1971 War: Why Did East Pakistan Start To Hate West Pakistan? Part 1 Ft. Dr.Hassan Bokhari | EP202

[@rishabhshukla-n7u]

This is what they teach in Pakistan studies. 😂😂

[@donjames7647]

Noting Compared to how Indians Hindus brainwash there children against pakistan and Muslims . Every child in India is brainwashed in schools against pakistan

[@youknow6968]

What do they teach you?

[@shashwattripathi4559]

​@@youknow6968 history, civics, geography, science, maths, multiple languages, computer science, environmental education, physical education, commerce, economics and political sciences

[@youknow6968]

@@shashwattripathi4559 you've mentioned subject matters, those are taught across the world, including in Pakistan. You're unable to differentiate the difference between my request, and your reply, tells me a lot about the fantasies you're taught in India, it's not a good sign. My statement was in regards to someone else's statement. I was looking for specifics, regarding the subject matter on hand. An intelligent contribution is really helpful in having a constructive discussion.

[@shashwattripathi4559]

@@youknow6968 let me differentiate the difference for you. The original comment mentioned Pakistan studies, which is the subject and not the subject matter. It is a replacement of what is history and civics in your country. The original comment didn't mention a particular war, or a chapter in your books. If, it had, I would have told you that we are taught Mauryan civilization, Gupta civilization, Slave dynasties, bronze age, fundamental rights, local governance systems etc. I hope this was useful. For more details you can Google CBSE curriculum and you will find everything that we are taught in schools.

[@Mukherjee68]

His talent “LIES” in FICTION

[@manoharsinghdhami]

He's a well read person? Hindu Muslim Hindu Muslim Hindu Muslim ..... Hindu Muslim That's crux of his study.

[@youknow6968]

Indian living under a Hindu government, casting judgement. Ohhh irony 😂😂😂😂

[@hadisworld2894]

@manoharsinghdhami That what Narendra Modi did in 2002 Gujarat riots, and doing now at large as PM of India. HINDU MUSLIM HINDU MUSLIM

[@manoharsinghdhami]

It's a shame for you to have a PhD scholar Guest like him. He's basically a moulavi.Good luck to you.

[@AjitJoshi686]

He is India watcher. He runs essentially blog called SAT South Asia Times which is full of India focused content. Why is he watching us one needs to be wary.

[@rahulborkar4881]

Ye sahi cartoon hai jo man me aa rha hai bakte ja rha hai😅😅😅😅

[@M5a5n4i77k]

He's Talking about Bankim Chandra's book ANANDMATH and cant even Fully know the meaning of it and doing some whatsapp university graduate chap talking

[@ayushkumar3645]

So called intellectual😂. Isse zyada Hindu- Musalman to maulana bhi nahi karte honge.

[@lsmdarealjatt]

Bhai jo bhi hai, yeh gandh hmaare me se nikal gya. Ek gila hai, yeh humara Punjab lai gye, enko bangal de diya jaata acha. Atleast, humara silk route bach jaata

[@Critic224]

Bhai ! Humare Bharat ke Maulana ko aisa na boliye! Dekhiye! Kaise Maulana nadwi , humesha Bharat ki haq ki bat karte rahe hain! Unko to BJP RSS ke log tak deshbhakt mante hain ! Haan! Aap Pakistani Maulanas ke bare me ye keh sakte hain

[@arpanahuja]

I have heard lot of Pakistani podcasters are funded by ISI. They are wasting their money on these jokers.

[@tilakmahto8179]

Thought behind things, Pakistan Pivot

[@hadisworld2894]

...and you open minded, liberal, civilized and through human being is watching and listening and replying him as a duty.

[@Godhuli59]

Bengali comes from Sanskrit when was it ever Islamic?

[@aashaykadu6549]

Avg Pakistani mindset to think every arabic script language is muslim and devnagri script language is hindu😂

[@ShahRaj-se2fw]

PAKISTAN SHOULD ABANDON URDU AND ADOPT CLASSICAL ARABIC AS STATE LANGUAGE 🎉😂

[@JitendraSingh-nr2cl]

Bhai asaa thinker or intellectual ka wajaa sa pakistan ka yhaa halat hai I don't blame the man he is the product of his nation

[@Asfandyar_]

Your name jitrenda Singh. That's says a lot.

[@prajjwalpradyot]

Basically, he said everything was related to the Hindu

[@harshvardhan3044]

When topic is hindu vs muslim🏋️‍♂️🏋️‍♂️ When topic is East pakistan vs West pakistan🃏🃏 Joker for a reason😁😁

[@rajupaswan476]

Vande matram is the national song of india and it means Mother I bow down to you. Muslims don't want to bow down is ok no one force them here to chant this in India but Anandamath was never Anti-Islam but a protest against then Muslim ruler who for his benefit was acting against the interest of common men and the British. If you talk from Pakistanis perspective then it's cool we can understand and what the hell is baniya? The things your guest is talking about the rise of Indian middle class was not only baniya but many others too like Marwaris, and Kharis in the north, the Chettiars and Komatis in south India; the Jains, Sindhis, and Parsis, and the Bohras, Memons, and Khojas in western India. They all belonged to those middle class who used to do trades and rose drastically..

[@xzx255]

Anandamath was written on the backdrop of sannyasi and fakir mutiny of Bengal . Yeah , Bankimchandra Chattopadhyay didn't like the Muslim invaders but why it is so surprising 🤔 Most of Pakistani ans Bangladeshi Muslims were Buddhist at the time of Muslim invasion- they were brutally tortured, murdered and raped . As for us , Indian Hindus, we didn't bend to this and remain what we are always.

[@rajupaswan476]

@@xzx255 there's difference between anti muslim invaders and anti Islam. Yes I agree he was against Muslim rulers or you can say invaders and most of the pakis were Hindus too mainly from lower caste who had no access in temples due to casteism and that was the time Sufism came to India and gave those peoples a place to worship and many peoples accepted Islam because of that. Torture, rape and murder was also the main reason why they became muslims. Being a hindu i am proud of my ancestors who never get lured by Sufism despite being belongs to lower caste lol..

[@mahboobkhan3710]

​@@xzx255v wrongful and lower thinking.

[@Nitish.Singhal]

According to his thesis all problem is Hindu... In every line he says hi du atleast 2 times😂😂 No wonder...he is a pakistani intellectual 😂😂

[@hs6736]

10:30 , aligarh muslim university is made on land donated by hindus ,and money from hindus and muslims . Please know your facts.

[@AjitJoshi686]

He is lying. He said emotions against Urdu language were started by Hindus of East Pakistan. Gen Tikkas justification to kill them used during 1971. Incidentally he was saying United Independent Bengal under League leadership would have been secular . Do we take him seriously. 😂17:05

[@parichaytyagi5471]

Please stop analysing India and get your facts right. The British took over India from Maratha Empire. Aurangzeb died in 1707. Maratha' fought 3 wars with the British. The British lost the 1st war and then won the 2nd and 3rd. The British then fought 3 wars with Sikh Empire. 1707 and 1857 mein 150 saal ka Gap hai. Does anyone talk about these 150 years

[@mangalapallichaitanya621]

Their ignorance is our strength

[@ajaygmaharaj]

Dude , I am Unsubscribing , I thought you are some serious guy who wants to talk something sensible and put Pakistan on right path of development and prosperity,,, But your choice of guests in past few episodes is showing that your fever of narrating right story is gone and now you have joined the bandwagon of Zaid Hamid Saab & Hamid Gul , 🙏🏼

[@ayushkumar3645]

Please restrain your propaganda. It is massively faulty , in terms of facts and narrative.

[@hadisworld2894]

The ratio of Indian propaganda is seven time larger than Pakistan Indian propaganda like Israel's covering US & UK.

[@hadisworld2894]

I agree, he maybe not 100% correct and/or poorly narrated, but facts are facts (You have similar counter facts and narratives).. The fact is in conflicts, one can't say that I'm 100% innocent and the opponent is 100% wrong. We see conflicts as a nationalist (highly porpoised views) not as Human. even human are not completely unbiased. No doubt India is bigger power than Pakistan, obviously its narrative is large and loud as well specially when siting in the lap of US against China similarly when Pakistan were, till 1990's (against USSR), at times India's facts and narrative was weak (whether right or wrong).

[@ayushkumar3645]

@@hadisworld2894 Not talking about narrative but facts. Wrong facts , one sided view. If propaganda is what they wanted, they could have uploaded a pdf file of Pakistan Studies book. 😆

[@newguyat77]

What a load of crap within first 10 minutes 😂😂😂

[@pro-democracy2028]

He has a PhD in Pakistani Studies from Harvard Madrasa which is an Ivy League school near Rawalpindi 😀. I have heard that Pakistani army has been trying to rewrite the history of 1971 war for obvious reason. This looks like a comical effort in that direction. Those who don't learn from history are condemned to repeat it. That is what we are witnessing in Pakistan today - a rhyming of history.

[@12dhruvpatel]

Next level delusion

[@pravin9524]

Searching for logic in the whole video 😂

[@randmht9976]

Hindus apne liya accha ker rha tha to usse muslims kese oppress ho rhe the ?

[@shantanudasgupta7935]

This is the question from 1947

[@vickboss6751]

@@shantanudasgupta7935 muslims have shame that nothing big like inventions, nobel physists, economic model of world etc. have come from them. to avoid shame they employ religion card everywhere . muhammad is to blame who said interest is haram(facts is interest is time value of money)

[@SD-kd4fc]

Literally Pro Max Lal Topi Never thought Pakistan could produce another Zaid Hamid hut this guest topped him

[@shubhang5]

Deluded and biased. From an Indian perspective.

[@sanamir160]

93000🤡🪖

[@Madhurima_NYC]

Another very revered poet was Nazrul Islam…. Bengalis worship his words till date… দুখু মিয়া … we can’t even imagine he had asked for a separate country… not possible…

[@AjitJoshi686]

You have a residual emotions left of united India like some Bangladeshi people have residual Hinduism. But if they as country were liberal Hindus would have been 20% now like 1947. There will exceptions but as a class of people there true colours were always visible.

[@Madhurima_NYC]

@@AjitJoshi686 you are not talking about relevant context and you know nothing about Nazrul and I suspect you have not followed the podcast. How is it related to what shave posted?

[@WaqarDKI]

We usually forget British colonist's backing behind partition. Without British support, partition was not possible. So real founder of Pakistan is Mountbatten

[@artisticsoulful]

Is this guy called an " intellectual guy " in Pakistan? God save ur country

[@Takecare55]

Hame maaloom hai jannat ki Haqeeqat lekin.... Dil ko khush rakhne ko Ghalib ye khayal achha hai.

[@notorious25796]

All those who were roasting him, where are those , after the fall of Bangladesh 2024!!! Hattsoff bro

[@manoharsinghdhami]

Iqbal ki ideology A failed state. Congratulations

[@sanamir160]

Inshaallah Balochistan juldi azad hoga 😊😊

[@Kashi-ti5zo]

Very bad thoughts

[@panikchand]

Good full support from India

[@shaukatmuhammad2016]

Pakistan ko tornain wala burbad ho, charon akayaan aapis mein khush han.

[@uzmamunawar3262]

مرے انڈیا

[@donjames7647]

Inshallah Khalistan , kashmir and Gujrat , Calcutta will become free first

[@nissarguru-xg1wx]

You guys started this partition game now why weep if you too got partitioned and will continue to get partitioned further.

[@vickboss6751]

Exactly

[@uzmamunawar3262]

Khalistan will appear soon in world map , dont worry

[@vickboss6751]

@@uzmamunawar3262 pakhtoonistan , sindhudesh aur baloch desh is definitely on card.

[@intellectualthinker2669]

​@@uzmamunawar3262 bro please be real indian Punjabi stars are bigger than pakistani stars and you don't even gave basic rights and facilities to Baluchistan and pakhtoon region

[@gurdeep3982]

The body language of the interviewer says it all 😂

[@vinodkhanduri2214]

The truth is that Pakistan has not learnt anything from history , what they did with Bengal are doing with baloch and pastun .it is because wrong history is taught in worst form.such intellectuality certainly deserve noble prize.

[@Salman-pw4hl]

Sad moment for Pak 😢

[@mr___swag925]

Pakistani so-called talented,intelligent and intellectual person 😅😅😅 Jo.. ki.. pak study padhke banahe.....😂😂😂

[@rajneeshtiwari5459]

I switched off within first 10mins.

[@youknow6968]

This was a beautiful discussion, based on raw facts, and sound reasoning. Very informative, and enjoyable.

[@Madhurima_NYC]

Rabindra Nath was anything but a Hindu Nationalist. You know nothing about him. Hindu nationalism to a certain extent was inspired by Ramkrishna Mission and related people but Rabindra Nath? Naaah! Please educate yourself. Another thing, many Muslims strayed further from power as they did not participate in the Bengal/India renaissance which was brought upon mostly by English/ West. Renaissance was a reason why Hindu Indians rose faster than the Muslims who refused Western education. It’s complicated I understand but it is not so linear.

[@santoshagarkar6760]

Thanx Jinnah for created Pakistan otherwise this types of foolish intlectuals might b destroyed india

[@pspsdan]

Seikh Mujib's point of view can be traced from his speeches. He used to quote Tagore. His mindset might have shaped by the literary and cultural movements of Bengal. Overwhelming theme of such movement was based on liberalism and humanism (Bengal Renaissance). One example can be adoption of secularism as core principle of Awami League. It was his effort that resulted in changing Awami Muslim League to Awami League.

[@ajaygmaharaj]

HOW DOES IT WORK ,, Certainly NOT BY FALSIFYING TRUTH , honey 😂

[@AjitJoshi686]

Whatever he says about injustice in East Pakistan same is done to Baloch and Pashtun people

[@fakharkhandaha3439]

Why Indians are so angry about this 😅😅😅, Partition of India was on the basis of Two Nation theory , so it was all about Hindu Vs Muslims. No one can ignore it

[@bhanumungali6000]

Very disappointing Guest, His knowledge and expression are both of the street. I’m sorry to use this kind of language but this is the only recourse. His discourse lacks depth, objectivity and established facts. His cherry-picking of certain names and historical events to feed an ideological stand is counterproductive and dangerous for young Pakistani minds. He’s deadly towards a society where books are not read, genuine and objective discussions are not held and his sort are the only source of knowledge. You must invite another guest with a contrarian (factual) point of view. I wish your channel success 🎉

[@uzmamunawar3262]

And i fear about ur head which lacks a brain

[@vinodkhanduri2214]

You can imagine what they teach in school in Pakistan. No surprise what Pakistan is today.

[@qaiser4u007]

Before watching the part two have to watch again part 1

[@shivangtomar2298]

Dumb man calling Indian revolutionaries a terrorist

[@PCore007]

Truth detector machines undergo this man's test.

[@aftabahmed4417]

Very nice good 🇮🇳 👍 👌

[@rajeevdatta8881]

Lal topi Zaid Hamid ka bhai lagta hai yeh "INTELLECTUAL" kehdi university toe padheya hai, to be avoided

[@captainisfand6655]

Very learned personally.

[@ravikumarvaranasi4698]

He is so good with his facts. Well done. Happy to watch someone talked and showed the real picture of bengal partition.

[@narayandutt_7]

Bhai kis class me pdhai chhodi thi tumne?

[@ravikumarvaranasi4698]

@@narayandutt_7 sorry sir, I did not get your comment. However, I am assuming you are agreeing with me. Thanks. People like him should expose more of Indian oppression towards Kashmiri too. Hope, Kashmiri gets their rights.

[@veer_Gurjar4]

😂😂😂😂😂pig don't hide behind Hindu name 😂😂😂​@@ravikumarvaranasi4698

[@balrajsingh6383]

Esi history ne hi pure bhikaristan ko zahil bnake raha hai 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@MeenaGujjar-xb4th]

He is a redicalised molvi not a historian and PhD scholar. It's shows level of pakistani education system that it's producing not intellectual person but it's producing molvi.

[@kannankarthik2009]

This individual is factually incorrect. Kindly invite guests based on their merit, and not on their prophecy to put Hindu muslim on every equation where thekr knowledge is from social media , rather than hard hitting litrature .

[@uzmamunawar3262]

And whats ur source of knowledge 😅? Crap 😢

[@ashish2256]

Isne history padhi knha se h, matlab kuch bhi, iske novel k sarikhe iski history knowledge bhi fictional h

[@harshasai8040]

Hated filled one sided propaganda

[@Poison_Top]

acha pakistan ban gya but isme 98% musalman kyun piss raha 75 saal se kyunke pak mein to na hindu power mein hai na teacher hai.. sindhi manush kya hai…? bloch or pashtoons ko konsa hindu study karvata… jab koi apni problem ko real dekhne ki jagah kisi dusre pe daal ke time pass karta uska barbaad hona teh hota or acha hai ke aap ayse hi kisi ko blame karte raho kyunke ayse problem to apni jagah rahegi or badi hoti jayegi or khud b khud kaam kar jayegi

[@tradingjunction5003]

For the channel admin: why your all experts are jokers

[@imnoone2567]

I really appreciate apecially ending highlights and waiting for the next epiaode as well

[@user-rs1dw6gy6k]

Great job Dr Hassan and team . I c lot of ppl here on fire 🔥 and their comments are living proof of the history U told is 100% correct.

[@pavanthorat1595]

Wtf did I just watch How can a person have this much wrong information, he is incorrect in all areas It's like listening to some old vining women 😂😂😂

[@anilkumar-dn6rq]

Bhai ye laal topi Gen 2 kaha se utha ke laye ho? Ye intellectual ka level hai pakistan me? No doubt ye haal hai pakistan ka ki aaj wo ek bhikhari mulk ban ke rah gaya hai

[@shahinareshvlogs2967]

HAAAA KUCH BHI BOL RHA H JO MU ME AAYA BOLTA CHLA JA RHA H BHAI HISTARY ACHHE SE STUDY KR KE AAA🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆

[@Rohit17426______]

93,000🤡 YAAD HAIN

[@rakeshbhartipangotra8224]

what a cartoon !

[@md.mahbuburrahman1113]

Best Episode ❤ Love from Bangladesh ❤.

[@Godhuli59]

He is SO SO TERRIBLE. It’s laughable

[@AjitJoshi686]

Bhutto would have wanted to rule entire India if possible. 53:19

[@navneetbugalia4835]

Start ke 5 minutes me hi Hindu- Muslim lol

[@developmentwithtariq]

zabardast sir Hassan

[@India-hc2hu]

Ab baluchistan , pakhtunistan & tahriq e taliban par bhi study karo . Hindu muslim ko angrejo ne ladaaya , hindu muslim sath sath rahte the .

[@lavnagar5085]

Bruh do some research first

[@vickboss6751]

Bias and bigotry in his research and analysis. I can point 20 factual errors in first 10 minutes of crap. Eg. Hindus not as a whole but learnered class was not comfortable with Bihar and odisha clubbed together. They were Bengali like muslims of bengal. They had families everywhere in bengal (Eg. Tagore was from east bengal) So they faught against British ploy to divide bengal on sectarian line. This madarsha chhap dump is vomiting nonsense 😂😂😂😂

[@aashaykadu6549]

A Pakistani cannot comprehend the fact that a person's cultural identity is stronger than their religious one...if they did then they automatically will become antinationals

[@Poison_Top]

is bande ne 1% real history byan nahi kari ulta isne apni alag history bnayi hai jisko iske alava aaj tak kisi ne nahi bola.. log future badalne ka kaam karte hai but jo apni history badalne ki koshish karta hai uska future 100% barbaad hota hai or aaj yhi result nazar aa raha pakistan ko dekhne se

[@arqamsaleem]

Enlightening conversation. I really appreciate both of you, especially MR. Hassan for sharing the truth with logic and evidence.

[@ashutoshkumar8052]

If this is the situation of so called “intellectual and researcher”, only god can save that country. Everything he says is biased and based on his religious identity not on facts.

[@Eric_lee610]

You lost just accept it, I just come here to dislike the videos.

[@gauravchaturvedi971]

Bhai tu baat baat me hindu musalman kar raha hain ... Isiliye tum sab devloped nahi kar pa rahe ho . Aur kabhi nahi kar paoge😂

[@mukhtarbinahamed7740]

Urdu Mafia se Pakistan ko bacha lo

[@YOUTUBE_AMERICA]

Today bengal is bigger than islamic Pakistan

[@sujaykonar216]

Isko pakder ke puch anandamuth me kaha likha Hai, ke musalman to hotiee bohot bura Hai.yahe Hai Pakistani intalactue. Kuch nahi padta Hai,u tube ultra pulta bolne lagte Hai.

[@atul9734]

His Bengal history starts from Muslims 😂

[@mishradev7244]

😂😂😂 ye pakistan ke educated log h shi hua tumhe alg desh de diya gya

[@md.mahbuburrahman1113]

We Bangladeshi wants reunification of Pakistan Again..... We wants our Muslim Brothers should reunify again and built a strong country again.

[@jijijijijjjiijijijjjjj]

নিজের মা কে পাকিস্তানের বেশ্যালয়ে ছেড়ে আয়।

[@nicepankajsaini]

Intellectual bankruptcy

[@mukhtarbinahamed7740]

Again propoganda by Pakistan.

[@imnoone2567]

For all shitty logics from india if you carefully listen till end you will realize he is actually giving references from different authors plus he mentioned and condemned the violance done by all whether its pak army , sheikh mujeeb or india

[@Dontmindplease111]

12 of 100= 1%… maths ka class eve 5 baje

[@adilmumtaz6975]

Part 2?

[@AshirbadBEHERA-cp2zy]

operation Trident ke bare me to kuchh kaho 😂😂😂😂😂😂 karachi 🔥

[@zaroonaz]

Pakistan studies walon ko mat lao bhai

[@fakharkhandaha3439]

In comments no one is talking with facts and figures but complete nonsense

[@AmitKumar-xn1zo]

Guest knowledge is very poor.He has only issues with Hindu, if it is true then Why pakistan is not grown. Why he played as setilite country of western country and now china. He has no idea or clue....

[@stdew07]

Kitna jhoot bologe bhai 😂😂😂

[@amitshenvi763]

Master in Pakistan studies