The Story of PERHAPS | Guns N' Roses 2023 New Song

[@janskala22]

Yes please, make a video about the 2019 leak

[@CommodoreVic20]

Please make that locker leak video 😊

[@stu1844]

Glad I recorded some of the village sessions when they were up a couple weeks ago

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

Been listening to Atlas Shrugged a lot lately 🤘🏽 kinda amped to hear that one with slash soon hopefully

[@stu1844]

@@WestCoastStruttin99 Oklahoma is good also. So is THYME

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

Yes for sure. Dummy is crazy too!! Can only imagine what Axl could’ve added to that one. Quick Song was great too

[@jamesriver3745]

Can't go wrong w Tonto and Zodiac either. Many of the leaks sound complete, as in fully developed songs minus the vocals. You can hear the changes into what would be the choruses and bridges, although I think Zodiac is intended to be an instrumental simply because if you look at the tracklists on these demos, it is the only song that specifically says NO VOX. Songs like Oklahoma, Dummy, D Tune, Tonto, etc all have no vocals....yet it never says so - unlike with Zodiac... Just speculation!

[@patrickhill3260]

Thought the leaks were better for all three releases so far. Although I think this is the closest one so far that Slash & Duff don’t sound totally outta place. Still, the leaks with the members who actually were apart of creating them just have a way better chemistry for the songs, as they would of course. Video on the locker leak 👍🏻👍🏻

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

We think alike 🤘🏽

[@charleykiser305]

I like this version of perhaps better

[@patrickhill3260]

Well it is certainly the closest one so far that Slash & Duff don’t sound out of place.

[@charleykiser305]

The like the demo of prehips but I prefer this version

[@charlief.]

Please release a video about the locker room leak.

[@jamesriver3745]

do a locker leak video for sure

[@SNAKE-zw5xk]

I like the village session versions more Scared for the general If robin fink had anything to do with that song then fuck Slash finna do something And duff is duff

[@marinadiamondz]

I don't understand the people that says they liked more the demo, at least to me, the demo of perhaps sounded like a not finished song (what a demo is supposed to sound), it lacked a lot of presence and it just needed that little something to be great, and the 2023 version has that. I don't share your opinion but I liked the video, keep going

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

I appreciate your input! The official version has grown on me since release

[@marinadiamondz]

​​@@WestCoastStruttin99that's nice! Perhaps is not the best gnr song but it deserves appreciation as well

[@charleykiser305]

I don't like the demo of perhaps

[@RickDunsford]

Yeah make the leak video

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

Cameo?

[@RickDunsford]

@@WestCoastStruttin99 sure

[@rocknhorror]

the general is leaked somewhere but forgot the link to it, does anyone know

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

There’s 2 versions. A terrible quality cell phone recording that you can BARELY hear. And then a Fan-Made version of it. There’s really no ‘official leak’ as no one really know what the song actually sounds like yet.

[@rocknhorror]

ok man thanks for the speedy reply, cheers@@WestCoastStruttin99

[@walterevans2118]

Is it just AXL who writes the lyrics ?

[@walterevans2118]

So the TITLES have changed across the time lapse ...Have the Lyrics been changed ?

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

Yes, Axl writes the lyrics. And most of the lyrics have stayed the exact same. Hard school, absurd and Perhaps all have vocals from 1999. They’re just edited in the studio to sound a little different

[@walterevans2118]

@@WestCoastStruttin99 The video mentioned that there was a DEMO of the new track PERHAPS which was originally released in the year 2000...Is this original version out on You Tube to make comparisons between them ? ......That was the case with VAN HALEN...For instance their 2012 single 'Tattoo' was played live in bootlegs before they were signed to Warners under the title 'Down in Flames'...And 2012s 'Blood and Fire' was demoed by EVH in 1984 titled 'Ripley' and so forth....

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

Yup. Hard school, absurd, perhaps, and others like State of Grace and Atlas Shrugged leaked in 2019. They were mixes from early 2000. I'm sure you can find the old Perhaps on YT, it was up a few days ago.

[@walterevans2118]

@@WestCoastStruttin99 thanks

[@sunnyd6019]

LOL so its a old song and on top not good, gee go figure.

[@keepdreamin]

This isn't the true story of Perhaps. The true story of Perhaps is Mr. Robin Finck. Robin wrote Perhaps. Robin creates an EPIC GUITAR SOLO for THE AGES on Perhaps. And Robin creates an EPIC GUITAR OUTRO for THE AGES on Perhaps. Perhaps is a Robin Finck Original. Perhaps is a Robin Finck song. This is the REAL story of Perhaps.

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

I see your point, but I’m sure Axl wrote the piano lick, which dominates the song, along with his vocal melodies. This is an Axl song, imo.

[@keepdreamin]

@@WestCoastStruttin99 Robin wrote the Perhaps lyrics. Robin wrote and created his EPIC GUITAR SOLO on Perhaps. Robin wrote and created his EPIC GUITAR OUTRO on Perhaps. Robin wrote and created the EPIC BACKGROUND guitars on Perhaps. Perhaps is not an AXL song. Perhaps is a Robin Finck song.

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

Get me a source on that

[@keepdreamin]

@@WestCoastStruttin99 You need a source to tell you Robin does the guitar solo, background guitars, and guitar outro on Perhaps?

[@keepdreamin]

@@WestCoastStruttin99 If you really need a source the source is Mr. Robin Finck. Robin says Robin writes every song he is the lead guitar player on.

[@jsebastian9547]

...yeah... song is ok... but nothing special.

[@enceladuis]

I liked it 🤷🏻‍♀️

Go cry to mommy

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

Having opinions is crying now huh

[@talknewz7617]

The song isn't good at all, a fail

[@WestCoastStruttin99]

I can say I prefer the leaked 2000 demo. Much less over produced; but poorer quality

[@maxymajzr]

dE sOnG iSnT GuD at aLl a FAiL - eloquent random dude from internet, cca. 2023.

[@marinadiamondz]

Lol the song is so good clean your ears