THE WARNING "Breathe (Live)" // Audio Engineer & Wifey React

[@ryankieth1675]

If she never sings it live again, that’s ok with me. That one time was special enough for a lifetime.

[@ronhall5395]

Well she won't anytime soon.

[@jayhegener3028]

Amen, brother. Amen.

[@Disciple_of_pau]

I’m agree with you🖤

[@InZomnia365]

Real music. Real emotion. This is why you have to love The Warning. There's no more authentic band in rock these days.

[@oldmanyeni1663]

This song is the first song in more than 30 years that stopped me dead in my tracks when I first heard it. Hit me like a ton of bricks. I have a copy of the lyrics to this song hand-written by Pau. As one of the 8000 in the crowd that night, I can say that it was one of the most moving live music moments I have ever witnessed in more than 40 years of concert going. Just incredible. Thanks for taking the time to watch that one.

[@Jmg831]

Awesome that you experienced it live

[@musikbyjh]

Thank you, Old Man Yeni!! I love how deeply you feel music. This definitely is gem.

[@jeffgray9943]

We know about booing someone off the stage; never saw someone being loved off the stage!! ❤❤❤

[@ripmcmanus773]

This song is heart wrenching enough, but to perform it solo, sick, and in front of 8,000+ people after swearing she never would? Tears. Lots of tears.

[@krash66]

Pau is a rare gem indeed. She is so very special!

[@spaceknave]

In the beginning everyone started singing with her and she says " no, no, I have to sing it." They don't catch that on the subtitles.

[@juancarlosgarzonuribe86]

Yes, she managed to finish it, but I think seeing 8000 people sing it with her made her cry

[@JohnDoe-og1dl]

The crowd finished it for her./ Thank you

[@corneliuscrewe8165]

Makes me want to give her a big hug. She is something special.

[@death_courir]

That what I thought too. Same at the end of the teatro concert. Just want to hug her, thankfully Ale was there to hold her and was joined by Luis.

[@sb859]

She finished the song because she's a trooper. Such passion on display. I'd watch someone make pottery if they did it with passion. The fact the whole audience sang it with her overwhelmed Pau but she gave it her all and belted it out! Puh Pau!

[@drewped]

Leave it to Pau to turn men into crying babies. IDK how many times she's gotten me. ⚡⚡⚡🤘🤘🤘

[@bankmystr]

'Flowers After Rainfall' is awesome... she is so cute. I love her giggles ❤

[@Jmg831]

Same, she’s a great reactor

[@chriso6719]

Included on the Error album, think the record company wanted one more song for the record, so Pau gave this up , as she said here, with the promise she would never have to play it live. The studio version was played at Teatro Metropolitan CDMX during intermission, check that out later, the crowd lit up the place with their phone lights.

[@FunEcar]

Yes, this was the entire song. Only the audience sung the "Aah, Aah Aah's" at the end. She hit the last keys of the song and then broke down. Also a shout out to @alitaaaa for putting together the muti-camera and translations of the video.

[@eloy6017]

There's a home video of Pau playing the piano when she was a little kid (she looks about 5 years old) and when she finished she bowed and walked away the same way she did here!

[@randymarple9830]

Wearing all white. Love it.

[@eloy6017]

@@randymarple9830 Yes, indeed. That one!

[@AlejandroAlvarez-bu8ld]

The title of that home video is: Sonatina Op 168 No 1 Rondo 3rd mvmt Piano performed by Ale 6 years old.

[@arctic_haze]

@@AlejandroAlvarez-bu8ld But as the title says, t was Ale not Pau. But they probably had the same teacher 😀

[@luisretana665]

I was there and it was a magic moment.

[@harrybroaddus846]

Yes, all three had the flu just prior to the concert. So still sick and singing a song very dear to her heart....respect.

[@cncs2806]

Pau is such a sweetheart, so talented and professional. All three of them are. Impossible not to love them. Viva The Warning! ♥

[@dirkmayer1536]

This is magic. True music from a young soul. Everything was true her. No ghostwriter, only family. Real music. Not seen often today.

[@death_courir]

I see we have at least two things in comon - The Warning and #nurderFCK. Grüße aus Koblenz.

[@dirkmayer1536]

@@death_courir schöne grüsse zurück.👌🏻

[@angelseda9823]

What you couldn’t hear too well on the video was that the crowd sang the last part of it for her and that choked her up even more !!!.. the fact that so many people were singing was overwhelming for her !!!.. Dani also cried while singing “ When I’m alone “ and they also had an orchestra playing along with them when they did “ Enter Sandman “ .. amazing show , maybe you guys can react to it sometime !!!

[@rgbenge7580]

You should see the rest of the video that preceded this where she sang Black Holes. She was so taken with the audience that started singing with here that she literally was shocked and overcome with emotion, at the end you can see some of the violinists tearing up. Because of the audience in Black Holes she decided to sing Breathe. You really need to see Revenant from Teatro Metropolitan as well. Haunting, emotional and one of the most beautiful pieces of music I have heard in over 50 years. Pau is truly something special.

[@Axelsanx]

You have to watch the two songs she did back to back, back to back. She was already getting emotional during Black Holes and then went into Breathe. Pau is so sweet.

[@keenian6164]

Have you heard that in 1 hour from the opening of selling tickets for 6 February 2025 at Auditorium in CDMX, they gone sold out??? There are 10.000 seats in it!!! AWESOME their are on their way to the TOP, those are numbers of BIG... 1 hour means there was thousands of fans waiting at opening!

[@SDsailor7]

Second show added on the 11th

[@seanfryou2692]

It is very very rare when I have an actual physical emotional reaction, this is one of the few. All three of these ladies are so ridiculously talented and it’s amazing that we get the chance to experience them. TWA!

[@ohTHATaaronbrown]

That was the whole song (it's the very short bonus track on the Error album), the crowd finished the last bit of singing, and she hit the last keys, and lost it. So moving...

[@JulioHernandez-jl9qk]

They just sold out 10,000 capacity Auditorio Nacional in Mexico City in 24 hours. Also opening for Avril Lavigne in France and Evanescence across Canada later this year.

[@pjdambra]

They should never open for anyone ever again. As much as I want to see them live, I won't go unless they are the featured act. I fact, To Only Act will be even better.

[@federicovilla3480]

​​@@pjdambra I just discovered The Warning 2 months ago and I'm obsessed now, but would have loved them years ago if I HAD KNOWN THEY EXISTED! Opening for these established world renowned artists gives them a tremendous opportunity to reach a large audience that still may not have heard of them.

[@bobbarber2070]

Also Halestorm on that tour.

[@dw9911]

@@federicovilla3480 and even more than the public exposure. there's no doubt in my mind they grew being around Lzzy and halestorm last summer, Dany's vocal confidence and power leveled up for sure...id guess in some writing as well...now along with Amy Lee, there aren't really two better people to learn from, and gain as friends in their business, IMO...like they have done already with lzzy and her "boys" as she says...Amy lee seems pretty solid to me as well, and has gone through her share of bs along the way. Got my seats, sec112 row 9 seats 6&7 rogers place 10/20 Edmonton, ab!!! thats 20000 seater, will be awesome! big jump from last time in a casino, which was of course also awesome!

[@dw9911]

now if they can just figure out how to slip Dany into "break-in"...ohhhhh man!? kzbin.info/www/bejne/hYbYh4Wbf7ilmZYsi=JREM6bgj_cvbK2fY kzbin.info/www/bejne/moPFgI1pfpeGqZIsi=OqDrnx82cVf88FVy

[@johndziadyk8624]

A tear jerker! Listen to the lyric version to feel the song till the end.

[@Sly.L]

Maybe one day I'll be able to watch this video without crying. Today is not that day. Great reaction you two!

[@randymarple9830]

Not me. I must have listened to it 500 times. Not crying is not an option. How hard I cry is problematic.

[@gohanzdad]

Great video! I've been waiting for you to react to this one. Glad you did the one with subtitles. As a father with a daughter not much younger than Pau, seeing her so vulnerable singing this song brought the tears to my eyes too. Pau, being the artist/musician she is, will always have a special place in my heart.

[@javadan]

The chain idea really works. Not only did Flowers After Rain play, but she chained to ChrisCobra who hadn't heard TW, and now he's joining the TWA. Good Job, Great Idea.

[@musikbyjh]

It was all @cheezyxyz! He's the mastermind and we agree, such a terrific idea. Love connecting with other reactors and sharing music!! 🤩

[@cynthiamiller483]

I hurt for her, losing a friend at such a tender age. She truly wore her heart on her sleeve; not too many can do that. Thanks, Chaz, for such a heartwarming story. I would have cried if I’d had tears, but you can take my place, Jeremy. We all love your empathetic heart. And we love you, Jillian, for taking care of his heart ❤️ 🎶 Cyd

[@keenian6164]

This was a magic, touching and unfortunely first and last performance live of this song! What a touching MASTERPIECE, boys!

[@phillipgroat9504]

Thank guys! Happy to mention flowers spread the love to chris cobra, the army did their thing and chris is into his third reaction now!

[@mt4design2]

During the intermission at the Teatro Metropolitan concert Breathe played over the sound system and THAT was an emotional experience. When this moment occurred, it managed to eclipse that incredible moment. These young women share themselves so deeply and everyone who comes into their orbit never wants to escape. The song is somber, but it reinforces the fact that we can’t understand the beauty of absolute joy without experiencing sorrow and pain.

[@shakkjohnson5701]

your chain reaction to flowers which in turn forwarded to another reactor that with the warnings army help get the dudes rent paid up and more besides the fact he is head over hills for TW, and already 3 or 4 songs in and cant get enough, awesome choice you made, thanks for sharing this reaction too, yea she only got thru half the song before she departed, thanks! Dany also has a teary eyes solo song at home on acoustic she did for a lost love one, maybe the same person idk, but yea great to see the chain moving along!

[@musikbyjh]

So happy to spread The Warning, love!! @cheezyxyz was the mastermind we have to thank for such a great idea!!

[@kevinthetruckdriver353]

*Breathe Backstory:* This was their third special show (3 total). This night Pau played *"Black Holes"* with a string assembled. After *"Breathe"* Pau took the love and return to her kit while the strings played an interlude while stage hands removed the piano. And Ale & Dany returns to start *"Enter Sandman"* with strings. *New music video:* The Warning released a new music video called *"Qué Más Quieres".* Yes, the song is in Español. There are several English language non official (studio audio) lyric videos out on KZbin. Recommend you see them a few times before you watch the music video. *PLUS PAU IS A CO-DIRECTOR OF THE VIDEO.*

[@keenian6164]

The Official music video of "Que mas quieres" it's on release in minutes on their channel!

[@iJGrimmX]

Beautiful and heartbreaking at the same time. Dany also has one of her midnight cave sessions where she sings a song for a lost friend and it too is beautiful and heartbreaking. It is something special for a band to share these emotional moments with us, unvarnished and raw.

[@carlosportillo2781]

what a lovely lady!

[@elvwood]

Finally got to see them live on Monday, which was predictably awesome (and I finally understand what everyone says about Dany's stage presence, it's pitched to a concert venue scale rather than a YT video scale so I didn't get it before). They didn't do _Breathe_ of course, but that's fine - I wouldn't expect it. And we have this video. They did do a good range, from old to new, including all my favourite more rocky ones from _Survive_ to _Hell_ _You_ _Call_ _a_ _Dream._ Still buzzing!

[@musikbyjh]

Sounds like a blast!!! So glad you got to experience these Queens live!!

[@larrywhite2956]

Of the huge list of Reactors that I have listened to over the years regarding my favorite band I consider you guys as one of the top Reactors on KZbin. Your knowledge, demeanor, and experience really do stand out! It is a pleasure to hear your love, appreciation, and continued support for these incredible sisters who I think we agree are simply amazing! Continue to do what you do best! Many thanks and much love from West Virginia, USA!❤

[@musikbyjh]

Larry - you star!! I'm sorry we are so late responding to this awesome comment. It meant so much to us we shared on social media as an example of a comment that makes all the work worth it. Thank you for being you!!

[@josevillasenor9222]

Crying 😢Pau makes me emotional ❤❤❤

[@PaulSink]

The crowd finished it for her!😢!This was such a difficult issue to sing about!❤ Paulina is amazing in so many ways!

[@FranCR62]

We all cried with that presentation and with that song that can be found on one of their first albums.

[@PaulSink]

TWA in da house! Paulina's passion is amazing. Per the agreement only a studio version as the bonus track was going to be done. Pau is explaning to the crowd she loved their excitement so much she changed her mind and did the song!

[@MrJest2]

I honestly think she doesn't want to play it live not because it's "too personal" - they put their personal feelings and stories out there all the time; it's what song writers *do* . I think it's because she knows herself, and knows she can't get through it without breaking down... and that would be unprofessional. Above all, they want to give their audiences a great show - and Pau bawling at the drop of a hat is not part of that desired experience. Nevertheless, she did it anyway, at least this once, and that's wayyy more than enough. My respect for her amped up - yet again - just due to her willingness to make the attempt, simply because she knew everyone would appreciate it.

[@PaulSink]

@@MrJest2 Guess your idea of "unprofessional "is different than those of us that have been been following TW over the last 10 years or have seen all they have shared on social media we love them being so open.And yes it did have to do with personal feelings!

[@MrJest2]

@@PaulSink I think you completely misunderstood my comment. Completely.

[@56brogerson]

I have been to many concerts and I have never seen a band that is so supported and loved by their fans. It is amazing and speaks volumes about the quality and honesty of these 3 ladies.

[@TeemarkConvair]

so so touching,, tear up EVERY time,, pure, raw emotion,,,, your reactions are honest,,

[@figuerio1]

!!!The Warning = 100% 🔥🎵ole ole ole oleeee Warning Warning🎵¡¡¡. Greetings from Argentina.

[@wchaza67]

Thanks for reacting to it! This girl... ugh, I just can't with her! Brings me to tears every. damn. time! And yeah, the audience finished it for her, there are a couple 'oh-oh-ohhhh', 'oh-oh-ohhhh' at the end that they helped her with.

[@spaceknave]

It's a short song, she finished

[@ScottT248]

Hard to believe she did this all while not feeling well. What a trooper she is. So far this is the one and only time she sang it live. They just released an official music video today of one of their latest songs Que Mas Queires and the video was created and directed by Pau. I suggest a reaction to it as it has a story in the video and it is fantastic.

[@SO.CAL-D.Edwards]

Call me a"Whambulance" 😭 I'm a big ole crybaby.. 🤘🎶✌️

[@scottinokc]

Someone is always cutting onions near me when I watch that.

[@TimoArula]

OMG,...that was beyond beautiful and touching, as an empath, this performance left me stunned and also in tears... Especially because Paulina is my absolute favorite !! I love All of them, but yeah, Paulina is the best (well, that doesn't sound creepy at all... sorry if it did! ). SO, new subscriber here for that !!! NWSU/FloorFan/Epican/Ayreonaut/TWA 🤘😎🤘.

[@musikbyjh]

Thank you very much and welcome!!!

[@TomTomson81]

Of course, Paulina pulled through to the end, at least on the piano. The fans finished the song for her. The last note on the piano was also the last note of the song.

[@gcarap]

Aileen said on Twitch today (April 30) she is reacting to The Warning "this week".

[@musikbyjh]

Great news. Thank you!!! 😊

[@gcarap]

@@musikbyjh Done! Evolve at VMAs

[@Scott_Diverscott]

Here’s some interesting context for you. At the time, their Pepsi Center show was the biggest headlining show that they had ever done. As Pau said, they had over 8,000 fans in attendance at the sold out show. When tickets went on sale it took, a few weeks to sell all of them, but they sold it out well before the show. This past week, they announced another show in Mexico City at the National Auditorium, which can accommodate 10,000 people. They sold out every ticket for the show within one hour. So, in true warning fashion, they announced another show. Any bets that when those tickets go on sale they’ll be gone just as quickly?

[@Astro-Markus]

It always happens. The same with her song "Black Holes". It always cracks my up.

[@caseschirmacher]

I was there! it was super emotional and beautiful 😢

[@scottlafleur4148]

I've seen The Warning Army called "bots" before when we flood a comment section. It sucks but it shows how unique TWA is.

[@Rabi.Rabi.Garchar]

When your heart exploted!!

[@christinehooper6488]

I'm not crying, you're crying.........

[@jluisg622]

Paulina es extraordinaria te mueve el sentimiento con sus interpretaciones con su voz triste y desgarrada Breathe es una gran muestra de su talento

[@mikerojas7096]

I was there!! Pau was great. Loved it.

[@scottmiller5785]

Pau is such a beautiful ❤️ soul.

[@SDsailor7]

I recommed the VERDY channel for Warning

[@steve318k]

Great idea ! She's a very knowledgeable authentic reactor !

[@JohnSmith-zl8rz]

Pau is a world treasure!

[@death_courir]

Thanke you very much. I´ll be right back just searching some tissue. 😭

[@stonejohnson122]

Listen to the lyric video

[@DanDuke]

Poor thing. Gets me every time. I have a rough time listening to Breathe off of the album because I've seen that video.

[@stevel4265]

An Evanescence song "Hello" does the same for me as this does ... it's deep she bared her soul and sometimes that helps immensely PS Awesome song too

[@AngelCelis69]

👍

[@elah1023]

AiIeenSenpai? Chick who hears every single song for the first time? :) Yeah, I don`t buy it. :) Flowers After Rainfall is at least authentic.

[@musikbyjh]

She finally reacted and totally dug them!

[@elah1023]

@@musikbyjh Good for Her. :) TW will make Her popular. :D

[@jimmyseiberling7534]

Can you get a shout to Molly Sanborn? She is a small channel reactor that truly could use an Army boost. She told me this week in her reply to me that she hadn't heard of The Warning, In This Moment, or The Pretty Reckless. A nudge from a fellow reaction channel might be all Molly needs... I follow The Warning reactions, and the lowest total views was 3.9 views, in only 4 days though... Thanking you in advance.

[@bigfan007]

An emotional performance, but unless you are inside TW tent, it is not going to appeal to many as musically it's not great. You can celebrate this as a great emotional performance, but not a great musical one.

[@musikbyjh]

We definitely understand your point.

[@SirCamsmorethanalot]

Please shut up Jeremy...blah blah blah then gives it away all in the first few seconds besides being obnoxious. Gone.

[@musikbyjh]

If this is how you were raised to talk to strangers, we are grateful you are "gone". Perhaps work on your social skills and avoid the keyboard. ✌🏽

[@alfonsogutierrez1392]

Can't wait for this and enter sandman with strings performances to be released in a go pro version with high quality sound, hopefully 🎹🔥🔥🔥🥁🎸💜🙏🌌🕯️🌎🌍🌏👍🤘🤘🤘💥⚡⚡⚡🇺🇲🇲🇽🎯🤞🌟🌪️🌪️🌪️👏🎆🎉⚠️⚠️⚠️

[@LostHate]

Qué Más Quieres official music video just dropped thought you'd want to know if you didn't already. I got the same response from Aileensenpai on Twitch. I've been working on her to do TW for a while now. Some reactors just do there thing and you can't get through to them. Sad but they and there channel are the ones missing out the most. 🔪🧅🔪🧅🔪🧅

[@timspeakman4555]

I was stood just a few yards from Pau when she played this and it was hard to watch to see her so emotional. But so privileged to be there

[@eveline5858]

I think we ALL cried❤🤗😍

[@Ruisu-San]

8000 people went to see The Warning on that day, she was very emotional. Yesterday she announced that they sold out a 10000 people show in Mexico in 2025. All the tickets were sold the very first day they were released for sale.

[@Cactusman1960]

Twice!

[@christinaalgate4899]

Hi Guys Pau was sick. She sang Black Holes with violins. Yoi should react to Dany singing When I'm Alone at this concert. Breathe is a short song

[@oregonlt3]

“A panic attack set to music”💔💔💔

[@TerryParsons1724]

8000 fans finished the last of the song out of love for Pau it was beautiful. Great reaction thank you 💗

[@2twenty]

Shout out to Flowers After Rainfall (Jesse). She shouted out & challenged Chris Cobra, who has taken the ball and run with it! Still waiting (patiently…kinda) on Rob Squad Reactions & Aileen Senpai. Thanks to you both. The Warning Wednesdays have become my go to for that mid week kick in the tail!

[@tay13666]

Was going to say that as well. Not only did she hit the ground running on her reaction in record time, but she kept the chain going and got another reactor on board.

[@musikbyjh]

Love this news!! We are late replying, sorry! Aileen's since reacted and we HEAR Rob Squad will react, but not holding breathe. Honestly, feeling like our mission was accomplished! 🥇

[@gerardogonzalez-hj2my]

That was the entire song but the ooh ooh ooh the fans sang them because obviously she couldn't do them. It was a magical moment between Pau and The Warning Army. Awesome reaction as always you guys love them and keep them coming

[@keenian6164]

hi, fabulous couple of amazing show! 😘

[@willkellit5232]

When she played black holes, in that song at the very beginning once it got into the pre course or the course or whatever, the audience was singing so loud right along with her she literally lost her breath. You see her singing when all of a sudden she's overwhelmed by how loud the audience is singing with her and it hit so hard she literally can't sing anymore. She turns and looks at the crowd, her eyes glowing with wounderment and appreciation as she's trying to get her breath back. It takes her about 5 sec. and she strarts moving her head towards the mic to start singing again and the crowd vocals up and she moves away again losing her breath once more. It was an amazing thing to see. She made it through Black Holes but that only made her way more susceptible when she started to sing breathe. Of course on that one she lost it and couldn't even finish the song. Did you notice when she started crying on breathe that there were no captions and then she finally looks up says something into the mic and stands up and walks off the stage, you know what she said? She said "I love you all". Can you imagine breaking down from an emotional moment and then hearing and looking up to see that you have 8,000 people standing behind you who love you. I could never even imagine what that would feel like. I have no idea, cannot even imagine the depth and magnitude of that feeling, but just like any human on the planet we all long for it. Hey can you guys do me a favor and just send me a reply to my comment saying yes or no. Yes meaning that you did see it(the black holes in this concert), and No meaning you didn't. And if you don't respond I'll just assume you guys are to busy and probably don't read these comments. But how busy can you be for a simple yes or no that's all I want. Thanks, love you guys.

[@musikbyjh]

Hi!! We see your awesome comment and appreciate you! And no, we can't imagine how it must have felt to have 8,000 adoring fans singing for you. Epic. Thank you for your comment and for being here. Much love!! ❤️🥷🤘🏽

[@chabirandjeanmarc7032]

Yes they were all sick. And you may hear that in the low register because in normal time Pau has no problem to sing there

[@Oskar2922]

Esta obra maestra 💫, la termino Paulina con 16 años, aun que la idea la traía desde los 13. Es una canción que dura 2:47 min., pero que duele toda la vida!!! 💔⚡

[@pjdambra]

Paulina is such a special person. The class just oozes from her every breath. 💕🎶

[@WaldoKitty]

*Breathe* when Pau plays Breathe i can't because i'm 😿😿😿 idk how she gained possession of my soul in addition to my heart... i think we all know that when looking at a keyboard, any keyboard, through tear filled eyes, it is impossible to see the keys properly... (that's why this is a pre-written comment in a text file 😉) 🧅🥷🧅🥷🧅🥷 TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA

[@jasonfernandovalenzuelamot7331]

Esta cancion es muy especial para Pau ella dijo que nunca queria cantar esa cancion en vivo por eso la emocion, aparte estaban tan emocionadas por llenar con 8 mil personas el Pepsi center y ahora acaban de hacer un soldout en 36 horas en el auditorio nacional un recinto de 10 mil personas es increible la magnitud con la que van creciendo. Saludos y buena reeaccion.

[@spidernose]

Lil Pau needed a hug.

[@rdombek]

Paulina in my opinion has the most beautiful voice on the planet. Thanks for reacting to this one!

[@aldomacias361]

It's okay if she didn't want to react, but the way she handled it was pretty bad, in my opinion.

[@SxCrime]

❤‍🔥❤‍🔥❤‍🔥

[@sergiodelatejaytejeda]

Pau and her fans relationship... "Love, with love repay it". 🤘😁✌️

[@MySnottyattaC]

💚✌️