Full UNCENSORED Podcast with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza on Islam, Pakistan and Blasphemy

Full Uncensored version of the podcast with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza.
Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza is one of Pakistan's most popular Islamic scholars and commentators. @EngineerMuhammadAliMirzaClips
Engineer Mirza comes on the podcast for a comprehensive discussion on Islam, Pakistan and Politics, he answers all your questions about him, his work and Islam. On this deep dive podcast, we discuss Domestic Violence, Womens Rights, Blasphemy Law, TLP, Firqawariat, the authenticity of Ahadith, Islamic Jurisprudence, Divorce, Nikah, Hijab and more.
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
Twitter.com/shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:30 Translation vs Interpretation Debate
7:48 Gendered Language
11:20 Surah Al-Nisa and Domestic Violence
16:18 Marital R*pe
18:38 Divorce
23:10 Abrogation Principle
27:40 4 Witnesses for Zina
29:58 Invasion of Privacy
31:00 Weak vs Authentic Ahadith
37:24 Blasphemy Law
47:45 Democracy in Islam
49:50 Ishq-e-Mijazi in Sufism
51:30 Nikkah and Zina
53:20 Areas of non-expertise
55:30 The State-Clergy Nexus
58:00 Moulvis who are wrong numbers and Takabur
1:02:30 Islamic Touch Politics
1:11:10 Aurat kee kamayee haram hay?
1:12:00 Is Hijab Compulsory?
1:15:30 Children in Madrassas
1:20:00 People making money on KZbin using Islam
1:23:00 Malik Riaz
1:27:50 Interest in Banking
1:30:10 Shia Hatred
1:33:00 Faith, Belief and Science
1:38:30 Being Friends with Jews and Christians
1:41:00 Did the Establishment launch Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza
1:46:45 Free will vs Pre Destiny

[@ThePakistanExperience]

The wrong version was uploaded yesterday, the one with the watermark, that had 20 minutes missing. 10 minutes around the 1:02:00 where we discuss Islamic touch Politics And then at the end after 1:38:00 where we discuss Free Will, Destiny and the Establishment. Also the question about being friends with Jews and Christians. Apologies for all the issues. Our editor had a family emergency so things have been a bit haywire this week. Thankfully everything is good now.

[@AnotherReactionForYou]

Can’t complain!! It was still worth listening.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

@@AnotherReactionForYou

[@Bilawal-Bhutto]

Thanks for this discription 👍

[@UFCFunda69]

Your voice is missing at 1:02:00 and afterwards

[@UFCFunda69]

BTW poor audio quality

[@EngineerMuhammadAliMirzaClips]

Ma-Shaa-ALLAH ! ! ! Well needed PODCAST. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! TRUTH Lovers ko SALAM ! ! !

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@NoorS2812]

AMEEN

[@NoorS2812]

May ALLAH S.W.T PROTECT All Muslim Ummah From Trails And Tribulations Ameen 🖤

[@jongxina4908]

Lekin allah ne to maa chod di Pakistan ki. It means allah doesn't support Pakistan.

[@peace4us]

10000$ for Ali Engineer 1000$ for U اگر کوئی مرزا علی انجینئر کو ختم نبوت پر لائیو دلائل کے تبادلے کے لئے تیار کرے تو اس ایک ہزار ڈالر پیشگی انعام اور علی انجینئر کو دس ہزار ڈالر۔ علی انجینئر یہ رقم خد رکھے یا صدقہ خیرات کرے ۔ اس کی اپنی صوابدید۔ جو کوئی ایسا کر سکتا ہے برائے مہربانی بتا دیں۔ Ghhg bcdezk

[@malikehsan923]

The willingness of people from liberal and conservative class to sit together and discuss the topics on which there is some ambiguity among the masses is a great gesture from the Pakistani intelligencia. It shows acceptance of one side for another's right to have a different persoective. Kudos to both for such a discussion ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@chetan_naik]

What happens if liberal rejects Mohammed's prophet-hood on live stream? What Pakistani law says, what Islam says?

[@mustajab2088]

Amazing podcast. Some of the toughest questions were asked to Engineer Sahab. He even became uncomfortable at times and salute to the host for his intelligence and his resilience that he showed against the bullying of engineer sahab. Engineer Mirza faced an educated and intelligent person this time as he claims for others about himself. Engineer sahab has now attained a level of confidence after all these years of dawat where it is alright for him to play and bully his guests a little bit I still have some questions unanswered which i would be looking for on different platforms

[@bibimaryam594]

There shouldn't be separated "sides" we all belong to one ummah... so let's just search for the true teachings of Islam which is never illogical instead of just not bothering to study deaper and just opt for the so called liberalism...

[@muhammadtalharaja2119]

Well structured observation.

[@Drhamzaasad]

Brilliant Podcast Shehzad! This was a very unconventional debate and each question you asked Mirza Sb (who’s a true intellectual and our society needs more people like him) served a purpose. Thank you for educating us with your podcast. More power to you…

[@chpa0803]

This is a masterpiece!!! Cleared so much confusion. This podcast will create a massive impact in coming days! Shehzad you are a Gem!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

Taqi Usmani defence of Colonial heritage in Pakistan is unreasonable 1:29:04 thanks 🙏 mrs

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

64% of Pakistan was not given for any Service to Islam 1:31:05 thanks 🙏 mrs? What harm Pakistan is . suffering because of Taqi Usmani defence decision 1:33:09

[@flavianrego2466]

Indeed he has, Allah Bless him and keep him safe.

[@trilokyamohanchakra6351]

​@@ghazanfarhussain5032itma toh nhi pata, PA itna sach hain ki, isl@m is the biggest pr0blem in the world

[@idbhandari9952]

Great Revelations.Appears to be rational 😮 religious teacher of Islam.Rational being Engineer knows how to navigate difficult questions as Islamic teacher.Enjoyed besides understanding about religious beliefs.

[@alinaqvi4653]

Came across this lovely clip where you, Dr Taimur Rehman and Engineer Saab were having Chae and Samosay.... We need more conversations like this in our country... great job Shehzad...

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Sweet. Send me the link to the video too.

[@abdullah_jameel]

​@@ThePakistanExperiencehere kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIHbeqprbNt-kLM

[@Outofthisworld794]

​@@ThePakistanExperiencekzbin.info/www/bejne/fIHbeqprbNt-kLMsi=ahFNXRhGtdeG5E5k

[@comparativereligiondailynews]

Freedom of Expression should be given to all. Abolish Blasphemy Law. There should be no Blasphemy law in any Islamic country. @ 29 September 2023 @ 12 Rabi Ul Awwal 1445 AH in India ❤

[@tamoorakram7499]

You are not the same guy who is with Sahil, brother; in this, you are acting like a son talking to his father. So calm and peacefully listening every explanation of EMAM.

[@zafreeraza1616]

I am 💯 percent agree on this

[@Moon-en4nx]

100%

[@shameen9973]

100%

[@asadbaloch1561]

Absolutely right brother in this podcast he is like a nana muna bacha

[@jawbrekaa]

Becuase shahzad is in not karachi.

[@ShahidAshraf78]

I thought a little to click on this video because of its long duration, but I ended up watching the whole video. Brilliant interview. All the tough and relevant questions and appropriate answers... good job, well done.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@riffatmalik6572]

Saaaaaame here broh I took two days but i couldn't skip 🎉 This is worth watching no doubt ❤ This is the 2nd podcast which i watched the first one was amazing with Adeel on Pakistani history 🎉❤❤❤

[@Faiza-Irfan]

Shehzad, you have conducted this podcast with utmost grace - Thanks for asking difficult questions and accepting answers with grace and fluidity- great job Shehzad! 👏👏

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@flavianrego2466]

Great job Shezad and Thank you Eng..,.Mirza. Allah bless you both AND>>>>>KEP YOU SAFE

[@bibimaryam594]

Toughest questions!!!! But ALHAMDULILLAH very logical and convincing answers... thanks to the team for raising such provoking points and hence clearing minds

[@messykitchen7]

Engineer explained entropy better than physicists... wow❤

[@ibrahimnadeem1064]

Thank God someone noticed this thing. Strongly agree bro

[@s.z3717]

‼️ More then entropy, He gives logical n mathematical answer on Khuda (vahdaniyat ).

[@messykitchen7]

@s.z3717 exactly I agree..... 💯

[@deepak1771]

Maybe your physics teachers were not good

[@messykitchen7]

@@deepak1771 I mean he explains very well

[@imranzahidphotography]

Shehzad, you as a podcaster are really improving fast. You beautifully handled every aspect of it. This one was not easy :-)

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@8balldrift688]

Wish the audio was a little better

[@alirehman113]

english is also not easy 😂

[@moholah3745]

O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends; they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend, then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people. Quran 5:51

[@muhaq755]

میری نظر میں احمدی اسلام دور حاضر کی زندہ ترین حقیقت ھے۔اس جماعت کے بانی کا دعوٰی یہ ھے کہ میں وھی مھدی اور عیسٰی ھوں جس کے آنے کی پیشگوئی میرے آقا و مولٰی حضرت خاتم النبیّین صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے کی تھی۔اللہ تعالٰی نے اپنے الہام اور وحی سے مجھے یہ خوشخبری دی ھے کہ اسلام میری خلافت علی منہاج النبوت کے ذریعے دنیا میں فتح پائے گا اور عزت کے بلند ترین مقام پر فائز کیا جائے گا۔ جسے قبول کرنا ھے قبول کرے اور جسے انکار کرنا ھے وہ اپنے انکار کے وبال کا سامنا کرے۔ من شآء فلیومن ومن شآء فلیکفر اللہ تعالٰی اپنی ھدایت کسی پر جبر سے مسلط نہیں کرتا۔

[@nadirkhan2250]

Took me 2 days to finish watching the video. Standing ovation brother!!! I absolutely LOVE where you have taken your channel over the months and years. You're educating millions through your platform. Would love to be able to meet you in person when I'm in Pakistan next to shake your hand and thank you personally

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@user-ww2lc1yo9c]

Did you run it at 4.17% speed of normal?

[@nadirkhan2250]

@@user-ww2lc1yo9c 🤣. Couldn't spare all 120 mins in one go

[@moholah3745]

O you who have believed, do not take your fathers or your brothers as friends if they have preferred disbelief over belief. And whoever does so among you - then it is those who are the wrongdoers. Quran 9:23

[@muhaq755]

میری نظر میں احمدی اسلام دور حاضر کی زندہ ترین حقیقت ھے۔اس جماعت کے بانی کا دعوٰی یہ ھے کہ میں وھی مھدی اور عیسٰی ھوں جس کے آنے کی پیشگوئی میرے آقا و مولٰی حضرت خاتم النبیّین صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے کی تھی۔اللہ تعالٰی نے اپنے الہام اور وحی سے مجھے یہ خوشخبری دی ھے کہ اسلام میری خلافت علی منہاج النبوت کے ذریعے دنیا میں فتح پائے گا اور عزت کے بلند ترین مقام پر فائز کیا جائے گا۔ جسے قبول کرنا ھے قبول کرے اور جسے انکار کرنا ھے وہ اپنے انکار کے وبال کا سامنا کرے۔ من شآء فلیومن ومن شآء فلیکفر اللہ تعالٰی اپنی ھدایت کسی پر جبر سے مسلط نہیں کرتا۔

[@neeluaziz1994]

Engineer sahab is really one man army of this present era!!!!

[@rabeeamirza2927]

People from all walks of life - this is the true Pakistan podcast we hoped for. Amazing work Shehzad. It's amazing to see people with such different views on same panel. More power to you.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@hotice31]

Aurato ka temperament - this statement is enough for everyone to understand that one of the biggest lies in the world is “moderate Islam”

[@ummijaan1448]

True. There's no 'moderate islam'. It's just 'Islam'.

[@Shreaadedaa]

sweeping statement

[@m.ishakziaee9861]

Ghaliban aapki shaadi nahi hui hai munna!

[@shayanareeb5886]

There's nothing like moderate Islam. What do you want to say?

[@deebars7413]

Humain Islam key mutabiq chalna hai, Islam ko humary mutabaq nehi. Islam is a way of life and it’s closest to human nature if you want to accept that is your choice, if not no one is forcing anyone.

[@user-ol1eh5hf5w]

I got tears in my eyes at the end and I cannot explain why. Shehzad more power to you❤❤❤❤ bless you and your family

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@kushlohana7842]

Absolutely loved the podcast..aap ke podcasts sun ke lgta hai k everything can be discussed. 🙌

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@royetkhan3599]

U can't beat EMAM with asking difficult questions .......He is a gem 💎 ...❤

[@ahsanriaz7387]

Modern Form of Manazra conducted by people with different opinions and views... Well Done... Need more of this...

[@nasirali17]

I have never listened to this long religious podcast in one sitting. Kudos to the host and guest, with honest and brutal questions to genuine and straightforward (w/o any fear except Allah) answers. It is an inspiring discussion in a non-free society. Now I wish and pray for the safety of both parties. Ameen! @Shehzad keep up the great work. @Engineer keeps calling out the injustice at every level. May Allah protect and guide you’ll. Ameen!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ABCD-cw3fs]

18 ghar ka 213 Afrad Islam kabool Karna chata hai Sind mein.. Maulvi 800rupy aur 200 khatna..vo garib hai kya kare..hum to Maseehey hai..koyee bolo.. a

[@Bilari94]

Well, i must that's a new beginning where people from different ideologies r sitting togather, putting forward their thoughts in an intellectual manner and appreciating efforts of respective clubs. Weldone Bro for this effort and may Allah guide us all towards path of jannah. Treat to watch.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@user-es6bu7ny4b]

Ali Bhai Proud to be a Muslim❤ ALhamdulliah

[@fahada6526]

May Allah keep him safe and protected. He's the best Islamic scholar in Pakistan.

[@moholah3745]

Warn the hypocrites that torturous punishment awaits them. The hypocrites take unbelievers as friends rather than believers. Do they look for honor at their hands? Truly all honor belongs to Allah. Quran 4:138-139

[@naidah494]

Brilliant….! One of the unbiased, rational and eye opening episode. Brilliant shehzad. And engineer sahab I thought Ghamidi sahab is one of the unbiased scholar but you stand out too now sir. 👏🏻👏🏻

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@alldayfortnite4119]

Excellent podcast Very intellectual,genius,and brave person Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza ❤❤❤👌👌👌

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@sunnyak3293]

First ever podcast in my life I have watched 1:54 hours straight.🔥 Thanks for that 🙌

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@hamayunkhan7477]

what Engineer Muhammad Ali said here 1:35:45 is absolutely spot on. Second law of thermodynamics states that any spontaneously occurring process will always lead to an increase in entropy( disorder) of the universe. Entropy will either increase or will remain constant. To bring an order after the disorder you need an intellect or a brain as we can observe in our common life. So the order in the form of life or revolving of stars and planets in elliptical orbits and all those fine tunings after the big bang expansion does point out to the intellect

[@f.50]

How does that prove Allah is real?

[@Shreaadedaa]

@@f.50 it proves that someone did the intervention, you have to find out who that is, we dont

[@rashidiqbal3408]

That's only true for closed system, engineer quoted wrongly, it's not external power, it is external matter or energy, not external power or GOD, like earth is not a closed system sun provides it external energy, so even entropy is increasing on earth it can have ordered things like a plant

[@hamayunkhan7477]

@@rashidiqbal3408Engineer didn’t quote anything wrong sir. Do your search properly, Earth is not an open system ( its closed system). Just google it. And secondly second law applies both to isolated & closed systems and its not just limited to earth. Lastly, you mentioned about sun so are you saying it existed before the Big Bang?

[@iamfkhn]

Masha Allah so glad to see intellectual debates in here.

[@karatekid7640]

This podcast killing the few brain cells left in Pakistan😂

[@aatmaDipoBhava]

Dont reveal this. A country which is full of lies is showing audacity on the controversial thing is like any belief system saying I am right I am right. Mera tarjumaa sahi baki sab galat. Ab kon bataye jiska tarjuma ker rahe wo kud hi NEO ISLAM ka NEO QURAN hai.

[@egoiisticprince7977]

Tm logon k brain cells itny hain e ni k kch smjh sko

[@aatmaDipoBhava]

@@egoiisticprince7977 haan sahi farmaya brain cells ke bare me, humare brain cells to tumhare khilaf shazishen kerne me lagta hai. Kafir ka formula sun le, 3A + YHJ_ki_Shazishen Allah army america aur Yahood Hanood Jisara ki shazishen aur pokistan r silent barbaad... ziafication ka nateeza dekh rahe ho na binod

[@Sam-wt1cx]

​@@aatmaDipoBhavaStone Worshipper, why are you here?? Go stand in queue for Gau Mutr & Gobar.

[@shobhitdagur1086]

Let them do. Do not disclose 😂😂😂

[@SSS-dr8hl]

Engineer Sb had been on many podcasts, but the way you elicited knowledge from him - only you could do that. Tremendous podcast, SGS.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Danish.Khan.19]

Engineer Sahab Is The Great Scholars and True Scholars ❤

[@mmansooralam]

Brilliant podcast 👍🏻 Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza never ceases to amaze me. He is not only knowledgeable, but also rational and logical in his explanations to all arguments!

[@talhakhaliq5195]

Behtreen podcast ..... One of the few podcasts that I loved the most ..... Ammar Habib , Muzamil shah , Atif Mian , pervez hodbhoy and now engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza .....

[@muhammadfaheemahmed2601]

A very Intlectual Podcast..❤ A big Fan of Man Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza..❤ And i want an Interview of Syed Muzamil with EMAM..🔥

[@rymaustudio5683]

A man and his love can change the world.

[@mosawirjan3428]

مزہ آیا سن کر۔۔۔۔ پوری رات نہیں سو سکا کیونکہ جب شروع کیا تو ہر ایک جملہ مجھے انتہائی اہم لگا۔۔۔ بہت خوبصورت سوالات بھی تھے۔۔ انجنیئر صاحب کی بات چیت لتا کے گیتوں سے زیادہ سریلی محسوس ہوتی ہیں۔۔۔ ❤❤😊❤❤❤

[@zujjaj]

Came here after watching his podcast with sahil, to see if the host treats every one of his guests like he treated sahil adeem. And I'm shocked to see his body language, his expressions and the way he politely asked "difficult" questions. Engineer sahab gave the exact same reply which sir sahil gave on abrogation principle, and I'm surprised the host was calm this time. I'm truly shocked and disappointed the way he treated sahil sahab.

[@homefoodfitness]

Tell me how many times engineer sahab interrupted Shahzad when asking questions? You can see the difference...sahil adeem wants to speak as much as he can...with whatever interpretations he has...watch that podcast again after watching this podcast...you would know the difference... Sahil Adeem never gives referances... Aadhi adhoori baataien...lots of philosophy which a normal person doesn't even understand..lots of jargon...and a hell lot of arrogance...the very core of Quran is somehow missed by sahil adeem. I have been listening to him for quite a while...and i am amazed by how easily ppl get manipulated by his wizardry of words... May Allah protect us from any kind of sharr..

[@Ahsanummati]

I listen to a lot of different podcast every week, The quality I appreciate most in a podcast host is their curiosity. This leads to better questions that lead to better answers from people they interview.

[@jyb2433]

I have just come here to watch this host's attitude toward MAM when he asks questions than when he asks Sahil Adeem. And I am astonished watching this man's attitude how obedient, soft spoken and down to earth he is here. And to Sahil he was asking same stuff like he had done some sin to this man. E.g. same question of beatng wife. Simply watch here and watch Sahil's podcast. You will see hell lot of difference. Disappointed by this host hypocrisy

[@ZahidKhan-hn2xq]

100% agree on this but the peoples he invited teaches us a lot and we get so much information from them...may Allah bless these two gems ( Sahil bhai and Ali bhai)😍❤. And I pray for the host that Allah give him Hidayyat. so that instead of being a hyppocrate he should be neutral and humble to every guest and be more mature.....

[@MyPersonal-qz8qd]

He helped me to understand Islam better and broke many understood negative stereotypes.

[@naturevibes999]

even your microphone's are not working well in the whole podcast, but most of people listen it continuously without pausing, so amazed and clear my numerous thoughts that i ever get confused, especially with the topic of imam bargah. WE WANT ANOTHER UNCENSORED PODCAST WITH ENGINEER MUHAMMAD ALI MIRZA REALLY LOVED IT ⭐🧠❤️

[@muhammadsohaib390]

This podcast has cleared up many thoughts from my mind. And I salute to bhai you and specially Ali mirza bhai for clearing it up. You deserve a medal for this . Really appreciate this.

[@Spectre645]

Brave man Engineer Sb ❤ Really enjoyed the whole podcast ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@sadiamufti8890]

Shehzad has been very respectful during this interview. A practice that needs to be followed by youtubers. His eagerness to seek truth shows in the honesty with which he carries himself. Well done young man. More growth to this channel. 👏

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Rational_Islam]

1:33:00 SubhanAllah, your explanation always amazes the people seeking knowledge Ali Bhai. May Allah keep you safe. JazakAllah 😍

[@hasannawazofficial]

Thank you for bringing this podcast!

[@chpa0803]

Watching this from Nepal. Shehzad, your podcasts are the best in the world. So much research and such a calm and humble way of asking some tough questions. I have learnt a lot about south asian geopolitics from your podcasts. Thank you my brother. ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@ak1256ol]

Can we connect in Instagram ?

[@alhamdulillahmuslim2812]

MashaAllah may Allah Guide us to the Right Path Ameen❤️

[@gamingwithali9579]

Amazing podcast brother. This one, and the one with Moroo are my top two favs. Excellent work.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@muhammaddanish1441]

A great podcast.. Since the engineer has a style of pushing his argument in an aggressive manner and Shehzad did often times get on a backfoot but still managed to ask the most important questions that pinch liberal and moderate people in Pakistan.

[@mustajab2088]

Amazing podcast. Some of the toughest questions were asked to Engineer Sahab. He even became uncomfortable at times and salute to the host for his intelligence and his resilience that he showed against the bullying of engineer sahab. Engineer Mirza faced an educated and intelligent person this time as he claims for others about himself. Engineer sahab has now attained a level of confidence after all these years of dawat where it is alright for him to play and bully his guests a little bit I still have some questions unanswered which i would be looking for on different platforms

[@huzaifastriker762]

Time spent for Allah is not time wasted. It's time invested!😊

[@StudyingReligions]

I think you should think more rationally

[@MrHeartheacker]

one of the best pod casts. Amazing Qs and "Rebuttals" by EMAM. JazakAllah

[@hafizkhalid394]

محمد علی انجینئر صاحب کو سننے سے پہلے تعصب کو ایک سائڈ پر رکھیں تو زیادہ لطف آئے گا ۔۔ میں بھی ایسا ہی کر رہا ہوں الحمد للہ !! مدلل گفتگو کی سب کچھ سمجھ آرہا ھے ۔۔

[@tmehmood121]

Bhai hum sab ko jo cheez side pe rakhni chahye engineer sb ko sunnay keliye to wo hai akal kyun ke akal wala aur ilm wala is jaisay insan ko sunnay se pehlay 100 dafa sochay ga

[@hafizkhalid394]

@@tmehmood121 بھائی صاحب میں تو سمجھا تھا کہ آپ کو ئی قرآن و حدیث کے حوالے سے انجینئر صاحب کو غلط ثابت کرنے لگے ہیں مگر آپ نے تو کمال ہی کر دیا😊😊 ۔۔۔۔میں حلفاً کہتا ہوں کہ میرا تعلق بریلوی مکتبہ فکر سے ھے مگر انجینئر صاحب کی علمی اور مدلل گفتگو سن کر اسے جھٹلا نہیں سکتا اور نہ ہی انہیں گالیاں یا برا بھلا کہ سکتا ہوں ۔۔۔مگر انہیں سننے سے پہلے واقعی تعصب کی عینک اتاریں گے تو سمجھ آئے گی وگرنہ تنقید برائے تنقید کرتے جائیں گے تو پھرکچھ بھی حاصل نہیں ہوگا ۔۔ اللہ پاک سب کو ہدائت دے اٰمین ۔۔۔

[@muhammadimrantahir4534]

Magnificent, the podcast was just amazing. Engr Muhammad Ali Mirza is on a whole other level. After Dr Israr saab he is the next uproaring Islamic scholar. He is just amazing.

[@ghayurahmed575]

Watching again. Fantastic podcast

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Codymaverick20012]

That was some revelation that Engr Saab was enlightened by Personalities such as Asma Jahangir ,Hamid Mir, Ghamdi Saab All of these personalities have been controversial in the eyes of the masses Btw respect 🫡 to this man , he is doing a great job may Allah protect him and he should continue with his mission ameen Secondly kudos to you @shehzad Ghias , I have been indeed enlightened by seeing your podcasts with personalities that have experience to share in their fields, that are quite diverse You are doing a fine job too God speed Your reply would mean that my well wishes have been received well 😂

[@AbdulHannan-yu9fk]

Mashallah...Very Good Podcast. Kudos to Host and Guest as well.

[@dodgeroliver8469]

Thank God you both are using English words so young youth can listen to this podcast. Jzk🙏🏼❤️

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@user-oq8hk4hy5d]

I am from Bharat, it was wonderful to listen to Muhammad Ali Mirza on Islamic Theology. Request to invite Ex Muslims like Sahil, Sachwala, Adam Seeker etc in your show and have a debate with scholars so that Momins who are leaving Islam can understand whats right and what wrong. Their channels are presently blocked in Pakistan and can be accessed if the location is changed to India in settings under profile.

[@ketunky3056]

You should go to poakistan

[@moazzamlxxl]

Why give these people such importance? They don't even have complete knowledge about the religion. The question of accepting and denying a religion comes once you know each and everything about a religion.

[@botsarmyy9218]

Most energetic part:-❤️ Faith believe and science

[@mdkvaofficial]

Ma Sha Allah... May Allah Bless EMAM Sahab & Us All. Ameen!

[@khalidmahmoodbhattistudent5315]

Haq Such ki Awaaz Hain engineer Mohammad Ali Mirza sahib Mashallah Alhamdulillah 🥰✨... Allah Pak ham sab ko sehat o hidayat Ataa farmay Shirk firqa parasti o shakhsiat parasti say bacha k Apny Emaan ki Fiqar karny ki tofeeq ataa farmay Aameen sum Aameen ❤️🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻❤️

[@umairjamshaid2173]

This is amazing. I was not expecting this!!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@fahadmalik4797]

What a brilliant guy 🤍 He’s an asset for the Muslim Ummah and I pray Allah keeps him safe 🤍

[@user-wm9ti8fk7v]

Zarghun Road، Near Railway Station, Quetta, Balochistan, Pakistan

[@bakhtawarilyas1341]

Really waited for this one after the picture you posted of you with him❤

[@abdulrehmansarwar418]

اس طرح کے سوالات علی بھائی سے پہلے کسے اینکر نے نہیں کیے، ویل ڈن اینکر بھائی ۔۔۔ One of the best Podcasts ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤

[@samibabar9543]

That's how you do discourse, EVERYBODY TAKE NOTES!!🔥❤️

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@noorulainahmed1769]

no words, amazing man Engr Muhammad Ali Mirza

[@mustajab2088]

Amazing podcast. Some of the toughest questions were asked to Engineer Sahab. He even became uncomfortable at times and salute to the host for his intelligence and his resilience that he showed against the bullying of engineer sahab. Engineer Mirza faced an educated and intelligent person this time as he claims for others about himself. Engineer sahab has now attained a level of confidence after all these years of dawat where it is alright for him to play and bully his guests a little bit I still have some questions unanswered which i would be looking for on different platforms Love from India to the host and creators of this video It was my first video of this host but surely won't be my last Inshallah

[@cerealkiller5599]

Hey, there's an abrupt cut at 1:10:44 ish. Was that a technical problem or a deliberate cut?

[@maxCarnag3]

Salam, great podcast. Its a shame a second one might not happen but please do keep trying. Ali bhai is definitely intimidating but you were slowing breaking the ice. Keep up the good work Shehzad!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Numann31]

23:30 wonderful question and a wonderful answer,one of the most intellectual podcast record in modern day world with E.M.A.M ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@tipjar247]

Comprehensive bayan Jazak Allah. What a viewership of EMAM

[@islamicworld5086]

مَا شَاءَ ٱللَّٰهُ ❤️

[@FauiqeAlone]

Loved every second of it. What a masterpiece 👏

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@SAHIB_06]

Ali Bhai, May Allah protect you 🙏🏻💖 ameen

[@shahnawazsoomro8093]

Very well done Shahzad sir. Loved the way you asked questions and took the answers. Loved the way engineer sahab replied to the questions with evidence and logic. Well explained answer with modern day application!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Usaamaaa]

The conversation was not only well-needed but also remarkably enlightening. Engineer Sahab’s profound explanations, especially on the intricate concept of entropy and his perspective on the existence of God, were nothing short of extraordinary. His ability to articulate complex ideas in such a clear and compelling manner is truly commendable. I'm deeply grateful for the depth of knowledge and insight Engineer Sahab brought to the discussion, making it an intellectually invigorating experience. I eagerly anticipate more thought-provoking conversations like this in the future.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@LineOut-wv2to]

Ali bhai is a genius and an asset of Pakistan and Muslim Ummah. his intellect level is unmatched. very tough questions answered very clearly. by far your best podcast so far.

[@pappu33]

A man who believes in angels and miracles is not an intellectual.

[@f.50]

Lmao to your tough questions, ask Engr to face an exmuslim, he's been avoiding them like hell

[@noorzahidzahid3850]

​@@pappu33niether a man who can't respect someone's beliefs

[@blackmamba9950]

​@@noorzahidzahid3850the original comment never said anything about respect, just that nobody would consider him an intellectual. You can always respect a normal person who's not an intellectual. You are the one comparing intelligence to respect

[@f.50]

​@@noorzahidzahid3850what a stupid logic, I'm supposed to respect someone believing in killing murtads? F off

[@sadenb]

Openly talking about beating women. I mean what else can one say. Open misogyny.

[@hassanahmed541]

Listen to that part again so that undertand its true meaning

[@hussainakhtar1094]

Engineer Ali Sb is way ahead and judge the interviewer's mindset absolutely. He then took the driving seat and just nailed it 🙂

[@mian_G37]

Form UK shehzad! its good to listen the Modern islamic views by the civic mulla of it will be very exellent if you give your platefrom for otherschool of thought like mufti Tariq masood to ask such difficult question. I hope you pay attention here.😊 Wish you very Best of luck 🤞

[@basitaliabbasi10]

Gotta say this was one of the best podcasts of yours.. we'd love to see again you with him

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@majidwas]

1:33:15 to 1:38:22 MashaAllah. It should be a separate clip.

[@maketake7814]

Best part of this video

[@nailaali2428]

Engineer Mirza, the real scholar. He's doing justice to the message of Islam and setting the best example for those who wish to be daee of Islam. May Allah keep him blessed

[@deenfitrat]

Thank you to both for your time. However, many times in this podcast, your voice was very low but Engineer Sahab ki awaz bohot clear this. Anyhow many thanks, Sheikh sb your hard work in question selection was key to the success of this podcast.

[@hibasameen]

A couple of of comments for Engineer sahab @EngineerMuhammadAliMirzaClips - I wont engage with his absurd and outdated views on women, male guardianship of women etc. because they are beyond the pale and not worth engaging with - but where he is more interesting than his peers is that he does at least engage with philosophy and science and uses reason when making arguments about faith. First, to clarify the cosmological Steady-State Model (SSM) was very much a 20th century phenomenon rather than 18th or 19th century, and not all its proponents were atheists. E.g. Einstein was one of the key proponents of this theory and he was a deist. But it is true that one of its most vehement proponents Fred Hoyle was in part motivated by his atheism because he found the Big Bang Theory (BBT) too close to the biblical cosmological account. And it is interesting and telling that the father of the BBT, Lemaître, was also a Christian priest. It is unimaginable today for a Muslim theologian to also be a leading scientist as Lemaître was, and this has been the case for several centuries. Muslim scholars have fallen so far behind the intellectual frontier, it's truly embarrassing. Most of the arguments that Muslim scholars adopt against atheists today are borrowed from Christian theologians and philosophers, and sometimes they fail at doing that coherently too. Even the Kalam cosmological argument from medieval Islamic Scholasticism has been updated and employed by William Lane Craig, a Christian theologian. Islamic theology today lacks originality and creativity - it no longer moves the world forward as it once did. The Ulema should focus on raising the level of their scholarship rather than proselytising, because with this level of scholarship, one may draw in some sheep in the herd but you will never draw anyone in with a modicum of intellectual depth.

[@subhasisghosh66]

Ma'am if you read Thomas Friedman's book, The World is Flat, you will get the answer to your question. Basically if from childhood you are told- "just read this book, all yours answers are here", then automatically your ability to think critically goes. Questioning the status quo is basis of development.

[@Us-man33]

We need more awareness from such great intellectuals in our Pakistani society. A panel of Pervaiz Hoodbhoy, Syed Muzamil, and Engineer Ali Mirza would be of great enlightenment and understanding of society,politics, religion, and science.

[@hanzalaahmed2993]

Hoodbhoy? For gods sake 😂

[@faranyousufi241]

so needed podcast plan next podcast on current affair and most trending disabilties in pakistan Well neeeded hattss off to the team who makes an effort! Salam!

[@hibajafri9214]

Loved it!

[@hotice31]

The operative principle in every argument offered by this religious scholar is “convenience”

[@jasha9sandhu]

Which keeps changing.

[@graphicsdesigning2479]

Life is simple

[@Faiza-Irfan]

I am sorry to say but the justification to support the clergy circles simply because parents will 🛑 sending their children to the madrassahs is WRONG!! Where-ever a child is ABUSED and you know about it, it’s your responsibility to CALL IT OUT!! When you remain quite your are equally to be blamed because you let the abuse happen - DISAPPOINTED!

[@saadzahoor8710]

dumbo he said that they do it on purpose and its wrong.

[@Shreaadedaa]

disappointed from whom? he clearly said its wrong and should be stopped and maulvi cover these incidents to keep the system for themselves,

[@Faiza-Irfan]

@@Shreaadedaathat’s the thing! Just because you are afraid that your madrassahs doesn’t shut down you would remain quite and not call out the one where abuse is taking place - misplaced priorities- and giving analogies of generals and chief justices doesn’t abrogate you of your ethical responsibility- 2 wrongs don’t make a right - on principe, if you know that the abuse is taking place, the good clean madrassahs need to stand up for those abused children - PERIOD!

[@maryamcheema8427]

Agree with you! I feel I’ve been censored as I can’t see my comment on someone else’s phone, I put the following comment but didn’t even get acknowledgment or response so I’m with you very disappointed: Is this the best scholar we have to offer? I found it difficult to watch this video, given the engineer's perspective, seems to contribute to the challenges Pakistan is facing. Compare this engineer who claims to be scholar to this soul kzbin.info/www/bejne/aqa7oWOpqKx6lZY. He’s basically shouting, the podcast should have had Syed Muzammil or any other proper intellect to call him it out on his lies. He’s vocal when there’s no one else more knowledgeable. It makes me sick on how Prophet Muhammad (SAW) would perceive this discourse, especially considering his compassionate nature and wisdom. Where is the wisdom in our scholars? We don’t worship God, we worship the opinions of others. Most of us are sheep, that follow fools because that is what this thinking teaches. Domestic violence is rampant in our culture because of this thinking - a successful cultures is defined on how it treats its most vulnerable. What about that nearly 50% (no one talks about it) of men in Pakistan that have been sexually abused as children so they express this trauma in oppressing their families and the cycle continues. Shehzad, perhaps you could have delved into questions like why an increasing number of Muslims in Muslim-majority countries are abandoning their faith and questioning the existence of God. The comments section sadly reveals a lack of awareness among our people (who don’t think and ask the real questions). Standing up against injustice is essential part of Islam; it's disheartening that more people don't vocally oppose this misinformation and hate, as God disapproves of complacency. It would be better if we didn't endorse scholars who propagate negativity. I regret to say that I'm unsubscribing because this content does not align with the hopeful direction I had anticipated for this channel. Islam was spread by the Sufi’s in this region, let’s go back to their true teaching not this ignorant version of Islam that bears no positive fruit. Let’s stop lying to ourselves and worshiping it, we were built on a lie and we continue the lies! God give us all the courage to seek and speak the truth!! God doesn’t change a state of nation until they change themselves.

[@ahsanaliiqbalansari2354]

​@@Faiza-Irfan lol engineer doesn't have any madrassa he isn't beneficiary of this system he has spoken many times against this he even said that you don't need to send your kids to madrassa for islamic education you just simply need quran and ahadith and continue your studies

[@Orphan_Heart14]

Love you engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza 🔥♥️🦅

[@allihyder684]

Ustad e mohtram ❤ The Man who make us realise about the purpose of life. Jazakallah SIR❤ @EN

[@parttimemerasi5872]

11 mins into the podcast and this person has said disrespected women, Pashtoon people and obese people. and I am shocked that this person is seen to be a revolutionary in Islamic circles.

[@hassanraza121472]

I noticed the same as he bodyshamed him and then presented misogynist thoughts.

[@nadeemqasmi7639]

At least he's honest, he said what's written in the scriptures of the holy book. He didn't tried to change the meaning, just said at it is.

[@abdullhaseeb4157]

unbelievable engineer sahb. what a legend.

[@syedsadathulla4624]

I love Ali Bhai dilse allhadulilla Allah hu Akbar thanks for your reporting bro happy to hear from you dear bro

[@fatimaibrar-sskmontessoris3307]

Well done Muhammad Ali shb. U explain very well. I didn't like Pakistan experience podcast but i m here for Ali mirza