The Royal Death Pits of Ur

[@TheHistocrat]

Sources (In order of video appearance): 1. Matthews R (2018) Peoples and Complex Societies of Ancient Southwest Asia, pgs. 433-444. In ‘The Human Past’, Fourth Edition, edited by Scarre C. 2. Pournelle J (2013) Physical Geography, pgs. 19-28. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 3. van de Mieroop M (2016) A History of the Ancient Near East, 3rd Edition, pgs. 10-17. 4. Beaulieu PA (2018) A History of Babylon, pgs. 29-40. 5. Hammer E (2019) The city and landscape of Ur: an aerial, satellite, and ground reassessment. 6. Algaze G (2008) Ancient Mesopotamia at the Dawn of Civilisation, pg. 44-46. 7. Margarete van Ess (2013) Reed as a raw material. In ‘Uruk: First City of the Ancient World’. 8. Algaze G (2008) Ancient Mesopotamia at the Dawn of Civilisation, pg. 106. 9. Nissen HJ (2013) Uruk’s beginnings and early development. In ‘Uruk: First City of the Ancient World’. 10. Vogel H (2013) The “Great man of Uruk”: The Art of Governance in the late Fourth and early Third Millennia BC. In ‘Uruk: First City of the Ancient World’. 11. Birch N (2013) History and Chronology, pgs. 116-120. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 12. Crawford H (2004) Sumer and the Sumerians, Second Edition, pgs. 16-36. 13. Stone EC (2013) The Organisation of a Sumerian Town, pgs. 161-169. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 14. Collins P (2013) Everyday life in Sumer, pgs. 345-358. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 15. van de Mieroop M (2016) A History of the Ancient Near East, 3rd Edition, pgs. 48-63. 16. Westenholz JG (2013) In the Service of the Gods: The Ministering Clergy, pgs. 246-276. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 17. Crawford H (2004) Sumer and the Sumerians, Second Edition, pg. 30. 18. van de Mieroop M (2013) Democracy and the rule of law, the assembly and the first law code, pgs. 277-287. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 19. Suter CE (2013) Kings and Queens: representation and reality, pgs. 201-226. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 20. van de Mieroop M (2016) A History of the Ancient Near East, 3rd Edition, pg. 30. 21. Beaulieu PA (2018) A History of Babylon, pgs. 33-34. 22. Wright HT (1969) The Administration of Rural Production in an Early Mesopotamian Town, pg. 41. 23. Steinkeller P (1999) On rulers, priests and sacred marriage: tracing the evolution of Early Sumerian Kingship. In ‘Priests and Officials in the Ancient Near East’, edited by Watanbe K. 24. McCaffrey (2013) The Sumerian Sacred Marriage: Texts and Images, pgs. 227-241. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 25. Schaudig H (2013) The Ancient Near East Ruler, pgs. 111-115. In ‘Uruk: First City of the Ancient World’. 26. Jacobson T (1943) Primitive Democracy in Ancient Mesopotamia. 27. Jacobson T (1957) Early political development in Mesopotamia. 28. Westenholz A (2002) The Sumerian City State, pgs. 23-42. In ‘A Comparative Study of Six City-State Cultures’, edited by Hansen MH. 29. Postgate N (1992) Early Mesopotamia: Society and Economy at the Dawn of History, pg. 297. 30. Crawford H (2013) Trade in the Sumerian World, pgs. 447-459. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 31. Marchesi G (2004) Who Was Buried in the Royal Tombs of Ur? The Epigraphic and Textual Data. 32. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pg. 1-20 33. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pg. 33-43. 34. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pg. 225-226. 35. Thomas HL (1992) Historical Chronologies and Radiocarbon Dating, pg 147. 36. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 37, 114, 116. 37. Moorey P (1977) What do we know about the people buried in the Royal Cemetery? 38. Baadsgaard A (2016) All the Queen's Clothes: Identifying Female Royalty at Early Dynastic Ur. 39. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 73-91, 97-107. 40. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 155-160. 41. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 400-404. 42. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 98, 316. 43. Braun Holzinger E (1991) Apotropaic Figures at Mesopotamian Temples in the Third and Second Millennia, pgs. 149-172. 44. Cholidis N (2003) The Treasure of Ur from Mari, pg. 143. In ‘Art of the First Cities’, edited by Aruz J and Wallenfels R. 45. Woolley CL (1965) Excavations at Ur, pg. 59. 46. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 159, 316. 47. Reade J (2003) The Royal Tombs of Ur, pgs. 93-96. In ‘Art of the First Cities’, edited by Aruz J and Wallenfels R. 48. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 61-62. 49. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 266-274. 50. Reade J (2003) The Royal Tombs of Ur, pgs. 97-100. In ‘Art of the First Cities’, edited by Aruz J and Wallenfels R. 51. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 121-123, 264-266. 52. Reade J (2003) The Royal Tombs of Ur, pgs. 121-122. In ‘Art of the First Cities’, edited by Aruz J and Wallenfels R. 53. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 74-77, 249-258. 54. Cheng J (2009) A Review of Early Dynastic III Music: Man’s animal call, pgs. 173-178. 55. Rimmer J (1969) Ancient Musical Instruments of Western Asia in the British Museum, pgs. 14-18. 56. Reade J (2003) The Royal Tombs of Ur, pgs. 105-106. In ‘Art of the First Cities’, edited by Aruz J and Wallenfels R. 57. Cooper JS (2006) Genre, Gender, and the Sumerian Lamentation, pgs. 41-44. 58. Westenholz JG (2013) In the Service of the Gods: The Ministering Clergy, pgs. 264-266. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 59. Michalowski P (2006) LOVE OR DEATH? OBSERVATIONS ON THE ROLE OF THE GALA IN UR III CEREMONIAL LIFE, pgs. 49-61. 60. Michalowski P (1994) The Drinking Gods: Alcohol in Mesopotamian Ritual and Mythology, pgs. 27-44. In ‘Drinking in Ancient Societies: History and Culture of Drinks in the Ancient Near East’, edited by Milano L. 61. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 274-279. 62. Finkel IL (2007) On the Rules for the Royal Game of Ur, pgs. 22-32. In ‘Ancient Board Games in Perspective’, edited by Finkel IL. 63. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 37-41. 64. Pollock S (1991) Of Priestesses, Princes and Poor Relations: The Dead in the Royal Cemetery at Ur, pgs. 173-177. 65. Woolley CL (1965) Excavations at Ur, pg. 77-82. 66. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 312-13. 67. Douglas F (2010) The struggle for hegemony in “Early Dynastic II” Sumer, pgs. 37-77. 68. Gianni Marchesi (2010) The Sumerian King List and the early History of Mesopotamia, pgs. 231-48. 69. Tummal inscription entry on the Cuneiform Digital Library Initiative, assessed 29th September 2022. cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?SearchMode=Text&ObjectID=P469677 70. Steinkeller P (2003) An Ur III manuscript of the Sumerian King List. Literatur, Politik und Recht. In ‘Mesopotamien: Festschrift fur Claus Wilck’. 71. Sumerian King List (SKL) entry on the Cuneiform Digital Library Initiative, lines 132-140, assessed 29th September 2022. cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?CompositeNumber=Q000371 72. Sumerian King List (SKL) entry on the Cuneiform Digital Library Initiative, lines 39-42, assessed 29th September 2022. cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?CompositeNumber=Q000371 73. Sollberger E (1962) The Tummal Inscription, pg. 41. 74. Archi A (2004) Translation of Gods: Kumarpi, Enlil, Dagan/Nisaba, Halki, pg. 322. 75. van de Mieroop M (2016) A History of the Ancient Near East, 3rd Edition, pgs. 46-47. 76. Beaulieu PA (2018) A History of Babylon, pg. 35. 77. Kramer SN (1944) The Death of Gilgamesh. 78. Vogel H (2013) Death and Burial, pgs. 419-434. In ‘The Sumerian World’, edited by Crawford H. 79. Crawford H (2004) Sumer and the Sumerians, Second Edition, pgs. 135-136. 80. George AR (2003) The Babylonian Gilgamesh Epic, vol. 1, pgs. 12-17 81. The Death of Ur-Nammu (A), The Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, assessed 29th September 2022. etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk/section2/tr2411.htm 82. Pedde F (2013) Burials in Uruk, pgs. 288-289. In ‘Uruk: First City of the Ancient World’. 83. Sumerian King List (SKL) entry on the Cuneiform Digital Library Initiative, lines 112-118, assessed 29th September 2022. cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?CompositeNumber=Q000371 84. Charvát P (2002) Mesopotamia Before History, pg. 227. 85. Sürenhagen D (2002) Death in Mesopotamia: The 'Royal Tombs' of Ur Revisited. In ‘Of Pots and Plans : Papers on the Archaeology and History of Mesopotamia and Syria Presented to David Oates in Honour of His 75th Birthday’. 86. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pg. 38. 87. van de Mieroop M (2016) A History of the Ancient Near East, 3rd Edition, pg. 65-66. 88. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pg. 39-40. 89. Woolley CL (1950) Ur of the Chaldee, pgs. 51-103. 90. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 316, 340. 91. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 94, 316. 92. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 312, 316. 93. Marchesi G (2004) Who Was Buried in the Royal Tombs of Ur? The Epigraphic and Textual Data, pgs. 173-175. 94. Smith S (1928) Assyriological Notes, pgs. 864-868. 95. Böhl F (1930) Das Menschenopfer bei den alten Sumerern, pg 83-98. In ‘Zeitchrift für Assyriologie’. 96. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 49, 316. 97. Woolley CL (1934) Ur Excavations: Vol. 2, pgs. 116, 316.

[@dgonthehill]

wow interesting, thnx

[@Zogerpogger]

Citing sources is just one of many factors that sets this channel above most others that make documentaries.

[@nickwilliams2745]

Wow I’ve written papers for classes with worse citation than your youtube videos and tbh it’s not even close

[@flashmanfred]

Bro this is what I'm talking about!!! Proper citations are soooo lacking in KZbin history (and other subjects). Thank you for doing this!

[@ObjectiveEthics]

Thank you for your hard work. Your videos are both informative and compelling.

[@Comuniity_]

I think the most important thing I learned is the sacred bond between a man and his barber dates back thousands and thousands of years

[@maxdecphoenix]

'barber' itself is one of the longer continually used words in Western Civilization. The root 'barb' has been in use since pre-roman latin into the modern age to describe 'hair'. The romans had a throwing weapon, officially called a plumbata, but was colloquially called martio(us)barbuli, or in English "Mar's Barb". A homage to the hair of Mars, god of war, being impossibly tough, sharp and able to kill men. The weapon, a metal spike featuring a gruesome counter-hook, with a bulbous weight on the other end, wasn't dissimilar from a hair with a folicle attached. This is where we derive barber, and also 'barb' as in barbed wire. Two otherwise completely unrelated concepts which owe a shared etymological root to a happenstances of roman paganism and militarism.

[@KD400_]

​@@maxdecphoenix jeez my man ur very intelligent

[@JTA1961]

The Barbery Pirates sink slow too...

[@diskgrinder]

Is that about the oldest joke?

[@MotherSoren]

@@maxdecphoenix thank u genuinely for the barber etymology lore 🙏🏻💜

[@philipmarx1819]

The Royal Death Pits of Ur is a kickass name for metal band.

[@rossbrook5919]

😂

[@Exit311]

They'd have an epic giga mosh pit

[@CyberClown2077]

The epic of Gilamosh you say?​@Exit311

[@methodicalmysticbutterflyi2669]

I think you're on to something. 😅

[@TheDudeMyDude]

It's more of a song title but I'm with you

[@thefritz123]

The depth and and sincerity with which you explore and present this topic is impressive. Thank you, Sir.

[@samaritan_sys]

History Time and Histocrat in the same week… I think I’m gonna cry with joy!

[@JohnVance]

New Historia Civilis this week too! The trifecta!

[@courtneywissler7983]

They do this on purpose! I get two great docs in a couple days then I have to wait months.

[@jojojacques810]

All we need now is a new Fall Of Civilisations!! 👌🙏

[@courtneywissler7983]

@@jojojacques810 yeah you know!! My three favorite channels!

[@thecollierreport]

Exactly

[@ian_b]

One could get very confused discussing Early Ur, Earlier Ur, and it's founding condition, ur-Ur.

[@hoponlopo8690]

hahaha xD

[@davem4316]

i hope mr peabody got there already, seems it would have been obligatory

[@gibsonseffern9780]

Yes indeed 😊

[@Zogerpogger]

What a treat! I love the Histocrats documentaries, as much like Stephen Milo's, they recreate the same sensation of curiosity and amazement I felt as a child when watching documentaries. The music, the pacing, the images used, all come together in a unique and brilliant way.

[@BarryB.Benson]

Couldn’t agree with you more!

[@benmann1896]

I heard Stephen Milo on this video! Pretty sure he reads a quote at around 55 minutes.

[@Essentia-Channel]

@@benmann1896 Yep, I thought that too.

[@paulm283]

Yes these are quality my friend😊

[@QuaaludeCharlie]

$5.00

[@User-435ggrest]

I love putting these on at night and just drift away while learning about history. Thank you😊

[@jourcontre-jour1286]

Thank you for covering Ur I absolutely love their civilization

[@helenamcginty4920]

Ha! We had a text book at my secondary school called From Ur to Rome. Unfortunately our older teachers had degrees but no teacher training. (They must have been some of the 1st women to be allowed to take degrees in Britain then. ). They were rubbish teachers. Our history teacher being one of the worst. She wrote stuff, in italic script, on the board for us to copy into our books, in italic script and using dip pens (this in 1959/60). Homework involved copying maps and pictures ftom the text book. Why? Who knows. All I can recall about Ur from her lessons is that it was in mesopotamia and can still see that damn priest in his long skirt that we had to copy. I must have switched off as I recall nothing more of our 1st 2 years history lessons. 😅😢😅 Thank goodness for channels like this.

[@lostinsomevalley]

Appreciate the incredible amount of time you put into this channel. Thanks mate.

[@alfrednewman4496]

You appreciate it yourself. You're not the boss of me. I'll appreciate the channel's time expenditure and level of dedication because I want to not because YOU told me to. smh.......some nerve .....bully! I know what's good and don't need......

[@JustSpectre]

The best video on this topic I have ever seen. Very well researched, exceptionally narrated, comprehensively presented. You have my honest thanks.

[@gregkosinski2303]

Any relation to the race traitor?

[@vanzikky]

Thank you for this quiet (no hectic cuts, no dramatic music) and informative video.

[@Daniel-sf2te]

I got to see some of the artifacts at the Penn Museum, and I am so happy to find this video to learn more about this topic. It is such an interesting site

[@The_Reality_Filter]

Your content is always of such a high standard and often concentrates on lesser explored topics. Kudos to you sir and may the algorithm bless you...

[@TERMICOBRA]

Thank you for being an educator. Your teaching style successfully transfers profound facts as you wrap them in well defined theories so we don't confuse the two.

[@Imperiused]

Listened and watched while I was cleaning. These videos are truly a treasure. The research, the images, the narration... I could never not recommend this channel. You're criminally underwatched!

[@remainselusive1]

You had me at Death Pits.

[@maxthepaladin2147]

Always nice to learn more about Sumerians and other ancient cultures of that region

[@ie1961]

My sincere thanks for this presentation.

[@ponkoot]

Love these videos! The interesting content and absence of random, distracting audio combine to make for perfect wind down videos. Thanks!

[@manosassassin]

Oh boy it's 2Am and the Histocrat just uploaded, there goes my sleep.

[@PBunyanOx]

At least you'll know who was buried in the death pits of Ur

[@davidsparks4826]

It’s 8 pm where I live. But all the same. 😂✌🏼🙏🏼Love and Respect

[@chadjonesvii9369]

7:15PM in East Texas right now. We are all in different time zones. That's a wide ranging audience. 💯👍🏻

[@alexandriasimms4842]

1.30am here in the UK

[@johnrice1943]

@@chadjonesvii9369 I'm in East Texas too!

[@fuferito]

Very glad to have heard Stephan Milo's contribution as one of your readers.

[@lindaschubert5459]

Thanks for a superb narration on Ur. I'd like to hear more information on this topic.

[@johnqpublic2718]

You're incredibly good at what you do, Histocrat.

[@damiengreen5935]

There is so much to praise about the discussion presented within this documentary

[@reedreamer9518]

I have to give The Histocrat credit for filling in much of the commonly left out details of these found artifacts, which tell an essential part of the history. Such as, the order and condition of the artifacts as they were revealed in the digs, as well as the preservation and reconstruction.

[@arvydas0069]

I got to walk on top of the ziggurat and walk around at will. It’s hard to imagine all those things were buried underneath, the site was in disrepair. It’s sorta in middle of nowhere now, outside Nasiriyah

[@SacredDreamer]

😲 AMAZINGLY Lucky

[@arvydas0069]

@@SacredDreamer There's no gate around it, no security, although there was a large airbase called Talil Airbase, which I used to run armed security out of for American Civilians and Military engineers. I accompanied the American US Army Colonel in charge of rebuilding Iraq, Colonel Jon Christensen, around the Ziggurat and complex next door. Walked beneath one of the oldest non-restored standing arches in the world on that site, which was very cool. Luckily, only Saddam had ruined the site, by, incomprehensibly, building on top of the ruins to restore its original shape. The result was that it took a bit of knowledge of history and some photos to aim for the original structure. There were loads of cast off clay pot pieces of unknown age. I'm willing to bet they were from University of Pennsylvania researches and such from around a century or more ago, not from any ancient settlement.

[@ariessolarhijiri2985]

@@arvydas0069 you fucking need people ruined way more quit lying on Saddam

[@mark.J6708]

I've been all over this site. Mesmerizing and ancient, you can feel it.

[@sgilbert5753]

The royal cemetery at Ur's communal burial seems to suggest a less than peaceful change in overlordship, or perhaps dynasty; in that the surviving defeated were honoring their revered killed, perhaps during an overrun or post-victory executions.

[@bluegum6438]

It suggests either execution or religious sacrifice to me. I would not be surprised if it was tradition to have the court of a previous monarch summarily executed, it makes a grim kind of sense - your courtiers can't plot your demise and in fact will actively try to keep you alive, while future rulers have the uncertainty and treachery of navigating an established political structure wiped away. The respect shown to the corpses and the merciful method of execution indicates that their deaths were considered regrettably necessary for one reason or another. Very interesting to think about.

[@russell2910]

​@bluegum6yes, much as trump wants to get rid of the deep state.😊

[@mattthai7378]

These are so much better than the podcast format. A lot more work, I'm sure, but so worth it. Thank you! ❤️🙏❤️🙏❤️

[@Zogerpogger]

Even though I wish the History of Britain series would get a new installment, I get the feeling the Histocrat gets curious and learns new things faster than he can make videos and thus ends up just making a video on what he is most interested in at the time or learned most recently. If this is the case I totally understand why there have been a few series that seem to be abandoned.

[@TheHistocrat]

Yeah basically. Also patrons vote on the topics so they control what gets made first.

[@Zogerpogger]

@@TheHistocrat Makes sense about the Patrons, thanks for replying!

[@justaskin8523]

@@TheHistocrat You made me think of something. Even in ancient times, people had patrons. An artist with a single wealthy and generous patron could very well be elevated above his own blood and childhood associates. You might not even need to have been a "good" artist; just one that has somebody like you and give you money...or whatever passed for wealth of the time. Maybe you were paid in sheep or water buffalo meat. Once your belly was full, you could trade the remainder for whatever your heart desired. Gold, pomegranates, figs, a nice daggar, a good pair of shoes or maybe undergarments that kept some of the sand out of (ahem) "places". Or maybe a dowry for that cute little chica you noticed when she was drawing water one morning. Or even a nice grave, complete with set-pieces appearing to be strong young men and women. Nevermind the holes in the backs of their skulls, lol! 🤔

[@robinanders3954]

Or he found out info so damning and unbelievable he decided not to share it...maybe

[@ChristinaFromYoutube]

​​@@justaskin8523or you were a teenager and had to sell tail to those rich old men for the privilege of focusing on your art. You give these ancient predators too much credit.

[@shelleymarquis2887]

Great and accurate depiction of donkeys drawing a cart in the art work. Donkeys and mules built civilization with donkeys being the first equid domesticated, some 10,000 yrs ago. Genetics show that they were domesticated only once in Africa unlike horses and dogs who were domesticated at least twice that we know of, so far. Our modern horses are descended from only one of these groups of early domestications. Donkeys deserve respect not the abuse they get worldwide.

[@AtunSheiFilms]

Amazing work as always.

[@biedl86]

The quality of the content on this channel is exceptional. Great video!

[@TheMercian13]

Coming in clutch with another great video.

[@anasevi9456]

Incredible video, thank you so much and I hope your Docos are appreciated for decades.

[@immortal5383]

The quality of these are appreciated. Keep it up.

[@Domenik-g9b]

Great work! I am absolutely in awe with the content you create and I look forward to spend many more hours listening to you. Plus I am always happy to hear anyone mentioning Dr. Finkel, he is an astonishing man, who deserves even more attention.

[@cattymajiv]

Dr Irving Finkel is indeed a treasure for humanity.

[@toslo24]

I think it was a combination for the followers to be buried with their ruler - 1 the succeeding kings would get rid of any potential threats to their kingship and 2 the followers would avoid a loss of status and hence 'choose' to be buried with their ruler. I think it would have been difficult to force a solider to bury themselves unless they were halfway willing.

[@Badficwriter]

I agree. Human nature argues elaborate shows of power would continue, unless there was a particular reason for it. So the mass death was not a show of power by the deceased, but a symptom of a shift in power, I think. Which doesn't mean they weren't willing, completely, due to the near celebratory trappings. (We mustn't forget how willing death cults are to reach apotheosis) Poison is not as sure as people think, death can be long and sickening. Kneeling to accept a death blow after a hearty drink of wine isn't that much different from poisoning oneself.

[@KittymoreJoy]

I do not agree, although the servants may have known that they would be killed with a ruler, does not always mean it was a willing act by a sacrificed person, but resignation. Did the Inca maidens understand that death awaited them at the end of a strenuous journey? Drugs always make victims easy to control minds and bodies. Human sacrifice had many excuses given 11:33 by those in political and religious people.

[@fisticuffsmate]

you post some of my favorite videos on youtube, i really do appreciate what you do!

[@ThatLadyBird]

This was an amazing video...as always. Counting the days till the next.

[@fishofthepeople]

Thank you, Sir. It's been a sad time waiting for you to post another precious piece of knowledge.

[@Riley-uy5pe]

love it when one of the fav history tubes uploads a nice fat video essay for all our enjoyment 😌🧡

[@vanguze]

Thank you. Truly fascinating.

[@HoH]

Incredibly interesting!

[@cocalicoman]

Gusto Rat and Historian Civilis upload on the same day. Early Christmas gift

[@burntbiscuit6438]

I got a mate that tells me bedtime stories a million miles away

[@otilium7503]

Beautifully done, thank you!

[@evankimori]

Today is really overcast and really quiet with a drizzle of rain. I've got a long drive ahead of me this morning and I'm lucky enough to have the Histocrat in my ears today. Thanks for making today great!

[@dbartholemewfox]

1:16:23 This poem probably references the rebellion of Ur (lead by Lugal-ane) against Sargon. Thus Enheduana is appealing to the goddess Ishtar (and others) to slay the supporters of Nanna (the patron god of Ur) because of Ur's rebellion against her father. Enheduana was actually high priestess at the Temple of Nanna (in Ur) at the time. After this incident Enheduana seems to have switched allegiances to the goddess Ishtar (aka Inanna), only writing poems for her, instead of the moon god Nanna. The idea that the poem is referencing a ritual mass funeral is pretty nonsensical if you read the entire poem. A more modern translation of the same lines (by Jeremy Black) make this clear: "In the place of divine encouragement, what is my standing now? May An extradite the land which is a malevolent rebel against your Nanna! May An smash that city! May Enlil curse it! May its plaintive child not be placated by his mother!" In this translation it's clear that Enheduanna is cursing the city Ur despite her close relationship to its patron god Nanna.

[@Angayasse]

A perfect treat - thank you so much for this work, this is extremely interesting!

[@rugosetexture2716]

Fascinating subject, beautifully presented. Thank you!

[@elcesar999]

The older the better and nothing older than Summer thanks my guy

[@iwxw8437]

Baal bek is older than sumer

[@klaatoris]

Great stuff. But I am curious about the "fashion sense" of the Sumerians. It seems to me like nearly all the ancient peoples of this region, from the Akkadians down to the Persians, liked to portray their rulers with big, long, well groomed beards. On the Standard of Ur, however, everyone from the defeated soldiers to the king are clean shaven and bald or short haired. Did the Sumerians have distinctly different aesthetic ideals from the other ones?

[@guird4]

I remember reading that the sumerians were very different from their neighbors in many respects - their language for instance is assumed to be from a different language family than the others. Where I read this, they suggested that the sumerians had been forced to move inland by an advancing persian gulf.

[@cattymajiv]

@@guird4 It's not just suggested, their language was a different one, unrelated to any other known today. This has been proven by the Assyriologists who study the tablets and Linguists who study ancient languages. Dr Irving Finkel of the British Museum, where most of the tablets are kept, and who studies them, has said that in several of his fascinating (and humorous) lectures.

[@Badficwriter]

Perhaps they shaved at different stages of the year? We know wigs and false beards were a thing in Egypt, but those things could get very dirty and insect ridden in a swampy area.

[@mikef.1000]

The shaving off of the beards of the defeated was calculated to shame them deeply.

[@klaatoris]

@@mikef.1000 That does not explain why the king also is bald and shaven, though.

[@VivaAlecto]

oh thank you this is exactly what I needed

[@massimosquecco8956]

Great report, Sir, I m grateful for your accurate work in making this video...

[@devinsmith4790]

The Sumerians are a interesting ancient culture.

[@lindanorris2455]

and gorgeous jewlery!

[@robinanders3954]

Especially when you research and find all ancient cultures worshiped the same so called "gods" just by different names. These same fallen angels who rebelled against GOD and choose to be worshiped as "gods" here on earth rather than serve their CREATOR and follow HIS rules. And this same ruling class of these same ancient fallen angel bloodlines worship the same so called "gods" as they did way back then. The ancient rebellion against GOD goes on to this day. That rebellion is almost over tho. Judgement is due and is coming soon.

[@janewright315]

​@@robinanders3954 just stop

[@valkoroska2369]

@@robinanders3954 right dude. say that to these dudes who make your religion religion as young as a baby in comparison.

[@sunstardrummer]

​@@robinanders3954😊

[@michaelhead7483]

This is for the algorithm so you reach a larger audience . Great vid

[@rc1800]

Yessss!! I just started getting into learning about Sumerian history as well :)

[@buttercxpdraws8101]

Love this ❤ And a special voice cameo from young Stefan Milo. Glorious 👏

[@cattymajiv]

As well as making great videos like this, I love the fact that you very obviously delete all the comments by the wingnuts. It's SUCH a huge relief to know that I won't have to try to dig through mountains of garbage about aliens, conspiracies by everyone with a degree, and other craziness, just to find the interesting comments! So what remains here are all the interesting ones! BRAVO to you on SO many levels! ❤❤❤

[@mungomidge1090]

Loved this, very informative and entertaining.

[@WitchyWhispersASMR]

Watch out, y’all, there’s a new histocrat video! My Friday night is about to get LIT 🎉

[@ficklefingeroffate]

Thank you sir! My Friday night is complete!

[@carriekelly4186]

Thank you so much for sharing this fascinating history of civilization's first largest city. Yes most likely priest figures for the early Mesopotamian Deities...the most interesting being the last..possibly grandaughter or daughter of Sargon? First very profound writers that we have a pen name to her writing. Morgan gallery has an incredible large exhibit of female Mesopotamian writers,poets,artwork and portraits thereof. Just mindblowing as how much i could relate to an artist of some four thousand years ago. Absolutely beautiful. Enheduanna. Her writing and this exhibit is a must for those interested.

[@silentone11111111]

Better than history channel by far. Great work.

[@johnnzboy]

Super interesting, your level of research does you credit. For future reference, keep in mind that, in Italian, 'ch' is pronounced like 'k' (e.g. Pinocchio) , so (Gianni) Marchesi is pronounced 'mar-kay-see' :)

[@bonifaciodachuva]

The fineness of their craftmanship is astounding; no wonder they would treasure it so much.

[@Stu161]

I think it's very interesting that the bead found in Mari is seen as strong evidence of Mes-Anne-pada's influence in that region. In North American archaeology, it's relatively common to find goods thousands of miles from their culture of origin.

[@King_king880]

Thank you for your rich knowledge in History and mythology.

[@fredericpaes7288]

thank you for one more great video

[@metalman7791]

Excited about this one!

[@jameswoodard4304]

Interestingly, after watching this, I looked up the writings attributed to Enheduanna (but may be much older and back-attributed). At the beginning of one of her long hymns to Inanna, and which stresses Inanna's role as the obtainer of the divine mes or powers, she refers to the goddess as "Mistress of heaven, with the great diadem, who loves the good headdress befitting the office of en priestess, who has seized all seven of its divine powers." The en priestess of Inanna in Ur would have had a distinct headdress. The headdress of Puabi mentioned in this video features seven prominent star/floral figures rising out of it. The only real evidence for calling her "Queen" Puabi is her apparent wealth and social standing. But to automatically connect this with Lugalship over Enship is largely ad hoc.

[@CatchingJeremy]

I loved randomly hearing Stefan Milo like an audiobook

[@karsaorlong3761]

sick, i gave it a like instantly, thank you good sir

[@jwolpert1310]

Great documentary! My daughter and I love the game of 20 square's and Dr. Finkels rules!

[@interstellarconveyance4865]

Any thoughts about the current national policies regarding preservation of these artifacts? Every now and then there are rumors of government officials looting museums, and or shutting museums down and "moving collections for protection", sadly the United States has a non interest policy which eliminates any scientific cooperation between our two countries. Thank you for an amazing and beautiful presentation into this ancient world.

[@danielfouardlibertarianono8017]

Through all the research and podcasts I've listened to about mesopotamia and ur this is the first I've ever heard of the cemetery and it's contents.

[@maciejtedeque8096]

Oh man i was waiting for mesopotamia again!

[@Guydude777]

Stellar content. Thanks a ton Histocrat.

[@JayGideon-7]

Very instructive, and thorough. Thank you. The rhythmic nature of the narration however soon became disagreeable.

[@ruthmusser4449]

I loved this. Shows how people always exalted others. Still today.

[@thesaints-7-andrew.]

Watching from Greece.hi everybody. Great documentary.

[@Zogerpogger]

For some reason I feel the urge to comment a funny thing that happened, even though it is not at all relevant to this video. In The Histocrat Q&A you said you recommended any History channel except M. Laser History, being the fool I am, I took that at face value. I was conflicted wondering why one of my favorite History youtubers did not recommend another of my favorite History KZbinrs! Then I saw an M. Laser comment saying to avoid your channel, I was baffled. When I asked for an explanation M. Laser informed me politely that it was a joke. I faceplamed hard, ashamed at my own thick-headedness. Thus ended my poor humorless torment. However I am now curious what your thoughts on TIK are, as M. Laser does not recommend (though I can guess why).

[@debztully1339]

Thanks for the content!

[@EnDB]

I saw the diagram, the harp, and two crushed skulls at a museum in Philadelphia a few months ago.

[@oconnorsean12]

This was excellent!

[@OmarJano]

I love to splurge on random history videos like these when I drink. Thanks for the awesome content! New sub.

[@joshhale7004]

this is excellent. Thank you so much Charles.

[@cyclingbrad4201]

Impressive presentation and narration!

[@darrencorrigan8505]

Thanks, Histocrat.

[@jamiel6005]

I’ve never been more interested in a video based solely on its title before

[@djn00dle]

You had me at "This video contains images of human remains..."

[@magicpyroninja]

There's more evidence than just that burial pit of human sacrifice in the area. During that time frame, the worshipers of baal used to sacrifice infants on the altar. We found the altars and the infant bones

[@royriley6282]

Modern archaeologists: Older scholars were presumptuous Also Modern archaeologists: Muh Rituals

[@wesdowner5636]

With all the knowledge that the excavators had of previous grave looting, why would any current archeologist assume that the remaining evidence and artifacts are in their original locations?

[@RaimoKangasniemi]

When it comes to 17:20, the idea of a female ruler was not totally alien in ancient Mesopotamia. The Sumerian king list from the III Dynasty of Ur names a likely mythological ruling queen of Kish, Kubaba, who would have ruled three generations or so before Sargon the Great of Akkad, aka around 2450 BCE.

[@Krommer1000]

Great video on a fascinating subject. Thank you.

[@LeifurHakonarson]

Very interesting - but that upward inflection at the end of words drove me up the walls ....

[@Primetiime32]

Thank you for the upload