The view from India after allegations of killing in Canada -

[@vinoddas5674]

There is a strong history of Canada turning a blind eye to terrorist activity targeted at India, starting with the bombing of the Air India Kanishka flight that was the worst airplane attack till 9/11. Secondly, Canada has, in the name of free speech, permitted it's fringe Sikh citizens to put on display a float glorifying the assassination of an India Prime Minister. Thirdly, as recently as just before the G20, the same fringe elements were publicly issuing death threats to Indian diplomats and putting up public displays of their names and photographs; none of which even attracted a peep from the government. Fourth, Canada has ignored acting on criminals with red corner notices issued by Interpol. And now lawless Canada wants to lecture India about the rule of law!! No wonder Indians don't think much of Canada and Trudeau.

[@leevuong8843]

Don't forget that the mastermind behind the bombing of Flight 182 in 1985 was the same as behind Indian Minister Indira Gandhi's assassination in 1984. Talwinder Singh Parmar was on the list of terrorists that Indira Gandhi asked Pierre Elliot Trudeau to extradite while she visited Canada in 1982, which was refused. Canada as become Khanadastan by giving safe haven to Khalistani terrorists and gangsters.

[@danniemoore97]

we get called racists when we accuse a Middle Eastern person of terrorism.

[@axdvhm11]

Correction: Trudeau invited a convicted khalistani terrorist Atwal (convicted by Canada) to his event in India.

[@Kaafiristani]

And then forced then Canadian NSA to blame India.

[@haridasshenoy8334]

That's true.

[@BOG0690]

Not surprising

[@pontifixmax]

I'm a Canadian who visited India in 2018 for five months. I loved the country. When I departed, I felt like I left a piece of my heart there, so this deterioration in the Canada-India relationship saddens me greatly.

[@JS-rg7vo]

no one cares

[@pontifixmax]

@@JS-rg7vo you cared enough to reply.

[@drackus001]

​@@pontifixmaxnice one 😂

[@krsna302]

Atidi devo bhava. Vedic culture and philosophy are phenomenal. Thanks for your kind words regarding Bharat. If only Trudeau understands where India stands.

[@phabove7]

Welcome back whenever you want. Love from India.

[@Roaming1001]

This is the problem of some or many immigrants who became a Canadian, their loyalty is not with Canada. They use Canada to advance their political agendas from the country where they belong. So many cases of these could be heard in our community here in Canada and could be read in news.

[@brustar5152]

This is the inherent danger of welcoming all and sundrie from wherever.

[@nazirkabbani]

I would not let a bad apple from one group to tarnish the rest or lead to false conclusions about the group. There are bad apples among locals and immigrants.

[@nuckygulliver9607]

when a white person does some thing we let that person define all white people but when it's the other way around we lay flowers on sth street and say, 'why! No hard feelings. In fact we think anyone that is upset is a racist."@@nazirkabbani

[@nuckygulliver9607]

when immigrants start saying, "hey Trudeau/NDP! Stop being racist to white CHrsityans!" that's unlikely right?@@nazirkabbani

[@sinsunjai]

just 2 days ago a khalistani was killed in Winnipeg. His murder was claimed by gangster languishing in Indian jail. A day before that another Indian fugitive by name of Arshdeep Singh (arsh dala) had taken credit for murder of provincial lawmaker of opposition party. And what he did this with pride on Facebook because he is safe in lap of your turd. This thing is costing real lives in India. People are extremely bitter the way turd has behaved. It is for turd to stop this gangsters from playing Facebook Facebook from his land. But he won’t, because this people are in trucking business and major drug runner from South America to canada, and use the same money to fund politicians there. These people also control immigration channels, forcing kids to support their agenda. They are accused of forcing girls into prostitution, didn’t know of this till Indian agencies began releasing their info. Took it with grain of salt , but was surprised when heard prostitution being mentioned with regards to international students in Canadian parliament itself. Canada is behaving like an enemy, engaged in proxy war through khalistanis. This mindset is remnant of Cold War when India was seen as USSR ally. And all this hue and cry because the terrorist was US & Canadian asset like Osama once was! We don’t care. If Canada can send troops to Afghanistan, India can certainly eliminate few. Because accusations are exactly the same, Canadian soil is being used to sponsor killings of Indian citizens.

[@henrythe8912]

Majority of us of Indian descent doesnt support the Khalisthan movement in any form. So as majority of the Sikhs. All Sikhs are not Khalisthanis. This was quite evident in the so called "referendum" held by the Khalisthanis recently. Only 5000 out of 770,000 turned up. That tells you something.

[@anootoshsarkar686]

Well tell that to Dustbin Turdo, hope he understands 😂😂 LoL

[@kavitaandy9361]

Is Mr Turdo educated? Or just desperate for votes? If a beautiful country like Canada has a dunce for a leader - oh dear poor Canada. These criminal khalistanis are just a handful - how can he protect them unless he is being paid off by China? 🤔

[@ivan-to2zy]

After 2 months of investigating Canada determined India performed an assassination of a Canadian citizen on Canadian soil. Trudeau wouldnt be claiming this unless he had a solid case as it'd be political suicide. Also, the leader of the opposition is even in agreement with him on this. And they bloody never agree on anything. And India isn't even denying this, just being outraged. India had soooo many better ways to handle this.

[@biggpicture2930]

With minority targeting and discrimination intensifying, it hard to believe that the kukii and muslim doesn't want to have autonomy from the hindu nationalists. Similarly for the sikhs!

[@jeil5676]

Are you suggesting that sikhs which are not separatists are okay whith the terrorist actions of the indian government? This is what you're saying. Most of canada does not care about kalistan. You just cant go around assassinating people and think the west wont view you as savage barbarians.

[@KamalSingh-no2sg]

Likewise Canadian media is absolutely convinced that Indian agents are involved. Western Media has this insane habit of laughing at what the other side has to say.

[@bulthaosen1169]

@lif6737 well it's absurd that's why. Western intelligence has a track record of failing disastrously. Need I remind you about Iraq?

[@FronosElectronics]

@@bulthaosen1169And you are... russian?

[@bulthaosen1169]

@@FronosElectronics I am whatever you want me to be. It's not like you people care about evidence so what's the point?

[@bryansmith536]

​@bulthaosen1169 there's a major difference between USA government and Canada's. We don't have oil baron crusaders running the country.

[@JT.Pilgrim]

@@bulthaosen1169Canada was not part of that Iraq war because the evidence wasn’t conclusive. Learn your facts. There is evidence. Its an intercept call from your diplomat to your government. The evidence came from a 5 eyes ally and corroborated by first hand witness.

[@alexkool3511]

He was not Jamal who S arebia killed. He was wanted terrorist who is directly linked to 2 bomb blasts in India.

[@agnimitram340]

The thing is very few issues unite the parliament in India. Last time when Pakistan attacked us in 1999 the whole parliament was united against a common enemy. Surprisingly this issue has managed to do the same. Recently the Canadian government allowed the display of assassination of former PM Indira Gandhi in the name of free speech. As a free speech absolutist I was surprised how can violence be celebrated in the name of free speech. Nevertheless the current leader of opposition happens to be the grandson of Mrs. Gandhi. I am happy to see our politicians are united for something.

[@kzal421]

​​@@goldenera1461they would it seems Canadians are really blind by freedom of expression they defend terrorism, violence Now wonder JT is their PM

[@sarthaksharma7918]

@lif6737 does assassination of a country's prime minister comes under free speech and expression? We don't condone these pure and vicious acts of hatred and violence. People die because of your bigoted notion of free speech absolutism.

[@rahulmachra8386]

@@chase-warwickneither do canada have free speech trucker protest and anti vaccine protest had also free speech rights but they were dealt with iron fist even Quebec free movement moreover calling out for killing of hindus is not free speech

[@nuckygulliver9607]

Trudeau wanted this so he could get back at India insulting him. Canadians have to say no to Trudeau/NDP hate and division.

[@rohanjarande]

Open incitement to violence and ethno-nationalism (especially through funding & nurturing terrorism) is not protected under freedom of expression & free speech, in ANY country.

[@itachiofthesharingan67]

At some point soon the Canadian government will need to come up with something more than “trust us.”

[@ps-ti6zt]

Trust us 😂😂😂😂😂

[@setme4ree]

Theyre going to get us involved in a war. Trudeau isnt even in charge hes a puppet and he does as hes tomd

[@speakwithfacts1]

​@@shrikantkh2639ur talking about urself not the entire country

[@x56080]

​@@shrikantkh2639yes but at what cost???

[@anime.kingdom1]

​@@shrikantkh2639 it's not a huge amount of investment they invest, that could destroy our market recently even adani market decrease but still market rishing , but it's perfectly true' that' it's a Haven of terrorism, so it's 2nd Pakistan, which is rich is that what you are talking about!

[@shivamsinghnegi1192]

Why the Canadian are surprised on hearing that indian are fine with an operation on foreign soil....did Sriya, Afghanistan etc. Had the same reaction when Canadian did the same with their partner in crimes..... chill out . Ignore and celebrate it ... like you do when you perform such operations..for humanity's sake

[@pizzaiq]

False equivalency is the best way to fail at making an argument.

[@mohapatraism]

​@@pizzaiqlife of Indian citizens also matters. Nijaar like terrorist carrying out operations in india from Canada is expected to be tolerated by india. Inspire of repeated requests no action was taken by Canada and extradition requests were denied. Why Canada takes in people from india having criminal back grounds on fake passports?

[@yashsingh0010]

​@@pizzaiqWhy false equivalency, both killers hiding in a country unwilling to co-operate. The only difference is that one is done by white man and other is not.

[@vineetsansi]

Nijjar's video's are out with Ak47 & other automatic (banned) weapons firing in Canada. This Guy had Red Corner Notice Issued against him before getting Canadian Citizenship and yet No Canadian media nor people are questioning their government over his profile. And Canadian PM is defending him like Pakistan defended Osama by calling martyr

[@loveu5045]

This what happens when you're a beta male and you get controlled by others. For Kanada, their PM is exactly that. A beta who wants to saty in power at any cost. More so, for the khalisthanis,,, if they really want khalisthan, then they should protest more against Paxthan, because pakisthani punjab province is the larger part of the undivided Punjab. Funny that those khalisthanis want only Indian side of Punjab.

[@JT.Pilgrim]

He was never called a martyr by Canada.

[@arunava25413118]

​@@JT.PilgrimNijjar had enough criminal records, shady past, and his citizenship was rejected two times by Canada. The way Trudeau has been rattled on his death shows his status nothing less than a martyr.

[@ExNihil0]

​​@@JT.Pilgrimhe wasn't called an extremist either, which he was. They were literally calling for murders of Indian diplomats on billboards in Surrey!

[@JT.Pilgrim]

@@ExNihil0 then use our judicial system to prosecute. Trudeau doesn’t HAVE to call him a terrorist. We have decorum and civility. Indian media and commentators speak with so much hyperbole and so dramatically its amusing. Like a little child learning how to navigate in a strange world. As is India is just starting to learn democracy. There is a reason why Indians come to Canada for education. Its so when you go home you know how to build a toilet. Now done mention the moon landings because you will be embarrassed by the facts behind the Canadian contribution to that success. Heck, India’s success is a gift from the west. Be gracious, listen, learn.

[@shrenikmehta89]

1 - We offered JT presidential suite during G20 but JT declined. 2 - We offered Air India One when his plane break down but JT declined. 3 - We continued with trade agreements even when Canda gave citizenships to people who are wanted in India for crimes like bomb blasts & murder. 4 - We offered intelligence about the guy who did kanishka bombing killing 380 people just 2 years before the bombing happened, JT's father declined. 5 - We waited 20 years for your investigation, no one else was convicted. 6 - Leader of "sikh for justice" openly released a video asking all hindus to leave canada, we still waited in hope of some kind of action against him. 7 - It's not just us, killer of the Bangabandhu(Who has been president & Prime minister of Bangladesh) openly lives in canada. Not anymore. You are not our friend. So be it! The country has simply decided. Pls keep your investments, we will keep our integrity.

[@thelvadam5113]

Your integrity? If we wanna go through history I can show you where exactly your integrity went

[@shrenikmehta89]

@@thelvadam5113 *Territorial integrity

[@va8085]

Excellently summarised. To add, constant threats to our diplomats and putting bounties on their head - in full public display

[@sunnysky11-e4q]

@@shrikantkh2639 Canada foreign reserves was measured at 86.5 USD bn in Aug 2023 and India's forex reserves $594.90 billion as of August 18, 2023 so how is canada Rich?

[@HistoryWreckingBall-vq5mo]

@lif6737Canada invites them here.

[@hellohsjkanhdhdhdbksks]

Rename Ontario/BC as Khalistan. Let's work together and resolve this issue.

[@JuanTorres-yi1hr]

These are serious criminal allegations; therefore, let's see the evidence! Period!!

[@random_gunner.9064]

​@@JuanTorres-yi1hrthen why without proof you did public shaming of India and started media trial... Do you have iota of knowledge what have you started?

[@JT.Pilgrim]

@@random_gunner.9064evidence was provided. Modi refuses to cooperate. USA has already put Modi on notice to cooperate.

[@rohanjarande]

LMAO

[@satishmaurya3404]

If Nijjar was an activist, then Laden, Al-Baghdadi, Jihadi John, Al-Zawahiri, etc.. too were activists.

[@ank337]

😂😂😂

[@peterwang6572]

Well you probably made a martyr out of him, Have fun.

[@TJSaw]

@@peterwang6572 India was against the Taliban even when the West was helping them in the 1980s. India has always been against terrorism but Canada is the hotbed of terrorism now and you’ve made a martyr of Nijjar, a criminal, a forger and a terrorist who had an interpol red corner notice against him. I hope you name your streets and squares in your capital city after this terrorist. It’ll suit your hypocrite of a country.

[@psr4550]

​@peterwang6572 that guy died in a gang war, we have bigger challenges to tackle

[@axdvhm11]

And what do you want? For India to sit idly and see attacks in India orchestrated by the terrorists harbored by Trudeau. Who gave him right to speak about a protest in India? You don't want interference, stop interfering in India's affairs and also rein in your khalistani gangsters and terrorists u hold so dear. And do not hackle Indians or put out a hit list of Indian diplomats on posters publically.

[@Ksgggg]

I love the way all canadian media tries to find origin of the problem but never discusses kaniska air india bombing planned and carried out by canadians.

[@PREMKUMAR-yi6xi]

He is citizen of Canada. He is an activist of Canada then why he was interfering in india

[@ironinfidel7792]

The Libranos had no balls to confront China on any issue, even when they imprisoned our citizens on obviously political show trial reasons. But now he is Mr tough guy when it's India? Give me a break. Turdeau has a history of loving terrorists. This is just another example.

[@nicerecruit4216]

We had assassins come over and kill someone on our soil, of course it's going to be taken seriously. Would you rather allow hitmen to have access to our country and carry out hits, while also having a chance of taking innocent Canadian lives

[@ryanward10]

​@nicerecruit4216 The FLQ were given safe passage to Cuba after murdering an elected MP in the 60s. The Air India bombing was ignored for 30 years. Trudeau welcomed the Kadr family and gave them money despite the fact Omar murdered a US soldier. We have a history of coddling terrorists.

[@shivamsinghnegi1192]

India is always alone... even now... it's west vs india... and earlier also but out of this we got a great allie Russia a time trusted one.. not the US , UK Aus..even if they are more dispora in these nation than in Russia..so don't ask why we we are more aligned to Russia than west.

[@MaryDunford]

Our loss.

[@bechansingh1560]

Russia and Israel. Maybe Israelis will take care of some Khalistanis too.

[@KamalSingh-no2sg]

Every Indian agrees with your thoughts Shivam

[@shivamsinghnegi1192]

@@MaryDunford who cares

[@randompersonintheworld232]

I don't think India is alone, more so, they don't want to announce their close allies. Why say they support USA, or RU, when they'd be hit by trade sanctions or affected in some other diplomatic way. India is staying neutral to benefit economically.

[@narendranadreddychintalapu2916]

India is not against canada India is not against the sikhs or Muslims or any other religion. India is against khalisthani violence, vandelism, terrorism which are politically supported by justin Trudeau and NDP leader that's all we are worried about.

[@randomtandom]

saal le moosko bey

[@pizzaiq]

Lol.. right

[@RizSpeaksTruth]

INDIA - AS A NATION- HAS PROVEN THAT THEY ARE UNRELIABLE FOR WESTERN ALLIES.

[@nofavors]

Canada ignored extradition requests in the 80s, and that caused the kanishka terror event. There is such thing as learning from history.

[@jeil5676]

You need a valid reason to extradite. Changing the definition of the word "terrorist" is not valid. The only terrorist in this story is the indian government.

[@xToxicNinjax]

Extradite Modi

[@BOG0690]

Yeah it's why Quebec gets special conditions 🥱

[@rajeevpandey18]

​@@xToxicNinjaxfirst extradite Trudeau. Pls don't over estimate urself esp sitting in the laps of US

[@jtrivedi5531]

Those who do not learn from history are condemned to repeat it. Justin Trudeau is doing just that. He hasn't learned from his father's mistake of 40 years back which resulted in 329 lives (most of them Canadians) being lost in the Kanishka Air India bombing in 1985. I hope those results are not repeated in Justin's time. But the K-gang surely feels emboldened now that they have patronage of Justin Trudeau and his minority government supported by the K-gang's affiliate NDP and its leader Jagmeet Singh.

[@charlesharper2357]

The problem is that Trudeau's coalition partner has links to Khalistan separatists...and they've totally ignored the radicals.

[@bulthaosen1169]

An Indian perspective. Well that was refreshing. This kind of journalism is nice. It seems he actually did talk to Indian people on the ground to get their perspective.

[@CurryScentedRedDotsIndians]

COOOWWW

[@CurryScentedRedDotsIndians]

🐮🥃

[@rupchand2177]

Now, lets see you asking for "Canadian" perspective be presented in Indian media!

[@Cray-wilder]

​@@CurryScentedRedDotsIndians MOOOSE

[@nishantsoni623]

We Indians are proud of it

[@Superman-tf3ed]

​@@mk1word ew on your mom for not using protection 😐

[@randomtrickspro8828]

​@@mk1word😂😂😂what happened u remembered ur colonial crimes

[@rajeshagarwal9039]

@@randomtrickspro8828 he remembered his parents are siblings

[@doylejodi7502]

Proud of WHAT?

[@shivamsinghnegi1192]

@@randomtrickspro8828 they just remember how there ancestor wipe off the native population...

[@rajasphadke3995]

Indian media is also showing AI 182 kanishka flight were denied justice in canada. Was it because canada was too soft on its citizens?

[@dipachakraborty5228]

Correction for the host: Nijjar wasn't a Sikh activist , he was a declared terrorist.

[@peterwang6572]

A government can declare anyone a terrorist btw. It's actually pretty easy. You just say I declare it and then it's true. No evidence needed.

[@anantabhardwaj6897]

James i dont know who are you but u are one of the rare foreign correspondents who has understood the mood in India really well. Good research. The only thing you have got wrong is whether there is strong Khalistani movement within India for a separate state. People in India speak freely when they say that there is no desire for a separate Khalistan in India. The Sikhs are a respected , patriotic and well integrated community not just in Punjab but all across India. Noone has anything against them and they have nothing against India.

[@jaykumar_khot]

Please don't give credibility to khalistanis by calling them "Sikh separatist". K separatists have nearly non existent support in Punjab. And lot of people who call themselves khalistanis are just organized criminals using asylum and political garb to do their dirty jobs.

[@powerwash5775]

Red chilies

[@সুমন্তনাগ]

@@powerwash5775 Ok , one of the Activists Sukhdool Singh aka 'Sukha Duneke 'got permanent 'Late' mark before his name in Canada by the courtesy of his fellow activists.

[@rupchand2177]

That is because there is no free speech in India. Even talking about Khalistan is banned. Whole organisations have been banned. Even peaceful protests and activism is banned. People who spoke up for free speech or for self determination are immediately labelled as "Terrorists" and jailed without trial and/or summarily killed. And you talk about "there is no support for Khalistan....blah blah blah. What a joke!

[@yubi4291]

@@rupchand2177 Member of the organized crime? Without balls so engaging in terrorism from remote? Brothers of the same terrorists that blew up Kanishka.

[@jaykumar_khot]

@@rupchand2177 I don't know what India you are talking about but please do study about north east insurgency. People who literally killed government officials and army personnel became democratic leaders under Indian flag after long dialogues. India is pretty free compared to its average income levels/socioeconomic state especially when it comes to political freedom, any surveys even those critical of freedom in India accept abundance of political freedom in country.

[@scorpfx3189]

The comparison with Khashoggi is nuts 1. He was a journalist / Nijjar at best a gangster and a terrorist at worst, 2. IN is a democracy / KSA isn’t, 3. His killing literally happened inside the embassy, 4. Ties between US and KSA are back on track if not better

[@krunal7558]

Could this situation have been prevented by Canada if they have acted on misuse of free speech and cry for help by india in past to act on people responsible for targeting temples and celebrating former PM assasination ?

[@ferociousfil5747]

Hearsays

[@brustar5152]

"Misuse of free speech" The first Gandhi would be mortified at hearing that phrase.

[@AbsentBabyDaddy]

Why are so many people anti Canadian, ppl from a different country attacked on Canadian soil, that’s an act of war and should be investigated, so far India has not provided any proof it’s just battle of the dictators

[@TheRealGlupShitto]

the phrase "misuse of free speech" means you generally don't understand the concept

[@Schrodinger_]

I think it could have been prevented if Modi didn't say "hey, let's kill someone on Canadian soil." And then did so.

[@pk-us8dr]

How can the PM of a country allege a govt in parliament for killing someone without any proof. Not only this, he also expelled a diplomat on this ground..... This is shocking.

[@JT.Pilgrim]

Who said there is no proof? The proof was presented to Modi. Biden told Modi to step up and answer the questions. Canada has good diplomacy and does not need to battle this in media. The truth will come out but how India responds will be very telling.

[@hatereligion621]

​@@JT.PilgrimIf he has proof, make it public, like he accused India in the Canadian parliament publicly

[@pizzaiq]

No proof? Think twice.

[@JT.Pilgrim]

@@hatereligion621 he didn’t accuse. He said there are credible allegations. Proof is shown in court, not in media. That said, you will see proof of signals intelligence (intercepted communications) from India government linking India to the assassination. When that comes out will you start changing your position or will you blindly defend an authoritarian PM? Rule of law. India has shown it doesn’t respect it by simply buying Russian oil at a discount. Russia invasion is a violation of the rule of law. Prove me wrong that India defends the UN Charter of Rights?

[@JT.Pilgrim]

@@pizzaiq proof was given. Modi rejected it.

[@nikhilsharma1106]

This is very balanced coverage of this issue. Most Canadian media outlets are not able to bring India's point of view this well.

[@ryanward10]

Most Canadian media are funded by the Trudeau government, and they attack everyone except China. Please be patient with Canada, we will deal with these problems the next time we vote. Most Canadians love India and wish to be friends and partners.

[@OafSite]

No it is not.

[@SarveshShrivastava-vi4vg]

Who is canada to interfere in india internal affairs. These extremists have left india for canada.

[@mjstecyk]

Why did you allow these extremists to leave India? You've roped Canada into Indian internal affairs with negligence or incompetence. Canada does not allow our criminals to walk free to other countries.

[@jatin9070]

​​@@mjstecykit does there are lot of gangsters that run away from india and are presently living in Canada. Canada's immigration and security system is a joke Lol.

[@fedsoza4975]

@@mjstecyksir go and check how many Canadians are in jail for drugs or transporting in other countries.

[@earthling017]

A gorilla in a zoo is throwing rocks at the house near to the zoo. The home owner has complained many times to the zoo that the gorilla is trying to destroy his house. However, the zoo insists that the gorilla has the right to swing its arms and throw stones. Also, the zoo claims there's no evidence provided by the home owner that the stones thrown by the gorilla are destroying the home. As absurd as this sounds, this has exactly been the Canadian response to Indian complaints till now. Freedom of expression is not an absolute freedom. Your freedom to swing your arms ends before your fist meets my face.

[@mjstecyk]

you're forgetting the part where the gorilla used to live in the house before he moved to the zoo. If Nijjar is so dangerous, why did India allow him to walk free? Political instability in India has now become a Canadian problem.

[@TheRealGlupShitto]

He was across an ocean in a different country. You people are so afraid of words. Extremely fragile and weak. You have no conception of what 'freedom of expression' means or why it is important to protect.

[@SK-hs4fp]

Nijjar wasn't a threat then. It wasn't until he became a Canadian citizen (by dubious means) and became the head of the KTF, a terrorist organisation (which has been acknowledged by his own supporters in Canada now), that he started organizing and funding assassinations and bombings in India

[@SurajMandal-lj6hc]

​​@@mjstecykwe didn't allow him to go Canada lol he fleed illegally from Nepal

[@ZuZungu]

Your reportera in India has a balanced and insightful view of the international aspects of this whole affair. Good reporting!

[@vishal.choudhury]

Source of Allegation: "Trust me bro" 😂😂

[@bestest1234567]

Such superficial knowledge of the total facts. Sikh separatist? A convicted person of Canada who was convicted for attempted murder in Canada. I hope the ignorance makes your people suffer.

[@dominict9418]

From a Canadian: Please excuse our incredibly stupid Prime Minister. Don't worry though, we will replace him in the next election.

[@Tribuneoftheplebs]

Pierre will get a trade deal done and not let diaspora grudges get in the way of our economy 👌

[@Artivule]

Canada is reducing its staff after Indian govt had asked them to do so, not due to threats. I think either you guys hadn’t seen the whole presser or you have omitted the part conveniently.

[@pizzaiq]

And what so you thibk 'asking' means...

[@RahulSharma-hi8id]

​@@pizzaiqindian govt ask canadian counterparts to bring count of staff at parity with indian staff in canada. Canada has more staffer in india than indian in canada.

[@BOG0690]

Canada has a closer relationship with America and America knows this is BRICS interference to mess with Canada/American relations

[@kth6736]

Yup they lie here and there for copium. 😂😂

[@stcoktin]

I think your information is ill researched though balanced. Consider this information: (1) Before Indian independence in 1947, Punjab was East Punjab which went to Pakistan and West Punjab which went to India. The capital of undivided Punjab was Lahore, which is in Pakistan now. Approx. communal distribution was : 40% Muslims, 30% Sikhs, 30% Hindus and the balance of others like Christians. After partition almost all Sikhs moved to India. The population of Indian Punjab is about 51% Sikh & 49% Hindi, discounting others. (Please note Sikhs in India would be about 10-15 times the Sikh diaspora in ALL 5 eye nations, Canada being the largest. (2) Sikhs constitute 2% of Indian population (140 million) compared to 2% in Canada(38 million). So Sikh population outside India is small compared to in India. Then again not all want Khalistan. So before you Canadians even think of your wonderful "freedom of speech" consider these demographics and history. (2) Recall the bombing of the Air India flight from Toronto sometime in the 1980s, which was attributed to Khalistani but strangely none could be prosecuted or the sentences carried out. This speaks volumes for the Canadian judicial system and clearly shows support. The PM of Canada then was Trudeau Sr, father of present Canadian. (The prosecution and legal system could not bring justice to 280 Canadian citizens on that flight!! So stop.shedding crocodile tears over Nijjar.(Not that I approve it, just Trudeau's hypocritical words expressed in your Parlament). (3) Check Nijjar's past history in India before migrating to Canada and how he got Canadian citizenship. (4) Lastly, there is no excuse for any contract killing. But in India, it is largely viewed as gang war between drug gangs and we do have some history. As well as the recent killing of a second person in Winnipeg, where a gang leader lodged in an Indian jail claimed ownership for the crime. (5) Lastly where is the credible evidence. Trudeau has not provided grain so far. We hear of eavesdropping by a 5 eye country but Trudeau will have to get that into the open if true. This will create further problems. I do not see that coming. Having opened the topic in Parliament and the press, there is no way you can hide the source now of you want a prosecution. Modi is unlikely to succumb to pressures after all that has happened. Possibly Xi and Putin will gain most from it. Do you think India will rely on the "5 eye' countries any more? Please open all ten eyes! Your leaders need to do so. This is an opinion from a politically unmotivated Indian. I am adding a video giving details of Indian plane that was bombed out by Khalistani terrorists in the 1980s: kzbin.infoB7NVV8D7LXU?si=XG3X8Fo7gxUjR595

[@xToxicNinjax]

Your assessment of India as a gang is correct

[@stcoktin]

@@xToxicNinjax Your toxicity is well explained.

[@ianleslie6971]

Seems like a well balanced article, thanks

[@luckysharma2102]

I know back in time 1984was hard time for sikhs, so many atrocities and violence happened against sikh community and genocide was committed towards innocent sikhs.I feel ashamed for my people but that was done by govt. of that time. Sikhs contributed & sacrifice so much for our land(India).we don't want them to loose. without them India is not India. Our Hindu/Sikh bond is much stronger then anything & we must solve our problems with dialogues otherwise someone else always take advantage on us.

[@shadow_prince_rex]

This is probably the best Canadian reporting I have seen /heard on this issue. Congrats to the reporter

[@someguy2707]

Truest of measure is that Trudeau has been consistently loosing minority votes, while Modi has been consistently gaining minority and women and especially minorities women vote. Even the most patriotic Canadians know that this was not the way to handle things with an ally, especially when Trudeau government has been ignored India’s concerns.

[@megamrswiss]

Most Canadians don't believe Justin either, this is just a highschool drama act as far as i am concerned. Prove me Wrong Justin.

[@Shmandalf]

Exactly this. Everyone here is absolutely sick of him and want him out of office. No one trusts the media here, either, so making this out to be a cultural issue is missing the mark.

[@CodeLife_12]

Considering the other options in Canada, many of us are ok with Trudeau. In an era where it's trendy to be a racist, mysoginist piece of ****, having someone who doesn't insult its population on a daily basis as head of the country is all we are asking for.

[@universaltruth9988]

Let's be real here, US UK Australia or newzea can always support canada & blame india but then guess what u guys r up against it's Russia china & india. So just be careful what you wish for. This world gonna suffer just because canada didn't handle this matter better.

[@CodeLife_12]

Or, and I know it might sound crazy to you, but maybe the Indian government should not assassinate citizen of other countries. How about that?

[@Tribuneoftheplebs]

​@@CodeLife_12 last time they asked nicely and Trudeau senior said no. Then the terrorist killed 390 canadians in the air india bombing. They werent going to let Trudeau Junior make the same mistake

[@chandrasekharmogilisetti8209]

Why don't Canada has given Citizenship to a person on Red Corner Notice for their Anti-India Activities.

[@axdvhm11]

Well i hope Trudeau's Govt renames BC as Khalistan. 😂

[@sendakan666]

Making a public allegation of this sort is unthinkable in Asian culture, unless it is against an enemy. And allowing separatists open space to fund and promote their movement is practically a declaration of war. I do not think the average Canadian has any idea what their PM has been tinkering with.

[@trvpgame7710]

The average Canadian doesn't support Justin trudeau.

[@pkr3747]

Please report on Nijjar.. who he was.. his videos with arms training terrorist.. how he entered canada and how he was denied visa first..

[@YOUTUBE_AMERICA]

Canadian needs to come up with something other than trust me bro It was well balanced just subscribed today Please cover all global issues with solutions

[@Shmandalf]

I wouldn't be so quick to trust a main stream media source on anything. No one in Canada does.

[@Lets_Be_Real_UK]

Pls don't put words into the mouth of Sikh people. Sikh people both in India and Canada are against the Khalistan movement. It's just irrelevant, and this fringe movement is a front for criminal activity. Also, are you seriously comparing the killing of a WaPo journalist with an allegations of killing of a terrorist? On the other hand by wielding terrorism as state policy, Canada under Trudeau is going the Pakistan way, and this is a very serious concern. FATF needs to examine these issues and deliberate on putting Canada on the gray list until it stops supporting terrorism under the guise of free speech.

[@JoyP09]

I dont agree with everything the reporter said about India but thanks for showing Indian perspective too.

[@MrHashisz]

No proof submitted, gangster dead in gang war today also, India to blame. WoW

[@MrBooga92]

Wonder why he didnt bring up Indian media showing the clips showing Nijjar with AK-47s or the death another terrorist a couple of days ago on Canadian soil *suspicious eyes*.

[@RkumarIyer]

Say it lady. India kicked out 41 Canadian diplomats. Please don't lie.

[@piku7800]

3rd day and am still waiting for evidence.

[@harish1255]

This is refreshing to see a journalist trying to see both sides of the story. Well done, happy to hear reporting and not opinions. Much obliged.

[@chandrasekharmogilisetti8209]

Are Canadian ready for a Quebec separate movement. If India supports it will Canadians accept it. It is same here.

[@anilshankar3538]

Canada and your PM Trudeau accept the fact that there is no evidence. Nijjar was a terrorist who was born in India and lived in India for many years and involved in killing many many people in India. He was involved in serial bomb blasts which took lives of innocent people in India. He tried to enter Canada with a fake passport with the name Ravi Sharma. Later on he married a Canadian citizen of Indian origin, but you did not give him Visa. There was an interpol alert to arrest and handover him to India in 2014. Then you gave him Canadian citizenship in 2015 violating all international rules and laws. You allowed him to wage war against India and promote terrorism in India. He was killed in a gangster war in Canada where there are 43 different Sikh Terrorists groups which are . They do Drugs and Arms deal worth Millions of Dollars. Do not blame India for all these. It is your inefficiency in running your country which is leading to such murders..Do not mess with India to cover up your inefficiency...

[@mlao1333]

"Do not mess with India" Lol you guys are so full of yourselves.

[@MaryDunford]

​@@mlao1333Really? 🤨

[@bechansingh1560]

​@@mlao1333 your generations will pay for this remember. Karma always pays back.

[@axdvhm11]

​@@mlao1333At least we are not a safe haven for terrorists. Also one quick suggestion u can have a trade deal with Pakistan. Buying and selling terrorists. 😂😂

[@rajeshagarwal9039]

@@mlao1333 that's what your PM thought too...🙃

[@antonyfrancis3247]

Canada must adhere to DEMOCRATIC VALUES and continue to encourage a REFERENDUM ON KHALISTAN. Following this DEMOCRATIC PROCESS, Canada must accede a part of Quebec as the New nation of KHALISTAN. One more addition to the growing number of NATO membership.

[@dreamerlohit]

How about free Visa for quebec people and a freedome of expression provided in India...

[@Vp13217]

Hi, Please someone in canada convey our message to your dear prime minister that for the person who he has claimed on our India is actually a terrorist, so please if you can not protect your country with letting the terrorist get the citizenship easily then please do not false claim on any country. Love from India! ❤ Namaste🙏

[@Nileeshgaawre]

JT: canada is country based on law and rules blah blah blah... INDIA: first show us evidences and then take retaliatry measures. Where is the prove?? JT : trust me bro canda is a country based on law and rules......

[@snsrikanth8863]

There was no reference to the thousands killed by violent Khalistani separatists in the 80's or to the Kanishka bombing. "James" might do well to research a bit of this history

[@vkab8217]

Have you interviewed a representative sample of the Sikh population in Canada about their support for Khalistan? The Khalistani movement in Canada attempts to make itself vocal and visible but does it speak for the majority of Sikhs there?

[@aleenaprasannan2146]

They can't. There have been cases of many Sikhs who openly opposed the Khalistani movement getting murdered in Canada

[@ramananthraman5821]

There is no analysis of the type of people from outside of india, who want a homeland in India. Common denominator is almost 95% of this group cant speak English, are not educated, are not professionals, are funded by various organizations like Soros to stir up.commotion. Sikhs from.India are the most enterprising, holding high positions, including chief of World Bank. I am a British Indian moved in here as a highly skilled migrant few decades ago. Firstly, i am a proud British and my interest in India is confined to friends and older generations living there. Wont say my way is the only way, but this is generally the case with millions of educated indians settled overseas. Why would only the sikh farmers protest in India and who funds these protests that is predominantly run and organised by the same khalistan from outside india. All boils down to funding for whatever nefarious reason it may be. Canada as country has been a safe haven for these groups.. how would treadau take it if the same group asks for a homeland in Canada?? That is what they agould be doing..scots and Welsh from here cannot ask for a homeland in USA CANADA AUSTRALIA UK

[@chandrasekaranrajagopal8292]

Childish behavior. Either put up evidence or shut up. I really feel sorry that people of Canada should put up with this guy.

[@TheFoox]

Indians are seething right now.

[@jemgodspeed]

Siikhing

[@rajeshagarwal9039]

Actually, most of us are waiting for Trudeau to do something even more stupid....he is kinda national comic entertainment for the country

[@anujkhanna2428]

The person they are mentioning who was invited for dinner by JT was not just a separatist, he was a convicted murderer and he was convicted by Canada. Don’t underplay your deeds.

[@biswaspratyush]

Ha ha ha ... he went and spoke with sikhs in India hoping to get bytes about khalistani support. Sikhs openly criticized the govt to him but he couldn't find any support amongst sikhs for khalistan. So sad. A trip wasted.

[@alanbabu8373]

Please don’t compare Kashoggi killing and this one whether or not India was involved. Its total different in many ways.

[@parthapratimmunshi1534]

A childish PM doing all the damage😢

[@mambaman9363]

This what happens between neighbours. Neighbour A ‘s dog has disappeared. The dog has frequently got off leash and been pooping on Neighbour B’s lawn. There have been complaints from B but it didn’t change anything until the dog goes missing. Neighbour A finds a witness that says he saw the dog being put in a cage by neighbour B’s son and carted off in the boot of a car. Neighbour A goes to neighbour B and asks about his dog. Neighbour B says he doesn’t know. Neighbour then A reports him to the municipality and the SPCA, as well as the news papers and media. Well we can agree when the problem first started even if we dont like the outcomes. It doesn’t need a complicated explanation. Just 2 neighbours falling out over one neighbours mismanagement.

[@zeusroyroy86]

Hello channel! When you mentioned what the khalistani movement is, you displayed the narrative suits your interest. There is no place called Khalistan but they have formed that in Canada I guess. Khalistan is an ISI-backed Pakistani shadow war to divide the Indian side of Punjab from the Indian subcontinent. It means breaking a sovereign country. Khalistani conducts several terror attacks and killings in India throughout the course of history. How come this made you think Sikh movement for a separate land? No Sikh supports their cause and you might not be that educated to know the events that far yet I have tried to make you understand. How come a PM of a friendly country accuses another country on the biggest platform of democracy? Where is the evidence? What JT wants we understand, its a request to you to please provide light on atrocities done by the Canadian government in Quebec.

[@rmat007]

Lame production by Globe & Mail. Why bother doing a video without any visual content ? There is something called zoom and google meet. Mostly free as well.

[@kktaur]

Don't forget Kanishka bombers are freely roaming around. So no surprise

[@vineetsansi]

If Jagmeet stays in Government then Canada will soon be Renamed to K-ANADA (K comes from Khalistan)

[@shiv7954]

Rename British Columbia has khalistan and gift it to khalistani Sikhs

[@vikasseth9544]

The difference b/w canada Vs UK and Austrailia is that these countries control extremism whereas everything is acceptable under garb of free speech in canada. The difference b/w democracy and anarchy is absent

[@vjaysan]

Obviously, the actions of Canada are no different from the other Western nations, just pure condescendence to the aspirations of developing nations. Canadians have openly called for violence against India and Indians despite that such blatant interference can lead to civil strife, both in Canada and India. We have seen such blatant interference in Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, Ukraine and many other nations, the consequences of which are very damaging to those nations and a dysfunctional state. Surely, these lectures on nationhood aren't useful, and developing nations should be given space for evolving peacefully. India has pulled herself out of the clutches of poverty and making the right choices towards her aspiration to be a developed nation. It is disgusting to see a G7 country making every effort to derail this aspiration of India. One can only surmise, as in the case of China, that all these are a concerted effort by the collective West, specifically the Anglosphere countries, to obstruct the rise of India. Before the end of the decade, 3 of the top 4 economies will be Asian, and that certainly poses a civilisational fear in the West. The G7 is just that and Japan certainly must feel the odd man out.

[@johndc2998]

We havent called for violence against India what kind of propaganda is that? Nobody in canada even mentions this situation... maybe indians thats it...

[@vineetsansi]

@@johndc2998 1. there are videos out there by the name of a Canadian khalistani called Pannu who is openly threatening Indian Hindus to leave Canada or face the consequences. 2. Posters of threatening Indian diplomats in canada with their pics & details were put out in Canada to harm them. Please google or search on youtube. I think canada media is censored.

[@CodeLife_12]

@@johndc2998 Propaganda in India is putting these crazy ideas in their heads. Nobody in Canada is calling for violence against India, that's completely made up.

[@TheMaestro116]

"to obstruct the rise of India" Oh you don't have to worry about "the West" for that, mother nature will take care of it.

[@peterwang6572]

Huh, literally just don't want foreign govs coming here and doing hits. Maybe just maybe your gov did some bad shit too. But don't worry, you seem to be justifying it just like the west. Maybe were not so different after all.

[@ishanshrivastav8223]

No Statment from Modi No Statement from Our Foreign minister S Jaishanakar..only MEA speaking From india side bt From Canada Truedeu Has Become Official Spoker of Khalistani Terrorists….he is a Shame for Canadians

[@healthforindia]

Asking for reduction in consulate staff of Canada is going to suffer visa for students who wants to study in Canada. This will put pressure on Canadian economy .Real-estate and banks may go for bankruptcy. About 15 to 20 billion $ genarated by students of Indian origin while studying and working part-time including rental business

[@flyingbee8188]

Proud if actually India did this!

[@rupchand2177]

Some commentators here seems to be proud that Russia and China and India are joining together (calling themselves "Global South"). They have even invited Saudi Arabia to join! That is a good club to belong to, I am sure... the "Club of Megalomaniacs".

[@LuLU-ep7wf]

100% agree

[@242sathish]

Why there was no mention about Kanishka bombing? Why the preparators were not bought to justice?

[@amrendrekumar2041]

Very much close to reality by Canadian news is never like this.

[@trvpgame7710]

As a canadian i dont care what the government says whatsoever

[@pramilamenon8621]

Now bow down to your Chinese masters

[@DavidMcCalister]

There is hope in knowing that people don't see Canada and Trudeau together... And that the rest of the world knows and acknowledges that he is the problem.. along with Jagmeet and not Canada itself... Maybe we won't be a shameful stupid country in the worlds eyes for much longer.

[@Antrix108]

21:55 I can assure you that majority of Indians are aware that it’s Trudeau pandering to Khalistanis , like his father did earlier (bombing of Air India where scores of people, 329 actually including many Canadians, was investigated in a lax manner, perpetrators like Parmar allowed to get away Scot free). Khalistan supporters like Pannu openly threatened all Hindus & embassy staff, and posters and floats celebrating killing India’s former PM Indira Gandhi are openly allowed in Canada , cmon Canada this is inexcusable. Pakistan agencies are alleged to have killed Karina Baloch, and Trudeau’s office has been silent on this. Despite her family protesting this investigation was closed in one day and termed as suicide. Trudeau doesn’t stand up to China which openly influences elections in Canada, and didn’t do anything when two Michaels were arrested He instead chose to mess with India thinking only in terms of vote bank politics and maybe distract Canadians from high inflation, deteriorating law and order situation in Canada and hoping to shore up his declining popularity. Boy was he mistaken. Despite all this majority of Indians have a favorable view of Canadians in general, and know them to be kind and fair minded. Canada really has to really look at its electoral system and see how a small minority of voters can have an outsized influence on the government. Despite being close to 2% of the population how is Jagmeet Singh able to influence all politics in the country. As a result of which you end up with a narcissist like Trudeau who is a spineless weasel. Canada you deserve better if you can’t tell I am pro Canada and its people.

[@nofavors]

How about when Indian authorities raised K terror issues and other safety and negligence issues with Canada? Did they not see this coming either? When terrorists are harboured and official intelligence data sharing is ignored by Trudeau and others in past, why is Trudeau expecting cooperation from India?

[@NirtieDigger]

Canadians are sorry bout our racist PM we hate him too

[@priscillawatson7049]

thank you for a clear informative report

[@daisys8342]

I'm pastor and I pray for peace and healing and for forgiveness love my country Canada may God continue to bless this beautiful country of Canada I'm praying for peace God bless this nation with peace and love blessing ❤❤❤

[@sakshambhadauria]

Ha ha

[@TJSaw]

As long as you host Khalistanis, you will know no peace.

[@trnswamy]

When Canada was killing Afghan people in Afghanistan, had they taken permission from Afghan government? Were they not killing Afghan people in their own country? The sheer talk of taking pride of a terrorist welding AK 47s as a Canadian national is a serious matter and this is nothing different from what Iran is doing. The fact that no major country has reacted to Trudeau 's outburst in parliament positively indicates where Trudeau has taken Canada today.

[@tejraju]

According to the latest Pew Resarch, 95% of the sikhs in Punjab want to stay with India. So in Trudeau's words; "It's just the fringe minority" that want a separate 'country' of Khalistan - not 'state'. And this fringe minority find a safe haven in Canada and deal in drugs, violence, guns, human trafficking etc. Surrey and Brampton have the highest crime and homicide rates in the country thanks to these 'advocates' or 'activists!' They have captured the gurudwaras here and indoctrinate the 1st & 2nd generation sikhs. They assassinated the Indian PM (present opposition party), Punjab's chief minister apart from several other kidnappings and killings of police men in India. And they also bombed the Kanishka Air India flight in 1985 that killed 268 canadian citizens, including 50 children. I wonder how Canada would've reacted if the dead included a majority of white canadians rather than brown canadians. Would you call it 'freedom of expression' then too? Are your morals based on convenience? Stop lecturing the world on 'rules based order' bullshit and speak realpolitik. If you want good relations with your allies, listen to their concerns - stop harboring snakes in your backyard. Khalistan issue is a question on India's sovereignty; 1.4 billion people are together on this issue!

[@abhijitsen3143]

Canada has a lot of land infact 2nd largest country after Russia....Trudeau can give some land to His khalistanis to build khalistan there...India already given its land during partition and still has 1.4 billion people to look after...hence no land here in india

[@pankeruha]

The land is quite khali too

[@abhijitsen3143]

@@pankeruha hardworking khalistanis will dig out gold from it....see their hardwork in getting ISI fundung

[@nofavors]

This is not balanced. This ignores information shared from India and also the dubious way terrorist was granted citizenship with fake passports.

[@axdvhm11]

I don't know whether Canadians are actually that naive or they just act like it. And it doesn't matter to us who Canada's PM is but Trudeau.. Common guys.. Don't you have any one better.

[@CodeLife_12]

Hey at least our democracy isn't crumbling.

[@parthasarkar2416]

Trudo question India's integrity and sovereignty not at now past also.Trudo think itis entertainment but indians don't think same