These Coins Look So Real They're Scary! I Was Almost Fooled!

[@CoinHELPu]

These Coins Look So Real They're Scary! I Was Almost Fooled! Join this channel to get access to perks: kzbin.info/door/IYtW3byS0u7rBmXg71pXQwjoin Buy Coins From Us: portsmouthcoinshop.com/ CoinHelpu Community coinauctionshelp.com/welcome-to-coinhelpu-community/ Coin Value App: coinauctionshelp.com/coincollectingapps/ Mint Error App: errorcoins.coinauctionshelp.com/wordpress/

[@ClanMacFarland71]

Wow, that's scary if you were almost fooled! Thanks for sharing, Daniel. 👍

[@coincollectingfun]

Crushed the like button! Excellent video and thank you so much for sharing!

[@MarkA-Coins]

Thanks for sharing Daniel. Very important video. I am not much for buying gold not certified. I seen a comment below about the counterfeits looking brassy. That's a good point. Probably would have snagged me though. That California gold looks N I C E !

[@lindanelson8400]

That was a very good catch. To date the only counterfeit coin I ever got hung with was a one dollar gold piece. I purchased it before grading services were around. These fakes are a real scourge for our hobby.

[@UneducatedGeologist]

There's alot of money in fakes. I bought a few of the most amazing looking Morgan fakes. Semi rare dates AU. They'd go for $60. Luckily I only paid spot for them a number of years back.

[@joelp6197]

wow, thanks for the video. crazy how good they look.

[@NuthinFancyCollectibles]

Great video, Daniel. Thanks for what you do.

[@brianhagler4490]

Crazy, Daniel- I had just sent you that picture a couple of months ago of that 1889.

[@rsitch1]

Thank you very much for sharing your experience, That is so interesting to see,” Fake Die”… Daniel your a channel of welcome surprises…!!!

[@nicolasrossi5978]

Interesting items. Thanks for sharing, it would be great ( and also more informative) to compare side by side with the actual coins they were trying to copy , or at least with a high quality photograph of the obverse and reverse of the actual versions in order to see the detail differences.

[@bradwilliams7145]

The patina reminded me of gold colored tokens you receive at a car wash or amusement center.

[@noobismatic]

Now I'm stressing even more about a gold dollar I've got out at PCGS. I need to move a few hours south, so I've got a pro I can visit. Knowledge is priceless! Thank you.

[@harvyss136]

I have the exact same year, the '54. I received from my mom. Shes 82. It was given to her as a child from her Grandfather back in the 40's. Apparently he had them for some time, so it's been in the family for easily 100+ years. I brought it in to have it looked at and just like these, its gold but fake. My Great Grandfather always thought they were real. As long as people are out there, there will be counterfeit's. Thanks for the great info!

[@-oiiio-3993]

They look a bit 'brassy'.

[@CoinHELPu]

Exactly

[@-oiiio-3993]

@@CoinHELPu Thank you, sir

[@trinhbui3585]

Good morning Daniel from Maryland. I like your video.

[@johncebasek6252]

If someone could clear up a point for me? Were the counterfeits made to scam modern collectors or were they circulating as counterfeits when the coins were in circulation?

[@johncebasek6252]

@@acousticshadow4032 Ah, thank you... (as he goes off to the coffee machine!)

[@UneducatedGeologist]

Yes that high quality they had a collectors premium for last 100yrs

[@Rob-sx8ek]

Yeah, definitely the first. Looking to get over on the novices or even some pros, I'm sure, as well.

[@marianmoses9604]

Chinese counterfeits if you were to ask me.

[@Rob-sx8ek]

@marianmoses9604 they're all over all of the market places. Selling like hot cakes too, sadly.

[@SSS-bd6li]

Daniel, thanks for sharing. Serves as a reminder for everyone to be careful and do our due diligence. Wonderful content as usual!

[@ehrenkrause9861]

Those California gold $1 they look more stamped than they do minted from the way the rim looks

[@shawncovert5447]

Coming for you makes it quite alarming and even more scarier, 🇺🇲🦅⚖️

[@shawncovert5447]

Someone as you who knows and been around coins you whole life, just think someone like me or others that don't have experience would get took in to the bank for sure. On fakes this good..

[@jerrydavidnichols6735]

I would say they are good enough to fool most people, very good counterfeits. Are they in the counterfeit Gold book?

[@CoinHELPu]

I didn’t look

[@motokenzo763]

Wow! Do you have a good eye...hindsight knowing they are fake...yeah, the finish of the strike looks off. Without that info no way! 🤠

[@evapayton29]

Thanks so much for the information

[@rodneymaynor6418]

Both counterfeit gold coins are great examples that just because they're made of real silver and gold that doesn't mean they're real. What's a few dollars worth of gold or silver when a good counterfeiter can make thousands out of a few dollars worth of gold back then and truth be told even now? Point made is just because it's made of real silver or gold doesn't mean that coin is actually real. I've seen this time and again at my friend's coin shop. People come in , they say hey! This coin is real silver or gold there for it must be real. Sadly this is more common than most would believe. Good educational video Daniel. Congratulations on the California gold coin that straight graded. Yes a coin must be PL on both the obverse and reverse to get that PL attribution. Thanks for sharing.

[@rvalens2]

I have an 1854 type 1 gold dollar and after comparing it to the one in the video, I wouldn't have bought it either. It doesn't look right. Its details and patina are off. As someone else already posted, it looks brassy. US coins are impeccably minted (errors excepted). And this coin appears to have been poorly struck.

[@Rob-sx8ek]

Must be tough when honest. For the most part, people come in with counterfeits. It's not like they're trying to get you, but didn't realize they had been gotten. Must be hard breaking the news.

[@CoinHELPu]

It is

[@marymastromauro8164]

Those are nice for counterfeit

[@donaldcombs7701]

That calaifornia gold piece is beautiful

[@mikebarushok5361]

I've had counterfeit British gold sovereign and half sovereign that look a little too perfect and a little bit reddish. The reeding is the dead give away. Too sharp. Good gold and tend to be slightly overweight. So, not hurt when buying for melt prices. There's a story that there were quantities clandestinely ordered by the UK from the middle eastern counterfeit producers because they needed them for inclusion in airman survival kits where the only universally accepted money was gold coins. I don't know if there's anything to the story, but it doesn't sound completely implausible.

[@dougwagoner2620]

Wow they are real looking coins Daniel

[@VulcanGunner]

This why I do not collect, although I did get burned on 10 fake silver Prospector rounds.

[@stevelauda5435]

I only buy from reputable dealers.

[@kingsilver638]

But was it a gold coin It still had to go content in it correct It wasn't being sold as a graded coin

[@torpedo1306]

It's kind of surprising that the grading companies wouldn't give a PL designation for just the obverse, like the California example, same if the reverse was the only side that looked proof like. It seems that having that designation, even with one side having it would still make the coin more desirable to collect than a coin that doesn't have that appearance. As for the counterfeits, at least they have the gold value in them, they would be good teaching examples considering that they still have some value, it shows the lengths that these fraudsters will go through in order to trick the unsuspecting buyer.

[@TheWinstonDouble]

It's really goofy. They do the same thing with cameo designations on 50s and 60s proof sets. You have to have the same cameo on both sides. I as the consumer don't give a hoot about that. I only care about cameo obverse. It would not be hard to put a dual designation for each side.

[@joshuahsimons9587]

Didn’t show reverse of 1st coin 🤣

[@stevec7712]

People were making FAKE coins back in the time of the ROMANS - I'm sure the Emperor would find you a job working with the Lions at the Colosseum in Rome - LOL

[@danieldevite668]

The headdress doesn't look right

[@michaelbishop7358]

Do you have a real coin to compare against?

[@buyystocks]

those fakes just look to perfect, almost no marks too, for soft gold.

[@Commin_Cents]

So are the coins real gold and just struck somewhere else, or are they not solid gold either?

[@CoinHELPu]

These are 90% gold

[@scottholliday9308]

👍

[@donnieberry455]

False dies, but we're they at least real gold?

[@CoinHELPu]

I answer that in the video.

[@dmpi483]

The fakes look real to me. If it tested as real gold I would have been completely sold on it.

[@yamaha226]

Fool PCGS and win i guess is the new game to play.

[@tom_morgandealer_pgh1648]

I consider my self a us coin expert (what i don't know i can find in books or online) i will always avoid gold. I won't certify or buy its just to tricky and hard to tell without sending it in like that. Fakes alot of time test out as real gold.

[@paulbegansky5650]

Hate fugazi