The Settlers New Allies Review - They never even tried!

[@WorthABuyreviews]

FYI any messages that tell you to go to Telegram for a free gift using my name are fake, there are no free prizes, it's a scam bot.

[@ElephoontOfTheShapes]

We wouldn't need free prizes anyway. Your channel is already a gift that keeps on giving.

[@MisterEE100]

@@ElephoontOfTheShapes lol... brown nose :D but true.

[@spugggaldon361]

I demand more free stuff! Excellent videos for free on the KZbin isn't enough free stuff!

[@pureplay7071]

@@ElephoontOfTheShapes 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Justin-qd8ib]

sounds like someone wants to keep the goods for himself...

[@rePAULsion]

Positives: "It uninstalls easy"

[@sivanshafiq9255]

LMFAO

[@janlundvall8783]

😂

[@goranschkreblin8769]

Bro 80€

[@WorthABuyreviews]

A few things I missed from the review due to the list of bad things being so damn long... The annoying tannoy voice you get all the time during the game, every time you spot an enemy you get this tannoy saying "Enemy in sight" if you watch the last 60 seconds of the video you can here it spamming all the time in the background. Also you don't get the control over your supply chain that you used to get, for example set percentages of things you need crafting or set specific numbers, things like geologists and pioneers are now gone and replaced by engineers. You also don't need to craft tools for the different trades, they are now born with the correct tools in their hands. It's all dumbed down, am so peed off :(

[@Retrofire-47]

@@MichaelJ44 You mean 2042, Battlefield 1942 was the creative bastion of the OG Battlefield devs.

[@livingsound5956]

You said you loved settlers 3 and 4, have you tried them with "Settlers United" they added a few things to make it a better playing experience, and HD patch for settlers 4 that looks beautiful! and also easy multiplayer, I see people playing all the time. you should check it out. PS I love your reviews!

[@johnmcafee9663]

im staying clear of ubisoft from now on based on the fact they are working with UK police to police in game behaviour in their games

[@bhushanharripersad5716]

You mean that they unlearnt the lesson that they learned when they dumbed down Anno 2205 from Anno 2070, so much so that the brought back the complexity in Anno 1800.

[@kevindeerenberg1142]

I love the settlers the classic settlers 2 gold edition. To bad games are not the same anymore miss the old days with gaming

[@jonevansauthor]

It's mind blowing that the managers really directed their team to make this travesty. Can you imagine being so arrogant that they thought it would work? They could have just made the game we actually wanted and taken the mickey with the monetisation and we'd have taken it just to get a good game.

[@XCROSSBONEX]

There is no need to make a better game. People will buy it anyway.

[@MisterMakerNL]

They measure success in moneys not quality.

[@MarekSurman]

Well CDPR thought vanilla cyberpunk will work so this is not THAT mind blowing.

[@Scytha86]

At this point people would be happy if they just remake 3 or 4 with this engine. After that they could "experiement" with new ideas (turn in to a console game) if they want if that is thier agenda.

[@MisterMakerNL]

@@andyc7747 To bad it doesn't.

[@TheMaynard88]

I am so damn sick of low effort remakes/reboots. Every modern dev seems to think remake=pretty graphics. Full stop. They absolutely gut the gameplay and depth of the original and insert generic cartoony animations that, idk, must appeal to other art college hacks, and then say the problem is YOU. The new Pharaoh is another perfect example of this. Anyway, thanks for saving me a purchase. Get yourself 10 minutes of therapy. I'll be in line behind you.

[@WorthABuyreviews]

Thanks Maynard, really appreciate the tip :) And I totally share your pain, it's getting ridiculous now.

[@robintst]

The director of the game said early last year that they had to redesign the game as the gameplay systems they originally designed were overcomplicated. Everything nowadays has to be made so even an infant can solve it, having to engage in critical thinking is too hard for everyone's feeble little brain meats.

[@Cenot4ph]

So they pretty much decided to make it a shit game then and there

[@robintst]

@@Cenot4ph More or less, yeah.

[@MisterMakerNL]

I think they IQ tested whales and realized they are idiots. So they trying too catch whales by making games for idiots.

[@MarekSurman]

There is still load of games coming out that are challenging and deep and very successfull...not sure why some publishers think gamers dont want it.

[@Kolopaper]

​@@MarekSurman Because even though action games(Souls style and similar games) that are hard to play can actually sell well, strategy games specifically are not selling for massive money for various reasons. One of those reasons, it's because they are hard to play. If companies don't see huge numbers like in their other games, they don't put more money/effort.

[@martinbennett9908]

Love the 'It uninstalls easy' plus point!

[@Dearestandme]

Ubisoft knows they don't have to try when society as a whole doesn't care anymore and is being dumbed down

[@MaxRager80]

They don't fool me with their shit games. Though most people do just consume, which sucks.

[@db8658]

Yep. I'm only one person, but I stopped buying "AAA" games years ago. Kinda wish more people would say goodbye to these lazy greedmongers.

[@andrejz8954]

@@db8658 same pretty much!

[@WuTangChopstick]

People born in 2000+ are so damn stupid.

[@ludomirsteinbruck9376]

It seems that gaming diversifies, there are plenty of ultra complex games out there, and people actual dont want games like this, so the blame tis more in Ubisoft

[@TrainingDummiesYT]

The miners don't need farms because they are eating ze bugs, and that's all you need to be happy. Eat ze bugs Mac!

[@MichaelJ44]

Anything is possible in the 15 minute city

[@Chozo_Ghost]

He will own no bugs, and he will be happy

[@oneill6291]

Yeah I was going to say - Our PM is trying to shut down all our farmers up here in Canada

[@braddimond7119]

Own nothing and be happy mac!!!

[@303storm]

Good to see enlightened people here.

[@cloverdog85]

Its ubisoft, so I didn't think they would try

[@vukandusanovic5410]

This makes me appreceate old games even more

[@robertn2997]

Settlers 3and 4, Knights and merchants, anno 1503 are pure gold compared to this

[@MrRafagigapr]

ubisoft can amazingly turn any game bad with 0 creativity and dulling it down

[@RyTrapp0]

It's just so damn frustrating to live in what I would argue is a golden age of enthusiast hardware(yea, prices aren't great; but we have an ABSURD amount of horsepower available to us now) - while the game devs are putting out straight TRASH. I don't give a damn about how "pretty" the new game looks with insane FPS, because it's a trash game, come the hell on.

[@Brenryz]

@@RyTrapp0 I was ready to click buy for an insane price of $59.99, then while watching a guy on Twitch getting constantly frustrated with clogged up roads. That was a major deal breaker for me. His people were running congested conga lines going nowhere, and couldn't create a second road lane as it wanted to merge together. This is a definite hard pass.

[@Jarekx2007]

There was passion then. The fall happens in every industry. The capitalists/money men eventually take over the company, and all the people who made it great either cash out, get pushed out or join them. Now their only purpose is to extract as much money in as short of time as possible from their customers. Nothing more. It's no wonder this game was set up to be like Clash of Clans with that fake currency store.

[@Doomblade3890]

It’s called The Settlers because they settled for less. Much much less.

[@AdamDeBeers]

I played Settlers on Amiga 500 about 30 years ago. Nowadays the games are made for infants. Remember Ufo: Enemy Unknown on Amiga 500? When there was large Ufo landed, or shot down ( 3 story ufo ) I had sometimes wait about 40 minutes for my next turn, when I clicked "end of turn" That game ( Ufo: Enemy Unknown ) was so demanding on this small computer. Oh yeah, I forget to mention, this game was played from floppies ( 3,5" inch floppy disc ). I miss old days of great games.

[@robertgaunt6299]

I played this game in beta and the responses from the testers where along the same lines as you have said. It seems to have been made with a focus on pvp battles and ranked battles ie build and army quick and attack the other guy. It was delayed after the beta because of the bad reception and it looks like nothing has changed.

[@orkhepaj]

because if you want change you have to fire the idiot managers who decided what this game should be first , i always wonder how the hell they get their jobs

[@FloundFahrdienst]

The irony of it all is that the multiplayer doesnt even work properly as of now and that was their main reason to change the 2019 version to this garbage of a game

[@sanderartable]

And dumbed down for console players....

[@ShikukuWabe]

saw some streamers the other day, it seems that the only thing that changed is that they placed more AI camps in between players so it will interrupt your ability to early game rush your opponent.. I played the beta too, was so disappointed, surprised after cancelling a dozen games, they thought this might still work..

[@jakejutras5420]

​@sanderartable oh STFU, platform being played doesn't determine intelligence ffs. Civilization isn't changes for console.

[@leaf16nut]

How do developers not see we don't want *massive* changes, especially in beloved franchises, just create the same game you did 15 years ago - new setting, better graphics, more campaign, and changes around the edges, not huge changes to the *core* features. I blame kids nowadays, games have been constantly dumbed down, extensive tutorials explaining absolutely everything and holding your hand throughout. Sickening.

[@mcsputz4494]

I have fond memories of The Settlers on the Amiga back in the day and was hoping to revisit the glory days in this latest version. Sadly not to be. Thank you for saving us the trouble and the coin of finding out how far this franchise has fallen. So disappointed.

[@georgerubypoppy1063]

The Settlers creator, Volker Wertich, has formed his own studio and is making the game this pile of garbage was initially intended to be. Look up Pioneers of Pagonia.

[@ZartaxtheWise]

Settlers 7, which is quite old and probably cheap, is good and will bring back memories. I payed 500 SEK ($50) around 94-95 for Settlers 1 when I was 13 or so and played it to bits. My save game name is still used as my wifi password at home. :D

[@saturn580]

Whenever somebody says they've "re-imagined" a great franchise, you know it's going to be garbage.

[@GangsterFrankensteinComputer]

It's the, "I'm going to try and sell my slightly similar idea under a recognised name", trick. I'll never forget American Psycho 2 lmfao.

[@gsangerl]

"Re-imagined" for the "modern audiences"

[@terencecallaghan8719]

I tried the beta for this.. I gave detailed feedback on how it could improve but it looks like that fell on deaf eyes. An absolute shame in every sense of the word.

[@MrSTVR]

Ubisoft is a dying company, and the funniest part is nobody even wants to buy them.

[@joshuat6124]

I only played settlers 3 and I remember vividly the moment I figure out how to get my first fish out of the river/sea. I was so so excited, because I think my miners weren't working. I didn't know I had to actually target a fish in the sea tile to get it to pull out a fish, the fish was so fat and plump, it was beautiful.

[@scottagon]

If they had spent half the time developing the depth and complexity as they have on the animations, this could have been a great game. Such a shame

[@atnfn]

I suppose ubisoft is going bankrupt soon anyway. Well deserved. They've turned all the games I used to like to shit.

[@actiontom]

Damn.. I still remember settlers 2 and I think I will re-play it. That was the best settlers. Period.

[@Swwatter]

No it wasn't. Period.

[@Monstrick1]

@@Swwatter Settlers 2 is great. Anniversary edition is great also. My favorites are 2 and 3. So different, yet so good. 7 was great also, although i was not a fan at first. Visual design is amazing though.

[@Swwatter]

@@Monstrick1 definitely not arguing that 2 wasn't great. Just that it wasn't the greatest.

[@insanebe1]

@@Swwatter i think it was the greatest, but this is just down to style of play - 3 & 4 were good too but i liked the "non click move" soldiers style of play in settlers 2, was more of a chess game than an RTS

[@VocaloidEnjoyer1]

@@Swwatter If you ignore any nostalgic feelings from a technical standpoint settler 7 was objectively the best. It was the first settler to introduce multiple ways to win the game, through, military, economy, trading, religion etc it was just a great game.

[@strugglesnuggledslime7040]

Whatever happened to german game development? They were the kings of economical strategy games and simulators in the 90s/early 00s but ever since Ascaron bit the dust it has all just been downhill.

[@EliasVergsen]

Nothing is challenging in modern games. They don't require you to think and pretty much make it impossible for you to lose.

[@Daniboi971]

That’s because kids these days can’t bare challenging things. Participation medals

[@icer22x]

In the world of TikTok and feeds, and vines, and whatever other instant gratification garbage you can think of, developers now have to produce games to satiate the appetites of the mindless idiots that comprise most gamers today. Everything is streamlined fast-paced trash with no sense of reward. It's all about the clicks and on-screen stimulation. Idiocracy was prophetic.

[@MichaelJ44]

They really need to remaster the old ones (actually.. let them rest in peace, away from AAA torment) , never played Settlers, but I made a comment last night in your stream Mac about the tropico franchise. It prioritises on Trade, economy and politics it might be right up your street .. it’s nice to be a little prck and imprison everyone who disagrees with El Presidente.. it’s really nice to do that. We aren’t too far off ;)

[@cyberangel82]

They did remaster all of the old Settlers games, what are you talking about?

[@MichaelJ44]

@@cyberangel82 wrong

[@obsi1]

I am happy that Ubisoft makes minus numbers. I only feel sorry for the employees who get instructions from the extremely bad management.

[@AetherXIV]

Settlers 3 captured my imagination as a grade schooler. I drew pages of battles and tried to copy the art style... so sad that games suck so bad now.

[@LimeymanZero]

0:18 Why are the blue guys fighting the Spotify guys?

[@Cenot4ph]

Everyone knows Settlers 2 was the best of the bunch, supply chain focussed to mobilize your military. It seems this game forgot what settlers was all about, creating the optimal supply chains to outperform the enemy

[@thespudmonke]

6:11 that death animation is the most nostalgic thing about this game for me. I played game this nearly 2 decades ago and remember VERY little about it, but that soul beam has stuck in my mind forever. To this day I get a little rush of nostalgia every time I play an RTS that has an animation even resembling it, and think back to this game. I'm about to throw away so many hours watching your playthrough of this game.

[@cann5565]

As a miner irl, that's pretty much how our owners act. 👌

[@stanislavkimov2779]

Seeing the 1st image with a blue-haired female soldier, everything was already clear about this game.

[@Kirgast]

My first intro to the Settlers series was the 2nd game. Friend and myself played it so much we used to frequently have dreams of still playing the game, seeing the settlers moving about the resources. I later got my hands on the 4th game, it was pretty good. Then i later played 6 some, it was eh. But 7 was decent. It took a lot i liked and made it work. But it also lacked some of the fun of older games. I was really looking for a new good Settlers game, but i doubt its going to happen now. As they seem set on killing the franchise.

[@dubstyle311]

Please check out Farthest Frontier. It reminded me of S2. WAB has a review.

[@Nicholas_Steel]

Did you know The Settlers II Gold Edition (DOS) included around 300 custom fan made levels (without any of their permission) with many of them unwinnable in the Gold Edition because Blue byte disabled the ability to build big transport ships in the Gold Edition? This is also why some of the original campaigns missions were replaced with different, inferior levels... They should work fine in the original The Settlers 2 (DOS) though. To play them you had to replace the campaign level files with the fan made levels. I don't know if digital distributions of the Gold Edition game include the 300~ fan made levels.

[@georgerubypoppy1063]

The Settlers creator, Volker Wertich, has formed his own studio and is making the game this pile of garbage was initially intended to be. Look up Pioneers of Pagonia.

[@sanethoughtspreader]

​@@georgerubypoppy1063 so far the art looks so cartoony :(

[@sanethoughtspreader]

​@@Nicholas_Steel loved settlers two. I love that it had multiplayer as a split screen on PC and you needed to mice to play!

[@tarnishedgaming6404]

Why is it on PS4 but I can't download it doesn't even say anything when u click on game

[@salaciouscrumb]

Thanks for reviewing this Mack, and so soon after release. Shame that blue byte missed the mark with this after Anno 1800.

[@BeasantN]

So Mack what your saying, and could've said in 10 seconds is not recommended because its another AAA POS and saved us 11 minutes we will never get back.

[@brianlevor6295]

I was late to Settlers, but even Settlers 7 had a complex economy and considerable challenge. You had to start with food, plan for tools, and when you got to gold bars had to choose whether to spend them on clergy, soldiers or traders. Either of those choices required other goods as well (books, weapons, horses, wheels, clothing, etc) with their own production lines. If you expanded too fast the AI would take your undefended land, but if you expanded too slowly you'd run out of resources. The story was decent and the campaign (esp the 2nd one) could be quite difficult when set to harder difficulties. Then the skirmish mode presented tons of options to play vs. AI. I will never buy this 2023 dumbed down garbage.

[@AlunParsons]

I play Settlers 7 more than any of the others, simply because I can finish a game in a few hours. It may not be the best Settlers, but it is infinitely better than this dross.

[@flankspeed007]

"It's 2023 and games suck now....AAA games." Amen Mac. Sad but true. Thank god for Indy games AAA has completely lost the plot.

[@5deadspace]

I can only imagine the game is this dumbed down because it's coming to console in March which annoys me. It's as if the devs think console users are too stupid for in depth RTS games.

[@GeraltofRivia22]

Literally everything Ubisoft makes now is utter shite.

[@robertrenato]

"It uninstalls easy" - that hit hard in the very last moment hahaha! Love Ya Mack Mack:D

[@Pl4sm0]

Hey Mac, any chance you try Returnal ? I think you will like it

[@NDHat]

WorthABuy never fails me. I was probably going to buy this new settlers, but you saved me lol. I appreciate it as always

[@slipknotsoad86]

That UI looks like it was made in unity following a 4 year old youtube tutorial. no personality to it at all!

[@DarlinaLTesh]

Settlers 1 on Amiga 500 was one of the first strategy games I ever played. It's so sad to see what happened to it over the years / decades... and now this? I'm lost for words... all this waiting, hoping and then this... oof.

[@Joxonart]

It's because people need to focus more on Indie devs, Local devs and less on Corpo Devs.. The Corpo Devs have only one care. To be First and Profit, more and more and more, even if they made enough profit, no, still need more. Its the Void in the belly that never gets full. Thats in theyr Nature it seems.

[@apothecarymaybe3402]

So another RTS being dumbed down for console?

[@thecoryguy]

This game isn't for gamers. As you've said in regards to all AAA games these days - they're holding your hand. The graphics and animations are the selling point.

[@nicolasperalta501]

Dude your reviewa are absolutely hilarious, precise, direct to the point, I love'em... When you said "you can watch the ENTIRE Lord Of The Rings Trilogy and never get attacked..." made laugh real loud

[@AndreOliveira-vm1xz]

I feel like it was almost worth it that the game was so bad, it made this review possible. Best review I ever saw

[@JerkyJones100]

Another kick to the nuts from the gaming industry. Sad state of affairs.

[@WorthABuyreviews]

On the plus side I have Atomic Heart to play all day tomorrow :)

[@danielschmidt7153]

Amen, I'm anticipating that game Mack

[@jamaly77]

​​@@Chambers36TheEnter88% on Steam. I didn't try it but seems you were quite a bit off.

[@Ilsyde]

Incompetency strikes again. Time to kill off another successful franchise I guess.

[@Monstrick1]

So much opportunity wasted. I've been dying so see more features, more unique visuals. SEASON CHANGES!!!. Damn, i want it so bad. Imagine having different temperature regions, different pack animals and so on. God damn, i'm so heartbroken. Thank you for the video D..:

[@whiteymcflightey]

Definitely need to have a strong WAHHMEN of COLOR be a character in a medieval European setting......

[@boeos]

Settlers one was always my favourite back on the Amiga.

[@TheBunt1111]

All they needed to do was copy and paste settlers 4 onto modern day tech and bam perfect settlers game. Alas they did not…

[@moliomotiejus6412]

"How does it feel to have lived long enough to see all your favorite franchises go down in flames?" -RedLetterMedia

[@ConnorTzupa]

Some developers just want to watch the game industry burn. *augmented joker quote" 😢😅

[@ShaneMcGrath.]

I used to love the series back in Amiga 500 days, Damn shame they ruined it. I hope it's because they have put all their resources into the next Assassins' Creed games, But I would be fooling myself to believe that, AAA game snow are a rush fest to appease shareholders, They either suck or come out and need a 20Gb day one patch just to make it playable. Can we go back to the 80's please, Good games were plentiful and you could afford a house on even a low wage.

[@-xARCHONx-]

One of the best features of settlers 3 or 4 was the complex production chains and map generator/creator

[@bernhardlabus8511]

And if you fucked up that chain at any moment, you were done. A lot of mission relied on that with stuff like hidden islands with good mine spots etc.

[@fidomuh]

What happened to all the fancy hero-centric stuff from their early looks ? Honestly, this looks nothing like what they initially presented and the only comparison I can see, is to the online-browser-settlers-crap they pushed out. Maybe this was originally intended to replace that and somehow they thought it would work as a full game? I don't get why they don't just make proper games any more. The Settlers has such a simple premise and the tweaks they presented could easily have worked as something "extra", so why dumb it down? Why break a formula that already works? I mean, the custom skirmish modes have been a core thing since the first Settlers game... It's such a shame to see yet another franchise completely ruined :/

[@pjbenton1980]

I make a note never to buy Ubisoft games.

[@bmnbl]

This is why RTS is 100% dying its not because people dont want it, its because developers dont care anymore. Last Age of Empires wasn't bad but its still very inferior to AoE2 remastered.

[@littleaussierippa]

"They Never Even Tried" should be the quote on the front of the box.

[@duke_revna6404]

Just another Ubisoft Ingame Shop setup. :( Settlers was this great series that got ripped apart again. But the man behind the old settlers is developing his own title. Lets hope that will be good.

[@kevinraposo348]

so another game where the devs mostly focused on presentation over gameplay mechanics.

[@ebrarian71]

"It uninstalls easy" - I'd piss myself laughing if it wasn't such a tragedy of a game

[@jakkuhl6223]

I saw a black woman's face in the first minute or so and thought, "this game is gonna suck," and I was right. Funny how reliable a predictor that is.

[@marissavanhelsing7309]

Ubisoft: "I don't understand why we are financially struggling now!?" Also Ubisoft: Keeps killing beloved game franchises

[@Applecompuser]

Their stock is $8.00 per share. Now, I know why.

[@ubermiley]

Been waiting for a very long time for this game. I loved the settlers 3 and i remember playing it as a 10y old and having a blast even tho it had hard systems i needed to learn. I can't put into words how disapointed i am to see this game. guess i'll have to wait another 20 years or so before i get to live those moments again in the settlers. Cheers for the review guys, well done.

[@Ramotttholl]

how did you find out were to place mines for ores? if that wasn't just a overlay you can turn on or whatever id add another + to the game + 'It Doesn't have X-ray vision'

[@esharpeh]

i suggest that you revisit northgard in order to play a more than worthy successor to settlers. you did not appreciate what it was 2 years ago and the game was vastly improved since then.

[@esharpeh]

@ALCLCF well... imagine a properly streamlined settlers with actually appealing pvp, exploration, straategic decisionmaking, multiple & different faction unique victory conditions in every single game, upgrades, light diplomacy and much much more. sure you do not have complex logistics trees anymore but honestly if you can only get your "settlers" out of big logistics you should play s2 and stronghold since only they do this, not even s4

[@_R2H]

A remake of 'Pharaoh' is also out. Maybe a review 😬

[@TheInterestRates]

Mack, I recommend you try Against the Storm. It's in Early Access and it's very Settlers. May just be right up your alley.

[@HabitsOftheWolf]

I feel like with the rise of the weak, everything is becoming weak. I thought rise of the nerds was supposed to make society very smart. Apparently we just cry and have no challenges, and become a bunch of pussies.

[@HabitsOftheWolf]

@Dawn Razor Well they are more or less awkward introverts, so yea, but they are now most people from all the whining I see haha

[@joppek77]

If the rumors are anything to go by, this game has been through some kind of development hell, so it's no wonder the end result is disappointing. Probably a case of the publisher meddling, wanting some kind of live service garbage and a cash shop. IMO the best "settlerslike" of today is called Foundation. It's early access and still comes up short feature wise, but it has good potential to be a spiritual successor to Settlers 1.

[@dereksmalls6238]

Foundation was my most played game last year, it's a great city builder!

[@TheRagingHardon]

"its 2023 and games suck now." :(

[@TheGXDivider]

Thanks, was about to buy it. I have fond memories of the Settlers 2 back in 96 and I was about to make a mistake :)

[@igorthelight]

2, 3 and 4 are good ;-) All after that - not so much.

[@EdwardDragon96]

The funny thing is, THIS WAS a The Settlers game back in 2019. They had a pretty decent game back then because back then it was made by the guy who invented The Settler. Management didnt like it (they wanted something monetizeable), so they took everything they had, threw it in the garbage, made the guy (the inventor) leave the project, stoped communicating with the community and threw out the Beta last year about a month prior to the planned release. They got told its sh*t, so they took it pretended to work on it for another year, then thought "f*ck you anyway and released it with minor changes.

[@k9wazere]

Which makes absolutely no sense to anyone except Ubisoft's management. They could have finished the Volker Wertich "Settlers" game, apparently fairly far along in development anyhow, then churned this pile out afterwards under a different name, perhaps "HerpDerp: The Gaim".

[@sambauman69]

The guy who invented the Settlers and who was kicked off this game now has Pioneers of Pagonia out, which is a REAL SETTLERS game, not like this crap.

[@SeiyuRavensong]

Love your reviews.. one of the very very few i trust.

[@kon_radar]

There are three great The Settlers 2 remakes: 1) The Settlers II: 10th Anniversary 2) The Settlers II: 10th Anniversary - Vikings (12 new missions) 3) The Settlers: Rise of Cultures (3 different tribes having different economy)

[@RonEmpire]

Yes the anniversary version was great. Funny thing is you can't buy it from ubi soft but only from gog. It's like ubisoft just doesn't want good games on their store

[@therealsunaru]

This has to be one of the funniest game reviews I've ever heard in my life 😂

[@mancamiatipoola]

Oh, you must be new here then. Welcome to Mack's Worth a Buy shack then! If you want to have a riot on a nice weekend, just open up the thumbs down playlist. You will laugh with tears at some of them. I can recommend my fav tho, which is Death Stranding. I LMAO every time at that one. XD Mack is pure gold because he is brutally honest and he curses like a pirate when he doenst like a game.

[@DiegoGajardo-q9x]

When are they gonna make a Settlers 4 remake!!

[@ZachNovak]

Showing your age with this one, my favourite game as a 9yo was the Settlers on Amiga, so many great memories of that game. I miss making my own roads haha This game has lost it's soul trying to be other games when it just had to be itself.

[@igorthelight]

Idie developer would make a proper Settlers much faster than AAA studios ;-) For example - try "Against the Storm".

[@ghostmark2005]

I remember trying to play the Settlers as like a 7 or 8 year old and not understanding it at all because I was used to AOE point and click on easy mode lol. what's the best settlers out of all of them?

[@clivewarner6571]

It's a toss up between 2 and 3 I would say

[@zhlo]

I was so excited to play this but i wanted to wait for some reviews. After seeing this all i can say is Ubisoft did a great job of destroying one of my most favorite games i grew up playing. Well done!

[@hrisak1]

Thanks Worth a buy for this great and fun review. Im born in late 70´s and played the first games in the 90´s over and over, loved III and IV and was really excited when I heard that a reboot of Settlers was about to be released. After watching this absolutely brilliant review I took a hard turn away from buying this bucket of diarrhea. It saddens me to see an all time classic like this get shat on and made with no respect and love for the history of the franchise. Makes me wonder if the upcoming release of the new Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown is also gonna be shit.

[@GangsterFrankensteinComputer]

Looks like AoE for 4 year olds.

[@jackcaven9614]

They have gone down the same road that EA did with C&C. In the development stage of a game they ask gamers (potential customers) whether they play this type of game, if the answer is no, they then give them multiple options as to why they don't, one being... it's too complicated! They then go about simplifying the game mechanics for these people(potential customers) this does one of two things, it alienates fans of this type of game because the deep game mechanics are what draws them to this genre in the first place, and secondly those gamers that chose the option 'it's too complicated' still don't buy the game because it's just not their thing.... end result... a game that nobody likes!

[@k9wazere]

We went from having small teams of artists (in every sense) who made games they themselves would enjoy.. to vast studios with thousands of (probably still very talented) employees - but the latter were/are merely employees whose bosses (and decision makers) value nothing but dollars. There is no art for art's sake today. Maybe there never truly was - everybody needs to eat - but the change from labour of love to "most valuable franchise/revenue stream" is obvious for all to see. The studios are too big. The games are too bland. The hunt is always for most bums on seats, and anything that doesn't generate more sales is cast off. But the solution is entirely in our hands. Just don't buy pap (like this).

[@Falky1]

Damn shame, ive been wanting a decent Settlers game to be released. I used to love playing Heritage of Kings years ago.

[@T33K4Y]

that's one of the worst ones 💀

[@Matruchus]

Pioneers of Pagonia from original Settlers developers will be released end of this year.

[@T33K4Y]

@@Matruchus yep!

[@Falky1]

@@T33K4Y wasn't for me 😊

[@Falky1]

@@Matruchus Ah cool, shall keep an eye out for that!

[@UssCerrrrrrrrrrritos]

6:52 good review, but you can select the map under Options and gameplay or Something Like that (I Just played the German Version)

[@WorthABuyreviews]

Thats not map selection tbh, that just lets you select maps you prefer to play and if you host a coop game and the other players have different preferences the game will make a educated guess on what maps you all want to use, thats hardly map selection.

[@UssCerrrrrrrrrrritos]

@@WorthABuyreviews also true

[@Keglanek]

Closing all the farms down? mack become the UK government for a moment there.

[@wombatpt]

Mac, i'm from the Amiga days also and this... This just makes me sad. You've been telling for quite some time now that this would eventually happen. They just don't care anymore, devs, artists, publishers, the f.... industry! Ruined one of my all time favourite games.

[@laylen245]

this is what happens when uni's dont train people to be creative anymore they train them to take orders and wait to be given the answers instead of work it out for themselves. i have so many friends with masters and docs and non of them can tell you how do something or even work it out for them selfs out side of what that bit of paper tells them they are good at.

[@GangsterFrankensteinComputer]

The problem is people go to uni to study video games lol.

[@burningsheep4473]

In case anybody needs more Settlers: "Knights and Merchants" is currently on offer over at gog for less than 2 €. It was made by some of the lead developers on Settlers II. It's more militarily focussed and the campaign eventually turns into a military grind, but until then it was quite enjoyable.

[@MrSteve0311]

Eat ze bugs

[@mikurowl4473]

The developers have made everything so simple in this game that I think that the number in 10+ age limit is not since what age you can play, but up to what.

[@deftsquirrel6738]

Weirdly I've been replaying Settlers 2 recently, an awesome game from my childhood. My son was asking about it and surprised how good the graphics were especially since it was made in the 90's.

[@dirtbikeryzz]

I mean its ubisoft this is expected. Not sure how they aren't bankrupt