One of my favorite concerts in the early 80s was Robin Trower with Dewar and Lordan. It's nearly impossible to replace a voice like Jimmy Dewar's. I'm chuffed that you included them.
@adamschronk36205 ай бұрын
Agreed!👍
@heimomoilanen96545 ай бұрын
Bridge of Sighs is a huge album. Still love it.
@robertlamkin64645 ай бұрын
A good argument!
@brianwilcox25434 ай бұрын
@@heimomoilanen9654 Robin just released a 50th anniversary deluxe edition of of Bridge of Sighs!
@anthonykishko17115 ай бұрын
Having gone to 10 Rush shows, they're the friendliest crowds I've seen. Cool, seeing people bring their kids and Rush put on a sincere epic explosive performance. The best!
@rik2bits5 ай бұрын
Those are the later days. There was definitely a superiority complex among Rush fans through their first 30 years - which was probably warranted! Their last few tours, you’d actually see actual, live women enjoying the shows. That was a rarity in the earlier days.
@DrOz-0075 ай бұрын
Andy said Rush could be the best rock band ever. There is an argument here for sure. Songwriting, lyrics, musicianship, cohesion, personalities, attitude, longevity, output, consistency, performance, sales, they have it all.
@patrickcarlson14004 ай бұрын
I had the pleasure of seeing them in their Hemisphere tour and Moving Pitchers and 4 more times including their last R40 tour seeing a Neil Peart drum solo was worth the price of admission by themselves and just watching how much fun they always seemed to be having and of course the unreal sound they produced live as a power trio like non other, or as Gene Simon's said when he's been ask to describe what type of band Rush is he'd reply Rush is Rush that's it
@majwilsonlion5 ай бұрын
Triumph
@Innerspace1005 ай бұрын
Allways overshadowed by Rush, but I've allways preferred Triumph over them. Rick Emmet is a very tastefull guitar player.
@jldibiase5 ай бұрын
@@Innerspace100 Totally agree. Rik is on my personal Mount Crushmore, Alex isn't.
@kevincarpenter81945 ай бұрын
@@Innerspace100 I believe they deserve equal recognition. Neil was obviously a more talented drummer than Gil, but Gil did handle some lead vocals. I prefer Rik's vocals to Geddy's and would put his guitar playing on par with Alex's. Of course, Mike can't compete with Geddy's bass chops. Lyrically, it depends upon what you're seeking and/or what mold you're in I'm a huge fan of both bands. Have all of Triumph's discography and most of Rush's.
@SuperStrik95 ай бұрын
@@jldibiase Rik has killer classical guitar chops. Didn't know until he gave a live performance/q&a session at the music store I used to teach at in the mid 00's. Great player. I love Alex Lifeson's guitar playing as well. To each their own though.
@ogam54 ай бұрын
@@kevincarpenter8194 : "Ordinary Man" called - might BEG to disagree about Mike vs. Geddy.....
@denniscain72185 ай бұрын
King Crimson's Red lineup (Fripp, Wetton, Bruford)
@IusedtohaveausernameIliked5 ай бұрын
What an awesome album! But not enough staying power to make the list.
@patrickcarlson14004 ай бұрын
I'd say Crimson is the father of Prog rock as they are the ones that set Buford and his then ban Yes down the path of prog when Yes went into a pub and just happen Crimson was setting up to play and Buford said he was going to be their drummer one day
@froggy5563 ай бұрын
@@IusedtohaveausernameIliked What are you talking about? Red holds up with ANTHING out today! Curt Kobain was listening to Red when he was working on "In Utero".
@IusedtohaveausernameIliked3 ай бұрын
@@froggy556 The music holds up, I was just commenting that King Crimson was only a trio for a short time so they don't really qualify as a trio. As far as the music goes "Red" is one of my favourite albums. And technically they weren't even a trio then, they employed other musicians on that album.
@froggy5563 ай бұрын
@@IusedtohaveausernameIliked BE THAT AS IT MAY, someone in Curt Kobain's management recommended that album to him as an example of a power trio in action. Don't shoot the messenger, I'm just telling the facts.
@girthbloodstool3395 ай бұрын
B U D G I E !
@doubleyouranger5 ай бұрын
very much so. geezer don't got them on his list makes it mush.
@NadirJones71Ай бұрын
Impeckable choice my friend.
@arvidsson565 ай бұрын
Hot Tuna made some good records as a trio. In my opinion Jack Casady deserves more recognition for his bass playing.
@KevyNova5 ай бұрын
Absolutely!
@BruceWalther-s2l5 ай бұрын
I am a Hot Tuna fan but I'm wondering if (arguably) their 2 best albums -- First Pull Up Then Pull Down (5 man band); and Burgers (4 man band, minimum) hurts their trio standing. Anyways, Jorma Kaukonen and Jack Casady a worthy mention. Great band no matter what the numbers. Plus, Jorma and Jack were the backbone of Jefferson Airplane. Not a surprise Airplane broke up in 1972 about 3 years after the duo started the Hot Tuna trio for their debut Live At Berkeley, The New Orleans House (with the impressive harmonica of Will Scarlet -- I really wanted to write that name with no apologies to Robin Hood.)😁
@impalaman97075 ай бұрын
But were they a POWER trio?
@KevyNova5 ай бұрын
@@impalaman9707 absolutely! Listen to their albums America’s Choice, Yellow Fever and Hoppkorv. Total power trio in every sense.
@KevyNova5 ай бұрын
@@BruceWalther-s2l their albums America’s Choice, Yellow Fever and Hoppkorv definitely are power trio though.
@markhuber59815 ай бұрын
Grand Funk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@b14m235 ай бұрын
Grand Funk Railroad all day.
@TSP-HIKER28 күн бұрын
Most powerful power trio ever! First 3 albums? PTP! Power Trio Perfection!
@emperorgongs28345 ай бұрын
Groundhogs RIP Tony Macfee. Budgie etc and all those unfortunate bands killed off by the music press. But loved by thier fans.
@WELLBRAN5 ай бұрын
groundhogs..no1 the loudest!!
@IAMTHERAZOR5 ай бұрын
Budgie was the shizzle!
@LorraineHinchliffe-vg5cb5 ай бұрын
I know they weren't a power trio, but I always feel sorry for the band Bad Finger. The lead singer ended up committing suicide, they were so royally ripped off
@markperry94275 ай бұрын
Budgie would be on my list, a great band.
@cavewaller5 ай бұрын
Edgar Broughton Band too
@Sid-gu5qk5 ай бұрын
Rush #1 IMO...... Who else you asked? Frank Marino and Mahogany Rush.
@arijokimaki43155 ай бұрын
Mahogany Rush would be number one in the list of most underrated power trios.
@charlesdigennaro49815 ай бұрын
Oh man mahogany rush! Saw them
@rft20012 ай бұрын
Yeah, Frank Marino and Mahogany Rush. One of my favorite live bands of all time.
@user-zt2wc3uh1l2 ай бұрын
I love listening to Andy talk. He has similar taste in music to my own, yet has introduced me to great artists I wasn't previously familiar with. He always delivers with passion and the insightfulness of an accomplished musician.
@paslowcb5 ай бұрын
I think the James Gang should be on this list.
@WhizzRichardThompson5 ай бұрын
You got there before me.
@jrm2fla5 ай бұрын
James Gang are good… but not the body of work like these other bands… Trower’s Bridge of Sighs alone makes the list. I’m ignorant about Primus… I think Rush are greater than the Police, body of work, etc.. but Police did so much in a short period of time (like Hendrix)…
@KevyNova5 ай бұрын
I agree.
@pgrovners5 ай бұрын
it's about quality not quantity.
@Datsun510zen5 ай бұрын
Had them first on my list of honorable mentions: James Gang, Toy Dolls, Grand Funk Railroad, Beastie Boys, core Genesis, Crosby, Stills & Nash, Husker Du, The Jam, The Stray Cats.
@trainguy10175 ай бұрын
Part of the magic of Rush is that they weren't simply band mates. They were truly best friends. This was shown after Neil lost his wife and daughter and needed time to get himself together. Alex and Geddy...WAITED FOR HIM. They knew the band wouldn't work with any other combination. Simple band mates would have said "screw it! If you can't tour we'll find someone else!" Not them! "Neil, you do what you need to do. We'll put the band on hold until you are ready to come back" That's how best friends treat someone that has gone through that kind of loss.
@grahamnunn89985 ай бұрын
Rush getting tipsy in Beyond The Lighted Stage is a beautiful thing. Read some of Peart's books and most of Lee's and the warmth comes off the page.
@robertlamkin64645 ай бұрын
Rush was as tight a band I ever saw. They were great at what they did. They along with the Moody Blues adapted their sound to match the times, flawlessly. My problem with Rush is Peart. To me - IMO - his lyrics always seemed preachy. They seemed holier than thou; like he was above it all. As a result, I rarely ever listened to them. I summation, I get an arrogant vibe with Rush.
@RaptorV1USA2 ай бұрын
Interesting perspective...i mean....They're song lyrics. I would guess that Neil himself would be the 1st. person to say that himself... They're just songs...while some may consider them deeply and they were obviously written with care and consideration often with a message/ theme of some sort..they are in the end, just songs. Melody, rhythm and words that came together to be enjoyed ....or not ......ultimately it's not that deep.. personally I was always more focused on the music...the composition melody and their incredible skills at performing their sets so faithfully...thats why I'm still rocking RUSH at nearly 60, and to me they are the greatest rock trio ever.. Be well brother.@@robertlamkin6464
@jasonmcloughlin53735 ай бұрын
Kings x - incredible band
@svenjansen2134Ай бұрын
Perfect trio
@mnick096217 күн бұрын
Love your take on ZZ Top. My dad was a photographer for the local paper here in North Carolina and went to take pictures of their Texas-shaped stage with all the steers, buzzards, rattlesnakes et. al. in 1976. Their manager gave him a copy of their latest LP and a sampler album. Dad passed them on to my 13 year old self and I was hooked. Oh, and a friend of mine who makes boutique tube guitar has Billy Gibbons as a client and friend.
@johnandrews35685 ай бұрын
Neil Peart's death has left a massive void in the time-space continuum. The world hasn't been the same since.
@greengrass10724 ай бұрын
It took a few hours after I heard he passed for it to sink in, it just didn’t seem real. Once it did, I lost it. It was like my own life passed before my eyes and how much Rush and their music was a part of it. I think I cried on and off for a week after the news. That has never happened to me ever for someone I didn’t even know. But his lyrics and that band have touched so many people on a personal level that it felt like you lost a family member or a close friend. I so miss that excitement of a new album and the tour that followed it. My oldest son is 19 and he is so into them and everything old school music. It’s so sad that he’ll never get to go through what many of us were lucky to have gone through with Rush. I would’ve loved for him to see them live just once.
@brucebrown734 ай бұрын
We still have Carl Palmer. They were both tops in my book
@user-zt2wc3uh1l2 ай бұрын
That's right around the time the Covid bioweapon hit, and the world went crazy. You're correct, it hasn't been the same since. No Rush tours or albums to look forward to. It feels like the good times are over.
@user-zt2wc3uh1l2 ай бұрын
@@brucebrown73 , while Palmer is awesome, he didn't play in the same iconic band for 40 years, nor write the lyrical soundtrack for the lives of millions.
@Bob-tq2jvАй бұрын
The Jimi Hendrix Experience and Cream were my top two too - and this list couldn’t be complete without Rush. Brilliant as usual Andy
@philford17305 ай бұрын
My top 10: 1) Rush, 2) Jimi Hendrix Experience, 3) The Police, 4) Robin Trower, 5) Stevie Ray Vaughn and Double Trouble, 6) Cream, 7) ZZ Top, 8) Muse, 9) Los Lonely Boys, 10) Triumph. ELP, Motorhead, Nirvana and Primus would certainly be in my top 20. Along with Grand Funk, The Jam, Green Day, The James Gang, Mountain, and Them Crooked Vultures
@mofost15 ай бұрын
Them crooked vultures & muse, good calls’s-es
@jakemore20245 ай бұрын
I love most of those but The Warning tops them all
@mistahwolfie5 ай бұрын
You're all going to kick yourselves... K I N G S X
@Rico_G5 ай бұрын
H E L L Y E S ! ! !
@John-k6f9k5 ай бұрын
@@Rico_G Oh man, that's so true! Kings X!!! Wait a minute who the fuck are Kings X?
@craigroaring5 ай бұрын
@@John-k6f9k They're a three piece.
@speciesgal2 ай бұрын
Couldn't agree more, highly underrated IMO. Had the pleasure of catching them in many small and intimate venues and loved the appreciation they gave the fans.
@Rico_G2 ай бұрын
@@craigroaring LOL!
@mrkitewine77005 ай бұрын
Watching Primus open for Rush on the Uk leg of the Roll The Bones tour was one of my favourite gigs. 2 of my favourite bands, both trios , all astonishingly good musicians (Tim “Herb” Alexander was the Primus drummer).
@guitarcd5 ай бұрын
I saw that tour in the US. Amazing show.
@SonofHendrik5 ай бұрын
Me too, saw Primus opening for Rush in Germany and in the Netherlands. In Germany they didn't like Primus, they didn't understand the music of them.
@bettyrose9593 ай бұрын
Larry LaLonde on guitar. The man starts his career off with a fricken masterpiece at 16 years old. Cemented himself in the books straight from the word Go. He's incredible.
@speciesgal2 ай бұрын
@@guitarcd same, Hampton Coliseum 8th row in front of Les and Geddy. Me and my buddy got shouted at for standing up and grooving during Primus set...didn't care LOL.
@gregoryvlchek2695 ай бұрын
The Warning - three sisters from Monterrey, Mexico will definitely earn their place on the list some day. In the past year, they've been blowing up in notoriety and popularity around the world. They're truly PHENOMENAL and are still young; 19, 22 and 24. They've been a band for TEN years - since they were literal children. And they were unbelievably good back then.
@jakemore20245 ай бұрын
They are already first..just accept it
@thespacealienssmogandgrog42835 ай бұрын
Absolutely. Glad I'm not the only one who commented on them here. The Warning are so great it's almost weird.
@jakemore20245 ай бұрын
@@thespacealienssmogandgrog4283 only a handful of bands as tight as them…The Who..maybe Rush
@Hartlor_Tayley5 ай бұрын
Great list and interesting commentary. Thanks
@holgerhieronimi40505 ай бұрын
what a great, eclectic, diverse & complete selection - ¡Congratulions!
@paulmichaud75655 ай бұрын
A beautiful little standalone essay on the Police in this episode. Well done, Andy. That alone was worth the price of admission. Not a power trio, a FINESSE trio.
@samibouhadida53142 күн бұрын
Well said 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
@angusorvid88405 ай бұрын
Rush, Triumph, Mahogany Rush, King's X, Tony Williams' Lifetime, Primus, Raven, Budgie, Eric Bell Era Thin Lizzy, Robin Trower Group.
@ΛεωνιδαςΑργυρος5 ай бұрын
Beck, Bogert & Appice. If they had had more masculine vocals, they would have been the quintessential Power Trio.
@NelsonMontana12345 ай бұрын
Yeah, but they needed a singer.
@andrewsheppard31895 ай бұрын
One of the few bands which were so bad that I departed early.
@jamesfetherston11905 ай бұрын
@@NelsonMontana1234 and songwriting.
@NelsonMontana12345 ай бұрын
@@jamesfetherston1190 True. Superstition was their best track. They had one decent original. I actually gave up on Beck after that debacle. And then...
@user-dh5bnafe4b5 ай бұрын
BBA's problem was that while the musicianship was great, the material largely wasn't.
@DrOz-0075 ай бұрын
Husker Du
@danpearce45475 ай бұрын
Yeah Husker Du! (also Sugar)
@IndySnowman5 ай бұрын
I remember them
@bpm6095 ай бұрын
And Big Black.
@visualanimal56345 ай бұрын
It needs to be said, loudly, that this is the most entertaining and thought provoking music channel on KZbin.
@John-k6f9k5 ай бұрын
Lol what a suck up.
@mauricerevelle84515 ай бұрын
The Jam.
@jonathansteadman79355 ай бұрын
Yep ❤
@NessieJapan2 ай бұрын
One of my favorite bands, but Weller did most of the heavy lifting. It was more of a "plus two" than a trio.
@malcolmjeffrey32354 сағат бұрын
@@NessieJapan Maybe at the start, yes, but the great Bruce Foxton learned and honed his craft over their lifespan and evolved into almost the new wave's Paul McCartney : inventive, melodic, driving and versatile, while still doing dual harmonies.
@Afterburner25 ай бұрын
No specific order- Cream,Taste,Blue Cheer,Groundhogs,Atomic Rooster(70')Grand Funk,Trapeze,Budgie,Rush,James Gang
@seancassidy6745 ай бұрын
yeah, Blue Cheer were 1st gen as well.
@astrogoodvibes61645 ай бұрын
One name.......Budgie
@davidbuie33165 ай бұрын
I came here specifically to say that I sure hope The Jam are on this list and I'm pleased to see the first commenter already beat me to it. Good work!
@AndyEdwardsDrummer5 ай бұрын
I mention them but they aren't.
@finneogan5 ай бұрын
I'm not the first to mention them, but there is a trio who played faster and more energetic than Motörhead even, had not just one frontman / singer / songwriter but two, one fronting from the drums. Yes, smashing the drums in the fastest band of the world (when they started) while singing. The most influential band never mentioned, never on lists like these, but those who know, know: Hüsker Dü.
@theskintexpat-themightygreegor5 ай бұрын
Absolutely. I watched this video knowing that I was hoping against hope that Hüskers would be on this list. You're right - they never make any lists, but they were amazing, and I had the chance to see them three times and they always KILLED.
@michaeljozwiak255 ай бұрын
1). You mentioned so many bands that I own at least one of their albums, except Cream and The Jam. 2). James Dewar is one of rock’s best vocalists. 3). “In City Dreams” and “Midnight Caravan” are my two most favorite Robin Trower albums. 4). Decades ago, my brother played in a Slo-pitch softball game against Frank Beard’s team. My brother did not know it was Beard, until they shared beer at the softball complex’s clubhouse. 5). I love the power trio Budgie. 6). I own albums by Soft Machine, Isotope, etc. 7). I like the album, “Spartacus” by the power trio, Triumvirat.
@wtcwtc98615 ай бұрын
West, Bruce and Laing..The James Gang.
@CraigHollabaugh5 ай бұрын
Loved this! Thanks Andy.
@tonicjack98234 ай бұрын
I'm really happy to see you mentioned The Nice and what a fabulous drummer Brian Davidson was. There was so much space in their musical arrangements that KE could basically take the band anywhere and everywhere when they played live. Lee Jackson was not everyones favourite singer, but he was a hell of a bass player. For me The Nice was the perfect trio.
@Bobmacca645 ай бұрын
Not only are ZZ Top musically amazing, they also knew how to sell their image and music to an audience through fantastic publicity stunts. They were, and are, a damn good, funny, and also clever band that has carved its own place in the history of rock. Nobody looks or sounds like them. Love them to bits! :) With Billy Gibbons being one of my 3 favourite guitar players.
@froggy5565 ай бұрын
ZZ Top haven't been relevant since they did that awful Elvis remake!
@Bobmacca645 ай бұрын
@@froggy556 Fair enough if that's how you feel about them. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. To be fair though, very few rock bands have been really relevant past a certain point in their career. Many of them are just doing the same thing they have always done, or they have become a 'greatest hits' live band. Anyway, I disagree on ZZ Top, but that's what's interesting. If we all agreed on everything it would be boring as hell:) Take care!
@bjornlangoren30025 ай бұрын
Billy gibbons is a legend, and more down to earth than anyone
@froggy5565 ай бұрын
@@bjornlangoren3002 when he learns to play Paganini on a guitar, you might convince me!
@bjornlangoren30025 ай бұрын
@@froggy556 why should he play paganini? Would YOU pay to see that? What are you, Yngwie's mother?
@mofost15 ай бұрын
A trio is a trio. A trio with a singer is a quatro. The fact that you gots to scrap it out & play & sing, somebodys got to be the singer(tho nobody really wants to be the singer) & that’s what makes it a power trio, garage trio, making it happen with just me & my axe & whoever’s brave enough to learn drums & bass to get up there so I’m not alone.😦🎸🥁
@callmeal30175 ай бұрын
Ok to have ELP there
@daviddrennon40898 күн бұрын
Hell Yeah!
@robertellison46915 ай бұрын
Cream is the cream of power trios. All 3 could sing, write, improvise and were the best musicians on their respective instruments.
@erikheddergott55145 ай бұрын
Powertrio 1a: November 1988: James Blood Ulmer, Bill Laswell, Ronald Shannon Jackson; A Concert Shannon gave me! Zürich, Volkshaus 1988. Powertrio 1b: James Blood Ulmer, Jamaladeen Tacuma, Ronald Shannon Jackson; Jazzfestival Willisau September 1989. Powertrio 1c: James Blood Ulmer, Amin Ali, Grant Calvin Weston; Bloods regular Powertrio in the 80ties and 90ties. Powertrio 2: Odean Pope Trio. Powertrio 3: Ornette Coleman: The Golden Circle Stockholm.
@RichardCThurston5 ай бұрын
I've seen the Ulmer/Tacuma/Jackson iteration and they brought it big time. Same with Odean Pope. Wowsa. Here are a couple others from that side of the genre. Bill is...Bill. A complete one of a kind. Bill Frisell, John Zorn, George Lewis. Bill Frisell, Melvin Gibbs, Ronald Shannon Jackson.
@erikheddergott55145 ай бұрын
@@RichardCThurston Tacuma/Weston also played with James Blood Ulmer, as with Ornette Coleman, Derek Bailey and Marc Ribot and Mary Halvorson.
@DoctorInsomnia-qw7us5 ай бұрын
I saw James Blood Ulmer open for the Clash in 79 NYC, the other opening act being Sam & Dave...a great night of music...
@erikheddergott55145 ай бұрын
@@DoctorInsomnia-qw7us Wonderful, I never saw Sam and Dave nor the Clash so I had to settle with Blood for many Times in all his very diverse Bands, from Psychedelic Country Jazz to Funk, from Blues to Free Jazz, Punk Jazz and Free Funk. I would have loved to see Sam and Dave.
@erikheddergott55145 ай бұрын
@@RichardCThurston I am actually puzzled that Massacre with Fred Frith, Charles Hayward or Fred Maher and Bill Laswell were not in the Video.
@grahamnunn89985 ай бұрын
I picked up Trower Live in the early 80s, a really gamechanger for a young guitar player.
@FloatingAnarchy615 ай бұрын
Good list. Robin Trower was also a top gurner. He had a impressive set of choppers and in the throes of a guitar solo he looked like an ecstatic beaver. Deguello is my favourite ZZ Top album, funky jazzy with a great mix of upbeat stompers like Hi Fi Mama and She Loves My Automobile, and the Funky Fool For You're Stockings, Cheap Sunglasses etc. The addition of the horns also beefed up their style. I first became aware of Les Claypool through the Tom Waits song Big In Japan which has incredible bass. I'd be interested in your take on Tom Waits. I'm not a huge fan of what I call his 70's tears in the beers stuff, but Swordfishtrombones onwards. It's like Beefheart mixed with a low down jazz and blues band from a carnival. Big Time is one of my favourite concert films, long overdue a release on Dvd, his guitarist Marc Ribot is amazing.I think I would have found a place for Budgie on this list, classic Welsh trio with another great guitarist, Tony Bourge. The album Never Turn Your Back On A Friend is one of my all time favourites. On Parents Tony absolutely soars on the guitar.
@mrkitewine77005 ай бұрын
Loads of great ones mentioned, I’d also suggest Bob Mould’s band - Sugar
@8mileshighАй бұрын
Bob Mould, yes, but with Hüsker Dü
@paulcollins55865 ай бұрын
The stray cats.
@erikheddergott55145 ай бұрын
Brian Setzer is an amazing Guitarplayer. Saw him 1981 in Montreux. For some Tunes Wilco Johnson stepped in. He was there with Pearl Harbour.
@unabonger7775 ай бұрын
@@erikheddergott5514 he certainly is. and was all of 19 at the time.
@jonathansteadman79355 ай бұрын
Absolutely, brilliant band!!
@scott-qs6sp4 ай бұрын
nice forgot about them
@stubbsz2 ай бұрын
I never thought of them but I should have.
@NelsonMontana12342 ай бұрын
GRAND FUNK baby! They're pretty damn special. Each player has a unique style and they have an amazing vocalist. As a drummer, you might appreciate the fact that Don Brewer was the first guy to play hard quarter notes on the hi hat, instead of the standard 8th notes. That created a different feel. Funkier -- more spacious -- heavier. It's been copied endlessy ever since. If nothing else, that makes them important.
@axxellein5 ай бұрын
Early Blue Cheer=Louder Than God!!!
@williambaxter46284 ай бұрын
Now you're talking!
@marksieczko77665 ай бұрын
Line ups change. For the most part these are guitar, bass, drums trios. Jimi Hendrix Experience Cream Rush Groundhogs Motorhead Grand Funk Railroad Robin Trower Rory Gallagher Johnny Winter ZZ Top Honourable mentions - Irish Skid Row (with Gary Moore), Atomic Rooster ,ELP, Police (would be in my top 11)
@billphelps56115 ай бұрын
Grand Funk Railroad! Good choices, fun video!
@vmax4steve5245 ай бұрын
My twopenneth would be Mahogany Rush Cream Jimi Hendrix Experience Robin Trower Earthless 16 Horsepower Barnstorm Taste and two others of whom I don't have any records by.
@FlightofElixirs5 ай бұрын
That rush rant brilliant. Really laughing out loud myself shaving in the toilet haha class
@pookiemartinez17455 ай бұрын
Budgie, GFR, Blue Cheer, Minutemen, Glass Harp, Dust, Road, Wipers, No means No. Taste.
@mccallosone49035 ай бұрын
i was worried you werent going to have ZZ Top. glad to see you came through. one of the most fun bands of all time, with talent to back it up
@dennismason37405 ай бұрын
The Chipmunks. I am not joking. The Chipmunks and their friend Dave produced a novelty Christmas hit record and the 'Munks were born, big time. The cartoon show literally taught children how to sing harmonies. You think I'm old and high you'd be half right. The Chipmunks were my power trio in an awesome sense. Yes, I just had a memory explosion and I will never lie to Andy. Plus Cream.
@AndyEdwardsDrummer5 ай бұрын
Give me an email Dennis and say hello andyedwardsdrums@gmail.com
@dennismason37405 ай бұрын
@@AndyEdwardsDrummer - I entered your address a few times, put it in contacts and all, doesn't seem to go through? Maybe I'm screwing it up. I'll re-do later. Do you have an alternative email? Effin June, somebody stop this massive acceleration. I play guitar when my body ain't working. Notice how your email above should be in blue? I'm thinking: There is a rebel letter in the address. Makes no sense. Meanwhile, or nicewhile, there's YT which seems to be going tits up here and there. "Let's eff the customers, we'll make even more money!". Coyotes live pretty much live in every U.S. state except for Alaska and Hawaii. Coyotes are magical, we've sung in the hills together, long story.
@BillRolette3 ай бұрын
First childhood albums
@dennismason37403 ай бұрын
@@BillRolette - "Al-vinnnnnnnn!".
@mikec6733Ай бұрын
@@dennismason3740 O-Kay !!!!!
@tophat7624 ай бұрын
Great list! It's amazing what Hendrix did with a 3 piece group.
@carlosgaspar84473 ай бұрын
robin trower and jack bruce in "truce"
@kevindohn67765 ай бұрын
and of course . . . . . . . . .Triumph !
@brewstergallery3 ай бұрын
Ned again with another trio, this time from Argentina called Invisible. The main man in it was the late Luis Alberto Spinetta " El Flaco" a legend in that country and S America in general. They made 3 studio LP's that fuse prog, heavy rock, jazz, ballads, tango, flamenco and do it beautifully. Some of their songs are numerous changes and complex arrangements but sound open and they groove. Spinetta started in 1967 ending with his death in 2012 wrote close to 400 songs changing his band and sound usually every 3 albums. I hope you have time to look into his work.
@maxxkarma5 ай бұрын
Rush is the ultimate power trio. They might not be the most important band in this list, but they are the ultimate. Started as power trio, ended as a power trio and 47years in between a power trio. No discussion!
@IusedtohaveausernameIliked5 ай бұрын
RUSH for the win.
@ShaunHensley5 ай бұрын
This is accurate
@stevemarshall39865 ай бұрын
Not important? Wtf.
@jirky0155 ай бұрын
@@stevemarshall3986 He said "not the most important band in this list". He never said not important. Rush is my favorite band but his statement is accurate.
@rodrigoodonsalcedocisneros92664 ай бұрын
Same thing for ZZ Top and Mötorhead. Long careers as power trios.
@jeremys55765 ай бұрын
Soft Machine, Grand Funk Railroad, Blue Cheer, Hüsker Dü, Melvins, Supergrass, and Morphine are some other power trios worthy of mention. I laughed with joy at your first pick, Primus -- one of my favourite bands as a teenager in the Nineties.
@GeofHolmes5 ай бұрын
Cream, Hendrix, Budgie and 'Sir Lord Baltimore' from New York. What a band!
@kevincentofanti38225 ай бұрын
Worth a mention and consideration of power trios: Robben Ford and the Blue Line. Great mix of tasty rock, jazz, blues and funk. Minor pushback is Robben' s voice is not the strongest. Musicianship is great. Give these recordings a listen.
@lamusiquequisecoute5105 ай бұрын
That's when Robben Ford was at his peak for me. Love his tone and his tasty soloing. I don't like everything from those albums and like you said, his voice is kind of bland but 'Think Twice', 'Good Thing', 'Top of The Hill', 'Running Out On Me', 'Life Song (One For Annie)' are really cool tracks. I don't know the album 'Mystic Mile', is it good?
@vincentrockel11495 ай бұрын
I've seen Robin a number of times. Better live than on records. Roscoe Beck is a great bassist.
@nazznate5 ай бұрын
Andy, first off (as you take your hat off) remember, when your hair gets to be that color, you know things... Secondly, I learned some time ago to just have fun with the "greatest" lists and not get my hackles up about them, but as you started I realized just how much I still love the power trio as an entity and you better get it right. I'm a few years older than you and grew up in south Georgia in the states, you in England about the same age as my little brother. I grew up with great love for some trios I knew would never make your list, and I understand why and ultimately agree (Mahogany Rush, Pat Travers Band, Montrose). I was pretty sure I knew who your top 4 would be and I was right. I'm very pleased that you recognized ZZ Top who I was adoring way before Eliminator.
@michaelhansen75165 ай бұрын
Minutemen. Probably not power and definitely not a sales leader, but a favorite.
@shma1israel5 ай бұрын
And fIREHOSE as well. That first album (Ragin', Full-On) was something else.
@chriscoughlin92895 ай бұрын
@@shma1israel Pedro boys throw down. RIP D. Boon, RIP Dancing Waters.
@honuman395 ай бұрын
I got into fIREHOSE before the Minutemen due to timing but I saw them at this club in OC called the Green Door to about 10 people and they ripped it up hard. I couldn't believe no one was there. Personal favorite power trios not on this list are the Cave Dogs and Buffalo Tom.
@pl335 ай бұрын
Both deserve to there
@divotor147Ай бұрын
Robin Trower, James Dewar and Reg Isador. Who can forget Bridge Of Sighs'.
@richeaton57525 ай бұрын
Time keeps on ticking... I was blessed. My first rock concert: May 19, 1973 East Tennessee State University (lol yeah, I'm old, but still above the dirt...) Rory Gallagher - ZZ Top 4 dollars It was about two months before Tres Hombres came out. (Dusty Hill's 24th birthday, I came to find out on his passing) It was Festival Seating and I managed to get about 15 feet from mic center. Rory Gallagher was pure fire right out of the gate, and his band was phenomenal. (particularly Lou Martin on his electric piano) Rory was amazing to see play and I think that he had as much fun as anyone. Then, Billy Gibbons and the boys came out. Back when they were the most badass blues rock band that ever was. Straw hats, jeans, no beards (but Frank. lol), and BG in a white tshirt w/ pack of Marlboros rolled up in the sleeve(lol). Needless to say, Rory and Billy made a big impression on a 16 yr old. Blues rock, slide guitar nut ever since. RIP Rory, Rod, Lou, & Dusty. Thank You! Keep Rockin' Billy, Frank, & Gerry
@chriscoughlin92895 ай бұрын
Holy cow - MY first as well! Rory at LA's Shrine Auditorium - Thanksgiving weekend 1974. With a then - unknown Rush and Wet Willie for openers! Taste deserved a place on this list.
@BruceWalther-s2l5 ай бұрын
That's Awesome. I learned on 1980's music and MTV becoming aware of the cool blues rock sounds of ZZ Top and "She got Legs ... She know how to use them ..." with the babes and the cool ass car in the music videos but I didn't become aware of Rory Gallagher until I saw him performing on my The Old Grey Whistle Test DVD (which also includes The Police; and Edgar Winter Group performing Frankenstein -- wow-- just to name 2 of 22 performers ... U2, Bruce Sprinsteen, Tom Petty, Randy Newman...anyways ...!) Rory Gallager was amazing, wish I had heard him decades sooner. It's a shame Gallagher never got the recognition he deserved in life or death. His trio band Taste got a few shout-outs on this sight, but like I mentioned a couple days ago the fact Taste only made 2 albums keeps them off a tops Power trio list (I guess). Love to find a recording of Taste at the Isle Of Wight performance (they brokup soon after, 1970). Again great ZZ and early Rory (Lou Martin too) in concert story. Cool for you. Some NVEE. I just wrote that? NVEE. Good Name for a rock prog and/or Power trio band?
@davidberge58512 ай бұрын
“Keith Emerson was prog”… I was fortunate to see ELP live several times… once my brother and I had 2nd row seats and during the encore Keith was up to his usual antics during America/Rondo a la Turk… he dragged the Hammond around creating feedback, lean back supported by the crowd and play the thing backwards and stab daggers between the keys… well, one of the daggers flew into the crowd… my brother picked it up, handed it to me, I gave it back to Keith and “without skipping a beat” he jammed it back between two keys. He was an utterly remarkable performer.
@arthurlaurey42325 ай бұрын
Marc Ribot Ceramic Dog. Now that is POWER.
@stephenzevetchin5 ай бұрын
Another nice one Andy. Thanks
@garyh.2385 ай бұрын
GRAND FUNK RAILROAD from Flint City, Michigan!!
@markhuber59815 ай бұрын
Andy hates most USA stuff. He probably never heard of GFR.
@impalaman97075 ай бұрын
@@markhuber5981 There again--how many Americans have heard the Edgar Broughton Band? I'm sure if a GFR fan got to hear the Edgar Broughton Band, they would dig 'em (I know I do!)
@robertgough58045 ай бұрын
Gfr crap saw them get demolished by humble pie at hyde patk
@garyh.2385 ай бұрын
@@robertgough5804 Unfortunate that you saw it as a battle of the bands rather than just enjoying a pairing of two bands playing different styles of rock music. Concert bills are not intended to be sports competitions.
@garyh.2385 ай бұрын
@@impalaman9707 GFR didn't get a lot of coverage in the UK and Europe. They focused mainly on the American market.
@scottbookman5 ай бұрын
This would be in the top three of my 10 funniest Andy videos.ranked
@johncrocker-nh7ey5 ай бұрын
I can't believe how America has been snubbed on this list we've had great power trios Grand Funk Railroad was one of the biggest bands in the world in 197071 the James gang my God was walk away funk 49 the Stray Cats you did have ZZ Top on it and I tip my hat for that George Thorogood and I'm still going to throw up Rory Gallagher put on Shane kicker and listen to that and see why Jimi Hendrix never wanted to follow him
@AndyEdwardsDrummer5 ай бұрын
Ireally wanted to put Stray Cats on there as I love them. I listed to quite a lot of Grand Funk as I had not really listened to them and a lot of the live videos had a keyboard player I think. I was also not that impressed...the Police are 1/3 American and Hendrix 2/3...
@kocinski87345 ай бұрын
Sleater-Kinney ... even though they gave me tinnitus.
@FlyJohnny1005 ай бұрын
Insightful look at trios...a huge part of our music history. I saw Rush at the LA Forum in the 80's, they were amazing. I had long hair back then, lots of it....I'm thankful for what I have left, but no longer rocking a rich carpet like Andy.
@ronnelson78285 ай бұрын
>>> Reg Isidore
@grahamnunn89985 ай бұрын
Also a fantastic drummer. Robin has great taste!
@ronmercer77665 ай бұрын
Twice Removed From Yesterday is a stone cold classic record. Definitely one of my two favorite Robin Trower records.
@G60syncro5 ай бұрын
The biggest takeaway of me playing in a trio was getting to play my own drums all the time!! I'm lefty so I would always throw a wrench in the lineup when it came to gigs with lots of band changes. It would only happen on the one show before the bookers picked up on it. In the end I told them "Look, I'm going to play my drums and I'll set my kit up front on the right side of the stage and you can move the mikes up on the backline kit when we're done." Once that got sorted, it brings up one point about having the drummer sitting in the back... Playing frontline with the guitar player off my hi-hat side meant he was on the crisper, tighter side of my sound palette, not on the loud washy side of the ride cymbals. I had his amp in my ear and he obviously had my drums in his ear but the loud brash cymbals were off towards the side. also, I had the bass player opposite the singer-guitarist still within earshot. So onstage it was all three of us, inches from the front edge of the stage, really close to one another and playing in perfect sync. It brings an in your face energy to a gig that you could never bring with a bigger ensemble where I feel it's just too wide of an aspect ratio for the eyes.
@relativetimeworx84595 ай бұрын
Well done including the oft overlooked Robin Trower band. Just unique enough to be special, but not so much for to be inaccessible. Your biggest omission for me, is King's X. No one else like them. Certainly, no other power trio can match their vocals. No one grooves like them either. If you're not familiar with them... start with "Gretchen Goes To Nebraska".
@robertglisson63194 ай бұрын
Your self-caricature of your self as a classic Rush fan was not only hilarious and spot on. This is why not very many girls/women can stand them lol...
@stephendoherty9815 ай бұрын
Any mention of Taste, Rory Gallagher’s awesome blues trio from the late 60’s?
@daviddrennon40898 күн бұрын
TASTE?
@daviddrennon40898 күн бұрын
Hell yeah!
@sarahhhh7755 ай бұрын
Highly entertaining. Thankyou. 😎
@jamestulk51114 ай бұрын
Three sisters from Mexico will eventually push their way into this list.
@thomasmalatesta73313 ай бұрын
They are the best band I have seen in 30 years !!! - The Warning
@iqbalmuhammad2920Ай бұрын
Depending on how many quality album & live performance they can produce in the future. They haven't even scratch theTop 20 in my opinion.
@deadpoetlive4 ай бұрын
The Jam is the first group that come to mind every time..."....Some people might say my life is in a rut....." ....from the opening line the very definition of a power trio.
@davidreichert93925 ай бұрын
Finally someone acknowledging that Hendrix was at his best with Mitchell and Billy Cox. His stuff with the Experience and BoG was great of course, but his work after Electric Ladyland was miles ahead. So few people seem to agree with me on that. So nice to see that you do.
@KevyNova5 ай бұрын
I absolutely agree!
@John-k6f9k5 ай бұрын
Having read his autobiography it seems Noel Redding was a bit of a prick. He was chosen by Chas Chandler for Jimi because he was just about the only bass player available at short notice. He was really only about adequate as a musician. Billy Cox was the bass player Jimi craved musically. Noel would sometimes play badly deliberately in concerts just to piss off Jimi.
@KevyNova5 ай бұрын
@@John-k6f9k I’ve seen many interviews with Noel and he always comes off as a mean, angry little man who thought he should’ve been as popular as Jimi. I can’t stand him.
@John-k6f9k5 ай бұрын
@@KevyNovaIn addition to the personality clash with Hendrix his main complaint was that his manager ripped him off. He literally seemed to spend most of his post Experience life sulking about it. So what Noel, many many bands were ripped off by their managers.
@neilsackman47235 ай бұрын
Totally agree with Rush! To me they will always be the top power trio. And actually my favorite band ever. Saw them every tour since Power Windows.
@davidliddell67105 ай бұрын
Johnny Winter Band. Second best Power Trio at Woodstock (plus bro Edgar for a few tunes). Be interested to hear your favorite Jazz Trios (might have to be top twenty).
@dirkardostevergreen48272 ай бұрын
Loved the snort. You’re hilarious 😂
@charlesbowman1055 ай бұрын
You're absolutely correct to include Nirvana on this list, regardless of what anyone else thinks.
@bjornlangoren30025 ай бұрын
I had them on my list.: Police Cream Nirvana Jimi Hendrix&co ZZ top Love primus, but not sure they were popular enough to qualify
@RaymondBCrisp4 ай бұрын
Can't believe Triumph didn't make the list. Always overlooked...
@Exposure2life5 ай бұрын
I'm Stayin' Alive for this one... and not holding my breath.
@bentleycharles7795 ай бұрын
lol.
@user-dh5bnafe4b5 ай бұрын
Great songwriting but not really a "Power Trio" i.e. Guitar/Bass/Drums with one of them also on vocals (or occasionally shared).
@TheMDJ20005 ай бұрын
Beck, Bogert & Appice.
@DIEmicrosoft5 ай бұрын
Nobodies ever heard of DUST. Early 70's power trio, Ritchie Wise, Kenny Aaronson, and a 17 year old Marc Bell (Marky Ramone). Did two albums (Dust, and Hard Attack) then split. FANTASTIC drums for such a young lad. Do yourself a favour.
@shannonhenson6095 ай бұрын
I have to admit.....you are the first person I've ever heard accuse the other two members of Double Trouble of being "lackluster". Chris Layton and Tommy Shannon are very highly regarded players. I don't think SRV would have put up with anything less.
@c.e.anderson5584 ай бұрын
True. They had to keep up with Stevie. Because SRV didn't think about what to play next. He did.t lnow. The music flowed from the cosmos to his hands. And Stevie could have gotten any 2 people in the world and he wanted Tommy and Chris. Rick solid and quick..
@goport3 ай бұрын
Great Video. Two points: 1. Totally nailed the geekiness of Rush fans. A guilty secret when blushingly explaining it to a partisan. Although when I saw Rush at the Millennium Dome the entire audience stood for the duration of both (long) sets. It was almost like a religious experience. Especially when they played the whole of Moving Pictures. 2. I know its been mentioned already but I do think the Jam probably challenge for a place on this list. Not my poison but in the DIY punk era they were very tight and powerful. They grew as as a band and called it a day before they got too long in the tooth. I get they didn't travel well but they had songs that seem to have stood the test of time.
@CraigHollabaugh5 ай бұрын
My guesses ZZ Top, Jimi Hendrix Experience, Rush, Cream, Police, Motörhead, Nirvana, Charley's Angels and hands down, the Three Stooges. Curly slaps a wicked bass.
@mrinalkundu15215 ай бұрын
Wilson, Keppel and Betty.
@GrantTregellas5 ай бұрын
The 3 Amigos?
@Birdlives2475 ай бұрын
A powerful influence.....Scotty Moore, Bill Black and Elvis Presley. Also, Chuck Berry, Johnnie Johnson and drummer.
The Jam should be on the list for me but we are all different
@Bass_Playa_Two_Point.OАй бұрын
I had the fortune to see ZZ Top during the Deguelo tour at the infamous Hollywood Sportatorium. Memorable.
@6dna5 ай бұрын
James Gang, Grand Funk, Stevie Ray and Double Trouble
@edwardyazinski38585 ай бұрын
Dbl Tbl had no egos and kept it tight for SRV. None of what tore Cream apart.
@andymoody83634 ай бұрын
New to the channel but now a subscriber. I was a bit doubtful at first with the exclusion of The Jam and I don't really lean that into prog so not every choice is one I would make but this was just so passionate and music literate I could watch it over and over. The Nirvana section should be clipped and shown in schools, absolutely brilliant and 100% spot on. Everyone's got an opinion and for my money I would include GD, I'd also nod to The Stray Cats although that may be too much in terms of a rockabilly genre band and you excluded blues acts. I think Placebo are worth a shout too. One criticism you could make is that it's a bit of a sausage fest so I'd throw the Courtney Barnett Three in there, possibly Peaness who are one of my favourites. Anyway, I really enjoyed it and looking forward to British Jazz Rock and if you're ever seeing a band at The Hare and Hounds let me know and we can have a chat over a pint!
@davidliddell67105 ай бұрын
When I was a kid in Toronto way back in the good ole days we listened to Rush,of course, but also Triumph, a power trio. I'd say their first album is proggy, check out Blinding Light Show. Wouldn't really expect them to be on anybody's list except old Canuck heads.
@karenjackie175 ай бұрын
I was going to comment about Triumph - I'm such a mega fan. I think they are WAY BETTER than Rush. That Rik Emmett is just OMG on so many levels. They are talented fun and inspirational. Who's Triumph you say? Find their performance at the 1983 Us Festival and you'll understand.
@rayr43205 ай бұрын
I guessed #3, im so special. Strong songwriting, many fine records. Can still listen to the music today.
@massimofalcinelli50435 ай бұрын
NoMeansNo..the punk-version of RUSH!!
@thespacealienssmogandgrog42835 ай бұрын
Thanks for the rec. I wondered how could a punk band be like Rush because the whole point of punk is to not give a crap about playing well but you have a point with the comparison.
@thespacealienssmogandgrog42835 ай бұрын
Of course Rush songs like Anthem and Bastille Day already had some proto punk in their DNA.