These Mods Are Ruining Minecraft Horror

[@Ado_enthusiast1999]

Man, rushing to the last location i died before all my stuff disappear is way scarier than this heap of garbage

[@lucderp_128]

Literally 😭

[@godzillarocks6331]

wrong.

[@Ado_enthusiast1999]

@godzillarocks6331 lowkey dont care

[@Wolf_Blob]

Ado world domination!!!

[@JackRogers-x9e]

@@godzillarocks6331Nah. It’s true.

[@Carpenter_ant]

The Boiled one mod is the most inaccurate attempt at making analog horror in minecraft yet idfk how the boiled one slides across grass of all things at that speed. And the fact it gives NO paralysis to the player is crazy

[@DT_JuniX]

A newer version gives a paralysis effect

[@Carpenter_ant]

@DT_JuniX isn't that the slowness effect one? I saw one which gave the slowness effect so the player could move still.

[@DT_JuniX]

@@Carpenter_ant No, it gave a custom effect called paralysis

[@AVeryStableFusion]

The boiled one shouldnt even be attacking cuz he doesn’t do that in the analog horror :/ and there is no tv.

[@Zentailium]

Feels like a complete insult to the original creator because it is literally just a reskinned cave dweller

[@funnymonkey3961]

5:08 from my own experience as someone with hemophobia, it’s less of an actual fear like “Oh no it’s blood! I’m going to die! I need to run the world is ending!” And more of an unreasonably intense reaction of disgust, like “ Oh no that’s blood! Don’t think about it, don’t think about it, oh shit I thought about it. I’m gonna throw up and the room is spinning.”

[@Lakita2880]

Quite a lot of phobias aren't just actual fear. I'd imagine its kinda similar trypophobia? (Actual trypophobia, not the people who act like they have it) where you get physically sick and your skin crawls and itches.

[@thunderspark1536]

​@@Lakita2880That's still fear, just physical instead of mental.

[@diogoayres7953]

Also, you're not so scared of blood in of itself (Otherwise haemophobics would likely also inherit some degree of of traumatophobia, a fear of injuries), more likely you're scared of diseases transmitted by infected blood.

[@Random_BS2889]

​@@thunderspark1536 sounds more like disgust or discomfort rather then fear

[@thunderspark1536]

@@Random_BS2889 That's part of the disorder we call phobias. It can manifest in various ways depending on the person, some people faint, some throw up, etc.

[@kidnappednapkin]

Can we have a mod where herobrine is the players best friend and we have a very good wholesome time with him like true bffs?

[@minecad2828]

I mean, From the Fog can technically serve as that. You just need to believe herobrine is watching out for you and not stalking you

[@EvanTheInsane]

@minecad2828 Exactly i mean he does sometimes punch me in the nose for Looking at him but he's just a Chill Fella.

[@oxotniknaoleney]

I actually had a similar idea for a mod. When you summon herobrine, he just starts randomly showing up in the distance, watching you. A fey days later he gives you a book with “Rendezvous point” written in it and some coordinates. When you go to those coordinates, you can see him sitting on a stair block (kinda like that meme, where vergil dmc sits on a plastic chair) and tells you that he is curious about your nature and is looking forward to cooperate in the future. You can then give him gold or diamonds on an altar in exchange for rare items, like totems of undying, ench. gapples, etc. or powerful armour and tools. Pretty cool idea, i hope somebody with experience in modding can make this a reality.

[@HasselPholen]

I agree

[@Roto3]

No.

[@braintrain4310]

I like how in 2 years Mojang went from the actually scary warden to the creaking, shame because the pale garden does have an eerie feel, it's just the horror it fails at

[@MasterCorneilous]

Based

[@Lindi-e7q]

Invalid opinion: prepare the death ray

[@oxotniknaoleney]

The creaking is not really meant to be scary tho. It is a surface biome, while the warden is in the caves. Creaking is more just a gimmicky fun golem-like mob to play around with.

[@memeymeme.]

@@oxotniknaoleney You could say that about the warden too, its got a gimmick, is golem like, and you can mess around with it (since minecraft has cheats and creative. The fact is that the creaking fails to feel like a threat (and therefore to be scary) due to fundamental flaws in its design philosophies that the warden doesn't have.

[@oxotniknaoleney]

@@memeymeme. there are some neat uses for the Creaking, like sight detection, or a cool, yet inefficient base defence in multiplayer. The very fact that the creaking heart is craftable allows for great utility in survival. The warden is wayyyy more dangerous, but not nearly as versatile as the Creaking because of it.

[@TurtleBoyoIsCool]

the creator of mimicer is one of my friends and he’s moving away from dwellers as a whole. his new mod silhouette was made with notelekz who is the creator of scopophobia, and he’s working on an update for the mimicer with new ai which will release next year

[@lucderp_128]

Something I’d personally find a better introduction to the mimicer is first show it off as a Steve watching you from the distance, soon it’ll come towards you and shift and transform into its “nightmare” version, maybe a vanilla style is also not bad

[@TurtleBoyoIsCool]

@ I’m PRETTY sure that’ll be a feature but it’s still being developed so we’ll see

[@lucderp_128]

@ that’s good 🙏

[@frickingfloppa]

​@@lucderp_128 there’s a mod like that called ’the Anomaly’ tho he either takes his time to spawn or just fucks you up every night, the mod itself is amazing imo

[@zombieboss5178]

@@lucderp_128 or idk, maybe it mimics other mobs and then attacks you? Maybe it's a virus that infects mobs and they transform and it can spread through prolonged contact and checking for infection is expensive in some way

[@amaze3727]

Im making a mod about an immortal snail, seeing as other immortal snail mods are mccreator slop. My idea is to make it scary, but a different kind of scary. It can keep its chunk loaded, spawns after the fist night, and is perma aggro'd on the player wherever they are. Slowly moves towards the player, can climb, "dig" out of being trapped, swim, and if it realizes the player is at a Y level higher than it, it gains the ability to fly if it is within a certain radius of the player (anti sky base cheese), as well as dig out blocks. Knowing you're constantly being hunted is what I'm going for, as opposed to jumpscare by big lanky man. IDK if it will be scary tho ;-; might just be annoying. The player would have no knowledge of where the snail is or how close it is

[@lucderp_128]

Make the snail super small but super detailed in textures and when it gets closer and closer you’ll be weaker and slower or your hunger will go down quicker, best mod ever then

[@Americanbadashh]

Mc creator hasn't been slop in ages. It's not the 2010s anymore.

[@amaze3727]

@@Americanbadashh It's always been slop. Will forever be. Pressing a few buttons and coming up with the same generic preset for armor, mobs and items isn't creative or appealing. Unless you use it for it's manual coding as opposed to being stunted by using it's Scratch "block building" coding mechanic, your mods will always be limited and spaghetti code. If you use Mcreator, I suggest you learn java and make your own mods instead. Take the examples I gave. The "immortal snail" mods that exist are all made on Mcreator. What does this mean? The snail stops aggroing on the player if they go too far. When it comes in contact with water it will sink and stop moving. It despawns. The player pillars up 2 blocks and it's over for the poor snail. Go to the nether or another dimension and the challenge is over. None of these are necessarily the mod makers fault. Other than using MCcreator, I mean. Maybe nowadays some of the issues mentioned above could be fixed using MCcreator's block coding, but not the main de-aggro issue.

[@nightwatcherking3185]

Make non immortal snails, which spawn in swamps, and have the immortal snail look identical, and possibly be silent when it moves. So you never know

[@tftc97]

​@@amaze3727 I think you're generalizing here, the slop numbers have significantly lowered over the years

[@madduckling4436]

the problem with all this , is that the idea of the dweller started out as a unique idea from a guy who wanted to give cave sounds a monster of its own , then it happened people started copying it , relying heavily on the creepy designs , if I remember correctly the first dweller was called the cave dweller he might've updated it by now , but still it fit more with the minecraft world , some of the new dwellers don't even belong in the world they seem like they're from another universe unfitting with the blocky style of minecraft in addition to that the developers went the easy route and copied someone else's homework , all of the dwellers stalk and kill the player , some tried to be a little bit more unique like the knocker... maybe...kinda... but other than that they all feel the same; The reason they get more attention is because of the fake reactions being uploaded on youtube , I literally cringe at those imagine getting spooked by the same thing over and over again for no reason even though you expect the jumpscare to happen and even if you didn't some of these youtubers literally make things more inconvenient for themselves on purpose by going out in the open and not getting any armor or a way to defend yourself just to let the kids on youtube get the reaction they want from you. sorry I know its long but you wanted our thoughts or opinions on the topic so here it is :)

[@lucderp_128]

Exactly my thoughts, The Root of Fear is for that reason a perfect example of a good Minecraft (maybe not horror) mod. It’s vanilla stylized, same for the original cave dweller and knocker sort of

[@snek9388]

@@lucderp_128 Horror shouldent be reused slop. Honestly what these mods lack is a sense of danger or anything. They are quick to attack give a cheap jumpscare or instakill and repeat. Something that stalked the player. Hid barely out of sight. Opened doors killed livestock maybe messed with their things slightly. Rattled trees and other things. And attacked the player depending on the time place and situation.

[@Spesnom]

Imma be honest, Mimicer was scary at first but then when Lookout3D started to overuse it it just got old and not scary

[@derthevaporeon]

Tom also made me look at the guy like a joke lol

[@kuronya3582]

Amount of inaccuracies in boiled one are mind bogling, from really terifying it become cheap jumpscare festival what exhaust extremely fast

[@Shellydandysworld88]

We owe the Cave dweller an apology

[@Archiver_Studio]

I feel that a lot of horror mods tend to forget they're meant to be SCARY Instakilling and repeated actions aren't gonna cut it after awhile The og Cave Dweller was scary because it had MULTIPLE different ways of hunting you, it could charge, and it could climb through 1x1 block holes to hunt you

[@azireinn]

so it could either charge at you or charge at you but in a smaller space. bro 😭

[@Archiver_Studio]

@azireinn Yep, that thing is swift and sadistic

[@kktyr4580]

EXACTLY, alot of these mod devs think it has to be a threat to be scary, take notes from games like Phasmophobia, and Subnautica, you need to keep players on edge as theyll be subtally scarred, make the entity's presence known but dont make it more talkative than the popular girl at school (cough cough FlameC Goatman) and just when the players start to get used to it and it loses its cool either add something new or change what it was doing, adding something new will put players on edge and theyll study the monster while changing what they know will make them question everything, have ways to catch players off guard, ect

[@Archiver_Studio]

@@kktyr4580 Perhaps instead of it just constantly being in the distance, or being triggered by looking Make it start out at a distance, then it gets closer over time After it gets close enough, the cycle starts again But something needs to be unique

[@NertNeverlander]

And the key point: it's all was just a sketch, a rough representation of concept's potential

[@absoluteCatastrophy]

someone shohld make a joke horror mod called "every dweller mod ever" and it just adds an invincible creature called The Dong Gobbler that crashes your pc when it hits you

[@UmCaraDoTijolo]

The goatman is now just a loud ass dog and the mimicer just spams "i see you, blablabla"

[@morbidly1]

thats so real bro

[@twertel-qz6xe]

the mimicer voiclines kind carry it. " My skin is stretched to its limits." that line hurt to hear.

[@hnaw1360]

1:26 I like the one second of Joy from Inside Out on this💀 Damn the true spokesperson of fear. The embodiment of joy

[@lucderp_128]

Omg how did you spot that 😭

[@hnaw1360]

@derp_128 Watch it again. It's STRANGELY obvious 🤣

[@lucderp_128]

@ yeah now that you know where to look it is obvious 😭

[@seagoulash9592]

Id love to see a mod that adds "white eyes", the sorta proto-herobrine that would supposedly remove the torches you'd placein caves after you left, it'd def add to the horror of a more vanilla experience

[@lucderp_128]

Omg fr, just a mod that makes your world have alpha generation and textures or a mod that adds an alpha Minecraft biome with alpha caves where the white eyes creature roams, with its shadow arms and body that can maneuver all over the cave ceiling and walls like a literal shadow before killing you or making you go insane

[@MaxwellDST]

yeah while that would be creepy for maybe the first 2 hours, after that it would be ''oh come on man he removed my torches again?''

[@BabanDlh]

I wonder how effective a mod that adds nothing would be You'll think something's gonna happen but it never does, you stay in a constant danger state

[@yata3826]

Sometimes sounds play but for no reason

[@BabanDlh]

@@yata3826 good idea

[@seandorama5932]

Would be hella fun to use to mess with people but eventually wouldnt people get used to it?

[@BabanDlh]

@seandorama5932 they'll get used to it like for everything

[@omegaentertainment01]

​@BabanDlh ...and perhaps blocks sometimes shift a little bit out of position when the player isn't looking at them, as if something you can't see is moving them?

[@kratoesgetsfreaky1383]

Another thing that I find redundant is that why do most of these horror modes don’t come up with actual unique names? Almost every single one of these horror modes have to go by “dweller”.

[@godgod4226]

I feel so bad for gargin who originally came up with the cave dweller AND the nextbot ai for basically 90% nextbots on gmod cause his two biggest creations in modding have been bastardized and shitted on despite them originally being good concepts and good mods.

[@GeorgeCowsert]

LookOut3D did an excellent job at completely dogging on the Dwellers by just turning them into goofy characters, with the player being the true menace of the story. The real problem with Dweller mobs is that they are predictable; you know that once you encounter it for the first time, it's gonna show up again. No, GOOD MC horror comes from stuff like Alex's Caves. The Abyssal Caverns and Forlorn Hollows are terrifying specifically because of their environments. You do not want to be there, and that's way before you even encounter a mob.

[@TotPocket]

I'd love to see mods for spooky creatures similar to the Knocker, but they never really are a threat to you or anything. They just watch you from a distance, phase into existence near campfires, curiously knock at your door. It sounds like a fun concept, and would be a funny shake-up from the current modding scene

[@Small-stick-o-butter]

Im also a fan of psychological horror, instead of the monsters just running at you and making a loud sound

[@chipahoyvg]

It's pretty hard trying to make a game like Minecraft actually scary tbh

[@GhostBoyCrimson]

brooo where is midnight lurkerrr HES THE PEAK OF THE DWELLER ERA DAWGGG hes: A: Completely killable,- although difficult B: Can be fought back against, hitting him will make him stunned temporarily C: Has so many mechanics i lost count making it unpredicatble D: has a model that feels like a minecraft mob rather then something out of tune wit the minecraft style

[@lucderp_128]

Yeah he has some cool mechanics I’d say but wasn’t much of a recommendation in my eyes, but hey that’s why we have the comments, so you can recommend it 🙏

[@hyx6194]

An idea for a good horror mod would just be a psochological anxiety horror. So there isnt any jumpscares just world screwing around with you more and more as you play. Starting off as random cave sounds then as time goes on, random sounds(pickup, craft door etc.), to awkward silences, random items slightly moving spaces in the inventory, fake mobs Blocks slowly moving when absent, Night and day randomly swapping textures etc. So you would have small anxiety attacks and stop to think a little. Good example of this is a mod from doom named ,,The thing you cant defeat"(peculiar name tbh) that does something to that point

[@dreamcast.0]

"The Vampire from Demeter" HIS NAME IS COUNT DRACULA!!!

[@lucderp_128]

Alright 😭 should’ve included Count Orlock/Nosferatu too

[@Soup_Can_Gaming_And_More]

I had an idea of a creature that instead of being hostile, it only attacks in self defence or when it's feeling threatened, and you could somewhat befriend it by leaving something like cooked beef to show that you ,ean no harm

[@lucderp_128]

Why does this remind me of the Debase ARG 😭 (good idea btw)

[@Soup_Can_Gaming_And_More]

@@lucderp_128 ive had this idea for months but this is the first time that I actually share the idea so thanks

[@blackhorizon_worldwide]

At last, somebody who decided to catalog underrated mod instead of reposting overrated dweller ones! =) On the topic of "From another world mod", I played that at one point, and it brought me a new kind of horror: Paranoia. Overtime, you struggle to trust anything in your world. And when you slay a mob you thought was untrustworthy, but turns out to be alright, you feel that sanity drain. I think it's really interesting when a mod explore a type of horror that isn't generic.

[@TrafficPartyHatTest]

I honestly believe it's nearly impossible to make a game like Minecraft (a sandbox) scary. You can make it dreadful, but if I can spawn in full enchant netherrite with commands or just build up 200 blocks away and render a thing impossible to get me.

[@Dillyj8]

One mod I find good is minecraft vhs, not because of well the horror like mobs in the game but the fact it turn both the fog and brightness down, where it hard to see, those two things are what make something scary as you dont know what is there, it more scary not knowing what you dont see then what you do see, as it give you the fear of the unknown

[@Stormalisk]

The fact Red Eyed Barry exists automatically makes them all inferior.

[@_.lol.its.me._]

Literally horror mods annoy me more with the loud sounds they use then it scares me

[@cooleecoolee9504]

Scape and run parasites really does well in minecraft, hell it scared me a few times just because I open the door just to see a adapted longarms at my front door

[@FunnyMantf2353]

Dude, i can't stop thinking about the Lookout3D shitposts whenever i see these mods

[@Cendimix]

Got quite the sobering reminder that most horror mods suck while I was trying to make my own modpack and ended up having a horror modpack of around 300 mods and probably only like 12 actual horror mods.

[@rawcommunist9170]

Im gonna be honest, I think the steve dweller mod is more of a mimicer than the mimicer mod. He doesn't come after you in the ovwrworld but he does try to find you in caves, making the stone step noise and when he find you, and when done correctly it is genuinely scary

[@rawcommunist9170]

Another thing I wanna point out is the creaking reskinned mod for the cave dweller, that mod in my opinion is scarier than the cave dweller because it doesn't make any screeching sounds to know when it's arrival will come, it's completely silent, and when it catches up to you it throws you off guard

[@JNJNRobin1337]

its only a matter of time before someone makes the dwellestation mod or a "dweller mod" that just makes the game close on startup (best way to be unbeatable is to not start the fight to begin with]

[@lucderp_128]

The fact you can activate this feature in the from the fog config where it can crash your game

[@MSSHDMUSIC]

Whispers of the Wendigo mentioned 7:40 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 As the author of that mod I must say I love seeing it being mentioned and I'm glad to put something out into this niche. Also 🔥🔥 video

[@twertel-qz6xe]

an idea for a horror mod I had is, " peacful" its just permalocked on peacful mode, but the world feels off, and some odd and unsettling things happen. no jump scares, just the stress. you know there is nothing to get you but you cant help but feel like there is.

[@Small-stick-o-butter]

Seeing things move around in the corner of your eyes in a cave in peaceful mode would actually make a solid horror mod, especially if it also locks you in single-player

[@arandomcrusader8822]

​@Small-stick-o-butter maybe occurring after a night or two as well, as a sort of paranoia because nothing is going wrong

[@xrinn6]

mimicer is probably the biggest slop entity there is

[@frickingfloppa]

2:20 what is my boy The Slumbering Omen doing here? 😭😭

[@lucderp_128]

Just an example

[@Wowoda]

For anyone wondering, the shaders in the intro are: spooklementary

[@sonicloverlol2]

Your fate was sealed the moment you stepped into that graveyard

[@AsbestosEnjoyer]

That spider dream example reminds me of a nightmare I had where it was literally just a kitten whose eyes were all blue/gray and foggy, and after I put out my hand they fell out of it's head snd revealed two sockets full of cobwebs and baby spiders. I woke up very disturbed

[@Marek_73]

I feel like there should be horror mods based on creepypastas

[@goosemanVEVO]

I think its easy to forget that horror is just as much about the part where you cant see the creature, as much as it is about the part where you can. A bosy horror monster suddenly rushing at you with a loud nouse is very scary once or twice, but it has no atmosphere or build up.

[@DynamicPancake]

Fr though the Wilted is incredibly underrated

[@TheMrFancyKiwi]

The biggest problem Minecraft horror mods have is that once the player dies to something it is no longer scary but so many of these horror mods jut have the monster show up, kill you quickly then ether disappear or camp your stuff. Minecraft is actually amazing at building an atmosphere of being alone to put you on edge then tall, lanky, loud, bloody creature 24 shows up moving like Usain Bolt and two hits you and all tension drops out.

[@lucderp_128]

The scariest thing you can do is play from the fog with peaceful mode 😭

[@PanTristeHB2]

we get it bro youre an horror expert

[@lucderp_128]

Thank you 😭

[@sadrkama4061]

But you can just use invisible creepers recourse pack and that is more than enough to scare you

[@zuzenfork]

yo from what mod is this silly goober creature at 16:09 ?

[@lucderp_128]

You mean Freakbob? It’s called Shloringus 😭

[@WinterHE]

See, I'm a person who only gets scared when completely immersed in the experience. Caving in Minecraft can be scary, not because a Creeper can fall on top of you out of nowhere and kill you, but because you are so immersed in the ambiance that you forget you are playing Minecraft, your brain takes over and makes you think "But what if..." And there isn't a greater fear than the fear of the unknown. I would find more "terrifying" a mod that tells you It adds "something" but in the end It doesn't, because you won't stop thinking about the "what ifs". I find Dweller mods to completely miss the point, a mob that randomly kills you out of the blue isn't scary, It is an annoyance, and when you are annoyed you are not immersed, you know you are playing Minecraft with a mod with the goal of annoying you. The Warden was great at first, but the fear is quickly replaced by the tension derived from not wanting to trigger the spawners, and It ultimately disappears once you have removed the sensors or spawners. I haven't seen the Creeking or whatever it is called because nothing was added in that update that makes me want to return to play the game, this new mob sounds like an annoyance to me more than anything. Some time ago I saw a video about a mod that looked promising, It showed the person in a forest with a pretty strong storm, the vibe was perfect, until this Dweller mob just appeared out of nowhere and rushed to the player and oneshotted them, great. The good atmosphere of the stormy forest with the low visibility was immediately broken by a fast moving mob you can't avoid that kills you in one hit, what a waste. From the recommended mods I want to try Manic because It looks fun to play. I would like to see more mods that focus on creating a more immersive and spooky atmosphere via sounds and visibility, I don't think "Dweller" mods can be scary unless they appear VERY RARELY and focus on psychologically messing with you, not knowing when they will finally show up and not knowing what they can do. The screaming mobs that rush at you and kills you in one hit will never be scary, they are nothing but an annoyance.

[@ZarkAnimates]

Tbh the Cave Dweller Addon for Bedrock worked extremely well, ik its not a mod for Java but it was pretty awesome.

[@lucderp_128]

The addon is so much better fr

[@ZarkAnimates]

@@lucderp_128 indeed so

[@noah-sraben]

There's a Cave Dweller Bedrock Add-On by the OG maker of the Cave Dweller.Honestly, it feels like one of the best horror mods I've seen, next to one of the Herobrine mods I've played. it stalks you, learns from you, adapts

[@lor1den627]

I don't appreciate the spider jumpscares :(

[@lucderp_128]

Sorry 😔

[@nohandlesplease]

Weeping angles might be a bit better. If you know SCP 173 then you know the gist. Keep your eyes on them or else. They take a custom stance of you catch them JUST in time and no need for a jumpscare noise.

[@Small-stick-o-butter]

I'll be honest, walking in the dark, empty stronghold by myself at 10:00 pm is more of a pants pissing adventure than most if not all of these mods

[@chris08crimson08]

I think the best way to scare the crap out of somebody is to make them more and more comfortable. THEN, have the door slowly creak open along with an eyeless steve standing there making gurgling noises walking towards the player.

[@teucugames5646]

We need an lobotomy themed minecraft horror mod

[@ethanhale6931]

Personally the knocker was my favorite horror mod, just seemed unique to me, though admittedly after the 10th night in a row of him showing up at my bed (and I had supremium armor [Mystical Agricultural mod armor] by that point so he literally did 0 damage) I got sick of him lol

[@0SeventyTwo]

I like playing with horror mods, but yeah, most are trash. Thankfully, im capable of fixing animations and adding my own features and fixing the annoying loud sounds to make what I think creates better horror.

[@cross_byte]

"scariest mod reccomendations" includes weeping angels (bad mod), dangers in the darkness (too annyoing [i guess that is a personal thing actually]), and something in the caves (literal slop) not saying they're all bad choices, but it did look like you did only a surface level dive into actual choices for people to be afraid, and i understand that is kinda hard because different people feel fear differently, but you should've tried to find more good conventional horror mods besides goatman and knocker fantastic video though, i enjoyed it a lot

[@lucderp_128]

Yeah the recommendations are more like “they make the game sort of scary when combined all together” instead of being scary when playing them standalone

[@violet_steak3412]

I'm completely fine with horror entities like the One who Watches and The knocker, but things like dweller reskins need to stop.

[@seandorama5932]

3:56 this made me more scared than 99% of horror mod (joking joking plz dont send me to the shadow realm)

[@BlackburnBigdragon]

Frankly, if you want Minecraft to be truely scary, all you need to do is load up one of those "Ultra Hardcore CTM (Complete the Monument)" maps. I used to play the ones made by Vechs all the time back in the day and they were terrifying!!

[@kuradamax]

ZOMG!!!1 Iz dat da HECKIN FART DWELLAH!?!

[@crybaby6845]

Horror is subjective. And while something that could really happen is scary for a lot of people. Something I find more scary is the unnatural. Some guy is some guy. Anyone could kill you, and that could be scary. But I already know what they are. Something that you can't explain, can't wrap your head around, you have no idea how to deal with it. That's scarier in my opinion. When you're up against a person, you may have an idea of what to do. But you'll never know what to do against the unknown.

[@brguii]

for the last 2-ish years, i've been playing horror mods, and it's quite sad to see the community go to shit, i've also been attempting to make my own horror mods for nearly a year now, as i have seen people's stuff and been inspired, but i know that my stuff isn't top tier, and far from it and i have just noticed you have added one of my mods! shloringus, purposely quite silly as the mod was originally some stupid little joke, but thank you and sorry that it lags... as archi said, mcreator mods kinda suck for that reason

[@emeraldhawk5148]

12:10 I'ma be honest you should really clarify that he died in minecraft because I straight up forgot he was playing on hardcore and thought he legitimately died irl

[@lucderp_128]

😭 I was worried about that already

[@50boiledpotato15]

We need a mod that makes masochistic people happy and non masochistic people suffer

[@GIGACAT573]

I find funny that im more scared of the vanilla lightning than all of those "horror" mods.

[@AzureTank776]

And then there's me, who always get jumpscared by the sound of the tools breaking

[@GIGACAT573]

@@AzureTank776 Not just you brother.

[@frisk5492]

The problem is with “horror” mod packs there is no suspense The best way to go about it is to have 1 or 2 horror mods with a ton/few “distraction” mods

[@Recoil1808]

IMO the best way to do Minecraft as a horror game is as survival horror. For this reason, I honestly think that infection mods are the closest to doing it right... And of course, some adventure maps, but back to the point. Where I feel that infection mods honestly fall flat though is they're too... Contained. They have one (or maybe a handful of) tiny little hub areas that will generally spawn around you, and once it's gone... It's gone. And of course because of how their progression works, it's impossible to start with a world already deeply infected by it, or have it snowball past what is already generated. Even if it were, again because of how their progression works, you'd be instantly thrown into the deep end against the most highly-adapted versions of the mod's monsters, made to be a genuine threat while in full, enchanted netherite and with weapon and armor mods.

[@detectiveinnitkid2880]

two modern horror mods I'd highly recommend are in your world and 000.jar, they tap heavily into the nostalgic and psychological elements of minecraft horror, in fact, both of them, especially 000, are intended to be like your playing a minecraft arg. they are by ebalia and are far better than the silence mod which he made too, which is getting remade and having more of the psychological and fear of the unknown elements intensely increased. the mods all have a shared universe with an interesting developing story, I'd highly recommend you check them out

[@lucderp_128]

If I were to play with those mods, I’d probably also make the world look like beta to get the extra nostalgia, because in a normal modern world it would look unfitting

[@bigrat1628]

Now I don't hate the horror packs, I actually really like them! My main gripe with them is how much damage everything does and I get it, its supposed to make you panic but sometimes its a bit much. Me and a friend decided to add a cave dweller mod to a modpack called MCSX and it made our experience a lot better and I really enjoyed the fear of just mining in general!

[@lucderp_128]

Yeah that’s a good modpack

[@osoairmazali787]

Well. Until next year derp! Lets see if wee get some new cavy news!

[@Frogsty]

very good video, i like it very much, also, speaking of horror movies, which one is your favourite, mine is noth that much scary but Krampus

[@lucderp_128]

Krampus is very cool tbh, sometimes goofy though, like they literally had that “joink” sound effect in it where the auntie was tossed out of the window 😭 I can’t really say I have a favorite horror movie since they all have their own thing that the other one lacks 😔

[@Felasonic12]

From worst to best? This is cinema sins vs cinema wins type of glow up

[@TransCat_]

15:21 btw I'm 99% sure that mod is called Neverend (also cool vid)

[@lucderp_128]

Yeahh I forgot the name 😭

[@Shadow_memez]

Are you trans?

[@TransCat_]

@@Shadow_memez yep

[@Shadow_memez]

@@TransCat_ i am men 🗿

[@Shadow_memez]

@@TransCat_ ayo are you gay? 💀

[@sammy_wills]

Oi dont rope the knocker in with all the bad ones. He's actually pretty good.

[@lucderp_128]

Sorry the thumbnail is an old one, he’s one of the good ones, you’ll see in the video

[@ItzPeechYT]

fun fact you can Turn off man from the fog structures in the config to get the old experience where he kinda just spawns. That was why i liked the old versions but when i figured this out I can still have the same experience but with the hanging from ceilings and stuff

[@HK-pq7pe]

No way bro forgot about the PEAK that is Gabble Goblin

[@lucderp_128]

😭

[@alexiacorbin3052]

5:06 i have trypophobia, giving me more of an intense, gut-wrenching repulsion when i look at these things

[@lucderp_128]

Sorry 😔

[@mcstabman5638]

Tbh the siren head mod is pretty good, it still does the "ooga booga chase" bit, but seeing and hearing it wandering in the distance is genuinely offputting, especially with foggy texture packs

[@lucderp_128]

He also does the hulk smash 😭

[@mcstabman5638]

@derp_128 he killed me through a building once lmao

[@Achromatic_0]

alfaoxtrot mentioned :D (he deserves love)

[@Coastly-u1n]

Sadly Im a bedrock player, but the og creator created a cave dweller mod on bedrock. It uses more of a paranoia style of horror. Not to mention he learns from you.

[@acrossarus]

If you want a good minecraft horror mod, try nevermore.

[@lucderp_128]

Yeahhhh

[@sirtartarusdev1937]

Its funny how A Craft Of Mine was initially gonna be a mod, and yet I have never played a horror minecraft mod. I dont know about scary, but they do seem hella fun, I might wanna try that modpack or whatever new one you have lying around Btw might just be me, but I think the fact that Minecraft is a sandbox game what makes the monsters seem funny rather than scary. If you could only build in certain zones, or with a Valheim-like building system... wouldn’t be minecraft exactly, but you would feel more limited against the threat I think Unless you are in multiplayer of course, nothing can stop you then

[@kannodePVC]

"This mpds are still ruining Minecraft!" Maybe... don't instal the mods?

[@lucderp_128]

Best advice, and I’m taking it 😭

[@MasterCorneilous]

16:20 you're such a chill guy

[@plill0_wmcfethers708]

only problem with the video is that you described a crazy ex trying to kill you as something that could happen to all of us. aint no way a minecraft like me is getting a girl friend lmaoo.

[@lucderp_128]

Maybe let’s just say a person that holds a grudge against you and breaks into your house and tries to kill you, doesn’t have to be a bf or gf

[@twertel-qz6xe]

the mimicer is actually not awful, I love the voice lines, they make it far scarier. " my skin is stretched to its limits." absolutely brutal

[@lucderp_128]

Yeah, it’s not awful but it has its flaws still that need fixing

[@Pocapka]

Kihec and the slumbering omen developer also make good mods together, they made Siren Head: Arival and it actually works like a siren head. They are now working on the Mangled Hound, should be out very soon (there's already a trailer) and it looks amazing. Also its not a dweller like the pale hound Slumbering omen is kinda nice too, it has a story, a scary goofy weird creature, but still a bit dwellery (you can also be a friend with the goofy ahh creature if they didnt change the mechanics too much) Btw campfires are good for sanity

[@RpgBlasterRpg]

Minecraft is supposed to be about survival

[@Clexie368]

How do u ruin something that has always been Bad?

[@lucderp_128]

Actually, you make a very good point

[@MasterCorneilous]

I really hope the jean jacket (from the movie nope) mod brings Minecraft horror to a better direction when it releases

[@dmwanderer9454]

modern "horror" has been diluted by childrens horror, and it all started with FNAF. (Bendy and Poppy actually, but FNAF started it)

[@ThepumpkinMPGOfficial]

DerpBlock is an underrated Minecraft youtuber, I've just started watching him and boy oh boy did I realize that creepypastas AREN'T real. Let's rewind the 27th of December 2024, 3:29 PM. I was playing in a Minecraft world me and my friends have, we were in 1.9.4, because we were doing a world on updating it every week. About ten minutes before the incident, my friends left, including the server owner. (We use aternos.) So, I was left alone, now alone, I build my house, having my game at max volume and subtitles on. Then it happened when I finished building. Subtitles: Gear Equips, Eerie Noise. I was genuinely freaked out when I saw that. I told them to join, tears filling my eyes, I was alone, afraid. The owner said, "It's 1.9.4, what do you expect? And creepypastas aren't real [my name]." I kept begging them to join because I was mentally freaking out. I am pretty messed up due to me watching a lot, and I mean a lot of analog horrors and playing horror games. At this point, a mental shutdown was on the verge as I kept freaking out. Eventually, I just hid in my house, but when I went to sleep, I woke up, OUTSIDE my house. I was about to mentally shutdown as it dawned upon me that I had genuinely freaked out over a children's game. (We're all 14 by the way.) I sent my friends pictures and the server host, my friend said, again, "Creepypastas aren't real [my name], are you stupid or are you THAT messed up?" Eventually, I logged off. The sad thing is, my friends just joked on it.

[@cometcal7387]

11:21 AlfaOxtrot? Now that's a name I haven't heard of in a while...

[@lucderp_128]

He’s Christian now (nothin wrong with that though)

[@cometcal7387]

@@lucderp_128 Yeah, that's fine. I just haven't seen his content in a while. I missed his stuff 🥲

[@Ultimate_Hater75]

I'm dyslexic and I too also have homophobia

[@lucderp_128]

😭

[@VyStarixOfficial]

My only problem with these horror mods is that they appear too often to a point where it's more annoying than scary, n the fact that they are too op so it's not even fun to have these mods if u wanna have a balanced survival experience