What does Modi’s cooperative & competitive federalism mean & why it’s becoming combative

[@ThePrintIndia]

Good journalism needs support from smart people like you. Subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/

[@KunalKrishna]

an expert from my Pol Sci notes - topic : Federalism in India "A/t Prof MP Singh, there is no center-state dispute in India. It is party to party dispute. Dispute does not arise when same party is in power at union and state" So true...

I fully agree with what you have said. Opposition to interstate development projects is simply a ploy by frustrated political parties. People will see through their sinister games & they will be defeated again as in Karnataka. Erstwhile Congress Govts of MP & Maharashtra had opposed Narmada dam & had even approached Supreme Court with partial success but the Congress lost power in the two states and Sardar Sarovar Project was successfully completed. Because of access to Internet (India has the largest Internet Savvy population in the world with unrestricted Internet access), the monopoly of the perverted, planted or politically-motivated media persons has ended and people eventually come to know what is the truth, what is good for the country & why it is not happening.

[@dilipmundhada5875]

I fully agree.

[@nikhilchaubey7]

Absolutely right.

[@subbaraotanguturu9271]

100% correct,sir. They deliberately do to shift blame on centre. It's especially true about regional parties. Mamta is number one in it. Stalin, KCR also are the same.

[@saxwiz]

Invaluable perception. Thanks for sharing

[@rishabhjain1997]

I like the hand gestures, but pleas try to keep your hands off the microphone

[@kushdesai2419]

Shekar sir is so into the process that he forgets he actually has a mic on. Very appreciable and exemplary. But please take care that you don't touch it sir. It hampers the audio quality.

[@savitashankar8575]

Humility and ability to take everyone along - now these are alien words to Modi and Amit Shah combine. This is asking too much..

[@almightyguy3987]

what humility and what ability?? Since the day one of his tenure every CM is targeting him. Humility and ability to take even a person along has disappeared from whole spectrum of Indian politics.

[@noufal7507]

You are a veteran at this sir.... It's a delight hearing you break down such complex situations keeping it's nuances intact.... Thank you

[@rishav4343]

Warning to headphone users 6:52

[@Lokendrasingh-gq4xp]

Thank you

[@jayanrajpurohit4711]

The hero we need 🙌

[@balajialagurajan243]

Thanks

[@RAJ-oi4ob]

🙏

[@N12SR48SLC]

😂😂😂disaster

[@deepanshugupta7552]

Sir please make one video about "Make in India". What is the progress, its limitations, expectations etc..

[@YashKansalx]

Deepanshu Gupta the problem is states Now Maharashtra has congress so no new development Companies invest in states with overlap of power India needs to cut down workers laws you can’t fire workers in India And environment you can’t cut any tree

[@sarath8317]

Are u an upsc aspirant?😂😂

[@dr.saurabhadhao7030]

Checkout yesterday's The Hindu.. There is elaborate explanations of Make in India

[@kokuyocamlin07]

Just imagine this political structure want to compete with China.

[@RahulKumar-ng2gh]

its a dream, we are gonna stuck in the middle-income trap, As somebody said it "India is always a country of unfulfilled promises"

[@saikrishnajalagam9787]

Just imagine same Chinese government collapsing to collapsing Indian democratic government.

[@robinsingh1567]

@@RahulKumar-ng2gh middle income trap symptoms..kya h..pata h..bol dena se nhi hota dost...

[@RahulKumar-ng2gh]

@@robinsingh1567 Kisi k ek line se turant judge Kar Lena, kis education me sikhaya jaata h

[@black__monk400]

@@RahulKumar-ng2gh , you are right. We see headed to middle income trap. Under Modi rule, the economy is in tailspin and may never recovers as highest GDP growth nation. BJP has damage the economy

[@babuni5299]

##I love the line Politics is like a Living being... That’s why we watch you Sekhar Gupta...You don’t make that comment unless you attain certain level of political Science Maturity.

[@lifeasislife]

[1] Indian Politics has a history of undoing what previous govt's did... first. Second, as of now, the only goal of the opposition is to Undo Modi and all his doings. The opposition does not want to compete by over-doing Modi, which would be true competitive ideal. If Modi (or in his term) a railway line is laid, the opposition wants to melt and use the iron... Most often your program fails to highlight these issues. The central government can bring investment, but its the state which has to absorb that. [2] In earlier times, funds to states depended on the centre-state relation, today its more transparent and merit based. So, its much easier for states to compete on development, while centre concentrates on Foreign Issues etc. but most states are constant attention mongers with bickering ideas of low level politics. [3] Regional parties, have no vision as it seems. They still see vote back with handouts, caste etc. What are states doing for job creation ? Closing down Foxconn ?

[@jyothikumar2926]

.Modis policy is to destroy this country

[@Anmol_Thakur888]

the strength of AAP wind in delhi is so much, i dont see any other party coming back to power in the capital... i am with bjp thou.. but the tangible facilities provided by kejriwal, i think will have a tremendous effect on coming elections...

[@rahulray9983]

BJP-AAP would get 35-35 seats

[@Anmol_Thakur888]

@@rahulray9983 nahi yr bhai, sab delhi wale AAP AAP bol rahe hain....

[@hemanshubangera5121]

Kejriwal or who?

[@nagraj2k1]

60 seats to AAP

[@vicky1447]

India is not a federation of states it’s a nation divided into states for administrative purposes.

[@vicky1447]

Amrendra Ray union and federation are two different things.

[@Ajitkumar_06]

Thanks for #CTC... Its very much political in nature than federal in true sense.......

[@KM-ff2gm]

The fact that we are contemplating on issues related to development, Nationalism and global competitiveness says a lot about the contribution of BJP in last 6 years. From 2004-14 we only witnessed government of scandals and china's growth.

[@theAraAra]

Not a supporter of Congress, but kind of ironic that you're saying that today when China's growth was 6.1% and India's was 4.5%

[@KM-ff2gm]

@@theAraAra India's growth rate has been dipped to 4.5% even during UPA from 2010-14. So I think demonetisation was a big fiasco, nonetheless it was a good attempt and displayed strong guts of BJP. Other countries with 1.3 billion people would have slipped into anarchy with that sort of decision. Second, Modi has tried to create competitive federalism while he was CM in Gujarat. Also, we should never compare China and India, two completely different political system. In China, they would have never had issues like Aarey Dairy Land or Canned Bullet Train project. People have minimum say in things...It's all about what Xi wants. If we do that in India...we tagged as Nazi.

[@allesgut7071]

Modi is a Man of WORDS and NOT Actions

[@prasadpawar7027]

Please do a complete episode on mumbai metro, bullet train and mumbai pune hyperloop. Even though hyperloop doesn't need state of Maharashtra to raise any money Ajit Pawar is saying that it is not going to happen and they just transferred Mumbai metro MD. 🙏

[@SiddharthBadkul]

Please share your views on whether good politicians are also good adminstrators and vice versa.

[@siimba0chris1]

is it creepy that i miss thee green kurtha sir worn or which is the image of CTC :P

[@pradhyudh]

I love it when he wears kurta

[@katiesethna]

It is very cold there! Lol

[@nkiyer123]

None of the political parties want India developed but only their fiefdom. The trouble of CAA began with the left and the Congress instigating the student's to protest and once things went out of control slowly edged out and put it on the police for violence eruption. Now every state becomes anti centre and oppose whatever the govt wants to do. Shear conveniently avoids this mention but puts the onus on Modi Shah. On Maharashtra he just sidelines issues and say we all know etc. This dialogue is very partisan.

[@digitalavatar5699]

The Kerala government is spending crores of public money to give advertisements against CAA and same time many flood victims of Kerala are in camps and didn't get any help. Paranari Vijayan is redirecting public money for his party's political milage

[@Killer_push]

If this is precautionary then i loved it But if The writer belives this as reality then i am suspicious of the observations

[@abhijitmore3729]

So happy that my comments on appearance made improvement 🤘👍

[@PRASADSHKL2007]

Politics have changed, stalling tactics won't work anymore. It is true cooperation and trust needed to be built by center as muchas state governments must need to reciprocate and take initiative as well if they want their states to prosper and not only keep the power or not interested in showing who is the boss. Shekhar sir the way you were explaining projects by centers plan to do were looking like you were discussing about multi nation project and not intranational projects.

[@subbaraotanguturu9271]

He is one of the anti Modi brigades. He becomes Sanghi if he by mistake supports Modi and his policies. It's dunzeon. Once become part of Naxalites, underworld and criminal gang no escape from it. Sanghi or anti sanghi. No middle course for it.

[@sajaljain8843]

@shekargupta please do an episode on the reluctance of supreme court on this matter of utmost importance. Also, give your view on how this all is going to play out in the SC.

[@YashKansalx]

Sajal Jain see SC can’t and won’t oppose it Because equality among equality

[@chaiaurbunmaska]

guys lets poll here and ask shekar sir to please make an episode on afzal guru

[@DineshKVohraNewsTime]

WHEN DID LAST TIME MR MODI HAD A CMs MEETING IN LAST 6 YEARS..IT SHOWS HOW MODI WORKS,,,NEVER HAVE A CM MEET/

[@rahulray9983]

NITI AAYOG meetings always invites all the CMs

[@almightyguy3987]

Actually all the CM are so hell bent to show their disagreements with PM, that they don't meet PM untill necessary. Jagan Reddy went Delhi and met PM. While visiting kolkata, PM met Mamta Banerjee. It's the CMs who don't want to meet him

[@YashKansalx]

Guykage true

[@NidzShah-ps6kr]

@@almightyguy3987 Obviously! The CMs have no faith in him. Modi-Shah make all sorts of gathbandhans whenever they need them, get overconfident - like they did in Maharashtra - and leave them high and dry. In MHT that completely backfired. The CMs have good reasons to be suspect. I'm not surprised at all.

[@almightyguy3987]

@@NidzShah-ps6kr In Maharashtra it's shivsena which acted like arrogants. We all know that in a coalition government party getting more seats chose one of their own as CM. BJP fought election with fadanvis for CM face. It got almost double seat than shivsena. A Coalition is a team game. If Kohli scores a century but others can't get enough runs to win the match, we don't say that because of Kohli only we lost. BJP- Shivsena gathbandhan wasn't made just because BJP needed it. It was a very long term gathbandhan, based on their ideological backgrounds. It's shivsena which left BJP high and dry because of arrogance

[@patillaxman6247]

It's just nice to keep listening you sir

[@gopalphadnis]

Who loses at the end of the day.. you seem to suggest that , Modi is doing this for his benefit. If opposition thinks by harming nation interest is justified to punish BJP.. and you seem to support such a thing even though you do not say it equal number of words.. that's pity state of affairs of this nation and people of India. You should make a program and suggest that come whatsoever, whoever has started the project, it should not be stopped. Where is Investor confidence otherwise

[@ameyakarnad9328]

@ThePrint I have a question. On Citizenship, Do states have powers to create something like Sanctuary Cities that are in the US and other developed countries ?? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanctuary_city

[@glamwithjyoti4254]

One more reason why we shouldn't select Congress at state level too, they will stall development project for their benefits

[@sanjaydongre]

nice of you shekhar ji , thanks

[@tonymontana09876]

Looking Sharp Shekar ji. 👍

[@indianfirst8172]

There is no point of using Art 131 in this case. Art 131 can be used when Centre undermine the rights of States. Citizenship is completely Central Govt's power. Opposition parties only want to make a wound out of scratches done by protest against CAA. (Everyone has right to peaceful protest) Indian voters has become very smart in last decade. They know who is good for PM post & who is for CM. But, our political parties are still with decades old mindset & considering voters stupid.... BJP lost Maharashtra & Jharkhand and majority in Harayana after abrogation of Art 370. Jharkhand after Ayodhya issue. Voters understand everything.... :D

[@YashKansalx]

Felt like national interest

[@neilbhatt7096]

All parties are playing communal politics over CAA except BJP.

[@bodigavikas576]

@theprint What was the episode in which Shekar Gupta explained abt india helping Tajiks to fight Al Qaeda .. Please refer the link

[@kaisermasood2106]

Mr Modi and Mr. Shah can show their 'seena', their charishma, their arrogance, thier conviction, thier emotion but two things they cannot show are inclusivity and humility - they perceive it as weaknesses. Thats their model - my way or the highway. Highway - they're travelling fast there.

[@arunrao487]

Extremely misleading piece by Shekhar Gupta. The entire premise that everybody agreeing with each other and the state and the centre being on the same page is higher on the hierarchy of the virtuous cycle is ridiculous. When the state and the centre agree on everything as has been the case with years of Congress rule, the only loser is the common man. I am really thrilled that there is friction between the state and the centre. This is what true federalism is and not the other crap that Shekhar spoke about. If both state and centre sing kumbaya, then all you have left is the sad state of India that we now saw till 1992.

[@x3nn0n]

This is not cut the clutter. I think it should be labelled #National Interest in my humble opinion.

[@PrathameshMone]

Bullet Train : New projects do NOT happen without filling coffers of a dynasty.

[@KoshyGeorge]

Interlinking rivers will be an ecological disaster.

[@harir6316]

Maybe you don't know how interlinking is done. It is not done creating canals. Notice the word linking the rivers which flow in the same direction.

[@satyanandapatel]

are you against bullet train?

[@mdi8164]

@@newsupdates3622 Lmao, calm down

[@theAraAra]

He's against the central govt acting like a feudal zamindar, not bullet trains

[@mohammedjalali5941]

States controlled by opposition are more interested to cooperate with Pakistan and china 😁😁😁....states are also unhappy with rafale deal got done, article 370 and ram mandir....let them cry as much as possible .....it doesn't matter

[@nishant_ketu]

Modi and shah must go

[@praneet2468]

You may try again 4 years to go ;)

[@satyajitchattopadhyayyt]

Why?

[@savithakl7577]

Karnataka and TN contribute to more taxes for north to get doles

[@vishalreddy6144]

2019 Tamil Nadu got highest funds from centre.

[@arihantdev1630]

@@vishalreddy6144 lie! Show the evidence

[@rajashashankgutta4334]

And Ambani contributes to more taxes for the government than you and me.

[@savithakl7577]

@@rajashashankgutta4334 so he is allowed to get away with attempted murder of Nusli Walia, given more corporate loans and also monopoly in govt contracts

[@AshokSingh-gl1jc]

All promises have become "Jumlas", no elaboration needed. In the context of Centre-State relationships, it is all right to say "co-operative federalism", and do the opposite. Co-operation, ipso facto, denotes a 2-way street, but this Govt believes it is either "my way" added with "or else". There is no dialog with the opposition, no all party meetings, nothing to to promote healthy parliamentary or democratic traditions. People like Piloo Modi, JP, etal, opposed the Govt of their days, but never denigrated any one personally. The present BJP (totally unlike ABV's BJP), believes more in trolling, calling people derogatory names (Pappu), labeling genuine protestors as "gangs", sends police to beat students in libraries, stops the same police from stopping goons on rampage, etc, etc. Most opinion makers and the common people think that independence of institutions are in shambles. It is the center which is always in a combative mode; they forget either that they are not in Opposition, or that India is or can ever be the Fourth Reich of Aryan/Hindutva supremacy

[@madhukadiri6132]

No need to confront, just have some logical, conclusive, meaningful debate that is broadcasted to the citizens of India.That's it, you would end-up with two answers - YES & NO. Majority-YES is to be recognised by all sides. :)

[@narayanans2636]

Like the 3 Cs Cooperative, Competitive and Combative. Can use in professional life also

[@justicefiles4544]

. I bought that the CAA was the law, the states are breaking the law.

[@gauravsaini1712]

Sir, can you do a video on the progress of BHARATMALA PROJECT ?

[@balajialagurajan243]

I had blue tooth headphones while shaving and listening Shekar sir. I felt like ENT SURGEON shoving his equipment inside my ears. Perhaps a shout out from Shekarji will only heal me. (Pouting lips)...

[@pankajmadhurSharma]

i watch him in 1.5X..

[@prashanttiwari5686]

Everyone does

[@RaviSingh-ur3gd]

Spot on ..... Modi needs to concentrate on the basics and get the RSS of his back.... Or he's finished

[@deepakgoyal483]

Ravi Singh bhai 2029 se Pehle Modi ko koi nahi hata skta 👈trust me 👍

[@hemanshubangera5121]

@@deepakgoyal483 Aur hataa diya toh bohat roega na 😅

[@kamalchauhan5470]

@@deepakgoyal4832029 k baad inka basp amit Shah or 2039 k baad yogi ji

[@theace691]

@@deepakgoyal483 Poor economic polices have beaten more powerful leaders then Modi. When people go hungry and without jobs, they forget about religion and start to see the reality

[@shivamraj2649]

I don't under why cong is against river inter link project

[@uzochiokeke4328]

River link = better crop for farmers = more money for farmers = no more loan waiver politics

[@TheLowsofSolipsism]

@Uzochi Okeke I'm not against river link, I think its a great idea but needs to be done modestly. If you research it, firstly every man-made change of geography will have certain repercussions. We have to way in wether the pros out way the cons. As an opposing argument, if we link rivers that are further away, you can reduce the force of the river. This in turn reduces the width of the rivers and at some point, it will just be too thin. Also reducing the width of the river also means they are more susceptible to drought and also reduce the area on either side of the river which are arable land. Dams are controllable, you can completely open the dams flow, if they’re willing to invest far more into able to controlling the river-link would be much preferable.

[@abhishekjoshi4648]

@@TheLowsofSolipsism In that case we should not build dams either. All the river grid projects are build to move excess water to drought areas. This is done when the water just flows to ocean especially perennial rivers.

[@TheLowsofSolipsism]

@Abhishek Joshi Please read my first paragraph before jumping to conclusions on the second one.

[@sabyasachiupadhyay980]

"Maharashtra is run by you-know-who" ;)

[@han-main-bhibhakt-hun-to187]

Aren't we union of states as federation? And not pure federation like US? Then what states can do against except appeal to supreme court?

[@babuvishy]

Think shekhar makes a two classical mistakes - (1) confusing between centre/state and partisan politics. Here there is no problem with federalism. What needs correction is the use of federalism as a negotiation tool by state. ( 2) very conveniently, shelhar puts the onus of 'earning' trust of state on the centre. This is dangerous. This is akin stating parents need to earn trust of their child. Bizzaire indeed

[@sameerchilmattur2338]

No competition. South feeds North.

[@tentfood9781]

Reserch on today’s vedio is not done it’s all common sense plz work hard.

[@IMTheOneGuy118]

Biased and skewed analysis. All those states you mentioned till recent were all with bjp , so don't give cooperation bs . Now we will see where these projects go.

[@dilipmundhada5875]

Best is to have state and central elections together. Then they will not fight for five years

[@udayhotshot]

People who are so bothered about India Economy... please pay your taxes and make your family and friends to pay there taxes then question about economy ... Im sure no one post's about economy. Acting so much about economy ... India survived when there is no economy after independence. So stop crying and start paying taxes and purchase properties without black money.

[@0609Bhuwan]

Please do not distort the constitutional construct - India is NOT a federation of states [ like the USA ] India is a Union of states. Clearly evident in art.356 where the central executive can dismiss the elected state government or change the borders of a state.. [ unlike the USA] Having fully lost power in the parliament the Congress and the left parties have now taken the battle to the states defying the center on laws passed by the parliament. This is a very dangerous route as this can/ will become a precedent for political opposition in the future where the constitutional framework on center state relations will be made redundant... What if Tamil Nadu decides tomorrow that they want to raise their own army and go to War with Srilanka ??

[@gopalsamantaa]

Sir your explanation is very practical and very bad for our country. If upa come to power and they will face same problem which will make our country in worst and worst...

[@sethumithran73]

Hey Shekhar, understand that you have to dance while talking, also can understand you need to hold a paper.. but why rub the paper on the microphone? Quite annoying...

[@10Fountainhead]

Shekhar jee - EK Audio Engineer hire karo... Lata Mangeshkar agar kharab mice par gaaye, toh baat nahin banti nah?

[@drdeepakthakker6749]

Need of the hour is inclusive leadership who can cut across partylines i.e vajpayeeji and pv narsimharao.

[@chaiaurbunmaska]

i challenge you the declutter afzal guru mystery :) i m certain no one not even a journalist of your stature can declutter this.

[@swapniln8904]

Problem is BJP is not able to forecast or guage future based on present parameters. They see short future and derive most of it for their benefit. They have nothing to do with good future of India.

[@Leo-wp4tn]

Please all of you see the episode on section 131 in rajya Sabha tv❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@PrathameshMone]

Center should dismiss such governments.

[@theultimateshield5133]

Sir could you explain more why did our founders included Article 356??

[@subbaraotanguturu9271]

To nail erring states. Even Nehru used it. But only Modi becomes dictator not Nehru even they he not used when badly needed against WB, Kerala and MVA, Indira. On CAA, Farm laws also he feared to act fearing to be called dictator that cost lives, properties also.

[@AbhishekSingh-oh3gi]

You said aborgation of federal structure, and talked about immune system of politics. It isn't like that Mr. Shekhar, it was people of different state whole chossed BjP. All we can say that during bjp wining phase; others shop was closed and they became nothing but a mere spectator. Now they got something to start cooking their food so they're going against whatever it comes from center. Be remember that India is Union of federal states in which center government enjoys more power than state. Not denying state has it's own power but something like citizenship solely falls under union government, so no one can deny this. These parties knows everything but still trying to nudge the union government in this which is to appease their vote bank..that look we tried our best. Also, you said something about new indian voter, you should remember they also voted in those years which you said was abrogation of federal structure happened. Now, youth of our country want and strong government, who has spine to stand like abrogation of 370. Those earlier coalition government intention was that which implementation suits their vote bank, that's why A370 was their, also everyone knows about wrong practice of triple talak but no one opposes as it doesn't suit their for their vote bank for appeasement. #Chameleon

[@indianfirst8172]

Yes agreed, there is no point of using Art 131 in this case. Art 131 can be used when Centre undermine the rights of States. Citizenship is completely Central Govt's power. Opposition parties only want to make a wound out of scratches done by protest against CAA. (Everyone has right to peaceful protest) Indian voters has become very smart in last decade. They know who is good for PM post & who is for CM. But, our political parties are still with decades old mindset & considering voters stupid.... BJP lost Maharashtra & Jharkhand and majority in Harayana after abrogation of Art 370. Jharkhand after Ayodhya issue. Voters understand everything.... :D

[@shenanigans4177]

Yeah, such a strong govt that it took 6yrs to table labour reforms, don't have any guts to touch the taxation system, no roadmap for future, no change in the defense policy, no enthusiasm for improvement in transportation, like allowing private players in railways. All the things you mentioned are good to hear but doesn't do shit to change your life for good.

[@sharadchandakacherla8268]

Road blocks shall come. Leadership must be Focused. They must earn the states trust, if they want to stay true to the party's ideology, nations development above any personal ego.

[@pankaj4u4]

you r the only leftist who tries to fight using logic. So its always funny to hear u. Keep up the good work :)

[@yusuf.k.m]

Those words have very little meaning any more. But to nitpicky, Shekhar Gupta is not close to a leftist. On the economic issues he's quite right wing capitalist(by Indian Standards). On social issues, he's a Liberal which in this regime I guess means leftist.

[@pankaj4u4]

@@yusuf.k.m I dint want to use the cliche sounding anti-national so said leftist. Whatever else u said is correct

[@NikhilYadav-mk4xl]

Lol you want us to thank you that you used leftist instead of anti national? Get out of the well man. Understand that there are going to be people of different views, people who you run to call anti national are in their mind standing for the country just as you are in your mind.

[@yusuf.k.m]

@@pankaj4u4 Ah right :) Yes that is better 😂

[@pankaj4u4]

@@NikhilYadav-mk4xl which thankyou??? And thanks for respecting a different view with your kind words.

[@SM-pr4gk]

Dude , u r saying as if mva came up in maha , now metro , sea link etc work will stop there. Previously work used to happen , its just tht work will happen in a consultative manner. And chhattisgarh is going after NIA after it was amendment. You should talk abt the environment ministry give nod to oil exploratory companies without taking environmental clearance.

[@punithkumar511]

even the mighty ussr got fragmented into diffrent countries i hope even india gets divided into many countries, tired of feeding the bemaru north indian states, i hope some day tectonic activity takes place and entire south india gets separated and settles somewere near central pacific.

[@expectopatronum9357]

Don't want India to get fragmented. Hope we can all live together but something needs to be done seriously about the power imbalance between the Hindi heartland states n others. Up, Raj, Bihar, mp seems absolutely disinterested ( or maybe it's intentional) to control their population. Ther fertility rates r way about he nation avg or replacement levels and in any case higher than the east / NE and south states. They will keeps adding mps year after year n sucking up resources at the cost of others and at the same time political power will lie with them as number of representatives from rest of India stal or decrease while their population n mp both keep increasing manifold.

[@nagraj2k1]

When Lok sabha review is done in 2025 states that have done well will lose more LS seats and bimaru s****** even more

[@tarunjain1537]

CMs reach out to modi govt only when they want extra funds for their populist schemes...

[@azzam687]

Assholes what do you mean extra fund does its their own income which central shows its power and prefer to give huge share where they have their own govern..... As if cenre earns for whole India...... In new gst they take the whole amount and distribute it..... Pade likhne ganwar wali baate mat kiya karo..... Agar share wise dekhoge to north States ko bilkul v nai milna chaiye southern States give 57% income to centre through taxes

[@azzam687]

And up who earns minimum and gets max share... Will you like when you work more and get paid less but as a federal demo tarif country we tend to distribute our resources but dnt ever think that central is doing some kind of favour to some one...

[@dilipmundhada5875]

I think your analysis is flawed and favours fragmented opposition. You are emphasizing Maharashtra as a defeat of BJP which is not really. Secondly MP and Rajsthan are more of anti incumbency. Chattisgarh yes was a real defeat.

[@dev.0122]

Sir the way i see it after watching this CTC.. state govts. just look like obstructing all the development work done by Union govt. whereas no state govt is even concerned about infrastructure and is only concerned with political mileage they get from CAA and NRC.. now days no govt. talk about the infrastructure only about social issues.. i dont agree with BJP in many things but at least they worked on infrastructure as you yourself had said in an earlier CTC.. p.s. please make a CTC on Russian constitutional amendment.

[@askformrs]

Sorry Shekar. This is not a federalism issue but of cheap politics. Look at list of people who are opposing and their background

[@BG-nk4fo]

2:50 Which state has got 5 IITs?

[@satyanandapatel]

states can only block means negative role not pro-people.

[@paulgladstoneboonpushparaj9420]

Paper on mic was hilarious

[@sagarsansare572]

This just reminds how fucked up Indian federalism is... God help India

[@saifkashmiri2981]

gupta is so happy that all development projects will be stopped by local, mainly congress govts

[@pratikbansuri]

The logic of this episode is false at its basic level. Its just politics. The CAA does not violate article 14 in any way. Firstly, right to equality before law applies to citizens only. Also, there is a reasonable restrictions clause. If it had not been so, I'll go and file a case against all forms of reservation as it violates my fundamental right to be treated equal before all law. But the SC has interpreted it many times as equality of equals. Therefore, there is a positive discrimination for the long oppressed sections of our society in form of reservations which does not violate article 14.

[@kapilughade164]

Why Congress has a philosophy for not supporting the river link... Plzz make a vedio or say answer 💯💐

[@aagantuk7370]

6:54 bhookamp

[@deshaurduniya]

Kuch bhi 😆😆😆

[@vijendranpragasam8285]

Very incomplete analysis and assessment. Donot blame the centre for passing CAA, CAA is not discriminatory to any Indian citizen. blame the state governments for trying to stall National projects like linking of rivers and bullet train project.

[@subbaraotanguturu9271]

In fact by accusing Modi a dictator opposition tamed him not to act firmly during CAA agitation, Farm laws agitation, MVA govt during Arab's arrest, on WB despite so much violence, Kerala despite so much gold smuggling, corruption in which CM's name cropped up. If he acted decisively not awaiting supreme court approval and imposed 144 section and made a few strategic arrests CAA riots could have been avoided. It's the same with farm laws arrests. It's true with PFI. The riots happened in the name of blasphemy avoided. In the name of federal rights every state doing what ever it wants as centre is helpless to interfere. If HC of that states favour or ignore as it can't enforce any thing,it's a country in itself, sir. It's true of WB , Kerala and even AP also where who ever questions it arrested, harassed and a few died during covid. MVA was any way was different where it arrested Republic staff on no case. All the states are bankrupted as centre is helpless. Due to this they are not able repair roads let alone invest in development. It's regional parties under Mamta, Stalin, KCR and Jagan etc are dictators not Modi.

[@PrathameshMone]

Work together = work to make money for existing dynasty or new dynasty.

[@swamykatragadda8661]

please speek and explain what is FRDI &FSDR. why modi government want the change.

[@koshuralliance8649]

States r behaving unconstitutionally. Citizenship is a central subject and they attract 356 article of dismissal

[@testmail783e]

Arr you taking hints from insight ias mains 2020 program??😁😁

[@mohittomar6713]

Kitna bhi Randi rona kar lo aaye ga to 24 main bhi Modi hi

[@xhitiz22]

Prr krr kchh naa paega

[@aagantuk7370]

Accha bhai

[@mohittomar6713]

@@xhitiz22 tu mat bol tu sulfa maar or mast reh

[@daneilpatro2776]

Congrats to quint Did print won any awards?

[@hemanshubangera5121]

😅 Ab aaya ooth pahaad ke niche 😂 Aap Chronology samajhiye Mota-bhai.

[@amitabhishek7089]

Central government can not show humanity on CAA gov have an upper hand constitunally so why to bend back.