These Stardew Images Are Wrong. Can You Guess How?

I created an even HARDER Stardew Valley quiz and forced my friends Floydson and Slothy to take it! Who do you think knows Stardew Valley Better? This is some of the hardest Stardew Valley Trivia I've ever seen!
Floydson:
/ floydsonyt
Slothy:
/ helloitsslothy
TWITCH ► / seaniedew
TIK TOK ► www.tiktok.com/@seaniedew?lan=
INSTA ► / seaniedew
DISCORD ► / discord

[@SeanieDew]

EGGY?

[@anitaaranceta780]

You have now forced me to go back and watch that video. I need more Eggy

[@apo11ocat]

EGGY? chain

[@anitaaranceta780]

@@apo11ocat EGGY?

[@apo11ocat]

@@anitaaranceta780 EGGY?

[@Kowery105]

EGGY?

[@marebear419]

Blade telling Seanie he's correct is so much more valid after watching the rest of the video lol.

[@elenna1237]

He also got the first one wrong (as Blade mentioned in the chat) - if you skip the Clint cutscene fast enough you get the furnace recipe without meeting Clint. Blade did it in his “marry Haley as early as possible” videos. 😄

[@UltraDumbass1782]

I didn’t realize that Blade said that in the chat. That’s hilarious.

[@BigUncleStunna]

"There's nothing stopping you in Stardew Valley from throwing a catfish on the path" -Seanie Dew (2022)

[@youarecheesefaceit]

It's truly inspiring to me. Changed my life.

[@garra123454]

Words of wisdom

[@captaindemozan2700]

There's nothing stopping you from throwing a catfish on the path in real life, either.

[@DrZaius3141]

That last image was completely wrong. a) As pointed out, you can have 20,500g current funds with 20,000g earnings, if you don't spend your starting 500g. b) As pointed out, you can deny the cat/dog. c) The real issue is that you can't get Strawberries and a copper pickaxe without spending any money - and no money was spent. The other stuff in the inventory might be feasible with no money spent (Melon seeds as museum reward, mixed seeds can grow hot peppers which can be put in a seed maker - so it's really just the strawberries and the pick that are impossible.

[@DrZaius3141]

Also, gathered from another comment - full backpack requires spending as well. Bottom line: The current funds only make sense with no money spent, but money was most definitely spent.

[@lazynoodle6739]

That's what I thought off in the last one too

[@SeanieDew]

yeah i'm an idiot

[@DrZaius3141]

@@SeanieDew I wouldn't be that harsh, it's rather a case of "outsmarting yourself". Which makes at least half of you smart.^^

[@kill_psyfurr]

@Valerie Cox you can

[@wooloosus6866]

The first one isn't correct, you actually CAN get the furnace recipe without "meeting" Clint. If you skip his cutscene before he talks, you'll get the furnace recipe without meeting him. Source: a million save files where I only met caroline and willy before the egg festival so I could get the tea sapling recipe early.

[@elenna1237]

Another source: Blade’s video on the runs where he married Haley in mid spring by manipulating billboard quests (which requires not meeting too many people). I’m curious though, didn’t you also meet Robin and Lewis, since they are automatically met as soon as you open your inventory after the start of the game? Or did you avoid opening your inventory until you got tea saplings? Because if so that’s some impressive dedication to getting them as early as possible.

[@wooloosus6866]

@@elenna1237 you can still meet robin, lewis, and one other villager (I chose willy for the fishing rod) and get at least one request from Caroline before spring 13, and you only need one request + talking and liked gift giving to get 2 hearts in time

[@salmence100]

I could easily watch a million of these, I'm obsessed.

[@TheRandomYTDude]

Comments by members

[@jazzxd9417]

A very cool comment by salamence1000

[@BrassWing]

Both of them answered questions like a Jubilee Odd One Out. They knew weirdly specific questions, but didn't know peaches and melon seeds??? Did they read random Stardew wiki pages and never actually play the game?

[@Sofisasam]

fr😭 like they didnt even know you could see the seasons on the top right or that ancient fruit grows in stages😭 no hate btw its just so odd to me HAHA

[@salem-01]

It’s like they knew a bunch of super intricate details but had never actually experienced any genuine gameplay

[@gracerose4272]

@@salem-01sadly a lot of KZbin gamers are like that :/ they just record the game for content and could never truly endure the stardew experience. Also it feels like a job to them, so why would they just play games for fun. Anyway that’s what I think at least :p

[@terramarc]

Feels like that last question just kind of fell apart with both “wrong things” being technically possible in game

[@twenty-three7194]

1. Eggy??? 2. Pomegranate?? Peach seeds?? keep up the good work

[@FloydsonYT]

stop catfishing me seanie

[@freddythemyth]

Bruh

[@Kiss_My_Aspergers]

One thing I never expected adulthood to do to me was make me laugh at a random chatter saying the phrase "split dye kitchen cabinets" (13:18). Certainly not as hard as I did, anyway. 😅

[@Poefeathyr]

I was guessing the inventory slots on the last one since he earned all that money and hadn't spent any so there was no way withoug cheats to get all the slots

[@kill4karma]

That makes a lot more sense than the pet answer

[@brooklynfoster4650]

So that makes two things wrong with it that were not the intended “wrong” thing, which wasn’t actually wrong. Makes total sense.

[@rinsinplays3461]

In the game I played with my friend they had an ancient fruit farm so I knew what they look like and I remember wanting to plant one in my pot but the game wouldn’t let me. The only reason I knew the ancient fruit can’t be grown in a pot is out of SPITE, THOSE DANG ROOTS

[@arimago]

1:44 isn't it possible to skip Clint's cutscene within the first few frames, and "avoid actually meeting Clint", as seen in BlaDe's early Haley marriage videos?

[@aminaaziz9019]

no i think u just leave ur house at like nine

[@zxrii]

Even if it was possible you still wouldn’t unlock the furnace recipe

[@no-thanku]

@@zxrii you would still unlock the recipe (CA probably wouldn't let you skip it if you didn't). actually, at 10:01 blade himself says in the chat "You got the first one wrong btw" so ariana is right

[@HoshiArt]

@@zxrii it is possible and you still get the recipe. As long as you skip a cutscene before their portrait and dialogue appear, you don’t actually meet them. This can’t be done with Marnie or Demetrius though bc they force you to pick an option (mushroom vs bat, pet/no pet)

[@gorefield9795]

"But what if you said no?" "..."

[@HistoricalArkiver]

"ANYWAYS!"

[@brieoconnor9824]

For the second one, if a friend joined your world and opened the chest then gave you the sword, it would still appear closed on your game, so it's possible

[@macewindu5195]

Yeah errors were made

[@Dark_Side_Productions]

In the last image, it’s possible to have 500g more than your total earnings if you never spend anything, since you start with 500g and no earnings. But it’s not possible to get melon seeds, pepper seeds or a copper pick axe without spending money.

[@truepotatoking7486]

For that final one, I thought the answer would be the backpack size. You didn’t spend any money to get the fully upgraded backpack, because your total earnings *SHOULDVE* matched your current money.

[@rainbowsequinedfannypack]

Love these types of vids cause the viewers can play along too, hoping these are fun for you to make so that you can make more in the future :D

[@_soothsayer_]

For marnies house I thought it was that she was behind the counter as she's never there lol

[@HidingMonkeyCatNinja]

yesssss I’m so glad you made another one of these videos! would love to see more of them in the future :3

[@somenorweganguy8569]

Ok, im gonna be playing along, before the answers are reveled, first one is the furnaces, the second one is the sword is out of the chest, while its still locked, Didnt get the third one, or fourth, JOJA COLA ONLY COSTS 55G, Gottem, Is it the peach on the tree in spring? Ancient fruit in the pot, That one was the first thing i ever tried too put in a pot and they have too deep roots, Didnt get the marnie one, kents pants??? didnt get the hp one, or the next one, But it- ughh i lost.

[@Phrog1919]

Joja cola is 75

[@funkytime69]

Peaches grow in summer Cherries and apricots grow in spring

[@umbrellaenthusiast4505]

This was so enjoyable to watch! I'd love to see more videos of this concept!

[@bruuh0_0]

Not me thinking the wrong thing in the ancient fruit one was the butterfly being inside

[@athousandcopperbeesinawiza5576]

You can get indoor butterflies with the Butterfly hutch!!

[@orion8818]

@@athousandcopperbeesinawiza5576 how do you het that?

[@Moonlit-Sorrow]

@@orion8818 You can trade 200 bat wings for a butterfly hutch in the Desert Trader. I forgot if there’s a specific day or always available though…

[@Lucy-ir2zg]

You can’t get beer yet because it’s 7:30am and the 1st day and you can only get beer from the saloon at 12:00

[@jessemilligan]

I love this series so much, hope you keep doing them :)

[@lexhilic]

the image guessing vids are fun :D going to watch this now hehe

[@fran-yt4ok]

These are so fun! Hope you make more in the future

[@jacobc246]

The last one he had strawberries, which means he had to buy strawberry seeds so he couldn't still have all his money from the start of the game.

[@EvelotlTheCatsalotl]

I love these videos! keep doing what you do!!

[@SamLabbato]

gotta love blade being a wiki warrior in chat

[@jacindahutton7673]

the last image he has never spent money yet has a full upgraded inventory...

[@alsanishat8520]

Aren't there 2 things wrong with image 3 tho, cuz crystal path you can only get from krobus after you unlock the sewer 👀

[@MajiggerRose]

I think you can get the crystal path from Robin. It's the crystal floor is what you get from Krobus, I believe.

[@mr_marigold]

This is a sick idea!!! Loved playing along :)

[@Type_blazenil]

The prismatic challenge is one of the easiest for me, all you really have to do is stockpile of lridium, blueberries, corn, tomatoes, copper, and fiber. All of which you should have plenty of, especially if you're preparing for Qi's cuisine

[@GlewmShrewm]

I love these videos so much! :)

[@meowmrrrrow]

"i dont want seaniedew totell people i smell" thats fair. thats really fair.

[@Ylurple]

i would love to see more of these!

[@CalliopeTank]

16:41 you can actually have 500 more money than the total earnings, as the starting money doesn’t count towards the total earnings.

[@daffysplash6325]

Is that… Morgana I see on Sean’s shirt? 13:29 P4G! Great taste in games, my guy!

[@TheAlexandrine]

Slothy throwing out the vaguest guesses in human history "I'm pretty sure you need a quest for these statues..." AND???? lmao

[@CoolattasLab]

I love that the videos where Seanie makes the images turns into everyone going "ERM, ACTUALLY" about how these things are totally feasible

[@cakeyeater7392]

Growing plants in planter pots actually is huge brain. Especially with the space warping effect of sheds

[@Kisuux]

woah, I'm extra early. I love your videos Sean, you're my favourite Stardew Valley content creator!

[@redweege2929]

17:20 also if your totals funds are 20500 and your total earnings 20000, meaning you never spent a penny, you couldn't have the golden pickaxe since it costs at least 17k to upgrade from starter to gold (iirc you can only upgrade them from the blacksmith?)

[@Jmeddlin55712]

The last one you also have all backpack upgrades. That would be impossible with the earnings and current currency total being what it is.

[@madeline569]

Omg I love these sm!

[@ahrifangirl]

in order to get the jojamart achievement, I had to make a whole new save file to go down that route, and I decided to fully commit to this "Evil Playthrough." This meant that in addition to joining jojamart, I would choose all the mean dialogue options, and, most cruelly, I would deny getting a cat or a dog.

[@daedricdarling7049]

The real problem in the second image is that you're using worm bins.

[@TeaUnicorn]

seanie is right, no one would ever say no to the cat

[@leegamabolz]

PLEASE DO THIS MORE

[@tylers2710]

Well, you can get the golden sythe without quarry bridge with the room transition glitch.

[@MBheARTed]

Seanie shifting in his seat after each correct guess 😂

[@tess4940]

I love how the example and the the first one are both possible.

[@littledumbrainbow4948]

2 sinks in Marnies house is normal. Farms usually have multiple sinks and one is for humans and another one for animal stuff. Both to clean their items etc. Because you can get bad bacteria from using the same sink/products to clean human and animal things together.

[@demonicmerma1d22]

The 1st image isnt quite right if you instantly skip the clint cutscene you dont meet him and still have the recipe You meet him when his dialogue shows up

[@Kubamorlo]

also i think Clint should appear higher up on the list as the npcs should be in alphabetical order if you have not met them

[@stuffyworld10]

This one was so much harder than the first. Last time I was able to get almost all of them, this time I don't think I'll get any

[@LuigiFan77]

That "hardest one" in skull cavern I got immediately

[@4PersonL_AccounT]

“Yes! That’s correct!” Blade: *INCORRECT* 1:58

[@the-og-cerealkiller]

I thought the last one would have been that you had an upgraded pickaxe, but the money difference is only 500g

[@leticiasantiago6122]

You're definitely my favorite stardew Valley KZbinr

[@sachahb2541]

In the skull cave one in the beginning my guess was that his energy was too low, meaning he didn’t eat a stardrop at floor 100, therefore couldn’t have gotten the key? Or can you skip it completely?

[@Rosie_Vick]

you could continue descending from floor 100 without opening the stardrop chest :)

[@D.S69]

well actually you can get to the quarry before unlocking the bridge by using A chair and a Sword/scythe on the first day

[@woooooooooooooooooooooooo]

I think this is glitchless, ie you wouldn't be able to get these screenshots without cheats.

[@bunnyskye7593]

If seanie had given Kent green pants it would have been less obvious I think

[@adorkablee]

I was so confused and I was like what- I watched this already but then i remembered i was in the stream lol

[@Kiss_My_Aspergers]

KZbin suggested this to me because I like Stardew, but the REAL reason I clicked is I LOVE playing games like this! So I probably would've clicked on it if it was some other media I liked... I wonder if one day KZbin's algorithm will be that efficient? Who knows. Laziness may be a greater barrier than actual technology. So yeah, really fun video, would play along as an audience member again! =) Y'know... if you make this a regular thing. 😉

[@radiopit]

You can get the golden Scythe before you repair the brige in a normal game but you need some out of bound glitches 0:09

[@CreationTheAnimator]

The last one I thought was the fact that you bought the backpack upgrade but still had the starting 500g.

[@Tiggy227]

At this point im like 98% sure you're also the voice over person for the shorts on the channel Mini Katana

[@dovelyy]

my answer for the first one was that where's the hotbar? but i don't even remember if you could see the hotbar when you have inventory up

[@eqwips]

actually if you play multiplayer the 2nd or 3rd picture is do able since you can have a friend open the chest then give you the sword then you go into the mines and the chest wont be opened

[@3emad.065]

Fun video. The only problem is i don't have friends to test try this with

[@chloed4628]

dang for the fist one i thought it was you would have had to met willy to get the fishing rod to have caught those catfish to have them laying around

[@aaronsam6884]

Gold scythe can be gotten without bridge using chair exploit to get to the other side of bridge and use the farm totems you get from various sources

[@Meebe425]

you can get the golden scythe before you get the quarry. If you clip out of bounds at the regular mines with a chair you can get to the quarry mines.

[@Hedgicorn]

I thought the last one was that the character had glasses but it didn't show them on the second tab. I'm not sure if it is supposed to tho.

[@adeptgirl3454]

It's funny because I've played this game since 2016 and never noticed the season icons in the HUD.

[@D01383725]

So proud that i got the Marnie one

[@serenitywingss]

"what if you said no?" *seanie error 404* "ALRIGHT GUYS-"

[@dennisthegamecatmanguso6953]

You never told us what slothy smells like!

[@armadillo5754]

It is in fact possible to get the golden schyte before building the quarry bridge without mods, you just got to do a glitch.

[@alexthealex69420]

Actually multiple furnaces could be there. I think. What if there was a farmhand who met Clint and got the furnace recipe.

[@jessicakucuk9502]

YAY!!!! a new Video

[@Cyanability]

2:40 To be fair, in a multiplayer game, if one person hasn't claimed the reward the chest remains visible I believe

[@Leafmemes]

You can get the golden scythe before you open the quarry(bridge) you just have to do some chair glitching

[@Fandommember]

For image 3 isn't the crystal square floor in use bought from krobus who you wouldn't have access to.

[@superPancakes22]

just looked it up and it is, I didn’t know that. I thought you bought that floor at Robin’s. Nice catch

[@rachelanderson6929]

It is possible to have access to sewers by Fall 18

[@Fandommember]

@@rachelanderson6929 but not with only 6 things donated as was in picture 3.

[@superPancakes22]

@@rachelanderson6929 True, but you need more than 5 items donated to the museum to unlock it

[@rachelanderson6929]

You are ABSOLUTELY right. For some reason I thought you were talking about the pic in Marnie's house.

[@greap2294]

I got the gold sythe without quary. Used chair with mind stuff.

[@leonardomoyavieira2806]

but... you can catch the golden scythe before the bridge, just use the cave bug + chair

[@stoffydarko]

this is so hard to watch how do they not know the most simple things about the game but somehow know really specific information at the same time 😭

[@questionablebits]

I got a starry hill painting from a boat from the night shop without donating to the museum

[@ryefrylol]

woah this was crazy

[@acreativeusername8433]

12:57 one of the chatters saw the book in shane’s room and said “does shane know how to read” as their guess 😭😭😭

[@harlslayer69]

I've not even watched the video yet but all I can think of is "EGGY?"

[@yehonatanroth9467]

The last one also had a different face on the top menu compared to the full body with the background image

[@fearharambe3321]

Just learned that Sean does videos on a channel called Mini Katana. He’s a Demon Slayer fanatic like me!

[@hilemonpie]

that was fun!

[@PrincessFelicie]

Wouldn’t having the sword without having opened the chest possible in a multiplayer game where another player threw their sword into your inventory?

[@dummigummi353]

You can get the furnace recipe from Clint without getting the credit for meeting him, I tested it

[@user-ek4cp1wm9m]

Bro fixed his mistake on mistake

[@Snatcherofspines]

TECHNICALLY SPEAKING technically speaking, the first image is entirely possible in multiplayer as you could receive a furnace from the community center and just wack it with a buddy then BAM two furnaces :O