The SHOCKING Merkur Skin Diver Mechanical - Perth WAtch

[@Antanix]

Don't be fooled by the Tongji movement - it is actually a better version with polished stripes and better construction. Based on an old Enicar design, so it is a pretty good movement if well assembled. Price should be a bit lower though.

[@PerthWAtch]

Yeah? How do you know? The company doesn’t tell me anything and they used a solid back. Regardless, it feels bad!

[@brucecoleman7412]

I just bought an Addiesdive that is somewhat similar to that one. It came on a bracelet and has the NH35 movement. I paid less than half. A complete no brainer!

[@PerthWAtch]

Yep, sounds like that one is much better than this

[@bw7112]

Which model is that? I am looking for this watch. It seems Merkur discontinued it.

[@markstanton63]

I have the same watch ..... No negative issues at all with it ... and the bezel crown and winding crown work perfectly

[@PerthWAtch]

Dammit they scammed me!!

[@alexsdg3441]

Hi Ivan. Good to see you but bad to see that watch, ha ha. You are right. The watch isn't much to talk about. However, I love the dial design (the indicies & minute hand design matches perfectly.) and the layout is very pleasing to the eyes.... I guess that is about it. (oh, yes. the dome crystal. that is also good looking). Thanks Ivan and hope to see you soon and hope that you can bring out something "super fantastic". Good day.

[@PerthWAtch]

Yeah, the stylised 12 and 6 are pretty cool too, I forgot to mention that.

[@RIOLOGY]

Incredible looking piece! Just wanted to comment a big thank you personally for being one of the OG watch channels that has inspired me to start my own channel! Appreciate your humbleness and straight approach to reviewing watches, big props man and best of luck, thanks for staying humble and true to yourself through all these years!

[@PerthWAtch]

Hey thanks for that man, much appreciated! And wishing you all the best with your channel also :)

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch BWAHAHAHAAAA WHAT A FAKE SUCK UP

[@brianmccord7387]

I don’t mind it aside from the fact that they misspelled manual - though perhaps they are trying to sell it to the Spanish market. I know people have complained in the past when San Martin have utilized screw down crowns with hand wind movements, because if you wind it all the way up, you won’t be able to screw it down.

[@willypayet2490]

Maybe this watch markings are for the French market ? Or to mimic some French watchmaking tradition. Next Merkur thing could be "phase de Lune" or "petite seconde " (moonphase or small second) ! Or even "répétition minute" in a pure "haute horlogerie" fashion! Who knows ?

[@markstanton63]

I think they used the French spelling

[@PerthWAtch]

Haha fair points that! Should've been automatic here for sure.

[@karyldavidkidd7111]

Watched the whole video, even though it is obviously not a gooder😂 piece. Solid as always.

[@PerthWAtch]

Haha thanks man, much appreciated

[@drebarthelotte5712]

Hopefully v2 will be Improved. Unfortunate to see.

[@PerthWAtch]

Have they announced that? It's perplexing given the other pieces I've reviewed were much better!

[@drebarthelotte5712]

@@PerthWAtch well I hope so. I assume they read reviews. Thank you for making a honest review.

[@bw7112]

@@drebarthelotte5712 They seem to place the crowns on the right side of the watch now. I am looking for this exact version but couldn't find even a similar watch with same crown placement and with the similar dial.

[@thehumblehorologist6091]

I don’t think I’d spend my money on it if I had other choices. However, if I had it, I wouldn’t mind wearing it. It’s not bad looking.

[@PerthWAtch]

Thanks for the thought - indeed, looks is where it stops with this one!

[@BarnOwl61]

Merkur usually makes nice quality watches. This is an unfortunate exception. Wouldn't want it for free. 😂

[@PerthWAtch]

Yep, I empathise fully!

[@steve8510]

THE DEMISE OF REVIEWS 😂😂😂

[@PerthWAtch]

THE DEMISE OF USEFUL COMMENTS 😂😂😂

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch THE DEMISE OF YOUR HAIR 🤭

[@PerthWAtch]

Wrong again Stevie! Next! 🤭

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch Hey do little kids stick their fingers in your ears at the bowling alley mistaking your head for a bowling ball? 🤣🤣

[@PerthWAtch]

Wow that’s random 🤭

[@philspencelayh5464]

I think if you have so little money to spend I'd be getting a Casio MRW200H then you won't get disappointed with the experience only an ultra cheap chinese mechanical can give.

[@PerthWAtch]

That's a good choice!

[@thegorn]

As ArchieLuxury would say... shiiitterrrrrr!

[@PerthWAtch]

Yeah that's right, immediately after he says "g'day you f@#kers"!

[@steve8510]

He knows zilch about horology and trolls if you disagree with him!!!

[@PerthWAtch]

Hello Stevie boy! Still trolling? 🤭

[@nl2935]

Hey there, I love your contents and reviews however I beg to differ on your assessment on this watch, u are really really uninformed, do let me share some knowledge on merkurs watches 1. Movement, yes it is a tongjie movement, but that dosent mean that it is not a good movement. The tongjie movement was created in the 1970s this movement was heavily inspired (or copied) from the Enicar Ar1010 movement. The tongjie movement may be cheaply available but it is by no means a bad movement. Well regulated tongjie has an accuracy +-10 seconds. Now merkur's particular tongjie movement is actually a refined tongjie with blues screws and Geneva wave finishing not to mention it is specially assembly by merkurs team. They did a couple of changes and refinement so that the stability and winding of the movement is smoother then original tongjie. 2. The case is 316l stainless steel with an all brushed finishing. Yes this is nothing to shout about but it is of high quality in watch standard. Notice the case has a Step design on the outer bezel area, this shows merkur uses it's own watch cases and not just slap on any generic case unlike other brands. The cases feels solid and is well CNC machined 3. The crystal as u said looks fantastic and it's thick and solid. 4. Mayb the inner bezel needs some refinement, but I give them points here for trying. 5. Strap. Well I don't judge straps as I have many stars my self. Overall I give this a solid 7 out of 10. Please do more research about tongjie movements and understand is importance in Chinese watch making. We should not judge things based on it's price solely. Also the reason why merkur has chosen to use a tongjie movement and took the effort to refined it, it is because to stay true to their Chinese heritage. I personally give extra credit to this. Open up the back cover look at the movement inside. Of course you can't compare it to an expensive well decorated Patek movement. But at least u should appreciate the effort that merkur has put in.

[@PerthWAtch]

Thanks for your comment - but I am really not sure why you are accusing me of being "really, really uninformed". I've reviewed several pieces with Tongji movements over the years. Yes, cheap does not automatically mean bad, but these are certainly among the worst movements I have come across in my time, if not the worst. I don't necessarily disagree with the 5 points you have made there, but you have not said anything that actually contradicts anything that I have said myself, have you? Perhaps you should watch all the videos I have made on watches with Tongji movements before making the wrong conclusion that I am "uninformed".

[@nl2935]

@@PerthWAtch this is a refined tongji. much testing has been done to ensure the stability of this movement. the other tongji that you have tested are those rough around the edges, badly assembled tongji. furthermore as i have stated tongji is heavily based on the Enicar movement. Enicar was a well respected watch producer back then. that's why I feel that you are uninformed. Since u are Chinese, i not sure if u are able to communicate in mandarin, you should talk to the founder of merkur to understand more. anyone can just buy an NH35 and used in their watches, But to research and take time to refine a so called "shitty" movement, well i have mad respect for that.

[@PerthWAtch]

I ask again - what did I say in the video which you disagree with? You're saying this is a "refined Tongji" movement... if that is true, then it is simply appalling that Merkur did not do anything to promote this at all on their listing. Which means it likely is not, and is simply an ebauche and cheap Tongji. You haven't felt this watch I have in hand - I can tell you it feels extremely badly made (as I said in the video). I am not going to open the watch, I do not have time for that, and I certainly do not find it useful to talk to company owners - you are likely going to get highly biased information. Much better to talk to third parties and independent consumers. It doesn't matter how much blued screws and decorating you put on a movement - if it does not perform and has poor specs, it is still going to be a poor movement. It also doesn't matter what movement it is based on. This point is simply not relevant. You could make a movement "based on" a Patek calibre, and do it very poorly.

[@nl2935]

@@PerthWAtch I guess you are just one of those guys that look down on mainland Chinese because u grew up in Australia or western country. Just too embarrassed to be associated with Chinese from China. What a shame.

[@nl2935]

@@PerthWAtch I guess you are one of those Chinese who grew up in Australia or western country who is too embarrassed to be associated with mainland China. You probably feel that things out of China are of low quality and only westerners are able to produce good products. What a shame that u totally forgot your ancestors heritage and culture. What a shame that you do not know how to appreciate the struggle that that our forefathers has faced. I feel so sorry for u.

[@garyk8285]

Not bad Ivan, looks good... probably don't trust the movement. Would it help me find a wife in Asia somewhere though? Would it increase my street cred?

[@PerthWAtch]

Thanks Gary. Sorry mate, it's no and no.

[@garyk8285]

@@PerthWAtch ;)

[@sparlinsahim]

When people are saying #mamacoo is a better option,I very much agree!

[@PerthWAtch]

People no say that

[@steve8510]

As if it had a rise

[@PerthWAtch]

Yeah it did 😎

[@steve8510]

Trolls people if they disagree with him.

[@PerthWAtch]

Oh hello Stevie! You are super prompt! 🤭

[@steve8510]

The clickbait king 🤣

[@PerthWAtch]

“Clickbait”? 🤭

[@steve8510]

Trolls anyone that disagrees with him when he posts clickbait.

[@PerthWAtch]

“Trolls”?🤭 “Clickbait”?🤭

[@steve8510]

Trolls everyone that disagrees with him.

[@PerthWAtch]

“Trolls”? 🤭

[@steve8510]

All this guy does is troll people that disagree with him.

[@PerthWAtch]

Oh hello Stevie - you are very prompt!

[@steve8510]

Substandard content and behavior.

[@PerthWAtch]

Great content. Substandard comment.

[@steve8510]

MINDLESS DRIVEL

[@PerthWAtch]

THIS COMMENT IS DRIVEL

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch Watch out! his hair is getting angry again 🤣🤣🤣

[@PerthWAtch]

Mindless drivel 🤭

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch Matches your bad hair 🤣🤣🤣

[@PerthWAtch]

Wrong

[@steve8510]

The troll reviewer 🤣

[@PerthWAtch]

“Troll”? 🤭

[@steve8510]

Unprofessional.

[@PerthWAtch]

It’s awesome

[@steve8510]

The clickbait specialist.

[@PerthWAtch]

“Clickbait”? 🤭

[@steve8510]

MORE LIKE THE DEMISE OF REVIEWS

[@PerthWAtch]

So wrong. What a garbage comment.

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch garbage in, garbage out... bwahahahaaa 🤣

[@PerthWAtch]

You said it ;)

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch It's an old skullcap right? 🤣

[@PerthWAtch]

Wrong - get your eyes checked. And?

[@shakespeare_hall4788]

Yeah Nah way to pricey fir what you get!....steel dive knicks it outa the Park at the sane price point

[@PerthWAtch]

Yeah Steeldive much better I think

[@steve8510]

Drivel.

[@PerthWAtch]

What

[@steve8510]

Another garbage review from the guy that trolls you if you disagree with him.

[@PerthWAtch]

Hello Steve the troll!

[@steve8510]

Superficial clickbait review.

[@PerthWAtch]

“Clickbait”? 🤔🤭

[@steve8510]

Very ordinary content.

[@PerthWAtch]

It’s extraordinary

[@steve8510]

Uninformative.

[@PerthWAtch]

It's awesome

[@steve8510]

Really awful content.

[@PerthWAtch]

It’s awesome

[@steve8510]

Terrible content.

[@PerthWAtch]

What

[@steve8510]

Garbage clickbait.

[@PerthWAtch]

Garbage commentator.

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch Says the expert on garbage.

[@PerthWAtch]

Garbage comment.

[@steve8510]

@@PerthWAtch Ha Ha that hairline, it's hilarious 😅🤣

[@PerthWAtch]

Another garbage comment.

[@steve8510]

Unprofessional.

[@PerthWAtch]

It’s awesome