Only 33% joint secretaries belong to IAS- How the service’s dominance has eroded under Modi govt

[@olah22]

MODERN IAS IPS ARE SOCIAL MEDIA INFLUENCER..

[@PhysicsIsGreat]

😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@PhysicsIsGreat]

Grand entry of IAS😅😅😅😅

[@theedguy3937]

Royal entry 😂😂

[@dobariyanaitikdineshbhai6832]

They also dance with Sunny Leone in a music video

[@PraveenKumar-jx4hv]

Unki job jayegi tho social media pe he ayenge

[@callofgamer4940]

Most IAS of current generation are full time influencers, part time IAS.

[@dragonbane44]

Very poor take by someone who has not worked in administrative line.

[@ashr55]

& most of them are completely involved in corruption

[@rdj127]

​@@dragonbane44 so always have to have a take why person has to be in rhe service , it is a known fact they are influencer now a days over glorificati9n just by coacahing mafia for money printing machine

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@rdj127 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS' House 11)Ex-NOIDA chief IAS questioned by ED for properties worth crores 12)IAS suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam

[@pxnishant]

They're free to make the choice to become an influencer. All Indian citizens are free to make that choice. That is no reason to criticize them, and it does not imply that they will not be doing their job as a civil servant properly. Also, after working so hard (during prep) and serving tirelessly during elections, situations of stress, and even on normal days - they deserve fame much more than the actors and actresses you fanboy over.

[@AlokKumar-sr3cq]

Civil services is overrated profession by media and universities professors coaching nexus..

[@sachinmishra6147]

Very true

[@hishighnessab5540]

A step in the right direction by modi govt. These IAS guys are shining examples of "Maximal Authority With Minimal Responsibility". Down with such feudal setups!!

[@PhysicsIsGreat]

They are public servant they shouldn't think themselves king like British India

[@AlokKumar-sr3cq]

@@PhysicsIsGreat govt has vested them so much authority to interfere in every sphere of govt working and public life

[@ladusingh2141]

only chaddis and half pants matter. This is leading to a huge crisis. It is already playing out badly

[@electrophorouselectrica4601]

Technical departments which require professionals do not require IAS. We need knowledge and specialist in these fields. ❤

[@ArawnOfAnnwn]

Watch the vid - this isn't about specialists. They're shuffling around babus into agencies that don't match their domains at all. The only difference is that the babus being favored now are fully loyal to the centre rather than also work at the state level.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@ArawnOfAnnwn That aside Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS' House 11)Ex-NOIDA chief IAS questioned by ED for properties worth crores 12)IAS suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam

[@KUMAR-bq4xn]

@@ArawnOfAnnwn Yes instead of shuffling, we must discontinue IAS and bring in specialist who have worked 15-20 years in that domain. They are the ones who can bring change to India

[@RealWorldCitizen]

IAS are also recruited from techinal fields

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@ There is a difference between being a practising engineer and having an engineering degree

[@manishanand420]

This is good reforms, we need to get rid off of old bureaucracy which was completely indulged into corruption but no work

[@user-ghtvkisswc34560O]

Abi 10 sal m chaand pr pahuch gye ha aur corruption to dur dur tk bhi nhi hai

[@bharatrai3978]

This is because of involvement politics in bureaucracy .

[@bharatbahte1496]

ⁿ​@@user-ghtvkisswc34560O

[@viratsinghkshatriya9158]

I'll give you an example.Sambit patra,mbbs and a full time politician became MD of ONGC,how is he more qualified bro compared to an IAS officer. It's simply political appointment.This is no reform.

[@quizzzz377]

​@@viratsinghkshatriya9158Maybe because he is a politician dude and Doctor by degree. I would say a doctor is ten times more qualified than IAS. A doctor can do administrative work but IAS can't do sugeries right.

[@Bittu11827]

Madam Now No IAS wants to work as JS with GOI . REASON IS High work load and 0 under the table earning. IAS r now happy with State Secretariat (state me still same old work culture exists😢)

[@rohanchhetri]

High work pressure reason is like a bodybuilder complaining about lifting weights. The training for IAS itself is far more work loaded than those of other central jobs. There should be a balance between IAS and other central job employees in bureaucracy. Systematically eroding IAS altogether will again bring same problems.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

I am not surprised at that! Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav.

​@@abhimanyugupta532but Ashwini vaishnav is an engineer

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Yes he's an engineer from MBM Engineering College(JNVU), Jodhpur

[@tbraghavendran]

​@@rohanchhetriI think you are an IAS aspirant. Explain me what problems would it create?

[@liberalindian8079]

IAS OFFICERS ARE GOOD FOR ADMINISTRATION ONLY ON ADVISORY NON IAS ARE MORE NEEDED ! WE REQUIRE SPECIALISTS IN DIFFERENT FIELDS!

[@grapeshott]

Politicians specialise in What?

[@KUMAR-bq4xn]

​@@grapeshott They are replaceable every 5 yrs by people. Thats their only specialization

[@resn9358]

​@@KUMAR-bq4xn But do we replace them?

[@free_soul9154]

​@@resn9358 but we can

[@Meateater2024]

Speculatists lack broad view

[@achieve-ias7989]

It’s best decision of this govt. Ias is there to serve people and should be accountable this is not British raj.

[@alileevil]

You do realize India’s administration was better under the British raj right? Indian administration was modeled after the British admin which intentionally subdivided the administration so that the ruling party will not have total control. Modi wants to be a dictator and this system stands in his way over centralizing his hold over the country.

[@akopparthi2008]

​@@alileevil Clearly oblivious to history,"You do realize that the british raj was very efficient for filling up britain's coffers and allowing them to assert dominance over us" Why would they create laws that benefit us it's for them,churchill literally starved us and killed 3 million Bengali's.The system benefited them not us-->That's why the whole damn thing needs to be overhauled because we are using a system that's served a different purpose during a different time now? Why are religions segregrated ? Relics of the british ... Won't comment on Modi because the last thing I want to do is get into a debate with someone who quite literally has never opened a book or done any research. Please try opening a book once in a while...It would help you a lot. Let's not get into a full fledged argument because that's a waste of my time.

[@alileevil]

​@@akopparthi2008 Unlike what the BJP has told you Indians became richer under the British. India went from a land of farmers to one where ordinary people could get into administrative positions. Let me be clear. The British always considered Indians as 2nd class citizens and even treated us as such. But, they also brought much needed progress and most importantly their common law which gave India a stable form of governance. Also its very important not to paint the British with a broad brush. While Churchill of the conservative party never cared for India, there was a lot in Britain who wanted to see an Independent India and even supported it. Say what you want, but if the British had not occupied us, India would not even be a country. We would be a collection of different States with a monarchy system. And please stop blaming the British for "religious segregation". Are you telling me that the rhetoric Modi and the BJP has been spreading against Muslims is due to British colonialism? Oh please own up to the fact that we Indians are racist and hateful.

[@akopparthi2008]

@@alileevil Didn't even express an ounce of support for modi but you've brought it into your entire argument.What a waste of time anyways.

[@naysayer7540]

Indian Muslims were responsible for partition, see Patel’s speech of Calcutta 1948 on KZbin. He clearly says that so many have stayed back who supported the Muslim league. Else how was it possible that Jinnahs party won almost all Muslim dominated minority reserved seats against congress Muslim candidates. Let’s not fool ourselves for the Muslims congress was the BJP of that time. Most didn’t migrate as they never realised that Pakistan will only be punjab Sindh and parts of Bengal. And even after partition they were given undue privilege to call the shots. They have been involved in all sorts of crimes, terrorism, overpopulation, vandalism, vote bank politics, conversions and anti national activities. Despite being a minority they behave like owners and creature nuisance during others religious processions. The hate is clearly from one side bcoz of their ideology. If you still wanna eulogise them be my guest. But sorry rest of us are not in the same boat. Have u ever wondered if they altaqiya they do now that they stayed by choice and this is their land, then why this violent mob mentality community didn’t come on to the streets to fight against their brethren who demanded partition. Else they are many instances where they fight and kill each other. Either u r a chuslim yourself or a leftist who is anyways a half chuslim

[@busyraj]

Great! we need to move away from IAS being handed every authority w/o having an iota of responsibility

[@Jaipur-kids-masti]

Railway minister is ex IAS , external affairs minister is ex IFS ….hahahaha

[@shivam.1984]

सब जगह RSS हाफ चड्डी वाले और भगवा चूतिये या कॉर्पोरेट के दल्ले भर दिए है NSA अजीत -डोवाल IPS विदेश मंत्री - S जय शंकर - IFS रेलवे IT Minister - IAS पेट्रोलियम minister - Hardip पूरी IAS और मोदी के गुलाम गोवर अंधभक्त कितना गोवर खा कर post की 😂😂😂😂

[@Pratim-z7l]

Guess you didn't watch the entire video

[@grapeshott]

It's just easy to get party loyalists

[@niteshsingh9158]

You didn't watch the video?

[@Sid20-jd7mb]

One of my friends working with state government Told me story of ias officer.. IAS officer was given charge to put together team and prepare website for online documentation of services like resident certificate, birth certificate, etc. his team designed so very well that even logging in was issue.. for 6 months .. with constant breakdowns . After lots of complaints from people.. local mla took it in his own hand and hired bunch of computer graduates to rectify the issue. And thankfully site is running pretty well now ..

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Not at all surprised Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) IAS officer suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam 11) 50 Crore stolen from IAS's homw 12) Ex Noida head IAS MOhinder SIngh raided. Documents of properties worth crores seized 13)Ex-IAS officer Net Ram’s properties worth ₹226 crore attached Feel free to add more!

[@priortokaraew7569]

Over 70 years later, we don't have one city that looks like the least developed cities in Eastern Europe or south east Asia. What exactly have the ias overrated offices been doing these many decades?

[@mohmmadnabeehasan4672]

Yeah filling their coffers.

[@trafalgarlaw4778]

listening to central government.

South east asia ,north east asia ,middle East aren't practical models to follow

[@ur.christiano.ronaldo7]

Now a days the cities are very much well developed.If you travel in usa then you realise our cities are very good and clean.The trains are also very good and clean.But the priblem that traffic is very congested.

[@ur.christiano.ronaldo7]

In tv we see that usa is very clean but actually the train,roads are very dirty than India.Not so dirty like dharavi but as compared to other place.

[@mandarp9472]

India needs more talented & experienced doctors, engineers, scientists, CAs & CFA, Entrepreneurs, businessmen, bankers than IAS officers if we want to progress and become a developed country. IAS Looby advised different governments till date and now we have very low per capita GDP of US 2,700 dollars after 70 years with poor quality of life.

[@useridsrell-s7w]

Very true. We need people who make things. Not people who have power to stop things from being made in the name of rules.

[@PhysicsIsGreat]

​@@useridsrell-s7wtrue

[@mahalak4383]

We need more ethical people

[@hemangipatil-nm1kn]

@mandarp9472 Being an IAS is not easy, IAS is more suitable for administrative role and responsibilities at the center as well state

[@daddydope258]

CFAs, CFPs, CAs, CMAs, MBAs, PGDMs, these are most needed there are 18 lakh jobs available in finance sector no-one is taking them only because of Govt. Jobs like these

[@guhathakurta1]

Good news!! Less corruption hopefully..

[@027atulyakumar2]

Probably the best step taken by govt . With them corruption will never reduce .

[@manurazgoit]

no, now corporate ceos are becoming secretaries.... who are not only corrupt but Super evil... eg. madhavi buch... sebi chief...

[@suryansh500]

Less petty corruptions But more big corruption

[@ScamAlert1001]

😂

[@je_suis_beau]

@@suryansh500 true

[@hishighnessab5540]

A step in the right direction by modi govt. These IAS guys are shining examples of "Maximal Authority With Minimal Responsibility". Down with such feudal setups

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@hishighnessab5540 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS' House 11)Ex-NOIDA chief IAS questioned by ED for properties worth crores 12)IAS suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam

[@s-qc9ns]

With 0 accountability

[@shailchauhan5117]

Great! We need to understand that an IAS officer is just performing his job and we need to ensure he not entitled to unlimited power.

[@niteshsingh9158]

No one’s asking for "unlimited power" for IAS officers-what’s at stake here is the balance of power and ensuring there’s enough independent thought and expertise in the system. matlab tumne video dekhi bhi kya?

[@adityavikramsingh9483]

​​​​@@niteshsingh9158Independent thought is not a monopoly of babus. No developed country in the world runs its governance using such an inefficient system. There is a reason that Indian bureaucratic setup is infamous all over the world. This system was established by Brits to subjugate Indians and not for development of the country. IAS are ill equipped in knowledge and training to handle everything from sun to the moon of the government setup. Specialists could rather have better understanding of running various government sectors.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

​@@adityavikramsingh9483 am not surprised at that! Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@adityavikramsingh9483 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) IAS officer suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam 11) 50 Crore stolen from IAS's homw 12) Ex Noida head IAS MOhinder SIngh raided. Documents of properties worth crores seized 13)Ex-IAS officer Net Ram’s properties worth ₹226 crore attached Feel free to add more!

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@adityavikramsingh9483 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) IAS officer suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam 11) 50 Crore stolen from IAS's homw 12) Ex Noida head IAS MOhinder SIngh raided. Documents of properties worth crores seized 13)Ex-IAS officer Net Ram’s properties worth ₹226 crore attached Feel free to add more if you want!

[@pinakidash2730]

Performance, performance and performance. Nothing else matters. Just because u passed an exam doesn't mean anything!

[@SourBoy-d8v]

So bring up short term decisions? Never pass a long term project because it would only benefit the upcoming IAS in that district not you. Never carry forward predecessors plan coz it can give them advantage, right? In short do the same things as politicians do, make new schemes and stop funding the old ones no matter how good they were. Terms like evaluation need some parameters which is extremely difficult to set in bureaucracy due to the dynamic nature of this job. Reforms are needed but to make bureaucracy efficient not to privatise it.

[@superninja8806]

This is a very good news, we need more specialists

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Exactly!!!! Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda/Jio/Airtel,etc 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS's home 11) 2 IAS being investigated in 200 crore Faridabad Civic Scam

[@navneetparmar3084]

They are no specialist under upsc they became specialist spending whole their life but now govt is bringing people on contract diluting executive, what's point of whole independent executive judiciary executive have become useless in front of legislators and then you cry police is corrupt system is corrupt, babu culture is important now then compare our defence minister with American our is rajnath singh who is politician and American one is 4 star general so is their finance and other departments who rose through ranks the same ranks which this govt is trying to destroy diluting century old service that has kept this huge diverse country together now what's gurrantee when bjp leaves power next govt will not appoint its own puppets , this govt has tried everything economic reforms demonetisation GST everything but failed now they don't even talk about these corrupted army with agniveer problem was simple just give army more money but naah we will change army and now braught special law for 15% reservation for IAS officers will govt recommendation

[@abhimanyugupta532]

​@@navneetparmar3084 am not surprised at that! Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav.

[@saratkumarpanda7007]

Once one person cracks IAS means he becomes master of all fields.strange

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@saratkumarpanda7007 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS' House 11)Ex-NOIDA chief IAS questioned by ED for properties worth crores 12)IAS suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam

[@pawankhurana1345]

Happy to know that Modi has cut the IAS Lobby to its size, well done Modiji

[@abhimanyugupta532]

am not surprised at that! Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@pawankhurana1345 am not surprised at that! Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@pawankhurana1345 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS' House 11)Ex-NOIDA chief IAS questioned by ED for properties worth crores 12)IAS suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam

[@user-dp48ry5]

मोदी को कुछ आता जाता नही है। काम सारा यही IAS करते हैं। पता तो होगा तुम्हे।

[@ablm1996]

I dont see how this is wrong. The beaurocracy cant be its own entity in a democracy like ours, it has to come under the Executive branch of the govt so policies are implemented with alignment. IAS aspirants crying in comments.

[@niteshsingh9158]

it’s about losing the intellectual rigor and debate that should precede policymaking. In a functioning system, the IAS officers (or any bureaucrats) aren’t just mindless implementers; they’re supposed to be the ones who debate, question, and refine policies before they even get to implementation. When you sideline these officers or reduce their power, you're essentially killing the space for intellectual discussion and dissent.

[@okman9684]

​@@niteshsingh9158government bureaucrats are not the idol of inthectuality. Most IAS officers are narcissist self centered intelectuals who use their knowledge for their own benefits. There is more chance to find genuine intelligent intelectual from normal public than a person who is out of touch from the ground and who wasted most of his/her life cracking exam and reading books rather thsn working on the ground amd interacting with actual people as a common man. You will always get a polished out view of public when you are IAS (e.g- roads will be built just before your visit to the place for inspection, people will talk happily like they are in paradise) but you will know the reality as a common citizen which you can never be after becoming an IAS hence you are out of touch with the ground reality and fed with a made uo reality by you surrounding officials

[@siddharthgoyal4008]

@@niteshsingh9158 most IAS / Civil services officers in India are rigid, lack any form of technical expertise to give any intellectual arguments to a large set of fields.

[@namangupta3160]

They clear a crap exam like UPSC. which is a lot about ratta fication. These people aren't suited for debates.

[@mohmmadnabeehasan4672]

​@@siddharthgoyal4008agree

[@santhoshprabhu2811]

India woke up after 65 years of independence, joint Sec Is not just a post to dominate. It's a responsibility to shape the policy. It's required various officers. Modi Govt doing that now for national interest.

[@mandarp9472]

IAS UPSC system has failed in the last 70 years. India still remains a developing country with very low per capita income of US 2700 dollars. China & India had similar per capita income in 1990s, but China surged ahead of India with per capita income of US 12,500 dollars. IAS system could not solve basic problems like high corruption in govenment dept, 5 crore pending court cases, basic facilities like 135 litre per capita per day good quality water, healthcare for all, education for all, good civic infrastructure, high level of direct taxes, 90% Public debt to GDP ration, rising crimes, law & order issues, biased laws, brain drain of best engineers, doctors & scientists to developed countries.

[@Mechantrechyrmang]

It failed because people who cracked the CSE failed to serve to the require potential. Some abuse the power the service gave them, while some have to listen to their corrupt superiors who pressure them into doing something

[@theedguy3937]

This pci issue is because of socialist model that was adopted by the prior govts america has been a capitalist nation even with crony capitalism their pci is pretty good so calling ias as reason behind pci disparity would be an inaccurate judgement

[@Dr_Suyash_Baghel]

​@@theedguy3937USA is a almost homogenous society man, India is very diverse with every group having different need to reach a developed status....to support crony capitalism you are giving absurd point.... What about China then they have Communist (left) govt and they have also proved that they are equally deserving in race of development... what's your say in that??

[@dobariyanaitikdineshbhai6832]

Indians when they blame politicians for bad governance almost never target the incompetent bureaucracy, I think they are the major reason why India is backwards.

[@theedguy3937]

@@Dr_Suyash_Baghel no i didn't support crony capitalism ,usa society also is plagued by many problems gun violence diabetes homelessness are some prominent ones, Well regarding china they may be communist in spirit but are capitalist in working also i would chose us over china any day ,what happens in china stays in china also there is model of dev comes with curtailed democracy curtailed rights which are too heavy a cost , we say that media situation is deplorable in india then it would he ghastly in china, there is another point since china has no independent reporting of figures its hard to believe their figures, so for me real question is whether china can be considered a model of development?

[@antarpreetsingh8886]

We are living in the age of specialization - be it doctors, lawyers, professors, scientists. IAS has for long been a generalist position - one day in Electronics, next day in Fisheries! We need specialists today - IAS or non IAS. Specialists who know a specific domain deep down - not just at administrative level.

[@milan_maji]

All Ias are specialist in their respective field

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@milan_maji Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav.

[@pravahsaxena3537]

​@@milan_maji yes field of corruption 😆

[@pravahsaxena3537]

​@@abhimanyugupta532 6th point is interesting. Can you give more information on it ?

[@pravahsaxena3537]

​@@abhimanyugupta532 1% ias officers are doing good job but 99% are just flaunting their 'status' 😅

[@aniketbelsare3029]

I am not a Modi supporter at all but I truly respect this decision.. After all IAS is generalist.. Why should we have them when expert in their field can lead the way

[@puneetsaini6014]

Now become one and see all the good changes india has gone through and yes the wrongs as well supporter doesn't mean we can't criticize the wrong but in his governance there are way too many goods than wrong

[@aniketbelsare3029]

@@puneetsaini6014 Supporter doesnt means we cant criticize the government well said bt unforunately BJP don't take criticism at all

[@puneetsaini6014]

@aniketbelsare3029 nobody does until unless they do a complete disaster and there is no coming back hahaha

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@aniketbelsare3029 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) IAS officer suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam 11) 50 Crore stolen from IAS's homw 12) Ex Noida head IAS MOhinder SIngh raided. Documents of properties worth crores seized 13)Ex-IAS officer Net Ram’s properties worth ₹226 crore attached Feel free to add more!

[@santhoshrgopal]

The report fails to mention that IRS, IAAS are all central services who wrote the same exam

Still permanent job, ops etc sucks and promotes inequalities the social part is the point and that must be taken into consideration

[@user-zp3dq9or7l]

Fucked up glorification of IAS

[@aabb-up3jn]

IRS is the most corrupt.

[@anjaanfakir]

Let’s see from a more rational perspective 1. Specialised vs Generalist Issue - Nowadays, almost 70% of the people who clear civil services are Engineers, many from IITs and NITs. A significant percentage of them have work experience with many MNCs. The number of civil servants with non-technical degrees/ zero work experience has decreased significantly as compared to a few decades ago. Second Point, many of the specialists work singularly in a single field while many of the governance issues require cross-sectoral/cross-domain knowledge. This cross-sectoral knowledge comes from working/ devoting your time in multiple fields. This is what IAS officers do all through their career. If I have to put a private sector comparison, you may think of grooming of various senior level executives in various roles in the organisation so that they gain a wholesome perspective of the organisation. A CEO may therefore be a generalist but equipped with a fairly good knowledge about the organisation’s various departments. 2. IAS dominance at central level - This is not by design but by the very fact that earlier the number of recruitments in other services was low compared to IAS. As the economy expanded and government’s functions increased and diversified, naturally the multifarious requirements in various specific sectors constrained officers from other sectors to get opportunities at centre. As their parent organisation itself would face staffing issues. Eg - Requirements for IRTS, IRS(IT), etc within their own parent organisations is already huge. 3. Skilling of IAS officers - A significant number of officers get enrolled in some of the top colleges of the world every year on the basis of merit -cum- scholarship. 4. Ground experience of IAS officers - All the officers work at ground level ie up to District Collector position at district which is pretty much as ground level/field experience that can be had. This gives ground level perspective on many matters that come in handy at policy making level. Many of the lateral entrants face limitations in this regard. Moreover, there are issues of transparency with regards to their transparency. Lastly , everyone needs to upgrade their career once In a while to remain relevant.

[@namangupta3160]

All is nonsense. You really do not need knowledge of variety of fields while making policies. You just need the knowledge of the main field and allied areas. You can always learn about other areas also. IAS is also not prone to corruption.

[@AbhishekKumar-yv6ih]

Great points.

[@adityavikramsingh9483]

@anjaanfakir The moot answer to all your points is that, the IAS cadre has the infamy to create 'red tape' culture and inefficieny in governance over the years. The bureaucratic IAS system is not as effective and rosy as you are trying to paint here. On ground most IAS are actually out of touch with reality and more interested in creating their own fiefdoms. Common Indians have known and suffered the ill effects of the dominanve of this system for years now and have been voicing their concerns. IAS system is the reason that ease of doing business in India is so poor. What you have stated sounds good on paper, but it has no connect with reality of India and IAS system. This system was created by the Brits to subjugate Indians and it remains a feudalistic setup till date. Even the Brits didnt create a similar system for their own country, yet some Indians seem to love it because of the glamour associated with it. It is high time that the system of governance in India is changed and more specialists are brought in to work in varous fields, rather than protecting the monopoly of babus in India.

[@dobariyanaitikdineshbhai6832]

​​@@namangupta3160 Yesterday itself I saw a news of an IAS doing corruption worth 500 cr in 18 months. Do not fool yourselves brother

[@rahulsawant8369]

Very Very Well said. I had also commented the same. When running a nation a focused and constricted brain like specialist can't at all do justice. But a Generalist who goes through the system from field work to running a ministry as Secretary. That Brain has gone through multi factor issues. Dealing with lawful implementation of schemes, to handling riots, to uplifting a district. A engineer can just tight a bolt or fix by troubleshoot specific stuff. There is no sense in saying A specialist is good then a Generalist when the job itself ask multi perspective capabilities.

[@OK-vf9cy]

good decision by government 👍 remove corrupt ias officers and select people who are experts in their domain

[@anuragpandey2635]

Great reform…. Salute the govt to finally breaking this hegemony…

[@kmokashi]

Thanks & due credits to The Print for bringing out such unnoticeable changes that Modi govt. is doing. Your journalistic standards are worth inculcating by others.

[@maheshjambardi771]

Otherwise this good work of Modi government would have gone unnoticed

[@ShortsbyAnand7]

This is a good work of Modi Govt's

[@rishipramanick6823]

This is actually a great job

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@ShortsbyAnand7 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) IAS officer suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam 11) 50 Crore stolen from IAS's homw 12) Ex Noida head IAS MOhinder SIngh raided. Documents of properties worth crores seized 13)Ex-IAS officer Net Ram’s properties worth ₹226 crore attached Feel free to add more!

[@ThePrintIndia]

Hi Krishna, Thank you for your kind words of appreciation.

[@akeshravi9640]

This lobby played a very important role in defeating BJP especially in UP during 2024...

[@balajik8672]

So if they support bjp it's good then. If they don't then are Anti National lobby blah blah.. Waah kya soch hain. So ur telling me Evms are fake drama, elections are decided by Pro BJP ias officers nd anti bjp 😢 ias officers Across India? 😮😢

[@NamanMittal308]

How? Can you describe it please? Govt wants to use them to work in their favour to win them election?

[@jaigagandeep.s5100]

@@NamanMittal308no In Implementation of government work they can bring hindrance by giving excuses . In technical sort .

[@akeshravi9640]

@@NamanMittal308 You don't know what a bureaucracy lobby could do to the government...Search in the Google to find out this lobby can mess things of government that lead to public anger against Government

[@sunny57jo]

@@jaigagandeep.s5100 which means BJP is doing right thing by bypassing IAS

[@DOrdinaryHuman]

This is one of the good reforms done by the NDA government! Just because somebody got less marks in one competitive exam shouldn't deprive them of the aspiration to level up higher

[@SathyaswamyS]

Lower level officials eg Constables and Sis need more promotion opportunities.

[@ExploringInternet0101]

All politicians should also clear UPSC exam 😂

[@abhisheksahay9283]

A UPSC passed person must also contest and win a Lok Sabha Election to be qualified for an appointment.

[@kundankmishra3151]

Ghanta UPSC 😂

[@abhisheknaithani3647]

Leak ho jaega paper

[@meimahanhu]

better to say clear GATE JRE or Jest not rattu tota exam

[@sitarampradhan8488]

If so voter should have 10th pass qualification to cast vote. Period

[@GeopoliticalIntricacies]

How a professor from Gujarat became upsc chairman?? This is something I could never understand.

[@naveensharma2509]

Gujarat ki jagah UP se hota to?

[@maheshjambardi771]

One third of the administrators as generalists (IAS) and two thirds who are specialists (IRS, IRTS, IFS etc) looks like a very good balance. Nothing is lost. This is actually better.

Still it's about joint secretaries usa even cancelled the civil service exam plus we are talking about overall

[@mritunjay4344]

IAS syllabus built for public service and control but when comes for technical and progressive they lacked

[@SourBoy-d8v]

Yeah there should be field training and strict examinations from time to time, rather than reducing them and putting in political party loyalist

[@parveshsinghbisht7421]

​@@SourBoy-d8vwhy can't we just put officers from other fields for positions which requires technical expertise!? I believe an IES is anyday better than an IAS in the field of economics

[@indian5626]

@@SourBoy-d8vSaab kuch drama only reality main Dekha ….system change honi chahiye….british ke time se Chal raha hai

[@skeptic3846]

Very good. Such erosion of power of civil servants is also needed in state level. Most bureaucrats are power drunk appeasers of their political bosses and do or think very little for the masses. Particularly in the state of West Bengal their sole objective is to ensure plump posting during their service and to secure reassignment after retirement.

[@sneheshtalukdar4345]

We are watching YOU..Next time apply for Govt services..WE will SEE...If Income tax is less by Re. 1 WE will SEE... Regards Anonymous Asst. Director in GoWB

[@Navdeep_sohi]

Bravoo!! This step will not only improve the the administration conditions at secretariat but also majorly will impact on mindset of youth who think that IAS is everything . But this is very wrong a good effecient doctor abled engineer skilled artist and all other professions are imp as IAS . We see foreign countries more developed because they do not emphasise on particular career but they help students to become best in their interest🎊👍👍❤️

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Here is a list of the really good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda/Jio/Airtel,etc 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100crore + cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) 50 crore stolen from IAS's home 11) 2 IAS being investigated in 200 crore Faridabad Civic Scam 12) 3 IAS in jail in mineral mining scam Also the same Indians go to USA and do tremendous good work.The brain behind ChatGPT is an Indian. Principle design engineer at SpaceX is an Indian and the innumerable list of CEOs Just a food for thought!

[@Navdeep_sohi]

@@abhimanyugupta532 sooo truee buddy 👍👍

[@user-ng5xr2ju2z]

Sanya, in your written article you mentioned that the youngest batch of IAS to get empaneled was 2008 while for other services it was 2006. There is a nuance in that- actually now there is a trend of Non-Functional Upgradation, basically officers of other services are given their promotion on time, the salary, perks, post etc everything is promoted, but official DoPT empanelment comes later. So for example, in Indian Economic Service, the latest batch to get to Joint Secretary Level is actually 2006, not 2003 like you mentioned in the article. Btw, very good story, I appreciate your reporting on Civil Services, it gives a very good view of the system.

[@hare12345.]

Good initiative by modi govt

[@therealist7327]

Modi is doing far better than previous Government. Utilising them with their very best. Long gone are those when salary accounts could get credited without attending the office. Work hard, no matter who you are.

[@shreyassinghrathod]

Print tried to defame modi govt instead led to appreciation for reforms😂

[@abrahamlincoln680]

What else can we expect from Print

[@DeeSund]

Bravo. Finally a govt. with guts to cut IAS to size. I was always under the impression that it was the politicians who held India back and it was the IAS officers who held India together. This illusion was shattered when I got a job dealing with the government closely. I noted that politicians, by and large and with a few exceptions, worked for the welfare of the people. Whereas the IAS officers were there to say NO to anything and everything. Never came across an IAS officer who had any progressive ideas.

[@AlokKumar-sr3cq]

Shameful for a country where its manpower is dominating NASA TO GOOGLE Harvard to Cambridge but in india health department planner is ias civil aviation head is ias r they only suitable specialist to head others with professional competence of any field

[@alpha4502]

Yes we need specialist of their respective fields to take care of different departments not Some exam clearing parrots.

[@PhysicsIsGreat]

​@@alpha4502😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅very true

[@almeshdevraj9581]

Nasa? Don't Nasa only hire Americans?

[@kamartaj3010]

NASA is a govt organisation they only hire Americans kabhi check bhi karle gawar Indians are not dominating NASA. Inse jyada toh chinese h top US university and research institute me par woh Indians ki tarah social media pe brag nahi karte firte

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Precisely the man handling COVID is a mechanical engineering chap!Anyways Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav.

[@ajsujit]

Is it done for better administration or to concentrate power and reduce checks and balances?

[@medman195]

why tf is this even a question you're asking here? pl, make ur own opinion. take only "facts" from others[including news channels]. P.S. Fact 1 : Babu system is one of the biggest hurdle for IN. fact 2 : Old corrupt Babus and Gov./judiciary ecosystem was/is indeed Congress' biggest allies, so definitely a factor in BJP doing this.

[@ajsujit]

@@medman195 I'm wondering if things could get better or worse. Are we replacing a bad system for an even worse system? Dictatorships have come in power by promising to get rid of corruption. It is always a good idea to think about pros and cons of every situation. I'm a mere mortal after all. Not an all knowing omniscient being that you seem to be from the tone of your response.

[@tejas1828]

Great because absolute power corrupts absolutely ! Different officers from their specialized background should be assigned in proportion to the IAS officers so that one's specialization is used for the betterment of the policies and people at large ! IAS officers can't be the sole of bureaucracy or administration alone!

[@hitenrodri1388]

But most of the so called specialised IAS officers know the loop holes and even manage to do Hundreds of Crores of Corruption unnoticed.😢

[@neji-hyuga-]

And you think modi is free from that rule of corruption?

[@drumsholto1773]

Modi government hasn't only eroded IAS's powers but whole of bureaucracy power. All the officials feel powerless themselves. It is not fun to work right now I can tell you for sure. And while general public and all the private sector people think this is very good. You must understand that the constitution gives power to three fronts Legislative, Judiciary and Executive and Bureaucrats are a major part of Executive other than the cabinet chosen after the elections. But snatching away the freedom of working and making policies along with decreasing staff to overwork them with worsening promotions and increments and without pay commissions. Well I feel a lot for the government employees nowadays. But the general perception is that they are all corrupt, they are all lazy, they are all incompetent. But I have seen them work and many of them do more work than a manager at a private company and without a bit of appreciation, as no one appreciates the work usually. Moreover the person who work diligently are pushed to work more for the shake of actual lazy and corrupt people people making liaisoning with higher ups. But general public never considers that, they never think that after all whatever good work is being done someone is behind it. And more than that everyone like media and all generally show the decisions that downgrade or exploit or make powerless the bureaucracy as a great step. But they don't tell that the power decreased from bureaucracy is snatched away by the same government that is making them devoid of it. And everyone knows that when 1 part of the government achieves too much power what happens. Division of power is must. There shall be boundary while making decisions. Bcz at the end of the day a balanced politics is better than a polarised politics as the earlier is democracy while the latter represents dictatorship.

[@santhoshprabhu2811]

😂

[@sitarampradhan8488]

Only 25% government employees are good rest are lazy craps. Otherwise India would have developed country.

[@solotourist4588]

Why only IAS. The exam has a name that "civil services exam", doesn't mean that other officers working for the state/center from levels 10 -18 are not civil servants !!!! Any officer at level 13, 14, 15, 16, 17 can be appointed as Deputy, Joint, Additional Secretaries respectively . There is no need of a IAS tag at the tail end of your name. All govt employees are doing a service to the nation so all have the right to equality in job too.

[@tbraghavendran]

Right to equality doesn't apply here.

[@SathyaswamyS]

Yes. In Indian police, constables and SIs don't have much avenue for career growth.

[@Subhransu1Rath1]

This is a good move. Development visible at ground level. A recent survey says 75% IAS are too corrupt.

[@jsg_6758]

Even 80 shouldn't be there...🔥🔥🔥

[@SourBoy-d8v]

Yeah 100% privatization should be there. Give UPSC Commission to Ambani and he will make rules in favour of Reliance oh sorry... Indian public

[@SourBoy-d8v]

Those who will fund the party during the election must be a bureaucrat. Common masses - Sir, a poor hardworking village boy wants to change his region's social status Govt. - nope, he can't tell him to work in a corporate for his life and change his scenario not his region. Only rich privileged can rule just like good old days of zamindars. Mr/ Mrs jsg_6758 - yeah yeah, capitalists I love you 😂

[@Nash5599]

Those three fire emojis damn now ur point is valid

[@Aman_BS]

​@@SourBoy-d8v How appointment of Non IAS is related to Ambani Adani. Hegemony of IAS has to end. Officers from various services should be appointed to centre bringing diversity and varied experiences.

[@SourBoy-d8v]

@@Aman_BS it doesn't happen. Every nation who walked on the path of lateral entry only broadened it's scope.

[@rrmishra277]

Modi Government doing the right thing by sidelining these overhyped IAS and now time to fix accountability on judiciary.These are the inefficient unaccounted resource eaters.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) IAS officer suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam 11) 50 Crore stolen from IAS's homw 12) Ex Noida head IAS MOhinder SIngh raided. Documents of properties worth crores seized 13)Ex-IAS officer Net Ram’s properties worth ₹226 crore attached Feel free to add more!

[@ftrhf]

Shaktikant das is a good example, even with a simple degree , excellence is not defined by one exam it is continuous effort

[@theedguy3937]

But he has done great job as a governor

[@ftrhf]

@@theedguy3937 you need not be an ias to do great things even with simple degree with knowledge & dedication towards your job one can do wonders.

[@theedguy3937]

@@ftrhf i strongly disagree with this simple degree is not enough there are multifarious and multifaceted issues in this 21st century world which requires big brains and practical experience so we need highly educated individuals to run the business

[@irreplaceable2002]

​@@ftrhfBro Shaktikant Das was IAS officer himself

[@amansahu7260]

Don't you think policies on Roads, Water, Infrastucture will be made btter by officers of ESE and railways rather than an IAS officer? I am happy and obliged to see this change.

[@navinshettigar5137]

It could be good for unmotivated IAS officers. IAS postings move like this for 2-3 years and work as top leadership driving strategies - Coal Ministry, Housing, Education, Water Resources. In private sectors you have specialists for each role, and they compete to keep their jobs.

[@mayflowerlily5326]

Good news less corruption and more productivity. This was a system done to serve the British. More reforms must be made in this system.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) IAS officer suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam 11) 50 Crore stolen from IAS's homw 12) Ex Noida head IAS MOhinder SIngh raided. Documents of properties worth crores seized 13)Ex-IAS officer Net Ram’s properties worth ₹226 crore attached Feel free to add more!

[@callofgamer4940]

Government instead of giving promotion on age basis, they should give promotion on Skill, Merit and Performance basis.

[@gauravnaagar5799]

Caste will prevail, only Brahmins will eat the entire resources of the country

[@saurabhmaskara1]

Very well said prime minister. As a country, we need to democratise services at all levels. Too many very smart young people spend years trying to crack the IAS exams and other services suffer. We need to really make this service less lucrative.

[@nishantgaurav4261]

Seems like a good thing. An IAS is merely a graduate and is not fit to manage things which requires technical expertise. Moreover, there are many great educational opportunities are available for IAS/IPS officer but most of them aren't even interested in increasing their knowledge. Surely, there are some great exceptions but unfortunately this is the case of most of them.

[@DeepakGoswami91]

A very good and visionary initiative to dismantle the hegemony of one particular service over the lives of billion plus Indians.

[@YaduvendraChauhan]

Thank God for that. Things have started to move and is picking speed. We needs specialist everywhere.

[@binaryxd4812]

they are now refining IAS very well. like IIT. only top brightest minds will get the posts.

[@TheUsedTextbook]

These are old British inspired structure, we need new structure for our future.

[@pawankhurana1345]

At the earliest, High priority, no more IAS exam, stop it New system please

[@SathyaswamyS]

@@pawankhurana1345 Do you think IPS should be abolished and ranks from ASP and above should be filled by officers promoted from SI and constable level?

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@SathyaswamyS Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10) IAS officer suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam 11) 50 Crore stolen from IAS's homw 12) Ex Noida head IAS MOhinder SIngh raided. Documents of properties worth crores seized 13)Ex-IAS officer Net Ram’s properties worth ₹226 crore attached Feel free to add more!

[@arindampal4982]

Administration cannot be properly monitored without proper knowledge of the subject. Person working in industries like power plant, railway projects, steel industries will have better knowledge about the subject and administration of that field. So Modi Govt has done the correct thing

[@useridsrell-s7w]

IAS is just fancy name for people who memorize unconnected knowledge that does not help them in any form or fashion to take decisions. They should give successful business owners those jobs. They know what is takes to make people around them successful.

[@TerexS-dw1hc]

Seriously, business owners?😂 tum sbka dimag erode ho gya h, flaw politicians me nhi dikhta, crony capitalism me nhi dikhta, societal degradation nhi dikhta, koi ek bnda jahil nhi poori ki poori country jahil h. Infosys ka wo bnda tumhe salary dega cheap or kam karwayega 12 ghnte wo chahiye tumhe, ya aise capitalist jinki profit share krne me fat jati h. Ya wo sebi ke log jo profit kamate h pr samne nhi aate. Oh shyd tum unki baat kr rhe ho jinka carbon footprint sbse jyda h lekin pollution hone pe dosh jata h normal logo ko ya unki baat kr rhe ho jo west ko copy krke business kr rhe h, machinery aaj bhi 70 ke dashak ki use krne hume gyan de rhe h.

[@SathyaswamyS]

All govt service exams are like that. Even the US has a civil service

[@kamalkrishna1000]

❤This is exceptional case Modi has taken right decision & it should be implemented in every state rigorously & no of Non IAS cadre must be risen upto 80%

[@militantGAMING]

So the politicians can change civil service but no one can change politicians but only the politicians themselves can. If the politicians can not keep their promise they are still kept or not questioned.

[@yashtiwari117]

Full time celebrities, part time public servants - it is time we make them accountable and stop treating them as some ethereal entity.

[@cricketforever1841]

Well IAS officers are expert at nothing except administering. I would not take a critical financial or economic decision based on IAS recommendations. I would take financial advice from experts in financial domains.

[@worldnews1545]

Excellent... Bro... People don't even have such commonsense.... That's the reason we had slow growth before bjp...

[@alpha4502]

These sarkari babus are good for nothing. They have failed in every sector where they enter. Specialized people of respective fields should be given priority.

[@worldnews1545]

@@alpha4502 not all are bad or failed... There are but handful of people who became IAS who genuinely wanted to help and uplift society.... They are those people who follow traffic rules and don't use their IAS card for privileges... While on other hand there are fraudsters who looted thousands of crores..

[@utkarshshukla6238]

RBI governor is IAS Finance minister is economics grad who did better job ?

[@adityavikramsingh9483]

​@@utkarshshukla6238Finance minister is also a retired IAS bhai😂

[@sunny57jo]

IAS meant I am sorry (to the ministers) . New officers need to be linked to the ground realities and have the skills to deliver the results.

[@quixoticfiend9274]

Enough of UPSC civil servants being in charge of every PSU and governmental agency. Allow lateral entry for industry experts and watch the efficiency treble.

[@adityavikramsingh9483]

There is a reason that the whole world and all Indians recognise the word 'red tapism' and Indian bureaucracy as the biggest hinderance in moving projects efficiently in India. That reason is inefficient work culture and fiefdom setup by bureaucracy in the past. A good step to get more people with relevant skills and experience to work in various fields of governance. Even the Brits who introduced this IAS system in India, in order to subjugate Indians, have no such system in their own country.

[@bharatpathik9036]

Good job. The erosion of quality due to quota system somehow gets balanced and neutralized by the move of lateral entry. Survival of the fittest.

[@dobariyanaitikdineshbhai6832]

Today's IAS dance with Sunny Leone while carrying a fake OBC caste certificate. Good riddance.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone

Come on they can enjoy

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda/Jio/Airtel,etc 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS's home 11) 2 IAS being investigated in 200 crore Faridabad Civic Scam

[@arunengine]

Great move, it should be done early 70s, India require specialist in key positions rather than generalist.....key positions should belong to PhDs, domain experts, industries_ corporates experts.

[@WowScientist]

*** This comment requires general level Iq* It is important to understand that Civil servants other than IAS are equally competent. Many IAS these days just want the VIP culture for themselves. If you have forgotten.... kindly google for recent case of Pooja Khedekar. Im sure you will find many other Babus with big ego and small intentions for Jan Vikas. It is also important to bring the backbone of Digital India i.e. NIC to the forefront if India is to be a Viksit Bharat.

[@pankajdubey5823]

Very well taken decision. They are most corrupt and arrogant amongst all India services officials. Breaking their dominance is a visionary step More officials should be inducted from the private sector through lateral entries .

[@AdityaYadav-jm2fn]

shi hai specialised aur skill wale logo ko lana chaiye..

[@soumenmondal4872]

Very needed reform. IAS officials thought that they are the boss of govt. only public is the boss❤

[@thegreatkabula243]

What about Amit saha son became chairman of BCCI/ICC.??is he suitable for that job? Why only IAS/IPS are targeted? Not Politician and their family....

[@abhimanyugupta532]

@@thegreatkabula243 Some whataboutery! Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS' House 11)Ex-NOIDA chief IAS questioned by ED for properties worth crores 12)IAS suspended in 1200 crore Gujarat Land scam

[@prangonweb93]

Hate him or like him..but he has done wonderful job in BCCI.

[@coupe97]

Almost 80% of Government officers are just doing their job just for benifits and are not focus on working with actual responsibilities. Not just government jobs, in almost all the jobs many Indians are either not happy or just doing their jobs. People needs to be more ambitious, also the cost of living and others are in questions too, but people should try to be ambitious and learn how to be happy with what they do.

[@SathyaswamyS]

The Indian system kills ambition.

[@abhinavchaudhary6342]

That's a good thing.

[@MohitKumar-ui9cn]

A report came that IAS officers in Chattisgarh were collecting 2 crores daily... I must say this is need of an hour

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda/Jio/Airtel,etc 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone 10)50 crore stolen from IAS's home 11) 2 IAS being investigated in 200 crore Faridabad Civic Scam

[@Tahchapa.]

Most people who commented on removing IAS officers were once who attempted this coveted post but failed even after so much attempt!! 😂😂

[@haraprasadmohapatra9268]

IAS/IPS should be abolished completely to eradicate corruption.

[@Vishleshan_2023]

Some IAS may be appointed by previous govt as their spy

[@nidhinmk8211]

Very good development Its time to look at the relevancy of IAS system as a whole

[@jainapurvab]

Guys never forget what Print , lalantop , Dhruv rathhi , desh bhakt were doing during general elections 🤫

[@laxmanbisht2638]

This is good for reform. We need experts to deal respective problem. For example, health should be taken care by a expert from medical fraternity. This is how it works in developed world.

[@olduncow4273]

Why should IAS have monopoly.

[@hiheloByby6902]

Because People Like you... Over Glorified It .... 😂😂😂😂 Gaaann Entry

[@npradhan057]

Some coaching centers raised the value of IAS for thr own benifits 😊...n some lower middle class people took it seriously 😊

[@Subhashish69]

What about the idiots from St. Stephen? The rotation door specialists! the emperor's of blocking reforms.

[@satheeshkumar3417]

Bold and welcoming initiative from Modi Govt. Technocrats shall be given preference who worked in the field/technology from bottom level, so that the Field will prosper and grow further like ISRO.

[@gokul2221]

While exposing the one side of reality , also kindly bring to light the positive changes brought about by any bureaucrats. So that print remains a neutral and relevant media

[@train_xc]

There’s a very little positive bureaucracy brings

[@rahulsawant8369]

​@@train_xcits you saying cause you have spectacle who's mirror just see's wrong in everything. So its better people like this mindset shouldn't talk on good and bad.

[@train_xc]

@@rahulsawant8369 then tell me the things that bureaucracy helps change the world or India. Generally only two types of people changes the world: visionary entrepreneurs and visionary politicians . Too much bureaucracy brings down the success rate. The reason why India is more successful in implementing policies now than 30 years ago. The bureaucracy has been cut down drastically, but we have still a long road to travel

[@prathammudgal9115]

According to me these steps are essential & will bring Flexibility and efficient Governance to areas like *Defence, Space, Research n Devlopment* where other personal roles matter as well.👏🏻 I don't see how this is eroding the IAS of India?

[@ajaypathania9895]

All who commented against IAS officers are those who cannot clear UPSC 😂😂

[@biswajitbhuyan9533]

Take the post away from them..these so called officers will beg in streets

[@rishipramanick6823]

So in order to comment on govt policies we also need to have a degree in pol science

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of useless babus of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone Feel free to add more!

Not always not really

[@SathyaswamyS]

Plot twist: They love IPS more

[@literarystudio1314]

Majority are engineers and doctors and they are not specialised in social sciences.

[@njain1983]

India needs domain specialists to make policies not the generalist Babus sitting in their ivory towers who have no idea of how things work on the ground. These Babus come up with policies which may look good on paper but do more harm than good, to people who were supposed to benefit from their policies. Maybe Babus can be useful in implementing the policies made by the specialists, as they know how the 'system' works.

[@niteshsingh9158]

You mean loyalists or ideologically aligned specialists-people who share the government's worldview.

[@OK-vf9cy]

​@@niteshsingh9158so you think that those ias officers who are corrupt and hold higher government positions are not loyalist

[@rationalmedicine3235]

It's a no-brainer that Indian Administrative Service should administer India. What is meant by "breaking the dominance" of the IAS? They are chosen through competitive examinations to get the best brains to run the country.

[@manoj4730]

its right Engineering service officer should head psu companies not some IAS

If it's an engineering and stem based psu then offcourse

[@manoj4730]

Then what is HAL BHEL BEML NPCIL and many other

[@wounderlust8954]

Great decission by govt appreciate that just being an ias it doesn't mean u khow everything in a certain field but not for all

[@meanoz9243]

Interesting how people who don't have the ability to crack UPSC are commenting on IAS culture.

[@indian9632]

People hate civil servants bcz they are corrupt.

[@UG-tz9dz]

And you don't have the ability to become prime minister of India but still watching videos discussing his decision. It's interesting 😎.

[@subhambhattacharjee4826]

So basically, you are saying that I have to crack UPSC examination to comment on the Indian administrative services. What kind of logic is this? These buggers are affecting my life instead of making them work for me. You are saying that I have to crack the examination in order to comment upon them or to ask about their accountability towards the public? So by this logic, you have to win election and become Prime Minister in order to comment upon his works.? do not glorify the UPSC examination. I know you might be an aspirant, but there are more intelligent people who in the very first place don’t want to crack this UPSC shit. They have some other life goals which they want to pursue, so stop looking at people who have not cracked UPSC as failures. They might not be interested in the exam in the very first place.

[@adityavikramsingh9483]

Rote learning is not the epitome of knowledge and critical thinking. Come out of this feudal mindset and start living in today. No developed country in the world has such and inefficient system like IAS. Yet these countries are way better in governance when compared to India. Whole world and most common citizens of India can see the ill effects of IAS and bureaucratic system of India, it is just the aspirants who seem to be worried😂.

[@CAanuragshukla]

Value addition due to technical knowledge is a more important thing than toughness of exams due to excess competition and no person has enough time to crack all exams of the world to comment thereon.

[@AncientTiger3]

It's high time the exams are scrapped altogether and industry veterans with actual practical expertise and hard-earned experience in enterprises are directly put into positions to influence outcomes and drive policies. We don't need this bureaucracy anymore.