How Pakistan got the nuclear bomb & then walked away from a peace deal

[@ThePrintIndia]

Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/

[@AliB19]

Remember this. India's second tests on May 13 were a failure, not detected on seismic signatures. Both times there was seismic activity from Pakistani tests on May 28 and May 30., producing close 5 scale earthquakes and India's tests failed on May 13 and the ones on May 11 was relatively smilar in size to Pakistan, yet Indians claim to have megaton bombs when their tests failed . Such laughable behavior from Indians. Look up up Seismo berkely pakistan and india tests data, and independent third-party verifiable unbiased report on both country's tests.

[@sabtaingopinath9652]

The Indians obsession with Pakistan continues.....

[@muhammadburhanzahid9435]

endians 😂

[@breaking324]

Pakistanis obsession with fake profile names impersonating indians 😂

[@afurqans]

Incorrect information. 1994 Benazir Bhutto was Prime Minister of Pakistan. There are several distorted facts and historical inaccuracies in this vlog

[@ChandranPrema123]

Thanks to our Communists😅

[@gauravmarathe3730]

Most of the time, I don’t understand what you want to say. Your narration is so tangled, it feels like a maze. We’re not here for an English lesson. Maybe take a page from your boss's book. The Print really needs to work on this. Every time I listen to you, it's like a game of topic hopscotch, and I never find the context.

[@Realist839]

go and listen to Palki Sharma...this kind of classic commentary is beyond you

[@Fogofwar99]

Yeah the bald guy is better, such a good topic but he couldn’t present it very well

[@Fogofwar99]

@@Realist839haha lol palki is the neogodi media. I hate her underlying attitude

[@hamzaasadullah9118]

Exactly, this is what I was thinking while watching the video. I remembered the iconic dialogue from a movies, "aray bhai kehna kya chahte ho?"

[@TirchmirTirchmir]

How did India get the nuclear Bomb?

[@AbdiazizzAbbulahi]

They'll never tell you because the idea was to arm india and make it as a disciplinary power to pakistan but the opposite just came to light and everyone was bitter while can't do anything about it Had a pakistani never thought a head of time we would have seen american forces on the ground doing what it's best known for "regime change" while being hosted in india We've seen Afghanistan for instance america stayed for 20 years to reinstate taliban even stronger than what they found

[@peptalk7658]

Don't you know, Indian scientists gave USA the blueprint. India is biggest Subarbower! The only reason it buys all its weapons from abroad is to help the global economy. INDIA, INDIA INDIA INDIAAAAAA

[@MrHumanforlife]

"India was willing to walk back if the rest of the world did. Obviously, the rest of the world didn't." Absolutely delusional statement

[@biorig]

Look at this education dude - doesn't understand India's position that continues to this day. Our position remains unchanged - We are the only nuclear powered proponents of universal nuclear disarmament.

[@studytime2570]

Why? Its a true statement.

[@biorig]

@@Jun_kid Yes, but nukes are now useless. Look at Russia. The way to win wars today is by attrition, economics, energy and population. India has to keep its demographic dividend lasting for another 50 years, invest in military complex, new energy sources and that is more potent than any nuke.

[@MarxistNationalist]

Beggaristani 🇵🇰 spotted 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jitmick]

Bhutto as a proponent of the Pak Army was hand in glove with them, let's understand that even a Pak civilian establishment is as enmical as their military bosses

[@romm2885]

Indians must not forget that Pakistan is country of 230 million people. Was divided into two, encountered Operation meghdoot in 1984, have insurgency perpetrated by RAW, continuously facing anti Pakistan government in India which has adventured in balakot and has ambitions to minimise Pakistan due to its weak showdown in recent elections. Most of the Indians think that India can coerce Pakistan due to its economic and political vulnerabilities. I would say they are badly mistaken. In case of any misadventure, Pakistan will respond resolutely and forcefully without thinking about the consequences. I am not saying all this out of some wishful myth but determination Pakistan has to reposed against Indian aggression. 🎉🎉🎉

[@zubairmohd2021]

Pakistan will respond with-out a second thought.. No Mandir and no Gantas !!

[@jitmick]

Bhikariyo...apna passport aur katora sambhal

[@modikiaisikitaisi5363]

Narrator forgot to mention that India lost the war with China in 1962 and lost territories that is still the case.😂

[@Nikraj789]

Please do not forget RAAW and Israel offered to destroy Pakistan nuclear facilities, and PM Desai sold RAAW to Pakistan.

[@snd9826]

Stop living in delusional world if indian propaganda. American had been on record there was no way to stop Pakistan from making nuclear weapons. It was a very thought out plan from the very beginning. Pakistan nuclear sites were literally impenetrable. American even thought of dropping millions of mines to make Kahuta non-functional at the end it was decided it cannot be done.

[@GGG-io1br]

American use German scientists and their experience to invent technology for nuclear test, the same technology transfer to UK and France, USSR use the said technology and experience for their nuclear bomb and transfer it to China. India use the same method and test their nuclear weapons........ Pakistan use the latest centrifuge method. It is the known fact that the first use of a science method is called invention and later are just copying or stealing the invented technology and India is also one of the countries involved in stealing nuclear technology.....

[@ShoaibKhan-no9nu]

ISI👿🇵🇰💪

[@ImtiazKhan-vk9jo]

The tea is fantastic...😅

[@jackthumberstone7935]

The tea was awesome

[@AndrewLambert-wi8et]

THIS IS EXACTLY HOW THINGS GET GOING. ALWAYS FIRST AN IDEA AND THE HUMBLY BEGINNINGS WITH A SMPLE LETTER TO THE RIGHT PERSON.

[@umarchaudhry5009]

Why did India test it's nuclear arsenal again?

[@VijayBalan-x4z]

An important aspect to this story is the Pressler Amendment, and how the US administration 'looked the other away' and certified that Pakistan was not pursuing the bomb (as required by Pressler), because the US needed Pak support during the Afghan anti-Soviet jihad.

[@JojoBoy-gh4gb]

It was the Communist Chinese that hand delivered a fully functioning plutonium bomb along with its design along the Karakoram Highway , from a test in Lop Nur in 1966…handed over a plate to the Pakistanis who were overjoyed. Chinese subsequently also brazenly proliferated miniaturised tactical nuke warheads to the Pakistanis . All this happened while self declared Americans and European Non Proliferation warriors looked the other away , it happened in broad daylight 😂😂😂, making a mockery of the NPT and NSG. 😂😂😂😂

[@Junaid-Jutt236]

feeling sad for your Whatsapp university knowledge 😊 level of your maturity

[@snd9826]

​@@Junaid-Jutt236sadly their level of maturity is 100 time less than what you think. Their hatred for Pakistan and fake superiority complex make them delusional. These are the people who blindly believe every propaganda which can boost their moral.

[@shahidahsan6507]

1000% Wrong. Pakistan's Nuclear bomb is a uranium one!

[@9GHOST1PARASF]

@@Junaid-Jutt236 it's public and acknowledged by americans themselves but worry not in your shi*y madrasa you are taught that you made the aataam bamb my foot

[@9GHOST1PARASF]

@@snd9826 yes we are more mature more powerfull more rich .Real superiority complex mr beggars cannot be choosers.Same with you you believe in every s*it taught in madrasa by maulana

[@chimtiazafzaljutt9392]

Dear, when describing technical and scientific things ,please don't bring hatred and propaganda in that. Thanks.

[@salahuddinorakzai7062]

Just get over it , India’s dream of becoming a hegemonic power in the region is history 😊

[@mukhtarh3133]

Why don't you tell how India got the nuclear bomb?

[@IrfanKhan-nu6iu]

One side of the picture described , it seems that India didn’t did any thing wrong & pakistan didn’t did a single fair thing regarding Producing nuclear weapons on both sides of the border 😂

[@KantilalPatel-o1j]

You need to improve your English first.

[@ajayrawat-bf9pc]

You are free to make an episode of out Nuke programme. Pak and China have been the worst proliferator.

[@RashadMunawar-q8u]

Ha ha ha 🤣😂🤣 Khan didn't steal any blueprint but he had names of company from where he could get parts required to enrich Uranium. Even a Msc student knows how to build an Atomic Bomb but only components is Enriched Uranium.

[@jagdishtalreja1014]

You missed out on China’s role in the design and test of Pakistan’s nuclear weapon with the chic-4 design tested in 1984 in Lop Nor.

[@subrasivaram7336]

"if you pay them enough they will even sell their mother" - AQ Khan about western companies selling nuclear components.

[@TantraySirPhysicsClasses]

How such a person can be so intelligent and so biased but unfortunately he happens to be both

[@mahmoodcheema7907]

Biased comments

[@Rehanharis777]

you call yourself journalist and make this video with distorted facts and historical inaccuracies

[@mshaikh4879]

It is said that while qadeer and bhutto started before zia took over but it is zia who mainly made and completed project by 1982 , within five years of his takeover . But this effort of peaceful nuclear technology goes back to time before ayub . Munir Ahmed was charged with delaying nuclear not enhancing it . Qadeer did not steal anything and charge of proliferation he denied . I would not write more but presenter must read book by kausar niazi , aur line cut gai , who was right hand man of bhutto . It is not a well researched presentation

[@gwarlow]

Hey, if Israel can have nukes then why not Pakistan. Actually I wish that there were zero nukes, but hey, that ain’t gonna happen. 😢

[@rahulanand4385]

Fantastic Report. Really Liked it

[@fahmad7194]

The million dollar question: Is Pakistan's nuclear bomb really Pakistan's?

[@jmkjmk434]

The million dollar question: Are you really stupid ?

[@biorig]

Status Quo is okay for India. Pakistan's nuclear weapons are a waste of time, energy and resources since they do not add anything to disrupt the status quo. Pakistan is no better now that it was before it got nuclear weapons.

[@Hujjathullah-fz7qh]

Did India's deployment of nukes change its status quo vi's a vi's China ? China took millions of its people out of poverty, even with nukes the Indian lower classes and the poor are still stuck in poverty. Is India's nukes not a wastage too ? 😂

[@HashiramaSenyu]

This Status quo is OK for china too. As long as india is landlocked in the north by pak and China it won't ever be a full fledged regional power let alone a super power. It will always have to rely on the west for support and we know how west supports😉. Given that india has begun to lose friends in the region since 2019 like the afghan govt in 2021 and recently in maldives. Nepal, bangladesh are also on their way to distance themselves from india. This policy of maintaining this inherently futile status quo is going to cost india a lot in the long run.

[@HashiramaSenyu]

Indian policy makers should find a way to make peace with at least one among China and pakistan

[@biorig]

@@HashiramaSenyu Blah blah blah. China is a failing power that briefly shined. With its population decline, we will see China in the next 1000 years.

[@indian9632]

​@@HashiramaSenyuthe way things are fine as its now for India. in few years China is gonna fight the west and find out the hard reallity. That buys India few decades to become untouchable

[@bobwiggle4533]

Monkeys are still fighting in the comments. Don't realise they are the same species

[@VictimHood-qv1hx]

Pak nuclear weapons are like a person buying Mercedes but doesn’t have money for petrol.

[@romm2885]

Self satisfying Indian Wishful myths.

[@hamzaasadullah9118]

You'd never see a man buying Mercedes but can't afford it. That's the mindset of a poor man that I could see through your comment.

[@VictimHood-qv1hx]

@@hamzaasadullah9118 Bhutto said we will eat grass , but will make atom bumb. Wish has come true

[@srinivasulumekala8308]

He tries to complicate analysis of simple issues to credit himself as a mysterious know-all defence expert. Most of what he shows off is ancient history, some of it is even BS. As for Bharat's genuine defence interests, this man should never be taken seriously, he is the biggest MC.

[@AA-bn9rg]

Your research is not fact based Pakistan acquired facility long before

[@AndrewLambert-wi8et]

SO IRAN IS BUILDING REPROCESSING PLANTS. THIS MEANS I WAS RIGHT AGAIN BECAUSE K SAID IRAN BUILDING PLUTONIUM BOMBS. NOT URANIUM BOMBS. IRAN WILL USE THE BLUEPRINTS FOR THE CHINESE URANIUM IMPLOSION DESIGN THAT THEY GOT FROM PAKISTAN BUT INSTEAD USE PLUTONIUM.

[@susharma9560]

Speakers with dentures should be avoided. Appears his mouth is full of butter.

[@aftabiqbal8347]

yea ...butter chicken

[@ThePolymerisst]

😂😂

[@mohammedmir777]

How did India got their Nuclear Bomb 💣. Have of the country lived on the footpaths at that time. 1975.

[@vinsin328]

hmm... Morarji Desai was given Nishan-e-Pakistan (Citizenship) for helping the Pakistan Nuclear Bomb Program and supporting terrorism in J&K. He accepted that.

[@Sid-MMA]

😂😂😂its not their citizenship, its just an honorary medal which they only give to foreign head of states and other dignitaries. From Iranians, to Qatris , to Chinese, to Saudis ,Tutks and dozens of others countries heads .... Even west Indian cricketer Darren Sammy got one in 2020 😂😂😂😂

[@romm2885]

You should have given to Nawaz sharif

[@ImtiazKhan-vk9jo]

Gobarbhakhts are funny materials..😅

[@1sagstermaster]

How India got the nuclear bomb & walked away with a peace treaty . Million dollar 💰 question ⁉️

[@ranjitpal9937]

Praveen Swami Sir , Please make a Video On Comparison of Pakistani Nuclear Weapon with Indian 🇮🇳 N Weapons

[@intikhabhussainmirza1975]

Excellent vlog but one sided story.

[@sakshambhadoria9998]

Military establishment and political class in Pakistan uses their power assymetry with India as a justification for the increase in defence budget and their rent seeking behaviour which results in corruption and public offices for these individuals. Development and economic growth is a casualty in this vicious cycle. These conditions along with rapid islamisation of society bred militant and radical organisations which threaten to disrupt the status quo resulting in continuous increase in resources for the uniform. External patron which provides diplomatic and security cover is also required. Earlier, the US played that role now its Bejing.

[@1sagstermaster]

Bangladesh will be the next to acquire nuclear capabilities from Pakistan and China

[@mshaikh4879]

But one thing which presenter fears underneath is correctly that reckless focusless coalition under Modi is ideal for nuclear confrontation . As long as pathans fear pakistan india reconciliation will reduce political space and economic benefits on both sides of border on afghan durand line reconciliation cannot come , same hardliners in india need to be tackled first , then will china like pakistan india detente or will iran like it , EU might not too .. nuclear confrontation is writing on the wall .

[@surendrabarsode8959]

1. Pravin is giving us the same message, though in nice words, that Mani Shankar Ayer delivered rather crudely a couple of weeks ago!! Anyway, what else one can expect from sickular gang in this country? 2. So let us be clear - first, India should NOT have anything to do with Pakistan- no friendship, no investments, no trade; any trade with it means we are financing terrorism against us and drug smuggling inside India. Second, let us watch how internal issues of Pakistan like Baloch and KP movement is sorted and Duran Line is renegotiated with Taliban. Thirdly, Pakistani civil leadership is shameless. Nawaz signed Lahore Agreement with Vajpayee and his Army launched Kargil operation. Thirty years later, Nawaz is trying out the same thing with Modi!! Fourth, J&K issue is over after Art 370 is abrogated. The only issue that is to be sorted out is reunification of GB into India. But that will happen on its own; why bother now?

[@Maverick-zo4kc]

The Print is a mouthpiece of Pakistan. What else can we expect from traitors like Pravin Swami and Shekhar Gupta?

[@ranjitpal9937]

COMPARISON Between India 🇮🇳 vs Pakistan 🇵🇰 " N Weapons " Will Be Hot Potato ?

[@silverimages836]

Pakistan 🇵🇰💪💪💪

[@shahierminhaas2442]

Long live pakistan

[@thePakistanexpress]

Hahaha Cry jhootistaan

[@9GHOST1PARASF]

live in dreams paki randistan

[@PfefferNusse-vr4yo]

well any wonder PK is now a pariah banana republic?

[@ashfaqahmed1865]

Aur India nay Russia ke meded say atom bomb banaya

[@yaqootmir6761]

Yeah pakistan got help and india built its bomb ALL BY ITSELF 😂

[@Kingzombiemyanmar]

imf loan and lodnon apartments make a real superpower. imf loan superpower

[@mohammadirshad3063]

A biased video,pro India point of view,a distorting story.

[@Kingzombiemyanmar]

imf loan pap johns london apartments and chill.

[@feezoo82pk]

yaaar, for GOD sake, i though he will say something intersting, all made up stuff

[@qulzam685]

What a rubbish nerration!

[@maheshadvani8311]

U r too late It seems u were sleeping Pakistan got nuclear bomb more than a decade ago It is History

[@heirapparent3433]

Thank you for letting us know. F*cking Moron. 🤦‍♂️

[@wassuphomies263]

This is a HISTORY episode.

[@Realist839]

u thought this happened last night?! geez, whats up with the intellectual ability of this episode's listeners?! stick to just watching Palki Sharma news bites.

[@parthanandi7151]

Bara pakateo Saab. Why don't you explain straight in stead of with all this old stories. Who has so much of time to listen to it ? Pls come straight to the main story. Thanks. All the best to you .

[@wassuphomies263]

^2 second attention span generation.

[@razahussainshah8173]

It's pretty updated information, but still, in 1984, Zia did cricket diplomacy and warned Rajiv Gandhi point-blank not to mess. Moreover, Pakistan's nuclear program is quite an advanced one, with much better delivery systems.

[@arslanali8998]

Rubbish 😂😂😂😂

[@jackthumberstone7935]

Can you and your viewers not move on? There is nothing your offering to th viewers that can explain indias political landscape Are you hired by modi and his lunatics?