Thank you as always for an amazing shuir. What a blessing to learn about Hashem in such a deep concept.
@ronaldsinger944511 ай бұрын
Rav Shimshon Raphael Hirsch, in my opinion, simplifies the interpretation of Deuteronomy 4:5 (and 4:39) as only God has independent existence and every other existence is dependent on God. Consciousness or awareness is a different issue and is relative to a person’s efforts and HaShem’s hashkachah pratite for the individual. Existence that is infinite and independent verses existence which is dependent on God defines God and man’s finite dependent nature.
@robertperonne38411 ай бұрын
I don't understand how the bread of shame arises from our sense of self? I thought it came from our ability to receive from God but inability to resemble him and give back.
@suneethamay361511 ай бұрын
I always remains as Christian
@jakobw13511 ай бұрын
Perhaps a good way to grasp our conception of G-D is to use the example of a MOBIUS STRIP - where you take a strip of paper give it one half twist and join the ends so it looks like a figure eight. Put your finger on one side and do one rotation - you end up on the other side. When you repeat the process you come back to the original side. This illustrates being in and outside of yourself - at the same time! The other idea has to do with the verb - TO ABSTRACT - meaning to pull back and see the context. We can only do that to Infinity - SO TO SPEAK. But, G-D is at the source of this ability. HE is both the abstractor and the abstracted - at the same time. ☺️
@rtwoods11 ай бұрын
You're a joke
@jakobw13511 ай бұрын
First, mazel tov on this very insightful and interesting presentation! Concerning the description of an object that does not yet exist and the example you gave of a tape recorder in the 16th century - that would not work because there are so many things you have to describe which are totally outside even the conception of people in those days - that it would just not work . G-D provides all of the details that you need to understand a particular concept and object for each generation. Our modern contraptions are totally beyond the 10 of previous generations - certainly going back several centuries! ☺️
@rtwoods11 ай бұрын
Writing again, you must like to hear yourself talk huh? DaVincis notebook disproves your little rant, and take it from a theoretical physicist your Mobius example is no different from your flawed analysis of the tape recorder. Do better.
@jakobw13511 ай бұрын
@@rtwoodsAnd you sound like a FLAWED and imagined physicist at best! Only G-D knows if you can do better!
@jakobw13511 ай бұрын
the KEN of previous generations NO 10! (damn AI)
@rtwoods11 ай бұрын
Stop cursing
@jakobw13511 ай бұрын
But IRONICALLY, don't you lose your sense of self and freedom to choose - when you LOVE The Creator?