Lessons From Ramayana

[@hearticulture6903]

In Kamba ramayan in tamil, Hanuman is called "sollin selvan", meaning the person who has the best articulation of words. The way Kamba ramanyan says is, when Hanuman comes back after finding Sita in Lanka to Rama, the way he uses words to convey is this. Normally in tamil we say, "sita was found", like stating "Sitayai kanden". However he thinks if I just say the word Sita first, Ram might break down thinking, something happened to her. Hence he says "Kanden Sitayai" meaning "SAW SITA" though it is not the right sentence formation in Tamil. Kambar poet states, Hanuman in such a way that he understands peoples emotion and changes his vocabulary to that extent.

[@aditeerao9455]

You know who is ramkinkar??

[@ASinUSA]

Ll

[@tyson2810]

Somebody tag makers of Adipurush so they read this comment

[@ElN246]

​@@tyson2810I was here to comment this same thing

[@Rabonykannan]

So it is all the writer's wish to set the characterisation to the Lead characters of the fictions ....

[@nitinnimkar1654]

Amiji is having good command on Sanskrit. And that's wonderful.

[@ShubhamPandey-jk9gw]

Nice to see that people are appreciating that the two holiest and most revered books of hindus are rewritten by a woman . Hope girls who say hinduism is most misogynistic , get some inspiration from her.

[@RahulChauhan-ny7zs]

Feminist be like : yeh toh na ho payega 🤷😂

[@punyashloka4946]

Hindu society has misogyny whether you like it or not yes it is not like Islam and Christianity, plus monotheistic religion in general is more violent in nature because of their theology. But that does not mean hindu society do not have discrimination whether it is caste based faultlines or gender based discrimination. Before anybody go crazy let me make it clear I am a practicing hindu and do not support leftist or feminist propaganda against hindus.

[@NoRiceToEat]

Hinduism is the least misogynistic

[@worldsoldestcivilization]

Lets stop giving importance to what leftists say.

[@RahulChauhan-ny7zs]

@@worldsoldestcivilization most of left people in India are dumb as right in india 🤷😂 But we should be talking about them who holds good position at many levels eg study economics interal issues etc etc Those are the real danger Not these idiots on twitter who got like lakhs or millions of followers. The main people know who to use these dumb wannabe left people and how easily they can get rid of them 🤷

[@sushmasingh8008]

Badhiya discussion! Sitaji ko ' bechari,Dukhiyari Parityakta' dikhane me Hmare sanskrit or Hindi ke mahan Sahityakaron ne bhi koi kor - kasar nahi chhodi. Phir filmon me bhi pati dwara tyagi hui,dukhiyari stree ki tulna hmesha Sitaji se ki gai. Is par kabhi vichar nahi kiya gaya ki Sita ji swayam ek rajkumari thin.Or Rajdharm ki shiksha unhe apne Shreshth Raja Pita Janak se mili thi.Raja ke kartavya wo bhali - bhanti samjhti thi.Or uske palan me Raja Ram ka poorn sahyog karti thi. Jaise filmkar creative liberty ke nam per manmani kar lete hain,usi tarah Kaviyon or lekhkon ne bhi Ram Katha batane me bharpur liberty li.Or thathyon ko Toda maroda hai.

[@priharahj5515]

30:00 i feel so much when i knw how much ramji missed sitaji how helpless he felt.. my eyes teared cant stand even imagining the pain he went thru

[@AstonishSingh]

Consequently 2nd great one Kushal! Great Podcast..Half the work is Right Guest, half of the rest is Right Questioning (Anchoring/Steering) and last 25% objective solutions explained in the Subjective manner.. KUDOS Bhai! And to Ami Ji❤️🙏🏻

[@drvarun4]

Jai shri Ram. Big fan of Ami ji. And sir what to say about you, thanks a ton to change the whole prospective of my life with Charvka and to have an intellectual India based podcast and soup for Indian /Hindu soul. Thanks a lot. Dr Varun Sharma (M.D.)

[@dhruvseoni8418]

Could we ever have a comprehensive session on comparative analysis of the major regional versions / other non-Valmiki versions and how they contrast from each other and the Valmiki? Or even for the Mahabharata, if such variances exist for it as well?

[@siddharthabanerjee4076]

Your podcast are unique and at a different intellectual plane. Kep it up

[@siddharthabanerjee4076]

Is there a podcast on Mahabharata?

[@morgoth8815]

@@siddharthabanerjee4076 yes search Mahabharat unravel - kushal mehra

[@sachisin1924]

I wish these Rāmāyanà lessons with full details were shown or adapted in tv serial Ramayan, the B R Chopra one.

[@wanderers8510]

Wonderful discussion! Mesmerizing to see how she remembers each and every sloka in Sanskrit.

[@arindamchaudhary9]

Rameshwaram wali Shivji ki Katha Valmiki Ramayan mei hai Ami ji... Jab we log Pushpak Viman se Ayodhya laut rahe the to upar sa Raam ji ne Sita ji ko voh island dikhaya jaga setu bandhan se pehle unke sena ruki hui thi aur unhone Shivji ka pujan kiya tha.

[@mukulsingh7530]

Maza aa gya bhai... pahli baar koi pdcasat 1x pr sun rha tha aur speed badhane ki iccha nhi hui Such an interesting podcast

[@ramabapat]

Sadhana is what comes between determinism and free will, to push the needle more and more towards the latter. Sadhana is building competence.

[@Padmanabham.]

#SaveSoil - Let's make it happen 🙏🏽

[@adityakale0648]

Jai Shree Ram 🙏🙏🙏

[@ydl589]

Kushal do Next podcast on hindu calendar systems.

[@lifevarsity]

Fantastic discussion.

[@SJ-nu9ok]

Thoroughly enjoyed this episode 👍

[@priyanshukumar7697]

what an amazing podcast thankyou sir

[@baba-nam-kevalam]

Ramayana is very practical book I don't find anything extra ordinary but don't know very real life situations explainer.

[@kpdwivedi1672]

Very nice discussion.

[@hearticulture6903]

Awesome learning.

[@madhukark8133]

My only take away from Ramayana is Yeh dard khatam kyun nahi hota hai bae 😁😁😁🙏🙏🙏🙏 Big Fan of Amiji Best books for young kids to interpret, relate the scriptures in present day n age

[@kumarsrinivasan5590]

Interesting discussion. But IMHO you guys missed one interesting character that is central to the entire epic. Mandhara. As she is called Kooni ( literally meaning bent woman not just physically but in charecteer). How this woman changed Kaikeyi’s mind so easily? There were no hints in the epic prior to this re Kaikeyi’s desire re Bharatha inheriting the throne. Moreover she must have also had strong idea the devastating impact her request will have on Dasaratha. Yet how did Mandhara changed Kaikeyi’s mind in one conversation? People don’t just flip like that yet she did!

[@yj9032]

17:48 basically Abhishek upmanyu's 'toh kya kai job chhor dun?' joke comes in 🤣

[@kpdwivedi1672]

Regarding decision making in two cases. Let me explain. 1. In first case of asked to go to forest. Here beneficiary of his decision was Bharat, his dear brother. The orders for forest came from his respected father and mother, both of them love him. Additionally he is obedient son as well. Regarding Ravan, this was the main purpose of his taking birth to destroy Rakksha which was not possible without him going to forest. Rest is for doing his duties towards wife, friends, and society at large.

[@MsWarbucks]

Many of the points you discuss are illustrated in the discourses on the Ramayan, especially those by Smt Vishaka Hari. It is in Tamil and may be that is why you are not aware of that. She so loves and admires Rama and Anjenaya and all the characters in the Ramayan. I did enjoy your discussion, too. I love watching people enjoy what they are doing, whether it is a concert or a discussion of characters in the Ramayan as in this one!

[@punyashloka4946]

Amazing discussion 👏

[@vvnrajuutube]

Palki is second to none to compare in journalism

[@MsWarbucks]

In Sundara Kandum, there is something about where exactly and who were impacted by Anjaneya when he burns part of the capital of Lanka when his tail is set on fire.

[@Tryingtosurvive_amonghypocrate]

Nagarwasiyon ne patthar pheka tha...maak udaya tha.. innocent to nahi the

[@MayankTiwari24]

Bit wierd to sit together and be on different camera frame on screen 😅 but great podcast

[@roman5782]

Why does this podcast with look like it was recorded in the 90s? Reminds me of serials like Shreeman Shreemati and Hum Panch.

[@TheJediPrince]

She is Beauty with Brain.

[@Priya24-n1z]

All are beauty with brains but not u

[@TheJediPrince]

@@Priya24-n1z STF Feminist

[@pallavigurav4607]

Hi sir .. I have a question about Urmila (wife of Lakshamana) what is exactly written about her in Valmiki Ramayan?

[@abhishek2026]

Please valmiki ramayan

[@vivekkapoor668]

Excellent discussion! How do we enable all to read Valmiki Ramayana?

[@Nonamam]

Will u be adding English translations?

[@APD867]

Ram has not given up; you can say Sree Ram is given up when he didn't fight again he has fall down but didn't given up.

[@rutube007]

Interview Jaya Kishori on such things, she tells the best stories.

[@kanahayakumar1682]

Jai jai shiyaram shabhi ko

[@tanmaysingh3675]

Shabri episode also laxman was angry

[@Sanathana7]

Lakshmana : Jagrata Bharatha : Sushupti Shatrughna : Swapna Sri Rama : Turiya

[@pronoyjitghosh4]

For doing tapasya you have to be a brahman , that's for sure, but it doesn't mean you have to be a brahman by birth. There are ways that can convert anyone (even a shudra) into a brahman. So for doing tapasya you just have to get brahmatya first. Shambhuka was killed because he was taking a short cut. And Shree Ram also interrogated about his intention for doing tapasya, which was full of malice, that's why he had to stop him. (Brahmatya has its own criteria, even a son of brahman might not be a brahman if he has malice in his heart)

[@arunjetli7909]

kushal i have aPhD in philosophy 1:05:42 1:05:42 from the American University Phrnomrnology snd neo marxism mistly Heidegger snd the Frankfurt. School i think getting into a debate of relative and absolute ethics is bogged down in Aristotelian logic t” The Critic “ the subject always has a role in denying relativity though an infinite abdolute but the critic makes the decision as to what is relative snd what is abdolute Yoi have fallen into the sand error as Kant who wants to pursue” Aoriori that ultimately justified bourgeois relations of production as well as well entrenched chridtian morality with a facade of secularism “ The Critc “ in western philosophy is always looking for rule to follow not recognizing thst sny rule in itself is synthetic so the ultimate decider is “ The critic”

[@suryasen7]

Kushalbuddin is not even at the level of aristotelian. He is an ayn Randist cultist with a fetish for universalism which stands for western authoritarianism. Same arguments are used by western colonialists against the pagans that they lack "Standrds" ie rules.

[@arunjetli7909]

@@suryasen7 I will not decry Kushan , I really like his attitude , and am a fan, of him , but yes “ also me” you have a point. I did not get into Indic logic till my sixties because my education in India andUSA never introduced me to the multivalued logic of the Jains or to the inductive logic of Nyaya, Samkhya other schools. This inductive logic was established in the west during the scientific revolution , but it has bypassed the western social sciences and humanities to this day, Kushal , I love your love for Carvaka , I like them too,but they fall into the trap of empiricism by giving importance to non existing transcendent God . Being an atheist or not is pretty much irrelevant to most Indic epistemology.. that is the reason that no Indians were burnt at the steak for being non believers. Theventire Kantian ethics, along with utilitarianism is a critique of certain parts of western theology, but retains its essence that’s being that it human being but an outside force is required whether it is the Bible or nature which is a quasi God

[@arunjetli7909]

Sorry for some typos it is 3 am and I just read this in the middle of the night as I got up accidentally and was too lazy to revise before pushing “ send”

[@suryasen7]

@@arunjetli7909 yes sir you've hit the nail on the head about western empiricism. Its object orientation derived initially from an attempt to "secularize" the agency of the monotheist God ie to ground religion's ideological orientation to the material ie "nature" and thus make it more stable but I think at some point there was also a falling back to religion's original impetus ie to culturally subjugate and propagandize. Thus the humanities "could not* be touched. Kantian object orientation thus realigned as the true God and the subjective ie the pagan the other the subject also could then be dismissed (routinely ) as faulty, as "superstitious" as it had originally during religion's original formulation as cultural propaganda. The rules based ethics gives western ideologies their authoritarianism. And thus naturally appeals to scoundrels. I see the carvakas as simply a non-existent school in ancient bharata. It was a term used to describe recalcitrant positions by habitual contrarians.perhaps also applied to egoists and epicureans. Certainly not a Darshana. Kushalbuddin I'm sure had a "hissy fit" reading your comments. Hopefully this text will be received by you and not erased.

[@suryasen7]

@@arunjetli7909 basically, exclusive object oriented logic is a prerequisite for cultural propaganda. It also is incidentally prioritized by scoundrels scamsters and the like, and in the colonial setting by sepoy collaborators.

[@vishal_prajapati5]

🚩

[@harshvardhansharma2920]

Kushal bhai tumhara hath to 2nd screen k mic tak pahuch gya to ek hi camera se kaam chal jata 😁 btw it was a good talk

[@kpdwivedi1672]

I don't see any problem. Even of hindus were occasional meat eaters during past, they have now moved on in the positive direction unlike many others around us. So celebrate this fact and be happy.

[@health_ness]

Pls don’t take this the wrong way, but Ami ma’am you are screaming in the mic. It is difficult to listen to you on earphones.

[@happyowl404]

Lovely session. O Kushal, tu kya nastik banega re, calling Bhagwan Shri Ram...:) I am typical hindu, RamBhakta and can equally related to Nastiks.

[@jidrit999]

Nastik bhi anttah samadhi tak phuncenge ghoom ghaam ke

[@Nonamam]

Nirishvara* not naasthika*

[@abhishek2026]

15:10 Ami ji apne bhagwat Geeta ke chapter 18 shlok 14 ka translation galat kiya hai 5 factors are अधिष्ठानाम, कर्ता, करण, विविध प्रकार की पृथकविधाम, दैव पहला शरीर है दूसरा कर्ता है जो आपकी आत्मा है तीसरा नानक प्रकार की इंद्रियां , इंद्रियां आपके शरीर के साथ। आत्मा बिना शरीर के अनुभव नहीं कर सकती चौथा है चेष्टा या प्रयास वो पूर्ण होना चाहिए पांचवा है देवीय शक्ति अब बात आती है की करना क्या है , शरीर, आत्मा, इंद्रियां उसके बाद प्रयास करो । फिर दैव अपने आप आ जायेंगे। जय श्री राम

[@Rahul-hn1iq]

Book ka url link not working

[@salmanazhar88]

Amazing lessons from MYTHology

[@abhishek2026]

It is not myth it is history

[@indieboy1033]

This kannada researcher thinks that Vanara is a tribe, not monkey. There is archeological evidence. There are samaadhi of Vanaras. kzbin.info/www/bejne/o2PHcpiLqc5_npY

[@kunalseth6437]

🕉️

[@raphael7470]

Maina tera ko ICICI mai money transfer kiya or tu ush money sa Canada ka restaurant mai khana kha raha hai 🤓

[@bindasskanya3509]

આવજો

[@mittusharma3824]

hindus are 78% that mean they won 🤣🤣🤣 what a smart analysis, that mean Islam and Charistianity is winning over hinduism everyday. anyway jab history vedo purano se padhoge to esa hi hoga, India me koi hindu that nhi hindu naam bhi udhar ka h persian ka dia hua or India me sb alag alag faith ke logo ko hindu bol dia or kch nhi h.

[@karthik1905]

Valmiki ramayan says where all ravana touched sita when he carried her ?

[@Charvakarishi4669]

Yeah so ?

[@paroxymal7688]

🤷‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@ramabapat]

Didn’t find it in the discussion. Sita did not even let Hanuman carry her, so…

[@gauravtributes5023]

kurand says where all "zayd" t0uched Ayesh@ when they went to popat momo-had for zaynab ?

[@iamworstgamer]

ye mumbaiya log tera tera karke sara dimag ka dahi kardete hain

[@health_ness]

Tera tera tera suroor

[@ankushsharma5802]

is ladki ki awaz kan me chubhti h, very difficult to listen for more than 2 mins.

[@abhishek2026]

Aadat ho jayegi hume bhi ho gayi