The Story Of Simon_12: Herobrine's Secret Brother

[@RenderingFrames]

Part 2 is out! kzbin.info/www/bejne/aqqsaYhvfr2Wic0

[@The_Jumping_French_Man]

Actually worth watching. We'll done

[@Nockgun]

6 months damn, cool vid

[@defiant2]

angelo is literally the best friend everyone needs

[@Lucas-h5c3v]

the thing on the sign is morse code

[@ReesesButtercupOnAStick]

THERES A PART 2??????

[@Dawson5773]

3:28 Something I want to add to this thought is the fact the zombified pigman was immediately hostile to the player, and zombified pigmen are neutral meaning they don't attack unless provoked. Not only did whatever entity spawn the pigman, but it somehow made it so the neutral mob would attack Simon on sight, something only hostile mobs do.

[@Heydec]

Thats truee

[@thingwithwings96]

One thing is- Im not sure how long this easter egg has been in the game but there IS a way for zombie pigmen to spawn in the overworld. A pig getting hit by lightning will become a pigman! It still shouldnt be hostile tho lol

[@Dawson5773]

@@thingwithwings96 A reply I made on another comment that I copy and pasted "Yeah, but lightning doesn't spawn when the weather is clear. While it is true a pig can be a zombie pigman from lightning, it is impossible to happen in this scenario. The weather has to be thunderstorm for that to happen, and one common sign of a thunderstorm is rain, but the weather was clear for a whole 3 minutes, from the start of the video to the sighting of the zombie pigman, but there was a cut in the video where a thunderstorm could've happened... EXCEPT that if a thunderstorm had happened, then other hostile mobs would have spawned and been on the surface like creepers, witches and enderman, though this does exclude zombies and skeletons since they burn in the day. We don't see any other hostile mob in the video until it hit night. If it was a thunderstorm, we should've at least seen a creeper, but all we get is the zombie pigman. So while you are correct a pig could've been struck by lightning, that is theoretically impossible to happen naturally, leaving only someone using /summon lightning_bolt on a pig, using a channeling trident on a pig or spawning the zombie pigman."

[@willow7715]

​​@@Dawson5773perhaps when the lightning struck the trees? edit: I'm stupid and didn't finish reading the reply

[@gabehembling1088]

there is a gamerule that makes all neutral mods hostile but i dont know if that existed in the time this series is set

[@HallowWoken]

Simon is a KING for brushing everything off and he was so loyal to his channel because he just wanted to beat the dragon no matter what happened

[@EraNewEpic]

He's even store his cursed world just to get his friends back he's definitely a main character!

[@sushamamohapatra2485]

5:01 ayo da pizza here (OOO)

[@gooberwoober-s7r]

man was adapting to it😭

[@M3D1C4LMELODY]

restoring your cursed haunted world to save your friend and throw hands with a entity thats been taunting/haunting you is amazing id like to have a friend like that

[@The_Real_Priest]

All of us could use a Simon in our lives. Someone who is willing to travel through hell if it means helping a friend in need.

[@aaronpd]

Copying a comment for likes is crazy 💀

[@M3D1C4LMELODY]

@@aaronpdno idea that this would be a lot😭

[@aaronpd]

@@M3D1C4LMELODY what

[@Glaiza-t1x]

I'm confused they know each other in real life why would Simon save his friend?

[@GeorgiaLosper-cr6wj]

I don't care if your stories are just fiction. I'm hooked. The fact that Simon caught on so fast to the entity is so bad ass

[@DARKANDGRIDDY1984]

i thought this was an arg?

[@muhammadafiq2493]

This herobrine alternate kinda seems like null man

[@anomalymart]

Simon restoring his cursed world to get his friend back and throw hands with the entity is badass💀

[@sevdijeshehu]

Bro be speaking facts

[@Igorson142]

lol

[@CameraSucksAtMostThings]

Fr that’s crazy

[@IllIlIIlIlIIIIIIIIIIIIII]

The fact this has *233* Likes and Angelo's fake username was xxangeloxx *233* what are the chances?

[@PeaNUTFERRET]

@@IllIlIIlIlIIIIIIIIIIIIII now it has 322 likes

[@Aegean619]

Simon is a chad for both trying to defeat the Ender Dragon and restoring his world to save his friend.

[@EraNewEpic]

He's definitely is a main character

[@Dragon_Lightaltacc]

W simon

[@Aegean619]

@@Dragon_Lightaltacc W comment

[@terri-leighwright1807]

No he is a gigachad

[@Amussing_smile]

better than dogs

[@bruh1737]

Simon restoring his world to throw hands and save his bro, truly a minecraft experience

[@DroppedBySpidey]

On god like W manz for that bro

[@Dragons_blood348]

W simon

[@cat_fighter_lol]

love your self lys

[@MatkoOfficial]

hes friend is stucked in game lol

[@anikshahini6964]

Bruh

[@ThisIsntWonderland..]

Angelo: “SIMON.. YOU NEED TO GET OUT OF THIS WORLD. THE ENTITY WILL GET YOU TOO!!” Simon: “nah…i’d win.”

[@trivialthe]

The scariest part is that 2017 was seven years ago, meaning the POV of this being a kid that's grown up makes a lot more sense than I'd first think.

[@chandlerbing7570]

The videos are not from 2017

[@flickour]

yeah look at the icon

[@jakubjesvorc]

22:57 Screenshot say 2024 as a year

[@tpoad0079]

@@jakubjesvorc BROO YOU ARE A GOAT FOR CATCHING THAT

[@vickylol5053]

IT IS FAKE

[@DaizyBlossom]

I haven’t gotten chills from Minecraft since 2015 but hearing those blocks break sent shivers down my spine

[@Feller19]

I got chills from the "He heads home" part, and the slow replays and zooms

[@TheMurderousBakedPotato]

I renember a while ago, I think the evil thing is Null, its like a urban legend thing

[@INFINTYX128]

You should watch the story on Andrew gaming genuinely horrifying

[@MonieThu]

C H I L L S

[@3t1Me]

​@@TheMurderousBakedPotatonull has red eyes I think.

[@Ugh-thu]

I want to point out that the birthday present was diamonds and the glitch that summoned the entity was supposed to be a diamond glitch. Simon was happy for the diamonds. The entity lured Simon to summon him. He learned it as the structure was built at the exact end portal. The entity learned what made Simon happy. (Edit: Damn this is my most liked comment)

[@lafanderockleelilit1014]

BRO i noticed it too but then forgot cuz the ending hit so hard

[@Ugh-thu]

So the entity is just like the mimic. It sees what you like than uses it

[@simonrey4706]

hiiii everybody

[@Addyfox2012]

Also. Isn't it odd that the present got placed... On stairs? Or is that something that just was patched/gotten rid of..?

[@jasujangid4108]

@@Addyfox2012 u can place blocks on stairs bro

[@godyeeter3606]

26:12 I want to point out three odd things in this clip 1. Angelo just joins the world in the end, on the exact pillar that Simon was on. How did Angelo get there? Why was he there? And why was he on the EXACT pillar Simon ran to? 2. When the dragon disappeared, the dragon's health bar didn't go away. I think this could mean that the dragon was moved, rather than being killed 3. When Simon was falling and disconnected, time seemed to freeze, like when you pause a single player game, the game freezes for you. It's hard to tell tho, I'm judging this based on the pillar and stuff. If that was Angelo, and the world was a multiplayer server, time wouldn't have froze when Simon paused the game.

[@LusLand]

it's just minecraft, but watching this late at night freaks me out...

[@Ight-ight]

Nah playing minecraft beta at 3 am is a nightmare do NOT do that shit

[@panagiotis12yt]

Fr

[@JustCrowXD]

Bro im in bed watching dis rn(its2 an for me) and a shadow outside my window is moving…it is just a tree but looks like an arm

[@LusLand]

@@JustCrowXD yeah, I'm glad I didn't watch it THAT early

[@thiagoodilonferreiradasilv3530]

Brooo fr this is just like watching spooky images compilation

[@agmass]

I usually watch these as background content while i do something else because its easier to digest and is pretty fun so i did NOT expect the ending to go THAT hard. celeste music was a w choice too

[@Mayayapayapa]

Me too, i was washing the dishes making faces as the story unfolded

[@galacticprops]

what makes this scary to me is how the alternate herobrine just stalks Simon pretty much in every video, just observing, gathering information to use against him. like how he impersonates Angelo and acts completely different to the "real" angelo we saw earlier. like you said I'm pretty sure the ending is Simon realising the angelo in his game isn't his friend, so he restores his world to try and get his actual friend back which is hopefully where we get a part 2

[@Pheonix_boys]

Dude it's been 7 years (6 if you count the last video being in New years), either Simon also got caught by alterbrine(my name for the entity) or he gave up trying to save Angelo

[@Pheonix_boys]

OR option 3, he saved Angelo, and gtfo'd of the world and put it all behind him

[@mjaypierce9549]

i think the end is going to be the player remembers angelos real name and says something about it the fake anglo acts like he is crazy simon_12 bans the fake anglo revealing the real anglo chat they kill the alt herobrine but then anglo and simon teleport to an newer update or teleports to bedrock editon

[@mjaypierce9549]

@@Pheonix_boys no

[@Pheonix_boys]

@@mjaypierce9549 no? What no?

[@saifarjunahamizan8029]

The fact that this video is post after the videos in the simon channel is like him reviewing himself and making up stories. This guy is the best horror story teller.

[@Azerwite]

random guy : if i see herobrine i'll call my friend kevin herobrine : if this random guy calls his friend kevin i'll call my brother

[@Sball_gluttonius_the_third]

Kevin if i find herobrine brother i Will call Alexander

[@nottotellymt]

Herobrine's Brother: if Kevin calls Alexander I will call Entity_303

[@LuckDragonCat]

Alexander: if herobrines brother calls entity 303 I’ll call notch

[@holden1259]

@@LuckDragonCat Entity 303: if they call notch I'll call saul

[@ThatOneSoldier-s1j]

Notch: if they call Saul ill call herobrine

[@Stellarisium]

that lore was better than 90% of games Edit: YOO THX FOR 4 LIKES THATS ALOOT!!!

[@ledadayton3517]

Except FNAF

[@Fiszy]

i dont think fnaf is 10% of all games

[@_Gam3r]

100%* idc about fnaf its literally arf arf ar arf pizza place run by murder guy

[@ledadayton3517]

@@_Gam3r do you know nothing about FNAF?

[@MITSUHA-N-1]

@@ledadayton3517 i mean he got the first ones tho

[@amethyphoenix]

0:45 "They could be playing on 1.12" Minecraft Window: *says 1.12.2* I think you answered your own question there, sparky.

[@ErrorR-R]

almost same thing

[@amethyphoenix]

@@ErrorR-R 1.12.2 is basically 1.12 with bug fixes and other things, so... it's still 1.12

[@ishu4227]

0:47 You don't need to know the date to know the version he's playing on. IT'S RIGHT THERE OH MY GOSH...

[@cloudsaysthings]

My current theory is that Angelo made the summoning shrine in order to give Simon that diamond block on his birthday. I say this because Simon mentions that shrine being a means to get "free diamonds." Maybe Angelo found the stronghold, built the shrine underneath, covered it with the spruce block so he'd know where to find it, and got the diamonds somehow from it while also bringing an entity into the world. He told Simon how to get to the stronghold and once there, gifted him the diamond block for his birthday. Perhaps after, he told Simon about the shrine, and SImon wished to get more "free diamonds" and built it himself.

[@FNCS_Cam3r0n]

and thats why Angelo didnt get the achievement when they arrived in the stronghold, because he had already been there before to set up the shrine

[@arasaras7738]

​@@FNCS_Cam3r0n but then why did he say we instead of he

[@XrayPlays007]

@@arasaras7738 because angelo told him about it and they both found the same video

[@hats8104]

My theory on both what the shrine does and why the entity came to life: when simon and angelo came to the stronghold only simon got the achievement meaning the pov we saw without bandicam was angelo building the shrine for he thought it was only for free diamonds but it was a wishing shrine that costs your worlds data and the shrine was for the entity. So after the shrine was built the entity came for its payment. Angelo or so we thought was angelo isnt him the only time angelo played minecraft was when simon needed a wallpaper for his pc, meaning that the angelo we were playing with was the entity himself

[@Kohai4323]

11s serously​@@hats8104

[@Thatonerandombelkan]

Angelo: "Simon, would you loose against the entity?" Simon: *"Nah, I'd beat the dragon."*

[@Khalid-dg4ty]

😂😂😂

[@Ibbylite-wh1lo]

If he put up his domain: eternal fear I might have a bit of trouble. But would you lose? Nah, I’d win, cuz throughout the nether and the ends, I alone am the one who throws hands ⛏️🫸🫷🗡️🤌👊

[@unfreakedjamin]

Lose*

[@Khalid-dg4ty]

@@Ibbylite-wh1lo domain expansion 🙏⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛⬜⬛⬜⬜⬛⬜⬛⬛⬛⬜⬜⬜⬛⬛⬛⬜⬜⬜⬜⬛⬛⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛⬛⬜⬜⬛⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛⬛🟥⬛🟦⬛⬛⬛🟥⬛⬛🟥⬛🟦⬛⬜⬛⬜🟨⬛🟩⬛🟧🟥⬛🟩⬛🟨⬛🟧⬛🟩⬛🟧⬛⬜⬛⬛🟥⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛🟨🟨🟥🟥⬛⬛⬛⬜⬛⬛⬜ ⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜ SIMON'S SAYS GAME 🙏

[@NotKeonAnimations]

You F@cked Up The Loose Spelling It's Lose

[@LilXTREME76]

If Simon comes back I would recommend that he downloads a gun mod

[@raxhel787]

damn.

[@NixNihel]

gawdamn

[@A.NY.A-fr]

Damn-

[@Kippiistike]

DAYUM

[@SpiritWolfGamer]

Jeez that’s one step forward and zero steps back

[@The_Mirror994]

The Simon Says signs actually gave me the creeps, everything about it

[@CasualCatOfficial]

Props to this guy for finding tiny, TINY, KZbinrs and finding tiny details from them, it makes it all the more believable (GUYS I GET IT, ITS AN ARG, I DIDNT KNOW AT THE TIME RESPECTFULLY, PLEASE CHILL)

[@ridwanulhoque4264]

I dont know if it is supposed to be sarcasm or ctually an honest comment. Those are actually a bit tiny so my doubt you are just saying sarcasm

[@dikshant-fingerstyletutorials]

@@ridwanulhoque4264 its sarcasm

[@KaleZZ23]

Why do people honestly beleive that this is real? It's obvious that this video was all set up by Render and he just used different accounts and went back to an older version of minecraft to completely fake the entire video. And it's almost like he knows how to solve the mystery, because he set it all up. It's all fake

[@CasualCatOfficial]

@@KaleZZ23 ah, well, the videos are still fun to watch in my eyes, but if you think thats the case (which is really reasonable) then im fine with it!

[@CasualCatOfficial]

@@ridwanulhoque4264 it wasnt sarcasm

[@i.noonespinzps0218]

"Herorbrine's Brother can't hurt you" Herobrine's brother who can access multiple dimensions including real life:

[@TheBlandestGuy]

dont worry, if he jumps you just gimme a call, Ill handle it

[@jacobhoward4349]

thank u Luigi

[@XamzaMahamoud]

​@@TheBlandestGuythank you😊

[@anteaterborzoiTheBigBorzoi]

Fuck that, man... Come into my world without paying bills or helping around the house...

[@MrMan12489]

@@TheBlandestGuythanks Luigi

[@Localcatgirl_]

Dude had the perfect reaction to hearing the blocks breaking, instantly running, leaving blocks behind him, putting lava down, and blocking off the mine Dude has legendary reflexes fr

[@blusshbug]

did anyone notice how angelo was also flying when the pillar broke? i think the entity is posing as him.

[@Fractvred]

The motive that Simon doesn’t want to abandon his world because he wants to kill the dragon is a pretty awesome reason to stay in a world with herobrine 0.5

[@reobrauer6445]

Nah its 2.0

[@leonardocouto3109]

I think it was a smart choice: this "entity" from Simon's point of view doesn't affect the real world nor any files besides the "beating the ender dragon" world, so getting spooked on your way to beat the ender dragon? Sure, fine, I can put up with it. It's a good subversion of the old trope of horror main characters getting into the mess anyway despite the spooks: in those instances, they usually have weak or no reasons to get themselves into terrifying territory and possibly even risk their lives. Here, getting spooked is no biggie in comparison to the achievement of beating the dragon and Simon has no reason to believe the "entity" can kill or hurt him, so why not put up with it and beat the dragon anyway? It'd make for a way past cool story to tell the whole 5th grade, too!

[@ahmadhuzaini-mb9hu]

herobrine 0.5?

[@JayceRay]

Other horrer monecraft protagonist: scared, and frighted Simon: throws hands with the entity to get his friend back

[@JarredBryan]

Horror* frightened*

[@ItsPedro9898]

I play monecraft everyday!

[@JayceRay]

@@ItsPedro9898 it's minecraft

[@ItsPedro9898]

@@JayceRay moneycraft

[@JayceRay]

@@ItsPedro9898 Minecraft

[@CobraGaming_Official]

The fact that no one LITTERALLY no one realized that simon's minecraft world was named " Beating the Dragon" and was never shown as "Beating the 'ENDER DRAGON' " as we saw in the recycle bin!. Edit 1 = Im Famous!!! thanks for 750 likes btw!!

[@JankyTableAtlas-st5gu]

I WAS FR SCREAMING AT BRO FOR THAT😭😭😭😭 bro used the date to see what version mc is when the mc window literally says it's 1.12.2

[@simonsikder4190]

well i mean sure?

[@sixtysource]

i noticed that immediately, either an oversight by the arg creator or its actually part of the story

[@Llominous3495]

​@@sixtysourceMost **GOOD** ARGs have insane attention to detail, NOTHIN is done without a reason, and since (hopefully) this is a pretty good ARG, I suppose that detail matters in some way

[@VKSelvaraju]

Noice

[@DigitalDigitron]

THAT ENDING WAS CRAZY OMG WOWZA

[@Enigmatic.cs_]

I think that angelo and simon's families (or family) were celebrating new years. Angello says "oh you got out too?", meaning that both of them were able to leave their families party, saying that their family was "noisy" or annoying

[@P.H09]

good point tbh

[@ericandmarijavolkman7559]

remember how the entity said "my base is my bedroom" ? the entity probably watches him in real life and it knows he's recording. So it decides to expose him of what the base is based off of.

[@i.am.Goldenmaster4409]

So like a stalker trying to mess around with his victim? Not a bad theory

[@fregsy]

still, it was singleplayer world. but if angelo were his schoolmate, why simon need to find his friend back from his world? did he gets kidnapped irl?

[@i.am.Goldenmaster4409]

@@fregsy yeah that's a good question and in the bottom of a pit video (where the entity said "my base is my bedroom") the time angelo says "I think I see your name" angelo's name is spelt wrong

[@PhaeronXII]

@@i.am.Goldenmaster4409 that's what i was thinking, the conclusions that are come to in this video seem cool, but they don't track. angelo gave him the lamp irl... or was it actually angelo. the angelo at the end--who seems much more like the real angelo than the "angelo" we saw "trapped" in the single player world--has no recollection of giving simon the lamp. and it was a singleplayer world, so even if there's an entity in it, there cannot be another player. so if angelo is "in the world, trapped somewhere"... that's not angelo. and the taunt about the base being the bedroom; the only conclusion i can come to is, the entity isn't just in the singleplayer world anymore, it's in real life. and i don't think it was simon that restored the worldfile.

[@i.am.Goldenmaster4409]

@@PhaeronXII nice theory actually

[@TheNPCwhoasked]

Entity:would you leave? Simon:Nah I'd stay

[@leonardonetto7490]

"Nah, I'd test this entity's patience and keep being haunted"

[@gigaswardblade7261]

I just don’t get it. Why would you want to stay?

[@TheAxolotlOfSuprises]

@@gigaswardblade7261 nah he would win

[@gigaswardblade7261]

@@TheAxolotlOfSuprises but he’s waiting every night to finally invite newcomers to play with him.

[@TheAxolotlOfSuprises]

@@gigaswardblade7261 dont worry HE ALWAYS COMES BACK

[@Rusted4k]

5:04 dawg dont worry drake was just having himself a lil visit

[@ImDru]

i need more angelo lore

[@tornadoplayzz-fl5bk]

Please do not comment about him Because… Nevermind

[@1234combo]

@@tornadoplayzz-fl5bkwhy shouldn’t he comment

[@1234combo]

@@tornadoplayzz-fl5bkwhy?

[@RotroGuy]

angelore

[@FluffyMapleMan]

LOOOOOOOOOOOOORE

[@Serial_Designation_N_The_Drone]

You know, there's more than just one character with white eyes, Null. Herobrine and Null are similar in one way, they both have white eyes, and when looking back at the footage, it's either that Null is actually watching Simon, waiting for Herobrine to eventually strike, or it's actually Herobrine disguised as Null. edit: my friends, this was just a theory, a *GAME* theory.

[@ThePolice233]

Nul isn in the game in the version i think

[@Alexzy39]

Serial designation N the drone!!!?1?1?1?

[@Rasmushojlund10194]

I heard from years ago they said herobrine's good and he's protecting you from Null, Entity 303, farman,etc etc

[@Serial_Designation_N_The_Drone]

@@Rasmushojlund10194 eh, Who's farman?

[@deepasakthitcl7630]

@@Serial_Designation_N_The_DroneI think he meant farlands

[@sigmahandsomerizzler]

What a miner bro, even thought something is haunting him he is still pushing through just to beat the dragon Edit:Y'all satisfied?

[@YOAlphaStarz]

Fr fr

[@pvzzombiegamer6694]

Bro was on that minecraft grind

[@Fern_17Q]

Real

[@OrangeSquare77]

Lil bro did NOT give a fuck 😭😭

[@racisimisabignono]

Gigachad ohio sigma gyat rizzler grimace skidibi toilet gyat

[@Anime_God87]

Definitely subscribe worthy bro I love watching these

[@tokyokitcat]

I think when he says he doesn't want to look under his bed anymore, he means irl because herobrine scared him, and kids think theres monsters under their beds

[@blobf1sh0]

FR

[@blobf1sh0]

But we don't know how old they are?

[@tokyokitcat]

​@@blobf1sh0they're in school remember, they talk about detention

[@blobf1sh0]

Oh yeah didn't think about that

[@Madux-k8r]

FR

[@rishan_khadakiwale]

this should be a minecraft movie. your detective skills are awsome

[@MUSA_SMSW_OFFICAL]

My balls hurt

[@Cheezy88]

Bro predicted

[@Sayll]

I have never had actual chills watching "spooky" videos like these before but this actually gave me chills multiple times

[@MinecraftIsFun72]

same i got them when he in the piller room

[@murielafzalsalam7699]

​@@MinecraftIsFun72 that part actually got me scared, i would just quit minecraft at that point or before that. But unlike me and some people that can relate, simon is a brave warrior

[@Natu_-ep4mu]

@@murielafzalsalam7699lmao

[@zurieljohnson9287]

Yo I feel like you never seen a raygloom video.

[@Bubba58102]

is it just me or at 18:59 can you guys also see someones username in the darkness for a split second, then after that happens, angelo says i think i see your name

[@davisise51]

its you.

[@nicokilpelainen8250]

i saw it too

[@EdinCrow]

1. I like to think that Simon started to restore the original world "Beating the Dragon" because Angelo didn't remember the lamp. The lamp must have been something that Simon kept close to him especially since he kept it next to his bed. But one thing that I noticed is that the original world was called "Beating the Dragon", but the world that Simon is restoring is called "Beating the Ender Dragon". It's a completely different world. Could it possibly be that "Beating the Ender Dragon" was the first world that Simon and Angelo played together on which could be the server in the wallpaper. 2. When Angelo says "where am i?" and "dark" it's still not the same gamertag as in the wallpaper. Meaning that the entity was either A. still pretending to be Angelo to give Simon some hope in a friend being there B. pretending to be Angelo so Simon could blame everything going on in the world on Angelo (Angelo getting into a single player world still makes no sense) or C. mimicking what Angelo could possibly be saying. Which 3. Continuing on from point C. in the paragraph above it could make sense. The server was in the recycling bin pretty much wiping the world to pitch black. If Angelo was still in there then he would only see black and not fully understand where he currently is as he wouldn't know that Simon trashed that server. Which is why he could possibly be typing out to Simon saying "where am i?" and "dark" but he is getting no response. 4. The unlisted playlist wasn't created by Simon_12 it was created by another youtube account called poodleswift which could possibly be Angelos youtube account. I am only led to believe this based on the fact that the playlist was already premade when it was delivered in Simons fishing.mp4 video. And in the last video on the unlisted playlist "0-00" Angelo said "yo i saw the videos you sent" and "sorry i didn't believe you". making me belive that Angelo was the one that created the playlist in the first place. 5. Continuing on from point 4 I don't believe that Simon was ever the one who talked about it in the first place. I don't believe that Simon was the one behind the reddit account or any of the secret messages to get to the unlisted playlist because Simon would needed to be sent the unlisted playlist link for it to be put on the reddit profile and in the fishing.mp4 video. I believe that the entity has been behind all of it. Slowly spreading itself through Simons computer just like how Herobrine was known to join all of the worlds on your device once you spawned him in one of your minecraft worlds. Herobrine and this current entity are alike but different in many different ways. This entity has been able to fully pretend, mimic, and recreate who Angelo was as a person. Who isn't to say that the entity is slowly making himself more known and pretending to be Simon now. I mean he was able to mimic Angelo, who says he isn't pretending to be Simon online? 6. I believe that the entity got into Angelo's computer first. It would explain why Angelo was the fake person. If Angelo did the spawning of the entity first then it would have targeted him first. The entity would then have noticed Angelo's closeness with Simon. By this time the Entity is already starting to dig through Angelo's computer like a root virus and sends a video to Simon to (being the diamond duplication glitch) get Simon to build his summoning ritual. Which would then let the Entity fully have access to Simon now. 7. During the video "2017-9-16-4-12-57" during the first second of the video both Simon and Angelo are discussing if Angelo is still in detention. So is Angelo an irl friend or an online friend for Simon? My theory Recap: Angelo was the first one to spawn the entity which slowly started to take over his computer. Eventually Angelo and Simon no longer want to play on the server called "Beating the Ender Dragon" and so Simon throws the server into his recycling bin. But, the entity was not happy with that so when Simon creates another world (single player) called "Beating the Dragon" he uses that as his chance to get onto Simons computer by sending him a fake diamond duplication glitch which actually spawned the entity into Simons world. Everything continues to play out and crazy things start to happen which causes Simon to trash the "Beating the Dragon" server. He and the fake Angelo continue to make another world to play together again but Simon knows something is wrong when Angelo doesn't remember the lamp that he had gifted Simon. Which then causes Simon to look back at the last world and truly rethink that his friend was actually his friend. He then starts to recover his first server ever made with Angelo (Beating the Ender Dragon) to try and get his actual friend back. But who truly knows? We can only wait to see if we will get another installment in this Minecraft ARG. 😁

[@aminishnamedvaati]

the idea that the entity can enter computers and replicate people reminds me of BEN from the ben drowned arg/creepypasta. BEN entered jadusables computer and then pretended to be his roommate in order to trick people online into letting it into their computers. not anything that adds to the theory, just a fun little thing i noticed in this comment.

[@EdinCrow]

@@aminishnamedvaati omg you just sparked so many memories for me 😂 but you are totally correct it does remind me of BEN

[@Muffln]

I hope we get another installment. The creator of the ARG 100% left room for more with Simon restoring "Beating the Ender Dragon" to save the real Angelo.

[@FlamingZ0n3]

Reddit lamp story

[@demongirl1019]

The real question is, if the Theorist Team picks up on this, would this fall under Game Theory or Film Theory? I wanted to say “Mat Pat” instead of “Theorist Team” but he’s retired 🥲 but who knows? Maybe Mat Pat will react to this on GT Live?

[@JSTUDIOSR]

if simon ever continues, he should invite this guy called "kevin". hes really cool trust me.

[@depressedroxas7944]

I’ve seen the name “Kevin” before in this comment section, though I am not familiar with it, is it from another horror Minecraft story?

[@N0tsoIidsnake]

​@@depressedroxas7944 its a meme where a dude in the comments section of a Herobrine video says "if i ever saw Herobrine i would call my friend Kevin"

[@depressedroxas7944]

@@N0tsoIidsnake Oh, I see, thanks for enlightening me about almighty kevin

[@litterbox019]

@@depressedroxas7944 indoctrination speedrun

[@GPmakesContent]

Kevin‼️‼️‼️

[@emre_ez]

The production quality was over the top and this whole thing was structured more cinematically than an arg explanation like how he waited til the end. i personally am not a detail seeker so i didnt notice angelo was diffrent or that there was something under the bed. the video was insane and i loved it keep it up.

[@GF-Nerd-t1v]

4:18 bro fell into the underground from undertale, is this how frisk got there???💀💀💀

[@starryskyesal]

every single time there's a good minecraft arg, you'd bet im boutta be hooked like a fish

[@starryskyesal]

or just good args in general

[@fortnitesexman]

this is garbage tho 💀

[@grizzlycharizard0017]

​@@fortnitesexman no its not

[@LebronJamalJames-nr4fh]

@@fortnitesexman how is this garbage

[@fortnitesexman]

@@grizzlycharizard0017 it's a textbook example of a standard garbo minecraft arg, it doesn't really do anything all too special and is way too on the nose

[@DUDEBRUHMICE]

24:26 that is actually terrifying, mainly because there’s no logical explanation to this, the dragon didn’t die, because the portal is still closed, the dragon could’ve been teleported away, but if that’s the case, why is the dragon’s health bar still there, then the island slowly destroys itself, the only thing that’s left is Simon and all the pillars, a moment of relaxation, but this moment is short lived, as we see all the other pillars disappears, fear and anticipation fill not only Simon but also the viewer, all the pillars slowly disappear, but nothing happens to Simon, then, “Angelo” appears, but why does he spawn in the end? Simon, rightfully terrified tries to talk to “Angelo” but gets no reply, Simon’s confused but then, the ground beneath him disappears, but something strange happens, when all the other pillars disappeared, the end crystal was destroyed, but not for Simon’s pillar, the end crystal, and another thing, “Angelo” just floats there, “Angelo” never moves an inch through out the whole video. I was genuinely terrified when I first saw this

[@shafat_gaming.]

fr bruh in the last moment i didn't realized that angelo is not falling bruhhhhh

[@SkyPrestigee]

the video is fake, its all for content, chill out

[@DUDEBRUHMICE]

@@SkyPrestigee Yeah, that part's pretty obvious

[@thetankthatnoonereallytalk5933]

@@SkyPrestigee that's what an ARG is, silly goober

[@DerpiMochi]

​@@SkyPrestigeeWoah really? I didn't know that 😱😱😱😱😱

[@WoolfVision2]

The Zombie pigman could have been a pig that got struck by lightning, good story tho.

[@NikoTheAndroid]

Yeah.

[@Roanvarga]

But why was it agresive..

[@Henry_manly]

Maybe he did go to the nether, hit a zombie pig there, or got scarde and accidentally hit one.

[@FunsterCats]

Yeah I kept saying in my mind

[@Arkstius]

Or having the portal break It can spawn them too

[@Phendet]

The celeste music at the end goes hard

[@princeroblox2024]

this Minecraft Arg is actually good, and actually made me invested unlike other args. Bravo

[@ItzEngi]

i really sat here for 30 mins watching a minecraft ARG documentation and honestly im really impressed with the quality of the video amazing video, would rate 5/5 stars if youtube still had that feature

[@1011One-xx]

Liking means 5/5 disliking means 0/5 there is no in between

[@evacookiecool]

"Who is under simon's bed?" Dude idk why but I started laughing. Edit: here if you cant find it: 4:59

[@Windy_Crescent-1234]

under where

[@user-yx3yr6ft1t]

​@@Windy_Crescent-1234 Underwear

[@blaquerose121]

His homosexuality

[@lemmycat4806]

im under simons bed😈

[@xaidenpaxton2292]

@@lemmycat4806 under wear?

[@Smartidiot69420]

This is my favorite herobrine story, the plot twists like Angleo having different numbers, the bed, the pillars, simon says, the realizeation on how simon realizes that this has happend, and how simon throws hands with the entity! Amazinh

[@RealKirb]

One thing I noticed: At the end, when he mentions a lamp. If the house in game represents his house, the Glowstone beside his bed could be signifying the lamp going out, and this other Herobrine being under his ACTUAL bed in Real Life

[@Minecraftisnotlame1]

nice

[@c00lkid24lolonroblox]

...

[@Sf2Titan]

Hold on, if simon_12's house resembles the real room, does that "Entity" really stalked him under his bed?

[@limpid_runaway1879]

😨😨😨😨😨😨😨😨😨 Uuuhhhh........now you made me worried....

[@limpid_runaway1879]

Wait.....if the entity being under his bed is true, then maybe it's just a monster from monster's inc that's able to hack Minecraft worlds

[@drrobot2364]

“What are the chances Angelo never came, and the alternate hero brine never left…” literal chills.

[@bleightz_games]

facts

[@InteredRobloxian]

my stupid ahh brain thinking the "...literal" is the read more button

[@TheAxolotlOfSuprises]

btw my theory is that angelo WAS THE herobrine all along

[@Kinzi_animations]

​@@TheAxolotlOfSuprisesme too..

[@Sammyjr04]

FR💀​@@InteredRobloxian

[@some_dude_in_the_internet]

What if angelo himself was the alternate herobrine all along? Think about it, he might've build the structure in the video 'birthday'. He might've been pranking him all along. But that might just be a theory. *Or, is it?*

[@HumHum3255]

Hey Vsauce, Micheal here Will Matpat be coming back to KZbin?

[@ICanEdits]

But that might just be a theory, A GAME THEORY!

[@jessebuff7958]

​@@HumHum3255 Sadly, no

[@Justanormalfarmer]

yeah bro normal player can't join a single player video

[@Noobdoesforfun]

​@@jessebuff7958but at least matpat is still here he's behind the scenes now

[@Asunderr-l2o]

The pigman can actually be explained. When lightning strikes a pig, it turns into a pigman. So the pigman was probably created when the lightning anomaly struck a pig.

[@Footystuff792]

But why was it hostile

[@AMentalFailure]

The best part about this is that it doesn't rely on old minecraft betas or alphas like some other args and web series do, this isn't cheap nostalgia bait that turns into a generic good vs evil story (well, at least I hope it isn't, hopefully the last episode, should it actually come, doesn't pull a mark101). Amazing analysis too, it was in-depth enough that it actually made me think and come up with my own therories. Loved it!

[@VoidfluxOrb]

Mark101 legit just ends with: "Uh so... this entire thing was fake. Everyone watching should make another one. Okay, time to delete the world now!" I would hate Simon_12 if he actually does this.

[@Orange-j6n]

Bro Simon is brave as hell

[@MUSA_SMSW_OFFICAL]

Ye fr

[@rose_magic.]

Yeah

[@treevee7376]

if I was Simon, I would've deleted that world and never look back

[@Itsfritzman]

​@@treevee7376i would just delete minecraft and never play it anymore

[@oof_guy.]

​@@Itsfritzman fr 🗿

[@eagle_llama]

29:50 for anyone who was looking for the music as I was, it's Resurrrctions by Lena Raine.

[@EmiWi]

celeste is a masterpiece of a game, i recommend checking it out if you liked the music in the end

[@riya-rianrao9863]

how do you know everything

[@rensdinnissen6162]

Yeah I know with Shazam app

[@rudyLisowski]

Thx bro

[@NeverTHOUGHTofIT]

That lightning hitting every goddamn tree top is now my favorite moment in Minecraft arg history.

[@MrMaximus222]

its funny that og minecraft can be scarier than the hundreds of copycat horror mods today

[@matthewfairo528]

yea just like og cod zombies is scary

[@DaDirtBlock]

​@@matthewfairo528it's because these guys know how to be genuine😅

[@joshuaalindada1416]

I mean, Cxlvin's From the Fog series is pretty terrifying. I do agree that og minecraft is also pretty scary when having creepypastas.

[@Gemin.y]

og minecraft had more legit stuff, making it much scarier

[@rinakumakage7077]

Well yes, but og Minecraft or just the old one in general was scarier due to how bare it was, it was so bare that it was unnatural, this is also the reason why I find java slightly more creepier than bedrock sometimes, bedrock just has a bunch of textures that make it more realistic, some special features too, such as the water color, in bedrock, the water in one area to the other has both a different texture and color sometimes, java only has one color and texture as far as I know, so yeah, you get my point

[@kathryningersoll7176]

Bro Simon is a legit giga chad like he is willing to throw hands just to beat the dragon and restore his world to save his bro is so heroic

[@Coco11d7]

Dude, keep doing these Minecraft mystery videos. I've only seen two and I'm hooked.

[@ghoulishffx]

yo me too i watched the one about find_nulla and then this one my mind is being blown

[@kaiho70]

@@ghoulishffxfr its so interesting

[@hunstraucity8644]

@@ghoulishffx I just did the exact same thing as you. Watched Find_Nulla and now this. KZbin is really pushing those 2 videos. And I ain't complaining :)

[@MinecraftIsFun72]

@@ghoulishffxsame these vids are so good like if he keeps on making them he can get 1 m subs

[@ilikecheeseandlemons]

@@ghoulishffx ong my mind is rushing with questions lol.

[@username-Reem]

Dylan does of Minecraft will be proud of you

[@B0uffon1116]

You should really continue doing these videos They seem such high quality and the storytelling and theories are crazy

[@shapeswitch_mood7221]

Those air pockets have the shape of ore generation. Probably Herobrine taking all the diamonds?

[@ashleymayeaguila9916]

yooo wait maybe thats how angelo got his diamond block for simons birthday or perhaps that was not angelo cz render said his name is different so maybe the angelo that gave simon the diamond block was herobrine 0.5?

[@darr3njov993]

​​@@ashleymayeaguila9916nah its 2.0

[@Luvl3yst4rr]

⁠you guys r onto something!

[@superkid5485]

Yeah

[@momawheelyismyname]

He just wanna be rich

[@WildDogXD]

I am truthfully terrified well done!

[@melon6978]

how does this only have 2 likes its a verified brooo

[@vietcongat5884]

Bro fell off

[@TheAxolotlOfSuprises]

nah simon would win

[@Bakilargaming]

Here before it blows up

[@ekodinvestment]

@Bakilargaming same her lol

[@sir_kronos_mc]

i love stuff like this... i know for certain that minecraft mobs are dumb as boxes of rocks... and i find it very interesting when these frightening mobs are actually intelligent.

[@The_coolest_dude101]

Simon: "it isn't about killing the dragon and beating the game, its to send a message"

[@MielFranklinFernandez]

THIS NEEDS TO BE THE MINECRAFT MOVIE PLOT, 100/10 STORY PLOT, IT IS PERFECT

[@electrickeeper6462]

Still better than the Minecraft movie that we will never get

[@pyro4894]

@@electrickeeper6462 Minecraft Story Mode

[@drakonian4385]

@@pyro4894 shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

[@Brendan-kx8iy]

Well this aged like milk

[@LolCat361]

The monster under Simon's bed was just concerned for his buddy and wanted to make sure Simon was safe.

[@DapperSpringsDraws]

He was just trying to protect him he doesn't want any evil nasties getting under there! 4:35

[@starryskyesal]

ikr how sweet of them

[@flame.6375]

It’s uh fake dude,,,,,well Simon is fake

[@MotoRunkey_]

Man i got really hooked on these videos, I’ve been craving something new and these are just that. I love them and will probably watch an unhealthy amount 😭😂

[@JoMatt16]

Yo this kid simon is a chad fr for trying to throw hands with a herobrine and trying to save his friend

[@TigerBro8]

Very good 👍🏻 It was very interesting how you analyaised it and made it better Keep it up buddy

[@RelMuslimSaudiKuwaiti]

2 VERIFIEDS ON 1 VIDEO? DAMN

[@Nitrecz]

fake verified channel (nevermind I put my cursor on the verify checkmark and the "Verified user" message never popped up, turns out my internet is shit or something)

[@Vylnn-ho1wl]

THAT ENDING GAVE ME SHIVERS BRO, CRAZY BANGER

[@NotVumionz]

i wish this playlist was real

[@TheOrdinaryGoalkeeper]

The most scariest thing in the video is that Simon NEVER played with Angelo and doesn’t even realise…

[@Emmxlyn]

Shit nvm I saw the rest

[@Corrupt01godmiai]

@@Emmxlynwdym

[@Sad_Face]

best video ive seen ever, crazy details, storytelling and everything.

[@SKgamer-vx1pm]

who tf is simon_12 💀

[@EPIC_HIMSELF]

¯\_(ツ)_/¯ don't know

[@cooliocoolster123]

its an april fools video lol

[@TheRealWildberry]

WATCH THE VIDEO

[@FoodgenieYT]

​@@cooliocoolster123 April Fool's was 5 days ago.

[@memez6dev]

He just explained it..

[@alisklai]

everything aside, all the lightning strikes on those trees are actually impressive

[@catchara1496]

Maybe used invisible armor stands?

[@jackgamingtv56]

herobrine: removes leafs and leaves the tree steve: removes the tree and leaves the leafs

[@HorchataSoto-b1c]

Fr

[@bruhifysbackup]

It's actually leaves, but I don't think anyone would care.

[@karinstolze3846]

SONICEXE

[@karinstolze3846]

😮‍💨😮‍💨🤧

[@Sonkie-d4w]

Simon is soooo clever to do the link in the subtitles and his reddit

[@ImranAli-wt1er]

Its something called "arg"

[@tommarnt]

this isn't clever this has been done by the args before

[@Theeverlastingbob]

The fact that I noticed the username difference the first time is crazy

[@Doodlez4life]

Bro this randomly came on and this was one of the most interesting fun mystery videos I’ve ever seen! Thanks!

[@monicaskrzypczak5023]

I just watched this and your most recent video and omg this is a phenomenal genre and I am so here for it. Everything about it is so good and I logically know you made the found footage but it so completely doesn't feel like it. And can I just say, I am so grateful you never include any jump scares. Every time I think it's going to happen I tense up and then it doesn't happen. Genuinely a better payoff than if there was one.

[@AlanO324]

If anyone wants to know what that is in the thumbnail its a mod called “The Mimic Dweller” Its a monster that spies on the player day and night and when you look at it, the monster chases you. It makes creepy sounds when it spawns and it stomps when its near. And yes if you are wandering it is killable, but it has around 300 hp so it will take a while and sadly its only on version 1.19.2

[@dethor6251]

Does pumpkin work againts it

[@Gege_akuttami]

​@@dethor6251 nah, but potato does 🥔

[@Arch-mv5te]

@@dethor6251 theres only one way to find out *dies*

[@ThePolice233]

Its actually look is probably all blak with white eyes

[@AlanO324]

@@ThePolice233 there is a another mod by the same developer called “Fake Steve”

[@Nothingseriousonlyme]

I think “herobrine’s brother” is actually Simon but from the future because when “herobrine’s brother” breaking blocks his computer’s crashing a bit and when he was mining the diamond the computer crashes a bit again and that he was warning him, maybe he got stuck in this seed and he saw himself over and over again and that it’s a loop forever until one of Simon actually deletes the world.

[@Aightmeh]

Story: 10/10 Story teller: 10/10 Video: 10/10 Clips: 10/10 Overall: Simon/10

[@aldonasuchowiecka8502]

For real

[@Rasmushojlund10194]

So its good?

[@roseakm5350]

The plot was mind blowing bruh like they wrote this on literal fire 🔥🔥

[@WakeUpEna]

Simon/12

[@phantomz-b7e]

simon is fake this gideo is fake iy is editor i am the editor of this video lol i cannot believe everyone believe me is pro edited

[@ASKPOLITELYGAMINGHD]

Omg this Minecraft Arg is actually good, and actually made me invested unlike other args. Bravo

[@kevinthebignooooob]

m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/b2KtZ59naNZ7qa8

[@GhostedGD]

this literally gave me chills. i need more simon and angelo lore,NOW!!

[@dinahamm1380]

YES I NEED MORE

[@simplytoast1086]

If this was real, and this "other Herobrine" was in my world, I would be shitting my pants

[@BestBREAD]

Simon: if herobrine tormented me out of my world he would give me some trouble Angelo: but would you delete it? Simon: *Nah id restore*

[@Soulorz_mlbb]

lmaoo

[@HeyShattered]

With my eagle eyes, I can spot that the xxangelo we saw at the start of the video had the suffix "322" at the end of their username, but the xxangelo introduced to us at 9:37 had the suffix "233". I've watched this video till 9:37 minutes so I don't know if Render covers this fact in the video later but just wanted to comment it.

[@Hu_Caramel]

ye that wut i was saying

[@umpatosemato4343]

congrats you got it

[@XenialXenon]

And then at 19:13 the difference is his name is missing the second "xx"

[@HeyShattered]

@@XenialXenon True

[@Frostyboifr]

The fact that someone went out of his way just to tell simon to build that totem, a little kid, is honestly hilarious

[@VerseVisionary]

😂

[@akaredman]

i'm currently watching this at 5:38am and its got me freaking out