The Overlap Live Fan Debate 2.0: Gary Neville, Jamie Carragher & Paul Scholes | PL Returns Part 2

[@skybet]

Will Salah leave Liverpool? 🤔

[@breezy1170]

got any odds on thay

[@theyreallmeateatersmeteorm3043]

If salah is smart he would stay. What are the options ? Barca and Madrid are on a steep decline shadows of their former selves after their main attractions messi and ronaldo have left. Bayern and psg would be a sideways move. Liverpool wouldn’t sell to city or Chelsea. Moving Any other club not mentioned would be a backwards move or sideways at the very least.

[@noneedtoknowmyname1610]

@@nevousabonnezpas4286 Villarreal are u mad bruv and barca cant even pay Phil Jones wages

[@stuartnicholson8298]

Yes

[@kaboutertje1561]

@@nevousabonnezpas4286 tf lmao

[@eddiea9658]

Gary “That’s why I’ve called for an independent regulator” Neville

[@adamebanks3837]

Gary 'let's be clear' Neville

[@billo19812]

Gary 'at this moment in time' Neville

[@Tricklyz]

Gary “there’s something not quite right” Neville

[@M4uvez]

"What would be" Gary Neville

[@bertieclayton4865]

in that human rights speech his whole arguement was that there should be human rights. Expert analysis!

[@WillMartinMMA]

I swear they just invite Ty on just so they can take the piss out of him. And rightly so!

[@Travis015]

Imagine if u are an Arsenal fan watching this and getting represented by ty, how embarrassing is that .

[@Sui_Generis0]

They do it for views

[@kevin084life]

Ty may be deluded but he is a lovable guy, you can't hate him. 😂

[@xstreamerog4352]

Need better representation for my club :@

[@xstreamerog4352]

@@Travis015 yep hurts

[@danthemaninthetrashcan]

Brilliant show just like last time, only complaint would be that we’re severely missing the legend Roy Keane though.

[@osman4945]

Thats your job

[@garethhobson2513]

There is a million vids on KZbin with Roy in them as it is to be fair

[@aziggerzagger]

2hrs over two episodes, and there wasn't one question to a Brighton fan, who are doing excellent this season. Not one question to a Brentford fan. Not one question to a West Ham fan, first season back in Europe for a long time. I understand we all want to hear from a Newcastle fans perspective with whats happened. Or Man United on Ronaldo. Or Man City because they are favourites. But who gives a toss about poor old Spurs. Or bloody Arsenal. Or Rafa at Everton again. I'm mean the Chelsea fan only got a say when he had to ask the question himself, and they are top of the league.

[@stivib5937]

You cant discuss things about 20 teams

[@historyconflicts1947]

who wants to hear your opinion?

[@Mubashir_AK]

Not putting down other teams, especially the Everton man was class when he spoke, but yes, I'd have loved a perspective on Brighton and Brentford.

[@chrismattravers5434]

You make a fair point....

[@Cataracta]

i agree as ManUtd fan.. its always interesting to hear the perspective of "smaller" clubs.. kudos for all the hard work. Wish the would be a pure debate about the smaller ones.

[@ajaytharwani5502]

Scholes is like that friend you listen to just out of respect even when you know he's talking out of his arse

[@MohamedShou]

But what did he say that wrong?

[@lorddarkcry9923]

@@MohamedShou chelsea have 25 clean sheets in 45 games

[@rashidkhalid3970]

Yeah and u are the friend who started supporting Chelsea from 2006😆

[@jommzom9715]

@@rashidkhalid3970 whats wrong in that, not everyone is a old boomer like you, Chelsea was a top team in 2000s while kid were growing up so its natural for new generation to support chelsea. idk why its hurt guys like you for others supporting Chelsea

[@sahilj9009]

@@rashidkhalid3970 and the most succesfull team in last decade, cry more, blues will go on winning

[@isaacharding]

Getting the fans involved is such a good idea - more of this please!

[@5thdawg917]

Why you got bitches under you comments

[@YerDaEatsCrayons10]

Only the front of row of fans lol the rest are just extras

[@causingerruckus4091]

@@5thdawg917 like you

[@harrymander4239]

Josh “we could talk about this till the sun comes out” Denzel

[@jAyDeN30111]

we could talk about *x* all day

[@anthony98339]

I mean is it not an effective segway?

[@brianmcsherry1338]

Yeah it’s not like we’ve heard that before! Tired comment already!

[@kevin084life]

Til dawn lol 😂

[@potatopicker1395]

Ty - “Arsenal is bigger than the sun”

[@calumrobinson3745]

I love the overlap but scholes just doesn’t have what Keane has, need Keane back ASAP

[@randombutspecific]

Both are trash pundits to be honest. Legendary players, don't get me wrong, but they are overly emotional, aren't very knowledgable about what's currently going on, and rarely give any sort of real insight. At least Keane is funny

[@calumrobinson3745]

@@randombutspecific being funny makes him a good pundit IMO, can’t just have boring pricks that have no personality. Don’t think Keane is that bad of a pundit really either knows a fair amount about what’s current

[@througheverything]

Agreed, Keane makes it much more enjoyable.

[@theslugboiii5969]

@@randombutspecific Keane knows more than like 99.9% of pundits.

[@connorr9100]

He’s so dead compared to keano

[@Meedster08]

The Everton fan was a joy to listen to imo… Paul Scholes, on the other hand, oof…

[@jplo5590]

@@jeslyn7794 Baz is a legend, makes us everton fans proud for sure!

[@hellohi1445]

Paul scholes is a clown.

[@fisheatsyourhead]

scholes might be the worst pundit that isn't named michael oliver

[@zacbro2841]

@@fisheatsyourhead Michael Oliver does punditry now?!

[@cragsyj1]

Baz is great to listen to. Shame carragher is just trying to score points and belittle Everton instead of talking about it from a punditry point of view.

[@Barlofontain]

Scholes: "Chelsea are weak defensively" Even at the time he said that, they had the most clean sheets in the top 5 leagues in Europe and they've have had three more clean sheets since, they've conceded 5 goals in 14 games and never more than 1 in a game Scholes: "I don't think they'll score enough goals" They've scored 15 goals in the last 4 games, (11 without Lukaku or Werner) It just proves that great players don't always make great pundits

[@MrHuytie]

is the season over already ??? wtf thought we were only 6 games in

[@paulie-g]

@@Alexmw101 Scholes was speaking about the quality of their CBs. He rates Rudiger, but doesn't rate Silva (old) or Christensen (young) as highly and makes the point that the Jorginho-Kante double pivot is what makes up for it. Kante is injured and Jorginho's having a blip and voila - Chelsea drop points to United and let in 3 against West Ham. I'm not saying I agree, just that his point is eminently defensible even now. I think Chelsea's defensive record is excellent, but it's a whole-team, systemic effort that has to be paid for elsewhere possibly. No way is it as good if Tuchel makes Silva play high and naked with tons of space to deal with like Van Dijk/Matip for example. Rudiger is excellent, but he's excellent in a 3.

[@Dilly221]

Aged like fine wine

[@Barlofontain]

@@Dilly221 didn't it just hahahaha

[@davidg5305]

Come on John. Write back? You absolute pudding. Times a prover. Just hold fire until the clock runs done 👍 #rentboys

[@McCumbo]

Wish we could sign fans. I'd be offering a record fee for the Everton lad.

[@Dom-zl7ms]

Boss isn’t he

[@charlielad6124]

Chelsea and Man City already bought all their fans

[@Hugzzi]

They should invite Ped too.

[@ljgizzle]

I was also taught to respect everyone's opinion. Then I heard Ty and I'm not so sure 😂

[@utd927]

That chin strap is outrageous 🤣🤣

[@jonmayhew4468]

Its velcro bro

[@jameslowell9702]

Time stamp?

[@KyleSLFC]

Thought it was a mask until you said🤣🤣🤣

[@Matt-ft2fc]

Looks like a boomerang hit him in the gob

[@generalwasteman]

@@jameslowell9702 the Newcastle fella, early on

[@MattMajcan]

i just wish there was more focus outside the top 6. so many interesting storylines this season, brighton, wolves, leeds, etc. and a lot of what was discussed about the top 6 is the same old talking points ive already heard 20 times on tv and social media. Also, the everton fan is pure quality.

[@FIL1994]

Sorry mate, the normal casuals fans only care about the drama in the top 6

[@dan15d20]

What's interesting about wolves and Leeds?

[@Thunder_Cheek01]

@@dan15d20 I'll sum them up for ya. Leeds is probably going through 2nd season syndrome and Wolves are trying to find their feet under Bruno Lage, done.

[@dan15d20]

@@Thunder_Cheek01 nothing then.

[@lichade2008]

I like the comments here. They must be the same fans who wanted the super league to happen. Just goes to show how fickle fans are here.

[@dios.9586]

7:29 This is literally Scholes admitting because he “knows” Steve Bruce that’s why he’s saying he deserves to stay at Newcastle. It’s the same mindset which is the reason he won’t say anything bad about Ole. Everything he says is worthless because he’d rather base opinions off his relationships than the truth.

[@auchleju]

Scholes and Rio are literally the worst

[@liamadams5121]

@@auchleju yeah, good players and very successful but knobs

[@johnbroadfoot5148]

Well they were teammates after all... Maybe there was something in his experience with brucey which led him to believe that he would be a good manager, but then again, thats just scholesey and not indicative for everyone. Thats why its important we have different points of view

[@blackenedsprite8542]

@United84 if you watched the final he also basically said 'it's in the bag' in the build up. He wasn't at all concerned about squad depth or subs then, he was literally saying we'd won and it was 30 minutes until kick off.

[@Travis015]

@United84 that was fucking shocking seriously our bench that game was better then Villarreal first 11 and rashford was limping around he was literally playing with one leg but and that didn't stop Villarreal from making subs to mange the game and give them more time , ole just kept watching arms crossed while we looked dead and he still doing it this season

[@evertonfc5380]

Well done Baz and the Geordies for challenging Scholes.

[@AB-tf2ik]

Scholes was absolutely useless in this.. he was only there to defend ole and Bruce

[@evilm4dn3z62]

@@AB-tf2ik well thats his opinion better than having an uncontroversial yes man

[@baldalan3921]

@@evilm4dn3z62 Those opinions make him a yes man😂

[@BradAaronTaylor]

Ngl, I'm still laughing about Ty. What a _madman._

[@blackenedsprite8542]

madness. complete madness.

[@godse573]

Genuinely concerned about him, though. It's clear he gets so much screentime because he's viewed as a joke, while it's been like this for a long time, it's now gone all the way to Sky shows. There's going to be a time he will realize he's used for people to laugh at and that ultimately will lead him down a bad path.

[@LA-fr7fx]

@@godse573 Agree.

[@blackenedsprite8542]

@@godse573 if you knew him personally, would you not deliberately provoke him with completely innocuous comments just to kill an hour

[@bowden__1419]

@@godse573 and now like this guy, people comment mentioning him just to get the likes and comments. Its not healthy

[@fragnade7079]

Lewis’s face when scholes said that Chelsea had the weakest defence 🤣

[@briankavo]

Fantastic forum for footie talk. Having the fans at the core of the conversation is the key to the success of this debate...

[@HumongousBeastBoi]

Someone: Breathes Ty: The Invincibles, The Invincibles!!

[@AnimefreakHQ]

Paul Scholes may have been a great player, but he's a poor pundit. G.Neville and Carragher were carrying

[@fleischer236]

Shame Roy want there

[@johnmichaelson9173]

I agree with you I'm missing Roy Keane he's brilliant & I'm a Scouser.

[@tucomtyler]

@@chichim2020 you've been paying attention. Totally agree

[@geoffreywright9856]

@@johnmichaelson9173 of course he is.

[@lukehegarty1166]

Spot on saying things like Chelsea’s defence is poor and saying they aren’t contenders is just bias . Gary tries to save him but he keeps going back to it

[@CMEAGAIN]

That Geordie missed a bit when shaving this morning

[@blackenedsprite8542]

he still had his bearskin hat on

[@fablenumber1fan]

His mate is wearing the other half

[@joshleach3349]

I’d love to see Micah Richards on this with Roy Keane 😂😂😂😂

[@duncankowable]

They'll burst onto the scene

[@kevin5073]

Roy “he’s just doing his job” Keane.

[@henzokenzo9478]

Micah couldn’t speak footy for 50 mins straight no chance.

[@pramodacharya5866]

Nonsense

[@monkeytennis8861]

Micah Richards has no insight about anything. He's totally out of his depth as a pundit.

[@ToffeeTVEFC]

Thanks again for having me on Guys :)

[@newcastlefanstv]

About time you did a video with us.

[@ToffeeTVEFC]

@@newcastlefanstv 100% Guys let me know :)

[@ThisIsEngland1000]

I'd love to see Mike Ashley buy out Stan kroenke of Arsenal....It would make AFTV pure comedy gold

[@capsy9]

it already is pure gold , i cancelled my netflix , brit box etc because i just couldnt find the comic relief i get from aftv

[@georgedolman444]

Hes a spurs fan as well 😂

[@kevinmckenna5010]

Never seen Paul Scholes so out his depth

[@evilm4dn3z62]

i mean nobody is on the level of carragher and neville but paul didn't prepare any of his answers and it showed through

[@yinyang8259]

@@evilm4dn3z62 snuck in Neville like we wouldn't notice. Hes just a yes man for sky.

[@yinyang8259]

You clearly haven't seen him play for England

[@adrianmarrinan7707]

Think most of what he said hes right. Maybe not the most articulate speaker. Agree on players needing a rest, 'less is more'. Agree on chelsea as well. Not enough goals and that midfield is protecting rather than creating.

[@coby-joewarhurst2390]

I mean Scholes has a point just didn’t say it correctly having the holding 5 then with Kante and Jorginho only allows 3 creative players in the team which then hinders them in goal scoring

[@TheFootballGurus]

Absolutely love this. Will need more overlaps for sure

[@ukgforze]

Love these they need to do these more often! Many have complained in the comments that their clubs didn't get a mention, they mainly focus on the topics of the moment, but over a 90min show it would only give 4.5mins for each team, given a fan can talk for that before the pundits get to answer & allow for some banter, you just can't fit in talk for 20 teams.

[@DylanRL710]

Bet all the other fans were so glad they came to listen to a “big 6” chat with a 10 min section about the World Cup

[@halcyonliverpool509]

How Scholes is still a pundit never fails to amaze me 😅

[@harambe6143]

Guy was talking about how he doesn’t think Chelsea are defensively solid enough like they haven’t statistically been the best defence in the country since Tuchel came in😵‍💫

[@evilm4dn3z62]

@@harambe6143 he's not wrong about the midfielders protecting them and that they play 3 at the back, a pretty defensive formation. Silva and rudiger the best two aren't on the level of laporte & dias, Varane & Maguire, or van dijk & matip so they need protection from either the 6 or another cb

[@odirilegoitseonemathe6138]

🤣 Mens is clueless

[@user-kn4gx5ih7m]

@@evilm4dn3z62 how are you comparing matip to Thiago silva. Silva was and is a world class cb

[@shafiqnorhisham9494]

@@evilm4dn3z62 lazy lazy take, if the back 3 system makes the most average cb world class, why many teams do this and still concede goals? Case and point, belgium, arsenal, even city played a back 5 when playing against chelsea a few times and still conceded? Other than kante, jorginho and kovacic are not natural DMs 😴

[@TheJBALLA26]

Paul Scholes is great isn’t he, doesn’t have a clue what he’s talking about 😂😂.

[@Auriflamme]

@Jonny Rotten Why do you think that is relevant to his ability as a pundit?

[@kevinwinston5925]

@@Auriflamme Isnt it obvious dufus ? He's earned the right to say what he wants considering his accomplishments as a player ! Also , whether he speaks sense or not is very subjective as it's his opinion versus yours and I'd rather listen to someone who's been there and done that .

[@TheJBALLA26]

For full transparency I’m a Chelsea fan who believes that city will probably just edge the season, but not because of our defensive record. It’ll be against the top teams we drop pts and we have a drop off of goals if lukaku gets injured.

[@aidanjohnburke7629]

@@TheJBALLA26 liverpool will edge out city if they dont have last seasons issues .once the spine (that had long term injuries) have developed that rhythm again they will be hard to stop. are scoring for fun and it was probably always going to take the midfield and back 5 three or four months to get match sharpness back 100%..once that does they will be so strong.

[@TheJBALLA26]

@@aidanjohnburke7629 I’m convinced that the style of play that Liverpool use will force injury’s. The same 11 can’t press and keep that energy level high game in and game out. Especially without squad depth and backup.

[@jaydenmerrick5837]

I can’t believe Scholes really said Chelsea have the weakest defence out of the top 4 🤦‍♂️ clueless man 😂

[@haidermahmood3829]

Man United has definitely looked more vulnerable at the back than Chelsea for real 😂

[@randomdaveUK]

Chelsea have built a fantastic squad, certainly not weak

[@mvjbass9561]

Player for player I actually agree with him - I think it's more Tuchel's system that excels (still some great defenders too ofc). If Tuchel was in charge at United and Ole at Chelsea, Man U would 100% have the better defensive record.

[@joshmansfield6101]

100% Chelsea system is what makes them so good defensively man for Man they probably are the 4th best

[@evilm4dn3z62]

he wasnt talking about defensive record he was saying player wise, of course 3 centre backs is safer than 2...

[@jdodger1091]

Scholes: defensively Chelsea aren't good enough. Since tuchel took over, Chelsea have the best defence in the world ffs

[@deanshields8031]

Especially after United conceded 3 goals yesterday.

[@gitsyd2262]

@@deanshields8031 what has man u got to do with it lmfao and it was 4 goals

[@deanshields8031]

@@gitsyd2262 because scholes said Liverpool and United have 2 of the best defenses in the league.

[@gitsyd2262]

@@deanshields8031 right but he never said they have the two best defences in the prem, and he was spot on when he said chelsea are conceding less goals because the two CDMs in front of them, chelsea have the best CDM in the world

[@kevinfagan6112]

@@gitsyd2262 he did tho? He said utd have better defence than Chelsea which is just wrong

[@jathisshravichandran1250]

Scholes out here trying to say Chelsea doesn’t have a good defense? I want whatever he’s been smoking for the past year😂

[@seanwilson486]

Think its starting to show now. If teams played with 5 at the back and 2 holding mids they should have a good defence

[@JKribbit]

Turns out, he's right innit

[@RoryJenningsFootball]

VIVA McKOLA.

[@forsuper6836]

You are a disgrace to Chelsea fans Stop speaking for us, you don't represent us.

[@voodoochile333]

Ponce

[@jameslaude3654]

@@forsuper6836 all these fan channels don’t represent the fanbase. They are fake imposters.

[@jameslaude3654]

@Benedict Wong AFTV is the trailblazer for this fake monstrosity. Then the others just followed.

[@ETH-Fitness]

I don’t get why people chat shit about fan channels that are big saying they are about money over fans. Aftv I understand but I don’t think Rory is all about money Or mark on the United stand

[@ciaraincarey5464]

Scholes has absolutely no clue about football for a man who was so good at it 🤣

[@kikoo.5381]

I actually got what he meant. He didn’t talk about the shape, it’s the defenders themselves. Rudger in a two is terrible but change the shape and make the adjustments then it’s a toss of the hat.

[@ciaraincarey5464]

@@kikoo.5381 who cares if he’s not good in a four if he’s playing in a 3 🤣 in a 3 he’s one of the best itl and that’s all that matters for Chelsea.. if scholes thinks united are better at the back than Chelsea he literally hasn’t a clue about football

[@evilm4dn3z62]

@@ciaraincarey5464 he never said united are better but playing in a 3 will mean you rely on your wingbacks to create chances look at how city suffocated them, but sure the man who's won it all doesn't have a clue...

[@ciaraincarey5464]

@@evilm4dn3z62 lol just absolutely blitzed through Europe last year 👍🏼 just cos he was good at ball doesn’t mean he knows it all , he’s managing career went well tbf 😂 and yes he did say Chelsea have worst defence in top 4 which is a genuinely atrocious statement

[@Jamie-yh5eu]

That Newcastle fans “beard” is out of order !!

[@richardfairs4871]

They share a beard.....a beard of two halves

[@BasedinReality1984]

He thinks it’s cool and his mate loves it.

[@ryiin]

Ironically he'd of been stoned. (not drugs stoned) with rocks for that beard in Saudi Arabia.

[@ze89412]

@@ryiin anything to get Mike Ashley out

[@ryanyb3699]

he looks like one of impractical jokers

[@seanmckiernan7890]

I find it hilarious that all those pundits have forgotten that Benitez managed at madrid just 6 years ago.

[@camcarrier6065]

They didn't

[@zaheeradam7555]

And then got sacked

[@JamesWilson-xh9zt]

He wasn’t given the opportunity to spend though same at Chelsea

[@realityusedtobeafriendofmi9159]

@@zaheeradam7555 Almost all managers get sacked. It might look like they walked but they were sacked. I can see what JC is getting at. YNWA

[@whatsthatnow308]

Love the Geordie fan at the start, "scousers and geordies", didn't even need an explanation. There are some incredible bonds on this island, true cockneys, scousers, geordies and glaswegians share something special, their hearts.

[@MrThedonhead]

So you missed the hooligans days 😂

[@TheAppeyes]

In terms of international breaks, I think they should all be done at the end of the season in a block. It lets the clubs keep their players all season with no stop-starting, and it allows the international teams to build a style of play and build some connections between the players, which would then roll on into a summer tournament.

[@toiletcomputer]

I hate interuptional breaks. There’s always a player comes back injured 🤕

[@ze89412]

@@toiletcomputer ohhh well

[@billo19812]

The football fans particularly the Everton, Liverpool, City and Spurs guys way more clued in than Scholes and Carragher. Carragher is crass

[@kratos.8151]

I thought carra was a bit rude telling that Man City fan to shut up in part 1. Think he felt too relaxed and crass here. Scholes is boring. Neville was boss. I say this as a Liverpool fan.

[@billo19812]

@@kratos.8151 Liverpool fan too, Carra gets a bit giddy and goes over the top at times, more knowledgeable than Scholes the potty mouth though. Neville is great.

[@billo19812]

@Jonny Rotten he has that to be fair to him.

[@sammy_1178]

@Jonny Rotten premier leagues maybe but football didn't start in 1990 lad go back to school, liverpool have 19 league titles only 1 less than united and double the champion leagues as united levels to this 🤙

[@kylewalkerr]

@@kratos.8151 True mate. Donno why Carra did that to Steve but anyway it was all laughs

[@codemastertalon6439]

Never knew the amish had a big community in Newcastle, good for them

[@geordietoonforlife.1155]

Brilliant show we need more of these the fans do bring some good talking points to the table and the pros definitely see the game in general differently and that’s because they have been in the game and now get involved with bigger debates which can only be good for the game going forward. 👏👏👏

[@Mljones6]

Great forum and really good to watch, but oh my god it was so frustrating how the Everton was trying to explain a very simple point that FFP will limit Newcastle exactly as it has Everton and Scholes just does not understand at all.

[@davidbatey1932]

The two Geordies sharing a beard 😂

[@George-vi5uq]

G. Neville says on every season about Salah that he's going to leave Liverpool. 🤣🤣🤣

[@GDLFC91]

He prays it will happen I feel

[@brianmcsherry1338]

18:15 Scholes calling Josh a “Knobhead” for cutting him off 😂😂 Robbie savage knows all about that!

[@primitiv252bulo2]

hahahah nice catch

[@unitish97]

That opening few minutes on Newcastle takeover was perfect. The concerns regarding ownership should have been talked about long ago. When you have let others in before, there was no leg for the prem to not accept this. And also, Newcastle fans shouldn't be criticized for celebrating. I doubt anyone wouldn't if they went through what Newcastle did under Mike Ashley

[@monkeytennis8861]

Scholes proving again that once again that away from the pitch he's got nothing to offer and he's just unpleasant.

[@kdze1012]

Scholes take on Chelsea's defense is truly dreadful. We are one of the best (if not the best) defensive teams in Europe since Tuchel took over. I'm not saying we're some infallible team but there is no reason to think our defense isn't good enough

[@siphobanda1707]

He means individually your defense is shit....and that's not sustainable football that you play

[@wanga_1098]

@@siphobanda1707 I think you have to give credit to our defensive coach. We recruited a defensive coach when the 20/21 season started under Frank and we were keeping clean sheets under Frank for the first 20 plus games. So I wouldn't really say it's not sustainable 🤣🤣🤣

[@wanga_1098]

@@siphobanda1707 look at the champions league group stages we only conceded 1 goal. And that was when Frank took over.

[@JamesHussain82]

@@siphobanda1707 if 5 shit individuals can win the CL while 4 great individuals cant, its obvious which is better. Its a team sport.

[@embonaldo]

@@siphobanda1707 id love to know who u support ?

[@AdamFitzJKD]

How is Paul Scholes saying Chelsea aren't good enough defensively does he watch football whatsoever?

[@cheikhhassenenema6743]

This panel is bias if you ask me. 2 former Man united players and former Liverpool speaking on behalf of every other team in the league. How scholes said that Man united defenders are better than Chelsea proved how bias he is.

[@abdullha8150]

when did he say this

[@abdullha8150]

timestamp

[@saiprem.n7706]

@@cheikhhassenenema6743 he said that the defense is weaker but kante and jorgino are backing them brilliantly so overall there defense is good but there defensive players especially the defensive players are not good enough that's what he said....Chelsea overall defense is good but along with kante and jorgino that's why they cannot contribute to goals...

[@AdamFitzJKD]

@@abdullha8150 46:08

[@drfrappuccino108]

Scholes is right in some aspects of what he says. Individually some of Chelsea's defenders aren't on the level of other top 4 teams like with Dias, Van Dijk and Varane. They play a 5 at the back with two sitting midfielders, so this is made up for by Tuchel's system. But for scholes to say they aren't good enough defensively as a team is absolute nonsense.

[@harrisonokoro7002]

Scholes is talking rubbish

[@Ihtamubna]

Thiago Silva

[@nauraj]

Scholes,gary this guys are always talk in favour of man uniyed. This season chelsea or Liverpool will win the league and this is true and they dont want to accept the reality. Coz they a jealous of celsea sucess.

[@deanshields8031]

United conceded 3 yesterday and another clean sheet for Chelsea.

[@jaishmohammed2415]

Chelsea aren't just sitting back back with 5 players. (yeah city game was an exception) look at the number of goals the Chelsea back 5 have scored.

[@njabulo2336]

Personally I would like the Overlap to also focus on other teams too just to get their fans perspective and make them feel involved too. Its bad enough Sky do this on a regular basis so i don't want to see another channel which is for the fans specifically to follow in Sky Sports footsteps.

[@Kugann]

no one cares about teams like Norwich

[@Afed390]

Lol this is done by sky

[@mohammedumair9881]

Yes teams from Midlands & South

[@fidel2285]

W all due respect, Paul scholes's take on Chelsea's defence and his Manchester United's defence is absolutely jokes.

[@ammarimtiaz88]

Never knew DT's brother was a Newcastle fan.

[@garymcburnie8323]

Who is dt

[@ChargedWords]

@@garymcburnie8323 Arsenal fan TV

[@garymcburnie8323]

@@ChargedWords what's his name

[@garymcburnie8323]

So you don't know dt

[@ChargedWords]

@@garymcburnie8323 what are you talking about??

[@miles3908]

This is honestly one of the best things out there for football fans. I hope they do this every month.

[@azysheff]

It’s not Sky

[@miles3908]

@@azysheff Literally on a channel that says “The Overlap - brought to you by Sky Bet”. That’s the Sky I’m referring to

[@azysheff]

Miles its a Gary Neville show sponsored by Sky bet.... what’s ur point? Sky didn’t make or own this show u numpty it’s a sponsor, if Durex decides to sponsor it would u called a durex show? Hahaha and did u not notice the Sky ‘Bet’ bit and not just Sky, or Sky Sports? Yh there’s a reason it’s Sky ‘bet’... it’s just a sponsor dummy not a Sky production or property

[@miles3908]

@@azysheff okay damn you don't need to call me a "numpty." The point was that this is awesome and I hope they keep doing them.

[@causingerruckus4091]

It’s ok not to know (Rashford)

[@benfuller2890]

Being a United fan, I love Scholes, but bloody hell he's proper thick in the head if he truly believes bruce deserves more time in the newcastle hotseat.

[@abhishekgadag9457]

And his comments about Chelsea defence was dreadful

[@cloudadwesley1610]

@@abhishekgadag9457 He isn't exactly wrong either. You would be deluded to think that his reasoning was dreadful. Go back and listen to the whole thing again. He did explain why he thinks that way.

[@abhishekgadag9457]

@@cloudadwesley1610 I HOPE THIS WOULD SHUT YOU AND SCHOLESY UP

[@cloudadwesley1610]

@@abhishekgadag9457 So without any explanation? Well done, you have outdone yourself.

[@daibonehead]

It's called loyalty.

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Big Respect to City Fan 👏👍 For restraining self from shouting at Carra when Carra in a flow deeming hes talking endlessly

[@Stuu_xx]

These fan debates are brilliant! Keep them coming.

[@brianmcsherry1338]

Warning ⚠️ Ty doesn’t speak in this part! Enjoy 😂 unfortunately can’t say the same for Carra!

[@brodjefferson3513]

Scholesy is denser than a plank of wood God damn

[@LoCoAde87]

Liverpool, Everton and Newcastle guys. Well spoken. 👏

[@fayesouthall6604]

Liverpool- it’s Paul Machin from Redmen tv. Really excellent fan site.

[@aaronbates7740]

Paul scholes' takes on football are genuinely worrying.. leaves me scratching my head after everything he says

[@geegee3826]

Good to see scholes for doesn't add to the theory that gingers are very odd individuals in society...

[@jodaresh1078]

That's why he failed at management

[@Junior-ov8me]

Gotta love Arsene Wengers logic. "What if a player is injured for a world cup?, therefore more world cups means more opportunity having missed one" whilst also wanting to bunch all the qualifiers together in which case if you're injured you'd miss all the qualifiers as opposed to 1 3rd of the qualifiers. Of course Arsene Wenger would go with the extreme example of missing a whole world cup because of injury just to get his idea across. Root.

[@thebiasedreview5432]

What is the use of other fans being here then? Could have spoken on Brighton and Graham Potter, Brentford's excellent start, Norwich's up and down etc. Instead we get a drivel on world cup every two years.

[@SylvanPaul]

The fact that Gary Neville referenced British Imperialism just blew my mind lol

[@binboy4034]

Top lad

[@boldizsaristvan1721]

He was utterly naive and hypocritical if he really believes for one second, but that by letting them buying Newcastle, they will eventually change Saud on the long run, and the that the club won't be used a sportwashing tool. Look at just Quatar right now. He's afraid to say that money rules all, and that PL needs this money as a whole, regardless of where it's coming from. Him being overly PC but unable to change the ugly reality is struggling within him, and it's on his face, but he ultimately took a stance of accepting it trying to naively cave out of it. With this he becomes part of the very process his advocating against.

[@aldenpadilla1773]

@@boldizsaristvan1721 when was the last time you spoke against Roman abramovic. Chelsea wouldn't be that strong without him.

[@senseihello]

@@aldenpadilla1773 Roman Abramovic is not a country. He is a person. No one would be against a singular random Saudi Arabian with no ties to the royalty taking over, they have a problem with the country itself or its royalty taking over.

[@boldizsaristvan1721]

@@aldenpadilla1773 I think we should get a few things straight then. 1. I ain't no Cfc fan. 2. I know who exactly Abra is and what he done. 3. My point was that either take a stance against all those things you're supposedly support, no matter the circumstances, or just shut the fuck up and accept how things are. Gary does neither, he decided to try and cave for both sides with this obviously seen-through bullshit about wanting to change the Saudis. 4. Exactly because of Roman Abramovic and the example he created, everyone should see the whole situation for what it is.

[@Zazzri]

Scholes take on Chelsea's defence just shows he hasn't watched us play. Maybe going forward fair enough, but terrible take on our defence.

[@vk1073]

It looks like one Geordie robbed the other ones mustache 🤣🤣

[@Danifornia3]

That Everton fan seemed the most reasonable and correct during the last debate and it's the same case now. Earned my respect sir. - from a united fan

[@ToffeeTVEFC]

Thanks Daniel :)

[@chrishaswell4405]

As a Newcastle fan this is amazing having us talked about at length and jealousy from over fans I never thought I’d see the day we used to everyone’s 2nd team in the entertainers days

[@walshknwsbest]

How people can support this disgusting take over is beyond me. Why was none of the owners horrible atrocities mentioned and how bringing them into the premier league says we support them

[@paulgraham8280]

@@walshknwsbest jog on, manure have a deal with them, didn't see you knocking them....

[@MrThedonhead]

No one will respect Newcastle again after what you done to Steve Bruce

[@brianmcsherry1338]

What’s the point of inviting down Norwich, Burnley, Southampton and West Ham fans etc they didn’t get a question in the first episode and this aswell!

[@garymcburnie8323]

Yeah your right big 6 as usual. Scholes a waste of time. Keane would of been better. Although savage would of been good just so we can call him a wonker

[@redmed10]

Some of them didn't even get a chair.

[@Olahardguy]

Really love the Everton fan

[@Cazzer1604]

Same, was looking for someone else saying this. He's incredibly eloquent and made good points in this and the last Debate, rate him highly (especailly compared to Ty). Most of them are good really, Spurs bloke as well is great

[@LoCoAde87]

I felt he was a little overkill in the first one of these, but he was very good in this one for sure.

[@Irfan87]

Agreed, he was the best fan on the last session as well.

[@ToffeeTVEFC]

Ha thanks mate , really appreciate that :)

[@ToffeeTVEFC]

@@Cazzer1604 Thanks Alex :)

[@joeyzaza9620]

Gary “I could be wrong” Neville 😂

[@jamescaulkett2081]

Brilliant show not enough open honest discussion gets the this sort of platform

[@carefreelewisg]

Thanks for having me on💙

[@Legnaldo]

Did Scholes watch the second half of Liverpool vs Chelsea? The way Chelsea united as a group was surely evident of a team that can win the league no doubt..

[@Mubashir_AK]

He's probably talking individually, but yes the organisation is exceptional. Tuchel has the nous for sure to win it.

[@sahilj9009]

@@Mubashir_AK Individually Silva is better than whole utd defence, wht is this disgrace argument? James is bttr than most RB if not the best.Kante is best at wht he does, no one is bettr than him, and Jorginhio just nominated for ballondor , so Chelsea has better players than most teams and will win the league

[@nezkeys79]

Yeah 10 men against arguably the best attacking side in the league and salah and manr couldn't score for 44 minutes iirc? That's a good defence lol

[@Ahmedrf9]

@@nezkeys79 Liverpool are better than Chelsea thats why we finished ahead of you in the league without any recognized center backs

[@nezkeys79]

@@Ahmedrf9 "ahead of you" I never said I was a Chelsea fan 🤡 Butthurt over a non Chelsea fan talking about how Chelsea had a better defence lol 🍿

[@7ampint]

Great concept, but very "big 6" biased. The other clubs in the league also deserve to be discussed.

[@josephjoestar995]

Neville's comments on the Saudi stuff was amazing, he understands so much outside of the game. Meanwhile Scholes comments about Newcastle were shocking, why's he here 😭

[@johnsmith-mk3zq]

Amazing?? Bloody hypocrite more like he should keep.his simple mind out of complex political cultural things he knows nothing about & just stick to football

[@JamboLinnman]

He doesn’t appear to understand that Abu Dhabi isn’t a country, but the capital city and largest Emirate in the UAE.

[@Cazzer1604]

@@johnsmith-mk3zq Is it so incorrect to say Abu Dhabi vs the UAE though? City's owner is Abu Dhabi royalty and not as connected to the rest of the UAE. Is it not like saying an English or Scottish owner vs a British one?

[@JamboLinnman]

@@Cazzer1604 no it’s not. He twice included Abu Dhabi in a list of countries… Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Russia and China, making me think that he doesn’t understand that it’s not a country. Scotland is a country, as is the UK. Abu Dhabi is a city (the UAE’s capital), as well as the largest of 7 Emirates that make up a country.

[@Cazzer1604]

@@JamboLinnman The term for what Scotland/Northern Ireland/Wales/England actually are are a bit wishy washy but I'd say they're on similar lines as the Emirates are to the UAE, or States are to the US/Canada/Australia. But then again you wouldn't typically say that someone is a Californian or an Alaskan instead of an American, or a British Columbian instead of a Canadian. So it is a bit strange Neville saying Abu Dhabi over UAE (although its easier to say out loud tbf). But then maybe you would say that if you know someone from there would prefer it? I don't know the details of the Emirates enough to know if Mansour et al would prefer to be called Abu Dhabi or Emirati or whatever else. Who knows if GNev is saying Abu Dhabi incorrectly instead of UAE/Emirati/whatever else or if he's saying that on purpose, is all I'm saying.

[@simonjames772]

This videos r so good it’s insane. Quality quality quality

[@veresandy]

Scholes talking about Chelsea like they are in relegation battle 🤦🏿‍♂️🤦🏿‍♂️

[@rosswalsh9587]

Please do more of these, such great content

[@10mibrahim]

Absolutely loved this. This content is giving me life

[@ArcticTemper]

You doing alright mate?

[@10mibrahim]

@@ArcticTemper ????

[@souravs8797]

u ok mate?

[@TheDjd111]

god i love watching this the 50 minutes just fly by

[@jonathanholt89]

Great show this, Baz is class as always.

[@sg3215]

Paul was heads and shoulders above the rest of the fans there in terms of analysis and logic. Hats off to him, great stuff.

[@01226icko]

Need to address human rights breaches by our own government before anyone else’s.

[@jamesduffy7549]

Correct. But why is it can't address our governments AND stop selling others weapons and letting them use our sporting institutions for washing? The problem (I say the problem, really we know its the purpose) with whataboutery is you do nothing because there's always something else

[@jameslaude3654]

Point being. You want a Saudi owner who’s got blood on his hands to see a ball hit a net? I agree the British government are awful but this is Football.

[@blackenedsprite8542]

nothing works like that.

[@01226icko]

@@cheesybellend6842 they are indirectly talking about the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, why not start with the imprisonment of Julian Assange?

[@01226icko]

@@cheesybellend6842 well that’s who they’re referring to when speaking about human rights concerns at the start of this debate who was a journalist murdered for expressing views the state didn’t support which is why I mentioned Assange who was also a journalist locked up for exposing corrupt governments. Much of what he exposed were also breaches of human rights and now his are revoked. I completely agree, abuse in general is hidden within institutions that are meant to serve the public but how does this correlate? maybe we should put Gary Neville in charge of policing and introduce an independent regulator? I think these concerns would be addressed more if that nonce Andrew tried to buy a football club. Yes we don’t execute people in streets but that doesn’t mean we are leagues ahead.

[@TheSixYardBox]

Thank you sky sports for not having ty in this section of the overlap 👍

[@mick78ftm]

Embarrassing little twerp that he is

[@amitkhanka4772]

scholes : chelsea's got the weakest defence out of top 4.. hmm.. only one goal concieved from open play.. 2 other were penalties..

[@ahmadismail9593]

Giving away penalties still counts as weak defense]

[@kaushalyadav8605]

So penalties are a gift from ref out of nothing ?? It has nothing to do with your defence and defenders ???

[@amitkhanka4772]

@@kaushalyadav8605 getting outplayed by the opposition's offense is worst then getting a questionable or even a 50/50 chance penalty

[@kaushalyadav8605]

@@amitkhanka4772 but that was not the original point ..was it ?? The point was u separated the 3 goals u conceded into something like penalties were not your team or defence fault …which it is …u conceded those penalties coz u were clumsy…ur team fouled them inside the area when u shouldn’t have ….Don’t pretend like it’s not chelsea’s fault and they don’t count

[@amitkhanka4772]

@@kaushalyadav8605 conceiving a goal from a set piece or a penaly is still better than getting outfoxed or outplayed or even outrun by offense imo.. least amount of goals scored against out of which only 1 from open play i'd say is a better defence than atleast united and liverpool..

[@chrisbaines306]

When the Arab owner wanted a new castle he never imagined this crap.

[@MrMRSHARPSHOOTER]

🤣🤣🤣👏👏👏👍

[@bartholomewlyons]

😄😄😄😄😄

[@UPTHEPOSH]

This is gold 👌

[@monkeytennis8861]

That's poor

[@michaelwhite4799]

This is the best football program ever please keep these coming brilliant. great set of fans as well.

[@justaguyyy]

Chelsea had the best defensive record last year and still have the best defensive record this year with the amount of games played. Scholes makes a really dumb error with assuming that Chelsea, like Liverpool or City, must have some world class pairing to be defensively good, but Chelsea rely on system more than any individual player in defense, and that's what makes them dangerous. Not to mention, they have world-class defenders anyway in Silva and Rudiger. Really weird analysis from Scholes tbh

[@szymko7]

shitty take, also called christiensen a young defender XDD

[@raziqroslan1764]

Yeah, everyone's reaction, Flav and the City guy even the Everton guy were puzzled as hell. Idt they can believe the shit that came out of his mouth

[@deeznutzz12]

It's more like biased and salty. Good player but shit pundit. He should stay home imo

[@neemnoa303]

But he literally said that it's the system that keeps them solid. The same system that prevents them from scoring more goals and being more creative in attack. That was his point. Chelsea sets up in a way that they have to choose one or the other: either being defensively solid, or being creative in attack. Liverpool or City doesn't have to make that kind of a trade-off.

[@deeznutzz12]

@@neemnoa303 Either defensively solid or being creative ?? Lol. Let's talk about CL. How many chances Chelsea created against RMA, PORTO, ATM, and in final against MAN CITY? and how many goals Chelsea conceded against all of them?? Just ssssssssssssh mate. I'm afraid you don't understand football

[@EliBrigante]

“We got the most money in League Two, we’re 17th”😭

[@Willster389]

City here - obviously I hope Sunderland are next for a big takeover. Glad for the inward investment into Newcastle and if they follow City's fabulous owners it will create jobs, build new homes and get the team that the fans deserve. By the way Abu Dhabi is a Bedouin country and a long term ally of Britain. Finding oil and gas is not a sin. Abu Dhabi is so innocent by comparison with other countries. Love Scholesy btw!

[@Soccerates]

Sunderland have had a big takeover already. Their new owners are billionaires as well.

[@dan15d20]

Being gay is a sin in these places though?

[@lugardstephen4414]

Nice video but one thing i can't avoid is investing!.

[@kennethgeorge2490]

Job will pay your bills, business will make you rich but investment makes and keep you wealthy, the future is inevitable

[@harolddouglas1385]

My life has totally changed since I started with $7,000 and now I make $ 29,450 every 14 days.

[@jesusfaith6441]

@Eric I started investment in cryptocurrency late July 2019 with the help of a well-known professional sir Charles Schwab who thought me great strategies on how to trade and accumulate profits

[@joshuaallen7949]

@Marxwell Josh I trade with him, The profit are secured and over a 100% return on investment directly sent to your wallet.

[@lukejarry5082]

After watching so many KZbin tutorial videos about trading I was still making losses untill Charles Schwab started managing my investment now, I make $6,800 weekly. God bless Charles Schwab. His been a blessing to my family.

[@done9668]

Scouse accent is so satisfying ❤️

[@slamdunkd12345]

Well in baz, a voice of reason 🤝

[@ralimis]

I really like Gary Neville and think he is a top dude. He talks so much sense - funny how you can go from hating someone (panto hate) to admiring them

[@graham3667]

Every day, I like Gary Neville more. He speaks intelligently and with sharp articulation. He would have my vote if he run in politics.

[@sukhdevr3489]

Doesn't speak with arrogance too which is great.

[@svavar82]

Gary's input is perfect. I have growing respect for him. -Liverpool fan

[@daibonehead]

And what do you think now after his performance on Sunday night?