Sardar Sarovar Explained: The Benefits and The Harms - The Quint

[@jG-ok2fc]

I am from saurashta region of Gujarat. Our fore-fathers were on blink of suicides due to continuous drought. The Narmada water resolves whole Gujarat'water problem.

[@sP-cd5nq]

Why couldnt u guys be relocated....poor ppl from other villages suffered.god knows if they got fair compensation....they hd to leave their homes for ur benefit when u cud hv relocated to their land .

[@GuruKhatri1]

Stffffuuuu ​@@sP-cd5nq

[@varadbhagwat2478]

The electricity and water has been provided to Gujarat but what about border villages in maharshtra and madhya pradesh. They still not have electricity

[@raviv3398]

Farmers in villages in desert of Katch now earning tons by horticulture with water of Narmada coming from 800+ km far, my village in Dhorela-Dhandhuka where land is dried and only 1 small harvest were taken by farmers, now farmers in my village take 3 harvest in year due to water of Narmada coming from 400+ km far. It’s what you get when we have strong leadership, Modi personally forced construction to high speed for the damn as well all canals network.

[@parandhamsai]

Benefits out weighed the harms. Isn't the whole civilization built upon that idea!?

[@pinkast5241]

It is the rule by which humans operate

[@essz_i4643]

@@pinkast5241 ❤❤❤

[@Nanak7878]

Arundhati Roy is known to oppose any development in India, even if it would benefit millions of people

[@ashishvasava1995]

Water is life line. So ,sardar sarovar is Good project 👍

[@drsiddysadventures551]

Totally worth it but fair compensation to the ones who are at loss is also a responsibility of government.

[@ashwasthamakumartripathi8784]

You are right but government need to take decision according to majority.

[@lalitSharma-vh7jl]

The biggest dam in china/world displaced 10 lakhs people and it's reservoir even have changed the speed of earth though by fraction and it have a installed capacity of 22GW

[@milind292]

Pls check the latest situation and circumstances over the world biggest chinese dam...

[@mukeshmehtadesigns]

Patkar was literally kicked out from Gujarat by RSS and Dam is reality,

[@pulz1191]

Proper rehabilitation should have been done to places where the dam was going to bring benefits. Otherwise it's an amazing idea and should have been completed atleast 30 years back.

[@vickyrajchudasama4173]

It is worth it. Benefits are far more enormous than loss

[@bhargavbellam]

Nothing is worthy when it comes to disgrace and hardship of my country people. As a citizen of the country, we can't let anyone face the consequences for benefiting the other, harming the ecology, endangering the wildlife, land mass and the lively river. I think we should have thought another alternative beyond sitting and hanging to the issue for 56 years, creating politics over the lives of people and a river. #CommonMan.

[@socialisnowantisocial471]

In Aug 2019 .. yes totally worth it ..

[@shipra16278]

No

[@himanshuborse8613]

Yes it was worth it.....

[@abhinavchauhan9401]

This dissapointed me this was not expected from The quint at least you could have researched facks by seeing award winning documentaries like drowned out and many other others and could have shown ground reality that the benefits of this dam was overestimated 20 times and the cons were underestimated 4 times you could have shown the quality of construction and how many times it costed the estimated cost you could have shown what the displaced people were promised and what the got in the end but you didn't...........

[@BLUE_GAMING_YT1]

Thank you so much for such clarity

[@charlesspajing6608]

Kisi admi ki bimar thik karne ke liye kisi ko marna thik nehi hai... I hardly oppose the dam that kills many soul to brought up new soul.

[@boomkaboombhuushh]

Jab Arundhati Jaise log kuch oppose kare, uska matlab kuch sahi ho raha hai... She's the biggest scam of India

[@meetpatel7549]

Yes, sardar sarovar dam solved many problems of gujrat

[@animeshk5455]

Pros >>> cons

[@piyushdhore]

Development is for people who are better off, not for the people living in the villages. What is expected of people losing their livelihood and source of income and food is to do peaceful bhuk hartals, when the government bulldozers run over their houses. The government is not for them, neither is development for them. They should die peacefully starving so that some media can come and take pictures while people sitting in their AC living rooms fill bad but enjoy their electricity while corrupt beaurocrats pocket their compensation.

[@pulz1191]

Ailing infrastructure ails India and Ailing India ails infrastructure..... Really happy with current central government which is focusing on infrastructure. Much much needed. A developing country has bad infrastructure and bad infrastructure leads to bad growth rates.!!

[@pramodyamanohari1852]

Thank u guys,your quick video was very helpful.

[@tanishkmahakalkar761]

It is worth it..!!!!🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯

[@durgayesade3950]

I'm an Adolescent student who has very little knowledge about this world. But this video really turned out to helpful for our sociology project. Thanks Qunit!!

[@hethshah2064]

WELL I SUPPORT THE PROJECT

[@shareloan]

I just know my RO was leaking yesterday and just took one day to get it fixed . :)

[@gvaanang]

70% of water will be used for Industrial corridor not for Farming..........

[@gvaanang]

Siddhartha Mallya: How much jobs, few Thousands? If 50 to 60% water is used on farming millions will benefit from it. Mostly Gujrati's and Marwari's will benefit from corridor, Not Marathi's or any one else......

[@gvaanang]

Siddhartha Mallya: u r shaming yourself......Dont delete ur comment......Let people see how Modi Bakth behaves.....

[@gvaanang]

Siddhartha Mallya: It have been proven u r a Paid Modi Army to shame MODI himself ......Dont delete ur comment......Let people see how Modi Bakth behaves.....

[@siddhantkhorjuvekar]

vaanan navin haaha still comment not deleted lol. U have to think from different perspective to understand the comment Which obviously u have not done..... Industries are backbone of 21st century. countries which had hard time realising this facts are the ones lagging behind nowadays. India is one among them. India has long focussed only on farming and have paid no attention to industrialization .we see industries something as a evil and we pay the price for it in terms of jobs , infrastructure.there is nothing bad in supporting farming but it has its own limitations in 21st century... 50 years back u could grow crops and sell the products in different country. Now with use of technology even arid countries can produce crops and grains in enough quantities e.g Israel, middle east countries e.t.c It's not question of modi or Congress.. whoever is in power should and must promote industries. already we r lagging behind in industrialization if we don't support them now then we r doomed.

[@gvaanang]

aslesh: Need to focus on research and Technology, not only industries...in 1992 india got RAW deal for its farmers in exchange of FDI....We have neglected our farmers long enough...Recently after Modi came to power again farmers got RAW deal in WTO via TFA...Systematic elimination of Indian farming sector is happening via WTO...Y wont u brainy people realize......

[@darshanteli1853]

Megha patkar ne dam ka virodh karke lakho rupye kamaye hai. Ye project Gujarat ke liye jaruri hai jese Punjab ke liye bhakhra nagl dam

[@rdpathan]

India ka pehle se trend hai, idea revolutionary rehta, implementation mein hagg dete. Trailers are well made, films are shit. Demonetization, SSD etc. sab yahi hai. SSD thoda moral dilemma jaisa hai kyuke its like that philosophical problem ke would you save your mother from dying or 10 people who you do not know, kabhi kabhi emotions aur logic ka tussle hota hai which tells us how imperfect the seemingly perfect humans are. Tum ye problem court of law mein run karoge toh 10 lives will seem outweighing the 1 life, but subjectively and emotionally which Medha Patkar is thinking like is also not wrong in her thought. I would like to sit out of the jury, ye itna difficult problem hai bc.

[@naveensundar4765]

This is a well shot video

[@hangkumchang2782]

small dams over big dams. renewable energy. these should be the thrust areas.

[@shotsout3942]

Absolutely yes!!!!!!

[@kamakshimmm9739]

Please see the supreme Court report of pros and cons

[@Xoro-rbk]

With the all the positivity outweighing it's negativity. A proper settlement of the displaced families could have been done 56years back.

[@dhruvin4441]

@ cry

@@dhruvin4441 how uneducated and shameless of you anyways , environment, forests etc can't be at a harm

[@Secular_Saddam_Hussein]

this Gandhian disease of protesting against everything must end...we need developmental projects like this

[@anudaniel443]

ITS WORTH IT WHEN IT IS COUPLED WITH THE FAIR COMPENSATION TO THE DISPLACED FAMILIES

[@parinsavla602]

It was due to democracy that such projects take eons to be completed. Medha Patkar was an asshole to just bash the project.

[@rapatel1642]

Its a no brainer of course it was worth it.

[@sagarpatil3974]

Very much help ful

[@SujeetSingh-rd7oc]

There are only harms. But can you do anything now? Can you go back there? Count three gorges in too? But I should not have any land and peace. I will have to fight for it. I am "haves" !!

[@ANKITPANDEY-vm8kx]

Is it Dam Age or DamAge???

[@sunnyzinzuvadiya1084]

ANKIT PANDEY iska to pata nahi but tu chutiya hai😂

[@anudaniel443]

ONLY WHEN IT COULD BE COUPLED......................

[@MurtazaSinghTomar]

If all the displaced families get resettled, all the tribal ppl and farmers are given sufficient compensation...then only it is worth it

[@sridevichilukoori404]

I think it gave a painful consequences........thinking through sustainability...

[@nostalgic4u752]

Same is the story going in now with farm bills..

[@Godguygamer]

Hmmm sounds like a *damm* problem

[@bharath_2023]

I support the dam

[@sumitasaindane329]

Loved it

[@premken]

Pros outweighs cons..

[@28ndisha99]

Thank you so much...it is really good and neatly explained...

[@amitsingh61670]

Does government have did something for 40000 displaced families? 2:40

[@neema2222]

People will get many benefits but can't let tribals loose lives, so... Don't know...

[@edwardelric715]

0:00

[@akmalahmed9]

A black mark in Indian environmental history. The Narmada bachao andolan, though failed, will always be one of the most democratic resistance movements the world has ever seen.

[@milliondollar5000]

Please explain about the fund that how much it takes and who gives such loans.

[@weeeewomeneducationwomenem5008]

Apne Desh Mai Bahoot Log Hai Aise Hindu Virodhhi And Development Virodhhi

[@TheSreealgeco]

Dam can change the name to with gandhi or nehru family names. The entire protests will disappeared and activities reshifted to assigned areas

[@twimukjamatia1425]

Wow suprp🎉🎉🎉

[@nirajbharat1783]

Kya irrigation ki jo bat ki gayi uske liye sarkar ne canals ka network banane ka karya imandari se karwaya ya pani ko bari companies k utilisation k liye muhaiya karwaya gya? Kya hazaro lakho logo k punarwas ka kam ground pr pura hua ya sirf kagjo pr ya wha b nhi? Kya historical, cultural, ecological, archaeological Drishti se mahatwapoorn sthano k sambandh me kuchh socha gya? The answer to the question- is the dam worthful or not, lies in the anwer to these questions.

[@allwinaugustine]

What happend to those protested farmers ?

[@amityaduvanshi9165]

Useful for me

[@divyarajsingh6914]

What about the rehabilation of 40000 displaced families ? Have all the families got fair and proper compensation ?

[@himansubehera2399]

divyaraj singh that is upto the government.. but for those 40000 families we can't sacrifice the project which will help the future generation the most.. it can solve agriculture, power problem in the western part of India..

[@dharmeshparmani8473]

divyaraj singh No they didn't got there fare compensation..

[@paalu84]

You are behaving As if these 40000 families have been thrown in to a nazi style gas chamber.

[@Jhaaninc]

Chacha Ganta nehru jisko uskay Marney kay baad bhi sab baja rahe hai 😊 lol ROFL lmfao

[@gitanjalikarki4249]

kutch people can be relocated.....aquaphonics n vertical farming for them........why increase human cost by making others in mp suffer

[@vanishwhite6423]

WHAT

[@bharath_2023]

Yes worth it when gaining something There will be some loss

[@beingfree7172]

It's is worth. But first rehabilitate those displaced tribals. Compensate there loss.

[@dhrumilff5068]

Yes

[@Kannadiga321-r4n]

Modi hai to Mumkin hai❤

[@finfet9828]

The question should be which idiot opposed it?

[@40aryanrathod12]

There are always pros and cons....

[@salmapathan6752]

main Gujarat se bol rahi hun aajse Pakistan pahle Congress ki sarkar ki tab karmchariyon Ne Apna pet Katkar paise diye ki Nirmala ke andar Bond ki tarikh 2014 Gujar Gai Uske bad 2019 abhi tak Hamare uske liye

[@sanjoyroy2862]

There is a China funded gang in our India.main work of this gang is to brake all devolving project in India lick as sarder sarovar project....

[@pramodmuthalik9400]

no dam

[@lakshya796-A]

I want to join the Quint !!

[@avnishukla6072]

.

[@shaunabraham3299]

DOOOD

[@gavalimahindra4381]

mahendr

[@Ab-ii4oc]

6 decades because of liberandus like u all who will oppose any improvement

[@masterraceofeverything4504]

Dafaq is this?

[@amypatel4134]

Yes it was wroth it

[@ambeshdeva3629]

Bol na aunty aau kya wali kaha gayi🤣🤣🤣

[@kajalbharti3544]

Nice informational video

[@sarojjamwal5371]

Dam it

[@monideepabhowmick5879]

It was not worth it..

[@pranavgohel6710]

Ask farmer of Gujarat lol do u even live there..not worth it

[@alpeshchoriya2570]

Rahul khan or Congress developments virodhi

[@umangd3959]

What madhya pradesh get ...babaji ka thullu

[@mathardey]

stop messing with nature

[@mathardey]

yes I live in a jungle and ppl r destroying my jungle

[@arjshahindia4546]

Jay k dude I think u didn't get my point. Nothing is free in this world bro. To have something, we have to sacrifice something.

[@mathardey]

alt resource , r&d etc

[@adityanegi21]

Kaha se lattey hai aisey dhakan .. anchor .. dude bla bka bla .. paiso ki kaami hai quint pe ...

[@jaidaniel3731]

Absolute waste! !

[@kishanpatel3546]

Graet project

[@vinitpordhiya6035]

If it collapse then what will happen ? Pray god not to happen this 🙏🏻

[@alpeshchoriya2570]

Congress des virodhi

[@vimaldob]

If sardar Patel had become India first prime minister ...India would be a develop before 1990

[@rajeshmishra9479]

Bakwas

[@ChuckyWannaPlay_]

anchor is beautiful :*

[@vicky4471]

Leftist XD

[@taoshunya4153]

It was just NOT WORTH IT!!!! And they (the current authoritative modi-gov, see we have to use Modi-gov and not BJP gov, why so?) are after implimenting 3 such "Giant" dam projects now. The Ken-Betwa got the green signal to kick-off. Even though villagers are protesting. Who is there to listen? Is this really the "Acche Din"?? Is what the common men are asking in the villages.