The Worst Player at Every MLB Position In 2024

Enjoy The Worst Player at Every MLB Position In 2024! Subscribe to Made The Cut for more mlb content!
#mlb #baseball #mlbvideos #baseballvideos
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

[@jonasirw1]

MLB should start giving out reverse MVP awards to honor these record breaking performances

[@madethecut]

Lol like the Razzy’s with movies. I like it.

[@Virtual_Sports-l4d]

the white sox would sweep

[@mgasolprodz33]

LVP? Cardboard Slugger? Paper Glove?

[@jacksheldon6961]

@@mgasolprodz33 what would the Cy young be called for this category

[@dio696]

@@jacksheldon6961the Patrick Corbin

[@tank6641]

White sox fan here - it should be all of the White sox

[@brendanthebomber.]

Same here

[@mlbwhitesox1320]

Exactly but I thought who was worst then Martin was Chuckie Robinson

[@ryanroggenbuck942]

Holy shit white Sox fans still exist😂

[@csnide6702]

Crochet and Robert are good ..... the rest ..? I agree with you .... especially GM

[@rrkumar78]

@@ryanroggenbuck942baseball fan here. Can we add a category for worst owner and give it to the White Sox with honorable mention to the A’s?

[@kingstonperez-2484]

bobby Miller has so much potential, every single game he played I was thinking he was gonna turn it all around and show us what he can do, but as usual every game he played he gave up around 10 runs in the first inning and crushed my spirits

[@Willy_Gee]

as a marlins fan this how I feel about Edward Cabrera he pitches like a cy young contender for a game or two then blows up in the fourth or fifth inning and gets injured for two weeks it's been like this for like 3 years now

[@TTGamingTrinh]

He was pretty good last year, but injury crushed his confidence. Hopefully he’ll bounce back next year😂

[@SuperCatacata]

@@TTGamingTrinh Never seen a pitcher spiral out of control so easily. Once Miller gave up 1 run, he would fall apart and instantly give up 5 more. Dude needs a sports psychologist or something, because his mental fortitude isn't strong enough.

[@massey4business]

The hell you talking about? 🤔

[@mitchellbucher1145]

Reminded me much of Michael Kopech’s time as a starter on the White Sox

[@Gcool243]

Jose Ramirez punched the talent out of Tim Anderson lol

[@mikewager3897]

Lmao nice

[@DemonKingBadger]

Heh, I just know Anderson getting punched was a long time coming

[@tstudios6469]

The fact that Eddie Rosario hit .175 with 8 HR and -1.8 war with bad defense is not on the list is wild.

[@DarthRich200]

as an angels fan. dont even get me started with drury bro 😭🙏🏽 we literally called him brandon “free out” drury

[@buzzawuzza3743]

Not so long ago teams were fighting for Tim Anderson.

[@asterhal5233]

Tim still stunned after the hit from Ramirez.

[@helloman3676]

Tim found out he's not him and that killed his confidence 🤣🤣🤣

[@TheJackyl1313]

not so long ago teams were fighting tim anderson

[@ryanroggenbuck942]

@@TheJackyl1313trueeeee

[@bobothegoat]

Feel like Mitch Garver deserves a shout-out for his time at DH. In the EIGHTY THREE games that the Mariners stubbornly left him at DH, he had a .170/.277/.356 slash line.

[@na78981]

These players may in fact suck but they are still 1000 times better than any of us watching this video.

[@PresidentFuller]

Well Maldonado is probably 600 times better than us lol

[@BigMonkey77]

Man as a Dodgers fan it hurts to see Bobby Miller play so poorly, his stuff is nasty but he didn’t seem to execute

[@Jarrett_Lee]

I'm surprised Chris Taylor didn't make this list. Man was.... something else this year

[@BigMonkey77]

@@Jarrett_LeeYeah Taylor is something else

[@Jarrett_Lee]

@@BigMonkey77 Not gonna shit on him too hard cuz I know he contributed a ton to the team but yeah probably an exit coming real soon

[@BigMonkey77]

@@Jarrett_Lee Yeah definitely, Taylor used to be a solid player too, tuff to see this level of decline

[@tombrown8443]

he declimed as soon as he signed a new contract. washed uo as soon as he got the $$$

[@johnf1235]

Jordan Montgomery should have been a honorable mention

[@texanfournow]

Rangers fan. Sigh of relief in order. And with a $25M price tag, I am guessing he was the "worst-per-buck" of this bunch.

[@madethecut]

That’s fair lol, he was up there for consideration!

[@EMiles802]

yeah the cardinals ran away with saggaese in that deal lmao

[@PaulStehr-o6t]

He’ll be back this year. He didn’t get a spring training in 24

[@joshuabarclay1550]

Incredible to see so many former top prospects on here. Great video!

[@isaacwebb7918]

Guys don't get the opportunity to play this many games without giving people some reason to believe they might get better. Someone with highly-rated-prospect status or at least one tool that seems to have potential to 'break out' once he 'finally puts it all together' might be given more leash, at least on a bad team, in the hopes they'll finally play up to what people expect. Players doing the same awful performance from whom no one's expecting better play any day now don't get the chance to play 50+ games, they get released.

[@aznpikachu215]

I thought Anthony 'Baseball is just a job' Rendon on this list.

[@danielwallsten332]

11:48 Even Maldonado was able to get a hit off of him 😂

[@NicolasBaker-w5l]

Mitch Garver, most god awful DH in history. A sub-200 DH, something only the Mariners could pull off...

[@Payythakidd]

As a os fan kimbrel 2nd half may be the saddest worst performance by a closer in major league history his post asb era is around 12.3 they shuffled him out there about 20 more times after he lost his closer role and he got shelled nearly every time his falloff needs to be studied

[@Sammy_Boy_Smith]

Hey! .... As a Dodger fan, all of us had his running joke in 2022 that when Craig Krumble came in, it was game over..for us. At the very least, he'd load the bases or get some runners on, and or have to have someone else come in that very inning, and waste other relievers. He was a joke all year, and we were wanting him DFA'd since June! When the Phillies took him in 2023, we fans were going to Philly chats and giving our condolences. " You're gonna hate this guy! you're gonna lose a bunch cuz of him. You're NOT gonna fix anything in the playoffs with this guy anchored to the back of your Ferrari. Lol". And They were doing the same thing we dodged fans did in the off-season when the O's signed him! .... " WHY " ?! FUN FACT: We won 111games in 2022. Kimberly - was 1-6 with 6 blown saves ( 4 we ended up losing). 10 fn game's we lost cuz of him! The Mlb record is 116 The NL record is: 112. If we could've won 2 more games, we'd be best all time in NL, plus 3rd best all-time in MLB. MS 116 • 1998 Yanks 114 • Reds n other team tied for 3rd with 113. Pitt & ? Tied for 4th with 112. And we're tied with Mets for 4th at 111. Our previous closer: Kenly Jansen: 5-2 5 blown ( 2 lost) We have the record! . We have the avg WAR closer: 3-3 5 blown (3 lost) : we win 4 more games to put at us 115 wins, to be best in NL wins of all time. 2nd most all alone in MLB . Soooooo, u can see where we're a little salty 🧂🧂. Lol What happened to the O's this year? Lol .... Same thing that'll happen to the team that signs him this season coming up! I hope it's the Padres!?

[@kiefdemon1979]

Jordan Walker defense sucks at RF because he's a 3rd Baseman that they threw out there without giving him any reps there. I'm pretty sure he's playing 3rd base in the minors.

[@PrazMaster]

Andrew Benintendi not making this as the worst LF is wild. Not a criticism of this list, just shocked that there was a LF worse than him.

[@spartacusgladiator]

Jordan Montgomery and Paul Sewald should have been on your list. We will PAY other teams to take them off of our roster!

[@rich7787]

I love these best/worst videos

[@aldenationvideos2582]

I think Noelvi Marte returning from his PED suspension hurt us more than it helped us lol. Reds might have actually made it to the postseason if his suspension had been for a whole year

[@HisCrazinessMike]

Clay Holmes wasn't considered for worst closer? really?

[@dougfowler1368]

Is anyone old enough to remember when you could first make teams with a a Commodore 64 game from strategic Sports Inc.? Who made a team like this with players from the early 80s, the addition to various all-star teams.

[@Essex626]

For DH, why not Mitch Garver? His numbers last year after he shifted to mostly backup catcher were acceptable for a backup catcher, but he hit .168 at DH playing there more than half of the season.

[@madethecut]

Still somehow was more productive overall, especially considering he played at T-Mobile.

[@pauldobobuto1031]

As a Paul Goldschmidt fan, 2024 was painful to watch, but now I see that things could have ended worse...

[@nathanjm000]

My team qualified players only C-Logan O’Hoppe 1B-Ty France 2B-Colt Kieth SS-Orlando Arcia 3B-Christopher Morel LF-Bryan De La Cruz CF-Leody Taverez RF-Adolis Garcia DH-Andrew McCutchen P-Patrick Corbin P-Miles Mikolas P-Griffin Canning P-Brandon Pfaadt P-Kyle Gibson

[@Runner2720]

The fall of of javy Baez and Tim Anderson need to be studied

[@mikekinsella2822]

laziness and contentment after a big pay day is all it is. .

[@PrimarySweeper13]

Though it hurts to say, Gelof was the leader in strikeouts this year which I saw first handed

[@oscarcastro6203]

damn i want him to do well

[@victortachiquin4965]

Suggestion: When you make videos like this can you please explain the stat meanings? I watch a ton of baseball but I don't know what the heck most of these WAR stats and all that even mean.

[@ShedTech8]

Love your videos big dawg

[@lktime]

I thought Bobby Miller was gonna do well because he throws the ball pretty darn fast and has other nasty pitches! He just didn’t do good at locating the pitches! How do you guys think Bobby Miller will do in 2025?

[@madethecut]

Hopefully well, though his underlying numbers don't look great. Still has the stuff to be a frontline guy though.

[@Zahrul3]

He hangs his offspeed pitches way too often, and tips hitters of his next pitch

[@dannylim3318]

He's young enough to catch on with a team, but not with the Dodgers. 2024 was the last year of his contract. With the return of Glasnow, Ohtani, May and Kershaw, etc. from the injured list, they should have plenty of starters especially with the signing of Snell, and the availability of Yamamoto. Miller only pitched so much because of the injuries.

[@duskreqm]

@@dannylim3318 The Dodgers aren't getting rid of Miller. He'll start 2025 in AAA with the goal of seeing if Miller can pitch himself back to the majors.

[@jevn11]

I was surprised to see Mitch Garvey not win DH but makes sense why he didn’t cause if there’s one thing he did kinda well was get walked

[@finbarTTV]

This could easily have been filled with just the White Sox players 😂

[@Sammy_Boy_Smith]

2025 list for Pitcher: Noah Synderguard he's throwing in the high 90's again, and is concentrating fully on making a comeback. .... It wont happen. Not long anyways. He wants to go back to his former self. Like CT3, ( Chris Taylor) he won't change his game, and admit defeat. Necessity is the mother of all change.

[@lanceweaver4830]

I really thought it was going to be nothing but White Sox players.

[@KirstenLass]

The Marlins did not develop Nick Gordon. He was literally in the Twins organization every year until 2024.

[@madethecut]

I get that, but his 2024 represents a year of underdevelopment with the Fish, which is why I mentioned the other guys as well to show the pattern overall.

[@coopertown_95]

Nick Gordon was a decent player as recently as 2022 when he posted an OPS+ of 111. The Marlins just have subpar development

[@PurpleSwordfish]

@@madethecut Just admit it was a bad take in regard to Nick Gordon. He was a Twins prospect, he's 28, there's not a lot the Marlins are going to do to develop a 28-year-old 1st round bust. Cabrera might just not be that great and Luzardo has had good seasons since coming to the Marlins. 2.0 WAR in 2022, 4.0 WAR in 2023 and 0.9 WAR last year dealing with injuries. He got better enough with the Marlins to get trade interest from multiple teams and a somewhat decent return despite the continued injury concerns. Would you give the Marlins credit for "developing" Jake Burger? I mean, factually you wouldn't because he wasn't a Marlins prospect. But, *you* wouldn't because you just have to pile on a team that is bad because they don't spend money. That's not about development, that's financial.

[@quigonkenny]

It's unfortunate that Maldonado's personal stats have gotten so bad, because his real strengths don't really show up on his stat sheet. Pitchers love him, because he's very good at calling games. And he's a great leader in the clubhouse. Unfortunately, age has very much caught up with him. I think his best bet at this point is to go into management. If he does, I'd be quite surprised if he wasn't heading a major league club within the next 5-10 years.

[@Ruthlesshauser]

Should definitely have been the entire sox roster

[@Frog_602]

Mitch garver deserves a spot but who knows at what position

[@dre32pitt]

2:42 I dont think anyone could've hit this Hogwarts-ian breaking ball lolol

[@Sportseditmaker595]

The standard glove 😆

[@johnpanfili1062]

Kinda crazy how a lot of these players were actually decent or even pretty good just couple years ago

[@paradiseproductions1313]

Suwinski and Bednar mentioned 💯

[@EnzoDinelli]

as I pirates fan, one of the OF spots has to go to Bryan De la Cruz. That guy was terrible

[@madethecut]

He was up there!

[@BigPat216]

He and Suwinski both broke my heart. Literally all BDLC had to do was be better than him and he was somehow worse.

[@Notkimbosliced]

Genuinely shocked Maeda managed to avoid the list

[@pamelarussell4440]

You say a third of the season is 50 games it is 54 games

[@mariyaswanson7136]

Cubs fan here- Very surprised Kyle Hendricks or Isaac Paredes didn’t make the list. Maybe if Isaac Paredes had played like he played on the cubs he would’ve been on the list

[@wesleycampbellcaretto6942]

2:46 what on earth is he doing???? That's horrible. I don't think I've ever seen a first baseman look that lost

[@michaelhupal9161]

This would have been a solid team at one point. Makes sense though because to be that bad and still get playing time there needs to be a decent track record

[@MaadhatsOnTwitch]

Mitch Hanigar/Garver not being here is surprising

[@paulbrower5867]

The Detroit Tigers improved greatly when they benched Javier Baez. Such shows how important a shortstop is. He used to be a good player. Maybe he is no longer a shortstop.

[@krizm]

worst pro players are so much better than ur average athlete but superstars are so consistent which is the separation

[@InglouriousBradsterd]

"Have we seen any more of an anemic campaign?" lol

[@KikeHernandezsMustache]

In terms of eye test, with no numbers to back it up, I can’t remember seeing any player as bad as lenyn Sosa on the white sox

[@WNB_Guy912]

Even as a Rockies fan, I despise Ty Blach and I hate the fact he’s even on the Rockies (only for his performance, his dog looks cool).

[@doug6259]

I knew Tijuan Walker would be on this list. He became an automatic loss for the Phillies.

[@DSTEWGOD]

Minnesota would be to blame for Gordon’s poor development, not the franchise he only became a part of last offseason.

[@mickeysanders74]

Gd to see NO Seattle Mariners on this list.

[@Chefraft]

Garver def should have been

[@jackgruber2147]

Crazy the no. 1 and no. 2 worst starters were from the no. 1 and no. 2 seeds, respectively

[@WelziFC1]

Walker is literally a cancer to a rotation. Not only do I hope he never suits up for the Phillies again I do not wish any team in the league to have to put up with him.

[@MagnoliaSivverson]

I am convinced Martin Maldonado played drunk

[@charlesmccallie7402]

Genuinely went into this video expecting more White Sox than we got.

[@geneglenn5119]

The professor for the cubs. He fell off so bad this year as a starting pitcher. He deserved to be on this list. Anytime he was pitching i basically chalked up a L for that one. Reverse it and we also had one of the best starting pitchers who i hope to see in your best at position video

[@timgrisham9051]

Tim Anderson also won a batting championship in 2019. Dude forgot how to hit.

[@fuhbox]

LeMahieu is getting old. sad. Also you absolutely nailed David Bednar for the closer. I watched five Pirates and I remember him blowing saves on all of them except for one. I thought he was good.

[@GameinHistory]

Some of these picks are brutal but fair Maldonado’s season really stands out for all the wrong reasons. Hopefully, some of these players can bounce back in 2025!

[@DSMTheEditor]

.174 SLG in 150 PA is absurd

[@mediocregameplays6612]

Martin Maldonado slander will never be tolerated.

[@Sammy_Boy_Smith]

@ MADE THE CUT- you forgot the bench/ utility player position? I will go ahead amd do it for ya bro: WORST UTILITY PLAYER: L A. Dodger's (ex) super Utility man- Chris Taylor! At 68 at bats, was hitting.067 ! He was hitting.130 up until August, then went up to a whooping.167 he also hit into many DP's, and lost a step on defense. Tho he still had a very accurate arm, plays most positions, and has a brain for the game. He is also very involved in the community! Nobody tries harder than him either.

[@andrewyarosh1809]

Given how much he’s being paid and how he took appearances from Austin Wells, I’d throw in a bonus catcher, Jose Trevino.😊

[@brianmckibben2400]

I almost hate to say it, but I feel like Alexis Diaz should've been an honorable mention for closer. The 3 you looked at were of course worse, but Diaz was well on his way to making this list for a while there 😂

[@morimo11]

The Wooden Glove and Lead Bat Awards

[@chris42069]

Tim Anderson won a BATTING TITLE. Think about that for a sec 😮 That JRam punch ended TA's career for real, he was NEVER the same after that.

[@not_tht_guy8499]

I'm surprised Kenta Maeda didn't take one of the pitcher spots

[@somerandomguy5977]

Walker has never been a strikeout guy and obsessing about a guy's strikeout rate being too low is stupid. As long as he's successful it shouldn't matter. A guy who should strikeout 6/K9 now has to try to strike extra guys out instead of getting quick outs, enticing contact early. Want to know why pitchers get hurt? Pitchers throw harder, strike guys out more, walk guys more. They're throwing more pitches per inning, harder, with more effort. There have been several great and above players that below average strikeout rates.

[@MaxwellGriffin001]

I drafted 4 of them on my fantasy team...worst draft ever bro...seriously

[@seizuss]

putting a coors pitcher seems unfair as bad as the numbers are

[@mam362]

Jordan Walker might get a freepass on his offense due to him being sent up and down all season, but the defense shouldn't have suffered the way it did because of that

[@andrewszaflarski5379]

Thanks in advance for the Chicago White Sox year in review.

[@YouDontKnowMebro69]

Love the channel!

[@SgtPepper4019]

put Jordan Walker back at third base. He has a rocket for an arm. Have a coach personally train him all offseason on footwork. Offensively he’ll be a star. He’s just a little raw and Oli butchered his development/confidence

[@petepyeatt6909]

Pitchers love Maldy, though. That should be mentioned.

[@davidmata4786]

Dodgers absolutely dodged a bullet with LeMahieu.. Rumor had it he didn't want to play for the Dodgers and that truly was a blessing in disguise..

[@Blackdog222]

DJ won a batting title with the Yankees. In his first year with the Yankees, he hit .327 with 26 home runs and 102 RBIs. Despite his down year in 2024 due in part to a serious foot injury, he still maintains a healthy and respectable .290 batting average over 14 years. Couple his .364 average in 2020 and his .348 average in 2016 with the Rockies, LeMahieu is the only player in MLB history to win batting titles in each league. Add four gold gloves and two silver slugger awards and this guy has a better resume than many in Cooperstown. There was a reason why the Dodgers and everyone else wanted him. The Dodgers would have been happy to have landed DJ.

[@davidmata4786]

@@Blackdog222 I'm referring to dude now, he's a shell of himself. Not trying to take anything away from his accomplishments, dude was sought after for a reason, he's just not that dude anymore. Dudes average, HR's, hits & RBI's have have been dipping in a downward trend since 2021. Is what it is.

[@ur_quainmaster7901]

It felt like Jose Abreu played 100 games.

[@bigsmokiee55]

So many current and former White Sox players smh

[@dlc435]

Many such cases

[@billybillington965]

imo 1/3 of the season is not a big sample size and it allows for some cop outs

[@MagnoliaSivverson]

Tim Anderson - from all star to all ass 🔥

[@mrmatches0619]

Maldonado... The ultimate tank commander.

[@BleedingBlueandOrange323]

Bryce Elder is the worst player to ever step on a baseball field

[@kurumauzamaki2731]

Surprised you didn’t mention martes ped suspension

[@EMiles802]

as sad as i am to see walker on here its deserved he needs to get a better eye at the plate desperately

[@somerandomguy5977]

Corbin Burnes' rookie season was worse and he bounced back. Over 8 ERA in more innings.

[@courtneyconaway3091]

I was expecting to see Orlando Arcia here

[@j.t.thomas9242]

DJ and Anderson have 3 batting titles between both of them and they both make this list…and as far as DJ the Yankees are still on the hook for the next 2 seasons. He can no longer hit major league pitching.

[@newocishim]

is nick gordon wearing an elbow gaurd on his knnee

[@cwolf208]

162 games in a year / 3 = 54 so therefore 50 games because 1/3 of a season minimum. Better measure would be plate appearances because a pinch hit, pinch run, or defensive sub would get you a "game played" but affect the results less. Whatever, it's not like methodology is critical in this anyway.

[@willscheib6098]

I knew there would be a Pirate on this list :(

[@gravitykat714]

Adolis Garcia ended Maldonados career really woke up those bats huh Maldonado?

[@malcolmting7127]

I wonder what this team will do better the White Sox or this team

[@mrpotato7396]

You should make a video about the worst popular players

[@Luke.Cooking]

The Javy Baez edition