are making art for games, promotional art included, they do something called a value study, where they draw and shade the entire piece in black and white, before applying the colour, it’s highly likely that at this point, the colours for the concept art haven’t been picked, or it’s not completely done or set in stone. Because of this, the artist went off of values and instead just didn’t colour it.

[@NightRaiderTea]

My source for this method n stuff is that I do game art as a uni course, so, yeah.

[@lieeeleeee]

Also if you’re making this poster and know it’s all going to be in shadow, why colour your value study if no one is going to see the colour. I think it totally makes sense for the gray scale to be left over from the value study especially because no one can really tell it’s not coloured due to the lighting.

[@catelynh1020]

​@@lieeeleeee It nakes more sense to color it in when it's a series like fnaf, though. The reason being the fanbase expects lore and other information in everything from color of text to slight differences in things to the html of a site to brightening of pictures or looking at their code. You can't get away with "i thought it looked cool" or "i didn't feel like putting in that extra effort" when the whole base expects to be able to pick it apart pixle by pixle

[@Vinesus]

@@catelynh1020 I think it’s better to leave it gray in that case; you wouldn’t want people figuring out such a large plot piece so early in the process

[@catelynh1020]

@@Vinesus It's fine if it's intentional to leave it gray, just not if it was unintentional

[@RariaRoyal]

I’ve been apart of the fnaf community since it pretty much started. As an adult sitting on my couch sometimes I just like to sit down and watch fnaf theories and feel like I did when I was 11 and it feels nice to see so many theories now feels like the old days. Somtimes it’s okay to be wrong and just enjoy the ride of putting stuff together. Because eventually in the feature we are gonna look back on these days be like damnnnnn those were the days. Appreciate your videos

[@bigbadgammagnome]

This, it reminds me of the insane theories Gravity Falls fans would come up with, and the fact that some of them ended up being true blew my tiny mind at the time. I think the only one I bought was the Stan Twin theory, which was amazing to see actually come true. At the end of the day, the fun didn't come from the theory being 100% right, but just connecting all the dots whether or not they meant anything. I feel the same about watching FNAF theories, now. Altho I'll just say I always thought the "Mabel has an evil twin" theory was stupid. Those who know, know lol

[@loganentertainment1814]

Amen brother.

[@InterstinglyGeneric]

Yeah it felt a lifetime ago, I remember when they called purple guy Vincent and The Hidden "Dog Animatronic" Fake Picture

[@loganentertainment1814]

Yeah, I remember Sparky the dog, those were the good ole days. Sure Fnaf is A LOT different now, but I'm still overall happy that its still kicking, even though I still sometimes think it was better off ending with UCN.

[@prince_chavv02]

Amelia playing Fruity Maze, a game last seen in the location DIRECTLY UNDER the Pizzaplex, that we know was also interacted with by one of the first victims of the MCI right before they were killed, and BOTH of them just so happening to bear resemblance to RUIN Girl.... is absolutely insane and idk why I haven't seen anyone else bring it up amidst all the GGY discussion!

[@higueraft571]

@@darkpain2452 >Dude they don't want to accept fnaf ar is canon that brings to who is the owner of fazbear Except it's BEEN accepted. Mr Burrows is the CEO.

[@LoudLiveOut]

I’ve been obsessed with your FNAF videos lately.

[@RyeToast]

Well I'm glad I could supply your demand!

[@DreaguiVII]

​@@RyeToast you know i too is obsessed with your videos. They are just very well made and well put together

[@1tsKen]

Hop on guys this is gonna be a long train ride

[@lu9077]

Dude same

[@johncrawford9418]

I mean she did have a resemblance to Susie, but we just didn’t think of her because we thought she moved on.

[@Pepeutra]

Absolutely based for putting a whole note explainin why the cats don't appear in the video W Rye, absolutely deserving of the gray brick

[@RyeToast]

Thank you so much!

[@Sheotimus]

It”s nice to think that Steel Wool could have the potential to troll us as hard as Scott used to, specifically theorists and haters. Great Video btw! It’s great having people in the community who is reasonable and open to new ideas as well as finding strong evidence to back up their theories. ❤🐻

[@meganimanic]

Really comical trend in Theorist’s videos claiming that each person has solved Security Breach 😂

[@RyeToast]

Lol we gotta get that click through rate somebow

[@lisahenry20]

It's just like calling something the final one. It never really is.

[@bubbleshock14]

I think Susie is a fair candidate. Of the MCI kids, she is the one with the most attention in the series, even more than Cassidy. We get the Fruity Maze game that directly tells us how William lured her in, and the Coming Home Fazbear Frights story. Speaking of... Maybe the ruin girl, and by extension, Amelia, is related to Susie somehow. Susie had a sister, so maybe she is her niece, or great niece. Maybe a stretch, but we know FNAF likes to keep things in the family.

[@grenouillesupreme]

Cassidy has the most attention

[@bubbleshock14]

@@grenouillesupreme in the fandom, sure. But in canon we get more about Susie than about Cassidy.

[@grenouillesupreme]

@@bubbleshock14 cassidy has an entire game dedicated to her, how is susie more present in the lore ?

[@bubbleshock14]

@@grenouillesupreme UCN? Or something else? Like I said, Susie's backstory is clearly told in Fruity Maze, and she has a whole story in Fazbear Frights. Even the fact that she was the first MCI kid killed puts more importance on her than at least the other three. We dont really know what happened to Cassidy other than being killed, and she isn't even in Fazbear Frights. Sure, Andrew is kind of a stand in, but he does have a different story to her.

[@grenouillesupreme]

@@bubbleshock14 yes i'm talking about ucn, well we know william was more violent when he killed her since the toy chica high school years mirrors william luring the mci

[@PointBreakGames2240]

I had thought about it maybe being Suzie when I saw the thumbnail and my first thought was " are we doing time travel or something now?" And then I remembered the into the pit story so I mean

[@RyeToast]

I mean, this is the first game with a confirmed ball pit

[@chromaticroses]

another point of note is that susie got her own frights story relatively recently. it would make sense if there were plans to maybe bring her back they would want to flesh her out more so ppl would be more invested i know people don’t want old characters returning but honestly the mci kids are so underdeveloped i wouldn’t mind if they played a role going forward.

[@MoonSoulez]

the fact people can M̶i̶l̶k̶ i mean theorize with even the smallest details is kinda interesting

[@RyeToast]

You know it souz viede

[@patrickbateman1434]

Elizebeth afton has a purple/pink top and red ribbon. The girl on the ruin poster has red and purple shoes. Plus if her shirt is pink then it could still be afton as he is presented as purple and pink in the mini games

[@Seriously_Unserious]

Thanks for the shoutout for my friend's fundraiser, Rye. I know I also speak on behalf of my friend and his family too. Sharing this with your audience is a huge help.

[@XionBrown]

This thumbnail looks awesome! When this teaser was first revealed I remember stating that this girl was possibly one of the three: Gregory's sister, Elizabeth, and/or Susie. I still believe this to be someone related to Gregory but after this theory, I can get behind it being Susie more.

[@RyeToast]

I mean all three are likely! And I know right? BarBADroid is crazy talented

[@tayloranderson7547]

Someone related to Gregory but after this theory, I can get behind it being Susie more.

[@BakedBananaB]

Haven’t even been through 10 seconds of the video but I already know it’s a banger

[@RyeToast]

I hope so!

[@wowmynamechanged]

even in security breach, chica has always been tied to susie. mazercize is literally a food-themed maze, just like fruity maze. (also, the secret chica hideouts scattered around the pizzaplex could easily have something to do with the dlc girl.)

[@nu_uh1]

I'm new to the channel and your theories are AMAZING they are fluid and make a lot of sense

[@RyeToast]

Thanks so much!

[@AngelicAutumn]

I love the idea of Susie being the the girl on the poster. It started with Susie and it could tie the series off so nicely. Great theory rye!

[@higueraft571]

>started Not QUITE. The Start was likely either CC or Charlie, Susie simply kicked off The Main Event...

[@ryley8211]

I personally think that Amelia is the girl in the Fruity Maze game. Her saying "you did not just do that" was her getting sucked into the game. That's the reason she isn't seen in the rest of the book

[@dylan.bissendmylife]

Another reason why it almost definitely can't be Charlie is because she seems to be present in the Pizzaplex already, seemingly haunting it. So there's very little chance that two Charlies (her spirit and her robot kid self) would be there at the same time. I'm pretty sure you mentioned it in a previous video (or maybe I'm remembering another youtuber's vid, because i know others have covered this), but there's a few hints throughout the game indicating that Charlie/the Puppet has influence over the Pizzaplex in one way or another. There's numerous Nightmarionne plushies scattered around the building, as well as power cables reminiscent of the Puppet's striped appendages, and most obviously, the Nightmare STAFF bots that are distinctly designed to resemble Nightmarionne. Could just all be coincidence... or maybe Charlie just couldn't rest in peace. Only questions now are why she's back, and what's she doing? So far we haven't seen her do anything to actively fight against Afton (as far as I can tell), so while that is her most likely reason for being present, I'm not fully convinced just yet. My bet is that she's going to have some involvement in Ruin, otherwise they wouldn't have put the signs of her presence into the base game.

[@sxnnykayla7136]

i have a theory about ruin, giving that the title was purple and the place was in RUIN in the poster, it could probably be about the Ruin of afton’s existence, it actually could represent elizabeth afton and may be showing that the princess quest represents Cassidy, and the in your dreams, staff bots could represent charlie, it could be the aftermath of the ruin, and how everyone can finally begin to rest, so that’s why I think the girl is representing elizabeth afton, robotically, spiritually, or metaphorically.

[@Ilikecrabs]

You actually taking time to respond to every comment takes a lot of dedication, love you vids btw

[@RyeToast]

I do my best lol, thank you

[@Ilikecrabs]

@@RyeToast no I thank YOU for giving us great content

[@christophermitchell9739]

Always makes my day to see your new videos

[@RyeToast]

I'm glad I can ☺️

[@SashaStowers]

One thing specifically about Chica's arcade cabinet, mentioned in the duffle bag messages is that it is running without being plugged in. They don't call out the other cabinets as doing this. It does seem like several characters are obsessed with the arcade games. I wonder if it is because there has to be somewhere for their non-glitched persona/spirit to go. That you can't delete someone's mind, but you can transfer it digitally and replace it ala FNAF VR. GGY is depicted as evil, but he spends his nights endlessly trying to beat the games and get higher scores which seems more weird than evil unless he thought he could free himself. At least one of the employees is so obsessed with the games to save the princess that he loses his job. We know that the princess is connected to Vanny, not himself, but he was still possessed/passionate enough to try to free her. We also know that someone keeps moving the cabinets around to spots where they can't be played or where no one would look for them (vanny's hideout/sun and moon room/Monty golf), and ordering games without logging them in the system so they can't be tracked. This could be to isolate the games so they can be played endlessly and privately, or to prevent others from winning/freeing the spirits in them.

[@justthereed5593]

Just wanted so say that I love your ad segments. It’s not just that they’re fun and integrated well, it’s the fact that you’re good at selling it. I’ll literally never use this video’s sponsor, but in other vids, your ads always actually get to me. They’re genuine and you’re a likeable creator so yeah, imma use those links haha. Thanks!

[@motouarashi]

Very fun theory! I was thinking the girl might be Cassidy, perhaps possessing the bot of another character (Elizabeth, Charlie, etc.). General idea is that the Cassidy’s spirit/ai was brought back accidentally with Glitchtrap or The Crying Child, was trapped in The Princess Quest arcade games, then released via Gregory playing in Security Breach. And now in Ruin, perhaps, she is back to return the favor by saving Gregory, and probably stopping Afton once more? William always comes back, but Cassidy is always right behind him. We need our little avenger out of the data files and back in the narrative.

[@bluegold1026]

The girl being Cassidy would have made a good theory to pop into the oven as well. But like Elizabeth and Susie, she’s been dead for decades now.

[@motouarashi]

@@bluegold1026Definitely a big factor in if it’s the real her or not, and I don’t see the real Cassidy’s spirit leaving William alone to chase a virus copy, so I’d say whatever she is would be of the same nature as Glitchtrap. Either they’re both the real spirits brought back, or both AI copies. And I admit to a major question mark on the how since I am uncertain where Golden Freddy ended up in the end, but Cassidy being bound to to the real suit as a transmitter could be debatable given her UCN role. The spirits/remnant/agony-to-animatronics link feels very loosely defined right now.

[@Tiki-doll]

I like the idea of Cassidy too! It would be a nice mirror to crying boy/ggy/Gregory

[@Sissina_La_Fnaffiana]

Honestly, one of my first and favourite self-made theories is that DLC Girl is one of Gregory’s friends that he met at an orphanage (since he’s homeless he was probably staying in an orphanage if the Gregbot theory isn’t correct) and that went missing at the Pizza Plex (main reason why Gregory went there of all places, to find his missing friend). And probably now Gregory is trapped so she’s trying to help her friend escaping. Probably also possessing Glamrock Chica? Could be from what we see of the scheme color, her presence of all the animatronics in the cover and how Chica acts in SB. Another thing that she could be, if the Gregbot theory is correct, is that that is Cassidy once she escaped the Princess Quest game, killed Afton (not killed once and for all, there will be no game then) and freed Vanny, since she probably knows CC because of both of them possessing Golden Freddy/Fredbear and probably collaborating in UCN, shown by male pronouns being used and the fact that Cassidy is shown to be a girl in the logbook. She could be trying to help CC/Gregory to end Afton taking the form of a child herself. These are my theories for now, but the thing of Susie being her is something that I thought too when I first saw that she had blonde hair!

[@lonelyguy5799]

YOU KNOW WHAT MAN, i would love that idea of having the other dead kids have the lime light for this dlc, like come on cant only be about emilys and aftons

[@Xainos28]

So I had a feeling of the same thing with Chica being more involved and Amelia is the new protagonist in the DLC ruin, but let me give you some other info that could help your case for this. In the chapter Storyteller, there is also a paragraph of Mr. Burrow seeing a girl with pigtails having a tug a war moment with Glamrock Freddy over a freddy plushie, it's interesting both Storyteller and GGY mentions this in the same book. Before the DLC was called Ruin, it was originally called "Chica Chowda" and came with a poster dawko revealed on his charity stream. We know down in the Shattered Chica boss area, there is a shrine dedicated to Chica with pink lights, pizza, chica themed shoes, and plushie. Also while not sure it could be part of it, it's very odd that all the Chica plushies have Skull n' Crossbones on their tags while the other three plushies got Faz E.'s logo mark. And of course Chica the only one looking far worst of the virus that she can be heard crying. Though by themselves don't seem much, putting them together that there could be more connections between Chica both SB and Ruin which can also lead this new protagonist linking to Susie.

[@Jademoon25]

This theory is very interesting and out of the box. I have not heard this mentioned anywhere and didnt even think of it- well done! This could be the answer!

[@AiRsTrIkExXzZ]

My immediate thought when you were talking about Amelia playing fruity maze was chica being connected.

[@8bitbarbie163]

honestly i really hope so because susie has always been so intriguing to me, shes explicitly called out so many times but never really gets that much attention, so if she is the protagonist i would love it

[@cassandra3524]

I love watching your videos

[@RyeToast]

I'm glad

[@zombee098]

FINALLY A NEW VIDIOOOOOOO

[@RyeToast]

Enjoy!

[@zombee098]

@@RyeToast OMG YOU RESPONDED

[@zombee098]

@@RyeToast im a big fan for a pretty long time

[@pugg0wugg083]

2:45 - The hair colour doesn't seem to match Elizabeth's. Elizabeth has strawberry blonde hair (the orange variety), while this girl is likely straight up blonde, or a variety of strawberry blonde closer to actual blonde. 3:10 - William Afton is incapable of making anything like the Charlie bots, which is why he used illusion disks instead. 10:06 - Amelia was playing Fruity Maze, so that could be our Chica connection. 10:19 - No, I don't think I will. 10:27 - Yeah, it's most likely a parallel. 11:36 - I'm gonna say a funeral. If she just came to the Pizzaplex after a funeral, likely to cheer her up, that could explain her behaviour in the story. 12:44 - Possibly.

[@oouuuhhggtt]

just wanna remind u that elizabeth is in fact blonde in the novels

[@pugg0wugg083]

@@oouuuhhggtt Are you talking about her depiction in the graphic novels or how she's described in the regular novels?

[@oouuuhhggtt]

@@pugg0wugg083 I’m talking about her in the fourth closet. the blonde elizabeth

[@pugg0wugg083]

@@oouuuhhggtt Which version of The Fourth Closet? The regular novel or the graphic novel? Because the graphic novel is unreliable when it comes to character designs eg. Jessica's hair being the wrong colour, William's lack of cleft chin, inconsistencies etc.

[@dixieacker2886]

Suzie is quite literally the first character I thought of when the poster released. It's nice to see I'm not crazy!!

[@goliathxanatos706]

I still think it’s Cassidy. The moment I saw the poster I immediately thought it was her. She’s backlit by a golden light from her flashlight, she’s in front of what appears to be a broken down Freddy, the dlc is presumably taking place after the Afton ending which means it’s Cassidy coming back to finally lay him to rest, and how GF was never once seen throughout Security Breach let alone mentioned, which is a first for this series. I believe everything about the girl herself is a misdirection. That the hair style, the shoes, the clothing etc are all purposely made to deflect what’s apparent in front of us. Why is she standing in front of a broken Freddy that’s lit in a golden light, if it’s truly nothing noteworthy? Personally, the simplest explanation/observation is usually the right one (Mike of SL connecting to Mike from Fnaf 1 and Charlie’s death in Fnaf 2 connecting with the ending of Fnaf 6)

[@randomrhino4371]

I also thought so. And it looks like we were right! the girls name is revealed as Cassie!

[@SkyBlew]

*Nice! I think you're absolutely ON IT with this one!* 😃🙌🏾

[@giggel388]

I like the idea that security breach is about the Afton's but the Ruin DLC would be about the missing kids, It builds on the foundations were familiar with and it works

[@Parasilized]

I thought it said “She was the fourth” and my bendy instincts kicked in

[@MrFancyDragon]

I do like the idea of a parallel characters representing others from the past I mean it’s kind of like that with the Fazbear Frights and Tales from the Pizzaplex. Maybe FNAF SB isn’t all just the same characters (minus a few obvious ones) but a bunch of new parallel characters that represent the past?

[@AlienKing321]

Interesting, but I'm still going with Charlie/Puppet. Puppet is mostly black and white, with a bit of red and purple, just like the poster girl.

[@laraschroeder5195]

I WAS THINKING THE SAME THING!!! So many people were thinking Chica is gunna be your guardian in Ruin and we’re drawing Ruin Girl and Chica together, and I kept thinking how oddly it reminded me of Susie!!!

[@Monkeytower]

Your so underrated

[@RyeToast]

Thank you!

[@pentagonyx]

I'm a SLUT for Game Theory theories, so I gotta say that I'm a believer that this is Elizabeth, because PatMat over here theorizes that the owner of the Mega Pizzaplex is Mrs. Afton.

[@patrickbateman1434]

I love ur vids dude

[@RyeToast]

Thank you so much!

[@thepokemonsamurai6512]

If this is true, I think it’d be really cool to see the rest of the missing children come back in a similar way!

[@sophiahatake]

you came outta nowhere to my yt recommendations and now you're my favourite fnaf youtuber, very nice human and very nice content

[@Biggicheese22]

Just a little thing I just came up with. The Amelia in ggy is the same girl we play is in fnaf 6 when playing the fruity maze mini game. The two girls have the same description, the lights on her shoes are purple, the only time purple is used is when afton has an affect on it. We see this affect in the mini game when spring trap is behind the girl in fnaf 6 luring her away. I feel like there’s a strong connection there, especially because the fnaf 6 location is UNDER the security breach building.

[@Chrome166]

What if Glamrock Freddy isn't inhabited by Mike Afton, but actually the soul coming through is Jeremy? The way he talks about "his friends" when he sees the blob, maybe Gregory or someone else (Charlie at it again?) is trying to split the MCI kids' remnant back into four bodies to undo the Candy Cadet melted keys situation. Maybe they're trying to follow Gregory's template and make actual robot kids for them, too.

[@salmanalshatti9209]

It probably won't happen in Ruin, but if FNAF were to continue after Ruin and William Afton were to come back (again), I'd really like for the Missing Child Jeremy to be the one to do him in for good. My reasons being: 1. I just really want to give him SOME relevance/significance to the lore beyond just "Oh, and this kid shares a name with like 4 other Jeremys and possesses Bonnie". Heck, I'll even take a physical appearance! Just PLEASE Scott, PLEASE FNAF, give the poor boy some TLC! 2. I think it's poetic in a way that the one to finally defeat William Afton (Springtrap/Spring Bonnie) would be the kid who possesses Bonnie himself. After all, who better to end the murderous zombie rabbit than everyone's favorite purple bunny and ending the slander of his legacy. But other than that, great video!

[@kiwi-senpai]

ALSO! since the girl in the poster is all greyscale that could be a reference to how dead kids are depicted in greyscale in fnaf

[@samanthahobbs8578]

Look at that beautiful Play button!! Congrats Rye! So fun to rewatch older videos, look how far you’ve come! Congratulations so deserved 🎉🎉

[@bimbolilith]

Important argument about why the robot is not Charlie, is that as mentioned in one of Fuhnaff's videos, there are already signs hinting at the fact that Charlie's spirit is "haunting" the pizzaplex, and I don't think they would put her into a new character, if her soul is most likely somewhere else already. It just wouldn't make sense narratively for her to be possessing two separate entities.

[@hartplastikkaktus]

She is greyscale, like the ghosts we see time and time again in the games. Could be one of them coming back to end it all. Maybe the one who was “the first and saw everything”? Aka chica whos spirit also loomed in one of the princess minigames and there is a melted chica animatronic

[@giraffy5748]

Maybe Ameilia is Susie's sister, in the Fazbear Frights Coming Home story, it is revealed that susie had a sister,named Samantha, maybe Amelia is the game version of Samantha

[@w.d.cortex8518]

3:30 maybe being gray isn’t a mistake, maybe it indicates that she actually is a ghost

[@Devil-cat1231]

I never played fnaf but I love the theory s

[@RyeToast]

You're not alone! A good chunk of the community hasn't played a single FNAF game

[@loganentertainment1814]

I think the other thing that we're all hoping, is that Matpat's theory to who's the CEO of Fazbear Ent. is Mrs. Afton would be revealed to be true. I'm super excited to see where the DLC will go.

[@mackleberry47]

The girl is micheal afton, he’s achieved his fathers idea of living forever in a way. The way his sister and the other funtime anamatronics left his body that’s no way to live for all we know he was probably in constant pain, he killed a little girl and put his soul into her body with remnant boom.

[@fabledpigeon]

I personally like the idea that she could be Charlie- I think ID’s fantasy did a video about that a while ago- well, more about Charlie in general but the idea was presented at the end. From what I can remember without going back and rewatching it, the post it note room has two different types of handwriting. Gregory’s, presumably, and the DLC girl’s. The door texture file, I think, was also labelled as ‘Charlie’s door.’ I can’t really remember all of it, but I really liked the theory and I recommend checking it out :D

[@thecreativekid13]

Not to mention, the first actual teaser for Ruin was a poster for “Chica Chowda”…

[@oouuuhhggtt]

also, a thing about the charlie theory, in one of the novels (I think the twisted ones) charlies outfit was almost identical to the dlc girl. also wanna mention ID’s fantasys theory about charlie being in the post-it room

[@Cure-Skywalker]

It would be pretty poetic for "The First" to help who's going to presumably be The Last.

[@princessmarlena1359]

I think the girl protagonist of Ruin is a new character, but inspired by an old human character (Susie?). After all, Gregory was loosely inspired by Evan Afton (aka “Crying Child”).

[@birdsareblooming]

So this is a theory I’ve been stewing on for a little bit after watching your videos. This seems the best place to post it because 1. I don’t have any following on Twitter 2. Although I do post theories to Tumblr, those are for other video games and a FNAF theory would completely fly under the radar and go unnoticed And since it was fully inspired by you I wanted to talk about it here to possibly get the discussion about it I’m looking for. If not it’s out there at least. I’mma need you to stick with me This started with the casting for the movie. If this is an actual factor or not it at least inspired this thought process. The casting for who is most likely the crying child (due to Instagram posts, who we can see in a leaked trailer as the four kids, etc) Looks almost exactly like Gregory, down to the hair. (Lucas Grant) They even gave him a name seen in a costume hanger in an Instagram post and also on IMDB, which is Garret. Also similar to Gregory name-wise somewhat. This is a movie that cast someone as Vanessa so they’re at least taking Security Breach into account. Either way, Gregory may or may not have some connection to Crying Child, not only with being similar but I realized that if you mumble “Gregory” you get “Golden Freddy” which would sound ridiculous if Glamrock Freddy didn’t literally say “Vanny” sounded like “Vanessa” and “Bunny” so this isn’t out of the question. and this loose theory was somewhat strengthened by this video. In this you proved that the girl in Ruin is connected somewhat to Chica. Whether in contact with Susie or something of the like. I may have an answer for you. You see, if we go with the idea that Gregory is “connected” to the crying child the same way this new girl is “connected” to Chica, that gives us the same order. Sans Marionette, Crying Child died before the killings of the original 5, first of which was Susie (Which you pointed out in this video) I’m going to get to fully why later but I believe we may see ~3 more DLC or something else with the next three kids representing Freddy, Foxy and Bonnie in whatever order they were killed. My first idea was reincarnation but that seems unlikely. My next one was just plain parallel. But after rewatching your one mimic theory it clicked. Much like how Gregory was selected to be possessed, I think these two kids and the ones we don’t know yet are being selected, I don’t think it’s going to be an accident that this girl ended up here (we’ll see). Because Glitchtrap wants to mimic what William Afton did, as close as possible. I think why that girl is there is because he’s going to select kids as close to the original ones as possible. I don’t think this girl is Susie or maybe even in contact with her, I think she’s Susie’s copy, a mimicry of her if you will.

[@WarweaponPunk]

Idk if I agree with it but I do enjoy it! Mostly because it doesn't feature past characters who got TOO MUCH of the spotlight already, it doesn't equal to RuinBeth theory(I hate that theory a lot), it doesn't equal to whoever thought of RuinCharlie, and it has a logical sense to it, not just "Oh, it's a robot child version of Susie" or "It's a memory of Susie and the whole Ruin DLC is one big trip into Afton's mind" no, it makes sense considering who we're talking about. It's so refreshing that, that alone, makes it good.

[@irladovelasquez975]

Facts I prefer ruinsusie better than ruinbeth the theory makes 0% sense

[@flapdaplap1537]

Dang Rye you soared with these videos and put wonderful effort into them, I hope to see you soar higher and make a big wonderful community

[@GeneralRavenBeak]

Rye toast, you never fail to amaze with your theories. Top notch content indeed :)

[@kendallgarciaa]

Nice, first time early to the theory !!!

[@RyeToast]

Welcome in!

[@reagan1197]

I dunno guys, we really don’t know anything about this girl so it’s like, how can we make good theories with little to no knowledge about her

[@Robbie-lc5fc]

The biggest stretch of this theory is that the purple thing in fruity maze is a cape, I was like 99% sure it was a slug.

[@lolcat909]

this also could explain the random appearance of Chica in Princess Quest 3 watching us from behind a hole

[@captain_chocolate]

If you mess with the exposure in the poster she has a pink shirt with a blue skirt.

[@brandon0sh]

Susie was the first thought I had months ago when i first saw the ruin poster. I figured nobody was talking about it because there was some obvious reason i hadn't considered why it couldnt be susie.

[@Azrail_Fenrir]

Okay I have a theory for you RyeToast. When Freddy gets Chica's voicebox upgrade his bowtie goes from black to purple, possibly representing Fredbear. To the left of parts and service we have 5 endos in cages, 3 white lights, 1 red light and one without a light. Is it possible that these are linked to the bite of 83. With a possibility that the uncaged endo is Spring Bonnie due to the glitching??

[@overworldgames7508]

This theory is the one thing I feel like we were looking for the whole time. And in-This case N with Said facts, you put out about it being Susie is the perfect reasoning behind her appearance. (I'm petty sure isn't wearing all black i can safely assume that Jackets dark Pink or purple?)

[@batriam5921]

one of the things that could point to this is that fruity maze is a single player game with no enemies as far as I remember. So I can't see why you would yell "You did not just do this" specifically at that game.

[@doublewoofwoof]

With the new mimic story in mind, I think Amelia was selected by vanny or the mimic because she looks like Susie and the mimic, in its quest to become Afton, is trying to re create the MCI. Starting with the first, Susie.

[@v.v365]

The only thing I can think of that sticks out to me about the girl’s design is the colors on her light up shoes being red and purple. Red is the color of the Blob’s eyes, right? And Purple is the color of Afton-possessed animatronics and dark remnant, I think. Blob is agony, manifesting as red, Glitchtrap virus and/or Afton’s dark remnant is purple, just wanted to put that out there and see.

[@thesanchezway3909]

Finally a modern FNaF theory that makes sense

[@Fearthemushroom]

Your theory over top of making a lot of sense, could add a really good gameplay mechanic where instead of jumping into Freddy to hide from animatronics, you'd have the ghost sort of cover and hide you, and maybe the storyline for this game is getting the sould back to Chica's body, uniting body and soul so it can rest in peace, but that would only really make sense if it was the original Chica's body, which then again, could be stored in a secret room of the pizza Plex, but that's just my mind jumping to different places

[@kotavelaz1987]

I think I remember a detail from the Silver Eyes books that Charlie was the most scared of Chica as her father was building the robots. I not sure I think it's Charlotte, but this could be evidence to support it.

[@seanbenoit3573]

Wait just realized that the quinces quest games are in ruins and people think the princess in it is Cassidy ??

[@undergirl04]

Now I'm upset that Cassie exists, Susie would have such a cool main character for Ruin!

[@bewtyboo]

Steel Wool may need to hurry up, the theorists are going to figure out the game before it releases 😂

[@megatronusorionpax4900]

I remember seeing a Matpat video where he theorizes that the girl might be Suzie, the girl who later posseses Chica and the girl from that dog mini game (Fruity Maze I think it's called) in FNAF6 which for some reason I could totally see happening

[@Benm8_]

I really have that feeling that fnaf is near its end

[@glitchtrap_playz2194]

The same 8-bit girl you showed in the video is in fnaf 4 and I really enjoy your videos RyeToast I hope you and everyone watching has a great rest of your day or night or evening depending on what part of the world you are currently watching this video.

[@NWolfsson]

12:35 A CAPE! That makes so much more sense than a slug!

[@somerandomperson9670]

Does anyone else notice how Gregory is left handed when it comes to holding stuff

[@venomfan2020]

8:40 Chekov's Gun, people... _Chekov's Gun..._ _"if it is accurately described early on, it is required to be of important use later..."_

[@New3DSLuigi364]

I Love the idea of Amelia Communicating with Chica/Susie!!! Just as Much as I Unironically like the Idea of Glammike aka Michael Afton inhabiting Glamrock Freddy!! /gen

[@original_namexd5690]

Gonna need someone to cover the Ryetoast cinematic universe

[@uhhYouTubeUser]

don’t forget about that poster of chicas food poster, i forgot what it was but chica definitely has a major connection

[@imalright48]

really sweet of you to shout out the donation page for one of your viewers mom's

[@janno7214]

My jaw literally dropped when you brought up the colors of the power ups in fruity maze omg😱