The truth of Partition of India

[@huachang126]

你的影片總能帶來反思，帶給觀眾不只是吃喝玩樂，還有多元文化、最實際最第一手的民眾街訪。 喜歡錫克教人人平等的理念，而各地政客為一己之利持續分化人民，真的令人必須時刻警惕。 非常喜歡與不同人的對話，謝謝你的努力！🙏 （還有真的好想買錫克教的劍喔，太美❤

[@joyon8693]

+1

[@anonymous-d5s]

pakistan and india both were declared as secular states at the time of independence but pakistan failed to maintain its secularism.

[@24BC_Channel]

第一次聽到錫克教，沒想到是這麼沉重的故事 但看到最後，那些參加慶典的群眾，還有說故事的大叔，臉上總是充滿充滿了希望 又覺得好像被治癒了😢😢😢

[@jimmytaiwan]

這位大叔導遊是我看過對工作跟生活非常有熱忱的 如果大家有機會去阿姆利澤 可以去住Madpackers Amritsar 真心推薦他！

[@KingerHammer]

谷歌地图上查到的好像是一家妇科诊所@@jimmytaiwan

[@lestrangek7214]

you will not see sikhs in pakistan even though it is same land of punjab but that's the beauty of INDIA unity in diversity

[@leolin7921]

Jimmy影片等級再次提升了~這次還加上動畫，太用心了 每集必追，期待多多上片~~

[@warpdrive9229]

Btw today India has as many muslims as Pakistan has at 14% of the population and growing. But cannot say the same about Pakistan where Hindus, Christians and Sikhs are dwindling in numbers. Pakistan is 97%-98% muslim and isn't secular like India.

[@jamie8812]

這期影片太不簡單了，花費心血製作，從內容到剪輯，品質完全提升，讓人感觸良深。 我本來對錫克教只是略有所聞，這次影片讓我有一定程度了解，聽聞哪段歷史遷移被仇恨所引起的悲劇，更讓人心情沉重，🥲 最後採訪年輕人跟大叔的言論，能感受到他們記取歷史用包容來提升自己，讓人心情為之一鬆。🥰

[@jimmytaiwan]

這集投入最多的心力一集阿

[@bigking2354]

Jimmy,很高興看到你帶我們四處去，還看字幕學習英文，謝謝你 香港觀眾報到😁

[@tracyho9746]

看得出Jimmy 真的很用心在做影片，很值得我們去思考🥰，在KZbin 眾多記錄影片中，很少在看到這種充滿深度的影片👍👍

[@yolanda-v5z]

錫克教这位大叔说的很赞，百姓大众都很友好，也不分信仰，不论是信仰伊斯兰，穆斯林，还是锡克教，都可以成为很好的朋友。战争暴动主要是政客引起的。感谢Jimmy，瘦弱年轻的小伙子，分享给大家这么多珍贵的影像。巴基斯坦和印度本来是一家，放眼看去，世界上很多这样的邻国。想到一句诗”本是同根生，相煎何太急“。愿世界和平，每个人都能幸福生活。

[@yiou8120]

本是同根生相煎何太急用得不太贴切，一方面认为同根生而已，另一方面认为是异根生。PS，巴基斯坦和印度真不是同一国。英属印度包括了尼泊尔，巴基斯坦，孟加拉，缅甸。

[@rishikabhardwaj8768]

You know nothing about indian subcontinent. A lot of Pakistani ethnicity is same as indian ethinicity like punjabis, sindhis,muhajirs,pathans. Even language of Pakistan urdu is indian origin language. India still has 3rd largest muslims ​in the world.@@yiou8120

[@游雅雯-b1i]

沒有過多的語言可以形容，看完真的很感慨

[@syshih604]

謝謝！

[@jimmytaiwan]

謝謝您的鼓勵❤

[@torrespit666]

會拍～屌！

[@jimmytaiwan]

OMG 我的偶像也來留言了~ Thanks Torres, you are one of the best content creators I look up to.

[@ShinYiApple]

好沈重的影片，也發人省思🥹也是第一次認真去了解這個議題，太謝謝你的旅行，跟分享！ 晚上點開了你頻道的影片之後就一部一部看下去，每部內容都好豐富，畫面也都好好！已訂閱😍

[@jimmytaiwan]

感謝支持

[@yjchen707]

非常喜歡印度系列的影片❤

[@tannyguo4627]

真的很喜歡吉米的影片❤️

[@春花林-h2f]

有質感、有深度…支持你❤

[@alicepear]

Your videos are meaningful. I appreciate the efforts you put into them.

[@chueh1282]

你很多影片啟發了我未曾思考的事情 好讚!

[@WhoopiChong]

Namaste🙏🏻

[@jimmytaiwan]

感謝支持❤

[@user-xudaodazahui]

兄弟，拍的太棒了！喜欢！

[@minfengchen9998]

16:30 後面這一段講得太好了!!

[@torilovato9500]

What happened during partition was very gruesome, the details are horrifying especially if you’ll get to know plight of women. If one community wants to attack another community, they go for women first, it has been historically observed. During partition, people killed the women of their own family especially the unmarried daughters cause they wanted to protect their honour, honour of their family, cause the other side would have raped or killed the women of their family or would have forced them to convert and marry. And both the sides did this.

[@mickey275]

很棒的影片, 發人省思

[@Jklinda-h8e]

有沒有按＂讚＂？

[@鄧驊]

台灣跟大陸不也一樣嗎？願和平。

[@beautifulgirl3824]

世界和平❤

[@悠-k8m]

影片結尾的幾位講得很好 非常有感觸 影片很棒 !!

[@Stanley96437]

有料 今天剛看到已訂閱

[@許明輝-d2h]

希望人人平等世界和平🙏

[@Aajkuchtoofanikartehai.]

Our history taught us and we learned that muslims are only live for their religion not for the humanity. Peace 🙏🕊️

[@tai-yunyu2263]

謝謝故事分享。我在法國唸書，聽到印度同學說，父母不準他們跟木斯林人當朋友。你的影片讓我知道背景故事。

[@CometFire2010]

It's all about history.

[@rishikabhardwaj8768]

I'm indian and I've so many muslim friends.

[@Alphabetagamma738]

​@@rishikabhardwaj8768 Rishika sach me h kya muslim friends, kher jo bhi ho thoda dhyan rakhna bs that's all i can say!!

[@Zack-j4n]

感謝拍出世界的另一個角落發生的事~

[@harisadu8998]

Since you were in Amritsar and you are making a video about the partition, you really forgot to visit the Partition Museum there.

[@rosechou3257]

你的影片真的很好看

[@cay8922]

我的天！剪輯的真好！！

[@Wellbirthson]

Do some research about Meghalaya too another sister of the northeastern state of India I'm sure you'll love it❤

[@brian79412]

唉~~~人類的心態原本就很難掌握的了，所以伊斯蘭教和印度教與錫克教，他們也許從原始教宗那一代的傳教的精典上就出現紛爭了，各個宗教為了要維護自己的宗教是正確的，所以就要屠殺反對或企圖想毀滅他們宗教的人，導致原本上一秒鐘都是好朋友、好鄰居的，因為知道對方是屬於想毀滅各方宗教的人，所以忍痛也要將他們殺死，為了維護自己宗教的正義性吧!!當然這種狀態不只是發生在宗教立場上啦!!連那些政治人物也一樣，最知名應該是發生在中國或是俄羅斯吧!!反對自己政治立場的人，就默默被屠殺掉了，所以到底發生了什麼事情??讓數十萬人因此滅絕!!這也許問現在的人，他們也無法跟你說得明白吧!!但是現在的人，已經沒有以前的人一樣的仇恨心了，他們都知道我們都是生存在一顆星球上的，所以我們要互相和平，帶著愛你與愛我的心態生活著的了❤‍🩹❤‍🩹❤‍🩹

[@xiongliu3770]

这是一期值得深思的节目！

[@Bettywithpaul]

街訪內容太有震撼力！！好喜歡這類型影片內容繼續加油💪💪

[@latiahsu]

看完好難過，真的只因雙方政客的對立導致百姓受苦，全世界的政客很多都只剩一張嘴而已

[@ericwkm2008]

与 马来西亚 的政客 超像，为了 选票 ，分化各族，马来西亚 东海岸 的 两个 州 ： 吉兰丹、丁家奴 96% 慕斯林 人口，烂政客 为了 选票 ，每天 向他们 洗脑。 就如 影片里 所说的，只有 10% 坏的人 、极端的人，每个 族群 都有 这些人，但经过 烂政客 渲染 一些 议题，就会 非常危险，造成 大屠杀。 马来西亚人 感触最深，我们 有 锡克教、印度教、伊斯兰教、佛教、基督教，但 那 1% 的 慕斯林 最极端。 马来西亚人 看到 的，认同的，请加 +1 。谢谢。

[@pranjalprakash5431]

Nonsense. Pakistan sponsors terrorists in india

[@xiangzhang3052]

很棒的节目 我们都是人类 为什么要彼此相恨 只是有一个不好的政府 哇 印度朋友说的太好了

[@tivo3720]

The Bengal province of India, was also divided. On based on Islam. The muslim majority part of bengal became a separate country Bangladesh, and the Hindu majority Western sider became a new State of India, West Bengal. I'm from Bengal... Our ancestors fled from Bangladesh during partition bcz muslims attacked the non-Muslims. Its always the muslim who 1st attack others. They destroyed many temples in Bangladesh. Not every Muslims r bad, but who r bad they r extremely bad, I have many Muslim friends from my childhood. Bcz my mother says watch the nature of ur friends not who they r. The Bengal region is historically and culturally Hindu and Buddhist. Total Bengal civilization is developed by the Hindus and Buddhists. But during the muslim rule in India, most of the Bengali people have to convert in Islam. Force convertion. Even these days non muslims population is rapidly decreasing in Bangladesh and Pakistan.

[@MH-jf2gd]

Very true ! After all we are all human

[@chinmeilien]

I highly appreciate this content, Jimmy! I love how you captured the sentiment of this saddest history told by the old man who experienced the partition, but at the same time you offered hope by showing how positive the way young people think now! They are able to express their acceptance and tolerance for the differences among the religions despite the painful past. 🙏🏻🪷🙏🏻🫡

[@GOGOrichardchen]

和平真的是基層人們的共同心願

[@rockychen2231]

很棒的叙事方式和视角，加油

[@suryanshporwal7321]

6:16 你展示了錯誤的印度地圖。🇮🇳

[@user-xf3xk7hh7q]

这集的ending很感人。

[@micsz5459]

博主听印巴故事感动的落泪，格局一下子就上去了；感觉你是性情中人，其实大陆和台湾又何尝不是，国共内战死了多少人，多少亲人分隔两岸，又有多少感人的故事？希望未来两岸和平！看别人的故事之所以感人，可能是因为客观，但是看自己的故事可能就扯上政治更多的是主观了。希望你未来能到中国大陆走走看看，把客观真实的环境、社会、人文通过这个频道告诉宝岛人民和西方社会。特别是新疆西藏~~

[@haoweihu1255]

請問火車載滿屍體，是只說在火車上屠殺，還是把人殺了以後放到火車上，謝謝撥空看我的留言，期待大老解惑

[@chika4153]

Hindus and sikhs were being massacred in Pakistan so they were fleeing through train but were caught by pakistani and killed in train there is also a movie on this train to pakistan you can watch it

[@joyon8693]

世界上的每一条生命都是平等。 只因为个人利益 而故意制造摩擦挑拨离间，让无辜的生命 受苦受难 牺牲！包括动物也是。 希望大家能够 尊重爱护每一条生命！ 功德无量感恩

[@CC-tb8fm]

政府很糟糕， 但人民有智慧。

[@趙子宏-p4e]

台灣

[@skyesui1036]

你的影片質量真的好高❤

[@劉保羅-g6p]

聽到互相殘殺真的難過啊!

[@Jin-if5ns]

這部真的太棒了 希望演算法把你推上去

[@yonight6871]

Jimmy，看你影片很長時間了，發現你自從去了印度，就瘦了好多，看來沒吃好睡好。真的吃了不少的苦，你保重小身子。印度也沒必要呆太長時間，還可以去其他的國家轉轉。

[@jimmytaiwan]

謝謝關心😃

[@frankfrank7997]

人生很短~世界很大~把握當下~😃

[@jampadawa-u8v]

well come to Byalakuppe sera

[@snowqueen8076]

冤冤相報何時了

[@ericsluo1875]

Sikhs in India are 28 Millions not 2 Millions, just like you said 2% from Indian population 1.4 Billions x 2% = 28 Millions

[@iftikharhusain6286]

As a Pakistani Muslim I condemn the killing of innocent people

[@iftikharhusain6286]

Have you decided to visit Pakistan

[@ritisadhanjamatia7217]

you come to agartala

[@謝正聰]

宗教都教人要愛，但也因不同宗教殘殺最多人。

[@Dinn3030]

!!👍

[@jimmytaiwan]

Thanks❤

[@Oigzbdbzdh]

0:02 0:02

[@animeshsarkar8042]

Bro y r showing the wrong map of India

[@jamesyoung5611]

每个宗教都说自己是和平的，相互屠杀是真狠😶😶

[@浪客吟]

您好，我記得印度是禁止空拍機入境的，請問您是如何取得在印度的空拍許可呢? 感謝您的回答

[@chindian987]

It's only at the borders and airports.

[@浪客吟]

@@chindian987 I mean, how could you take a drone through airport customs or borders?

[@HaoHuang-t3x]

海关会要你给钱才可以进入

[@anonymous-zt9xw]

​​@@浪客吟just get permission from telecom department

[@tommylee6161]

影片最后的采访发人深省，两岸要和平。

[@binmoos2561]

锡克教人很讨厌自己的印度公民身份。

[@aravatgroup7280]

Another propaganda comes straight from the damned government! KZbinr needs to do more researches in this historical clash, don't ever interview and believe of what the Lala said. Do not address holy place epicenter. Learned to pronoun "Harmandir Sahib Gurudwara", "Dabar Sahib" before you go there. Sikh religion is one of the finest religion in the world, Punjabi Sikh's hospitality is superb kinda an exceptional compare to the rest.

[@jamesyoung5611]

印度人口的2%你确定是两百万？😅

[@jun6145]

2%=近3000萬。

[@andyyang1158]

說明一個道理，政客的嘴臉全世界各地都一樣~🙄

[@michaielyan6566]

印巴分歧的原因，絕非單純的種族宗教問題，而是政治力介入。反觀現今兩岸關係的矛盾，更不該 如此，因為我們同文同種宗教習慣完全一致，然而民進黨政府為了，而親美 反中，將戰火引入家園，則顯得更加無聊................。

[@bhupeshkumar2537]

To all foreigners let me clear Muslims demanded separate nation for themselves and they got Pakistan and east Pakistan (Bangladesh). Even after all this India allowed muslims to live inside India and given them every right.

[@WhoopiChong]

omg 難怪你出片要那麼久😅 還一直在等你的影片 原來因為你的片都是如此有質素的 😢😢 非常獨特 興別的旅遊vlog不同 也太有質感了，與人民的對話我也能感受其中 看得我想哭了！特別是最後那年青人的一番說話， 我們都是人類，為什麼一直要在分？😢😢😢😢🙏🏻 你也令我對人類改觀 相信善良一直在世上❤❤❤ 感謝你

[@joyon8693]

+1

[@OSAAMABEENLAGGIN]

你們認為自己是中國人還是台灣人？ 如果是的話，你們將來會不會成為中國的一部分。 如果不是為什麼

[@supergirlfromheaven8421]

China attack others countries beside it and then say they want peace 🕊️✌️ anyways their history is very mess up and weak .

[@harisadu8998]

It is very important to understand that every time the violence and killing started from the Pakistan side and the Hindus and Sikhs responded with killing in revenge. But who started it is important also. You can look it up easily. In Punjab, the violence started in March 1947 in Rawalpindi and Kahuta. But in Bengal the violence began in August 1946, known as Direct Action Day.

[@吳致廷-i2b]

感謝你努力的去當地採訪，讓我們看到就算是國際間仇恨的國家，但在底下的人民只是想要安穩的生活，誰也不願意要去傷害他人，就像我跟中國的朋友一樣，在遊戲裡面一起闖蕩歡笑，在現實裡卻有可能要兵戎相見，就如最後印度教跟錫客教的帥哥一樣，不要被利益所逼，要能和平共處，願世界和平，謝謝你Jimmy

[@jimmytaiwan]

謝謝支持❤

[@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz]

Actually it was never about sikhs vs muslim but muslims vs sikhs & hindus. I am from bengali refugee family 3rd gen 😢😢😢 my ppl were killed in today's Bangladesh/ that time known as east pakistan

[@xt3747]

I like India ❤

[@jerrylee7360]

你的影片質感真的很高，我身為觀眾，謝謝你帶給我不一樣的視野。

[@asirau7389]

謝謝您！非常的有感觸

[@林田麒]

就像是北韓跟南韓

[@KingerHammer]

如果一个台湾人在中国大街上随便问路人对台湾人看法，我敢说百分之一百都是和视频里一样的话，因为你看到了活生生的台湾个体在你面前，你是无法对这个活生生的个体产生仇恨的，但是在网络，在集体中，你就不是独立的个体了，你要让渡一部分意识成为集体意识的一部分，集体意识又被HEADQUARTER控制着，而HQ为了不让这个集体无所事事而散掉，就必须时刻提出一个明确的敌人来凝聚集体，这就是人类社会的本质。你很少见到个人对个人的民族性政治性仇杀，但民族政治性仇杀一旦发生，个人意志几乎就没有存在感了，所以我们一定要对集体力量庞大的实力时刻警惕，他们一旦做出行动，将对人类社会是毁灭性的伤害，俄乌战争开战前没什么人会相信欧洲会重燃战火，然而当战争开始后，一切都会卷入其中，讲道理也变得不那么重要了

[@jumpking2333]

如果一个大陆人在台湾大街上随便问路人对中国人看法，会怎样？好好想想是哪个政府在给人民灌输仇视的意识形态，在考虑自己应该说什么，不然就容易漏洞百出

[@TripuraTipperah]

Hey bro Do you know that when Tripura Kingdom joined India in 1949 , the Tripuri people(Tibeto-Burman) became minority in its own land due to India' partition ? Lakhs of hindu refugees flooded Tripura for which the Indigenous people lost all political economic administration power to the refugees because in democracy the majority rules

[@陳宥璁-i4n]

喜歡你的影片分享，有別於其他旅遊頻道，喜歡你融入當地的介紹方式，人人生而平等無貴賤之分。最後的年輕人與大叔的心得很有共鳴

[@Suman-hy7mu]

Use correct map of India You are travelling in India and not even using correct map.

[@kof6215]

兩國衝突的問題真的就想裏面的人說的，世界各地都正在發生 尤其我們的兩岸處境更是其中，希望我們的可以領悟到『好好相處』這樣的真諦。 這支影片帶來非常獨特的視角，讓我們理解更多在地人的思維。

[@Jklinda-h8e]

Jimmy長得很像苦苓，英文發音不錯，加油！我會讚美，也不會忘記按＂讃＂加油！

[@jungkueitung4707]

標體什麼印度最危險，到處軍管，十萬人屠殺，不少台灣人自助或跟團都去過阿姆利則，不要學許多視頻主用誇張悚動的標題來引人觀看

[@akashsahoo7376]

他制作了精美的视频，给人们带来了新的前景。像你这样的仇恨者是不会理解的。来自你的关于大屠杀的丰富内容，你忘记了天安门广场吗？印度并没有高度军事化

[@咕咕-e1v]

想了解錫克教人人平等的思想理念，人人也包括女人嗎？ 是否真正落實在生活中？

[@Ranjul_kumar]

In this country, what dictates more is your social culture n environment than religion. It depends upone where you live. One reason being the various influnces of various religions and ideologies on various places to varied degrees. Geography and environment also counds, and india happens to be strikingly diverse in these aspects.

[@angelo11111]

你的影片真的很讚! 感謝用心拍攝

[@-StarrysVlog]

I was so moved by this video, thank Jimmy for letting me know so many different cultures

[@joyon8693]

谢谢你分享你的收获！非常用心的视频！ 值得关注

[@Saarah-ol2yi]

Assalamu Alaikum🍀去年我也去到了Wagah Border, 不過我是在巴基斯坦那裡。多數人都是用著和平相處、不分宗教去看待，只是有心的政客，不這麼想。謝謝你的影片分享。

[@pranjalprakash5431]

Nonsense. Pakistan sponsors terrorists

[@蕭任任]

有新片可以看了耶

[@jimmytaiwan]

久等了

[@UngSenang-bs5qg]

印度-锡克 是一家亲, 中国 - 台湾也是一家亲

[@binmoos2561]

锡克教人很讨厌自己的印度公民身份。

[@harisadu8998]

In the partition of India, especially in Punjab, Muslims were displaced in the highest absolute number. Then Hindus and then Sikhs. However as a percentage of total population in Punjab, Hindus were displaced the most. 47% of Punjabi Hindus lived on the Pakistan side.

[@ggmagic6176]

能从你的视频里看到大家对于不同种族 不同信仰的人的认同 感觉非常欣慰 世界会变得更好