Railways, revenue, forest-an eclectic group of services gains focus under Modi govt as IAS sway dips

[@surapaneniarunsai5051]

I have immense respect for the IAS, but most of these IAS Babus work in state governments, where they seem to forget they're supposed to be civil servants, not political servants. Adverse long-term effects? My foot. Decades of these Babus holding high positions, and did we see any change? Not a chance.

[@abhimanyugupta532]

🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone

[@navneetparmar3084]

So the new nepo babus who used recommendation to skip through promotions will listen to you 😂 what a joke same story while demonetisation same for GST and new tax slabs same for kisan laws same for agniveer and now upsc 😂 this govt has seen failure in whatever they tried even after 370 couldn't even win kashmir 😂

[@smarsp9175]

​@@navneetparmar3084BJP did something which congress were scared to do.

[@adityaraj2213]

@@smarsp9175 yaa hire boot lickers and Random ppl who know nothing about the given post Ex: Railway officer in Culture Ministry 😂

[@rishipaldreamlbsnaa]

Do you know guys, what was the initial purpose of introducing bureaucracy in india by Britishers,,,called as Colonial bureaucracy which had the Imperial Civil Service (ICS) at its top basically served the ends of India's colonial masters. After independence, in the early years there was a lot of enthusiasm amongst both the political leadership and the bureaucracy regarding nation building. But after some decade of independence the scenario has been changed and mostly bureacrats became the puppet of politicians for their personal benefits. Do you know, paper of Ethics introduced in upsc syllabus in 2013, why? because as per report of DoP&T the selected candidates by upsc were Rattu Tottas. They selected just by reading some specific and defined books and syllabus. But today condition is different, candidates selected on the basis of considering various parameters. youngest bureaucrats work with integrity and probity. We have many examples. There are both kind of people good or bad. Politicians also corrupt but why whole blame putted on bureaucrats. Govt is introducing lateral entry option because they want to promote favouritism and nepotism in the system. They want to decline the efficacy of constitutional body (UPSC). We don't know guys what is the mindset of govt behind this. Because leteral entry system was recommended by 2nd ARC 2005 and UPA govt thought to implement this system. 2004-08. Don't blame only NDA govt for this.

[@AB034TX]

It's one of the smartest silent reforms done by this government. Confronting IAS lobby directly would have been much more difficult. Also, other services have some brilliant officers.

[@karanjena1766]

Bsdk ias officers lobby is silent protector of all resources of india I know they do corruption but eurasian script followerf midi and bjp by giving power to these services and employing their "men " is now targeting to loot all the resources

[@prakashsalaria3888]

I am from industry. I had an opportunity to interact with senior administrators of state and centre. I think, NaMo's decision is right because with the changing time and technology , mearly an administrative capability is insufficient for the progress. Much different attributes are needed for progress. Just an IAS background is in sufficient.

[@ajaysinghaswal]

Sab jugad vale ...neta chaploos....kaam karenge????

[@abhimanyugupta532]

Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone

[@RBuser-o4c]

@@abhimanyugupta532 No 9🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@counterpoint9260]

Modi has failed to bring more accountability for existing officers.no accountability

[@counterpoint9260]

@@abhimanyugupta532 no wonder everybody in UP or Bihar want IAS or govt jobs...

[@bozenjobin]

Experts should come instead of IAS. Clearing a general exam will not make you a perfect material to manage specific areas where expertise and rare skills are required.

[@MrPoornakumar]

@bozenjobin That is why it is for policy. Expertise (& expert) must be on tap & not on top. If at the top, one can muster an expert to take advice from, take a decision and leave it to the experts, for implementation. Problem comes when wrong advice from an expert might lead to disaster. Thus, he should be judicious in selecting him/her.

[@gametabulas]

I do not support bjp but still some of their policies are right including this. IAS is not an educational qualification. An IAS is not an expert, here in CG chief factory inspector was from Forest service. How is that possible? How can someone with entirely different field or field experience is made to administer technical departments? Welcoming policies from central government. 👌

[@kreeba5220]

A positive change under the bold, innovative leadership of PM Narendra Modi. Decades of experience clearly shows that IAS is not enough. Efficiency or integrity can't be measured solely on the basis of academic or UPSC score.

[@Smartsam2024s]

Why centre government is not changing the selection procedure and curriculum of bureaucrats?

[@MrPoornakumar]

@@Smartsam2024s Curriculum of bureaucrats? What does that mean? Curriculum is for preparing for an examination. Or is it, curriculum for bureaucrats?

[@SudhanshuKumar-b7o]

Don't tell me that you worked in IT cell

[@rohitsah1265]

If INDIA want to become a develoed nation by 2047 ,then government need to do one thing is that to reduce the craze of UPSC by reducing perks and providing only which is necessary.

[@Volvo-f2y]

NO, IMPROVE THE LABOUR CONDITIONS IN PRIVATE SECTOR. APPROACH SHOULD BE +VE, not very negative.

[@anandms7537]

​@@Volvo-f2y yes right, private sector is too uncertain and in government jobs are there for life time even if they don't do any productivity.

[@Volvo-f2y]

@@anandms7537 Let's begin with electing qualified, educated leaders. That's more primary. For instance, the current Chinese premier is a Chemical Engineer by qualification. Let's remove all the illiterate and criminals from our politics first. Is that fine for you sir?

[@anandms7537]

@@Volvo-f2y educated candidates are the one ruling us, expect few, leadership and education is different, for example kamaraj from Tamilnadu was not literate but he is the one who reformed education sector in Tamilnadu. People and leaders both have to cooperate for better nation.

[@Marshaltit1552]

@@Volvo-f2y The current leader of the Government Modi discontinued study after intermediate but later did his B.A. and M.A. through distance education. The leader of the opposition Rahul went abroad to study not because of his capability but family influence and wealth. But when he talks he does not appear very educated. Whom do you want to remove and whom to add Sir?

[@santanodcosta3360]

Best initiative by Modi to curb corrupt IAS and IPS from civil services.The most honest and hardworking non IAS cadre must also be sent to the various states as well as Chief Secretaries.

[@Brokeearther]

Politics will corrut them as well. They are only humans.

[@sm1256]

I am glad this is happening. We want to see those qualified and established people who want to do the public service, rather than IAS that just lurk in a corner with bellies full of corrupt money.

[@mahalak4383]

During covid, I hardly saw any ministers doing work. It was Dc, sdm, DDC and so on who were managing everything from quarantine centres to feeding the stray animals. You need more ethical people than so called experts.

[@GauravSingh-fw2xf]

Make sense , Just Rote Learning history and Geography in UPSC to score good rank 25 yrs back doesn't make you entitled for Joint Secrataory Role. IAS Lobby has failed to upskill , there is zero public information what they are upskilled in and hard assessment to verify their level of upskill . Attending workshops/training sessions in name of up-skilling is hog wash. IAS working style is like a glorified call centre who are delegators at best and not problem solvers. Other departments allege that these IAS officers due to their close proximity to ministers take away the credit for hard work and innovation.

[@Drganguli]

Well this does not seem like a bad move. Many railway people are willing to have better systems level knowledge

[@truthalwaysprevails662]

No s*, railways is run efficiently now with no issues at all like in the past 😂😂😂😂

[@babua63]

Absolutely the right decision taken by the Modi government. IAS officers have repeatedly failed the people in holding their own and the law they are supposed to uphold and work under, repeatedly, in the face of corrupt politicians. If the service has no spine it does not have anything else to speak for itself.

[@mahalak4383]

How will lateral entry prevent that?

[@nishant54]

​@@mahalak4383 By bringing relatively honest workers from other services since most ias are bootlickers.

[@marsplanet128]

The country is fed up with corrupt practices of IAS babus... Modi ji is very right in this approach... Still IAS are occupying many important positions in the Government & they needed to be shunted out...

[@shankerram6076]

What domain expertise does IAS officers have???

[@divankersaxena3809]

a Generalist ............

[@RBuser-o4c]

They can pull a babu on you?

[@AbhishekKumar-yv6ih]

Tell me what qualification does a Politician have? Still they are able to run the country. Right? Everyone must understand, that an ideal IAS officers are not an average intellect. The role is generalist for a reason, because you are expected to have the flexibility to serve any department at any point of time. In a country like India, where diversity is driving aspect, you can't have a specialist governing over India. In earlier stages of career, one is expected to learn the field expertise for effective implementation, gradually as they transition to policy making, they are aware of the ground level realities, which makes them an effective decision maker. You can argue that a specialist can better handle some specific areas like Economy or Environment. But you don't need to be an expert for this. You already have all the data from your team, you just need to make the most efficient decision based on utilitarianism and your experience. Most of the big tech CEO are not a hard core programmer or domain expert, Eg: Steve Jobs, Satya Nadella or Sundar Pichai. If they start gaining expertise on each and every product they launch, it will be impossible to work at that level. As you become senior, your most important quality is how you delegate, use your team effectively and be right most of the time. A senior IAS officer job is nothing different. They act as an enabler and facilitator. It is not about one can not gain the expertise of a particular domain, it is really unnecessary. Whole department is there for you to present all the possible options, as a leader, you need to your judgement to find the most suitable option among them. It is not very difficult to learn any field in this era of AI, where every information is at your finger tips. This can be easily done as and when required. My personal experience, I have seen the most effectively run team in the top tech with the manager not an expert Software Engineer, not even a Software Engineering experience, they just know how to use the team most effectively and what product should the team should focus on.

[@varunms850]

@@AbhishekKumar-yv6ih They have mandate of the people, the greatest qualification in a democracy.

[@bismarck9938]

He is IAS, Almighty expertise!!

[@psenthilkumaran6092]

Field experts are more qualified than IAS officers. So mix is better. Well done Modiji.

[@ChiranjeeviViswaTejaJupudi]

Why does Print feel so sad that IAS is gettign sidelined for other services. Are there some long term investments which got affected?

[@selfrealisation646]

Absolutely not. It's only task is to criticize the NDA govt. If influence of IAS is increased in the present government, then they will criticize that the influence of IAS is increasing during the government.

[@Violina65]

Coz the print favors reservation 😅😅

[@WARRIORisLives]

Because they don’t get any favours from bjp

[@rishipramanick6823]

It is termed as horses for courses In Agri medical aviation u need to find people from these respective background otherwise policy won't be framed properly ministers should also be from these fields like we had harshvardhan he used to be health minister we have vaishnav iit graduate in railways

[@nivanbagchi]

Sanya Dhingra low-key consistently delivers high engagement videos. She has a natural pulse for journalism.

[@Violina65]

Very Good. Best way to counter the Cancer of Quota Policy😊😊

[@lalityay]

Lateral hires may have short term focus rather than long term vision, they may show political favours than career development, demotivate and may have conflicts with regular IAS officers and lack bureaucratic skills. Why not hire them as contractors for their skills.

[@schadenfreudeegoism7485]

This

[@atokimruk937]

India needs smart problem solvers, not fools who memorize for " Eggjams" ( Exams), vomit, get first class first but are unable to do anything applied or practical in real life. So Modi bringing in smart problem silvers and go-getters is the best thing that has happened.

[@dikshitakalita3527]

If you think, UPSC is all about memorising, it goes on to show your scewed knowledge of this exam, or in your way "eggjam"

[@mahalak4383]

Lol..looks like somebody doesn't know anything about IAS selection.

[@nishant54]

Absolutely they are rote learners and kaala angrez. Nothing creative or indian about them.​@@dikshitakalita3527

[@schadenfreudeegoism7485]

If you think UPSC is just about brainlessly mugging up shit you’re clearly delusional. The exam process is highly competitive, dynamic and unpredictable. For someone to clear it means they are analytical, problem solving and people who get shit done. This isn’t a board exam.

[@ManishJha-t3p]

Very good decision, that's how the powerful countries work.

[@shekhar2005]

This is what you can come up when you have half baked knowledge. EO Division in DoPT which does all these appointments is headed by IAS only. Still most of the additional secretary and secretary posts are manned by IAS only. It is just as JS level and below level IAS are less willing to come and their respective cadres also sometimes do not relieve them. Many services officers are happier in their cadre that is the sole reason of skewed representation. Railway off late has been tasked with lots of heavy work and monitoring due which their officers are coming more on deputation at centre. Plus continued long Delhi posting is also a criteria for many to come on central deputation.

[@marsplanet128]

You are right 👍... IAS is still not sidelined... They are ruling the system

[@harshvardhangarhwal6885]

So much more to cover But what a start.. thank you print

[@nv9991]

Manmohan spent 40+ years in the system. He was most experienced and qualified to make these changes. But he didn't. A person who is perfect on resume may not be best on actual performance. I don't like Modi for "camera consciousness" & Some unscientific statements he makes once in a while... but we can definitely say that he has demanded a massive cultural shift in top-babu culture. He made these entitled lobbies start delivering with timebound commitments. he has still not managed the total shift, but Babus has already felt the heat. Modi also took away their "lucrative" "side benefits" opportunities. What is the point of being top babu, if I can't walk into some club and demand a "free membership" or "get a few free return tickets for my wife's summer vacation" or "get a few free franchisees for top car brand for my son". What is the point of slogging with time pressures without these side "lucrative" benefits? Working in state secretariats is much more comfortable as it still works the old way.

[@GEMINI033]

Yep why only top level service chiefs should be an ias and ips officer and most of them are shitty

[@singhm4709]

Mars me rahata hai? Bjp under states had failed in their own criteria, check their own published data

[@nv9991]

@@singhm4709 So? We were discussing manmohan and modi getting work done from Central babus. Why are you changing goal post to states? May be.. Hate for bjp/modi has overpowered your rationality?

[@Kalinga_3]

70% of secretaries & 65% additional secretaries are still IAS That shows leadership positions are still under IAS

[@climatepact245]

Don't spread as will be shrinked too😂😂

[@amrit0501]

wait for few years 😂

[@deepakthirdreich]

@@amrit0501 and why would it affect you?

[@sivaganeshk123]

It will shrink

[@ankurkumar55]

38% bro research well

[@WARRIORisLives]

Domain experts have realistic experience, that they can boosted the Indian growth to next label.. Modi govt did the best decision… Keep it up…

[@AM07638]

For a wider reach, kindly present the Hindi version of this report.

[@_aidid]

How about Hindi dubbing?

[@GaneshSrinivas-y4l]

For wide reach please continue in english. Whole world doesn't speak Hindi but a little english everywhere

[@nousername1587]

​@@GaneshSrinivas-y4lthe world doesn't care about India. In India maximum people understand Hindi

[@ashokdahiya8154]

IAS very much required to be cut to size, their attitude is like,,goras,, and only put speed breakers everywhere. IAS is required to be changed totally,90% r Deadwood

[@abhimanyugupta532]

🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone

[@tendrhurt]

Making the system meritocratic is the best thing that happened to GOI. There should be no entitlement based on cadre, seniority, etc. The promotions should be purely based on merit - domain expertise, hard work, probity, ability to make and implement effective policies, etc. Let them sweat it like the private sector managers to earn their promotions. We don’t need bunch of entitled politicians or bureaucrats running the country to ground like the previous administrations did.

[@1984sib]

It's Modi Management. Non-IAS should be promoted more. That's why Bharat is developing internally and we are becoming more powerful and leading towards a five trillion economy.

[@pmt7483]

A good thing. We need experts not entitled people at the helm.

[@ArawnOfAnnwn]

Watch the vid - this isn't about expertise. They're shuffling around babus into agencies that don't match their domains at all. The only difference is that the babus being favored now are fully loyal to the centre rather than also work at the state level.

[@riturajroy2136]

3 lateral entry position -Joint secretaries

[@pamdogra]

Modi is doing a great job. He is the only one who has National Interest at heart and innovation in blood.

[@helpfullyhonest7767]

One of my neighbors, who comes from a Hindi literature background, is currently serving as an IAS officer in Gujarat and has recently been appointed as the Managing Director of Gujarat Medical Services Corporation Limited. While I respect his position, I strongly believe that such critical roles should be assigned to individuals with relevant expertise. Even though he is an IAS officer, I am confident that someone with a medical or healthcare background would be better suited to do justice to this position. This highlights the need for reforms to ensure specialized appointments for technical and vital roles-something commendably being emphasized by Modi's administration.

[@wasteyourtimenow5290]

Indian economic service should get finance ministy to lead as nodal officer not ias.😊

[@5h1kh4rV3rm4]

As someone who’s planning to do a masters in economics and give upsc ies, I agree.

[@akbarali-fh4rb]

Despite being a Pakistani and sheer critique of Modi, I agree with Modi Govt decision.

[@nv9991]

sheer critique of Modi, ...... What difference does Modi or (anyone from India) make to your life. Tu kyu begani shandi me Abdulla ban raha hai? I don't care who becomes PM or CM in Afghanistan unless that person sending terrarist into India or that person is pushing illegal migrants into India. Modi is not doing either of that with Pakistan. Tu kyu faltu me uska critique ban raha hai? Is it "Umhha ka Chumma" business troubling you?

[@india3572]

Who cares😂btw tu pakistani yaha critique karne wajay teri islamic democracy ko karo😂army hai jo harne ke baad bhi medal leke ghumati hai aur log islamic law aur under army dusre ko criticise kar rahe hai 😂 respect toh nahi tha par tum log gadhe ki bhi level par kar chuke hai 😂

[@xcel5203]

​@@nv9991 STFU , speak for yourself. Have seen the number of Andhbhakts who infest cross-border channels with crap . Learn to appreciate others views .

[@nv9991]

@@xcel5203 Andhbhaktss who have opinions about Pakistani politicians are as stupid as this gentleman is.... unless that Pakistani ledership is encouraging sending terrorist or illegal migrants into India. Then victim has right to comment on other state. Like afgani have right to have opinion about President Bush. You seem to lack basic logic behind "mind your business" phrase.

[@nv9991]

@@xcel5203 Is "Umhha ka Chumma" business troubling you too?

[@harrysaran7730]

I personally know 4 of my classmates who wasted their time/life to become IAS. 3 of them are working in call centers and 1 who was successful, moved to Europe after 5 years of service.

[@AlokKumar-sr3cq]

Lateral entry and selection from medical , technology engineering teaching agricultural and weather specialist must be selected as joint secretary rather than only civil services of different services

[@skgautam486]

I think this is right decision because specialist do better work in special area rather than ias

[@SathyaswamyS]

Unpopular opinions 1. IPS should be abolished and police recruits should start at constable or SI level. 2. The title of collector should be replaced with district administrative officer.

[@Sahil-xoxo]

So what’s the problem . Domain specialisation is necessary for healthy growth

[@aniMesh100BC]

We don't need babu, we need experts 👍

[@dilippawar9099]

Good move by modi... Ias is worst Beauracrcy who behave like British gora saheb.. Experts should be officer instead of ias babu

[@prithvi9727]

This☝️was necessary despite the misgivings. I hope IAS gets diminished further through appropriate checks and balances considering the lateral entrants. IFS too needs a major overhaul with more cadre.

[@ArawnOfAnnwn]

Watch the vid - there's hardly any lateral entry. All the centre is doing is pushing out govt. employees who work at both the central and state level, in favor of employees who only ever work for the centre i.e. are more loyal to delhi.

[@prithvi9727]

@@ArawnOfAnnwn Yes - I got that view as well but I stated my own conclusion based on the video. Yes men will persist no matter which government but getting lateral entrants apart from IAS cadre is a small but essential step - is what I was trying to point out.

[@MrDeltaNoir]

Govt is being slow and careful. It is obvious where this is heading. Let the youth channel energy into industry and skills instead of wasting their youth behind rote learning exams that will boost their dowry. Modi has the receipts, he has experience running able administrations and gave India its fastest developing state - Gujarat. Trust the process

[@prithvi9727]

@@MrDeltaNoir I approve this☝️comment wholeheartedly. Well put .. rather very well put. The time India gets this dowry baiting (mal)practice that has seeped into our culture out of its system, that'll mark the true beginning of the revival of not just the economy but also Indian ethos, culture.

[@mahalak4383]

If govt is deciding, they may hire people who are pro govt than who are actually good at their field.

[@ImmigrantTribe]

Great move by Modi Govt. Every chair needs to be shaken once in a while to do away with the comfort and entitlement. Even the ministers face election every five years.

[@ankittiwari-ex2tu]

Thats a good step....consistency. Reings hegemony in buerocracy

[@ratanbhattacharjee7233]

Modi Govt's reliance on officers with doubtful integrity who in return for freedom of Corruption will do everything for image management of Modiji. Chairman's of UPSC NTA, Governors ,LEA Judiciary.

[@Brokeearther]

Its a good reform. Skill level must be given priority.

[@spashtvakta]

Saw it in a reel earlier last yr, thank you for the details 🎉

[@Me-ws5zt]

Finally Phunshook wangroo getting job rather than Chatur Ramalingam.

[@alok5402]

Extremely good report🎉🎉🎉 Keep up the good work. 🎉🎉🎉

[@Kalinga_3]

One more thing you missed is the fact that with Technology, the very work and need for "ground experience" is reducing. And with think tanks like NITI Aayog, the policy level work of Joint secretaries is not relevant. IAS officers have good state level exposure and later worked as policy experts in senior positions Now the very work of these positions has become more execution driven, administerial and technology oriented, making it easier even for officers from other cadres to work in these positions.

[@raghavendravishwas5929]

One of the few good works done by Modi

[@MrPoornakumar]

Work of UPSC board, partly (33%) gets undone, it means. The missed then (in interview) are given a second life, to prove their worth. Also there is switching (of personnel) between various services. Yet the difference between policy & implementation (in say, Dirctorates) remains & needs a fresh look.

[@FINDMYDEVICERAVIDAS]

It's a great move by the government Now all the relatives of politicians will join all higher posts ful democracy now it's just like monarchy right

[@salimsayed5839]

Excellent video, thanks for sharing and enlightenment on the issue.

[@loadrunnergaming]

Modi sir is truely gr8❤

[@abhibuddy2]

Interestingly, not a single mention of the True domain experts like Indian Economic Service and Indian Statistical Service, who are the Central Services with specific domain expertise and also well equipped with the functioning of the Central Government

[@sbasu5859]

Please send out an RTI query for the no. of Addl. Secy and Secy posts that are presently staffed only by IAS officers.

[@monmayurigogoi9000]

The anither harsh reality is, people who are against the IAS postings are the same who will never clear the preliminary test in their entire life, if made to sit for.

[@AbdulMannan-yq7xy]

its good to breakk the nexus posed by ias lobby, high headedness and corruption is epitome is the service

[@copingthecope]

Off with this colonial system 🎉

[@menezesl]

Good wprk by NaMo

[@TapanSarkar100]

Many IAS officers also opt for central deputation for huge work load and in many cases states do not release officers whom Centre appoint in Delhi. Modiji has changed babu culture to a great extent.

[@rangavesa2016]

Chandigarh mayor election is good example for paritisan officer.

[@anime_co_in]

A team of generalists and a team of specialist would be defeated by a team of generalists and specialists

[@nileshmishra4602]

Very informative video

[@psriram6641]

I think the point that is missed is that in the "olden days", IAS officers used to be brought in to head all sectors, even things like railways, where they did not / do not spend time in lower levels. So, all subordinate officers would be of the respective stream (railways or P & T or whatever), but the higher level joint secretary and above would come from IAS - this was supposedly so that the "leadership" would be under direction of the central government, even if they were unfamiliar with the sector. Current government policy has done away with this and is posting railways people to lead railways segments, P & T people to lead P & T segments, Audit and Accounts people to lead ... and along with that, some get posted to other segments where they may contribute usefully, just like IAS officers. After all, they are all selected on the same exam process but given different alphabet designations based on their rank and choice. To draw a parallel from engineering, IIT engineers may be the top picks, but they are not the only capable of effective actions. One might even argue that there may be more effective participants from "lower down" the pecking order ...

[@eduvisionary]

The silent elephant in the room that canNOT be spoken about: RSS. Officially, no figures will be available for how many of our bureaucrats are current or former members of RSS or affiliates. Yet, this is the obvious source the BJP would look at if they wanted a bureaucracy ideologically committed to Hindutva.

[@GautamMahara-k1q]

Media choses what stories to run - so the question is who is asking you to make this a news after 10 years .

[@amrit0501]

smart

[@Prat-zi1ou]

why do people of your kind think world is against them in every point of life

[@abhimanyugupta532]

🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone

[@adityavikramsingh9483]

​@@Prat-zi1ouwhy is print so sad with this change, when most Indians and other services are welcoming it.

[@HarmanHundal01]

Aren’t these chamchas of the 56 inch tongue satisfied with having Godi media that they want the Print to not show this either?

[@asimbandyopadhyay8433]

You look stunning Ma'm in your presentation as well as in your sleeveless.

[@Ceo-tv7mc]

All officer are in favour of Modi government

[@elsa407]

Also many of us we don't aim for upsc for the sake of serving the nation but rather for the personal perks that this title brings.

[@_aidid]

Administrators should be recruited based on their merit and knowledge of certain fields rather than general knowledge

[@xyz5409]

Great explanation

[@tanmoymitra22]

Why top posts be restricted to IAS officers in Government? Other Group A services are also at same level of pay and there are equally high calibre officers in these cadres......IAS hegemony is not doing desired service to the nation in the year 2024

[@bitpat81]

This is because most of the IAS officers do not want to go on Central deputation They want to remain in their parent state cadre.

[@nishant54]

😂😂 who cares about what they wishes.

[@ManishJha-t3p]

Deserving candidates are now getting equal opportunity

[@videomagazine3718]

The history of Indian Administration started during British time and given only to the Royal importance. Not to the people of India. It means lack of unemployment, many so poor, no importance to per capita income, etc.

[@abhishekyadav2191]

good decision.

[@vishalattri8854]

Now, upper middle class who were enjoying the destruction of lower middle class purchasing power while chanting modi modi started feeling the heat. Nothing left in the hands of middle class, so they ( government and billionaire friends) are now going after the upper middle class, which can be shown in the last budget. First, all jobs under group B,C,D were converted to contractual basis. Now, they started cutting group A jobs.

[@BijayK21p8Q-je6lm]

That's a good thing. Ias will be reduced to few department only

[@hardeeprajput5667]

10:16 it is not slogging in work. It the demand of the post or call it law of nature. Power demand attention.

[@joydip9044]

The Civil servants from other services or should also be given chance So many aspirants who waste their seat by giving attempt once again which creates more pressure for those who are appearing first time will get lessen

[@piyushrawat6188]

May This Govt. Will Appoint A Senior Captain As A Head Of Directorate General Of Shipping Instead Of Non Marine Background Director General Of Shipping Mainly (IAS) DG Shipping Rules And Fees Structure Is Too High It Is Difficult For A Seafarer To Bear The Cost Of Courses And All Formalities (Mainly For Freshers) Or Who Are Struggling In Small Companies.. Please...IAS Is Not God...

[@bijoylyngdoh9516]

We need hardwork over domain expert

[@indian5626]

Good decision by Govt

[@rahulverma949]

Why lateral entry is require, you need domain expertise right? but IAS are also domain experts, years of study for just to crack the exam(that to be with their specialized domain subject), and then training(2 years), then assistantship(12 weeks) and after serving for at least 16 years in their domain they become joint secretary, aren't they become domain specialist? and if an IAS is corrupted because of the power and perks then it will gonna happen with the lateral entry officers too. and the most important thing is it is unconstitutional because minority, girls and backward class peoples are less likely to be domain experts in india, and the exam gives them a chance to stand out. If domain expert is too good then any IAS officers then apart from UPSC their must be an exam for domain experts too to avoid any chance of favoritism, providing reservation to backward class, minority and girls. Don't think all IAS officers are same they are also expert in their domain.

[@ROHIT690THAKUR]

Modi is streamlining and overhauling bureaucracy in India. Lobg term vision is really good in Infrastructure, Defence, setting Manufacturing factories.

[@rohitsah1265]

This is a leadership of Narendra Modi ❤

[@abhimanyugupta532]

🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫 Here is a list of good things that happened in India and the men/women behind it. Glaring is the absence of the IAS: 1)Public Transportation - E. Sreedharan (Metroman, Indian Engineering Service Officer) 2)Information Technology Revolution - N.R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys), Azim Premji (Wipro) 3)Space Revolution - DR APJ Kalam , Vikram Sarabhai, Satish Dhawan 4)Green Revolution - Swaminathan 5) White Revolution - Verghese Kurien 6)Aadhaar Revolution - Nandan Nilekani 7)Telecom - Sam Pitroda 8)Blue Revolution(FIsheries) - Hiralal Chaudhuri and Arun Krishnan And many more. What do you see the IAS in the news for these days? 1) 800 crore found in IAS house 2) IAS officer has 500 crore wealth 3) IAS officer found collecting Rs2-3 crore daily 4) IAS invoved in 2000 crore liquor scam 5) Pooja Singhal in a MGNREGA Scam and some 100+ cash recovered 6) Chief secretary taking 20 girls to his house for "job for sex scandal" 7) IAS has resorts worth 90 crore 8) Train derailments on rise under IAS Ashwini Vaishnav. 9) Who is this IAS officer dancing with Sunny Leone

[@swagatabhaumik978]

I don't find any logic that an IRS or IPS or Railway Service officer is not a domain expert for rural service etc. or jobs performed by IAS officers if that needs more management skills, public relations etc. than technical knowledge? Any good administrator can do such jobs. The point is efficiency in administration and management skills and public relations skills, which anyone working as IRS or IPS or Railway Service can achieve.

[@sreejith-g8l]

DRDO director tanu jain a dentist, why we should settle for a generalist at highly technical leadership role if we have the best minds in the country working in some foreign countries who will be ready to comeback and serve for the country

[@SyedAliAkbar-sp3uk]

This is in one way good, because all these years IAS means " I am superior" IAS persons were under impression that they know every thing in the world. And country could not progress much because of them. This is in one way bad also because under BJP rule mainly Brahamins will occupy top posts . Nagpur effect.

[@mahalak4383]

We need more ethical people than so called experts.

[@AG-cv7fx]

We need more technoracts , people with specialization in those domains and not Babus who think they're born with Brahma Gyan and can do everything.

[@kartikmore9228]

Add cronies in govt without any transparent rigid process and enjoy corruption 😊

[@BhajjiDiGaddi]

So before Modi .. all IAS officers were not corrupt, everything was perfect , iAS officers were not aligned to political parties or particular politicians and did not do or accepted favours .

[@shivam.1984]

​@@BhajjiDiGaddi IAS officer was constitution binded And come under Scanner any time And there Promotion On the basis of ACR Where These out sider come there is any Source. Is Govt of india is Corporate office Or The Govt Office.

[@BhajjiDiGaddi]

@@shivam.1984 there rank also comes under constitution..do u even know who these people are …one of them is confounded of Infosys, people who are IIT , IIM , Harvard , Ex CEO or president from corporate world who are expert in there field and who can give better results in high growth areas because of there expertise which an IAS does not possess because they have not worked in those fields ever .

[@thebestevertherewas]

​@@shivam.1984 Meh, technological shift happens through researchers and domain experts not Bureaucrats. Babus are the greatest threat to the economy of India 'the US innovates, China imitates, and and the India regulates. Lets innovate with the times, instead of stifling innovation. Manmohan spent 40+ years in the system. He was most experienced and qualified to make these changes. But he didn't. A person who is perfect on resume may not be best on actual performance

[@sin24586]

Only criteria for selection is loyalty to the ruling dispensation…this domain expertise is all BS. Govt for all needs will hire a state service officer as cab secretary 😂

[@urmilaprabhakarambaskarA-wk1cx]

I assure you Madam that the Collective Intelligence Of Indian Beurocracy in times to come is going to be lowered and also of our PSUs including vital organisationns like DRDO,ISRO in this Industry 4.0 times which has already begun. Example is ISRO chairman had visited IIT Pawai , students listened to him keenly but when he told them the packages at ISRO,half of the students simply walked out. Its a elaborate subject Madam But I will window it up here. Thank you Madam for bringing this to us 🙏

[@MrDeltaNoir]

Space researchers should find better opportunities in the pvt sector. That's exactly what the govt of the day with popular mandate wants. With due respect, PSUs were important for the era they were put together in...but the world has changed.

[@urmilaprabhakarambaskarA-wk1cx]

@@MrDeltaNoir True Sir 🙏

[@lone_warrior665]

Meritocracy should always be promoted

[@AvinashYadav_8]

IAS role should be for OBC, ST/SC OR other reserve categories only. For so called more civilised or forward moving should put for non-ias roles. How will this make up the sense for the story.