The Witcher Old World Board Game Review

[@beakerkell]

Monster trails definitely fixes the monster issues you had. I won't play without it! I completely agree about the rules, though. It can be pretty frustrating at times, but not a deal breaker.

[@gergelyvarga4764]

They just released a printout (kickstarter newsletter) for explanations to the icons (2 pages or so).

[@cardiner-lv]

Your positives and negatives basically were exactly what our game group experienced. One thing I can say is Monster trail improved theme a lot but it makes it even longer, but for two I would not play without it

[@GrandElemental]

What really annoys me is that some issues are fixed in the expansions, and some of the content is KS exclusive. Retail version is quite disappointing.

[@cardiner-lv]

I doo agree@@GrandElemental

[@mikehall9240]

Love the format of your videos guys! Always a pleasure watching. Keep up the great work!

[@skapadamdc]

Hi, just mention that middle earth quest uses the same deck building/life stile mechanics. It's an fantastic and also very very very thematic game that I recoment to try anyone who likes tolkien's world. The best board game of lord of the rings in my opinion. Regards!

[@juanpablozabala4975]

Absolutlely! Also Gears of War

[@bricevanliefde9287]

Bar wibes!!! You guys are easily some of my favorite game reviewers and you crack me up!

[@jonryan835]

What a great review format! Thoroughly enjoyed the review, and subscribed so I can check out more of your stuff.

[@BoardGameHangover]

Thanks so much!

[@janmoetting1571]

Thx for the video! The expansions are highly recommended, if you do like the base game. They add lots of new events and story killing any repetition. There are new monsters and monster abilities, you can play as mages and even as Ciri!

[@Biodelic]

Ciri is a Kickstarter exclusive and only available with the stretch goals. So is the Monster Trail, the Wild Hunt and the Adventure Pack. The stretch goals almost double the content. The retail version is a massively stripped down version. It is almost criminal for the price asked.

[@janmoetting1571]

@@Biodelic Well it's about 70 to 80 € which is quite normal for a Asmodee game. It's a good quality production. The expansions will soon be in retail for sure.

[@Biodelic]

@@janmoetting1571 Well, the basic pledge, without the minis, including VAT and EU shipping was 90€. Please don't get me wrong, it is a great game in its essence. I was a Kickstarter backer and would love for people to get the "full version", simply because there is so much much more there. I find it wrong to sell it at that price in retail with half the content. You also lose out if you buy the regular expansions because the strech goals also boost them massively. The strech goals components will hit retail supposedly at the end of 2024, which is a very far in the future and I am unconvinced it will really happen.

[@thehaydenroper]

Gonna echo the need for expansions. Monster trail is a must for monster variety. The others are not needed but add a decent amount of variety to the game (mages are fun, skellige is a fun but unnecessary add on). The legendary hunt monsters also make the game feel more epic as you got a boss to work towards. Although this may take it from a family+ game to a family ++ or mid weight game. Imo worth the upgrade in complexion/fiddlyness for more advanced gamers

[@zenster1097]

I think the Monster pack should've been put into the game period. They made it a free addon for the KS, but that's not good enough, because it's technically not part of the game. They should've stuck it in the game.

[@Verboten_Joey]

I'm interested, but I can't justify the high prices. Three plays until you feel the need for an expansion is poor value, especially for a game that is $80-$100 CDN. The expansions are also $60-$70 CDN each, it's absurd.

[@caesarsihombing2822]

U should play it with monster trail expansion, its makes all monster unique and make monster hunting more exciting

[@jamvng]

With Monster Trail it becomes pretty interesting. I have the Kickstarter Adventure pack too which adds a ton of exploration cards. So replayability becomes much better. My main issue with it is the game is really long and big for what it is. Makes it harder to bring out.

[@bujniaq4810]

The core game is unfortunately a demo version of Witcher, you have to play with both Monster Trail and Legendary Hunt expansions to feel as a complete product. It's extremely sad, but true.

[@lucsky603]

You guys are amazing. Very good entertainment and fair rating. This was the first time i watched the channel, but for sure not the last.

[@BoardGameHangover]

Really happy to hear that! See you around!

[@chuckm1961]

You must be AP'ing that poker. With my group, it takes about 20 seconds.

[@robertwiniarski6330]

Greatings from Poland🙂 Two great games from my country in one episode, thanks😁

[@feeltheway6254]

Literally was today years old, when I found out you guys are from Latvia! Cheers, comrade!

[@GoonBoard]

Great job guys. Excellent review. Get back to us.

[@DumahAtreides]

Monster Trail expansion is essential and addresses the main aspects to turn this more into a gamers game. It isn't available currently in retail, but it is coming soon. There's an official iconography sheet to print out now

[@Vlad65WFPReviews]

are you sure the Monster's Trail box will come to retail? I have seen it in other rewards and it seems essential to make the game worthwhile for replayability.

[@DumahAtreides]

@@Vlad65WFPReviews It's not marked as exclusive and there have been comments from the company saying 2024.

[@RAWxxx07]

Thx for the info 👍. What is exclusive then? Besides Ciri?

[@DumahAtreides]

@@RAWxxx07 A monster pack with 4 other monsters is all besides Ciri

[@RAWxxx07]

@@DumahAtreides okay thx. Which things are a must have in your opinion (monster trails, mutagens?) and which don‘t really enhance the experience. Thinking about getting a Witcher Package, but not sure what to get (don‘t need the extra dice for example, and not sure about the Skellige expansion)

[@tonybowers9490]

Thanks for sharing. The rulebook is lacking. A legend and glossary help any rulebook. Also, I think the poker is extremely lacking, so we house rule it. The base game can be a bit simple, but Monster Trail improves the game a lot. Would be nice to have a bit more monster variety. I find the Witcher: Old World to be dripping with theme. Making your Witcher stronger via your skills and cards. The stories, the minis, the monsters, the fighting. They all fit well into the Witcher World.

[@ptastydactyl]

Man you guys make some great content! I was kinda bummed I missed out on this campaign. I'm backing The Witcher Path of Destiny now which is obviously different but should get me my dose of Geralt.

[@juanpablozabala4975]

Greatly influenced by Middle Earth Quest by Corey Konieczka

[@ChristianDellon]

Do you guys have the Kickstarter version with more cards or just the basic?

[@frozenermarcel8057]

Going first is actually quite a big deal for pvp and the fact that there will be an uneven amount of cards because of it.

[@Why-Ron75]

Great review and awesome channel. Yet, I must admit, I was really really waiting for your review for Black Rose Wars. How is it even possible that you guys didn't upload one for either the original or the Rebirth version. This is tramendously unclear to me. Yes, there are lots of games out there, but the fact that you haven't experience this one yet is quite.... shocking? Anyway, hopefully you will.. soon enough.. Subscribed to follow along ;)

[@RamyASMR]

I am one of those diehard Witcher fans. Read books & have over 1k hours (and even hold a world record) in Witcher 3. HOWEVER - do you think it‘s worth it as SOLO game exclusive? From what I‘ve gathered maybe not?

[@cardiner-lv]

It is just okey, but after few times it will get stale quickly, but community is huge behind this game, BGG is full of great variants of solo game that actually have autonomas

[@RamyASMR]

@@cardiner-lvthank you very much for your insight! 🙌

[@janmoetting1571]

If u are a diehard fan i can recommend the game just for the look and feel of it. Ok, it is not a Mage Knight, but it is fun playing solo. Go on board really did a good job to stay true to the source (books and game). And no, it is not just capitalising on the ip.

[@LordVampire1985]

I love it solo and I’ve only played the base game so far, even when I have everything else except the Mages expansion. I also have the playmat and the metal coins, they are not needed, but add a lot to the feel of the game. I also painted all of my miniatures the last couple of weeks. Again, not needed, but fun! If you can, I strongly advise to get a deluxe version with the Kickstarter box with all the miniature monsters. Deluxe, because the miniature monsters are AWESOME and especially since the expansions DO NOT have monster tokens, only miniatures. So if you want to get them later on and you only have the standard version of the base game, that’s a thing to consider. The Kickstarter extra box adds Monster Trail, Adventure pack and Wild Hunt which adds a lot to the game (more diversity, more characters, more monsters, a lot more quests and adventures and a co-op mode). These will be available in 2024 for retail, exceptional Ciri and the Lost Mount, but that might be a long wait. Wild Hunt seems great fun solo too, as does Legendary Hunt. Both change the core of the gameplay again for added diversity. So if you’re a Witcher fan, get this game! It even has me replaying Witcher 3 again.

[@jonathanjoyce2376]

It really depends how complex and deep you want a game to be. It's satisfying to build your deck for great combos and to try out the different Witcher Schools. I would say that the mini expansion that comes with the KS adding more exploration and quests is needed to avoid seeing cards too often.

[@justanerd1138]

Love this game yet feel that this is one of those cases where you are not playing the game at its potential if you don't have several expansions (some of which are not available at retail yet as I understand it). Monster Trail for moster personality and Adventure Pack for event variability. The Mages and the Legendary Hunt add great new ways to play. The Wild Hunt and Skellige are ones you can live without but those first four... man it is a different game without them and that makes for an expensive entry point.

[@SherlockChromesSFY]

Are Monster Trail and Adventure Pack included in the Deluxe version of the game? I only see the Deluxe version and 3 main expansions available online (Legendary Hunt, Skellige and Mages).

[@andreicojocaru5710]

Great video as always. Just a quick question, are you guys going to be at Essen Spiel this year? Would love to meet you!

[@caska2894]

Thank you for a great review, you are the best. Just ordered the game. It looks awsome !

[@666olbaid666]

Sveiki Zēni! Jums ir arī kāds veikals kur var nopirkt galda spēles vai arī jūs varat ieteikt kādu labu galda spēļu veikalu ar plašu klāstui? Esmu Runebound eng meklējumos, bet pašlaik nesekmīgi.

[@red1948]

Where can I buy it?

[@krisjaniszviedrans9871]

What is a Geralt?

[@kiteee666]

You should definitely try "the thing" board game

[@Shadenium]

Completely different genre.

[@ShmavinShmenhouse]

You guys are the best reviewers

[@Shadenium]

The production quality of the video is so high.

[@tbatrics]

I think you saved me a purchase. Doesn't sound like it is for me.

[@Fetapeter]

00:24 ❤

[@viesturskokarevics2427]

Cool artwork.

[@El-gu2hi]

Janis T goes to some scary bars…

[@Biodelic]

This game without the Kickstarter stretch goals, aka retail version, is just a sad shadow of the full game and way overpriced.

[@thomasjclay]

What are these Wideos you guys talk about all the time? 😂

[@juhas514]

Absolutely needs the monster trail expansion, without it the game is just meh...

[@Deltium5683]

This game is definitely not for me and just capitalising on the Witcher IP.

[@chuckm1961]

What do you mean by saying it is "just capitalising on the Witcher IP"? Your first phrase is "the game is not for me," but your second phrase seems to suggest that the game "just" exists to make money and has no merit objectively. Which is an odd statement, because it has a unique card mechanic and very streamlined game play.

[@19263411]

I unfortunately have to agree, I went all in for this one, but I skipped their new campaign.