'My Sister Died Due To Medical Negligence, We're Still Fighting for Justice' | The Quint

[@gauravsingh9226]

Brother.. This is our real India... Fight till last breath... Lets be an example...

[@rishavbudhauliya8352]

​@sawal7478 read again.

[@anonymous_guy_]

​@@rishavbudhauliya8352I read it too 😂😂 theek toh bol raha hai woh ❤dey

[@SANAKHAN-di9en]

True

[@tejasvinigouripur2980]

It was not done on purpose. I being a doctor went into anaphylactic shock. And was in ICU one week. There are risks with even simple medicines. And no one will know you are allergic to so and so medicine. Allergy can be from simple rash to sudden death. The doctor or nurse has done nothing purposely to harm the patient, this can happen in any part of the world by any doctor or nurse. For that you need not curse the country. First let us know what is your contribution for your nation, then abusing and trolling

[@muditadhingra4352]

​@@tejasvinigouripur2980true

[@Dfghjdal]

This is anaphylactic reaction. It is unpredictable. It can happen to any medicine. But what we need to know, 1. Is that whether dynapar was indicated here? 2. And whether it was given intravenous or intramuscular. Intravascular is not given usually bcos there's chance of anaphylaxis. 3. Another thing to check is qualifications of doctor and nurse. Now a days lots of unqualified people handle modern medicine without any knowledge. Bcos no one will prescribe dynapar for cold and cough or even for a fever. This is an important issue to be investigated.

[@mgsa5722]

But isn't there an antidote for the reaction? If she was given that she may hv survived

[@aish1027-s2c]

Find out one...

[@Tazzo802]

Yes, adrenaline is given in anaphylaxis

[@bit9374]

It's not as u mentioned "unpredictable" , have u never heard of a test dose ? That is the procedure everywhere, before the entire dose is administered,the procedure is to first inject a test dose to check for an allergic reaction,that is the whole purpose why test dose exists so u saying it's unpredictable doesn't make sense

[@libingeorge3871]

Valid point..test dose are very rarely done in India..that's the truth

[@vivekchavan2579]

Now imagine the standard of doctors passing out this year after cheating in NEET exam.

[@DragonZeeyo]

50,000 Doctors will be there like this. Or hm yha BAMS kr rhe hain.

[@razahasnain9326]

Max hospital Patparganj

[@medico877]

Im also doing BAMS ​@@DragonZeeyo

[@preethuu9625]

Quality drs r diminishing nowif same incident occuring usa they will b sued forthe entire life

[@Vaibhav-x6r]

I read some comments everyone was saying something but no one talking abt what we can do what we can contribute they think that thay can only like to support but thats not only way & also that does not make much bigger impact . But I thought abt it & called Apollo customer care told them abt this they understood the point & told me to email abt this so the team looks over this . I DID THAT U CAN DO IT TO AND I MADE EASY FOR U . NOW I AM GOING SEARCHING OTHER HOSPITAL CHAIN NAME AND EMAILING THEM SAME THING BCOZ IT TAKES LESS TIME AND CAN SAVE MANY LIVES. I AM HAPPY😊❤

[@sumeetpalit6362]

I lost my father the same way. An uneducated nurse gave him plasma in wrong nerve. Immediately the nerve blocked we told her to stop but because her shift is going to end so in a rush she pushed the whole bottle forcefully. We lost our father because of these non-empathetic criminals. My heart still hurts and i blame me for not stopping her at the right time. I wish i had more medical knowledge and was able to make decisions at the right time.its been 4 years still i am researching on medical videos so that nobody else had to die this way 😢. I am with you and do whatever it takes to take justice for your sister ❤️

[@johndavidson3424]

Never trust a nurse in all this, always go for doctor or procedures done under proper doctor's supervision. My parents are Doctors, so ik.

[@raj33317aka]

similar case in my area. A girl lost his whole hand due to injection given in muscles instead in nerves. Her hand become black and inorder to stop infection in whole body, doctor advice to cut her left hand. Without proper training nurses are recruited in small hospitals and even in big hospitals. Most female nurses don't know to give injection properly. Human life has no value in India. Hospitals just want your money, they don't care if you live or die.

[@realracing3specter295]

i wonder why the medical community not force government to pass the laws which prohibit the un-skilled/un-trained/uneducated medical staff to enter hospitals or vicinity? many times, they are the ones who operate on patients on behalf of that unavailable doctor. that staff is not doctor, so by no means they should be considered for diagnose or operate. Its a serious life lesson, never ever let them operate on you.

[@shubham-oh4ki]

When stroke symptoms start patient need to admit immediately. Due to lack of knowledge many people delay which cause patient become paralysed. Tpa injection which dissolve clot can be given only within 4.5 hours of stroke symptoms start.

[@_iam1533]

Nerve me plasma?

[@Batman007-1A1]

If that doc really prescribed Dynapar for cold and cough, Cancel his license immediately 🙄

[@anshulmalviya8096]

I lost my Father to a medical negligence as well I was young not even an adult had no clue what to do , the Medical and the legal system failed me.

[@Shubhankarnikhil29]

Very sad to know that brother…Please take care of yourself and your family 🙏

[@palashtandiya4860]

Sorry for the loss brother. Please fight the matter in the court with a good lawyer

[@silife750]

U r not alone dear... we lost our 6year old cousin due to wrong medicine. Doctor thought she had dengue she had just fever. The female Doctor messed up .. little girl died. It was almost 20 years ago in Mumbai. My uncle and aunt still have not recovered 😢 they miss her so much! My uncle secretly calls My dad and still cries!!

[@anshulmalviya8096]

Thanks for whoever replied I am glad there are kind people like you all . This incident did change me completely and I think I am more responsible towards my family . It took a while but I am better now. I realised what the reality was and moved on for better . I wish things get better in this country and people don't have to suffer like this .

[@Real728e7]

​@@anshulmalviya8096for things to get better i think this video should be watched compulsory in every hospital with their whole staff

[@NiharikaGuha]

Value of human life in India…. Sad state of affairs

[@shashanknigam783]

value of any middle class family india

[@samuraiani8559]

One very crucial detail is that when the Lawyer said Inj Diclofenac is given IV 5:34 . As an anaesthesiologist i can say that, instructions written on ampule to never give it via direct IV shot push which can lead to symptoms like anaphylaxis & it will be life threatening. We always recommend giving it via IV drip or Intramuscular (IM) injections. Hope it helps everyone.

[@koninika10]

I agree

[@pranjalisharma8429]

Coming from the medical fraternity, I simply feel sad for how our community behaves ! Deeply saddened to see this . May you find justice and may your sister rest in peace 🕊️

[@bijitatoppo3655]

Most Nurses are oversmart, they dont even have a kind way to talk.

[@aashigurung1054]

Nowadays everyone is oversmart, not just the nurses

[@professor7197]

​@@aashigurung1054 nurses kuch jyada hi akad mein hoti hai. !

[@rkh7360]

I'm a doctor. Why dynapar for cold n cough? Her brother getting emotional was heartbreaking. Plus it is intramuscular. Plus doctor is minimally qualified. MBBS with diploma in child health. Not qualified to treat respiratory/ENT problem. But even so, even MBBS interns know Dynapar is IM n only for severe pain. (EDIT) To all who are saying 1. DICLO can be given IV, everyone knows practically speaking, IM is the preferred n safe method. I have never given it IV in my 15years of MBBS+PG+practice. I have never seen any doctor or nurses across 5 hospitals in three different states that I have worked at give it IV. Hence spoke from practical experience. And everyone knows any drug in IV form is inherently riskier. 2. Regarding treating cough n cold by anyone. Sure. Cetrizine/sinarest + antibiotic +/_ cough syrup. That toh even pharmacy wala deta hai in my state. That is not called treating. That is called copy paste. No offence.

[@user-wo4ss8zg6o]

Dynapar AQ can be given IM or IV as it is an aqueous solution. It has been in the market for many years now. Also, an MBBS is qualified to do primary management of a cough n cold. Do you think every doctor in the hospital is a specialist? MBBS doctors r a major part of health care providers. Not having a specialist degree is not a defence.

[@Hunteriscoming]

@@rkh7360 🤬

[@mbbs61]

That's the problem with undereducated doctors... Diclofenac comes in both iv and Im preparations And an mbbs doctor is qualified to treat all respiratory infections

[@vidyasagarchaubey1238]

Anaphylaxis can happen ......even in good ICU setup we loose the patient

[@libingeorge3871]

It's anaphylactic shock..even if she would had came with severe pain it would have the same result..

[@maxxwalker3965]

Corruption and poor civic sense have ruined this country to the core

[@ditto2849]

My heart goes out to you brother. I too have a sister, we went to hospitals for dengue test and when nurse administered her something her bp shot down. God help us from these unqualified killers 😢 just making money

[@ultimatedeshbhakt1923]

All this happened due to the doctor's mistake. Strict action should have been taken against the doctor. Now we have some hope only from the court.

[@doctorsaab959]

Doctor should be blamed! Lol..don't go to a doctor there are rare incidences which can occur.

[@mgsa5722]

​@@doctorsaab959this was not a rare incidence but one of Greed and Stupidity. They just injected her to make money. Though I don't know why sm1 will go to a pvt hospital just for cough and cold

[@and_still.]

​@@doctorsaab959 engineer should be blamed

[@sahildetlM]

​@@doctorsaab959 his brother should be blamed right

[@freeflyingangel1321]

​@@doctorsaab959You ppl are so prideful of your occupation,but have zero responsibility!!

[@hussainshaikh7372]

Thanks for covering this incident

[@PalakRajpal-vo1hv]

"Justice for Simran! Her story matters, and we will fight for the justice she deserves"...

[@Meenar2507]

May she get Justice.😔🙏 Rest in Peace mam

[@siddharthnayak1993]

The negligence which costs anybody's life is not acceptable... strong action should be taken against the medical field authority... support to the victims family 🙏

[@nickim270]

Doctor here. Many factors collided to lead to this unfortunate incident. There was no indication to give something like Diclofenac injection. She didn't even have fever. A simple tablet for cold would have sufficed. There is a strong chance that it was done to inflate her bill. That being said, this type of reaction to Diclofenac is very rare. And if she had taken any Diclofenac containing medication at any time in her life, she would have a reaction. The nurse was not diligent enough to spot signs of allergy as she was giving the injection and she ignored patient concerns. If the hospital could not provide solid evidence that timely life saving treatment was given including any relevant paper work, then it is a clear cut negligence issue.

[@gayaprasad-js6yl]

Hlo doc... yesterday my body temperature via underarm was 98.4 and via mouth it was 98.6 ..but doctor said it was not fever..can you explain what is the range of fever in both ways of measuring (armpit and mouth)

[@Mr_Rain_Forest]

Temp varies person to person

[@KPCStudioOfficial]

​@@gayaprasad-js6yl arm Pit 98.9 is considered fever, but confirm this by taking oral reading too (99 + is fever)

[@rajarshihalder5038]

To declare any person has fever. The body temperature (to be precise the rectal temp) should be 100°F and above. Moreover don't put thermometer into the mouth. It is an old technique. If by any chance the thermometer breaks or leaks the mercury inside that thermometer then it would be hazardous as mercury is toxic.

[@impossible9599]

​@@gayaprasad-js6ylconsider taking Paracetamol 500mg only in case you have fever above 99°F constantly over 2hours. As a doc, i always try to avoid giving injections even though patient demand dard ki sui de doh sir. I scold them and give oral medication only for 3days max.

[@Huzaifa-zd8wi]

I'm a neet aspirant, I realised that being a doctor even non surgical is big responsibility

[@sagaronline265]

as a brother i understand his pain.hospitals now a days are just in hurry to fill their targets and doctors have become money robots.

[@rinkypatnaik1990]

cent percent

[@ShubhamSingh-jk2qz]

Lol your generalization is hilarious

[@ep..]

What about medical collage fee structure?

[@Cinnamoroll-u7v]

Generalization Ever seen govt hospital Pg resident doctors are working continuously for 72 hours shift With having a mere sleep of 3-4 hours for whole three days 110 hours+ per week Have u ever worked this much Sab toh bas corporate ke 70 hours par bolte hai India mein doctors already itne overworked hai vo kisi ko dikhayi nahi deta Aur gyaan Dene sabse pehle aate hai Training bhot rigorous hoti hai They cry everynight And patients keep on blabbering Here in this it was purely a medical negligence That doesn't mean you will target whole fraternity

[@joonobug]

@@Cinnamoroll-u7vthis is not just one incident even in comments section there are many. And doctors are money robots I have seen first hand you are no one to deny that.

[@tanweeransari4034]

The doctor needs to be arrested immediately otherwise someone else may lose their life...

[@evelinesharmila3217]

Sorry for the loss of your sister. People should stop going to hospital for simple cold and headache. Even if you go get it treated by tablet first. Don't take injections unnecessar we hear like giving wrong injections, sharing the needles etc happening at some places Some people have myth that if taken injection all symptoms will stop at the same time.

[@shamathakare3530]

My mother almost died due to an anaphalyctic reaction to anesthesia prior to a spine stabilization surgery for a cancer tumour in her spine . She stopped breathing for 8 minutes . Thankfully she survived adter a week on ventilator in the icu . We never got a clear picture about what happened as she had never had any reactiion like this to general anesthesia during prior surgeries . We asked the doctor for a written report so that we would know exactly what to do if she required surgery in the future . But the doctors never gave it to us . They protect their own . There is a lot of opaqueness in the system

[@sanaahmad4290]

I lost my father due to medical negligence. He died after post surgery of heart. The doctors never clearly told us anything.We got a lifeless body and in return gift we payed 22 lacs.

[@AYUSH-wv4ly]

How can u say its negligence. Mtlb kuch bhi bologe

[@radhikadutta9717]

I am so sorry for your loss. What surgery of heart did he go through? Was it an emergency surgery?

[@radhikadutta9717]

@@AYUSH-wv4lyThat’s extremely rude of you. Please be a little sensitive. She lost someone close to her. The least she wants is unnecessary rudeness from idiots.

[@sanaahmad4290]

@@radhikadutta9717 Thanks🤍Humanity still exist.. A women standing up for another women.. God bless you

[@sanaahmad4290]

@@radhikadutta9717 He had gone through Bypass surgery along with mitral valve replacement surgery. After the surgery. He got an infection which had reached to multi organs. Doctors never told clearly anything.They also didn't give us the angiography cd. I was feeling so helpless.That trauma still haunts. When I saw this video I cried a lot. What his brother is going through his family and fighting for the justice.... Kudos to him kyunki he is doing that jo sab k bs ki nhi hoti. He is fighting with the system

[@sunilpatel71]

Simran should get justice 🙏🏻 Rest in Peace 🙏🏻

[@DrMarinPrince]

She definitely wasnt treated right. I hope you find justice dear family

[@indranilchatterjee8795]

Hello, a mbbs doctor here. Inj. Dynapar is diclofenac which is given for pain relief. It is given by intramuscular route but after dilution it can also be given via iv route but it should be infused within 1hour. In common practice, one gets to see dynapar being given to many patients iv as well after diluting it with 10ml sterile water and infused within a minute. Mostly nothing happens to patients, but it can cause tachycardia and heart attack. What his sister had was anaphylactic reaction to the drug, a patient can have anaphylactic reaction to any drug but having such a severe anaphylactic reaction to diclofenac is very uncommon. what needs to be checked is that did the nurse by mistake give some other medicine or if she forgot to dilute dynapar in the 10ml sterile water.

[@theunfitdoctor]

Why was the Drug sensitivity test not done prior to injection?

[@theunfitdoctor]

Why was the Drug sensitivity test not done prior to injection?

[@toshitsharma6563]

Because doctor does not know. Ques is what is the nees to giving dynapar injection? Doctor needs to justify his prescription.

[@PankajVerma-xw5nf]

@@theunfitdoctordrug sensitivity is not done for every drug usually it’s done for antibiotics , you could go into anaphylactic shock even with simple drugs such as paracetamol. The fault here is mostly this doctors are not well trained enough for resuscitation of patient , otherwise anaphylactic shock is usually manageable and unnecessary giving iv/ Im injection to patient.

[@Hunteriscoming]

@@indranilchatterjee8795 I kheel you

[@rajattiwari4542]

Support for simran, we are with you

[@amrindersb]

Sad part in India is there are no rules for doctor negligence...in USA if any doctor conduct 1 wrong test which is not supposed to then patient can bring that doctor to court and claim hefty money and doctor license can be cancelled but in India due to doctor negligence someone die even in that doctor does not held responsible there is no perimeter to held doctor responsible....😢

[@gauravraitka9927]

There should be a rule for doctor also his licence cancelled if there is medicle negligence

[@madhusreejyothinagaramv664]

There is no need for an parenteral injection for just viral fever and cold, nurse should have stopped giving the medicine if the patient complained of itching. And he should have given adenaline immediately after securing airway, why did he even take chance for avil. Always remember judicial use of drugs even with NSAIDS.. Edit:yes,I agree anaphylaxis isn't predictable but it should be treated robustly if that happens with adrenaline.

[@MK-wn6hl]

I'm not a doctor, rather an engineer. Logically speaking, shouldn't there be an official policy that all injections, whatsoever, be administered using a test dose first, possibly subcutaneously for slower absorption, and only once that succeeds, infuse the full dose via the desired route (IM / IV etc) ? Grateful if any doctor could discuss this with me.

[@jayanthrohan]

@@MK-wn6hl It's not the norms even in best hospitals. Anaphylaxis can even occur after test dose is given properly. Giving test dose is done mostly for antibiotics. It's not possible for each drug. A patient might respond from getting mild itching to cardiac arrest which is quite unpredictable

[@GDe-gi1kz]

​@@jayanthrohankeep ready with adrenaline, nor epheneprine and anti allergy drugs , i am a boose doctor

[@madhusreejyothinagaramv664]

@jayanthrohan yes, it is right.That's why I was saying that itching should have been a warning sign for nurse, yes it not possible to give test dose for every medication.

[@indiankid8601]

​@@madhusreejyothinagaramv664 nobody thinks of anaphylaxis with simple diclofenac first and that too so severe. 100s of patients come each day and get different injections. Very high index of suspicion is needed.

[@isyisy8282]

Anaphylaxis can occur in any person with any medicine or food. People react differently to drugs and food. The name of the culprit drug or food is not written on the patients forehead. The doctor purposely did not push the patient in that situation. People often visit doctors without checking their qualifications. Often the patient or their relatives force a doctor for injection (injection shopping) without knowing the hazards assoc with it. Patients do not understand that oral route is the safest. Anaphylaxis can occur dramatically and unintentionally for which the doctor is not to be blamed. There can be a biologic and genetic variability predisposing a person to such a reaction.The doctor tries to save the patient but he should not be blamed for any adverse outcome to patients life, as the reaction occurs and comes suddenly like a bolt from the blue. It can occur in anybody. Better to listen to both sides of the story. Nowhere test dose is given for common drugs like diclofenac (dynapar). Doctors have to deal with this unavoidable risk of administering injections for which test dose is never recommended or taught.Doctor's profession is quite risky and they are easy targets for blame.The doctor also should be competent enough to handle such a situation, esp using most imp life saving drug Adrenaline in Anaphylaxis. I think, doctors will be safe if prior consent is taken for adverse effects of injections. Sympathies with the patients family.

[@rashmitatudu1539]

Exactly

[@littlegenius6646]

Must not comment without watching the video. If you had watched it you would have known that Dynapar is never given in normal flu

[@coolravi4290]

Le test dose of injection crying at the corner😢😢 If a doctor knows that drug can cause anaphylaxis then why the hell sensitivity testing not done It may be a routine case of anaphylaxis but it took someone's life

[@mgsa5722]

Ask her Parents to Understand! A Qualified experienced doctor would have administered adrenaline injection immediately and intubated her. Her life cud v been saved even after the extremely stupid first action by doctor to give her dynapar injection which is usually given after major surgery for pain relief or to RA, arthritis patients

[@iamdanyboy1]

​@@coolravi4290it's not practical to give test dose of all drugs. Dynapar doesn't commonly cause Anaphylaxis. Test dose of antibiotics IS given however. For that matter any food you have never had before can also trigger anaphylaxis. However, the main fault here , if any , lies in not promptly identifying the anaphylaxis and administering Epinephrine or even an anti histamine for that matter. It's a medical emergency that all medical setups should be equipped for.

[@ghostofuchiha8124]

I lost my younger brother to cancer because of this medical negligence. All the medicines which we bought as per directions were never given to my brother and we're sent back to dispensary , this kept happening for months till my brother told my father that these nurses are just giving him saline and adding nothing into it.

[@shivamkarhanatg4208]

Keep fighting, otherwise these type of negligent people would have no fear of any repercussion. Doctor and medical staff should be on trial for murder and the committee that gave clean chit to Doctor should also held responsible for their actions also.

[@SurprisedArmadillo-rh8ft]

I lost my father when I was 17 years old he had cold and fever we took him to hospital where they told us to do some tests and ..I had no clue what exactly happened but. It was due to medical negligence. They just gave him one injection..when he ..started frothing and he was gone 😢he died infront of my eyes .😭 Still can't forget that day .

[@unknownme7177]

Similarly my 5 year old sister died 1 week ago .

[@SurprisedArmadillo-rh8ft]

@unknownme7177 may her soul rest in peace brother

[@positivekumar3546]

Medical negligence is no less than a heartless serious crime. Medicine is not the field where one shows negligence. Docs/Nurses / Medical staff showing signs of negligence in duties should face penalties like license cancellation or even imprisonment.

[@Ramman-m4t]

My Uncle died bcoz of Wrong diagnosis & treatment by a well known hospital in Hyderabad. Before we realized that, they left no evidence of their negligence with us. We were helpless. It's been years. But, we still feel the loss.

[@subh_8208]

Thank you Quint... I feel sorry for the family. May god give you strength.

[@EverySummerHasStory]

Feeling sorry for him..but this will Happen if you fully support privatization..They have no Sense of responsibility . At least gov institution can be accounted if they make any mistake

[@abadulhaque7835]

Lol,there you can't even lodge an FIR if you get treated at government hospital,we provide free treatment but you can't sue

[@MyThoughts19902X]

Are you serious? Private hospitals keep more accountability because incidents like this could stop their entire business. Also, the pay is good so better doctors and care would be available.

[@aniltuli5860]

लानत है ऐसी स्वास्थ्य व्यवस्थाओं की दुकान पर... और ऐसी दुकान को संरक्षण देने वाले... प्रशासनिक और राजनीतिक तंत्र पर... 🙏

[@rohitkukreja23a]

In India lot of innocent people lost life due to medical negligence. It is heartbreaking to see that so many families, especially those from middle-class backgrounds have had to bear the pain of losing their loved ones in such tragic circumstances. What is even more disheartening is the fact that incidents like these seem to disproportionately affect those who are not as privileged while the wealthy seem to escape unscathed. I understand that you have been tirelessly fighting for justice for these victims for over a year now and I commend you for your dedication and perseverance. It is imperative that you continue to seek justice for those who have been wronged and ensure that such tragic incidents do not happen again in the future. I'm with you brother and everyone should stand with you. I believe that it is crucial for us to come together and work towards creating a safer and more just society for all individuals regardless of their background or social status. By advocating for the rights of the victims and holding those responsible accountable, we can make a positive impact and bring about meaningful change. I stand in solidarity with you in this fight for justice, and I am here to offer my support in any way that I can. Please know that you are not alone in this endeavor, and together, we can make a difference.

[@Madhav1806]

Finally someone came to talk about this Subject. In every country there are strict laws against criminal negligence but in india if u talk anything against to the doctors they will put in a jail by saying u r harassing doctors... Wha ji wha ji they can kill you and says u don't hv any ryts to qtn them. In India Everyday Thousands of incidents happening like this but still u can't file case and u don't get support.

[@maliniap6021]

Pray they get justice

[@adityasharma2]

This is shocking. My heart goes out to the family. Nobody should have to go through this. Stay strong ❤

[@Eunice138]

Sad to know 😭. Rest In Peace, Sister

[@IndiraBachmann]

My prayers for you and for your family brother I too lost my Grandfather and My Nanu in muti hospitals .... Now losing them I decided to do a nursing course and I thank GOD that I came to know the major drawbacks in the health department.There must be a special law and judiciary system for the health department .More changes in policies and infrastructure with accountability of each and every individual and situation!

[@VaibhavKulkarni-e9e]

God bless her soul 🙏

[@fulwantikumari5617]

You are brave brother...........

[@bharatmatakijay3449]

As a doctor, it's so painful to see such incidents happening. But in a country, where hardly 20% doctors are produced purely through merit, whereas rest either are through backdoor entries, through money or through reservation, this will keep happening. Plus a good part of those 20% are leaving India with every passing year. Future is pretty bleak...

[@PriyankaNikalje-o6p]

Govt should strictly do admission on merit only at least for medical faculty

[@vinaykandari9910]

Yes and what about the doctors which will become after this neet paper leak?

[@Studyus-d5t]

​@@vinaykandari9910there is no paper leak., cji denied it ...and he is correct

[@saiyedjamal333]

Diclofenac (Dynapar) is not being given IV I don't think nurse cud do such blunder most probably it wud hv bn givn IM based on symptoms it seems anaphylactic shock but generally it is manageable wen anaphylaxis happens within the hospital premises

[@nishantbharihoke]

It's not the nurse, it was the doctor who asked her to

[@aleti-gk7uj]

he never mentioned it is IV

[@user-wo4ss8zg6o]

If it was Dynapar AQ it can be given IV, as a bolus or an infusion. But diclofenac is quite well known to cause anaphylaxis unpredictably.

[@indiankid8601]

Diclofenac can be given both i.v. and i.m. Even it is written on the vial 😂. Go check.

[@iamdanyboy1]

@@indiankid8601 only Diclo aq. Other brands often have a surfactant or lipid emulsion base for the salt. Which can cause lipid embolism.

[@mehulk53]

Sounds like anaphylaxis due to diclofenac injection (basically the most severe form of an allergic reaction you can see). Legally, anaphylaxis would fall into the therapeutic misadventure category rather than medical negligence (unless other pieces of negligence are also in play). Despite what people are saying about test doses, they often fail at ruling in or ruling out allergies at the bedside. Anaphylaxis is unpredictable and rarely can occur spontaneously even without an obvious triggering allergen. Regarding the endotracheal tube (if it was indeed placed), it was probably removed shortly after death was declared. It isn't that shocking a detail. General practitioners are often not trained enough to deal with such emergencies. Medications like avil, hydrocort aren't going to save you in such severe cases. This is not urticaria. There is a very narrow window to stabilize the patient and unless you've been trained properly, the outcomes will not be good.

[@joshuakatta7094]

This is harrowing. I'm sorry for your loss.

[@crushedcornbollgaming8188]

Om shanti 🙏.

[@jaikishan801]

Such kind of hospitals should be closed permanently.

[@neerajsinghbhar966]

Medicine bhi bahut nakli hain market mai ,even paracetamol tablet and injection is highly nakli

[@TamannaGupta-w9z]

waiting for justice

[@WORLDDISCOVERY-y4k]

Dicloran injection should never be given intravenously always intermascullary, but if needs to be given IV should be given through normal saline

[@animeshkrishna8800]

Rotten justice system....only some of the case we heard of Fastrack justice but rest of case it takes lifelong 😢😢

[@rohitsharma66]

This is what happens when 90 marks get the medical seat. Those low marks doctors who got the seat based of reservations are now treating the patient and consequences? Here's the video! Most of doctors don't take the vials seriously. My uncle lost his some part of flesh due to wrong injection, that affected part became black and eventually ended up in ICU.

[@madhisathya2766]

Why attack only SCs ??? It could also be High caste Hindu who would've got a seat through Management quota. There are many colleges giving seat without entrance for 20-30 lakhs. There are many upper caste Hindus too who have committed medical negligence. If you want to truly stand for justice look at the whole picture.

[@anupamhalder475]

Im an MD /DM Cardiology. Anaphylaxis is rare and often dramatic What you are looking at problems at multiple levels 1. NSAIDS being given with no indication 2. Poor nursing awareness to anaphylaxis 3. Poor management for anaphylaxis. Intubating the patient on spot could have truly saved her along with proper CPR / steroids and epinephrine Thus MOCK CPR codes are super essential among all medical staff While it can be difficult to do test dose for all medications we need to doggie or what exactly was injected

[@seduloushuman3338]

Nice work. Brave and nice reporting by the quint

[@TheGoldenGallery]

It should be a serious concern of each one of us that we cant even trust doctors, someones has lost their child and entire system kept silent and shameful thing is no media or news channel is covering this serious matter except Quint.

[@roshni6565]

Prayers for your sister 🙏

[@himanshugupta4893]

Very unfortunate. Please share this as much as possible

[@anish11040]

My father died in military hospital SC Pune due to medical negligence in 2022.. I saw how they treated my father...isse desh mein kisse ke himmat nahi hai armed hospital se sawal kar sake ..mujha treatment ke file tak dekhne nahi diya mein request karta rahiga gaya.

[@genuineselection5635]

Hey anish i know what you have suffered. My mom also suffered due to negligence of Command Hospital lucknow. Actually yes there is a syndicate working in Army Hospitals to not give proper meducations. They only give NS and paracetamal for emergency patients also. And yes these military hospitals are death beds. Civil hospital ke against toh complain ho skta hai lekin ye Command and Base hospitals jo unethical procedures kr rhe hai unko rokne wala koi nhi hai.

[@mythusharma9139]

Army hospital hai bhai koi Nukkad clinic nahi. Itna hi sahi treatment chahiye toh America chale jaao jaise hamare saari engineers jaa rahe hai. Doctors aur Jawaan yahi rehkar Bharat mata ki seva mein hai.

[@anish11040]

@mythusharma9139 ..ex Indian army officer the mera father and even my brother is also Indian army officer...jisse cheez ke knowledge nahi hai woha bola mat.

[@genuineselection5635]

@@mythusharma9139 koi bharat mata ki seva nhi kr rha. Sirf infantry units me thora jazba hai desh seva ka aur usme bhi abhi allowances band kr do toh koi nhi dega apni service. Sab employed hone ke liye army join krna chahte hai na ki desh seva krne ke liye. Aur tumhe ek fact btau jab kargil hua tha toh usme bhut se officer apni hi unit ke jawano dwara shot kiye gye the qki jawano ko mauka mila tha us samay worst officers ko eliminate krne ka. Ye baat kisi Army family se puchna wo batayenge

[@YADAVARPITKK]

Aap ko case karna chahiye shayad hi apke pariwar ko nyay mile 😮

[@shivashankar9668]

I have a sister who is my best friend i cant imagine the pain he is going through right now😔.

[@RGI17]

May u win this case

[@meghnamehta7694]

Do let us know if we the common people can help in any way..a young girl died due to medical negligence..it is a terrible tragedy

[@arjun.islampur]

Humare Neighbour Mein 1 Joint Family👪 Hai ⏳ Unke Class 7 Ki Ladki 👧 Health Issue Huwa Thaa Le Gaye Hospital🏥 Injection Diya Chali Gayi Coma Mein.. Thank God Kitna Ku6 Kr K 🎯 Bacchi Ko Bacha K 🎯 Laye Hai ⏳ Wo Log

[@Beinghumane1]

Hope you will soon get justice brother, You're doing a great job Quint, pls continue your efforts for providing him justice.

[@fightforyourrightofficial]

If there is delay, the victim family should approach the concerned high court.

[@sourabhsandeep3489]

This is truly shocking. No one has the right to play with another person's life. Our constitution clearly states that no doctor should be harassed or assaulted, but what happens when lives are handled carelessly like this? There should be a proper system in place to address these kinds of situations. If someone can’t provide the right treatment, they shouldn’t be experimenting with a patient’s life. Unfortunately, today, many large hospitals seem more focused on maximizing bills than truly caring for patients. The judiciary is the only place to turn for true justice; blind trust in the system, including the police, isn’t always enough. Stand firm and fight until justice is served. strength to the family. Thanks quint for bringing up such stories.

[@kajalkataria4899]

Justice for her

[@Yorichi_01]

I lost my sister 6 months ago due to medical negligence, other than most AIMS and Some POPULAR MEDICAL COLLEGE mostly from local medical College students will be not qualified if there is proper exam for MBBS certificate or licence

[@Justhuman5563]

Justice for Simran

[@abhishekmawle8460]

This is real Journalism and continue to make efforts to maintain that real victims stories are bought out and justice is done

[@ambareenkausar6905]

This is so horrible and unfortunate. 😢

[@SrikanthAdapa-q3y]

This will mislead anyone not having medical knowledge, life threatening anaphylaxis is very severe and rare complication of till then unknown allergy which obviously nobody would know until it happens, very unfortunate but there is literally very little chance anything a medical centre without an intensive unit can do. The doctor followed the right protocoll after the allergic reaction, also diclofenac is never the first choice but can be given for fever, not only pain. The nurse is ignorant of not recognising an allergy to medication, she should have immediately alerted the doctor instead of administrating it further.

[@RagnarLothbrok-n2h]

@@SrikanthAdapa-q3y the most same comment here🙏

[@pooja-wg1eq]

Looks like that it was an anaphylaxis . This is an extreme emergency condition. Even if this happened to her , it was the duty of the doctor to immediately give drugs to counteracting the action of dynapar. I say this not only as a doctor but also as a human being. And frankly speaking I dont know why dynapar was given to her in cough and cold. Ofcourse anaphylaxis can happen to anyone, but all doctor are usually trained to give counter protocol for the same. And if it is proved that doctor has given counter protocol, then I don't think doctor is at a fault here. However if he failed to do so , then this guy must be behind bars. This is a common problem with small private hospitals. Staff is hired under low salary . I will ask the family members to check the qualifications of the doctors. Are they even MBBS doctors?? I know one hospital where an ayurvedic pharmacist is working as a RMO , a post for MBBS doctors, unless specified otherwise but only for doctors not pharmacists.

[@ritaranee4787]

Modis india

[@tapomitamallick3637]

Oh no.What hospital is that?A homeopathy dr is still considerable.

[@anilajanagama524]

Allah apke ghar walon ko himmat de sabar de aapki takleef ko door kare. Ameen

[@sreetamaray_]

I hope Simran gets justice and the doctor and the nurse should be arrested immediately. Why did it take 1.5 years to arrest these criminals when there is clear evidence of medical negligency and ignorance? Most Doctors and nurses in India are not qualified to even crack the medical entrances let alone treating patients. Seriously we need a bettery medical and judicial system.

[@asraamaryam]

I hope your family gets justice and some form of action is taken against the accused so that no else suffers like this through their hands.

[@HK-cb4qc]

Beti ki kami puri nahi ho sakti par agar aap sach mei Beti se pyar krte ho to is hospital or iske zimmedar logo ko maza chakha do

[@kalpanabansal2209]

Hoping and praying for the justice to be served as early as possible 🙏🏻🥲💔

[@surinderbirsingh7809]

Very sad 😔

this channel really trying best to bring out truth. very less people do that not even government do that. great work you guys

[@anweshabhattacharjee5943]

I lost my father due to medical negligence. His hip was broken but then the doctor said that his reports were normal after a week he slipped into coma and never came back. The whole medical system is a joke in our country.

[@tapomitamallick3637]

Cough and cold hai toh try treating with home remedies and warm water.Pehle hi dr ke paas kyun jaaye.

[@l-earnfactology1449]

Feeling so sorry for ur loss

[@gaganBhaisaab]

It's medical negligence. Doctor should be punished. Simple. But then, we are also a Banana Republic.

[@the-owlet1425]

This doctor must be prosecuted for murder

[@mgsa5722]

True. Greed to make money too by giving unneeded injections

[@lavichawla1917]

​@@mgsa5722how much does 1 dynapar cost?

[@PPPPSSSSCCCC]

100 rupey

[@indiankid8601]

​@@mgsa572231 rupees ka aata hai dynapar aq. Bahut kama liya doctor ne 🙄. 10 rupees syringe 💉 ke jod lo.

[@mgsa5722]

@@lavichawla1917 it costs very little if u buy from chemist but Hospitals put their own price on everything. I came to know about it wen I twisted my ankle. Ankle plaster cost was rs 450 on Amazon, rs 550 in shop and ortho charged me rs 6000

[@sheikhyamin4556]

Man i cant watch this full bro, feels so shocked and so hurt, may god grant her the best place in heaven.

[@monalepcha6486]

bhai ho to aesa... 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@RAHULSHARMA-ei9ko]

This happens due to cheap nurses kept by hospitals to save money .I was told by a docter that this happened with his patient but he immediately gave the patient crp and saved the patient later he went to his boss ,his boss replied he doesn't have time for this .

[@nurmohammad259]

What happens justice delayed,justice denied. The family of the girl should get justice immediately.

[@amitdeshmukh9660]

F for judicial system.

[@sanb2023]

Doctor's medical degree and Nurse's qualification needs to be checked for this...! All the students who goes for higher Medical studies in East Europe, Russia don't get enough experience like they get in India...NEET Exams and all kinds of seat Reservation in medicals studies, Nursing, BAMS, homeopathy needs to be evaluated by Indians law makers....

[@madhisathya2766]

NEET needs to be optional, many prominent doctors from India never passed NEET.

[@sanb2023]

@madhisathya2766 Most of them are from Non reservation seats.NEET or any other examination needs more strict system.And action against all these agents is very much required.There is no fear for such crimes.The amount these agents get is the reason they think we can bend the law and enforcement for our benifits.

[@doctorsaab959]

Omg i m really very sorry to hear that.

[@sagarsoham7920]

Medical negligence se jiski bhi jaan jaaye dukh ki baat hai,chahe wo koi scholar ho ya duffer doesnt matter

[@marinafernandes5508]

Very sad .. I'm going through same pain