SC puts end to 'Bulldozer Justice' & India-China education gap in special two-in-one

[@ThePrintIndia]

Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/

[@debasischakraborty8252]

Please read carefully written order of court. You are agent of deep state for spread narrative against India. Do you think everyone is full ?

[@naveen2719]

if govt cares so much about justice, then they should introduce police reforms and accountability in the system

[@rejijai9120]

govt doesnt care about justice, only about exerting more control. They have infact tightened the IPC further

[@ReviewSmartTech]

In short .. basically Supreme Court confirmed a process to demolish unauthorized constructions, doesn’t help any unauthorized constructions in any way….. now you will see all unauthorized properties demolished very easily with no recourse as process is followed…. Remember how no one caught for doing encounters…..

[@kundanpowar5944]

Whether Yogi will heed to SC judgement or find another loophole to carry on with his brand of justice , only time will tell. But rest assured EC will never issue bulldozer as an election symbol to any party, ever.

[@nikumat]

This is celebrated because the judiciary just doesnt work. We see the SC , but to get anything out of the lower judiciary is nearly impossible. If the courts do their work on time this wont be needed. The helplessness of the common public fuels the support to instant justice.

[@dineshprabhu7874]

❤Two Comments Shekharji 1. While we hail this judgement generations will curse us for the impossibility of now demoliting an illegal structure - all politicians will use it to the max. Alternately the judgement should have focused on penalising Executive for demolition of structures that are legal 2. Lighter one - Anpadh movie has Mala Sinha and not Meena Kumari

[@2010anilshukla]

None of Yogi’s actions have been struck down by the judiciary and even here, it’s not against Yogi. He will follow the rules and continue doing what he doing what he does. Commiserations.

[@fiddlediddle11]

Has anyone gone to court against any of the demolitions?

[@reach2prasanna]

When was the last time you heard any of our political leaders speak about the need for breathable air, better roads and cleaner streets? Never.

[@pratiush1000]

Shekhar, thanks for not interrupting your colleague in this episode. Good episode!

[@amarndeepbamra3137]

WHERE ARE THE JUDGES WHEN WAKF BBOARD SAYS ALL VILLAGES BELONG TO WAKF WAKF CLAIMS ALL PROPERTY YOUR ARE MOHAMAD INBTHE GARB OF SHEKHSR GUPTA SAY SOMETHING ABOUT DICCTATORIAL ATTITUDE ABOUT WAKF BOARD MOHAMAD SHEKAR GUPTA

[@RahulBajaj-ov3hz]

He is an old time commie 😂

[@savithakl7577]

Likes of Shekhar, Rajdeep are very happy

[@manjulashanmugasundaram706]

Are judgments implemented now a days,?

[@deepakv21]

Bulldozer Justice…. This says it all ..while I’m against demolition of houses but then how you will deliver Justice… our courts has failed to deliver Justice. When will SC wake up on delivery of Justice?

[@diwakarsingh873]

23:12 second part starts

[@hariharakamalcharan5900]

Wow, great , now I am going to build a house on the road and ensure the law is on my side and atleast drag the case for 10 years , let it for rent , make bogus sale deed and sell to 10 people , defraud more gullible people untill the law proves and then take action, by then I will make a booty

[@sivudu69]

Go ahead. What's stopping you?

[@nv9991]

@@sivudu69 wow. An ordinary Indian citizen like you is encouraging him to commit an illegal act. What a moral degrade this nation has.

[@nilwa4190]

Go ahead and built it then.

[@balaji1826]

Don’t celebrate too early Sekhar, bulldozer will still go on

[@tapemaj]

@@balaji1826 ought to

[@xxyz2023]

Which is illegal

[@raviilapavuluri6072]

Some day it will be in your house. You should say this even then

[@amritinaction7890]

​@@raviilapavuluri6072if I would not be doing anything wrong to anyone it won't happen

[@sumeettanwar1608]

​@@xxyz2023read the judgment, it actually made it legal and in favor of Govt where they don't even have to go to court in most cases like for Govt land only private land like telengana is doing where people spent 80 lakh to make a house and have all the paper, only those got the protection not people who broke the law.

[@rajasecarane]

Thank you very much for talking about this judgement. I was disappointed yesterday when there was no coverage of that on your channel but I'm happy today having gotten a CTC episode on it 👍

[@ramachandrankannan274]

While I am all for following due process, the latest ruling appears to ensure no demolition is ever possible. This is incentivising encroacher and against the spirit of “rule of the law”

[@Mrashisharora]

Will Supreme Court pay for the damages against which Govt takes such actions. In last 75 years, they have 80000 + cases, have they done anything about it. They enjoy their salaries and vacations for themselves. They're not here for justice.

[@Vamsi_Ind]

GuptaJi.. you always root for less bureaucracy. I am amazed to see enjoying explaining the loooong bureaucratic process.😂😂

[@groupscontentandupdates5252]

In my opinion these type of judgements and opinions are helping hands to islamisation of Bharath. Thank you

[@arvindsingal4969]

Not Meena Kumari ji. It is Mala Sinha.

[@jagadishsharma5668]

Sekhar how do you justify when these very criminals whose properties are buldozed themselves create / build these properties by buldozing innocent citizen . We had accepted these action of the yogi govt because we believe .... in karma 'reap what you sow'

[@kailashnathganesan4659]

What about speed of clearing cases by courts? What about the 1000 holes in the law that is used by culprits to escape the law. Bulldozer action can never be justified, but I think this is just the symptom of the slow legal system which isn't always delivering fair justice.

[@SkyGlitchGalaxy]

I wish we had bulldozer justice in Ireland.

[@BlueJay-2k]

The minority deserves it, but you are the invaded minority in Ireland 🤡

[@arunhuddar]

While the punishment should befit the crime; there is an increasing feeling that criminals don’t care a hoot for law. There needs to be some ways whereby there is fear of law. Cases get dragged forever or there are so many loopholes or the likes of Sibal who can twist the law to suit the client

[@flora9069]

Most people don’t even know the laws of the country. How can they fear something they don’t even know. When has there ever been a moment to teach laws to cops let alone the general public.

[@sunilroyyuru8327]

Everybody celebrates bulldozer justice as long as it is not served to them. Excellent verdict from SC, as governments across political spectrum (ex: Congress Govt in Telangana in the name "Hydra",UP Govt etc) are resorting to this hooliganism in the name of justice.

[@BharatThatIsIndia]

Don't you think that courts are allowing these types of misadventures for 3-4 years and then SC is coming down on this? They must have acted faster bcz cases were filed much earlier. And what about our local courts and HC? Are the sitting tools for politicians who are in power?

[@Bruh-og8rb]

Bulldozing will continue, state has to give 14 say notice before bulldozing and videograph the entire process. Rest everything will go on as it has been.

[@BharatThatIsIndia]

@Bruh-og8rb We will see then what our SC is doing against it. If they will not take action against that state government then SC stature will reduce further.

[@ishankeshri9328]

​@@BharatThatIsIndiaAhir Youths should come on streets and stop this bulldozer justice. sadly even they voted for bjp in Haryana

[@BharatThatIsIndia]

@ishankeshri9328 And still u r jatiwadi chamcha

[@BharatThatIsIndia]

@@svrkprabhakar It means that those whe were doing this were goons and destroying people homes unlawfully.

[@rajshekhar1147]

Very sad.. without speeding up justice system, SC in its jealous wisdom stopped speedy justice n fear of law.

[@rajshekhar1147]

We want buldozer justice free from court's intervention like religious places act.

Demolition of illegal structures isnt for bulldozer justice though

[@mg.f.9023]

Today the world knows there is huge skill gap in emerging digital technologies like IoT & AI and skilled people in this area will bring a lot of money to India as compared to other fields. What does China do ? They Incentivise companies in AI skilling by giving them tax breaks for 10 years and also giving them monetary support .This attracts a lot of local companies into this field and competition improves quality of courses and people get skills cheap.

[@sadanandgote5544]

The fact is that for criminals, illegal construction is a small matter. Why criminals, even apparantly innocent citizens, businesmen are used to illegal constructions. The govt . can easily find out illegal constructions done by criminals and issue them notice of 15 days and then demolish.

[@ashishb]

No facts, only opinion.

[@xxyz2023]

It is in the research paper mentioned in this video

[@xxyz2023]

Go to Indian Govt's Indian Stats Institute and look for the research paper

[@xxyz2023]

Highly quality of facts

[@sabysachikar4439]

Shekhar Ji, the second part of your story is important and big overhaul and social engineering to adjust to present day requirement of rapid progress and modernisation is required. And what can be better than to compare with our neighbour. First part of the Bulldozer story, while theoretically all is required what our Hon.SC says but in day-to-day life it seems Bulldozer policy is effective to correct the course in a democracy. Because one cannot expect well behaved socity in a diverse and poorly educated mass like in India. Many thanks🎉

[@anubhaanushree536]

One important factor to consider is the Communist and Cultural revolution. These movements focused on the lower classes. in fac, many elite educational institutions were made redundant during these movements. Indian politics did not experience any similar push for greater inclusion.

[@SagarDhamane-s3s]

Excellent comparison between India and China education. Hopefully we will address this gap soon and correct our mistakes.

[@Zethuzzz]

The curriculum of most engineering colleges in the country is extremely outdated and not at all relevant to the demands of the current industry. This is something that needs to be fixed at the earliest. We have all these fancy bodies for higher education run by incompetent bureaucrats which have been the bane of this problem

[@vinm2010]

Degrees from bihar will never have takers

[@hemikovsky]

Send Yogi to Jail. All will end!

[@udaysahgal]

It seems you are deliberately prolonging the video. Do you earn extra money for making longer videos ?

[@sanchitbhardwaj4230]

I feel like a luddite asking this, but for the past few videos I cant seem to find the links to articles and judgements quoted in the videos. Can anyone help me?

[@tapemaj]

Shekhar Ji “anpadh “ starred Mala Sinha ! Not Meena Kumari … 😅

[@zurichkunst3615]

Serious journalism and rubbish ads do not work… Skipping it too!

[@sudhirnayak8086]

How can the court give authority to confiscate personal assets of an employee even if it’s a mistake. Isn’t this setting a new precedent. In its zealousness to cover every loophole, these strict rules will mean only one thing - no government employee will touch any unauthorized construction. While the almighty government will still find ways to do what it wants to do. In the end, it’s a lose lose decision.

[@mg.f.9023]

The Chinese must be shivering hearing of our bulldozer weapon.

[@talatkhan628]

150000 Muslim homes were demolished by governments illegally. Sadist enjoyed the game. A very sad affair😔

[@Dionysus-m7h]

150000 mullah squatters or land poachers got screwed you mean to say?!!Alhamdulillah...may 72 virgins work overtime!

[@nitinskadam]

Was those homes were legal????

[@soumaSR]

​@@nitinskadamuncountable numbers of buildings outside major cities never really follow all laws or protocols Hindu, Muslim, Sikh buildings all alike. Just visit any rural district and see for yourself...

That's not a justification though Islam is a threat ​@@soumaSR

[@margabandhuvenkates3770]

Bull dozer started by your favourite party MVA in Mumbai and later extended to treat real criminals living in unauthorised residences

[@amodjp]

1)Kindly upload seperate videos for different topics, viewers should have a choice 2) it would be great if you don't mention old Hindi movies thats ok in a pensioners club 3)Finally a brief conclusion that education in China was subsidised as compared to india was required, Our youth choose humanities education over medical or engineering due to the cost of education

Choice too all fields are equally important

[@jayaprakashkg7473]

It won't stop , only due process has to be followed

[@sivasakthisaravanan4850]

25:22 Even Tamil film music has an equivalent song. In the 80s Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra along with Maharashtra started self-financed engg colleges and rapidly expand professional education on a massive scale (downsides of this is a separate story). But eastern India, Bengal, Bihar, Odisha, continued with humanities until late 2000s. They are left behind in economic growth.

[@MistyMusings-n7x]

It would have been great if the episode could have been within 20 mins. Too long content. 😢

[@ajinkyashembekar]

Bull dozer is not the only demolition machine is there??

[@jw8752]

Good judgement indeed. Only wish that the time taken, very often, in the demolition of unauthorised construction and construction on encroached land in India is not more than a month or two and made ineligible from common tactics of planned delay and procrastinations.

[@v.hariharasubramoney7346]

All said and done, Bulldozer Justice , though unlawful, was the only way open to a stern ruler like Yogiji, to bring some sense of lawful State, from the totally anarchic State he inherited from successve Congress, BSP and Yadav Governments due to their promotion of Goonda raj. Normal lawful procedure could never bring the situation as of now. It WAS the need of the hour. It served the purpose and now we can try to do the same lawfully However, neither the Police not Judicial System here is ready to bring law's heavyhand in reasonable time. Police dept all over the country is corrupt to the core and subservient to the politicians. And the Law moves at snails pace So, one has to thank the Bulldozer that has given a reprieve to the ordinary citizens of UP, in particular.

[@aks23154]

Calling the big Delhi Riot as " Dhakka-MuKKI" ? How much more you will fall down Mr Gupta ? Don't rejoice much. The Bulldozer use is not banned. Only a guideline to be followed is laid. No one has right to encroach Public / Government land and sit pretty. You are an advocate of anarchy.

[@sureshpanchanathan1139]

Would be keen to see the education chart of USA based on the last chart. Please share if possible

[@TheFebruary10]

Does waqf act follows natural justice? Arbitrary action by private party?

[@nagappachinnannavar6653]

I am looking for some information from this judgement and how it can impact the legal and authorised properties within the buffer zone (water bodies) because of NGT rules. The property in question has all the approvals by major authorities from 2006, and construction happened in 2010. But NGT came much later and put them in buffer zones. People have put their hard-earned money into buying their dream house, and suddenly, one law or notification makes them into a buffer zone. It affects people both mentally and financially as they can't sell their properties at the market price. There should be clear guidelines for this kind of case, where there is no mistake of the house buyers as there was no such rule before. I hope this rule will put proper guidelines for this kind of legal and authorised property. When I say this, I am not against the environment and lake protection, considering the future generations. I completely support it. Once a house is built,.However, the Supreme Court can put proper guidelines, procedures and compensation measures in dealing with this kind of legal and authorised property. guidelines should be there even when the house is old and the resident wants to demolish and build it again, Approvals should be given or the government should acquire it if they really need it for environmental purposes with proper compensation measures.

[@sivasakthisaravanan4850]

Hitchhiker's Galaxy fans Like...

[@salilganu6152]

Comparing Indian education system with Chinese one reminds me of hype about certain states COVID control success (declaring victory) over others just after first wave. We'll see the 'outcome' as the time goes by. Let's say they are definitely good at self promotion for sure.

[@rogerIndianKing]

Skip to 6:15 for the real start!

[@mg.f.9023]

Law like in our Bollywood films always comes in late in the movie.

[@ABC-lf2kh]

I guess most common citizens like me do not read these judgements and base their opinions on narratives, half information given by media. But I did better this time and as per my limited understanding after reading it, in this particular judgment, the court seems to have taken a balanced approach. The most important provision is that this judgement "does not apply to the structures which are constructed on encroached land or which violate the pertinent laws". So you can see for yourselves what it actually means and what message it gives to the government of the day.....

[@Aditav8680]

Pls don't compare India chaina! It's like Comparing Apple with Cucumber

[@ajeetrayakar7582]

Well the Process can go Forever ?

[@Ophra-notfree]

When our judiciary or its pronounciations are beneficial to the rule of or constitutal governance?

[@pmm7268]

Social sciences & humanities is important, but not more than 10% of total academics should go to social sciences & humanity. Colleges & universities should not allocate more than 10% of seats. Exclusive social science institutions should not give admission to any student who could not have higer performance in education and students with low intelligence should be filtered out. Being an intellectual cannot be fools vocation.

Yes but more than one etc chance now eg the center is talking of boards twice a year , I have completed my ug in pol sci scored just 55.25 marks due to family issues and fights etc have enrolled for IGNOU ba economics etc and would go for du 3 yr llb as a dual degree my preparations are going fine i scored low in 12 th too till 11th I was fine i want a future I am 24 i want to make money etc too

Older people must be judged with metrics of their times I m enrolling in a second ba only coz I want a 60+ ug degree which I m sure i can manage in both llb and IGNOU ba economics my semester performances ,internships etc must be the judge I was enrolled in pg program for a while too and could secure internships in proper organisations

[@bimald1]

SC is trying to make life of future Hindus less traumatic . It knows this land will be Saria land. SC hopes muthalman will recall the good gesture and serve less trauma on Hindus.

[@maheshjambardi771]

LOL

[@VishalKhopkar1296]

Btw Israel also demolishes houses of Palestinian terrorists - and those house are not even unauthorised

[@soumaSR]

Jews eat beef and pork is forbidden in their holy book so how is that relevant to us people of Bharat? We are a free republic not a province of Israel.

[@speedbird109]

Anpadh started Mala Sinha Dharam phuttar, Shashikala, Nasir Hussain, Balraj Sahni.

[@mali3490]

Do Deewane shaher mein, raat mein ya dopeher mein. Aab o dana dudhte hain, ek ashiana dudhte hain!

[@butterchickenandnaan]

Judgement to bahana hai Gyan kya gan inhe bas batana hai

[@YashRaikantiwar]

SG takes too much time to explain song lyrics and quotes. Nobody cares. Focus more on substance sirrrrrr.

[@ashishb]

Pathetic journalism

[@avikmallya]

We don't want old song metaphors and also we don't want explanations, we are educated enough.

[@maheshjambardi771]

But we do need translations. Not all of us understand those old songs as we did not grow up learning Hindi. Just brief translations without explanation will be good enough.

[@thesecretsheriff]

🙏. Many including you inadvertently accord it some respect by calling it bulldozer justice. It was from the very beginning a state executed illegality and state sponsored anarchy. Nothing short of it. To in any way associate the word justice with it is a big mistake and going against one's own advocacy. Quote and unquote will not undo the error.

[@kalaichelvannadarajan5299]

👍👍👌👌👌💕

[@ayan_keepcalm]

Courts r becoming bunch of jokers

????? Your woke liberal ego can't ruin the lives of the people like that

[@ArkiSyiem-l3x]

𝕸𝖊𝖒 𝖎𝖘𝖑𝖆𝖒 𝖇𝖆𝖑𝖑𝖆 𝖙𝖆𝖓𝖌 𝖇𝖆 𝖐𝖘𝖊𝖒 𝕻𝖗𝖊𝖘𝖙𝖔𝖓 𝖑𝖍 𝖍𝖆𝖕

[@anupsinghkr]

Topic itself is so boring.. Don't want to watch... What supreme court said, you also know, state governments have way to navigate..... At least be little natural to intellect and make some insight full episode......

[@veryCreativeName0001-zv1ir]

most of the things the government does is boring , if you want "exciting" things watch bollywood if your government is doing boring things it's doing the right thing

[@BlueJay-2k]

You want strip show here?😂

[@IndianArma]

Average republicTV viewer

[@JiyoDilSe-qi9ut]

❤Two Comments Shekharji 1. While we hail this judgement generations will curse us for the impossibility of now demoliting an illegal structure - all politicians will use it to the max. Alternately the judgement should have focused on penalising Executive for demolition of structures that are legal 2. Lighter one - Anpadh movie has Mala Sinha and not Meena Kumari