The Traitors Season 1 Player Ranking

[@VereditoRainbow1012]

I'm so glad Cirie won, I wanted that for so long, and she really played hands down the best game. One of the most dominant games ever since she got 0 votes and people never really suspected her.

[@sibais]

She got zero votes?? 😮

[@VereditoRainbow1012]

@@sibais YESS, people suspected her but not that much, she was never targeted or voted.

[@sibais]

@@VereditoRainbow1012 Fkn ICONIC

[@themasksamonji8606]

WELL she was suspected until the dum-dums (faithful I mean) think a woman could not be a traitor at all in the game. and that's what trip all of them up.

[@will9594]

I dont think its fair to rate quentin and andie so high when theyre the sole reasons why the faithfuls lost

[@harrisonlol5406]

I personally believe Stephanie played the best faithful game. The fact that Andie and Quentin never suspected Cirie is pretty ridiculous to me. I understand them not fully believing she was a traitor but to not even question it just confuses me. If Steph made it to the end, she would’ve at least considered Cirie being a traitor and would’ve had a better shot at winning for the faithfuls than anyone else

[@dangolden8020]

There is NO CHANCE that Andie and Quentin should be this high, if anything they need to be near the very bottom. The only reason they were kept around for so long was because their reads were sooo atrocious, and they clearly lacked any strategic mind for the game. Even though they both technically reach the end, I don't think either of them stood any chance of winning because of how blinded they were by their personal connections. Cirie kept them around because she knew she had them wrapped around her finger, which isn't a testament to their gameplay. They were never voting her out in any scenario. Quentin voted wrong literally EVERY SINGLE VOTE, and Andie was just, well...... a really really Awful player (with the cherry on top being the final fire-pit scene lmao)

[@frida.7831]

I agree but between the two, Quentin was much much worst.

[@xaviern5746]

Not to mention how annoying he is for thinking he is so intuitive

[@Prior2Popular]

100% You’d have to be delusional to think either Andie or Quentin were even AVERAGE at this game! If they were threats, the traitors would have taken them out before the end.

[@tiaradarling3441]

Kate was so iconic. Makes it to 5th place when people accused her from the start. She knew she wasn’t getting the money so why put effort into a challenge that you’re not benefiting from. The paper thing wasn’t as big as people made it out to be, she explained and people dropped it. I would start giving up too if people accused me every week, left me out of the cliches and having to defend myself every week. Poor lass couldn’t catch a break.

[@ingodube4519]

I can see the argument for Stephanie being number 3 because She almost figured all the traitors and She had Cirie trying to avoid her murdering. The biggest flaw in her game was the fact that she was so blinded that Kate was a traitor. I would've put Quentin in the same spot as Kate because he had really poor reads throughout the entire game. Andie was fine but I think she had the same flaw as Anjelica for being very emotional and struggling to make strategic decisions at points. Cirie obviously played the most impressive game and It is really perplexing how consistent she is on every single game she plays. This is the fourth game she makes all to way to the final episode, It's insane.

[@Furrito_272]

This was the first one I’ve seen her on, what other shows+seasons has she been on? She was my favorite the whole season (minus Rachel, I loved her outfits and hair lol)

[@actuallyalec]

@@Furrito_272 She’s played Survivor seasons 12, 16, 20, and 34!

[@VereditoRainbow1012]

I'm just shocked Andie and Quentin couldn't do math for their lives. 3 traitors with 2 gone, and they voted to end the game. Then Arie quits and says he was recruited, which means that there's still one left, and they vote to end AGAIN, and are shocked they lost LMAO.

[@Furrito_272]

I know, I was shouting “DO THE &*$#&@$ MATH!! DO THE $*#&@%& MATH!!” And now I think that they both failed every math class that they took

[@VereditoRainbow1012]

@@Furrito_272 I was just laughing the whole time, bunch of dumb asses

[@kylepedley7328]

To be fair, they are told at the start that there are between 2 and 5 traitors. With Cody and Christian gone, and Arie saying he was recruited, they may have believed that there was only 2 at the start, seeing as they never seemed to even entertain the idea that Cirie could be a Traitor.

[@GK-ob1ni]

​​@@kylepedley7328that's a good point, but I still wonder why it never crossed their mind that there might have been a female traitor. It seems unlikely that the show would have chosen only male traitors (or only females).

[@themasksamonji8606]

@@GK-ob1ni because none of them believed that a woman could be a traitor. but there were times they suspected but they just did not look at it deeper.

[@kylepedley7328]

Quentin should be much lower on this list… his reads and theories were *always* off the mark, sometimes wildly, and that he was willing to end the game at FOUR players left and only 2 traitors ejected, is insane. Andie was equally clueless most of the time, but they fair the tiniest bit better because of their late-game suspicion of Christian. Speaking of whom, he belongs at number 21. He was terrible as a traitor and just got lucky that the bigger personality clashes took so much of the spotlight and heat away from him. He’d have been toast early on in the UK or AUS versions.

[@jasmine1stan857]

I have zero idea why Quentin is that high, he is in my opinion one of the worst strategic players of any show I’ve ever seen

[@SurvivorGumball]

I don’t blame you. I think what it came down to was how close they were to winning. While Steph and Rachel were better strategic players, their actions painted a target on their back to where they were taken out. Quentin wasn’t targeted as much and was at least closer to winning the game, even tho he makes the wrong decision. But I can see the merit for rewarding people like Steph over Quentin.

[@jasmine1stan857]

@@SurvivorGumball I get that but still personally I wouldn’t put too much stress on placement purely. Dude was so bad at the game he didn’t even have a chance, that’s the main reason why he makes it as far as he does

[@willbontrager6209]

Quentin and Andi are the dumbest people alive. I doubt they'd even get the concept of Connect Four let alone any strategy game.

[@jman0922able]

feel like these rankings are more based on placement rather than how good of a player they were

[@duncan3932]

Quentin gave Meryl a run for her money in terms of being totally wrong about everything, lovely guy but really poor at gameplay

[@MicahsMindset]

Quinton should be lower imo his reads were atrocious

[@nadavharari5125]

Quentin should be lower. At least below Steph and possibly below Cody. He literally doesn't have a single good read on the game

[@4Tom4lepus4]

I was thinking the same thing while watching the show. He was so confident and yet he was literally one of the most wrong players throughout the game. It was kinda hilarious.

[@LiveAndLetLivia]

Love your analysis-- this was fun to listen to. Cirie played a masterful game and it was a really satisfying season because of her. I would have suspected her right away, and I'm shocked more people did not, especially given that so many of them have been on reality tv before. If it were me, I would immediately assume that the producers brought Cirie on to be a traitor rather than a faithful, because who would really care or enjoy her winning a prize with 4 other people at the end, if she made it that far? The audience would want to tune in, week after week, to see if she could take it ALL. I get players who were reality tv newbies not putting that together, but not those who have experience with producers deciding things. You know? Pretty baffling. 😂

[@Tony-mi2sf]

you should put Andy more behind because the faithful lost because of her, she literally sending all the faithful home...

[@elii5840]

I'll just say this out loud that, Kate deserved better. literally was used as a shield and NO ONE was on her side after Brandi left.

[@elii5840]

Also, Quentin and Andie DIDNT DO WELL on this season, literally accused the wrong person table by table as Steph carried them on her back

[@hectortorres5259]

I was soo confused when it was bottom 5 and Quentin and andie were not mentioned. They were the worst. Just manipulated the whole time which is how they got to the end. The normies were just outplayed the whole game. I mean Christian was begging to be outed most of the time and would not have gotten far if not for Cody and cirie. Quentin was soo wrong yet soo sure of himself. I rolled my eyes everytime he spoke. Andie was too obvious that he was a faithful and just coasted by because cirie knew she could manipulate him as well. I mean he had a chance to make a move with Kyle but still could not put two and two together. They made it to the end cuz they were some of the worst. I laughed hard when they just threw the green fire in after aries last ditch effort to out cirie and the look on andies face as she just snatched that money out of his hands. (Quentin with that same stupid look he had everytime a traitor was ousted since he was on the wrong side of the vote every time). They both deserved to lose and we’re bottom 5 players in the game.

[@hassimiqbal7474]

andie is a boy

[@hectortorres5259]

@@hassimiqbal7474 oh my B.

[@Nintendoshi]

Steph played so much better than Quentin and Andie. At least my opinion.

[@afonsomonteiro2003]

I understand why Quentin and Andie were placed so high but considering the game format is completely different from other reality tvs, I dont think longevity really equates to anything in the traitors, so I have to agree with the comments saying they should be lower. They're comparable to goats in survivor kinda hahaha, Cirie had them wrapped around her finger so she kept them over Steph, the more perceptive and better positioned faithful.

[@theggamer2824]

Finally it’s great to see Cirie be the Number 1 for a reality tv show gameshow season. Because usually She can rank high in survivor seasons but is always overshadowed by the winner of the season. Not this time she gets the Number 1 that she deserves.

[@krisvalderrama9043]

it's interesting that Stephenie did well in this game, considering she was an alternate and she almost turned down the participation to this show

[@castform5032]

Quentin annoyed me so much while I felt bad for andie I’m glad the faifhful lost because of Quentin alone also felt really bad for Kate but honestly she was hilarious throughout the season and my favourite of the season

[@Markleonard9524]

KATE IS AN ICON

[@MrBananaSamich]

Stephanie, cody, and christian should all be higher than andie and qwentin imo. Yes the ladder two each made one crucial mistake, but the only reason the other two went to the finale was because they had such a bad radar.

[@_myronspov]

Imagine if Rachel was a traitor, the tables would’ve turned IMO

[@ZavidWebster]

My New Rankings: 20. Bam 19. Geraldine 18. Michael 17. Reza 16. Brandi 15. Azra 14. Kyle 13. Ryan 12. Cody 11. Amanda 10. Quentin 9. Anjelica 8. Christian 7. Shelbe 6. Kate 5. Stephenie 4. Arie 3. Rachel 2. Andie 1. Cirie

[@buddy605]

Ridiculous to have Quentin and Andie even in the top 10

[@SB-jq8jj]

20. Michael 19. Reza 18. Geraldine 17. Azra 16. Ryan 15. Bam 14. Andie 13. Quinton 12. Rachel 11. Kate 10. Kyle 9. Anjelica 8. Amanda 7. Shelby 6. Cody 5. Brandy 4. Stephenie 3. Arie 2. Christian 1. Cirie

[@pookiesnackenburger]

Uk version is so much better

[@whatsthepurpose1420]

don't do Kate dirty like that..

[@frida.7831]

I would switch Andie with Stephanie and then take Quentin way lower, at least under Cody. Andie was at least well liked between the faithful but Quentin wasn't voted out because he was invisible. What friendships he got? Even though that leaves Christian at number 4, I think it needs to be considered how much the Traitors lead by Cirie dominated the season. Edit: thanks for the list!

[@xaviern5746]

rachel and steph could gave gone further had arie not been recruited as a traitor... that was so unfair on the faithful's part..

[@TedAllen2009]

Andie was a way better player than Quentin she voted Christian & Cody out Quentin didn’t

[@scottdylansinger]

I'd say Cirie (clear number one), Arie, Stephanie and Cody played the best games this season.

[@upvotecomment2110]

Not even close

[@jakesj]

Rachel should be lower just due to the fact that she gave everyone a lot of reasons to vote her out and then got defensive and down right rude when shit hit the fan. I didnt watch bb12 or bb13 so i cant speak on her perception there, but wow this was a terrible look for her lmao

[@avawarrior7937]

Christian, Quentin and Andie ranked too high