Untold Realities behind Pakistan's Economic Decline.

[@maliali2075]

Very blunt, naked and horrifying but true to the core. Excellent by Kaiser Sb.

[@skylark304]

LOOTED LAND

[@Fourthpillarluvv8773]

@@maliali2075 ye itna sach nhi bol skty dear🙂

[@8016tm]

You are wonderful anchor person. great respect for Qaiser Bengali Sahib,

[@SuperMario-9]

Economically bankrupt for 5-6 years, morally for 75 years. The sad story of pakistan.

[@naeemiqbal5819]

Typical indian comments

[@hafeezullahkhan4680]

Bengali saab k leya salute, he is a great expert in economics and it's true, he explains and make you understand economics in such a easy way, he is a great intellect, but Alass our country has not used him as an expert for the benefit of country.

[@murtazamansoor6440]

Host has very Calm and composed personality. Guest was also very good. Great Factual conversation

[@chwaqar528]

Raftar team sab aysi hai dheema lehjay myn sab se acha muzamil shah ko sunna lgta mujhy

[@gulshank4919]

Faisal waheed you have lot of courage to listen the truth about ur country these blunt truth are not easy to digest from # 🇮🇳india #

[@manhar3891]

OMG!! This man bursting all bubbles. Very rare personality, his views are 90 degress. No bakwass.

[@docshah.]

He is member of ppp zardari k sath hain....

[@quddusquddus136]

The host deserves huge applause for conducting this incredible conversation with a rarity. It’s impossible to fathom poverty in Pakistan. Yet, it’s not simply there. It’s created systematically by the strong-the plunderers.

[@ANASARIFRIAZ]

This channel (Raftar)'s turning out to be a REVOLUTIONARY CHANNEL !! Hope this works out in broader term....

[@khaliddurrani6432]

Golden words of mr Bengali “ the rulers were never in power “.

[@khawarabbas1234]

The rulers were in power, but they didn't have power.

[@spritualist6519]

No, he said, " They were in power but did not have power".

[@fahmad7194]

He is saying it as it is 👍

[@ehsanjavaid1858]

I 100℅ agree with sir that we have to lower the expenditure of Army and Civil Servants... Salary, medical, house, 5 servants, free petrol, free electricity, free gas and Result 0℅.. Again good work Raftar.. 👍👍

[@angeleyessvenska9330]

all those perks were given as the sheeples were brainwashed that the foj will do deen hifazat, prevent yahood uz hanood from coming to chabao the momineens etc..........natahij: Kshmir raha Hindustan or Pak ban gayi IMFistan

[@JawaidMunir-f9d]

Our Army create parties and after it's achievements they disappear one party and generat another parties.

[@JawaidMunir-f9d]

Sub Kuch isilie ho Raha ha k hamari Army aur Siasat Dan India aur America ka k haathho biki hui hai.

[@JawaidMunir-f9d]

Chahiye ye tha k factories banate aur maishat par sanjidgi se soch te lakin ku k hamare Apne RAW k agents bane huwe Hain is lie Pakistan tabah ho gaya ha ab soche k China mukhlis tha lakin hum America k paltu kute bane huwe Hain.Bajwa ki bivi arbo rupe ki Malik ha .maadni zakhair par koi kaam NAHI kia ku k agar karte to Pakistan ko tabha k sey kare gay ye sirf Army ha Jo k Pakistan ki tabahi ki wajah ha ye bazair India k dhushman show karte Hain I'll be We karte Hain

[@naeemiqbal5819]

Indians comments

[@kachrachi]

Full respect for Kaiser sahab. I wish other economists can be honest like him. Hope he stays safe

[@ahmedashiqali4553]

Kaiser Bengali is very intelligent and have very information with very great view. Do more podcast with him and do over politics too

[@pranavvenkata475]

I'm from India and I'm impressed with the clarity and meaningful questions asked by the host. The guest also seems to be very knowledgeable. We need these kind of discussions🎉💯

[@AlHindMaskeen]

Speaks about ur pathetic standards. 🤣🤣

[@bhupenderrawat5922]

Aree tutne de pakistan tera kya jata hai

[@nicolasflamel3489]

for them, you are nothing but kupphar. Your comment is like someone in Winterfell watching a podcast btw two white walkers on state of whitewalker economy across "the wall" and commenting, this white walker is asking nice questions.

[@JaisonLucas-co3do]

@@bhupenderrawat5922 Any one who enjoys seeing someone hurt or falling down is called a "Sadist". Kisi ka bura hote dekhke kyo kush ho rahe ho.

[@AlHindMaskeen]

@NavyaSagittarius they contribute far more than entire gdp of ur bhikaristan.... now go get some aata 🤣🤣🤣

[@snathan3198]

Very honest, straightforward discussion. I don't fully agree that before 1977 there was economic boom in Pakistan. USA and UK were very powerful then and were fully supporting Pakistan and forex in the form of grants, projects and loans were coming in.

[@nightking8490]

True. Same with Musharraf. 🇺🇸 Funding

[@ranahammad4561]

Mashallah best podcast Economics par ziada se ziada videos banaye Thanks

[@abdulmoeezbhutta9913]

Bring gentlemen lile him more often. What an analysis. The stability in his voice and confidence in his talks make me listen to him with out any break. Love this guest. Thankyou raftar for bringing him

[@Walijadoon]

This is what i call the real journalism and respected sir telling naked truths..

[@cmramakrishnan9570]

a very clear and bold anlysis by econommist kaiser bengali and a balanced host . the real reason for this condition was just touched 'Muqabila with India". both the host and the guest reflect the Pakistani mindset that has led to the present condition of Pakistan. "Muqabila with India". Pak army thrives on this. How can it reduce expenditure on its bloated army?

[@Tariq_Amin]

One of my favourite economists, love listening to Miftah, shibbar zaidi, Ishfaq Hassan.

[@usmanghani8897]

Qaiser sahab ko 1st time suna mai tow in k analysis ka Fan hogaya hun ❤

[@AurangzebPTI]

one of my best economist who i love to listen more and more and people like him should be in the cabinet with full authority if Pakistan needs to prosper.

[@hafeezullahkhan4680]

He is very right, we have to cut down the expenses of Army and civil service

[@GlobalBaloch]

یہ ملک فوجی آفیسروں کی عیاشیوں کے لئے ہے عوام اگر بھوک سے مرے بھی یہ اپنی عیاشیوں کو کم نہیں کریں گے۔

[@اکرام-غ2ذ]

درست فرمایا اپ نے

[@nikhilv4499]

1946 pakistan banega 1947 pakistan zindabad 1970 operation searchlight 1971 bangladesh zindabad 2024 taliban ttp mission sharia 2025 khybar Pakhtunkhwa zindabad 2029 baloch liberation army 2030 balochistan zindabad 2034 sindh separatist movement 2035 sindhudesh zindabad 2040 ek tha pakistan 2050 kon tha pakistan lee jinnah did i create 5 countries or 1 whatever being jinnah i am proud that i created world jihadist factory saved india

[@helpingtrader-007]

@@nikhilv4499 You forgot Ghazwa e Hind. After Ghazwa e Hind: kon tha hindu? 😂😂

[@sjishah]

​@@nikhilv4499whenever KPK Zindabad, then it will be your Ruler within year's. You should praised Pakistan Army who is defending you from the people who rule over you for 1000 years and can do it again for further 1000.

[@fuckas..r]

that's great

[@saqlainofficial5559]

بہترین گفتگو کی ہے قیصر صاحب نے ان کو دربارہ دعوت دیجئے گا ۔۔

[@GlobalBaloch]

بہترین تجزیہ کرتے ہیں بنگالی صاحب اور حقیقت پر مبنی تجزیہ کرتے ہیں۔

[@AbdullahAzzam-y7k]

Raftar and its guest selection ❤❤❤

[@mustafalabbaikwala6436]

46 min is a very good conversation

[@Doctor_Kahani]

Such a transparent analysis.

[@MuhammadJAVEDMUSHTAQ]

1 aik lafz I listen v.carefully, love listening to sir... Especially solutions..

[@aliimrankhalil]

Excellent show and fantastic expertise of Dr. Sahib

[@KanishQQuotes]

This was brutal. Kudos to the guest

[@javedfazal59]

Kaiser Bengali Sb’s analysis is very comprehensive and correct. But who will bell the cat and how and when?

[@PhadJHR-bz7th]

I guess it will have to be Imran Khan. Now or never. Right now millions of Pakistanis know this and they're doing everything in their means to get Imran Khan into the driver's seat

[@sbmr]

بہت ہی بہترین تجزیہ و تحلیل اور عادلانہ راہ حل

[@navinbhatia9936]

30 to 31 minutes discussion is classic. He is right when annual budget's 40%goes in debt repayment+40%towards defence +20%only for nation buildiing

[@Jainhospitals]

Excellent Interview, Thanks Kaiser Bengali Ji very experience advisor.

[@yogeshtambe13]

A very sensible and meaningful conversation. Such people from Pakistan are very rare to watch and listen to. As an Indian I totally agree with Mr. Bengali that the reason behind the Pakistan as failed state is their Army and honestly Pakistanis will have to go through extremely tough time to survive in coming years.

[@nonask_1156]

Holly molly this is the third podcast i am listening about sinking Pakistan. Feeling so hopeless like this guest 😢. May God keep us on the right path.

[@Syedrafi88]

I am not hopeless. Its has been going for past 75 years. People just waking up now. Pakistan was a failed project initiated by Jinnah.

[@uk4490]

Muneer mistri is sinking the Pakistani Titanic.

[@immu365]

​@@uk4490Hafiz g😅

[@MohinKMoh_Kamran]

Why should God help? When the people are happy foisting Munir on top?

[@mohammadharisfahim6614]

He speaks like a true honest and benevolent teacher

[@mushahidhussain2840]

hats off to RAFTAR!👍

[@muhammadkhawariqbal6417]

A salute to Dr Sb. This the way and these are the causes. Such type of economist brought to power to save the country and the nation.

[@adnangul1202]

One of the potential reasons for our bankruptcy are our DHAS. These have dumped 70% of our national income into lands rather than in the development.

[@m.shoaibomer7822]

wonderful economist...and good going team @raftartv .

[@gunjanagrawal8195]

Touchwood in india we are very grateful to PM Modi...... earlier 2014 there were lots of power cut in night and day time.... approximately 7 hrs daily but since 2016 i rarely remember when my home lights turned off and rarely find bill which is more than 800 INR ❤❤❤❤❤ Love my mother land madhya pradesh, India 😅

[@AlHindMaskeen]

Then keep voting 4 BJP, else u betray ur community.

[@ashkhan7887]

Since 2014, India is a witness of religious anarchy, discrimination against minorities and money moving within just few billionaires.

[@mumtazahmed8099]

Salute to Mr. Kaiser . Very Bold and Blunt. MashaAllah 🤲🏽

[@komalsingh1074]

Pakistan has always been preoccupied with the destruction of India instead of focusing on improving their country. Net result is the innocent people suffer. Very sad indeed.

[@storyverse705]

Wah excellent 👍 Maine first time suna hai inko point to point, precomposed, calm or koi faltu baat Nahin very informative for students.

[@panwarg6156]

Infantry units of millitary must be reduced. Police should be inforced instead.

[@bali3470]

Excellent sir انکو دوبارہ مدعو کیا جائے اور (economic technicalities ) پر بات کی جائے ۔

[@PKJohn-mv8pv]

So long as Chinese products keep on coming to Pakistan, industry won't progress.

[@ZaheerAhmed-ku1ey]

Bohot sahi aur truthful baat ki hai aap ne......agar in baton pe Amal Kya gya to shayad Pakistan k haalat ache hosakte hain

[@mirfanali1937]

How conveniently he overlooks the repercussions of shifting the capital from Karachi to Punjab, the Dacca debacle, and, above all, the brutal and destructive nationalization that Pakistan has never recovered from to this day.

[@GuzzarAwan]

Punjabisation of Pakistan

[@wajiwaji-jy9km]

It was the best decision to shift capital from karachi to Islamabad, First of all, Karachi is far from any major population of Pakistan, it is literally in the middle of desert, where as Islamabad I'd located in middle of country, very close to lahore Peshawar faisalabad Rawalpindi and other major cities, karachi has no major city close to it, also Karachi is coastal city, so it has threat of attack, it has a huge migrant crisis bcz it's located on sea, so first destination of migrants from myanmar and other areas, population crisis is another major problem, and infrastructure wise, its worst except few developed areas

[@mirfanali1937]

@@wajiwaji-jy9km Smh. The amount of ignorance that still exists baffles me

[@wajiwaji-jy9km]

@@mirfanali1937 when you don't have any point, just start shit talking, blah blah blah

[@mirfanali1937]

@@wajiwaji-jy9km I wish you had even a shred of knowledge that would have warranted me to enlighten you comprehensively. Unfortunately, there's always that one ignorant fool who feels entitled to comment in your thread. Pathetic.

[@rajeshrkale]

Bengali Sir, I am very much delighted your boldness, open spoken words. Sir peopkes like you are also required here in India.

[@database4074]

ووٹ دو : ہر 15 دن بعد قیصر بنگالی صاحب کو لازمی بلایا جائے

[@SaurabhSingh-pp6ys]

Excellent clear thoughts of the guest. Very good hosting too. Point Blank questions and even more clear answers. Hope Pakistani generals and Shabaz Sharif listen this and act.

[@KyaHamAazaadHain]

خاکسار کے خیال کے مطابق پاکستان کے تمام مسائل کا حل ھماری بھادر افواج انڈیا کی طرح اپنی حدود میں واپس جائے اور آئین میں مزید سختی کے ساتھ افواج کا سیاسی معاملات میں مداخلت فوری بند کی جائے

[@rajatrao]

Generous Host and Knowledgeable Guest. Kudos!

[@pratapchandra2932]

Very nice conversation …. It’s an eye opener for all responsible citizens of any country .

[@rahatqadeer4400]

What a noble personality... He's so lucid n clear in his analysis ... Difficult talk simply in Layman's language... These scholars are never welcome at National levels... SALUTES 43:56 Bengali sahib

[@JamshadAhmad]

That's what a respectful and thoughtful conversasion looks like.

[@RealizeGSB]

Dr Kaisar Bengali is one of few pakistanis speaking truth,that I have lheard. Hats off to him.

[@channel589]

Great and intelligent economist with fact based logical examples. Sir Qaiser bangali showed past, present and future of Pakistan . Take this person conversation serious otherwise world will not take you serious.

[@H.a-e3j]

Sir you are very true speaking. MashaAllah

[@lokeshwar4093]

watching Dhruv rathhy suddenly AI works effectively, Raftar channel recommendation pop-up, After watching this true and transparent research documentary/podcast they convinced me to subscribe this channel.

[@muhammadfarooque9482]

Hats off to Dr. Kaisar Bengal for such a deep analysis of Pakistsn's core issues in simple words. We are prevaleged to have genius and patriotic Economists and scholars like Kaiser Bengali.

[@skm843]

What an excellent analysis of pakistan's economy by Mr Bengali Sir. What an excellent economic Think Tank of pakistan. Why these peoples are not invited by the Govt as economic Adviser for the people of pakistan. Love Bengali Sir. From India ❤️

[@tariqshaz]

Good work @raftartv you are are doing excellent job. Thank you Qaiser Babgali sb for being honest

[@abdulrehmanq4350]

As a Communist I totally agreed with Bengali sab, I think Socialist policies must be started to rescue our economy, we must be minus our army and government.

[@muhammadraza1919]

Dr.kaiser Bengali is an Economic expert.His analysis about economy of pakistan is very true.

[@muhammadusman-vc5re]

After this analysis we know the problems, their causes and solution. Now what is left to know and hurdle to solve for Authorities. Thank you, teacher.

[@snkumarkumar1859]

I fully agree with Qaisar Bengali Saheb about the need to cut defense and other public expenses. This kind of crisis requires action on many fronts with twin strategies for medium and short term and long term. Sacrifice from every one will be required but elite should be willing to share much higher burden than lower and middle class.

[@hussainishakeelshah9049]

True soul, brave and intellect in Pakistan...speaking very candidly and logically. ....

[@xanax3683]

when i find such unbiased podcast from pakistan it makes me surprised, keep up the work. 1 subscriber added

[@altafkumail904]

زبردست گفتگو حقیقت پر مبنی ایسے ہمدرد تجزیہ نگار اور ماہرین کی ضرورت ہے

[@ahsannazir2944]

Some one told many years ago that "These are duffers". - Asma Jhangir Just 3:30 minutes says it all. Lekin Kaiser Sahab January 1972 may honay wali nationalization ko jaan kr miss krgae. Jahan say barbadi k aghaz hua tha.

[@airliner791]

Genuinely responded to every question. SubhanAllah! My salam to Mr Bengali.

[@cyberdyn1]

💯% Right Analysis 4 sure ✅️✅️👍👍

[@rajmaheshwari444]

Kaiser saheb is a realist, a rarity in Pakistan. Unfortunately people like him are not in any serious decision making in Pakistan. If people like him are given real power and authority, change for the better can happen.

[@sadiqayaz3413]

Well done. Great show. A very informative. I will recommend this show to every Pakistani to watch. Keep bringing such guests into your show.

[@readingexperience9349]

Compared to shabar zaidi, Very sensible and serious response Zaidi sab bore naheen honay detay

[@syedirfanahmad9626]

I appreciate Raftar management for this very useful interview

[@sumonpaul8316]

Such a wonderful person Kaiser Bengali Sir !! Being IT guy, when I hear his speech, it seems, economics si the most simpliest subject and that is his karishma !!! Pakistan should be proud of having such a great teacher. My interest on economics grows by watching his videos only. Lots of love from Bangladesh !!!

[@hasnaincreationsworld9708]

I'm extremely impressed by True Reality... If we are not aligned ASAP, things will be going worst...

[@nowie4007]

Absolutely love dr. Kaiser sahab Thank you so much for this informative interview ❤❤❤

[@hasnainali2159]

MashaAllah very commendable podcast, very productive and informative. Kasir bangali is very veteran economist.

[@Yehaipakistan01]

Thank you for video , Salam to Prof sb.

[@hamidsultan9156]

Thanks you so much Dr. Kaiser Bengali Sb for such clear and straightforward analysis

[@iftikharalikhan4303]

Excellent analysis . Best suggestions and ideas to improve economy and bring stability. Thanks. Mr. Qaiser must be member of economic council and projects.

[@santoshkhillare3201]

Good going app acche logo ko bula rahe hai ...mai india se hu aur practical log muze bahot pasand hai❤❤❤

[@PalzerPalzer]

Your reactions to the expert's answers which were very alarming n eye opner were very Casual n Cold.

[@rashidparacha2618]

Excellent, Kaiser Bengali is Genius, he is an asset of Pakistan. I wish that who are running this country on borrowed money listen to this great Pakistani. Hats off to him. May Allah give him excellent health and a long life, we need such a man to serve the nation.

[@shamsshaikh4721]

Very nice analysis of Qaseer Bengali,I like it, please send this video to the relevant person's, department, establishment, President, MP, COAS, and to media house, All social media, thanks.

[@Wasimgr88]

Great discussion. Drsahab figured out real problems of economy.

[@taleembada5669]

Masha Allah I listen dr sb first time thanks to raftar team that they introduced him to me word Word is gem love ❤️ and respect

[@salmanshohab7388]

I have great respect for Mr. Qaiser Bengali. I have even studied his book, and I admire him greatly. I second his various opinions. I completely concur with the notion, we must produce manufacturer goods, but here, with great respect, I fail to comprehend his wisdom. I just want to ask a question. We are producing power at a very high price. For industry, we need power, and in order to establish comparative advantage, we need cheap power. Even if we reduce GST, can we compete in the international market?

[@MuhammadFaisal-jv9ef]

Great session. Dr Qaiser Bengali Sahab. Portraying the reality is not that easy here and you have done a remarkable job. You are a true asset of Pakistan.

[@Tahirkhan-zu6ou]

Love the way Doctor sab has described Logically and rationally the empathetic and sophisticated economic condition of pakistan.

[@nadeemjan6138]

Exceptionally Ture Specifications Mr. Kaiser Bengali Great Man

[@sheikhmairaj92]

It is truly eye opening....I feel very fortunate that I met Dr sahb and about to meet again