How To Visualize (if you can't visualize)

[@H2ogamerPRO]

My mind is, pitch black, pitch black, pitch black. There, that's my apple

[@markperryman2474]

Me to

[@malarai1648]

Me too

[@purefranciska1299]

Same

[@astontrainspotterandroblox]

Same

[@plagueloll]

Same

[@Malepical]

For those of you who are having trouble with this exercise, I think some people are looking to produce images that sit on the inside of your eyelids like a movie screen.. I can do that but can't sustain it just yet.. only flickers that disappear when I try to look at it.. but visualization via imagination is different and easy... it's just like day dreaming.. there is no actual image on your eyeball but you can "see" quite clearly in your mind.. it's like accessing an old memory.. when you think of a moment in time as a child, maybe at a park or at school or whatever, any moment in time you remember clearly.. when you think of that moment and replay the moment, what you're experiencing or "seeing" is your image... so remember a time in which you ate an apple... do you remember how it looked? how it felt? how it tasted? where were you? what were you wearing? remember eating that apple as if you were eating it now... remember what it looked like as you picked it up, wherever you were... maybe you were at the breakfast table, or on a school bus, or in the grocery store stealing.. remember the moment you held that apple up, just before you took a bite.. remember how the smell rose up to your nose as you opened your mouth to bite it.. slow that moment down and freeze it... just remember it like a screenshot from a movie you took with your cell phone... zoom in on the apple in your memory... you already remember what it looks like.. just remember it's surface, the light bouncing off it's skin, the size and heft of it.. now focus on the apple so that the rest of the memory fades away... no worries about what you were wearing or who was nearby.. all you remember is that apple from that particular day... do you still remember it? do you REMEMBER what it looked like?? if you do, congratulations.. you just visualized yourself an apple! the key to visualization is to not worry about what you think you're SUPPOSED to be seeing with your eyes and just IMAGINE using real life experiences, places, objects and people... imagination incorporates any technique the brain can find to communicate with itself.. whether that way is by actual images being seen on the backs of your eyelids, or by a memory or a daydream, it doesn't really matter at all... just let your mind speak to you the way it feels most comfortable.. if all you do is close your eyes and see black but you can remember what an apple looks like, that's your visualization... don't compare your way to the ways of others cuz you'll never be satisfied with the outcome, always doubting it's authenticity.. just accept that your brain will show you what it needs to in the ways that it needs to.. nothing is "wrong" with you, you are perfection! 😍😘💕

[@martyr3757]

Mallorie Erin i can vizualize correctly but i have some focus trouble

[@ChristopherWanha]

A tip I read was to practice with your eyes open, looking outward without moving your eyes and just paying attention to the scene what's on the left of your periphery, the right, but to specifically not focus on anything in particular, just a blank stare. This is beneficial to those who can conjure images ,but those images disappear as instantly as they appeared, a possible explanation is that you literally moved your eyeballs to look at it and focus on it, and there is sufficient enough sensory detail on the inside of your eyelids to pull you out of your imagination and back to the external imagery of the inside of your eye lid. If you instead make sure to not move your eyes and focus on conjured imagery you may be able to sustain that imagery for longer duration.

[@danielmonteiro5876]

Hey Mallorie Erin Thanks a lot for the advice and putting in your effort to help others

[@RosieBrownie]

Christopher Wanha Thank you SO MUCH! That's exactly how I did it when I was a very young child, I used to visualise and "daydream" a LOT and I remember it so so vividly! And nowadays I can't do it at all, after I turned like 13 it just "went away." My aunt told me it was because I was growing up and my third eye was closing.... 😕 (I might add, I'm on the autism spectrum and I was going through trauma and depression at that time and I was developing dissociative disorder, so that COULD be why!) Thank you SO much for reminding me of this simple but genius technique!!! Maybe I can get back into it with some practise! 😃👍 *Thanks for sharing your knowledge!*

[@vicb9129]

I tried all of this. I'm laying beside my partner right now, and without looking at him, I don't know how he looks like. It's called aphantasia. Do you have any other ways that I can maybe practice? It would really help, and thank you 🤗

[@JamJells]

This worked well for me. red stem no room crisp on table tart. But no sight. Just thought. Its the verbs we need to learn and use. Working on details helps the most. Thanks!

[@ElegyVio]

Jesus is the truth

[@FreeRangeCreative]

So.... This isn't how to visualize if you can't visualize. This is "If you can't visualize things, I'm going to request you to visualize things." It seems like this is a little like asking someone with no left arm to just go ahead and raise your left hand in the air anyway.

[@h.a.s.42]

Exactly. Frustrating.

[@ewanyoike100]

Lloyd Metcalf

[@joseantoniolopezgomez3614]

No man, don't give up so easily..do accept the challenge. Any thing you get is much better than nothing. I can't visualize, that why I came to this page. To be encouraged somehow, ok?

[@alcachofillapodrida4866]

I interpreted it different, like if you could see an apple, which colour would you LIKE the apple to be.

[@brotherseraphim9700]

Hmm, I didn't think so, not when he's distinguished between visualizing in the sense of literally seeing the apply in imagination, and seeing it in concepts. When I tried it, I wasn't seeing it in imagination, but easily enough conceived it, and this had the "feel" of seeing in imagination - had I seen it in imagination, I'd have given the same answers, and felt the same; close enough for me. Similarly, when trying to "see" in imagination various "images" for us in the art of memory, I find that there, too, it works just fine to *intend* to see it, even if in imagination I"m drawing a blank. Anyway, that's how it works and seems to me.

[@whiteside08]

Red, stem, leaf, room temperature, crisp, and in black space.

[@ElegyVio]

Jesus is the truth

[@madmagus7693]

Most people can't visualize well because they never actually see objects in exact detail in the first place. So they get a fuzzy object when they look into their memory. Practice by looking at an actual object intently for a couple minutes, noting every detail, then close your eyes and try to recreate it in your mind's eye. Do this multiple times. Practice this every day, and your visualization/memory recall will dramatically improve.

[@scottbuckman4816]

Thank you for this video! I'd like to add... If everyone could just take a step outside themselves for a moment…When we were children, we had no inhibitions. We just did stuff. Experienced things. Wanted something, so we found a way to get it or do it… As adults we create in our heads all sorts of walls, blocks and things that would prevent us from getting what we want. Stop doing that! Stop being mean and nasty to yourself and go get what you want… Feel good no matter what! You will being is all that matters… You have that you get everything else. Why beat yourself up?! Literally ask yourself why am I beating myself up? There's enough people out there to do that for you knock it off! There's enough people out there trying to prevent you from getting what you want there's enough people out there beating you up there's enough people out there trying to tear you down and take you off your path… Don't allow that! Go get what you want; simply do it without harming anybody or anything in nature. This planet provides everything you came here for and more! Think about it, feel it in your gut try to imagine what it would feel like to have what you want and allow it to come. You need to allow yourself to receive! When you get up in the morning nothing negative has happened yet… Don't allow things to filter in and ruin your day your hour your moment. You're in charge, you're in control and you decide if you feel good or not… Not anybody else. They don't get to do that for you. You're not theirs, you are yours! Don't have the attitude I will never, I can't, I won't, or anything like that. Everything is right there for you. The fact that you say well I can't have that, is the initial problem with you not having… You all know what it would feel like to be $1 million in debt don't you you know what it feels like to be $1000 and that you know what feels like to owe somebody 10 bucks and you don't have it… well if you know what it feels like to be in debt or to want that car that you don't have or that house, flip those thoughts around… Try to see yourself in that house...why not? ..you feel miserable. Why don't you feel good instead?! Teach yourself to feel good all the time-screw it! Look misery in its eyes and smile and say I'm gonna turn you into everything that I want and everything that I came here for. Get up in the morning or the afternoon or the evening and do everything and anything you could possibly do to bring happiness into your life if it's playing cards with yourself play cards with yourself, if it's going for a bike ride or a walk or dropping to the floor and doing some sit ups if you think about it, Do it… Keeping in mind to not harm anything in nature. We don't need to be harmful creatures to get what we want… Train your brain don't allow your brain to train you! We used to be told that as human beings we have the most powerful computer in our heads, the human brain. We need to start using our brains again. We were given the ability to create. We are as human beings wondrous creators...look at what we've done with this planet… It was a ball of trees dirt rocks minerals- we didn't get here as humans and have buildings and roads and cars and schools, And we certainly didn't have theme parks with roller coasters and waterslides… We even created things like birthdays and such for kids to enjoy. We domesticated animals so we could have a friend when we can't find another human being to partner with. We've invented and develop things like the camera and the motion picture camera & the digital camera in your phone ..I didn't grow up with that. Everything we think about all day brings us what that is. You may as well think about everything you crave, desire, need! You came here because you have desires… And it certainly wasn't to be miserable. OK done have a great day thanks for reading… Just before I go, my dad used to tell me I was gonna wish my life away… So I stopped wishing and now I wish I hadn't. Don't stop dreaming don't stop wishing wanting and imagining! Love to all peace to all happiness to all

[@muyiwaogunmefun4664]

This is good. Thank you.

[@frankkkkk]

This comment might as well change my life. Thank you for taking your time to write this.

[@DivineMaster11-2]

Wow. ❤

[@charliep.9107]

I have aphantasia & none of my senses work while trying to imagine something. I just KNOW. I dont know if since i was born this way or had brain damage from overdosing on flouride pills when i was a young child if i can gain the ability to imagine with my senses internally. The only thing i noticed is u telling me to think about an apple made my mouth water.

[@grandyamz9768]

My Apple is green crisp tart sour juicy

[@ivibrown1953]

it was a pink lady apple with a stem with no leaves. It was room temperature, sitting on a blue plate on a purple table with the the light of a cloudy day shining through the window onto it. Thanks for walking us through this. I don't so much see nothing.. I just can't usually make up my mind which image to commit to. I tend to often feel bombarded with possibilities and start feeling anxious.

[@K1rkHammet]

Fell asleep while watching this video and woke up 5 hours later in the morning :s

[@sylthasmodeus2709]

HAHAHA

[@kushalhamal9871]

I find it very hard to imagine even you called “imagine an apple”

[@karaoketaylorxsingsfan232]

Me too

[@PumpkinAndShadow]

I have no voluntary sensory recall, the new term for it is Aphantasia. It was affirming that I was able to create an apple in my mind and answer these questions. I do still wish I could experience visualization, but being able to recognize that my imagination is still real is very helpful.

[@ctrl_alt_create]

i have aphantasia so, no visual apple for me, but anyway: the invisible apple is blue. it is shaped like a red delicious apple. it has a stem, and one leaf like the apple logo. it is ice cold to the touch (i mean duh, it's blue) and has a mealy texture (it's a red delicious, after all) I can even taste it. bland. it is floating in space. well, it could be on a table, but alas it is not; it's just floating in an infinite field of black.

[@23CoSo]

So simple but so effective. Well done, Josh.

[@zenithji25]

Rubbish, your title of the video is "if you can't visualise" and you are asking the color and taste of the apple listen, everything is just black that's why I watched your video

[@nicolefermor]

Hi, i recommend you take an a test for Aphantasia. It might clear up any questions you have about not being ale to visualize or in general just see black.

[@johnysantefit3626]

This video was very helpful to me. I’m the same way I only see black but I was able to imagine the image of an apple. The goal was not to “see” the apple but imagine it. Maybe you need more practice and change your attitude towards it.

[@10noahw14]

When I visualized stuff i realize that I’m just imagining it and it goes away help

[@skinnyfella1976]

How can I imagine any of this without seeing it? Its just picking random answers. I could do this ten times and pick a different scenario every time.

[@miki_agnes]

I used to be very good in visualisation, very vivid, but do to a few traumatic experiences in my youth, I, unconsciously shut it down, probably a defense mechanism, I can feel, but see nothing. I really want to regain that ability. I hope this will work..

[@peggyfinsterbusch852]

Green, so stem, no leaves, on the kitchen counter. Very helpful, no picture, but appreciate noticing the detail, my mouth even watered at the thought of the taste.

[@hiyosuki]

aphantasia is new to me,I never really knew about it,I would be so confused when people say "close your eyes and imagine a rainbow" or something and all I see are white circles,but the thing is I can still see things when I dream,like I can actually see a rainbow if I'm dreaming,it's really confusing and weird but oh well

[@abbymartinez8459]

Exact same thing for me

[@GringoLokoMusic]

Red/Yellow (Honey Crisp), No Stem, No Leaves, Cold, Straight out of Fridge. Crisp taste.. Great video that helped

[@connorfrankston4040]

My apple was red, with a stem, no leaves, cold, hard, crisp, sitting on a table. Thank you.

[@siglematic3092]

I used to be able to visualize so good when i was younger..but now i can't as good

[@ItsVuze1]

Red Has a stem No leaves Room temperature In a white background

[@MB-rp6od]

So I just found out today that I may have aphantasia. When I did this exercise I could not see anything and could only think about these attributes. The question I have is when non-aphantasia people see the apple, are they learning information from the image? Do they determine whether the apple has a stem from the image and not from deciding it has one? I honestly didn't know if the apple had a stem or not and felt like I was just assigning attributes randomly to create the profile of this apple, but I never saw a manifestation of the apple.

[@TheAccountingAlchemist]

It was a beautiful red apple with a stem and no leaves. As I reached out to pick it up, it was chilly to my touch, crispy on a bite and sweet as I tasted it. This is beautiful

[@kyleealexis]

Red, stem, one leaf, room temp, crisp, and on a kitchen counter! This helped! Thank you!

[@lucasa1849]

I feel like I can have very vivid dreams and daydreams. But when told to visualize on command I cant do it. And I don’t know what visualizing something is supposed to look like, so I can’t tell if I’m doing it right..

[@ElegyVio]

Jesus is the truth

[@lucasa1849]

@@ElegyVio no.

[@robloxer1183]

@@lucasa1849 Shut up,jesus is truth,your just dumb

[@doggies400]

It worked for me. I saw an apple floating in space dark red with a stem, no leaves crisp and tart and room temperature, I could smell it too. I think people get confused because they think visualization uses the eyes. It doesn’t. It uses the vision center in the back of the head. If they close their eyes it is dark and they are seeing the back of their eye lids. When we see, the light that enters our eyes and turns into electrical signals that travel down our optic nerve to the vision center of our brain, which is in total darkness, and yet we see. So if people try to visualize using the back of their head it’s sometimes easier and you can learn to do it with your eyes closed or open. It just takes practice

[@foo_tube]

Pale green with a little bit of red. Stem, no leaves. Crisp. On a bar shelf in the kitchen where we tend to put apples. Maybe it was a memory? Is remembering a visual memory different than visualization?

[@rhondagenesis6985]

Green apple, crisp& juicy, stem, no leaf, sitting on a table.....Thanks Josh....this was helpful

[@GiniaMarie1]

Apple: green, cut in half sitting on a vinyl record label. You can see a stem, the seeds and it's spinning on a turntable. I hear . . .Baby you can drive my car . . . Beatles! Then I imagined a real green apple, it had no stem, but there were little white spots leading down the little funnel where the stem used to be, and some brown too. I reach out my hand and feel the hardness, I take a bite and my salivary glands start working. It snaps, it is crisp and a little cold :) It's delicious! Thanks, that was great.

[@its_chyguy6892]

watery dew drops on a bright red apple, with a brown stem and single flag like green leaf at the top. It was floating in space. imma train my visuals to become more vivid thank you

[@angelspiderlily2641]

I do have Aphantasia and for me the title sounds like "How do i cook if i cant cook"

[@athol32]

Is it possible that visualisation skills improve very slowly ? Becouse i have been practising 3 months and my progres was a litte bit or nonthing so i stopped. I started again and i am afraid that i have something like biological barrier.

[@yeplucero2565]

Red stem with one leaf on the right ,it was outside air temp. It was not completely hard and crisp but it wasnt to mealy. It was on the ground near a tree.

[@HippieChildTerra]

How does this apply to past life regression? Can you still have a successful past life regression if you can't see anything?

[@jojomariejosee]

Red apple wot a hit of brown on it, a stem with one leaf on it, crisp and juicy, floating in black space! Thank you, this was really helpful!!

[@ascottk33]

He's using conceptual ideas to build on a simple concept. Anything you can describe verbally can be substituted for visualization. He keeps adding more concepts verbally. I have aphantasia so I rely on conceptual and aural thought processes for my imagination. Look up Temple Grandin, an author who has Aspergers, who categorizes thought processes into visual, conceptual, and aural.

[@ElegyVio]

Jesus is the truth

[@jjvoity7797]

could not see anything, I just picked traits at random out of the options given - red, no stem, no leaves, room temperature, crisp, floating with nothing around it. Sadly, I don't feel this exercise helped me.

[@xx.6852]

I only see it blurry (not blurry) but not clear and it is dull, this has helped me thanks!

[@markperryman797]

My brain is a darker shad of black

[@GiseleGrenier]

red and green, stem, one lead, on a table, cold, crisp and tart .

[@debbieteague6070]

Thanks for that exercise. My apple was green, no stem, cold, in my hand, it was smooth, and tasted crisp; yum. Could not see it at all; just black screen. My Reiki instructor says it is very important to visualize so this will help. The instructor said I can see - just is blocked.

[@d3vinity]

What if you have aphantasia?

[@bricology]

Precisely; it sounds like that's his situation (it's also mine).

[@woozii.capalot]

@@bricology I dont see black when I close my eyes. I see a bunch if colours and shapes, usually a brick wall that is rainbow coloured

[@nryane]

I imagined baked apple slices with sugar and cinnamon, with taste and smell. I could sense the slices and imagine the cinnamon-sprinkled thick liquid sauce they were in, without “seeing” them clearly. I could NOT imagine an actual apple. What many of us experience is due to aphantasia, the inability of the brain to create “sighted images” or pictures. Interesting. Although I am unable to “visualize”, I dream in technicolor. I don’t remember specific “images”, but everything is bright and clear and in color. I believe that my emotions are what are being “dreamed”. If I need to “visualize”, I can imagine being in a safe place, by a flowing stream in a forested area - and it presents as if I’m actually IN a place of safety, with green grass and trees and bushes. It’s more like a photograph, with me in it, experiencing peace/calm/safety. Still not an actual “picture” - more like feelings that happen to have those colors. Once I discovered a name for this inability to “visualize”, it made my process clearer to me. My brain works DIFFERENTLY. It isn’t inadequate or lacking. Such a RELIEF!!! I would go away from personal development classes feeling “less than” and unable to “SEE” my future. And yet my life has been interesting and fulfilling. Thank you for reassuring us about visualizing and for encouraging us to use whatever senses come up for us during the process. Blessings!

[@jcazabal4004]

Greate exercise..nice suit

[@tassiad.9137]

dark red almost like wine colours, crisp and juice it was floating in black space but when u mentioned table it was right o top of a table. but it was hard to keep an still "image" of the same apple in focus

[@epjlovelife4035]

Green apple with no leave, just static in space, crispy and juicy. Thanks Josh

[@shortyduwop9172]

My apple was red with some green, had a stem and was sitting on a table. It was crisp and juicy.

[@stanley432leasure5]

it was red , had a stem 1 leaf, room temp.crisp, on a wooden table, i paused the video and tried it again . everything was the same ,but this time it was more of a feeling instead of an image. cool technique thanks .

[@sebsebastian9704]

Good lord. You are the first person I have found to actually address the HOW TO of visualization. Thanks so much (I only see black too, so this is such a great find).

[@bryanforster1095]

Green, no stem, no leaves, floating, crisp, cool, juicy, and thanks for giving me an insight

[@reneelynn1964]

My apple is also green with a stem no leaves. It's floating and its hard a cold with a crisp wet tasted

[@sudarshanbadoni6643]

🎉Thank's. A good exercise to attemp and in my case memory of an Apple tree having just a few leftover apples on some branches is reviving when touring a place. What kind of taste will be of that maroon color type of apple was a curiosity and attempted plucking one and was a wild taste experience quite interesting in comparison to usual apples we having. Thanks. It was off season in winter quite cold as apple's have already been harvested and packaged for dispach in nearby big shedd godown. Thanks again.

[@dancingshiva7008]

Apple was red. On a table in the kitchen. Had a stem. Sometimes had a leaf, but mostly didn't. Firm and room-temperature cool. Deliciously sweet and crisp, though the mushy sensation/image keeps slipping in. Hmm, visualizing the sensations other than/along with vision... Good technique... I'll try this.

[@valeriesmith15]

Thank you, when you said don't visualize. I started to see the shape, it was red no leaves, a stem red, room temperature, on a table and it started to roll off and it fell off the table, it make the crunching sound, when it fell off. That felt so real.

[@ElegyVio]

Jesus is the truth

[@rhett3oo]

when i try to imagine things i see like them very fuzzy and through like a beige lense with cracks and i just loose focus immediately

[@auroraanni8122]

Red, stem, no leaf, room temperature, crisp and floating in space

[@expresslawn5214]

I can't visualize but I can imagine. I do believe it depends on how eyes located and on what part of the brain u concentrate. People who can't visually see something do still have dreams and can comprehend world around. Some just stare at the closed eye lids or forehead and concentrate on eyes instead of the empty space in the mind that's why they can't actually see the image. And when we get older it's harder to teach urself or believe urself. I didn't know people can actually see when they say I imagine and thought it's a figure of speech. Now I'm learning. It's not easy.

[@demetriamiles6197]

My apple was green and sitting in space. I imagined it would taste crisp and had no leaves...room temp and actually had a little bruise on it. It was sitting in space...just darkness surrounding it. Thank you for the exercise. Growing up in Detroit makes it difficult for me to imagine a forest or even a river bank. I joined the Marines at 18 years old and traveled the world but I still can't imagine the outdoors well because I'm not an outdoor person. Wishing I could imagine a better place while my ex husband continues to stalk me, breaking into my home, stealing and destroying my property including security cameras. He's even purchased a WIFI jammer so that I haven't been able to catch him on camera and take it to court in order to prove he's violated the terms of the protection order. I really need to feel better and I awaken each day positive and listening to law of attraction videos but he has something else that he's stolen or destroyed to distract me from the good feeling I work to achieve. If you have any ideas please share them. Thank you in advance for any and all suggestions that may help me to visualize a better place while I'm being stalked and made to feel unsafe.

[@alexbaker3958]

It was a crisp red apple with one green leaf coming out of the top next to the stem. It was cold to the touch. It was on the table of my old house in Pennsylvania.

[@edwardsrubyg]

I first saw 3 apples, green yellow and red. Then I chose to focus my attention on the red apple, with a stem and one green leaf. It was on a white porcelain saucer. My apple had a hard texture. It was room temperature winter cold. It tasted sweet and juicy. Its smell was subtly sweet. I enjoyed your guidance. Thanks.

[@ElegyVio]

Jesus is the truth

[@chrisgray7320]

My apple was yellow/green with a red blush to the bottom left hand side, no stem, no leaf, no temperature. When asked to reach out and touch it I just prodded it with my index finger and it was solid. This is where the 'imagining' ran out, it had no temperature, I couldn't take a bite because it wasn't real, I knew it wasn't real, so I assigned the quality of crisp and juicy. It wasn't floating in space, it was front and center at eye level of what would have been my visual field were my eyes open, but it was on a black background. As an aside: I recently paid a lot of money to take a course on hypnotherapy. During that course we did an exercise on the 'Watkins Bridge'. I volunteered to be the subject, despite having made the tutor aware I could not visualise they went ahead and tried to induce hypnosis using visualisation. It didn't work and I didn't enter a hypnotic state. Later on the tutor gave us a technique for pain control that involved visualisation. I had lower back pain at the time so despite my disappointment at not being hypnotized I resolved to just randomly assign the 'answers' to questions that required visualisation. It involved shape, colour, movement and altering the size, shape and colour of this imagined object. I didn't expect this exercise to work, after all I was cheating by just making up my answers on the spur of the moment, almost like a word association response. To my absolute surprise my pain lessons dramatically. (I haven't actually experienced that pain again since). Sadly I ran out of money half way through the course and could not complete my study. Following my failure in the 'bridge' exercise though I had already more or less decided to end my pursuit of the dream of becoming a hypnotherapist due to the fact I felt like a con asking people to believe I could hypnotize when I had not been hypnotized myself. One of the most frustrating things for me is this; I believe wholeheartedly in the benefits of hypnotism, yet despite the now common knowledge of the existance of this condition, I cannot find guided hypnotism audio that does not ask the subject, at some point, to visualise. The only one I have found so far is a clip from Sam Harris on a mindfulness exercise. I've stolen his audio and laid it over an instrumental track. Its not perfect but it kind of works for help getting me to sleep at least. If anyone out there knows of any guided meditations that don't use visualisation I would be grateful if you could point me in that direction. Also I'd be interested to know how many people with this condition struggle with mental arithmetic. I have always consoled myself with the thought that I can't do maths in my head because I can't 'see' the numbers. Although I have to say I find it difficult with a pen and paper too :)

[@crystaljmelice]

So I saw black mostly but I found myself going back to a subtle visual memory of me eating a green apple from the fridge

[@DanGirEnt]

Red, stem, no leaves, on a table, crisp, cool but not cold. Thanks Tellman!

[@karneevsandhu]

my apple was mehroon color, with stem and small 2-3leaves on the table,it seemed hard..room temp not cold, and but was not crisp when bite..i visualisd this....i think I'm not able to imagine with some specific person face.. I'm trying but can't.. I'm not able to imagine something with my own face

[@omgwe1]

green with stem crisp and crunchy sitting in dark space but vivid becoz of colour.Thanks imagining helped a lot. cheers

[@elainelockhart55]

big red apple, no stem, no leaves, room temperature, with red candy over it, a candy apple sitting in clear foil on my counter

[@sugihputra3567]

Amazing. That's work to visualize my mind

[@Galaxyofbrian]

It was a green apple, it was room temp, and it had a black stem, and it was floating in the vastness of darkness. It was a strange apple.

[@sygnalloy]

red, stem, no leaves, cold/nothing/ bland and crispy/ hard/ in a black void floating.

[@laceybluecat5723]

i am a feeling person. how do i use this to follow along with visual meditation or NLP?

[@izegaegbe]

I had a red apple, it had a stem with no leaf. It was room temperature, hard, crunchy and juicy. It was on a plate on a table

[@jyothymjohn]

in a basket with all other red apples. this has a stem with a leaf, fresh from the farm, very crispy and tasty

[@ctrl_alt_create]

thank you! as someone with aphantasia this was wonderful. i have been watching "visualization for people who can't visualize" videos all morning but they're all full of shit lol. I thought you were too when you described your ability to visualize as "poor" rather than "nonexistant", but this "technique" of side-stepping visualization is pretty brilliant.

[@ElegyVio]

Jesus is the truth

[@hiteshjaatjaat]

red and yellow mixed apple with stem, room temp, harder, no leaves, floating in white space. help me please.........QUICK

[@bu11et98]

Red, Stem, No leaves, Room Temperature, Crisp and juicy, plate in space

[@younesschaouki2179]

I see an apple that has a darker red with white green lines and dotes and curves ..they are all insignificant conpared to the dark red and the is a dusty brown stem with no leafs if i touch it its cold and hard . If i touk a bite its krespy but not jusy if i hit it with my finger it has a unique sound and if i smell it it has the apple smell

[@neddymarella1571]

Red apple Had a stem with no leaves Couldn't touch it but it looked crunchy and juicy It was on a white plate on a white table in a green garden I am impressed I thought I had aphantasia

[@darzimus]

What if doing this kind of exercise over and over again leads to the ability to visualize?

[@whitecollar4911]

Hi, Its easy to see a apple but whats the point visualizing an apple. We visualize something we would like to see or, we like to be. So tell us how to make it reality things in our visualize process there are many videos which is similar to this visualize e.g apple, orange, or flower but tell us how to visualize the success of our business where it would be something like that hope u got my point. But one thing here your explanation is very clear and good

[@jackraves7363]

I was asked to "see" this apple, no one said anything about leaves haha! THNX!

[@remilekunadegbamigbe6462]

Green, has a little stem with no leaf, it is firm but juicy, real sweet, it is room temperature but is it floating in space.

[@2004avat]

this didn't help me any

[@erosxtoasty]

Me: **trying to imagine something** Also me: tf why do I just see a long red bar

[@pewpew5996]

ALAMJWIF

[@Sloppyunderfoot]

Floating in space, red streaks, crisp, room temperature, stem, no leaves, sweet.

[@bharti.khajuria]

Red apple with stem without leaves. Room temperature, sweet taste but not too much. Was neither too hard nor too soft. I was sitting on it and we were floating in the space

[@johnysantefit3626]

Very helpful video! Thank you! I was able to imagine and see an image for the first time.

[@bricology]

The trouble is that he's using the term "imagine", when speaking to people who may well have aphantasia (as I do). The very word "imagine" refers to a visual process (that of producing an image), when people with aphantasia lack the ability to form images in their minds. A better term would be "conceptualize". I can't *imagine* an apple, but I can certainly *conceptualize* it. That may sound like a semantic distinction, but it's also a useful one. I suspect that there are ways for aphants to develop their abilities to conceptualize (distinct from producing images) that might result in better results for some mental processes.

[@nita2bjuan7]

All I see is black too. I did not see the apple but I was able to answer your questions. I do however, experience very vivid dreams that i remember with great detail when I awaken. My apple was red, no stem, no leaves, cold, firm and on a table This was a very helpful exercise. I was indeed able to answer all of your questions with my eyes closed. I am going to apply this exercise to something else and see if I can strengthen this newly learned ability. Thank you!

[@chynabranche6202]

how did you not see the apple but are able to answer his questions?

[@nita2bjuan7]

@@chynabranche6202 Good question. The only way i can answer is to say that when provided the choices, I was at least able to make preferences like I know I prefer to eat red apples more than green. However, at no time did I actually see a picture in my minds eye an actual red apple. I imagined its essence though, the feel of it, how it may taste, I could imagine it cold too (which is another preference vs. warm). He instructed to not worry about actually visualizing it. So, it was easy for me not to.

[@chynabranche6202]

I'm not sure and I may be wrong but it seems, the fact that you said you were able to imagine these things is your mind's eye. You had to have seen the image to recall a color and answer the question even if prompted.. If you could imagine how it tastes then this is visualization at work. He instructed not to visualize So you wouldn't try so hard and miss the mark. but if you are able to remember your dreams, day dream, think about past memories or remember what someone's face looks like, then that is your mind's eye visualizing these things. Why? It's not your actual eyes but you're STILL recalling. Your visualization might not be as strong as someone else's because it requires work to easily be able to do these things for some people, but your definitely starting to visualize if you remember that your particular apple is red, had no stem or leaves and could imagine its essence.

[@nita2bjuan7]

@@chynabranche6202 Hearing that makes me happy and optimistic. I have been so frustrated because I hear over and over that in order to manifest material things you have to visualize them first. So when i close my eyes thinking of that dream home, i see black...no house, no door, no blade of grass. But I have always had vivid in color dreams that I can recount in detail. You have inspired me to not give up and practice at least the technique from this video. I honestly appreciate your giving me your time. Its refreshing!

[@chynabranche6202]

You're welcome. I was once where you are until I realized I was trying to hold. There are guided meditation exercises that you can do on KZbin that can help you focus on you're mind's eye. It really helped me. Also, I'm not sure what your diet is but changing my diet and getting rid of junk foods have helped me as well.

[@chrysoula5226]

I just know my apple was green😂 Like who can see stems and shapes that's so weird?!? I hardly saw a different color than black.

[@matzewrath]

Apparently most people can. I'm definitely not one of them and that's because I live with a condition called "aphantasia". You might want to look it up you don't know about it ^_-

[@itsfausti7849]

you don't have to see you have to imagine it, like your mind is creating the image you are not actually seeing it

[@Shanethefilmmaker]

red, stem, no leaf, cold, Crisp and Juicy, hard, floating.

[@josephhoelscher8627]

Red, stem, no leaves, table, cold, crisp… then the color lightened a bit & it was a delicious Pink Lady!

[@BradAfterDark]

Room temperature crisp green apple floating in space. Stem, no leaf.

[@AkshayPatil-qf5eh]

my apple was green, it had a stem and a leaf it tasted sweet and juicy for me very tasty. nut for some reason i could not feel its temperature on my hand my touch sense is weak i think. need to work on that.

[@Apo0]

Red, stem, 1 leaf, hard, cold, crisp and juicy, and just existing in space.

[@uchennadavid6571]

It was a red apple, sitting with other apples on display at the grocery store. It had no leaf, with a stem, I reckon it was crunchy soft at room temperature.

[@HanNick3]

red and green shades, no stem or leaves, its room temp. lovely juicy, crisp and succulent.

[@mariseriddell6612]

red stripy, stem, no leaves, wonderful strawberry smell, crisp - I am salivating - it rested on a green bench top.

[@babyfawn]

Red fuji looking apple with stem, no leaves on greenish wooden tabletop. Room temperature, crunchy, crisp. Cool, I can visualize. Thank you very much for this video because I wasn't exactly sure what this meant. Also, I'm an artist.