A Protestant Talks With a Catholic Theologian (First of Five Conversations)

[@aespejolc]

I am a catholic priest. I love your videos, it helps me to understand what other denominations believe and understand. I love your openess and most specifically your thirst for thruth and understanding the mystery of Jesus Christ. Keep up the good work, keep up looking! God bless.

[@paernoser871]

Thank you for what you do father. BTW... A word from the young.... More traditional Latin masses, please. Viva Cristo Rey!

[@maggiemcgee8487]

Hey it’s a rogue Legionary!

[@aespejolc]

@@maggiemcgee8487 did you mean happy Legionary? 😂😏

[@Andromedon777]

@iraje hall Yeah no

[@Andromedon777]

@iraje hall Quit being so arrogant

[@GrantParker]

Missed the opportunity to call this video "A Protestant and a Catholic Walk Into a Bar..." C'mon Matt :)

[@CrankyGrandma]

brilliant

[@ludwigvonn9889]

But its a restaurant

[@marcoromero1355]

Yess

[@Kitiwake]

@@throughhumaneyes7648 I would love to hear your views.

[@throughhumaneyes7648]

@@Kitiwake honestly im not in a place to argue. I do it too much as it is. I apologize for commenting and possibly raising negative emotions. God love you.

[@wilhufftarkin8543]

You should totally talk to Fr. Mike Schmitz! That would probably be the most wholesome conversation possible ;)

[@commscompany1502]

Carolus Magnus then Trent Horn and Brant Pitre

[@Renvere]

I think he would enjoy talking to Bishop Baron as well

[@aarongoss8514]

Yesssssss!!!!

[@nathanmarsili5265]

Or even Father Ripperger

[@wilhufftarkin8543]

@@nathanmarsili5265 Fr. Ripperger is level 120, while this guy is level 5. That would be unfair. ;)

[@jenc5371]

I love how the Protestant guy intently listened. Jesus must be happy seeing us united.

[@m.e4752]

❤

[@earonkilgo8735]

Jesus and his apostles

[@earonkilgo8735]

Came against false teachers of Gods word

[@flamingfir3774]

Listening is not the same as unity but all good.

[@eliseos4127]

So what! Did u want to see a punch up. Of course he listeneed, who wouldn't.

[@ChachiTelevision1979]

Former Protestant - Catholic for 6 years now. We’re thankful that you’re having these discussions, man. Praying for you - please pray for us too.

[@leahjames6870]

May I ask, what made you all convert to Catholicism???

[@ChachiTelevision1979]

Leah James It was a number of things, but it was mainly history and logic. I was reading backwards in time into the reformers, to the schisms, to the early church fathers, then ultimately to the scriptures (both old and new testaments). Each thing kept pointing to the Catholic Church.

[@ChachiTelevision1979]

KinnPlays Yes, though I’m a slow ready and it look me quite awhile.

[@meusisto]

@KinnPlays Of course! And Christ also came specially for the illiterate, who could never in their life times read even a line of the Bible. Christianity is not the religion of the book, but of the Person - whom we truly meet in the Eucharist.

[@meusisto]

@@leahjames6870 In a nutshell, I realized it made no sense to believe that God allowed his religion to be corrupted (soon after its beginning), then allow it to be restored only 15 or 16 centuries later, just to be corrupted again a little later (since protestants disagree with one another on some key issues) and even so believe that I particularly was in the right denomination, stp. Moreover, that meant I believed not in Christianity, but in the Bible: but a book can't talk by itself and must be interpreted. Thus there are many different interpretations. This way I believed only in myself, in my interpretation. In short: it was stopping believing in myself and beginning to trust in Christ.

[@isaiaht.5711]

I have been a Protestant my whole life, and I just attended my first RCIA class yesterday! I researched Catholicism for almost 2 years before I took the leap of faith, and God willing I’m on my way to full communion. Keep the awesome videos coming, Matt! If possible you should reach out to the Apologists at Catholic Answers, that would be fantastic dialogue!

[@matthewm5581]

Isaiah Tucker You’re in our prayers, Isaiah! The Easter Vigil will be an unforgettable day!

[@jenibertucci2457]

Your first Eucharist will be amazing. It is going to be a powerful Easter and I am excited for you. I've been blessed to be a cradle Catholic, but do recognize the power in Eucharist. My biggest "advice" is to spend some time in adoration.

[@beautifulspirit7420]

Congratulations Isaiah, you were a Christian now you will receive the whole truth of the Gospel and Christ himself in Communion! I am a convert from atheism. I had an encounter with Christ in 1985 and received my sacraments of initiation becoming Catholic in 1987. Praise God, I love Jesus and I love his church.

[@waynebergin3117]

Congratulations Isaiah!!! I'm so happy for you!!!

[@DW-yl9ww]

Hope you got to attend a May crowning and watch them carrying a statue of Mary around kissing her feet and placing flowers. And did you get your first rosary yet? That is idol worship. And good luck with the false pope.

[@behling89]

I was once a protestant. Now I'm a Catholic. I converted in 2018 and in 2019 I had my first communion and confirmation.

[@tinupeter]

Hebrews 10:26-31 For if we sin wilfully after that we have received the knowledge of the truth, there remaineth no more sacrifice for sins, [27] But a certain fearful looking for of judgment and fiery indignation, which shall devour the adversaries. [28] He that despised Moses' law died without mercy under two or three witnesses: [29] Of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy, who hath trodden under foot the Son of God, and hath counted the blood of the covenant, wherewith he was sanctified, an unholy thing, and hath done despite unto the Spirit of grace? [30] For we know him that hath said, Vengeance belongeth unto me, I will recompense, saith the Lord. And again, The Lord shall judge his people. [31] It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God.

[@georgeibrahim7945]

behling89 Welcome Home

[@behling89]

@@georgeibrahim7945 Thank you brother!

[@dibalaish]

Welcome home !

[@xxFairestxx]

Welcome home friend :)

[@frjohn413]

Great discussion guys! From an agnostic convert to Catholicism now ministering as a Catholic priest.

[@Lab-Rat]

And the Angels rejoice!

[@Kiru____]

Fr. John God bless you

[@dennix5057]

Hey man I hope to join you one day congrats!

[@learnbibleversethroughpict6027]

Thank you Fr. John for listening 🎧 to God's call 🕊️🕊️🕊️🎉😊

There is no god. Christianity is bullshit. Become atheist and believe in science

[@richardl.hernandez1401]

As a Roman Catholic, I appreciate the fact that we can dialogue with our Protestant brothers-in-Christ. Keep up the great work.

[@em1694_]

Richard L. Hernandez same here. I love it

[@PVCGunita]

Same here! God Bless everyone! #ecumenism

[@PVCGunita]

@uncivilizedengr even still. Though we aren't fully brothers and sisters in Christ, we are still brethren, or in the process of. That's why the Church prays that everyone may be one, as Jesus prayed for that time. We still consider you a fellow Christian, and as Christians we are technically (and should be) one big family.

[@kelslo74]

Phil do you think you and Mormons or JWs are on the same page too? How about Islam? They think their God is the same as the Jews. When you really want to know the truth,God will bring you to it.

[@PVCGunita]

@@kelslo74 The statement I said was meant for a Protestant/Evangelical. Even then you'd still treat them (other people not in that category) with love, like how would you treat your family. Love one another, even those who don't agree with you. It's not entirely their fault they are born JW, Muslim, etc... Unless of course they were born and raised as part of the Church, and then rejected it in their own free will, while understanding everything about what the Church is. It's not a black or white issue, there's more than meets the eye.

[@rinjuchenet772]

This is my current Theology professor! My respect for this channel has grown.

[@eDENjoetree]

He’s a very knowledgeable man, and explains things very well. You’re lucky to have him.

[@jenniferlewisharris7761]

You're so blessed!

[@SnowySpiritRuby]

Hey! Didn't know you had a youtube channel! He is definitely my favorite professor I've ever had, and one of the only reasons I was able to get through college successfully and graduate on time with the rest of my class. And he has this brilliant knack for being able to explain complex topics in a way that actually makes sense to me, even when no one else can, like what the separation of light and darkness during creation really means. (I was just randomly scrolling through comments on this video, and did a double take when I saw "my current theology professor", so I looked at the username - oh hey! somebody I know!)

[@thepickle5214]

As a Protestant, and seemingly the only one in these comments, thank you for doing these videos Matt and allowing everyone to understand a little more about their more distant brothers and sisters of Christ. Your work has done a lot of good and with any hope it will allow dialogue between each Church. God bless you brother.

[@Zaillothen]

Don't worry I'm here too. Will never pray to Mary! (Though she deserves respect as everyone else does)

[@19nineteenthirteen19]

​@@MatthewN07You don't pray, just clasp your hands and.... ask? 🙄

[@MatthewN07]

@@19nineteenthirteen19 I changed my stance now lol, I went through a brief stage of leaning towards Catholicism because it seemed like the 'cool thing,' but I have pretty much settled in a Presbyterian church now.

[@19nineteenthirteen19]

@@MatthewN07 Luke 8:21 NASB95 - But He answered and said to them, “My mother and My brothers are these who hear the word of God and do it.”

[@19nineteenthirteen19]

@@MatthewN07 happy to hear it Brother. I was enamored with a lot of the liturgy and traditions of the Catholic Church. But Mary worship, no matter how they dress it up, is just plain wrong.

[@AJ_Jingco]

FINALLY a Protestant who is RESPECTFUL of the Catholic faith.

[@samanthacharlton4123]

Finally a Catholic who isn't taking digs at Protestants 🙄

[@Korgon2013]

Indeed. I went to a 3 hr baptist church, 1 hr was devoted to catholic bashing. Real inspiring.....

[@Crazygirl-eu5dc]

I went to a Protestant church in London once and they also kept bashing Catholics. They were crazy Evangelists and I don’t like Evangelism. I realised Catholics are way nicer people.

[@stevencable6317]

Aj Jingco read history. The catholic church and the papacy deserve zero respect

[@AJ_Jingco]

@@stevencable6317 Well NEITHER are the Protestant Reformers either. They committed atrocities also like Martin Luther, Albert Zwingli, John Knox, King Henry the VIII and John Calvin.

[@redknightsr69]

I'm actually turning closer to becoming Catholic because of your channel. It helps me figure things out. I think what most Christians have a hard time with is accepting that you can be a part of another denomination of it fits them. I appreciate your honest and informatve videos.

[@carolinasjmj]

Jonathan Walker will be praying for you brother, what a beautiful thought that you are on your way home!

[@michaelaratnam6517]

Jonathan walker... I am sure Matt is doing this to you unintentionally 🙂

[@georgeibrahim7945]

Jonathan Walker download the Catholic answers app on your smart phone and listen to former Protestants now Catholic such as Jimmy Akin, Tim Staples etc

[@3firstnames983]

Become Lutheran instead. Same historical church but reformed to get rid of all the non biblical stuff

[@georgeibrahim7945]

3FirstNames Lurther started his own non biblical stuff such as being saved by Faith Alone. I’d rather follow the church Christ established the Catholic Church which means universal rather then the church a former Catholic priest started. Luther also wanted to remove the book of James which he called the epistle of straw and the book of Revelations out to but managed to remove some books out of the Old Testament that didn’t suit his doctrines

[@rsnowden]

I was a protestant for 40 years and converted to Catholicism after reading Church history, studying the history of protestant reformation, and observing the many problems with the protestant arguments. One clear observation, if Christ did not leave us with a Church, Christianity would look very different today. Protestants take the Nicene Creed for granted.The Church formulated the creed in response to heresies plaguing Christianity, mainly Arianism and Gnosticism. Each part of the creed is in response to a heresy the Church spent centuries combating. Had there not been a Church to formulate theology, the faith would nothing like it does today. You cannot read Apostolic Fathers without seeing they all strongly believed in a single Church. Christ instructed us not to divide and 500 years after the protestant reformation there are thousands of protestant denominations each claiming to have a better understanding of the scriptures than all the others. And every day more are created. As a protestant, I knew very little about the Catholic Church. What I knew I learned from other protestants who learned what they knew from other protestants. It wasn't until I began reading about the early Church did I have any concept of the full history of our faith. I knew of Aquinas, Augustine, and a few others but had only a cursory understanding. I had not read what early Christians who worshiped with the apostles had written. What did they have to say and how did they worship? All this is lost to protestants who stop at the death of Paul and don't pick up again for another 1,500 years. The depth and richness of Catholicism is mind boggling. If you are a protestant and curious to know what you've been missing, I recommend reading "The Fathers of the Church" by Mike Aquilina. It's a broad overview but it's a start.

[@lukejohnson1274]

It's nearly impossible to study Church history (openly and honestly) and NOT become Catholic. As a 37 year long Protestant my pride of realizing I was wrong was the last obstacle to me becoming Catholic.

[@elihu311]

Uh studied and still LCMS

[@lukericker8325]

Silverbird901 You can believe in a single Church and not call yourself a Catholic. In fact it’s easier, because you include all sons and daughters of Christ, those who are saved, as fellow members of your church body in Christ. We are unified in Christ, not Catholicism. We should be small “c” catholics, if that makes sense. (in the sense that catholic means universal). When you decide to name something as “the” church beyond Christ, you are actually the one drawing divisions. I agree that people should learn more Church history. Most protestants would find themselves agreeing with most Church fathers.

[@johnbrowne3950]

@@lukejohnson1274 My favourite part of Catholic church history is the Spanish and Italian Inquisitions where innocent non-Catholics were tortured and burned at the stake because they refused to convert.

[@tysonguess]

@@lukericker8325 "When you decide to name something as “the” church beyond Christ," Your issue then is with Christ because He is the one who said the Church founded on Peter would never be prevailed against (Matthew 16:18). He also said we have recourse to this church (singular) when we have disagreements and He said that this church (singular) will bind and loose infallibly (matthew 18:17). If heaven cannot affirm a false teaching, then Jesus is saying that this earthly authority He established will bind and loose (permit and forbid in regards to the faith) infallibly. So, since Jesus said we have recourse to this earthly authority it must exist in every century and it will be the only church that has made binding decisions that all Christians believe. There is only one church that meets that standard. In the absence of that earthly authority Christians can never have anything more than scriptural relativism. One can feel morally justified in how they interpret scripture but in the absence of the authority of the Church we can never know with certainty what scripture means with epistemic certainty. Which explains the ever growing fractured state of Protestantism. I too was a Protestant apologist and lay philosopher until I encountered the early church, which was thoroughly Catholic.

[@avantelvsitania3359]

20:06 From a Catholic perspective, the importance of Rome can be seen in two aspects: 1) It is not important simply because that's where Saint Peter died. But because that's where he was Bishop. The leaders of the Church after the Ascension of Christ were the Bishops, and Peter was the first among them. So after his death, the new heads of the Church would be his successors in what he was: the Bishop of Rome. 2) Rome is also symbol. The Romans were the ones who crucified Christ, and first persecuted His followers. So the head of the Church being in Rome, the center of the Empire who tried to crush "a small movement from Judea" , is a remembrance to the power of God that can defeat your worst enemy, no matter how big, and turn him into your friend and supporter.

[@ThisGuyfashoo]

That was actually beautifully said. Great points. - A fellow Roman Catholic

[@ceciliach.1906]

Not only that.... The importance of the magnitude of the Roman Empire. That helped the spread of Christianity big time. The times of God are perfect.

[@flickdrumming2851]

Super Clear on this verse brother. Romans 1:7,: "To all in ROME who are loved by God and called to be saints: Grace and peace to you from God our Father and from the Lord Jesus Christ."

[@flickdrumming2851]

@J P "immature" I assumed that you are a kid.

[@albertchristian4156]

Maybe it's God's way to fulfill Isaiah 53 chapter 12, "Hence I shall give him a portion with the many, and he will share the booty with the mighty, for having exposed himself to death and for being counted as one of the rebellious, whereas he was bearing the sin of many and interceding for the rebellious." The mighty nation by the time Jesus lived, the same nation that made the crucifixion and salvation possible was the Roman empire. So they will be God's tool for saving humans through His Church. His work is truly remarkable. Praise God!

[@kristynoble8848]

Raised Lutheran. 30 years a Catholic Christian. Still learning and growing in my faith. Thank you for you videos!

[@eliseos4127]

Go to an Orthodox ceremony...the original church. You will never look back!

[@AG-rb4qe]

@@eliseos4127 It's not all that

[@eliseos4127]

Try Orthodoxy.

[@Theworthsearcher]

@@eliseos4127 Yes, it is also beautiful. ;) There are many works nowadays to untie the eastern Christianity and the western. I hope, the 2 big tiles will untie soon. ;) You just have a different "exercise", so it just does not really matter. It is also apostolic int the meaning of the foundation on the 7 sacraments. I've been on a greek catholic mass simetimes. It is different and I did not understand as well, as the roman catholic because it has eastern melodies, which is not wrong, or bad, is just different, like a gospel mass, a rock mass or a latin mass or a quite mass or a gregorian mass and so on... ;)

[@learnbibleversethroughpict6027]

🙏🏿🙏🏿

[@rcwarrior868]

Matt, I love what you’re doing. As a practicing Roman Catholic, I love seeing your videos interviewing Roman Catholics. Many people misunderstand our beliefs, and it’s great that you are taking the time, and effort to understand and inform others of what Catholicism really is. I really appreciate what you’re doing, may God continue to use you as his instrument to bring people to Christ 🙏🏽

[@Kitiwake]

You not be surprised that Roman Catholics live in the diocese of Rome... only.

[@rcwarrior868]

Pat Aherne actually that is incorrect. The term “Roman Catholic” refers to the liturgical rite used at the mass. Most people that call themselves “Catholic” are of the Roman rite. There are different rites in the Catholic Church such as the Byzantine, Coptic, Armenian, etc. which are Catholic and under the authority of the Pope as well, they simply use a different liturgical rite.

[@jg2072]

Again I bring up the need to a a specificity to language. Throwing around the term Catholic to only being Roman Catholic doesn't help the discussion. But on the other hand saying Roman Catholic gives a definite starting point. Work to fully explain your point so that we dan advance the discussion. Peace

[@JoeLandrigan]

@@jg2072I may have misunderstood you, but I think you have this backwards. "Roman Catholic" is shorthand for "Roman Rite Catholic" and is excessively specific and doesn't actually refer to a church, but to a subset of that church. All Catholics belong to the church of the Pope, regardless of whether they are Maronite Catholic, Byzantine Catholic, Roman Catholic, etc. Something like 90% of Catholics are Roman Catholics, but if you are referring to the people who hold the beliefs that "Roman Catholics" hold (which all Catholics necessarily also hold) then you should not say "Roman Catholic" but "Catholic." The only difference between "Roman Catholics" and non-Roman Rite Catholics is the way they worship. That difference may mean one rite speaks Aramaic in their worship service, and another speaks Greek, but it's the same beliefs. So "Catholic" is actually the more appropriate term under 99% of scenarios.

[@dongyeonkim9549]

@@rcwarrior868 Catholics teachings are way off the Bible. The antichrist

[@georgeibrahim7945]

Bro it would be awesome if you can interview someone like Jimmy Akin, Tim Staples or Steve Ray who were former Protestants now Catholic and see their insight on what made them come to the Catholic Church

[@CrankyGrandma]

Or Scott Hahn....

[@georgeibrahim7945]

Cranky Grandma yeah he’s awesome too

[@ghallora]

@@CrankyGrandma yes! Dr. Scott Hahn.

[@monstersong7433]

And Jeff Cavins!

[@coondogbob]

Scott hahn trent horn

[@rachela.5311]

Former Protestant here, too! Now a very happy Catholic!

[@albertonuno1790]

Interesting!! Excuse me for asking this question. Have u read the Bible? The whole bible?

[@chuckHart70]

Welcome home.

[@chuckHart70]

@@albertonuno1790 I thought all Protestants did?

[@albertonuno1790]

chuckHart70 yes that’s why we are not catholic anymore

[@jackcraven8345]

Alberto Nuno stop

[@damon2098]

Myself as a Protestant theology grad and a very intelligent Catholic friend are having similar discussions -- heck perhaps we should film them. Thanks for this video man, very encouraging that we're able to unite on so many points.

[@jesusislordsavior6343]

Damon If 'uniting' means accepting multiple heresies, count me out. I am a firm believer in the fundamental unity of the Church, but under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, not some overarching administrative superstructure. When Paul warned against the partisan spirit in 1st Corinthians 1:10-17, I don't suppose that he intended compromise at all costs. That would be in conflict with the tenor of the rest of his writings.

[@Scottf573]

@@jesusislordsavior6343 this is very well worded

[@jesusislordsavior6343]

@WethePeople My house does not include the pope. I am not, have never been, and have never considered being Catholic. Jorge Bergoglio does NOT represent Biblical Christianity, Catholic claims notwithstanding. True, there are many Christians within the Catholic denomination who cannot disentangle themselves from past attachments, but no one can force them to leave if they do not wish to leave. JESUS ALONE is Head of the universal Church, which is a spiritual Body and not a temporal territorial/political entity. He is also the One Who will take over after the fall of the present corrupt world order, which will have to culminate in one-world government before it is totally destroyed.

[@jesusislordsavior6343]

@WethePeople I answered this objection on the page already. I said that my house does not include the pope. I am not, never have been, nor have ever considered being Catholic. Bergoglio does not represent historic, Biblical Christianity but is a heterodox ecclesiastical politician. There are many Christians in their denomination who feel bound by traditional loyalties and needlessly so, but one cannot force them to leave if they choose to remain. Jesus alone is Head of the Church, which is a spiritual Body and not a territorial/political organization like the Vatican. It is He Who will rule in justice and righteousness after the present world order has passed away. I believe that a brief period of one-world government will come about before it is inevitably destroyed.

[@DylanGames1000]

You should be catholic

[@weshayward7939]

Son I’m so proud that you‘re talking to people who view things different, also I posted this on Facebook for all my friends! Love mom

[@davidjulian8643]

If you are indeed Matt's mom thank you for raising an awesome human !!

[@jg2072]

I second David Julian. Bless you and your family for raising your son. I'm using the TMBH videos to teach my son about Catholicism.

[@weshayward7939]

David Julian he takes from his father

[@davidjulian8643]

@@weshayward7939 God Bless:)

[@DairangerSentai7]

Lmao when you're on the rise as a KZbin channel your mom gives a shout-out

[@mickyfrazer786]

And this is how faith (and all other things) should be discussed, with love and charity. Great work.

[@Christopher_Wheeler]

Matt. I want to say, "Thank you." Before I found your channel 3 or 4 years ago, I was really struggling with the concept of, "I'm right! Everyone else is wrong" when it came to my faith and other Christian denominations. Watching you unpack with so many other traditions has made me realize that the other doesn't need to be wrong for me to be right. I really appreciate your honest but respectful conversations with those who have a different mindset as I do. That being said, I'm still happy to be E Free...

[@josephjackson1956]

Christopher Wheeler thank God you've realized that others don't have to be wrong in order for you to be right! I see this with many Christians who are caustic and accusatory, and it's impossible to develop a good dialogue with them. Congratulations on receiving God's grace of charity!! :) I do have some advice: keep what is good and recognize what you actually agree with. You'd probably be surprised to see what you agree with when talking with a Christian who is from perhaps a different part of Christianity than you. I practice this often, and I see that many things that others believe is what I believe also! Test everything you come across to see whether it comes from God, or of the enemy. You can become quite sensitive as a result to good versus bad, and I think that is a good thing. ;)

[@colton7373]

“The other doesn’t need to be wrong for me To be right” that is so cool! God bless

[@DanielMaloneJr]

joe men As a Catholic I agree. For you to be right the other person must be wrong. That doesn’t mean however that you can’t have an educated and civil conversation with someone who believes differently than you.

[@johnwalsh6827]

Joe men absolutely right. We can’t all be right. As C.S. Lewis and others explain, the truth is not subjective. Just because your Protestant/Catholic friend really really believes what he is saying and seems to be a really nice person....doesn’t mean he is right. The truth doesn’t cater to us, we must find it and believe. If I’m right, and you disagree with me, then you’re wrong.

[@Christopher_Wheeler]

iraje hall Most people groups have a history of violence. That doesn’t mean we can’t repent and grow from these things.

[@AboveAnyOther]

Matthew, Thank you once again for treating my faith with respect. The more we all get to understand one another, the more we grow closer together.

[@anthonyhulse1248]

@kim burley neither do we. Nor do we. So get your facts straight.

[@anthonyhulse1248]

@kim burley the One, Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church.

[@anthonyhulse1248]

@kim burley there's nothing about being in error.

[@anthonyhulse1248]

[edit] nothing funny

[@anthonyhulse1248]

@kim burley Except you are as wrong as it's possible to be. The RCC (and Eastern and Orthodox) are the original Church, instituted by Christ, faithful to his commandments, and partaking in the sacraments Jesus created. Your idol is your idea of what the church is.

[@eogh]

Strange this video ain’t loading for me just showing thumbnail yet your other videos are! Love from an Irish Catholic and god willing a soon to be priest.

[@ohmightywez]

God bless you! As Fr. Hollowel says, seminarians right now are firemen running into a burning building. My dad was the only one of 4 boys to get married, his brothers all became priests. And two of my high school friends have become priests in the mid-1990s. It is so difficult for young men right now. I wish you well in your vocation. All prayers and love

[@kingofcelts]

Good luck my fellow Irishman, may you always have such a strong faith. I'll pray for your guidance for your vocation. Rgds from Dublin..

[@sciencelearnremember]

Have a family then become a priest. We need fathers like you, AND Fathers like you.

[@eogh]

Magic Cookie Church Salve Regina mater miseri cordiae, vita, dulcedo et spes nostra salve Ad te clamamus, exsules filii Hevae Ad te suspiramis gementes et flentes in hac lacrimarum valle Eia ergo advocata nostra, illos tuos miseri cordes oculos ad nos converte Et Jesum benedictum fructum ventris tui nobis post hoc exsilium ostende O clemens, o pia, o dulcis virgo Maria

[@eogh]

XYU thank you for your comment and prayers

[@masonthompson3284]

Matt, I gotta say. I love you, man. Your videos were instrumental in helping me solidify my faith during a time which otherwise I definitely would have turned away. So thanks a ton in that regard. A year & some change later, I’m on my way to the other side of the Tiber if you will. But whether I’m a papist or protestant, you’ll always have a supporter in me. Keep being awesome & thanks for letting God use you in this way! Your stuff is truly a wonder with this Jesus thing we all got in common in a way or another.

[@monstersong7433]

Hooray! Welcome home! What convinced you?

[@masonthompson3284]

Monster Song Thank you! I wish I could point to a specific point or doctrine, but I think the best summary is that I came to see the Church as the best example of the visible body Christ established. I used to only watch Protestant apologetics (before finding Matt, even) and later analyzing the arguments of other plausible denominations is what got my foot in the door.

[@CrankyGrandma]

Mason Thompson amen!

[@amandah8178]

Mason Thompson - Welcome home! I made that swim myself. At first I was doing it grudgingly. I knew I needed to but did NOT want to. Now I thank Our Lord every day for making me a Catholic! It’s the greatest gift! God bless you!

[@monstersong7433]

​@@masonthompson3284 Thanks for responding, I admire the approach you took.

[@jackienguyen1551]

You should definitely try and talk to Fr. Mike Schmitz! He’s AMAZING plus it would make an amazing video! :)

[@sineadmaire1729]

agreed! I would love to see that!

[@marianalemos4636]

agreed

[@jbz2291]

Agreed!

[@grupoaranzamusic]

I agree as well. Another scenario I think would be very interesting to watch, is with Michael Voris 👍

[@davidwilliams6966]

Cool, they still have Friars around?

[@rise357]

As a Catholic, thank you so much for the respect you give us Catholics and our Church.

[@ethanjsc]

I also respect the Catholic Church but I’m always dismayed when Catholics have a grudge against Protestants because of a group of whack Protestants that bash Catholicism. Most Protestant churches from my experience view Catholics as brothers

[@tomgjokaj3716]

As a Catholic myself brother first of all I want to thank you for doing these videos and for being so classy it is wonderful to see people who love Jesus Christ and who genuinely have differences in theology but get along in a brotherly way without yelling shouting and arguing with each other God bless you keep up the great work brother 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@kevinonbass44]

It is SO REFRESHING, amazing and rare to see a conversation with 2 different people of different backgrounds that are not screaming at each other.

[@Subeffulgent]

Excellent video. You're asking all the big questions. I was the Protestant for 26 years I am now in the process of converting to the Roman Catholic Church(I actually like to call it complimenting my Christian faith), not losing any element of my faith, actually gaining some things God bless you and your family keep up the good work! 👉✝️

[@cliffpyle3155]

3n1productions100 You are correct in referring to yourself as complimenting your Christian faith or making yourself a complete person of faith. Convert is an abrasive terminology and infers you were not Christian prior to your change of faith.

[@alyssasloneker5126]

Same!! Non-denominational to Roman Catholic :))

[@CrankyGrandma]

and we all lose a bit when we are split. While I believe the fullness of faith is in the Catholic Church (not just roman catholic) I also believe that we are lacking because of the split's we've had. Our protestant brethren have important functions to the body and we need to reunite to be complete

[@CrankyGrandma]

Cliff Pyle I find “cradle “ anything to often be lacking. If you want to know a twin, ask a stranger who has settled down there rather than a native who is apt to be blind to the views. Israel faces the same difficulty. Go to the converts. Mind you there are cradle Catholics and Protestants with faith and zeal but we each have that spark of conversion where our faith becomes ours rather than our parents or cultures

[@LeesInUSA]

Welcome home brothers and sisters..!

[@gregoryh3270]

It's a breath of fresh air to see two people from different viewpoints dialog with respect and genuine interest. Matt's comment about the conversation flowing so well sums it up. It was a pleasure to watch. Great going, guys!

[@asoaresjr]

Oh man, I would pay to see a similar discussion with Scott Hahn

[@culturecoroner]

Yes. Lots of dollars.

[@Heffernan-D]

WE NEED SCOTT

[@AN-cr9cy]

Yesss! And John Bergsma.

[@Medico9814]

Yes I would love to see either Scott Han or Steve rey ❤️

[@SamKnotts]

Patrick Madrid Allen Hunt Trent Horn All the former Protestant Pastors!

[@Fiftynine414]

After decades of being called a “statue worshiper” and a “papist” by Protestant neighbors, I thank you for a respectful conversation.

[@Fiftynine414]

@Anil Löeb No. I was born and raised in CA. Southern Baptists and Nondenominational christians slander Catholics here. Now the LGBT groups do too.

[@chuckHart70]

@@Fiftynine414 Who cares we know the Truth. ONE HOLY CATHOLIC and APOSTOLIC!

[@axisofego1112]

@@chuckHart70 They need a central leader who protects the congregation.

[@wisevirgin3405]

If you don't want to be called a "statue worshiper" and "papist" then you should stop following the pope and worshiping statues. That was simple.

[@Fiftynine414]

@ My Irish Catholic mother married an “Okie” during the war. They settled in Modesto, CA and we got it from both sides! My parents taught us to stand strong and we have.

[@jessamynwhite]

Careful or you’ll come on home 😉 but all jokes aside, this Catholic loves watching your videos because of how amazingly fruitful the discussions are!

[@jessamynwhite]

Proto Orthodox I’m sorry if what I said came across as condescending. That truly wasn’t my intention. I was trying to go for lighthearted banter but apologies it missed that mark.

[@camillawhitman8968]

@@jessamynwhite Matt's wife here. I just read this thread to Matt as we are driving. What a kind thoughtful initial comment and then response. Rest assured, you did not sound even a little bit condescending.

[@mish375]

@@jessamynwhite It seemed lighthearted to this Protestant. 🙂 I just get annoyed when people use it in an arrogant way which you did NOT at all. It's nice seeing polite Catholics here. Reminds me of being with family. My mom's side is almost all Slovak Catholic. My dad's side (until the more recent atheist generations) has been a mix of Catholic and Protestant since the Reformation. His side is mostly German so there were likely Lutherans in there. And I chat with a Catholic friend from the USA as well. We always find it sad when we see Catholics and Protestants being mean to each other. This thread is refreshing.

[@bobpolo2964]

@@jessamynwhite read it like a joke on my view

[@theamericanimperator9325]

XYU They have every right to be angry. Latins sacked Constantinople which consequently lead to an Islamic takeover of Eastern Europe.

[@kentadamson6992]

Great interview Matt! I love your videos, they show the love and grace of Christ. I am a Protestant who will be recieved into the Catholic church this spring sometime, pending the slow down of the virus. I think for me it really was the fathers that converted me. Upon reading them, I found that early Christianity sounded nothing like what my contemporary non-denominational church taught. I am looking forward to being home. My first confession is coming up and I cant wait. God bless!

[@andrestinkler9410]

may I ask how you agree with justification by faith and works? Also how do you agree with the authority of papacy

[@aarongoss8514]

Once again, from a Catholic POV, I am so very thankful for your incredible respect and willingness to have this conversation! May God reward you and bless you in your work and ministry!

[@7776ify]

Please interview a catholic Exorcist- Fr. Chad Ripperger. Would love to watch it.

[@eDENjoetree]

Great Priest. Love him.

[@jemperdiller]

Ripperger will shoot lasers from his eyes and convert him

[@crose7974]

YESSSSS!!!!

[@snarbruce4532]

100% right

[@EastLosAngeles1964classic]

Excellent

[@LeesInUSA]

Thanks Matt for the video. I am Catholic but I really love to listen to conversation with Protestant brothers that is full of love and respect.. I just wish the video was longer!

[@mile7981]

Born and raised in a lukewarm catholic family in the Philippines, I took the teachings lightly if not totally ignored them. But I came to my senses when now that I am able to visit different countries, going to a Catholic Church feels like home. And interestingly, no language barriers as I can participate in the worship in every mass. It would be indescribable and magical when one day, people from different races, from different nations would come together to participate in this great banquet, with one voice worshipping, glorifying and praising God. 🙏🏾✝️🙏🏾

[@josephzammit6396]

I’m publishing a weekly KZbin video on episodes from the life of Don Bosco, entitled ST JOHN BOSCO by JOE ZAMMIT. In this series I’m narrating events and miracles from the splendid life of Don Bosco. St John Bosco used to perform a miracle almost every day, through the intercession of Mary Help of Christians. From the lives of saints we can learn how to love God more and draw closer to him. Thank you

[@brierrebreaux3040]

I'm so excited about Part II ! It reminds me a lot about the convos I have with my catholic friends (as a baptist in South Louisiana there's a lot of them) I also wish I knew how to become as learned as Matt is! Great job brother it was fantastic!

[@MajorWeakness]

You are so right, I'm a catholic in south Louisiana and we converse with Baptist all the time, I even married one lol

[@brierrebreaux3040]

@@MajorWeakness See this guy gets it!

[@augustuslc]

I wish Fr. Benedict Groeschel was still alive, you would have had an incredible conversation with him. He great theologian and could explain things better than most ppl. Best wishes from Peru.

[@katieli8849]

I didnt know he has died... when was that? I watched him on youtube

[@glenlevinzon3012]

katie lie 2014

[@katieli8849]

@@glenlevinzon3012 ah then i saw old vids of him. thanks for the info

[@carousel87]

Great questions Matt! Keep them coming. I returned to the Catholic faith and I'm learning a lot from your videos. :) I really thank the Lord that we can dialogue like this with so much respect and love. Peace my brother! Can't wait for the 2nd part!

[@gpm006]

Thank you - I'm rediscovering my Catholic faith (and engaging with my protestant friends) and really appreciating the light you're shedding on both paths.

[@inhocsignovinces1081]

“When Protestants speak of salvation, they are describing justification; when Catholics speak of salvation, they are describing sanctification.” Peter Kreeft

[@landonvinyard2434]

In Hoc Signo Vinces God’s election is one thing, if we aren’t talking about the thief on the cross situation. As a protestant, I don’t believe you can have justification without the process of sanctification. They’re part and parcel. God bless you!

[@PhilGeissler]

So how is one justified in the Catholic view?

[@PhilGeissler]

@DiscoFalcon I am finding a trend in Evangelical circles of Works Salvation. Works not in the Catholic sense, but the ability of one who once was saved to lose or leave their salvation, which imho is works salvation.

[@HazardxBomber]

@DiscoFalcon Interesting, I am a protestant and I have found that most protestants believe that salvation is guranteed. This I find strange as in my church we DO NOT believe that salvation is guranteed, rather we must 1. believe in God sincerely, 2. recieve the holy spirit. 3. Baptize in water. 4. stay away from sin. these are the four points we think are needed to reach salvation

[@PhilGeissler]

@Cortney Nicholson thank you for your response.

[@mitchellscott1843]

My favourite Protestant KZbinr with another great episode. Can't wait for part 2.

[@beautifulspirit7420]

I appreciate Matt and him approaching the Church and Her members with love and respect. I don't think I have ever seen a Protestant do this on their channel before, sad to say. God bless you Matt, thank you for responding to God's prompting for this holy work.

[@Renvere]

Thank you for this, Matt. I grew up in a Protestant home which was rabidly anti-Catholic. I’m glad you’re shining a light on other Christians and helping everyone see each other as people rather than us vs them.

[@eliseos4127]

Go and try Orthodox church and liturgy as Hank Hanergraaf did and u will never look back.

[@toti35]

I was close to leave catholic church until I did a retreat and learn about my church. I am in LOVE with the catholic church. If you are leaving catholic church just give yourself one opportunity to learn about it before deciding to leave.

[@lolhey6954]

toti35 but what about Jesus Christ. Are you in love with the person of Jesus Christ. Also read rev 17 and 18, your church is actually a merger of paganism and true Christianity. They teach a false Gospel. Read the book of Romans please

[@toti35]

Joel Schumacher no but no thanks.......all of my questions were answered properly. Today, and probably forever , I believe Catholic Church is the true and only one. Thanks anyway.

[@lolhey6954]

toti35 Sir, the Catholic Church adds thing to Christ. All you need is Jesus

[@jeremiahong248]

@@lolhey6954 Jesus, has set up a Church headed by Peter as the rock of the Church to teach others what Jesus has taught and given divine backing to the Catholic Church that Satan will not over come it in Matt 16 :18 I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades will not overcome it. Jesus appointed His disciples to be His representatives on Earth by investing divine authority unto them when He breathed the Holy Spirit into them in John 20:20 Jesus gave the keys of His Kingdom to Peter and the authority to act on His behalf- to.bind and loosen in Matt 16 : 16 -19 I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. "The keys" are abilities to open and explain the Gospel truths, and a mission and commission from Christ to make use of them; and being said to be given to Peter particularly, denotes his after qualifications, commission, work, and usefulness in opening the door of faith, or preaching the Gospel first to the Jews, ( Acts 2:1-47 ) and then to the Gentiles, ( Acts 10:1-48 ) ( Acts 15:7 Acts 15:14) and who was the first that made use of the keys of evangelical knowledge with respect to both, after he, with the rest of the apostles, had received an enlarged commission to preach the Gospel to all nations, beginning at Jerusalem. There are 32000 denominations each proclaiming to be the one true Church. The only way is to look back to see what Jesus taught and what the Apostles and early Church believed. They all.hold Catholic beliefs like the true presence of the Eucharist etc. The Apostles were also given the authority to bind and loose and the authority to retain / forgive sins in John 20:21 - 23 So Jesus said to them again, “Peace to you!As the Father has sent Me, I also send you.” And when He had said this, He breathed on them, and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.” Jesus promised to be with the Catholic Church till the end of time and the mandate to proclaim the Good News in Matt 28:20 teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age." Thus the Apostles have divine authority to represent Jesus on Earth and knew the correct interpretations of what Jesus taught. That is why they wrote the New Testament under the guidance of the Holy Spirit. The Apostles passed on these teachings to the Early Church Fathers and their disciples. The teachings and doctrines of the Catholic Church after 2000 years is the same as what Jesus taught and what the Apostles upheld. All of the present Catholic clergy can trace their ordination back to the Apostles. These are the biblical basis of the Catholic Church. All other 32000 denominations/churches including yours are founded by men without any divine authority and are not found in the bible.

[@kol5300]

What about the Pope sanctioning the Lgbt community, even though the bible strongly layout such actions as against His very Word.

[@mrsmchistory]

I'm also a former evangelical Protestant who was very anti-Catholic but I'm now a Catholic! I came home at the Easter Vigil 2015, after 6 years of prayer and discernment as I began questioning parts of my Pentecostal Protestant faith.

[@jasmincowo8011]

90snostalgicgal welcome home! ✝️🙏🏻

[@johnm6926]

Welcome back 🙏

[@miguelconfesor4701]

The Lord is pleased with you ☺️

[@learnbibleversethroughpict6027]

Thanks be to God 🙏😇

[@MarioRodriguez-gr8wc]

Hey! Welcome! It’s Good Friday!

[@beyond0077]

“ Evangelization doesn’t stop when someone picks up and reads the Bible, it stops when we all come back to one house, one table, one meal the Eucharist ” - Steve Ray

[@caleblagrange7164]

AB D114 when Jesus was teaching with his disciples was there more than one Church?

[@caleblagrange7164]

@AB D114 I reread it but I'm still confused. What did I misinterpret?

[@beyond0077]

AB D114 Do you honestly believe Jesus meant make your own churches, read your Bibles and see you on the other side... lmao no

[@PaulDo22]

@AB D114 One Body. How much more can clear can Saint Paul be? He didn't mention multiple churches/multiple bodies. You are trying to impose your view of Scripture instead of God's view. You can't make Scripture into your personal view, it's God's Word not Your Word. Protestants/Evangelicals do not understand Scripture because the canons of Scripture were determined by the Catholic Church and Protestants weren't around for over another 1,000 years.

[@PaulDo22]

@iraje hall Spot on.

[@bluestripsnow5974]

I’m a Catholic and I’ve watched these 2 videos multiple times each. I admire this conversation and I cannot wait until part 3 comes out!

[@SantaNMS]

HI, Matt! I want to thank you for your work on the 10 minute Bible Hour! I really enjoy your channel and how open and respectful you are to folks you may or may not agree totally with. That disposition is such a rarity nowadays. God Bless you my friend from a fellow Protestant from Madison, WI!

[@GuilFernandes]

May Christ unite us all under His Grace! Catholic brother here praying for you!

[@francescob3574]

As a Catholic this is one of my favorite channels. Great discussions and Matt is a great host who approaches history and tradition in a respectful, logical, and intellectual approach (from a Protestant POV).

[@SuperIliad]

What this Protestant does is what so many do not: He asks questions of those that can fairly answer from the Catholic point of view, rather than ask those who cannot. Secondly, when the Eastern Fathers were persecuted for rejecting Arianism, they came to Rome for the final ruling. Always it was to Rome for ultimate decisions.

[@josephrbarton]

Not anymore

[@shaunsaega]

@@josephrbarton because Rome is going through an eclipse, just like the Fatima apparition told us. But our Lord will never leave us, He will fix it all.

[@omorthon5774]

Why was the very first council of the apostles called by James and not Peter? Why was the first ecumenical council called by the Emperor in Nicea and not Rome?

[@SuperIliad]

@@omorthon5774 Wonderful questions. Now, look it up.

[@omorthon5774]

@@SuperIliad ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ seems to point to Orthodoxy to me.

[@soldieroflove247]

The part of the video when you said “be careful studying that church history you’re about to become a Catholic” was interesting. There’s a gentleman by the name of Tim Staples who went through that journey. Look him up when you get the chance. I hope to see you have a conversation with him on one of your videos one day.

[@georgeibrahim7945]

Karlo Santo Domingo yeah Tim Staples is great on Catholic answers so is Jimmy Akin and I like watching Steve Rays videos who to was a former protestant. Scott Hahn is another great one.

[@eliseos4127]

I don't think so. Nothing but rotten history and apologists. Disgusting. Look up Orthodoxy, the original chuchc they never tell u about.

[@soldieroflove247]

Bob C I believe it was “to be deep in history is to cease to be a protestant”

[@soldieroflove247]

Les Adonis no thanks

[@Lambdamale.]

@@georgeibrahim7945 Steve Ray has a really good book. Upon This Rock. It never convinced me but was the best representation of the Papacy I've ever read.

[@loonshkij]

Please bring us the second part of this conversation soon! I think that there is so much misunderstanding of the depth of Catholic/Orthodox theology, and that very often people see Christianity through a strictly Protestant lens. More discussions with Anglicans/Episcopalians would be fascinating as well. Thank you for your good work. I've recommended your channel to many fellow Catholics. (I'm Ukrainian Greek Catholic/Byzantine rite, BTW - not all Catholics are Roman/Latin rite.)

[@bradw2213]

The right and left lung my friend.

[@superomnenomen]

I have been both a Roman Catholic Church, btw where I’m from, AND a Ukrainian Catholic Church and I have to say everybody I met was VERY lovely.

[@eliseos4127]

Goodness gracious me! Are these the only churches out there? What about the original church...Orthodoxy??

[@mercy1459]

@@eliseos4127 la del rito latino y ortodoxo son Iglesias Cristianas Católicas. En la antigüedad solo era la iglesia Cristiana Católica Apostólica Romana de hay se dividió el imperio romano en dos y se podría decir 1ue nació la Iglesia Cristiana Católica Ortodoxa. Por algo Pedro fue obispo en Roma .

[@buterflylover121]

It’s so great how respectful y’all can be towards each other in this conversation! Looking forward to part 2

[@roberthiggason6994]

Been missing your videos, Matt. Glad you're back.

[@behling89]

I'm very intellectually driven. And intellectually the Catholic Church interests me quite a bit more than protestantism. And in all honesty, I knew more about theology than the average christian, I'd say. I was already a christian and I was anti the Catholic Church with conviction. The deciding factor for me to become Catholic, surprisingly, had nothing to do with intellect. I did not want, by any means, to become a Catholic! I was fasting and praying quite a lot at the time, then a series of "coincidences" started happening in my life. When there are two or three it's ok, but when in a short period of time there are around ten or fifteen coincidences... well, makes you think, right? So I started remembering things ever since I was a child. And in each place I had lived, each address, each country there was something that was profound and related to the Catholic faith that I had never noticed in my life. My entire life was laid out in front of my eyes and I could suddenly see a pattern, a path that I was suppose to follow. That gave me a lot of anxiety, because I had known my whole life the Catholics adored saints and the Virgin Mary and that that was wrong. Finally I decided to go to a Catholic Church. When I finally did, about two weeks later, I was very skeptical, and so was my wife who I had convinced to accompany me. She was not a big fan of the Catholic church, I'll tell you that much. There was no way I could have a transformative experience, I thought. I expected it to be boring and a mistake. What was I doing there? I did not know much about a Catholic Mass, I did not know exactly what the sacraments meant to a Catholic, but a few minutes after the Mass started my whole life changed. I felt for the first time in my life a direct connection to another realm... God, the angels, all of that (mind you, it was in the beginning of the service, not during the Eucharist when Catholics actually believe that that happens - but I didn't even know that at the time). It was the most unique feeling that I've ever had and I don't know if I'll ever experience it again. Out of nowhere it was like a storm going on inside my body, I had goose bumps ALL OVER. I had NEVER felt like that. I looked to my wife and I was tearing up and I could't even talk (for her it was a regular Mass, but she noticed something was different for me). At that moment I just knew I was home. And I don't say home because it's just a way of saying it. I truthfully felt like that, like I was my home, and that that's where I was supposed to be. My wife also converted and is also a devout Catholic. It doesn't matter if you want to believe a certain way or not, it doesn't matter if you understand something or not... some things are the way they are, the way God created them to be.

[@benjaminlquinlan8702]

Go careful of God's brightest star there light lightbringer.

[@benjaminlquinlan8702]

So interesting how intellect gets so much in the way of faith finding. Your story, and how the pattern emerged to you is beautiful.

[@eliseos4127]

How can you say u r an intellectual when you don't even study or mention the original church...the Orthodox church??

[@behling89]

@@eliseos4127 When I say I am "intellectually driven", it does not mean that I claim to be an intellectual. As a matter of fact, I wrote that it was not my intellect that brought me to church. Do you really think that someone you do not know and who is sharing their personal experience on a youtube comment is required to mention whatever you think they should? Also, how can you be so sure about what I study or what I don't study? As to your other comment, how can you understand from 'I was once a protestant. Now I'm a Catholic." that I said there were only two options? How exactly could you know what I did or did not consider before? Leave your ego and outrage aside and think for a second instead of being combative for no reason. What do you know...?

[@jamielinares7599]

Amen! I’m so happy you and your wife are home! When I am in mass, especially during the Eucharist, I am often so overwhelmed with God’s PRESENCE and GLORY that tears just stream down my face. Peace be with you!

[@craftycrayon9283]

You are highly respectable for a protestant my good man. A civil dialogue is always the best kind.

[@NK73080]

hey i think personally the stereotype of the angry protestant stopped with martin luther, as well as with many stereotypes of the catholic church.

[@50Street21]

Fabulous conversation between the both of you. That is what life and religion are about. There are no closed doors. Thank you. Darryl

[@Name-le2cc]

Interview Trent horn next ( apologist on catholic answers) please. I would really love to see you both talking

[@georgeibrahim7945]

Evutey xoxo would be even better to interview Jimmy Akin, Tim Staples, Steve Ray or Scott Hahn since they were former protestants

[@beautifulspirit7420]

I love Trent Horn though, he is young and has such a creative and clear way of teaching.

[@unboxingcatholicism]

Up!

[@MarkshaneClemen]

@@georgeibrahim7945 Trent Horn is a former protestant

[@jenarana4788]

He’s a former agnostic not Protestant

[@dimesonhiseyes9134]

I've only made it to minutes in and I can tell you a 30 minute video is not enough I want more

[@SnowySpiritRuby]

Then I hope you've seen the other 3 episodes he has put out over the last year and a half.

[@Sky33lark]

When I first began to believe in God I went towards protestantism but after aabout a year of prayer for more truth, I began to get closer and closer to the Catholic Church. I am hoping to be confirmed this December 💜🌈 if all goes well. Thank you for your video, brought me even closer to God 💜

[@guardtheham1233]

Lovely story, mine is similar. I prayed too after feeling a way about Seeing Joyce Myers ministries. I think prayer led me to my husband who was Catholic and then I converted because I fell in love with him and Jesus Christ ❤❤❤

[@kelseymatchen9569]

Love these videos. Your willingness to have these conversations is awesome! Keep it up!

[@rsissel1]

I'm Orthodox, and I think your video series is very important to foster understanding among those who name the name of Christ. I would encourage those of us watching this series to promote it among our Christian friends.

[@gregm6894]

I appreciate the candid and respectful discourse in this video -- but, listening to the Catholic Theologian's explanations I cannot help but see that much of what he says is in disagreement with what I read in God's Word. I am a 'Born Again' Protestant, saved by the Grace of God through faith at the age of 51 yrs., I'm now 77 yrs. old. I was born and raised in the Catholic Church, went to Catholic schools through high school, even went to a seminary for 6 months. In all that time, I was never encouraged to read, nor study Scripture -- and instead was told that performing all the Catholic rituals would get me into Heaven. Consequently, my life became a search for self satisfaction, filled with sin and broken relationships/marriages. My oldest daughter got genuinely saved during those years and tried her best to gently witness to me -- it fell on deaf ears -- until God brought my life to a point where I knew I needed someone other than me to control my life. With my daughter's prompting, I said a feeble, half-hearted prayer to Jesus, asking Him to take control of my life -- I really did not expect answer. The answer came that very morning, as the Holy Spirit convicted me of my total selfishness and sinfulness, and my total need for Jesus. That was 25 years ago, and since then my life has changed 180 degrees -- all by the grace of God. I have now been actively studying the Bible for those 25 years, and simply cannot reconcile many of the major Roman Catholic teachings with what God's Word clearly says. I know that I am a saved sinner, being sanctified and sealed by the Holy Spirit -- just as God's Word says. We are not saved because we are sanctified, we are sanctified because we are saved. Ephesians 1:13-14 -- "And you also were included in Christ when you heard the message of truth, the gospel of your salvation. When you believed, you were marked in him with a seal, the promised Holy Spirit, who is a deposit guaranteeing our inheritance until the redemption of those who are God’s possession-to the praise of his glory." In my understanding, Catholic doctrines like the 'Treasury of Merit' are a clear contradiction to the all-sufficient atonement of Christ, clearly taught by the Scriptures -- and even as stated by the Catholic Theologian in this video. As for our good works, Isaiah 64:6 says -- "All of us have become like one who is unclean, and all our righteous acts are like filthy rags; we all shrivel up like a leaf, and like the wind our sins sweep us away." I do believe there are many truly saved Roman Catholics, who have fully put their trust in Christ for their salvation, just as I am sure there are many professing Protestants who are not truly saved, because they are trying to earn their salvation -- salvation is a gift of God. Ephesians 2:8-9 -- "For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith-and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God-not by works, so that no one can boast." May the peace of our Lord be with you.

[@kerrykoehler2601]

Thank you for these videos. I am Protestant and will always be Protestant. I respect the Catholic Church and its traditions and beliefs. I would never show disrespect to the Catholic Church. I am tired of the many videos I’ve seen of Catholics trashing Protestant churches. Thank you for these respectful dialogues.

[@rubygaytan9009]

I really like how respectable you approach the different religions. It makes it for a nice conversation to listen with opportunities for much learning. Thank you!

[@Thunderstruck951]

Thank you very much for doing these.

[@jacintapatton9862]

I'm catholic but I love what you do and your videos! Its beautiful and comforting to see calm and open conversations between two people of different but yet similar religions. I love hearing from both sides and the explanations of both faiths. Thank you for doing what you do! So much respect:)

[@briansantotomas9701]

I would love an episode with you and Scott Hahn. Great insight on both sides. Keep up the great work!

[@tubinho79]

The reason I came back to the Catholic Church: John 6:47 "Most assuredly, I say to you, he who believes in Me has everlasting life. I am the bread of life. Your fathers ate the manna in the wilderness, and are dead. This is the bread which comes down from heaven, that one may eat of it and not die. I am the living bread which came down from heaven. If anyone eats of this bread, he will live forever; and the bread that I shall give is My flesh, which I shall give for the life of the world." The Jews therefore quarreled among themselves, saying, “How can this Man give us His flesh to eat?” Then Jesus said to them, “Most assuredly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you have no life in you. Whoever eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day. For My flesh is food indeed, and My blood is drink indeed. He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood abides in Me, and I in him. As the living Father sent Me, and I live because of the Father, so he who feeds on Me will live because of Me. This is the bread which came down from heaven-not as your fathers ate the manna, and are dead. He who eats this bread will live forever.” These things said he in the synagogue, as he taught in Capernaum. Therefore many of His disciples, when they heard this, said, “This is a hard saying; who can understand it?” When Jesus knew in Himself that His disciples complained about this, He said to them, “Does this offend you? What then if you should see the Son of Man ascend where He was before? It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh profits nothing. The words that I speak to you are spirit, and they are life. "But there are some of you who do not believe." For Jesus knew from the beginning who they were who did not believe, and who it was that would betray Him. And He said, “Therefore I have said to you that no one can come to Me unless it has been granted to him by My Father.” From that time many of His disciples went back and walked with Him no more. Then Jesus said to the twelve, “Do you also want to go away?” But Simon Peter answered Him, “Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. Also we have come to believe and know that You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.”

[@sil2819]

tubinho79 Be A good Catholic so proud of you 🙏💪

[@KalonOrdona2]

"This do in remembrance of me," said right after he said "this is my body [and] ... my blood ...." It's a token and a ballast, like baptism: a symbolic act, not a literal one.

[@andrewmarusic1975]

@@KalonOrdona2 bible was written in Greek. in John ch 6 the exact word that was used is trogo, which very literally translates into 'gnawing' or 'chewing,' as in food, mashing of teeth. in english you can confuse literal with figurative but in the original language there was no confusion: see early church fathers (tertulian, ambrose, justin, etc. who comment extensively on this).

[@AJ_Jingco]

@alan21usa Jesus did NOT say "My Flesh profits nothing."

[@davidludwig3975]

It was so relaxing and refreshing watching you guys. Loved it!

[@TakeUpYourCross]

Okay Matt, you've had me constantly checking for part 2 for a month now. When's it coming? 😁

[@englishlearningcenter1470]

Me too

[@rikardohaxhari1214]

3 hours ago hahaha

[@earonkilgo8735]

The word Christian is in God's true word. But the word Christianity is not in God true word at all.

[@earonkilgo8735]

Just like the word Bible is not in Gods true word at all

[@earonkilgo8735]

The Roman Catholic Church is not of God at all. If Peter was living today he would be against the Roman Catholic Churchs

[@carrieel3260]

What an inspiration for how to dialogue well & respectfully. So refreshing in our divisive culture. Can’t wait to listen to more.

[@cllewis1]

Key phrase: "I've been studying church history for a long time, and I'm still not a Catholic...I don't feel like I have to be." At the point where you believe what the Catholic Church teaches about the sacraments, then that's when you will realize a Catholic is what you have to be...because when you believe what the Church teaches about the sacraments, you will want to receive them. My experience, anyway.

[@jackhall201]

If you want to understand the Catholic faith look up Dr Brant Pitre you'll find him on KZbin

[@TomLandry1]

Chris - I think it's going to be interesting to watch Matt for the next few years... He's clearly a Well Educated person on matters of the Faith, and he's "dangerously" close to making the same "Mistake" I made a few years ago - the same "mistake" Scott Hahn, Marcus Grodi, Dave Anders, and countless others have made. :-) And of course, that "Mistake" is in giving The Church a fair hearing. Speaking ONLY for myself - I'm like the friend that Dr. Homes discussed in the early part of the video. I accepted Christ, But then (years later) I DID Come to the Realization that Christ founded an actual, visible, earthly Church, and that it still exists. Faced with that realization, I found myself with no choice BUT to accept HIS Church (and its been a Wonderful choice!!!). However, I respect that others Can (and do) reach different conclusions.

[@CHEKPNT]

Chris Lewis keep studying everybody has their on pace to get there...

[@MrKev1664]

Christ be with you I do not understand how anyone can study but not think they must obey God bless you

[@leopic501]

I don't feel the need to be a catholic I feel the need to worship Yashua and know and learn how I may do the will of the father his way his time line in his son,s name .

[@catholictransformation696]

I think it's great that you took the time to have a calm, Christ like conversation knowing going into it that you would both not agree on everything and you didn't choose a debate format which I think is a nice change.

[@TomLandry1]

AGREE 100% - and it's why I keep coming back to Matt's video's. Frankly, I find Debates QUITE Counterproductive, and IMO they SELDOM lead to Truth or Conversion!!! ALL they prove is which combatant is the more skilled Debater!! SMH..... As anyone who has studied debate or rhetoric will tell you, a skilled debater can take EITHER SIDE of a proposition and make a compelling case for it. That's HARDLY a basis to seek or find Truth!!

[@lancevaughn5337]

Hi from Sheridan Wyoming. Catholic now, raised Presbyterian. Enjoy your channel. Thanks!

[@dafonearth]

Please release the next part of the video ... I can't wait! You're doing a great job showing humility and understanding. Bravo!

[@vilarinhosss]

Matt, Matt, we all know where this is going for the last few years... looking forward to your 2021 first communion

[@chrismccarthy2321]

Absolutely love how Matt touches on how his American libertarian biases on authority and individuality affect his perceptions. Looking forward to part 2.

[@TomLandry1]

INDEED!!! I was once very close to where Matt is now. I was more "American" than Christian, and (Sad to say) like MANY Americans, I didn't realize how close I was putting MAN's institution (the State) to GOD's Institution (His One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church).

[@jack_skeean]

Great video Matt! I wish more people were having dialogues like this. I converted to Catholicism because I was ultimately convinced by the historical claims and the logical necissity for a divine interpreter. It's interesting to hear your point of view on this! I'm curious, are you familiar with St. John Henry Newman?

[@anar3602]

What do you mean by "divine interpreter"? * Do you not believe Jesus' words in John 16:13-15? * Are we not called to follow Abraham example, taking God at His word? An act of faith and expectation which was accounted to him as righteousness _(James __2:23__)?_ _ _ _ _ John 16:13-15 - _"However, when He, the Spirit of truth, has come, _*_He will guide you_*_ into all truth; for He will not speak on His own authority, but whatever He hears _*_He will speak;_*_ and _*_He will tell you_*_ things to come. He will glorify Me, for He will take of what is Mine and _*_declare it to you._*_ All things that the Father has are Mine. Therefore I said that He will take of Mine and j.gdeclare it to you."*_ James 2:23 - _"And the Scripture was fulfilled which says, “Abraham _*_believed God,_*_ and it was accounted to him for righteousness.” And _*_he was called the friend of God."_* . . . . . . . This is one of the issues I have with the doctrines of the RCC. That they encourage lack of understanding and faith in God's desire and ability to fulfill what He has promised. Instead they call it penitent and humble to walk in a lack of faith. When in reality we can stand as saints in the righteousness of Jesus Christ _(2 Cor __5:21__),_ boldly able to come before the throne of our holy God and Father. Hebrews 4:16 - _"Let us therefore _*_come boldly_*_ to the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy and find grace to help in time of need."_

[@anar3602]

@XYU When you say "church", do you mean a man-made religious organization or the definition the Bible gives of a spiritual entity that is made up of all born-again believers that make up the body of Jesus Christ? Yes, I agree that God can use men both good and evil to assemble HIS BOOK. BUT if the catholic church hadn't existed, would it have come about anyway? *of course* Why? Because God is able, even inspite of the stupidity of mankind.

[@anar3602]

@XYU When I speak to catholics they wear the achievement of the assembly of the Bible as a crown of eternal righteousness on behalf of the RCC. As if it equates a man-made religious organization unto righteousness there after. While forgetting that all religious organizations are made up of both righteous and evil men because we are in a fallen world where humanity has a propensity for evil. It is this very type of docrine that is used by all cults that places their "church" as the gatekeeper to Heaven. Making their "church" the way, the truth, and the life. This is a blasphemous teaching that robs glory from YHWH, and introduces idolatry that ultimately leads to damnation. This is likely why there are thousands of protestant denominations. Because no one religious organization is holier than other. Righteousness is defined individually before a Holy God. YHWH is a personal God first, before being a corporate God. It is only IN Him that each body part is a member of His Church. Why? Simply put, salvation is found in Jesus alone.

[@anar3602]

@@joemen3332 You mean someone needs an man-made religious organization aside from having the Holy Spirit to preach the gospel? That's the silliest thing EVER! Hello . . . do you know how many missionaries have gone into the mission field with no backing. God told them to go, so they went. He directed them, He provided, He opened doors and souls were won. Sorry but you need to listen to testimonies after testimonies after testimonies of all the marvelous things God has and is doing. All I can tell you is that He is way bigger than you're giving Him credit for.

[@anar3602]

@XYU So if you agree that a man-made religious organization is made up of both evil and righteous men. Why would you equate the doctrines that come out of the religious organization as righteous and equating it to "the one true church" that is the gatekeeper to heaven? That logic sounds beyond flimsy?

[@jasonstewart5502]

Looking forward to seeing the rest of this conversation! Please post the next segment of this soon!

[@annexong9350]

I am a seminarian now in Archdiocese of Davao in philippines and i love your videos, it means that you are open to the Roman Catholic Religion. Thank you for your openness 😇

[@JP2GiannaT]

I'm so happy I live in a time and place where discussions like this can happen.

[@BomboWise]

I want you to have him on more often! I like how discusses the opinions and ideas!

[@danstrikker6465]

I really appreciate how respectful this is and how you're genuinely curious and want to learn.

[@CTS55555]

I read more than once....the books "Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist" by Brent Pitre and "Salvation is from the Jews" by Roy Schoeman. I am Catholic all over again because of those books.

[@lisaschmidt9718]

Look into full Preterism, it's a view point that is completely different then what's out there!

[@davidwilliams6966]

Its true devouring parts of God to take on their attributes is ancient idea

[@davidwilliams6966]

@@Catholic_Tiktok All Pastures of the true Roman faitj!!!!!

[@nilocblue]

As a practicing Catholic, I'm so thankful to see a dialogue like this. I've been so disrespected before and bullied by protestants before, and OBVIOUSLY this isn't everyone, and OBVIOUSLY there are rude Catholics to Protestants too, but I do admit hearing a Protestant respectful to the Catholic faith is so endearing and feels like a rarity. (No mean to offend anyone really)

[@metaljimmy217]

WHY WOULD you be a member of an unproven cult that is ran by a homosexuial priesthood who aren't allowed to Marry ,, etc ?? lol

[@jesusislordsavior6343]

nilocblue If you care to read some history, you may find that the bullying goes BOTH WAYS. 'FOR ALL HAVE SINNED AND FALL SHORT OF THE GLORY OF GOD.' (Romans 3:23) As I've observed, some Catholic hard-heads feel that bullying 'Protestants' is a mark of great virtue. I've met others who lack conviction. Frankly I'm not sure which is worse.

[@KeithMcormack895]

@@metaljimmy217 it's not a cult and the vast majority of priests are not homosexuall

[@RicardoReyes]

Matt, do you want Catholicism? ::insert archer meme:: Because this is how you become Catholic. Once again, a great video. Really do enjoy them.

[@Kitiwake]

Some people don't want to become Catholic because being Protestant is so convenient. You have no conscience about divorce and artificial birth control and have thousands church hoping options if you feel inconvenienced. Protestantism is much better "choice".

[@Jooo923]

He is on his way...Lord willing

[@Ackms421]

I'm on the edge of my seat for the second part brother! Intriguing stuff.

[@misseli1]

I really like these discussion videos, and I always appreciate how respectful they are

[@men.276]

Loved this. I Sincerely believe that those of a pure heart and Love for God eventually find there way to the fullness of Christ. It may be bumpy but God gets His people to Him. Hallelujah.

[@andrewbora7562]

No man why the pause 😂. By the way Brilliant conversation, God bless you both. I would really be thankful if you can talk about the fundamental differences between Catholics and Protestants like the Eucharist and Mary.

[@pi4t651]

@XYU Speaking as a Protestant, I think the contention about Mary isn't about a particular devotion about her, or about any supposed appearances made by her (miracles being attributed to saints is of course something we would disagree on as a general principle, but I think most Protestants would concede that if they were mistaken and saints *could* arrange for miracles then Mary would be able to do so). The thing that causes contention is (from a Protestant perspective) the Catholic Church's extreme regard for Mary. Now, we might be misinterpreting things - we do only have an outside perspective, so maybe this is simply a misunderstanding. Or I might be misinformed altogether on some points, in which case I'm sorry and please correct me. But from my perspective, it looks like Catholics attach enormous significance and importance to Mary, declaring her the "Queen of Heaven" and seeming to treat her as second only to God Himself. I'm not sure of the formal doctrines - maybe a few other people (Peter, maybe?) are technically placed higher up but she's way up and seems to be venerated far more than anyone else in practice. Again, maybe this is inaccurate - I'm only saying what it looks like from my position. Based on what I see in the Bible, she doesn't seem *that* significant. I mean, yes, she's a very important figure in history and is doubtless with all the other saints now, but I don't see anything placing her above, say, Ezekiel, or John the Baptist.

[@markfreivald1252]

@@pi4t651 Hi, pi4t. Mary is, indeed, exceptional to the Catholic Church. There are many reasons for it, many of them Biblical. However, she is still not God and we do not worship her as God. Here is a list of reasons why she is exceptional. (No particular order.) I understand that you might not believe everything I put below, but perhaps you can come to understand that *if* the Catholics are right about all these things, then it is no wonder that she gets special veneration. (Not worship.) 1. Mary, more than any other human being other than Jesus, has had a special relationship with the Holy Spirit throughout her life. We know specifically that the Holy Spirit was there at her conception (the Immaculate Conception), He was also there at Christ Jesus’s conception, and she was also at the Pentecost. However, we also know that the Holy Spirit has had a special relationship with her throughout. 2. God the Father, the Holy Spirit, and Jesus Himself entrusted her with the life of Jesus Christ from conception to adulthood. Jesus *gave himself to her* for care and protection. 3. Luke 1:48: “Behold, from now on will all ages call me blessed.” (Who, throughout the ages, has called Mary blessed? Not most of Protestantism-but the Catholic and Orthodox Churches have.) 4. At the foot of the cross, Jesus Christ Himself proclaims Mary the mother of his church, and puts her under the care of the Church through the Apostle. By this proclamation Jesus Christ named Mary our spiritual mother. Not a part of the godhood, but she clearly has a special role in the Church. As such, she helps us and nurtures us the way only a perfected spiritual mother can. 5. Mary is shown in Revelations as the queen of heaven. 6. There have been many apparitions of Mary, including ones like Fatima, where upwards of sixty thousand people witnessed her miraculous sign made with the sun. 7. The Bible shows her in Cana working as an intercessor for the family having the wedding. Jesus first resists, but she persists and he then agrees, at which point she says to the servants to do whatever he says-because she is always aligned with Jesus’s and God’s will! But how strange that Jesus would seem to change his mind! What is being shown here? It shows that Mary has a special role to intercede and she has influence over what God does! The results then and now are miraculous. 8. The New Testament is full of perfected “types” from the Old Testament. Adam was the imperfect first born, while Jesus was the perfected one. Eve was the imperfect and disobedient mother of humanity, while Mary was the sinless (preserved from sin by Christ and the Holy Spirit at the Immaculate Conception) and fully obedient handmaiden of the Lord. The Ark of the Covenant was the sacred receptacle for the written word of God, while Mary was the pure and unstained vessel for the Word mad Flesh, Jesus Christ. 9. Certainly, just by virtue of being the mother of our Lord, she deserves special honor and respect. There are many, many more things--these are just the ones off the top of my head. To Catholics, it is manifest both from the Holy Traditions passed down from Christ and the Apostles and from the written Traditions of Holy Scripture that Christ Jesus meant for Mary to have a special role in the Church as our spiritual mother, and that she is very involved with helping all of mankind for the sake of her son. If Christ deemed it so, then we honor it!

[@markfreivald1252]

@@pi4t651 One more thing worth mentioning, pi4t. Mary, more than any other human being, shared the perfect love with Jesus Christ. Of all human intercessors, she with her pure heart has the greatest knowledge and experience to bring us closer to loving Christ perfectly. We turn to her to help us find that love, and everything we seek through Mary is directed toward Jesus Christ. Furthermore, she always wills what God wills as was shown in scripture, so we are completely confident in her spiritual guidance and intercession.

[@pi4t651]

​@@markfreivald1252 Thanks for the respectful response. I'd like to respond in kind to the points you raised, explaining how I see them as a Protestant. As before, I'm not trying to attack you, or Catholicism, just explaining the different conclusions. I think your second message really shows the fundamental difference between the Catholic and Protestant understanding of Mary. But let's go through the points in order. 1) Rather famously, most Protestants (myself included) don't believe in the Immaculate Conception, since we don't think it's supported by the Bible. (The Bible also doesn't explicitly say she was there at Pentecost, although I agree it seems reasonable given she was at the crucifixion, and John had taken her into his home by this point. But of course, receiving the Holy Spirit at Pentecost doesn't set her aside from the other believers at that time.) I can see how holding those doctrines would lead one to hold Mary in high regard, though. 2) Hmm...that's a reasonable point. I hadn't thought about it that way before. 3) I disagree here - I think most if not all Protestants would say that Mary was blessed, and blessed greatly. I mean it says so in the Bible - apart from Mary's song, Gabriel tells her that she is "highly favoured". But one can be greatly blessed without receiving the veneration that Catholicism gives to her. Also, if someone is blessed they're very much receiving a gift from God, and one which is unearned. While the gift is very good, it seems strange to me to honour someone for being given a gift. It would be like giving a child honour because their parents gave them a lot of money, if you'll forgive the crude metaphor. Shouldn't any honour in Mary being blessed go to God who did the blessing? 4) I read that as a far less symbolic and more human thing - Jesus knew his mother would need to be cared for, and even while being crucified he made arrangements accordingly. If he'd been meaning his pronouncement as announcing that Mary would be the mother of the church, wouldn't he have said "behold your mother" to Peter rather than John? Especially if Catholicism is correct about Peter's importance as the first Pope, the rock on which Christ built his church, etc. On the other hand, if he was just making sure Mary would be looked after, it makes sense he'd choose John - he was particularly close to John, and we know that Peter had a mother in law and thus presumably also a wife to look after already. 5) Sorry to be a pedant, but Revelation*. Addressing the actual point you make, I've seen...rather a lot of contradictory interpretations of things in Revelation, which people have believed in quite firmly. Comes of not having a unifying set of doctrines across Protestantism, I suppose. The upshot is, I'm dubious about any specific interpretation of the signs and prophecies in Revelation - we see the general pattern, but I don't think we'll see what was specifically being described in each verse until the new creation has come and we have the benefit of hindsight. With that in mind, I don't think the Catholic interpretation of that passage as definitely being a literal description of Mary's significance holds up on its own merits - even if I were Catholic, I think I'd only accept that interpretation because it was part of Catholic doctrine. 6) I'm not familiar enough with events like these to comment on their theological implications, so I'll simply let this one pass as "not something I've heard of". Although...if the Catholic position on saints, prayer and miracles is correct, and if Mary does tend to show up a lot more than other saints...might that not just be because you're praying to her more? 7) Interesting. I wouldn't have taken that as a sign of Mary always being in line with God's will, but just of her faith in her son. If you're present when I'm having an operation, and I tell you to do whatever the doctor tells you, that doesn't mean my will is fundamentally aligned with the doctor's - just that I trust that the doctor knows what he's doing better than I do! Similarly, I wouldn't have taken the fact that it was Mary who got Jesus to change his mind as a sign that she has special influence to do so. There are, after all, other examples of Jesus (seemingly) being persuaded to change his mind. The woman who talked about eating scraps under the table springs to mind, as does the centurion who told Jesus it wasn't necessary to come to his house. I'd take it as a sign that Jesus will listen to any of us and our prayers might persuade him to change his plans - that we don't need an intercessor between us and him, and more than Mary did. This is getting a bit long, so I'll finish up in a second comment.

[@pi4t651]

8) Hmm. I'm afraid I don't see the connection here. If Eve was an imperfect parallel to Mary, wouldn't we have expected her to come before Adam and be his mother rather than his wife? If we're going to read a parallel to Eve in the New Testament, I'd say a more obvious choice would be his bride - ie the church as a whole. Not sure about the parallel with the Ark, either - Jesus repeatedly described his own body as the Temple, and it's again his body which is identified with the veil in the temple in Hebrews. Plus the Ark was the symbol of God's covenant with the Israelites - the symbol of the new covenant could be said to be Christ's body, or the bread and wine of communion/mass, or perhaps the cross - but I'd find it hard to accept "Mary's body" as a candidate. From my perspective, this looks more like the Catholic Church has reached its conclusions about Mary from other reasons, and then looked for parallels of her in the light of that, rather than seeing those parallels and using that as a basis for their respect for her. And that would be a completely reasonable thing to have done, as long as those parallels don't end up becoming used as justification for the conclusions that were already assumed. 9) Agreed, though perhaps we'd disagree on just how much honour and respect that calls for :) As I said, your second message seems to show the core of the difference between our views of Mary. As a Protestant, I don't see Mary having the things you described. It's clear that she had a strong faith, of course, and that she put that faith into action when she accepted God's task for her. But there have been many notable Christians who have done that throughout the ages, and indeed many prophets in Old Testament times. I don't see anything in scripture to show that she was anything more than a faithful (by human standards) servant of God who was given the utterly unique job of being God's own mother. Which would obviously still make her very significant (see point 9) but perhaps not worthy of the veneration Catholics give her?

[@josephalvarnas2333]

Truly a wonderful series of conversations. I am a life-long Roman Catholic and this is really the first time that I have see this type of respectful conversations between fellow Christians who love and live the words of Jesus. I look forward to each of these videos. Keep up the amazing work.

[@antoniusrusticus383]

Very nice conversation. I suggest you also interview the Byzantine Catholic chaplain at Wyoming Catholic. By the way...the Syriac Maronite Catholics & the Byzantine Italo-Greek Catholics never were in schism with Rome.

[@CrankyGrandma]

How about Chaldean? I was privileged to be at a Chaldean Mass in San Diego, where the default liturgical language was Aramaic, not Latin. Yet the prayers, translated into English, and the heart of the Liturgy were the same. More poetic, more Eastern, but the ancient prayers were so familiar to this Roman Catholic. Chaldean is also Catholic but I don't know if they reunited or never were in schism

[@antoniusrusticus383]

@@CrankyGrandma I know Syriac Catholics & have seen Chaleans on EWTN...I didn't mention them because this theologian is at Wyoming Catholic College, which also has a Byzantine chaplain.

[@antoniusrusticus383]

@@CrankyGrandma I understand that Chaldeans are reunited Nestorians.

[@CrankyGrandma]

Antonius Rusticus the Chaldeans are primarily in San Diego and I think Detroit? In the US. Mostly Iraqi refuges. Still speaking Aramaic! The liturgy was profoundly beautiful. If you get a chance to go, definitely do so

[@michaelkatopodes]

Cranky Grandma you’re right on the Detroit part! Basically all of metro Detroit, tons of Chaldean churches, stores, bakeries, restaurants etc!

[@GrahamGroove]

wow as an Atheist i must say this video was extremely refreshing, no brandishing ill will or general negativity just 2 good men talking about what connects and separates them on a topic i really know very little about, fascinating keep up the good work !!!

[@MattWhitmanTMBH]

I really appreciate that Sam.

[@JohnAlbertRigali]

@Sam Graham I hope that you get inspired to inquire into Christianity yourself. ✝️

[@hansweichselbaum2534]

Great discussion! Feels like a peaceful oases after listening to a couple of "militant" religious channels.

[@manub.3847]

Unfortunately, even with "explanatory videos" there are far too often "militants" in the comments, who don't really listen, but condemn others with their way of expressing themselves.

[@markfreivald1252]

@@manub.3847 Take heart, Manu. This is the world we live in, but these discussions only have any effect inasmuch as God uses them to do so. Passions and egos will assert themselves, and we are helpless against them--but God knows what is in there hearts, and he can use our faults and ignorance to shape our hearts. The strife and discord that we see is not the whole picture!

[@Agape-Jesus]

Matt, thank you for what you do. I am learning so much about each Christian denomination; Orthodox, Catholic Protestant and I’m sure much more to come.