There's a Bad Moon Rising | Blood on the Clocktower with special guest Jon Gracey

[@realmzjetter409]

My understanding is that when the Grandmother dies, their ability is no longer working, so they no longer have a grandchild. So if they're brought back their power works again so they get to know a player, so it's up to the story teller if it's a totally new person, or the same one. That should probably be decided when they're brought back, so Chris should have been woken up and told who their grandchild was. Leading to the hilarious dawn announcement that Chris was found alive, only for them to die again because their grandchild is found dead.

[@EzFlyers10]

Grandmother regurgitated needs to be awoken immediately, it's effectively a setup thing. "You start knowing"

[@ProudLeonidas]

Ben burns disagrees, I don't have receipts but it would be after the disrupters as it is an info role.

[@ST-jl2lh]

Sam had his hand up far too early at the end there. He should have been looking to snipe the tied vote.

[@Noah-qu9fb]

100%! Chris had his hand up originally, Liz obviously votes, then Sam can vote because luckily he's the very last hand (which is the very best position to be in as evil).

[@commander-fox-q7573]

I mean you didn’t regurgitate anyone, there would’ve been an announcement even if they died immediately again. Or at least an announcement that they had died in the night despite already being dead. Ultimately it’s fine since the way it is run is also a totally valid world where no regurgitation was made but you can’t really say there was a regurgitation with the way it was run in the game imo.

[@stingersplash]

First time here (algorithm with NRB member) but I feel evil got too much help. Telling Liz the order matters was basically saying "reverse those two" and then not giving Chris a new grandchild felt unfair too. But in the end it didn't matter I suppose lol.

[@staceymcpeek8408]

Yeah, there were a few questionable calls there. However, town was towning SO hard... that double kill on Zak was absolutely wild given the kill pattern.

[@csarmii]

I feel like after that D3 town deserved to lose. The gossip causes a death for no reason which almost guarantees evil win. No one tries to count (they have 5 alive, any mislynch is just game after that gossip). No one points out that this is their last execution. Then they mislynch a corpse for no reason (cause it might be a Zombuul after two double death nights). I understand that this is their first game, but I don't think there should be a regurgitation there at all - if the demon selects two players correctly (not the goon and not the gossip), it should be game. Not that it matters, apparently.

[@ProudLeonidas]

Saying order matters is explaining a nuance to rules. Not heavy handed.

[@hccdgvvfccdgn993]

Gracey got the youtube algorithm to my attention

[@darbyl3872]

The dead players should be allowed to gossip, and the dead Gossip's token ready in case they come back to life that night.

[@masondeross]

Losing his mic for the final day just made Sam too low profile during the convo that everyone forgot him and he couldn't make himself look suspicious, that was rough watching that day and wanting to hear him speak up to make his claim of fool less iron clad in everyone's mind.

[@somecallmetim4490]

Learning, during roll call after the game, that you killed in the wrong order, is the best way to learn how important picking order is... It is also the most fair.

[@JoseLopez-zo3mf]

Shouldn’t the storytellers, on the day after the regurgitation, told town that Chris also died along with Fiona and Ribs? This would have given town more info on is being a shab demon. Otherwise how is town reasonably supposed to know that a regurgitation happened that night?

[@somecallmetim4490]

There were double kills every night. That's reasonably all the information needed. Town just wanted to believe the gambler and tinker died to their own abilities on night two.

[@somecallmetim4490]

I misunderstood what your comment was fully about, sorry. If the regurgitation happened correctly, I do believe Chris should have been woken up, then died again in the morning.

[@nsnick199]

I don't think town should have been told necessarily but as others have pointed out, Chris should have been woken and shown a grandchild.

[@EvilAliv3]

Shouldn't when the moonchild picked the goon, directly die? The Goon ability says "Each night, ..."

[@darbyl3872]

The Moonchild kill happens the following night, if they are alive, and not drunk / poisoned.

[@EvilAliv3]

​@@darbyl3872 Oh ok, i completely skipped reading the "TONIGHT", and thought it happen on pick :D

[@campslugbones]

Great game! Emily, it would be super helpful for the storyteller to keep the tab open with the character descriptions during the game so viewers can have a quick reference for character powers. Thanks for considering!

[@RPGeeksDND]

I normally try and keep it there but clearly forgot this game! Good to know it's useful :)

[@matthewlove4082]

I feel like that game ended up being pretty balanced despite how swingy it was all throughout. 😂 The Tea Lady confirmed a lot of players but then the Evil team got help with killing the Tea Lady (and they needed it), there were way too many Outsiders but the Godfather still didn't get any kills, the Gossip helped the Evil team out a little bit, the ST decisions felt competent, and despite a secured win the Evil team still lost! So, good job guys, it went well in the end. 😂

[@zackfg]

Such a fun game!

[@nsnick199]

Those were certainly some gossips lol

[@EzFlyers10]

Bmr is tricky, I know, lol, but omg those gossips

[@skakried7673]

What app is being used here? I wanna give it a go.

[@RPGeeksDND]

This is the official Blood on the Clocktower app online.bloodontheclocktower.com/ happy demon hunting! 😊

[@skakried7673]

@@RPGeeksDND Thank youuuu ^.^

[@jeremiahsmith4470]

Is it just me or were there two missed godfather kills?

[@nsnick199]

No outsiders died during the day, so there were no godfather kills.

[@jeremiahsmith4470]

@@nsnick199 wonderful, thanks for clarifying, I thought it was just when an outsider died, I should learn to read the wiki more! 🤣

[@miracleweathers8612]

The tinker can die any time it can hide and confuse so many People

[@notsaying911]

Wait.... Did Zack get 2 ghost votes? Or am I thinking he got 2 ghost votes because he got someone nominated after being killed?

[@RPGeeksDND]

The app won't let you vote twice once dead so I think that may just be Zack being a vocal ghost. He may also have dropped his hand quickly before the clock hand got to him!

[@notsaying911]

@@RPGeeksDND Ah, that makes sense then. Nice to see his streak is still going strong though.😂