🎨COTMAN vs PROFESSIONAL - WINSOR & NEWTON watercolour COMPARISON and REVIEW (2018)

[@druidobianco9734]

Perfect comparison. Both are outstanding paints, you can clearly see the professional line is more vibrant and smooth but the student line gives you really good colors for not so much money, therefore is a great option

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much Druido! 😊

[@Tiffany-bd1eb]

Thanks so much for this comparison! I just bought the Cotman set of 45. :) I was a reading lot of negativity on the Cotman set on Reddit and was doubting my purchase but your amazing owl shows me its potential. A great artist can always make it work! Also I really like the palette that comes with it and plan to use it in the long term haha.

[@oona3914]

I bought professional Winsor Newton half pan watercolors, but there is room for more paints and I was thinking should I mix things up and order a few cotman half pans or fully keep it professional. This video helped me see that some of the colors look almost the same, but in some of them there is a huge difference, so thank you!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

You are very welcome! 😊

[@Drumaier]

Yes i think the earth tones are almost the same. It makes sense since those pigments are cheap af.

[@rebeccanewberry3176]

Every time I'm at the art store I ask myself if the more expensive paints are worth it. The only other thing I wish I could see is a lightfast test (maybe putting the paper in the window for a few weeks and seeing the fade on each?). Thanks so much for showing these differences!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi Rebecca! I have a new video going up today at 4PM GMT which might be helpful! 😉

[@rebeccanewberry3176]

@@SarahNewburyArt can't wait! I'll keep an eye out 😃

[@deepeshbkenwar2353]

I keep on reading that the paints are tools and a good artist will be able to make the Cotmans work as well as the artists’ range. Now I’ve seen it. Awesome owl.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Aww Thank you! 😊😍

[@walterpierluissi1379]

I have been in watercolors since 2009 after spending over 20 years in Acrylics and about 6 years in Oils (which was my starting point back in late 1970's)... Ans since 2009 I have been a fan of Winsor and Newton art supplies... I started with the Cotman series and then move to the Professional ones; but still use Cotman as my prefer one for journals watercolors. And your review is actually splendid...

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much Walter!

[@gorway7]

Great review... I used Cotman for many years and still do for teaching and my own field sketch palette. I tend to buy only tube colours now and re fill any pans. The 21ml tubes, are great value and seem better quality than some of the Chinese made Cotman pans... don't know why! Some of the pan colours I have bought felt gritty on the palette and you could feel the slight abrasive texture if you ran your finger over the colour when it had dried on the paper - I have not had that with the tubes. Though I mainly paint with artist watercolours now, I have no qualms about mix and matching colours I like. WN Professional artist grade watercolour are more finely milled and you do notice more transparency in some colours like yellow ochre compared to the Cotman. One I can't live without is Cotman Cerulean Hue - I find it better behaved than genuine PB35 Cerulean and way cheaper - It mixes better, doesn't flocculate and is great for skies or cool shadow - Mix it with a little Ultramarine and you have a perfect Cobalt blue hue or add a little light red and you have pale greys for cloud shadow. It's a permanent part of my colour palette and I wouldn't swap it for anything. I have tried other artist grade - phthalo based Cerulean hues but keep coming back to the Cotman.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Peter! Its really interesting to hear your thoughts on tubes vs pans- I have recently read that the formulation of pans and tubes is different and each has its pros and cons - I may steer towards refilling the pans with tube paint as I use these up- I also really appreciate the advice re the Cotman Cerulean Hue- will definitely try that out!

[@sabihashehzad7391]

I agree with you as I also prefer cotman tubes

[@jonyoder2356]

Thanks for spending the time to paint such a beautiful owl for the sake of the comparison. I haven’t used watercolors since grade school so I’m excited to do it again but with much higher quality materials and more experience with painting (oil and acrylic).

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Jon! Enjoy your watercolour painting 😊

[@hansendesigns]

Sometimes a ‘Hue’ can be used when they replace toxic pigments, eg:cadmium

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you for the info! 😊

[@SNEAKchannel]

the best comparison!! great clip!!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! So glad you liked it! 😊

[@iraceruk]

What about the longevity of the paints? By which I mean both the 'light fastness' (degradation by UV Light over time) and the longevity of the paints themselves. I have an old set of professional half pans that must be thirty years old. They're still moist and I can still 'activate' them with a splash of water. I'm wondering if the Cotman range would last as long...

[@milyypink]

Great review! I’ve had a small cotman set for years that I only recently started getting good use out of so I was curious how the professional set compared. I’m a digital artist but I do a lot of ink and watercolor sketches, and while the professional set looks fantastic I don’t think the price is justified for loose sketching! The cotman set is great for throwing a splash of color onto something.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! I would love to try digital art, even just as a way to sketch out ideas but I struggle to get my head around how it all works! Hats off to you! 😊🌺

[@akgreengirl9876]

Thank you! I’m getting back into watercolors again and sorting through the different grades of paint can be a headache. This helped immensely! ❤️

[@SarahNewburyArt]

So glad to have helped! 😊🌸

[@Becktastic01]

I think i would buy the cadmiums instead of the hues, and maybe stick mostly with cotman otherwise. I noticed the professional looked creamier even when applying to paper which is nice but I doubt I would need a full set. Thank you for the recommendation of white gouache, very helpful tip!

[@Dao_Tui]

Love the own!!!! So nice. and thank you for the very nice video. I think they put the yellow ochre in because a lot of people seem to use it. I guess they took the most popular ones. A lot of beginners (me included) are a bit scared to use a certain colour if it really pops and you don't yet know where to put it. I started with the Cotman series. I LOVE them. But I decided to slowly upgrade. I use the tubes and make my own colour palette and it gives me the option to buy an empty mixing palette that is as big or small as I like. I got my first Cotman water colours as a small pan palette with 12 colours. I then bought an empty tin to add pans into and bought some already filled pans and some empty ones to use the tubes for the empty ones. Yesterday I bought my first 2 (tiny!) tubes of professional paint. I want to gather a good range of colours first , then use my new palette for the pro paints only. Will keep using the Cotman for practise and also for anything that is just for fun. Although I don't plan on going into paid art, I'd use the pro series for anything I would make especially for someone.

[@MrsBarnabas]

Many thanks, Sarah, for a clear and unbiased review and comparison - for your comment about the paper, too. :)

[@rmuller366]

I’m grateful to see the comparison here Sarah. I’m working my way through the New Botanical Painting book, and have found that starting for practice on the XL paper is somewhat frustrating. I’ll finish this pad for practice and warm up only. It felt as though the paper was fighting me. But then when I used cotton papers for the final piece (Fabriano and Strathmore) painting was like a delicious breeze, lol. Paper most certainly makes a big difference. Thank you for sharing!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi Rita! I agree, there's nothing quite like painting on cotton paper! 😊

[@donnaeturner]

Love your painting, thanks for the video.

[@BronzeDragon133]

Thank you--I was actually looking for a good student set to learn with, and you sold me on the Cotman!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hey Dragon! Thank you for watching- have fun with the Cotman, they're a good set 😊

[@happymv5350]

I loved your comparison approach! Look forward to more of your paint studies and opinions.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! 😊🎨

[@happymv5350]

The Art Hive - Thank you! I need to catch up on all your vids! Is there a WC paint you are curious about? I have a stock of several - happy to send you samples of anything I have - a mix of Holbein, M. Graham, QOR, Mission Gold, Daniel Smith, Old Holland, Lukas, Yarka - St. Petersburg/Jack Richeson palette. I also have a cool Peerless Bonus Pak - more ink than true watercolor - but so fun. Happy to share what I have!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Wow thats so kind of you! I have been curious about the QOR and M. Graham watercolours. 😊🎨

[@happymv5350]

The Art Hive - Heck yes - happy to send you samples of what I have! I forgot to mention I have a few Sennelier wc’s as well. Love the notion of sharing when I can......as there is nothing more satisfying than promoting/helping a fellow artist grow. Just ask you do the same when you are able - good karma! Will you please direct me to where I should send the sample set?

[@SarahNewburyArt]

I love the idea of sharing art supplies! Not sure the best way to send you an address though as don't want to share it everywhere? Ideas? 😊🎨

[@maurogatti2009]

Do NOT be sorry, you did a good job, did not talk too much and were really helpful. Thank you!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Mauro! 😊

[@pesto12601]

Lol.. someone as good as yourself could use dirt and the painting would come out great. For those of us that are NOT artists.... either will work just fine. Thx.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

😂 Very kind of you to say! 😊

[@jamesfollon]

As someone who is a beginner, I find these videos very helpful but jumping in at the deep end can be a good way of starting. Experiment, make mistakes, and then do it again. I thought this was a good video for someone at my level.

[@denisesheehan9189]

Amazing owl! My bottom line are Cotmans and Art Spectrum. Using water colour of lower quality than these 2 has frustrated me so much that painting became hard work.

[@KOUGA108]

Is it bad if I actually liked the Cotman version of the owl more 😂, idk but the reddish brown feathers on the cotman side just looks a lot more interesting to my eyes. I am a beginner at watercolor and those are some Insane skills you got there. Didn’t know it’s possible to get so real drawings with watercolor.

[@theadster2702]

Beautiful owl!!!! Great video full of info.

[@notvangogh]

That was a great comparison! Thank you so much! You are very talented! The owl was so lifelike!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you, you are very kind! 😊

[@bonfoon]

Thank you for the comparison and review. I'm a student and will now start with the Cotman

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Glad it was helpful! Happy painting! 😊

[@asli5956]

I have the 12 pan version of cotman and some colors separate after mixing

[@iknownothing-49]

Thank you...you’ve soothe my anxiety about having the Cotman set. Plus, I do have a few better watercolor tubes that I can switch out.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

You're welcome! I think the type of paper you use makes more difference than the paint and the Cotman paints are good so enjoy them 😊

[@suegoodfellow3687]

Thank you so much for this comparison, very helpful indeed & nicely narrated.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! I'm glad it was helpful!

[@bushrarehman]

Your review is spot on. I have used both but honestly i could not paint so well with the cotman series on that paper like you did❣️

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much Bushra! 😊

[@bushrarehman]

@@SarahNewburyArt It's a pleasure

[@bigboyanimation3799]

Hello, do the professional version have more then 24 colors or only 24?

[@ejicon3099]

Great comparison. I current have/use the Cotman set and haven't had an issues with them but seeing how much easier it is to work with the professional series, I'm sold. The owl painting is beautiful. Now, I'm curious if there's a big difference between tube liquid paint and these dry watercolor paints. Thanks for sharing.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much! I have done a video fairly recently on the difference between pans and tubes - not sure if you've seen it or fancy a watch but in case you do, here's the link 😊 kzbin.info/www/bejne/gIibqaCmeq6no6M

[@producer73]

Little trick I've used for man years in removing tape, and or any sticker. At my art table I keep a Black n Decker heat gun in a custom holster. I use that heat gun mostly to remove my masking tape from my paintings.

[@esling77]

Ty for this. I know that Cotton Paper is the only way to go and that being said Hats off for this Super Awesome comparison done on Paper that everyone can afford.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much! 😊

[@jendesign5537]

I just received the professional set today. Right away I was disappointed when doing the swatches. Prussian Blue & Viridian, are pastel instead of deep rich bright colors. Also as you mentioned there is no dark brown. Some of the paints have an almost gel like texture which I see a lot in lower end watercolors. A lot of the browns in this set have that gel like feel and I just couldn’t get the colors to show any depth. I have almost every brand watercolor there is and I have to say Schminke, Mission Gold, Danial Smith & White Nights are so much nicer rich and vibrant.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

I get what you're saying!- I do have a few of the tubes of Winsor and Newton which I think seem to have richer pigments but I always end up going back to Schminke or my Mission Gold set. I love trying out new paints and its interesting to compare them- I haven't tried the white Nights yet but hopefully will get to try them out at some point. Its great to get other peoples opinions so thank you for commenting 😊🎨

[@jendesign5537]

Thank you for your reply! Love the owl, excellent review.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

You're welcome 😊😍

[@chyanneperez1301]

What paints would you recommend for a beginner with a decent budget? I am torn between these two sets but if there are other companies you might suggest, I’d love some feedback!

[@unicornattacke6684]

@@chyanneperez1301 i got Schmincke watercolors for my Birthday. They are the best watercolors and, because they are a german brand, always high quality. They also overfill the tubes sometimes, that means you get more paint than you pay for. And the tin case the colours comes with has a lot of mixing areas. The also have a selection of over 140 colours, that is a lot. Schmincke watercolors have only one flaw, one of their manny yellow tones can't get mixed well whit one of their manny purple tones. It looks weird. But when do you even mix these colours in the first place? 🥴 ( I forgot the names of the colours ) Schminke is really expensive but you absolutely get what you pay for. Winsor and Newton on the other hand is good for sketches and doodles, yknow stuff where you kinda waste paint. And they are super good for travelling and mostly designed for exactly that.

[@MaryYoungblood-xy8vg]

I just bought a 14 PC Cottman field set of half pans. I can't afford W&N yet. I like them.

[@CozyCreates]

They have a canson xl watercolor pad to use also

[@MrQuuze]

Bigger differenfce whyat i imagined. i used cotman years ago and still have some artist range pans but slowly go very likely fully Schimcke Horodam works so much better for my personal needs.

[@marvelenia6702]

The Cotman Series is vegan, the professional is not. That is why for me personally only the Cotmans have moved into my art supplies. Thank you for the review!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Marvelenia! I've learned something new! 😊

[@montygemma]

I use either depending on what work I'm doing. If I am painting an English landscape in March I'd use Cotman, If I was painting a summer or Mediterranean scene that had strong colour I'd use the artist quality. Very often I use both in the same work.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thanks for your comment Syd! Tha's really interesting !🙂

[@coolkid-xc1yi]

Have you tried the white nights paints? If you have, how do they compare to the professional W&N watercolors?

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi! I have some but haven't used them yet so will have to let you know!

[@deejay2838]

Great info, and love the owl!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thanks DeeJay! 😍

[@abipaine5067]

Blimey. ABsolutely stunning. Subscribed. Can't miss out on your talent!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much Abi! Enjoy the rest of your weekend 😊

[@sondrabrown442]

Great comparison review and love the owl!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Sondra 😊

[@FelineFurKin]

I’ve got the pro set, thank goodness for the £100-off offers they have sometimes. I also have a 12 set of Cotman from about 1999 and some are a little paler or a different shade eg sap green, but some shades seem nicer in some way or not very different. Just bought the Cotman 12 tube set so I’ll see how that goes, I’m having to be frugal right now.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi Carryl! I always look out for special offers as sometimes you need to experiment to find what you like best and it can get expensive. I think you'll enjoy the Cotman tube set as I've heard lots of good things about them. Happy holidays 😊

[@TandZAptLife]

That was wonderful! I will never get anything as beautiful as that made, but I know I will have fun using the paint. I did not know that you're supposed to tape down the paper. Maybe that's why I struggle so much with my paper buckling. So I will do that. Is that masking tape?

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! The tape I use is either washi tape (in this painting) or scotch magic tape. Happy Painting! 😊

[@lilitincher4973]

Great comparison! Just what I was looking for. Thank you.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Lili! Have a great week 😊

[@JorjaZanetta]

I really can use both, in different type of works...of course the professional set it's more pigmented, but the Cotman set it's perfect for diary paints.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

I totally agree! 😊

[@terencemolloy1827]

I have the professional set but the quality these days isn't so good. I mainly use Jackson's artists paint from tubes now. Big tubes at reasonable prices

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi Terence, that's really good to know- I will have to try them out, thank you 😊

[@muskndusk]

At 9:50 do you mean glycerine rather than gelatine?

[@evagharabaghi3106]

Great review, thanks for sharing!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Eva! 😊

[@rosieroro7490]

Beginner here 🙋🏻‍♀️ Thank you for the video 🌸💜

[@SarahNewburyArt]

You're so welcome Rosie! 😊

[@khueng139]

I'm going to buy a new watercolor soon this video is so helpful

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! Exciting buying new watercolours! Have fun 😊

[@rackpunch4026]

Very helpful Sarah. Do you stretch your paper? I'm a complete novice and so far haven't mastered the art of stretching without the paper sticking to my board 🤔 I wondered what your take on it was. (I'm currently using a gator board)

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! I haven't stretched my paper before as typically I paint in my sketchbook or on blocks (where the paper edges are glued on all 4 sides). Washi tape seems to keep the paper flat enough on smaller pieces of artwork (A4 or less) and then I tape my paper down to a board, but if I was painting on larger pieces I would have to look into it!

[@rackpunch4026]

@@SarahNewburyArt Thanks Sara, this old watercolour lark isn't as easy as it looks 😁

[@sabihashehzad7391]

Cotman tubes are very good, buy all the single pigment colors from cotman and some convenient mixed colors like indigo, Paynes gray and sap green 😊

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Sabiha! Great advice 😊

[@sabihashehzad7391]

@@SarahNewburyArt actually I missed writing I buy 😀 I'm happy if you take it as a advice 😊

[@gryla5290]

So this is what a god tier set looks like. I've heard a lot of praises towards the cotman set, which I've learned later on was only their student set, so I couldn't imagine how much better the professional set was.

[@malimillions]

Wonderful comparison!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much! 🙂

[@moistwater8289]

I prefer the professional because it will last you longer and you'll get the most out of your money

[@throughmyeyes9940]

if you do layering, use Cotman

[@MadroneHumanRights]

Very helpful thank you.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

You're welcome!

[@mjpete27]

You have done a nice job with your comparison, I would also offer that you are an exceptional artist and you can create a wonderful painting with any grade of paints! I have become a convert to DaVinci Paints from California. Great professional paints at very affordable prices! I am a true fan of Denise Soden “In Liquid Color” her Earth Friendly Palette is a wonderful selection for just about every subject matter. Have you ever tried DaVinci paints? Thank you for sharing your expertise and this lovely video! Have a lovely day.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you, you are very kind! I would love to try Da Vinci watercolours- especially Denise's earth friendly palette but sadly, they aren't easy to get hold of here. I could order them direct from the Da Vinci website but I think delivery is quite expensive. Have a great week 😊

[@kathy8818]

wow! the owl looks great

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Kathy! 😊

[@kathy8818]

@@SarahNewburyArt yw

[@imrobie5758]

Very helpful, thank you!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

You are so welcome- Glad it was helpful!

[@melk6079]

It works fine if you apply Cotman in layers? it doesn´t wash off from the paper? (sorry english is not my native language)

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi Mel! As long as you let the paper dry completely in between layers it should be fine but it will also depend on the paper you are using. The better the paper, the easier it will be for you 😊

[@melk6079]

@@SarahNewburyArt Thank you so much!

[@sherrygraham8650]

Would you consider the Colman’s be a good starter set for a somewhat beginner? If not what would your recommend?

[@SarahNewburyArt]

HI Sherry! Thanks for your comment! Yes, I would say Cotman are pretty good for a beginner- I know quite a few people who use them- another set which you might consider is the White Nights watercolours 😊🎨

[@sherrygraham8650]

Thank you, I’m planning on gifting myself a set next week for my birthday.

[@LukeHanlonArt]

Wow the owl is stunning! 🦉 Have you tried any water colour pencils before? I don’t really use watercolours but I find the pencils with brush pens work for me a lot easier because I am hopeless with a paint brush haha

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thanks! Only done a few bits with watercolour pencils but probably need to give them another try soon!

[@mahmoudsaz7027]

Woow fantastic work my dear friend. You are so talented stay connected 👏👏👏👏🌹🌹

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much 😀

[@CozyCreates]

If you want they sell the individual half pans to add to the set.

[@STICKYArt]

Love these paints! I just reviewed the tubes!

[@johnallison9174]

Nice side by side comparison ...

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much John! 😊

[@gillypend]

Fascinating! Thank you.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

So glad you enjoyed it! Take care 😊

[@mekagooden4915]

Love the comparisons. The cotman set looks more warm the professional is more cool toned.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Meka! 😊

[@anahiflores7202]

*sigh* I feel a little bit disappointed after watching the video. I am from Argentina, yesterday I payed for the cotman set $3000 pesos (or €48/£43) and now I get to know that they're the cheapest tool even though it's Winsor and Newton. They were expensive as hell if we talk about pesos, so I feel sad to be honest. And altough practice and hard work are heavier than tools lets say, I feel terrible; Shop sellers here believe that they are selling you the ultimate profesional set and they know nothing. Much less I do! Gosh. So much money inverted in something that is ment for students and there are Much better things. I feel so fooled. RATS!! I will try my best with my set but still... gosh.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi Anahi! Don't feel sad, many artists use the cotman sets and love them! Yes, they are advertised here as student grade paints not professional- but that's not to say they aren't still really good. Get some good quality paper if you can that's 100% cotton -as this makes more of a difference ( in my opinion!), to your painting than the paints themselves. Use the cotman set you've got and enjoy them. You can always replace them with higher grade paints if you want to, once these have run out. 😀

[@nicoleo5017]

I'm from Dominican Republic, and it's the same here, I expend $15 on a set of cheap brushes, and then found them in amazon for $5 or so, I guess they are also charging custom fees and stuff, but still... 😕

[@jaccusefashion]

Don’t feel bad at all, the Cotman range is amazing. A lot of pro’s use cotman. They are as good and better than a lot of so called pro paints

[@amyx231]

I upgraded to Cotman last year. It’s a world apart from the cheaper paints. You’ll go far with Cotman.

[@solitaarts]

oh que pena,aca se re abusan pero los colores no se ven tan malos, me ayudaste mucho y te agradezco :c

[@johnf4659]

can you fit a full sized pan in the tin if you put it side ways?

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi John-Yes, you can fit a full size pan, sideways in the tin 😊

[@johnf4659]

@@SarahNewburyArt That's great. Thanks

[@beaast4249]

Very interesting, thank you!

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Bea! 😊

[@tuanaboglu2641]

Can I ask somethin canson block is good or bad

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Hi Tuana. I have not tried the canson block but the mixed media sketchbook I used in this video is ideal for trying out ideas, quick sketches and testing supplies 😊

[@tuanaboglu2641]

The Art Hive thank you soo much ❤️

[@tuanaboglu2641]

The Art Hive you are soo talented and I love your arts realy😊💗

[@tuanaboglu2641]

Good I love it thank you soo much 😊

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you, I'm glad you like it! 😊

[@zulrechdog1739]

I prefer more phthalo blue(PB15) to Winsor blue(PB15), it is intense and a little more transparent.

[@juliab.8200]

Thank you 🤩

[@SarahNewburyArt]

You’re welcome 😊

[@weepingangel8190]

not to different from eachoter, i feel like the cotman just needs more layers to achieve that good bleed effect

[@Tolentine0_0]

I can't even afford to buy a cotman haha. Btw your painting looks so cool, its so beautiful

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much 😀

[@amyx231]

The right eye...it’s piercing my soul. There’s just something special about the right side.

[@IcebulletZ]

Cotman is fine. It's not as vibrant but workable for sure. Stunning owl.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Jayce 😊

[@thisisart3750]

How about reeves?

[@SarahNewburyArt]

My very first watercolour palette was a Reeves one but in my opinion, the cotman watercolours are more pigmented and perform far better. The Reeves palette I had was a set of 12 pans and I seem to remember them being quite chalky?😊

[@thisisart3750]

@@SarahNewburyArtRevees under Windsor newton.. how about Winsor?

[@sakurasoftware2313]

The cotman set is more ment for students therefore a wider range of pigments such as Indian Red. The professional set is for professionals who know colour theory and can make MOST of the color wheel with just the primary plus black, so everything else is like a convenient bonus. Most professionals don't need more then 12 premade colours to work with. They're just there for convenience.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Good point. 😊

[@SathishKumar-pw9fu]

Owls eye looks vibrant on both cotman and professional

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you 😊

[@advaithrvasistha44]

Your painting is awesome@

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much! 😊

[@advaithrvasistha44]

Btw i am 14 and I have an art channel kzbin.info/www/bejne/emGypn5qor2sg7s Plz check it out Love from India

[@johnnyrbattaglio6943]

Thank You 👍

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! 😊

[@Becca-UK]

Awesome video. Thank you so much 🙏 subscribed 😃 x

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you so much Becca! 💜

[@seannethecloud]

Honestly there isnt much difference apart from the professional set has more pigment. With the Cotman set they are completely fine and you can get the same pigment depending on how much water you use or how many layers you use.

[@slvva]

Pigment in professional is different than in Cotmans. Looks the same but isn't and if you paint something in Cotmans and hang on your wall, after few months you will be disappointed how your colours look like.

[@lindsayspoon4783]

Very interesting 🧐

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you 😊

[@lindsayspoon4783]

@@SarahNewburyArt no, thank you ! 😊 i appreciate the time, energy, effort and $$ you put into this to help other artists/creatives out!

[@TheSunshineCrafterKellyFusco]

Great review! Thx

[@Iennaish]

Just bought a cotman set for a friend's birthday 😂

[@EveHarveyArt]

Nice mate well done :)

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you! 😊

[@jessicapearson9479]

Actually they make a 48 colour set.

[@TheSunshineCrafterKellyFusco]

Ps...awesome Owl! Wow

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Thank you Kellly! 😊

[@SarahNewburyArt]

*Kelly not Kellly ?!

[@danaparsonsliquidcosmosart2669]

if only I had started watercolor when that pro pan was 50.. it's now 100.. ow

[@SarahNewburyArt]

Ouch! I usually wait til there's an offer on! 😊

[@davebryan1890]

There's deals on the professional set on Amazon for £40/45 for the 24 half pan set

[@montygemma]

I use both qualities depending on what I'm painting. The Cotman are good but lack strong colour intensity so if I'm painting an English landscape I'm more likely to use Cotman, if it's a Mediterranean scene I'd use the Professional. Sometimes I'll paint the sky and distance in Cotman and the foreground in Professional that works well.

[@SarahNewburyArt]

That's really interesting, thank you! 😊