Guild Starfire 1 DC - Affordable ES 335 Centre Block Alternative - Electric Guitar Review

[@charleyeastman1795]

why am I watching another deep dive review of a guitar I have absolutely no interest in and I’m not going to buy? Ace presenter? INDEED. Thanks as always!

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Charley that's very kind and very much appreciated! 🙏😊

[@bb-bryzontrap1525]

You'll buy it

[@mwpv11]

I own Epiphone, Gibson, Gretsch, Wolf and Guilds and the Guild can hang in with the Gibson very well. i gig a lot with the Guild and it never disappoints at all. I think too many people under rate the Guild without giving them a try and they are missing out. I would take my Guild over the Epiphone any day. Better quality and sound. Epi is good but the Guild gives you a more professional feel.

[@bradleyclosson5042]

Your playing is always good. You don't have to be super technical to sound good. A lot of technical players sound sterile and lack soul. I'd much rather listen to a player like you because you can feel the music. Another great review, thank you!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Bradley that's appreciated 🙏😊

[@voiceofexperience]

Ditto!

[@jmartini8875]

Agreed. Colin plays with feel. I can usually tell when he's enjoying the ride.

[@williamarthurfenton1496]

I find there's no correllation between technical skill and feel. Just as many of either have soul, or don't. I mean Angus Young is on guitarist levels pretty average, but he absolutely massacres Joe Satriani who I think is one of the most soulless and tedious players I've ever heard. Ditto with Yngwie Malmsteen. But saying that I think Steve Lukather has tremendous feel and he ain't exactly a slouch. I don't think much of Slash who's another average guitarist as far as technical skill goes, I don't think he's got much feel at all.

[@GaryTimms-p5j]

Agree, a so called technical player can sound boring while some more natrual less technical player is good to listen to

[@petririntala]

Thank you again. Absolutely enjoyable to watch as always. What really caught my ears this time was your playing. I don't know is it just me, but I really thought you were on fire. Then you mentioned it yourself how you enjoyed playing that thing. Rock'n roll. It's only rock'n roll but I like it. And that's what the world needs.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Petri, I had fun playing this one and it's great to hear that came across 🙏 😊

[@hod8931]

Thanks for the review! I have a custom shop es335 but I wanted a lower cost semi hollwbody to use as a back up. I checked out the guild, epiphone, gretch and D'angelico. After I played all of them, several times, I ended up with the walnut D'angelico premiere. It just spoke to this old guy. Have a great week.

[@davesnothere.5528]

I am in the same boat, could you tell me more about you choice to go with the D'angelico..

[@hod8931]

@@davesnothere.5528 it just felt like home. Its weird but immediately while playing, I either like a guitar or don't. The epiphone came in second for me.

[@PowerInOne22]

Awesome review, thank you! Always was curious about these. Watched Steve Turner live melting my face off with a vintage Starfire many times.

[@bueller8278]

Been eyeing this one for a while. Would love to see a Guild/Gretsch/Epiphone shoot out as they are all in the same price range

[@kingstumble]

Nice honest review. I bought one of these guitars a couple of months ago--second hand but in mint condition( the goodie bag wasn't included though!) I am completely in love with it. I don't mind the finish---it's an all laminate body(in common with most semi's) and doesn't try to hide it. Mine only weighs 6.4lb. I believe they are made in the Samick factory. I've got a 335 and a D'Angelico semi but the Guild has overtaken them both in my affections.

[@henrydiaz720]

How do they compare with 335s in tone and playability? I want an epiphone SG Special P90 but after seeing this, I want one of these Starfires! Dammit. Now I have to save up twice as much!

[@kingstumble]

@@henrydiaz720 Playability is on a par with the 335. The neck is thinner but after a few minutes you don't even notice it. Fretwork is perfect. The Starfire is less bright and has a lower output which I assume is down to the Alnico II pickups. My 335 has Alnico V which are more aggressive. Alnico II suit me better as I lean more towards jazz/blues. But they are standard size humbuckers so you can change them easily if you want to. All in all I would thoroughly recommend the Starfire.

[@henrydiaz720]

@@kingstumble What's the problem with the finish?

[@kingstumble]

@@henrydiaz720 Absolutely nothing in my opinion. I was referring to the fact that Colin wasn't keen on the look.

[@henrydiaz720]

@@kingstumble Oh...yeah. As a traditionalist, (euphemism for old guy) I prefer the red. The green too, but the olive drab would take a little getting used to for me.

[@richfiryn]

Love these videos you've been putting out man. Very thorough, and offering the viewer a great chance to understand about the various models you're showcasing. I'm excited for arrival of an Sire H7 i ordered 8 months ago to finally get here this month. In heritage red of course !

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Rich, crikey 8 months??... you are a patient man! 😆👍

[@frozenborderline2109]

The cherry laminate finish might invoke the marmite effect for some, but I think it looks sweet. Perfectly servicable ''affordable'' guitar for some Kinks/Dave Davies Brit-invasion stuff plus it certainly looks the part. I'd just add a Bigsby and good to go!

[@spdaltid]

Another enjoyable vid Colin. Nice guitar and your playing is a hoot - in the best possible way!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Bob! 😆👍

[@txkflier]

That's a nice-looking guitar for sure. I could listen to you play (and talk) all day. I can hardly wait for the next episode. Thanks!

[@GaryTimms-p5j]

Yep, always enjoy your playing and great riffs, good to listen to, my type of playing

[@touchthesun2448]

It's real purdy! I just can't get over that... well made. The deeper you go, the more impressed I am. The price is right and it sounds great for an entry level. I'm kinda surprised, it's so PURDY! The walnut might be interesting, but the red ROCKS!!!! Great jam...that was tasty with my coffee and pastry. Sweet, Buddy Guy is awesome. He's like 85 and still rockin'! Thanks Colin...keeper?

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Bob, yes it's got a great vintage vibe to this one... I like it! 🙌 trouble is that I like 9/10 guitars I review and want to keep them all! 🤣👍 Have a great weekend brother.

[@markpell8979]

Tuned with my early Monday coffee and cig and thoroughly enjoyed! I could see/hear you went in trying to dislike this guitar (as a critic really should) but were won when you played it. The single coil sounds were interesting, kind of a country vibe. Liked that. Like the finish ok too, and the neck obviously is not limiting whatsoever. At the price point I say it holds its own and looks sexier than the comparison items. Cheers!

[@touchthesun2448]

@@theguitaristas this next one will be very interesting Colin! I can't wait to see what you put together for this coming Friday! Have FUN with it!

[@mortonwilson795]

Another great Saturday afternoon diversion! Enjoyed your playing (as always) and the Guild seems a nice guitar! Thanks!

[@evengar81]

We should ask you to make video with you playing all the way 😂 so much joy to listen. Feels like you play not with fingers but with your soul!

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Andrey that's very kind! 🙏😊

[@damien6997]

Yeah I'm hooked on these deep dives. Alot of guitar that won't break the bank. Many good guitars available these days. Good to see

[@wesleyb_92]

Always here for anything you do. Thoroughly enjoy your videos

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Wesley I appreciate the support! 😎👍

[@firstsgtrichard]

A very enjoyable 38.47 minutes of my time. Thanks again my friend! I have been trying out an EART 335 ($289.00)and have been enjoying it very much. Very affordable and although I play like crap, my friend who is a great player wanted to steal it from me so gave it to him as a birthday present...guess I need to buy another 335 Alternative now...will keep watching the comparisons. Rock on brother.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man, thanks for supporting... and your kindness in gifting that guitar to your friend definitely justifies you getting a nice replacement! Enjoy the hunt brother Richard! 😎👍

[@davidhamilton7780]

Sirens outside. Colin is on fire! Great to see you enjoying yourself - thanks for a great show and I'm really looking forward to to the 335 comparison. Have a good 'un!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers David! 😆👍

[@lamps2137]

Picked one up (Emerald green w/guildsby) a couple months ago and I just say this video today. Spot on review, the first thing I did was change the pots, jack and switch. Threw a bone but on it and a roller bridge for the Guildsby and if is as perfect as you can get for a budget instrument. Factory pickups don't sound bad at all.

[@GuitarBailey]

Probably the most informative reviewer on KZbin for guitar at the moment everything you want to know about and no rambling

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Eric that's really appreciated... hang on a minute though did you say no rambling!! 🤣👍

[@GuitarBailey]

@@theguitaristas I di I love how concise you are and don't just fill in the space with Needles commentary you cover yhe gear and specs how it sounds ita perfect your the best

[@theguitaristas]

@@GuitarBailey 🙏😊Cheers Eric that's kind.

[@davidaustin6271]

Great detailed review as always. Appreciated the tone/volume knob sounds not being overlooked, and discussion of the color detail. Clearly a set to 10 and forget guitar, but a REALLY nice one at the price. Totally looking forward to the "shoot-out" of the group. Fun to see you cutting loose a bit and sounding good!

[@davidaustin6271]

I do also wonder how the D'Angelico 335/like guitar would compare. I find them appealing myself. I guess they are a few hundred $ more though.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers David thanks for the kind words! Yes price was a definite consideration for this series and I think D'Angelico and Hagstrom were out of the equation.

[@darwinsaye]

Another, lesser known contender for 335 rivals is the Hagstrom Viking. Saw one in a shop window in the late 70s when I was just starting to seriously play guitar - it was the first 335 style semi hollow I ever saw and the first guitar I can recall being really enamoured with.

[@theguitaristas]

I looked at those... just a little more expensive than the others at around £700 but I bet they are good.

[@gustafrenstrom8549]

I was looking at one of these online a few days ago but couldn't find a proper review of one then you release this! Great work as always.

[@theguitaristas]

Spooky timing... do you believe in fate? 🤣👍

[@gustafrenstrom8549]

@@theguitaristas I'm starting to haha. I'm really looking forward to the comparison.

[@mattporter6128]

Not sure why but Guild is a brand my tiny mind has always associated more with acoustics. This is a cool guitar, not perfect but nothing that can't be fixed. Thanks again Colin for another interesting review. I'm off to see Bonamassa at the RAH tonight, not sure I'll see many affordable guitars there though! 😂 If I get the chance I'll ask him if he'll lend us his Lazarus, so you can compare it to the Epiphone you've got 🤔😁

[@MaTTheWish]

Yeah, even cheaper Guid acoustics are so sweet in my experience. I played a Bob Marley model at guitar center, and it was just one of those guitars that was amazing from the first note. So light and clear and boomey.

[@theguitaristas]

Hey Matt, have a good gig mate!! I see on Instagram JB has just taken delivery of another previously unknown burst with a bigsby courtesy of ATB so I'm sure he wouldn't miss Lazarus... 😆👍

[@mattporter6128]

@@theguitaristas What a show tonight! He kicked off with an SG, switched to a ES 335 for the next song, then a Strat for the next, then a Tele for the next I think, and then a Les Paul. Not sure he has as many guitars as you though Colin 😂 Bonamassa was on great form and his opening solo was so blisteringly white hot I thought "how's he going to top that?" And he did it too. He really is unbelievable, at times I was shaking my head in disbelief. A great band to back him up too, they were real top performers, one and all. The old geezer on the drums (sorry I forget his name) was particularly impressive! I saw the Instagram post about his 'new' guitar (valued at £175,000 I believe), funnily enough ATB are just down the road from me, never been a customer though, way out of my price bracket! 🤟

[@theguitaristas]

@@mattporter6128 Cheers Matt, sounds great man, and I suspect he did it through fully cranked dumbles and fender twins... how is your tinnitus this morning? 😆 I think he might have a few more guitars than me though 🤣👍

[@jonathanhandsmusic]

Guild electrics are good guitars and have their own following, myself included. But as you say, they’re also known for their acoustics, which are superb.

[@Αδιάφθορος]

That was SOME review!!! In depth!! Thank you very much

[@MRoo1oo]

My first hour at work on Fridays are spent watching your reviews, it's a great way to start the weekend.

[@theguitaristas]

Nice one... what a great job you have!! 😆👍

[@acuduncan]

Man, I gotta say I really appreciate your videos. You really bring a thorough and balanced review to guitars. I find myself always starting with your videos when I'm researching a new guitar. You can also really tell that you enjoy making these videos and just truly love guitars. Please keep making them, because you're great at it! You also are a great player.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Duncan, that's appreciated!... I do tend to buy guitars that I like (or think I will like!) so there is a genuine enthusiasm for most of them and I'm glad that comes across! 😎👍

[@c.alejo8846]

Great Video! How would you compare the Guild DC1 with an Epiphone Sheraton? Any preference? Thank you very much!

[@theguitaristas]

I think I did a comparison video!

[@c.alejo8846]

@@theguitaristas Hi! yes, I think you compared it with an Epiphone 335 which you thought a bit dull or so. What about the Epiphone Sheraton? Do you think the Sheraton is a better guitar than the Guild DC1? I am not sure which one to buy. Thanks! love your videos!

[@kkrekula]

Nice to hear/see you on fire in the playing! Great!

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks man! 😆👍

[@נטעחת]

waiting for that comparison video!! Great job on making these videos

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers coming soon! 😆👍

[@oak3076]

Thank you so very much for sharing your joy. You have made an old man smile and laugh. Very much appreciated. Have a Blessed day.😄

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks man I really appreciate the kind words and support! 🙏😊

[@Jomor44]

A long time ago before computers never mind KZbin. My dad took me for my first electric guitar I wanted a 335. For some reason the salesman talked me into a Starfire IV. Had it for around four days.Fifth day back to the store for my ES 335td. Been playing and loving it for fifty five years .

[@scratchpadski9094]

Been looking forward to what you're doing this week...ok, time to watch 👍🏻😎

[@trevor2173]

Crazy. My Guild Starfire IV should be at my door tomorrow so this could not have been timed better. 😆 love these deep dives. I will not be taking mine apart like you did in this video. I’ll leave that to the professionals. Great channel!!

[@jsphillip60]

I used to own a Starfire IV (1996 model). I loved that guitar! I got in a bind and had to sell it, but now I'm looking for another!

[@theguitaristas]

Nice one Trevor, I reckon that will be a nice step up in the wiring dept! 😎👍

[@trevor2173]

@@theguitaristas I’m hoping so😂. We will see.

[@danielemilazzo432]

So, is the IV any better than this one?

[@trevor2173]

@@danielemilazzo432 I dunno. Good question. I’m very pleased with the guitar so far. Play it every day. My Casino has been sitting in its case ever since I got the IV. I don’t know where they skimped with the Chinese counterparts. I’m assuming the wiring harness? Tuners?

[@S-T-E-V-E]

My attention was first brought to these when I saw you could get one with Dynasonic's on it, the 'Guild Starfire II ST Dynasonic'. They were £999 brand new MSRP but you can pick up a second hand one for around £600. I've never tried one but they did catch my attention!

[@TheStepheno]

I love watching you build up and dig in , love the jam man . You have great content. Great 👍🏻

[@docgify]

It was nice seeing you play “enthusiastically” it was great thanks Colin,more power to you brother

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man that’s appreciated! 😆👍

[@jordantaylor1988]

I've never played a Guild that I didn't love. Nice rundown mate

[@chrispfeifer7628]

I've never thought about music having to be perfect. It only has to please you. Great videos. Nice to see another old guy like me still playing Peace ✌️

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Chris, and less of the 'old' if you don't mind! 🤣 it's true of course... 😆👍

[@NotSoSweetBand]

I’m really enjoying these videos. Perfect way to start the weekend. Particularly good playing today too 👍🏻

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Lee that's appreciated have a great weekend! 😎👍

[@grg-mpgmusic7247]

Friday brunch with Colin....interesting choice this week. Never was into Guild but now..... Let's get the Crocs coordinated with the guitar finishes please.

[@theguitaristas]

ooh a selection of Crocs!... maybe I need some new shirts first though?? 😆👍

[@grg-mpgmusic7247]

@@theguitaristas Shirts are fine. I have shirts like that and still where them thread bare and all. Embarrass the grandkids all the time

[@stephenupton]

I did a exchange deal for one of these guitars, and someone before be added a dusenberg style trem and it sounds great, mine is the single cut model, it’s a great alternate guitar that sounds really good, and don’t break the bank, thanks for a great video enjoyed it,

[@standingbadger]

Great to see you going deep into that Guild! Images of wild, debauched parties from down the ages with lots of coloured lights all flashed through my mind as I was listening to you play. That top: in the trade it’s know as a triple ‘A’ MFI-grade top 😉 - the best and has to be paired with a dark blue shag pile carpet and white vinyl sofa to get the best out of it. And lots of mirrors. I did love the sound of it though. Cheers!

[@theguitaristas]

🤣👍

[@rockinbobokkin7831]

I felt like you nailed that groove. You clearly enjoyed that guitar.

[@Bona-Who]

Good Day Colin! Love it as always! Thank you.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Brent, have a great weekend! 😎👍

[@geoffwhitemusic]

Vis playing beyond one’s *perceived* ability: I teach music lessons. And the adage I follow is, those who mind don’t matter. And those who matter don’t mind. Also, in my experience, MOST people are better than they think. But you already know this-you’re just a very humble person. But I still thank you for inspiring me and anyone else reading this to just go for it.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Geoff that's appreciated 🙏 😊 I do like to think that what I may lack in speed and technical ability I make up for with enthusiasm! 🤣👍 But seriously If what I do inspires others to pick up guitar and play that's a real bonus.

[@nickwebb9290]

A great review as always. Not a model I’ll be needing but your video is really watchable and hugely informative 👍

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Nick! 😎👍

[@aldanino]

Another brilliant review and the icing on the cake is your playing - always reminds me of 60s jam sessions - you clearly enjoy yourself what's more can we ask for, keep trucking man,✌

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Al that's appreciated! 😎👍

[@mrfq_abg]

Thank you Colin, I've been watching this series on repeat, definitely very useful & thorough breakdown. It doesn't help your playing makes them all sound good! Please do more in this series- Hagstrom Viking perhaps?

[@theguitaristas]

😎🙏

[@ericoswood1856]

Guild is not a brand that comes to mind for many players, that’s a shame. I have a Guild Starfire 3, a Starfire 6, and a Bluesbird. Great guitars, I’m glad you did a great review on these. Hopefully people will check these out.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Eric, yes that' very true... and me included. They don't even seem to be available from many places here in the UK and I has to order this months ago.

[@Olibertau]

Hi Colin. Finally it has been sold. 🙂 I didn't understand why it didn't go. My own experience with the Guild Starfire is with the 1 SC, single cut with 20 frets instead of 22 for the DC. I found it a bit flat and decided to give it a good treatment at the first strings' change. So, a good fret polishing, fingerboard oiling and then, after mounting new strings, I followed this advice : lower the pickups and adjust the individual pole pots heights by unscrewing them. There was some white material going out, surely wax. After that, the finger board is gorgeous, the sound of these pickups is now great. A fantastic guitar for the price !

[@theguitaristas]

Sounds like wax for sure. Yes great guitar and has finally gone to a good home with the others!

[@peskypesky]

You've sold me. I'm getting one of these. And your playing is better than you realize.

[@theguitaristas]

😊🙏

[@gernotboesser6901]

This guitar suits you well, your playing really is vivacious 👍

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks man that's appreciated and vivacious is a great compliment! 🙏😎👍

[@aljohno72]

Fantastic reviews as usual 👌 I defo think a Larry Carlton H7 needs throwing in the mix 🤔 before judgment day 😎🤘

[@peterbishop4438]

Nice review... only eclipsed by your play out jam :) Yes... you certainly were into that Guild... and it showed! Good job!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Peter... did it show? 😂👍

[@davew8542]

Nice review Col. It’s a nice looking and sounding guitar. Your comment of enjoying yourself and why you do this, shows in your enthusiasm. It makes for an entertaining show that I for one look forward to every week. Keep up the good work ( and get the PRS....I know the birds...🙂)

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Dave... don't remind me about those birds it gives me nightmares! 🤣👍

[@murielpalmer-rhea8250]

I have a Guild FCE45 from ‘90 and a newer Guild Bluesbird. The Bluesbird was advertised to have split coils, but doesn’t. Will play it a while longer and maybe ask our Luthier if he can get the split coil harness, but no rush.

[@shroompicn-shrooman]

I almost bought one of these.. but I ran into a CV Starcaster for $200 US .. and I'm very pleased with it so far.. Your video on the Starcaster had me a little hesitant about it with the wiring issue you had. Mine has worked flawlessly and has become my go to in the garage band I play with. It's even got the other guitar player on the hunt for a used one as well. Thanks for the work you put in and the investments you make buying these for us to enjoy. ✌🍄👍

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man, I still have to fix the problem with mine and am poised to look at the switch...

[@shroompicn-shrooman]

@@theguitaristas and they make them so easy to work on 😳 Good Luck 👍

[@theguitaristas]

@@shroompicn-shrooman Yeah I keep putting this off! 🤣

[@stevenhorton7457]

Great review as always Colin 👍

[@henryhartley9993]

Nice one Colin, really like the sound of this guitar....

[@tigersteamer]

Right on man good review I'm not sure I did those pick ups but it's a good-looking rig

[@angelsrr]

Great review, as always. Great playing. The tune you were playing at 20:15, was that Oh! Sweet Nuthin' by VU? Really sweet !

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man... yes you got it! 😎👍

[@willsutton3767]

Colin - great review (and outstanding playing!). I owned one of these and can agree, they’re excellent. I thought the neck profile was outstandingly comfortable. If you love it and plan to keep it, a new wiring harness would work wonders AND send the pickups to Radio Shop for a rewind. They made a video a few years ago showing the rewind process for a set of Starfire HB1 pickups. You would not believe the amount of wax that was in there! Enough to really choke the tone. A proper set of Guild pickups are fantastic and very unique sounding. Enjoy!

[@paulsworld2]

Another great video Colin. I think you need to throw a Gibson 335 into the mix. Then a compare with all of the variants. I honestly love my Gibson 335!!!!!!

[@theguitaristas]

I think it may be down to find the 'right' 335... I'd like to try a few.

[@holybanjo]

Just discovered your channel via this excellent review of the Starfire which was a total revelation. Was not expecting such a deep dive and my god you’ve saved me so much work! Having watched this I now know exactly what to replace/upgrade and most look like easy fixes! Would be nice to see a comparison review with some of those niggles fixed like new pots and perhaps new hardware, bone nut, maybe a pickup rewind? Too much to ask for those Buddy Guy licks too?!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Matthew glad you found the channel! 😎 I’ve done a whole mod series on the 335.. definitely more to follow on this or the Gretsch 2622 at some point! 👍👍

[@nednobody3253]

Nice review, For the price seems like the real deal. I had a pawnshop bought Sheraton that I never bonded with as all the gold hardware had been switched so I wasn't sure about the pots an pickups. But with a couple of tweaks and an assortment of pedals. This is an attractive guitar.

[@GraemeCampbellMusic]

I had one of the original 60s ones when I was just starting out in the late 80s (got it trading a pointy Washburn in). It was a great guitar but being young I didn’t know what I had and swapped it on later for something else. Always regret that. I’ve been curious about these new ones, so great video Colin.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Graeme 😎👍

[@buzzburb1]

Cheers man, great review as usual , looking forward to the series as I own both the Starcaster and the Gretch you mentioned , be interesting to see how they stand up , recently bought the Squire Mustang hope you do you`re stuff on this in the future, keep them coming Friday night would`nt be the same without you !!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man, you keep watching I’ll keep knocking them out! 😆👍

[@georgecarothers3926]

Damn Bro, your videos have me hooked. Keep up the good work 👍

[@scottdavidson6066]

Nice driven tone on your solo! I’m liking the darker sound of the mahogany, too.

[@keithblakeman2823]

Great honest review, lovely looking guitar especially the pickguard shape, neck binding and headstock but the finish looks like a red stained 1950's coffee table. Looking forward to the shoot out with the Epi and Gretsch and loved the wig out around the 38th min. Nice definition between the spilt coils, clearly audible. Don't knock your playing, I really wish I could.

[@michaelszarzynski8698]

Excellent presentation!... As usual.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Michael! 😎👍

[@nicolasbeaudry6158]

Great playing as always mate. Hi from Canada Quebec Montreal ❤great looking guitar too baby

[@smokepeddler]

The new (Fender) Guilds are really good. BTW all Gibson ES models have always had laminate tops.

[@steffenschmidt4727]

Love it❤️ Great guitar and review as always ✌🏽☯️✨💯🎶🤘

[@edwardbelcher8612]

Just got one of these today and, your review is spot on with what I found on my example. Superb fret work and feel on mine and I love the flat profile of the neck, weight is just right for it's size and other than some leftover polishing compound in one of the F holes, no real cosmetic flaws that I have found so far. The string height on mine was a little high and the intonation on the 3 bass strings was way off lol. Other than that, I think it would be hard to beat this guitar for $549 US plus a set of 10's to replace the 11's they put on these for whatever reason.

[@alphillips87]

I'd love to see you review acoustic guitars as well!

[@theguitaristas]

I don't think it's likely though to be honest... I never really play acoustic and am rubbish at fingerpicking which is probably why! 😆👍

[@alphillips87]

@@theguitaristas no worries

[@paulgeorgia8013]

Another great, informative review. If you ever mange to get your hands on a Firefly 338, they are the least expensive 335 alternatives, at around $140.00. They’re surprisingly good for the money.

[@BobEstremera]

Love your reviews and how much fun we all have watching you have fun too. Between this Guild and the Gretsch 2622 with P90s, which did you enjoy playing and sounding more?

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Bob, it’s a close call and I’d like to do a comparison but I sold that Gretsch a while back… but I am actually thinking about getting another as I regret that! 😆👍

[@Klaxet]

I played one in local shop, in Emerald Green color and I couldn't put it down. Also it looks much nicer than in Cherry, it almost felt like a Gibson ES 335. Just wish Emerald Green would come without the Bigsby I am not a tremolo fan - way too heavy.. Excellent review, thank you!

[@margaretzabinski9977]

"Nice noises coming out of this" AGREE. Looking forward to next weeks episode. I have to say I love Guild guitars. On my Starfire ll MIK the mahogany is covered with black paint that looks and feels like plastic. It feels cheap like you said, but it has mini HB and they sound great. Your Starfire is going on your "very, very cool " wall I'll bet.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Margaret, yes indeed there is something very effortlessly cool about this one! 😎👍

[@markfahey3921]

Great review, I think for the money it is great, I've played the sister starfire with a single cut - Venetian style I think. For the money it seems dead on and certainly great value for money. I just can't get past the looks of the Starcaster, but that's my personal preference. A shame about the electrics, but opened up they sound ok. I gig with a Boost pedal (made in the UK by BOO pedals - try them, best boost pedal on the market in my opinion). Personally, I'm not bothered for coil spits, but if it comes with that then fair enough. At £430 you can mod the electrics but a great guitar for the money - at this price nothing will be perfect but Indian Rosewood - well there's a huge plus to start with.

[@davidkay3443]

You should get your hands on an D’Angelico DC premier. 335 shape. F holes. The tone is incredible. Had it week now. Just needed slight tweak on the action and oiled the frets.. stunning finish. 7.2lbs . Seems to have a lot more clarity than the epiphone 335. Not to dis similar to the riviera with the mini humbuckers. And the D’Angelico has the best headstock . Stunning. I’d recommend you try one. Would make for a great video. Speaking of which enjoyed this as always. This is my go to on a Friday. Great way to start the weekend

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers David, I am definitely going to have to try one before long! 😎👍

[@colatutube]

Mate, you are the most entertaining, amusing informed (kinda), addictive goitarist on the Web. Really look forward to your additions. Been at this goitaring since 1967 and still learning bits n bobs. Didn't know much about pickup outputs or neck profiles etc. but totally hooked on your presentation method.....info, humor and self deprecation......love it! Still want to see you review the Epiphone Sheraton II Pro and not the tribute version you wheeled out a couple of times lol. It's a TOTALLY different instrument. You can borrow mine if you like, I'll send it down to you. All my guitars (my Les Paul Standard excepting) are main name play/sound alikes and in my opinion perform and look as good,if not better than the named brands. Anyway, coz of you I'm trouble with 'er indoors ' but aint gonna stop me collecting and playing just as long as I can afford it and can still knockout a 12 bar. Thanks.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man thanks for the kind words and support!... in fact I have owned (and stupidly sold) a Sheraton pro II and totally agree with you. I need another but wish you hadn't reminded me! 😂👍 Hey there are a lot worse things we could be doing eh?... remind the missus of that and you'll be fine! 😎🎸🎸

[@stereovox5]

Hey! A guild! Looking forward to the “rivals” video! I was quite impressed with my starfire I SC. Purchased it because I became tired of waiting for what would have been my 6th Epi Casino (I have issues)… had low expectations, and it is now my go to guitar in the house. Great neck, I like the pickups. Pots and switch are crap and need to be replaced for pro use… but the guitar is better than its price. It is different, decidedly not a 335 or a casino… but a very useful different. Great review. Keep them coming!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Michael... I think an SC is on my list now too! 😆👍

[@emil8446]

In 1965 I got a Starfire III, cherry red. I traded it in to get a Les Paul in 1969. Still have the LP, and wish I still had that Guild.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Emil, nice to have that Les Paul still though! 👍👍

[@emil8446]

@@theguitaristas That it is.

[@das_edelweiss8736]

Omg thank you for doing this review! Probably one of the best review of this guitar out there! Question, do you think the pickups sound great in person? I’ve heard that the reason why people seem to love or respect guild is that their pickups sound very clean, bright, and very articulate. It’s a very distinctive sound according to them and they just love them for their clarity and the very clean and crisp tone they give.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man, yes I really like them as they are... it's got plenty of character so I don't think I will rush to change them.

[@briandevitt6903]

I like this one mate. I don't need another guitar of this type but I would consider this one if things changed. I like the colour too. As always a thorough and entertaining review.

[@theguitaristas]

Come on now Brian you always need another guitar! 😆👍

[@briandevitt6903]

@@theguitaristas well that is true. In my case its a single cut......don't tell her indoors.

[@largeeng]

Another good review! I might have to check this out, It's my birthday next week and well, I don't need another guitar but, well, you know how that goes lol. How about a review of their triple P90 single cutaway semi hollow (forget the name)?

[@chrishenderson9130]

Love the neck pickup. Very chimey. And your playing was really great on this one. Can't wait for the shootout, but my iced tea epi 335 pro is my baby. Also looking forward to the tribute/studio/standard shootout. Cheers from America

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Chris! 😎👍

[@francovani393]

Lovely job on this one! Nothing sounds like a Guild . Doesn't cow down to imitation to the holy Gibson : its a sound is fiercely individual

[@jefftucker201]

Great vid Colin, nice little 335 alternative that! Have to agree about the Push\Pulls, really not a fan of them myself either on any guitars! Have a great weekend mate, all the best.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Jeff, and you mate have a good one! 😎👍

[@anakinskywalker6598]

I'm torn between this (w a tremolo) and an epiphone es 335. I usually play grunge and alternative. Any suggestions?

[@theguitaristas]

See other answer! 😆👍

[@MartyGerman]

My first serious acoustic guitar was a 1973 Guild Madeira which was a wood kit gathered in Guild's Connecticut factory and, sent to Japan where it was assembled. I still own and play it! I think it was one of the first attempts for a major US brand to reduce costs using "over seas" assembly? The guitar has a seriously Vee shaped neck and beautifully figured Maple wood (both quilted and Birds Eye), Their Connecticut factory backed up on a great trout stream! Unfortunately, when Fender bought them, they moved the US factory to Southern California. So it goes?

[@BobEstremera]

Love the fun we all have watching these reviews. Between this Guild and the Gretsch 2622 with P90s, which do you enjoy playing and sounding more?

[@justa2]

Don’t put yourself down Col wish I could play as well as you ! Some great playing in this video ! I think you can really tell when you like a guitar - I like the Guild it sounds fantastic and is just that little bit different. It may become my third guitarista influenced purchase !

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man that’s appreciated! 😁🙏

[@rubenvangansbeke4267]

Hi Colin, thanks for this excellent review. Very curious for the comparison with other ES-335 Rivals... Especially curious on which guitar you prefer. I myself am in dubio between the Emily Wolfe Sheraton Stealth by Epiphone, and the Guild Starfire I DC Pelham Blue... Two extremely beauties if you ask me... And both sound amazing... Help!! ;-)

[@theguitaristas]

Hey Ruben, that reminds me I still need to make the part 2 comparison!... it's coming as soon as I have fixed the Starcaster wiring 😂 So choosing between Stealth and Starfire is tricky 🤔 I rethink the Stealth is the harder rocking darker choice... the Guild for more blues and versatility perhaps? Hope that helps!

[@rubenvangansbeke4267]

@@theguitaristas indeed it helps, thanks Colin! As I play in a party coverband, with a high variety in the playlist, I would think the Starfire would be the better choice for me... Looking forward to part 2!!

[@sixbladeknife44]

Great review and very inspired playing, the guitar does sound very nice. With some upgraded pots I’m sure you’d get a lot more variation out of the tone control. I’m a feel player also, I appreciate technical playing but it’s never been my thing…personally I much prefer to listen to emotive players that aren’t afraid to get a little sloppy and take chances, Page was always a good example of that. The first jam reminded me of VU’s Oh! Sweet Nuthin’, good stuff 😎

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man that's appreciated... and that was exactly where the inspiration for that jam came from! 🙌