The Age of Atlantis Review - with Jeff Knapp

[@DigitalMase]

This is an awesome format. Fantastic review, and probably the best rules overview ever posted on the Dice Tower.

[@stefansibbes2440]

Let me have some of that Kool Aid.

[@matthieuverrette6209]

Wow! Great review! I now wanna see more of your stuff. Great rhythm, humor and all so clear. Thanks.

[@justindavis5728]

Wow give this guy a raise. excellent review, very clear and entertaining.

[@SamiPaju]

What the… Why aren’t there more of these types of reviews by Jeff on Dice Tower? This is amazing! Great production quality, love the humor but still very well explaining the game!

[@TabletopToolbox]

There are! And there's another one coming really soon! Search "Dice Tower Jeff Knapp" to see what's out there!

[@JMauricioCA]

Excellent video. Happy for back this project. Wainting to get my copy in hands.

[@DoppelgangerF02]

awesome review! i was hoping someone would review thissssss also this is incredibly edited and hilarious

[@JoeyBagOdonutz]

Great video. Hope you begin to do more soon!

[@chrisgesell8752]

Excellent review. Looking forward to more content

[@chuno2112]

First time seeing a review by Jeff and loved it. Both descriptive and fun. Will be following

[@Brockoly3]

Awesome review Jeff! My game group is playing this tonight, and recent videos of this game are scarce. Your production, clarity, and subtle humor were top notch. I'll be sure to keep an eye out for your reviews in the future!

[@TabletopToolbox]

Subtle?! Dang - I gotta try harder... ;) lol! Thanks!

[@wtfbruhnonono4696]

Agree with all the positive comments about the quality of the review here, from the production to the thoughtful exposition. More from this man, please.

[@TabletopToolbox]

Duly noted - stay tuned!

[@JohnFlower-NZ]

Jeff Knapp did a stellar job of reviewing this game. I thoroughly enjoyed his humour and I felt that he gave the information I needed to want to buy the game along with the caveats that the rules might take a bit of study due to how they are laid out. Sadly the game is difficult to get a hold of due to issues relating to the manufacturer of the game. I'll be getting a copy if I spot a secondhand one with the metal Poseidon for sale in NZ.

[@hassanlopez4621]

Absolutely amazing work on this, Jeff. I want to see more videos by you!

[@MasterDecoy]

great review. funny, informative, and well edited. hope to see more of them in the future

[@TabletopToolbox]

Thank you!!

[@pigasos15]

super presentation! Love it!

[@patricksteele]

Your production quality is fantastic. This is definitely a game I should check out. Thanks!

[@magnusjakobsson7424]

First review I've seen with you and I must say...it was very good! Looking forward to see more of your content! Cheers from Sweden!

[@rasmusjakobsen4478]

Great review, and helpful for getting a few rules straight...I got my copy some weeks ago, and played through half a solo game - I was distracted by other games and also had a feeling I might be playing it wrong since I finished age 1 in 1 year...but I guess that happens in the game. Anyway I'm exited to get back to it again now. It does look pretty...

[@Baelrahtube]

Fantastic review! Would love to see more of your reviews Jeff 😎

[@TabletopToolbox]

More are coming!!

[@salemcopty]

Great review. Thanks for the overview.

[@TabletopToolbox]

Glad we got to play it yesterday, Salem!

[@moo422]

Another great video. Fantastic overview of the rules, super clear!

[@guandjs]

I am not interested in the game but I did really enjoy the review, Jeff. Your analysis and humour was excellent!

[@TabletopToolbox]

For what it's worth, that's kinda my overall goal - if you like the video regardless of the game within, then I'm on the right path. Thanks. :)

[@bigg3110]

Jeff this was a great video, thankyou 🙂

[@meangreenlipsey]

BEST DT video to date!

[@PsychicLord]

Great review..... one of the best the DT has done.

[@andresmicalizzi5420]

Awesome Review. Just played my first solo game (recieved my copy yesterday)... I agarre with everything you said... The quality of the Rulebook and reference sheets is my only gripe with the game...

[@nury973]

Great work by Jeff, the quality of the video is top notch.

[@zoltankaldy]

Great video, thank you!

[@ShaggySasquach4231]

This was shut up and sit down levels good hats off to you

[@TabletopToolbox]

High praise - thank you!

[@fofimino]

This review is AMAZING! One of the best boardgame reviews ever! Congratulations, keep up the AWESOME work Jeff!

[@goldblend86]

Top quality stuff Jeff. Did I just watch SUSD or the Dice Tower ? I'm now off to search for more of your videos hoping you have covered something I will actually be able to get to the table! The age of atlantis will have to go into the retirement pile with food chain magnate by the looks of things...

[@tteshera]

This was an awesome review. Haven't seen one from you before, but already you're my favorite DT reviewer. Great job!

[@tberceau70]

Great Review Jeff! Excited to table this one.

[@KarpetRydOFunk]

I haven't watched much of the Dice Tower in a few years. Is this guy new? I like him.

[@TabletopToolbox]

Hi! Welcome back! I am indeed somewhat new! Not necessarily a "regular" but I've got lots of plans for 2023!! Stick around! Lots of cool stuff happening on the Dice Tower!

[@ptbochiro]

Great review! Thank you for the detail, nuance, and structure of your approach.

[@michaeltaylor8686]

Fantastic review; thank you. I'm keeping my eye out for it on the second hand market

[@Sebastian-rt9qf]

Fantastic (funny) review Jeff! Well done. Your little videos you made before which occasionally aired on the The Dicetower, were hilarious and I think you can be great asset to the reviews here on the channel. Also happy with the choice of this game as I am still awaiting the delivery of my KS copy. And with all the delay and campaign hassle I was not so much anticipating the game anymore. But with this video, I might still be curious to give it a positive turnaround!

[@TabletopToolbox]

Thank you, Sebastian! I started off on Board Game Breakfast and still do clips there. I'll have more coming out following the Dice Tower Retreat!

[@acidfloyd2]

This was an incredible review and very funny! I picked this game up at a local game store a couple weeks ago and have played it twice. I completely agree with you and also rate it a 9, maybe higher as I think it will reveal much more each time I play it. Such a fast game too and has that Boon Lake feel where if you come out ahead early you can work to accelerate the game end while your opponents are enamoured with advancing tech and engine building. Very cool game and very cool theme!!

[@iamtec87]

Well done.

[@cptsound1972]

Hey Jeff - great job. I liked your delivery and pacing. Hit all the points we want to know about a game.

[@nipzie]

Did you ever get your blue workers? A fulfillment company sent me their spares when they didn't answer emails, I got lucky. Shout out to Pick and Pack Logistics

[@JoseMedia2421]

Awesome review! I received my game.. this pumped me up to try it.

[@roosterchains]

Side note, any KSers actually get the game yet? Been more than 2 and a half years and still waiting....

[@TabletopToolbox]

This really bums me out - unfortunately soon after I posted this, Eldorado Games essentially vanished. He never even responded to me about the missing blue cubes from my copy. I read somewhere that he got a new job and has apparently abandoned his responsibilities on Kickstarter. It's really, really disappointing...

[@roosterchains]

Still not received or have had email responded too

[@housecaldwell]

Such a shame that this KS was one where the creator took the money and ran. Would you consider doing a followup? I would love if someone got the story out there. The real shame is that it appears the game did get made - but won't actually be shipped to anyone. But who can say because the creator disappeared 3 months ago. :-/

[@TabletopToolbox]

Hey sorry but this is completely false. Most backers did receive their copy - there were a few issues that unfortunately the designer didn't resolve before Funagain closed their distribution center. Now he's trying to scramble to even get back his unshipped copies. I won't say he's done EVERYTHING right, but he didn't take the money and run. For one thing, I reviewed my own, backed copy.

[@xRyzZ69]

If European, check with Zuta Games. Got my copie last week.

[@TabletopToolbox]

@@xRyzZ69 if I'm a' peein' where?!?! 😆

[@roosterchains]

@@TabletopToolbox Still waiting for mine, Daniel has not responded for months. Funagain has and said they need him to release the game. 4 months waiting and Funagain gone now.

[@TabletopToolbox]

@@roosterchains *sigh* I feel your frustration. He posted a comment on his last update that he was trying to get the games from Funagain. I think he waited too long - totally his fault. I just wish he'd step up and do the right thing.

[@bernardorippe7024]

Financiably responsible XD! you made my day

[@crokinoledk]

Have you played Windward? It’s a pretty good game. If you haven’t, give it a shot and don’t relay on BGG marks. Most of the 8 and higher ratings nowadays refer to Kickstarter steroid productions with very often mediocre gameplay and over 100$ pricing.

[@guitarplayr8]

Enjoyed the review! The Island of El Dorado was the first game I ever backed on KS and was amazed by the production, but the gameplay fell short for me. Windward looked interesting, but didn't quite convince me to back it, same with Capone. Age of Atlantis definitely made me want to check it out, but like you said, the "meh" games so far made me want to wait. Good to hear this one is better than their previous games. El Dorado Games are good people and seem to be getting better with their game design. Can't wait to see what they come out with next. Island of El Dorado and Windward have both made it to retail, so would not be surprised if this one eventually made it as well.

[@BenSaidScott]

This is a brilliant game. The rule book eaves a lot to be desired, but it’s so intricate, and the tech tree upgrading makes every game feel very different.

[@b_player55]

This guy is good

[@ScytheNoire]

They shouldn't have tried to cram the rulebook all onto one sheet. It was a horrible decision that they got feedback on. They were also asked to include those player help guides for each player. El Dorado ignored all the feedback backers gave.

[@nipzie]

There's nothing wrong with a game as a 7...that's a good game. There's a 10 scale for a reason, if you want a 3 number scale then rate them a 1,2 or 3

[@ironwolf56]

Thumbs up for proper pronunciation of orichalcum.

[@wyatth2992]

Great review! Thank you. Also, I really enjoy Windward. I haven't even tried Age of Atlantis yet, because we're still exploring Windward and slowly introducing expansion content. They both arrived in the same box.

[@bradlybillingsley1870]

I just got my copy of this game, and I love and agree with your entire review. Very well done!

[@1ShotJC]

Great review that made me crack up more than once!

[@Aaackermann]

WOW! This is the BEST review on Dice Tower by far! I love your humour and your clear and sophisticated opinions. Even better than Toms! Quick! Duck and cover... ;-)

[@UnimatrixOne]

Noooooooooooo, never!

[@w0lfang]

This is a great game. I buy games all the time so end up playing them once or twice gets shelved and taken out every so often. I have played this about 10 times and it always comes to game night! Love it!

[@markmorvant5684]

Great review! Yes...you made me look. LOL!

[@boyblueandco]

This rules.

[@Chris-rx8jg]

Great review. Ill gona look on second edition

[@herbstera]

The problem isn't really the 5 bucks (thats's moderate compared to others projects and ... its -ok- at the time). The communication was catastrophic beforehand, the delivery to late and i didn't get (or understand?) the mail to pay it on gamefound. They opened it up again or better told that they would, no other mail followed, but now i found the option to pay the additional fee, i hope to get the very promising looking game with the next wave. But even that was hidden beneath some very strange workflow of reopening the pledge, which didn't work as i would expect it to do. We will see :)

[@PPZ22]

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@jwspiker]

dice tower approved, wait.. love your reviews jeff, reminds me of the details Sam used to give on this show

[@yegods317]

Am I the only one who feels that this game was designed originally as a cooperative game? Just based on this video's description of the game play, it seems like it would work pretty well coop.

[@TabletopToolbox]

There is a coop mode in the variants rulebook but in all honesty, I haven't even looked at it!

[@yegods317]

@@TabletopToolbox interesting... is that posted online anywhere? my group only plays coops, and I did like the look of several of the systems in this game.

[@TabletopToolbox]

If I'm honest, I only knew this because I saw comments on the BGG foruks which, if I recall, were complaining that it's ridiculously hard. I haven't tried it, and I didn't read the rules for it yet.

[@TheDiceMatrix]

T'was a pleasant watch!

[@bencpower]

Nice to know El Dorado finally made a decent game. I was a backer of their first game and it's pretty terrible.

[@TabletopToolbox]

Wanna know the crazy part? After filming this, I bought the Legends edition of Islands of El Dorado... I'm at least gonna try it... :)

[@bencpower]

@@TabletopToolbox - Hey, who knows? You might dig it. :)

[@nipzie]

@@TabletopToolbox it scored higher than the original base game because it added some complexity and revamped the rulebook which was atrocious in the first edition (in it's clarity, not quality, unlike this rule leaflet)

[@uplift-yourdailypickup6424]

I like this review format a lot, however I'm still unclear about how good a game this is. I gravitate towards reviews with a rating system for this reason. I gleaned that the reviewer liked it fairly well and it's the best from this company.

[@TabletopToolbox]

"How good a game is" is up to you. My role is to tell you about the game and let you decide if it's right for you!

[@williammathon7135]

Am I the only one upset at the fact that the art of this game seems like it’s completely ripping off Awaken Realms’ Lords of Hellas ? That Pegasus on the cover is almost exactly the same as Perseus’s in LoH !

[@JasonLaw29]

7.2/7.5 is meh? 😁 Lots of games on BGG get scores in the 7.0-7.5 range but that doesn't mean they are bad. Not that I have played Windward but I use to think 7s means good though not great games 😄 . Edit: Ok, fair enough. I felt very meh about Tapestry and it scored a 7.4 on BGG 😂

[@TabletopToolbox]

Haha - and I was trying to figure out how to defend myself! But note the different inflections of the "meh" - I was simply suggesting that it's not universally loved. It is clearly liked more than Islands, which was my primary point. :)

[@JasonLaw29]

@@TabletopToolbox Understand 😄 In any case, 7s are not bad :P

[@TabletopToolbox]

@@JasonLaw29 I never said it was bad. I said it was "Mmmmmmmeh." ;) What someone considers a 7 to be is entirely up to them. :)

[@JasonLaw29]

@@TabletopToolbox Fair enough :)