They Should've Warned People About This - Paco Rabanne Black XS EDT Comparison & Fragrance Review

I'm Aussie Marcel, an Australian named Marcel (if it wasn't obvious), and in today's video I'm comparing both the new and old formulation of Paco Rabanne Black XS. Was it a change for the best? Subscribe to the channel if you want to see more fragrance reviews and fashion videos!
#fragrance #review #fragrancereview #pacorabanne #blackxs #blackexcess #aussie #australian #australia

[@k1a2n3e41]

The original black XS was my favourite fragrance to date with in my college years. Better than a wingman.

[@AlexFarleyMusic]

When I was 15, I went to Europe on a summer school trip in 2006. We were in Verona, Italy exploring the city. We stumbled on a fragrance store and decided to stop in. I don't know what inspired me to pick up this scent, but I was enthralled with Black XS. I knew I had to have it. This scent is representative of my coming of age and a nostalgic reminder of my trip across the globe. Every Christmas while I was in high school, my mom would buy this for me and I was just as excited to get it then as I was when I first bought it. Two years ago I bought the reformulated scent. The first whiff took me back, as I hadn't smelled it in over 6 years. I'll never remember what the original scent was like, but it's a nostalgic trip down memory lane. Wearing it still gets me compliments and transports me back to Verona when I was 15. I'm happy they brought it back, all formula changes aside.

[@AussieMarcel]

Thank you for sharing that, mate.

[@Carl-Shef1989]

Ah man, I want to smell the new bottle as I loved the original but I will be upset if it doesn't smell similar enough :(

[@MrDboyTV]

My Dad used to have the original one and the smell is very memorable for me because it’s the perfume he used when he came back from abroad back when I was a kid

[@brokegamer8724]

same same

[@michaelbrow1099]

So thankful someone did one of these. My first premium fragrance I got and very unsure whether to get original or new one

[@darlinggarcia8544]

ORIGINAL ALWYS BETTER

[@Carl-Shef1989]

What did you go for ?

[@DarkOakGenerated]

I Smelt the Original Formula back in like 2017 and my 12 year old self Loved it INSTANTLY. Stuff was Absolutely nuclear on my clothes after testing it, haven't smelt it for 5 years but I STILL want it. I think that shows how good the old one was.

[@igorgiga410]

hello, please help, I found the old black xs packaging, so I'm interested in whether the black xs is still produced in the original packaging?

[@sector7676]

Just found out about this :( Now I have to stock up on the original formula as I really love it. Thanks for the review!

[@AussieMarcel]

Cheers, mate!

[@jasonism123]

I remembered I had that original version back in 2007. The best fragrance of all time. Based on your review, I ain't getting the new one. Thank you.

[@danielsan3681]

Really good review and comparison. 🙂👍

[@tateduku]

Just scored a 100ml tester of the O.G bottle 95% Full, for $20 (Chempro).. wouldn't have even looked at it if I didn't see the review...great frag🍓🌹 💪🏾

[@Carl-Shef1989]

jeeze thats a great price.

[@pimpdaddy2kool]

Great review! I was able to get a tester of the old version for the same price as the new version

[@AussieMarcel]

That’s a great price. Cheers, mate. Enjoy!

[@timik35]

What is the batch code of your old version?

[@dop3hasib]

Aussie represent! Can you do a top 10 under $50

[@Carl-Shef1989]

Man I loved the original. So gutted they don't make it anymore / its difficult to come across / expensive. Wonder if there is a clone for it ?

[@abunadia5506]

Excellent review mate!🇦🇺

[@AussieMarcel]

Cheers, mate!

[@ElZorro-games_memes_stuff-]

The old one is my frangrance for years...Let's see if I get the old version or like the new one...

[@drpow6244]

I tried the new one in a mall and it wasnt that bad or different as everyone says. The new one may also be more suitable for the summer or warm weather.

[@Kamil-ib7td]

I love 2005 version, its for me something magic

[@stevanb.2590]

I wonder why they even reformulate something that was nearly perfect. Yeah, they smell similar (not same for sure) but I'm not sure if newer version was first one that many people would fall in love with it. Newer one has less unique smell, lasts less.

[@AussieMarcel]

Yeah, it’s a carrying shame, but sometimes they have to reformulate fragrances for legal reasons. E.g. They find out a certain aromachemical used causes rashes in some users, etc. In other cases they do it to cut costs.

[@stevanb.2590]

@@AussieMarcel yeah man, it's a shame, Black XS was one of those you don't think twice when you buy it - you can't go wrong. I still have original bottle somewhere around the house (without the cap) and it still smells the same. I remember "old" version being more "oily" than this one, hard to get it off the skin or clothes.

[@lampionization]

¿Como conseguir la vieja fórmula?

[@theghoulboyofficial]

i compared them the other day & the new one definitely has much more of a fizzy opening compared to the OG's more sharp impact. i do have some issues with longevity on the original though, but that's an issue with most fragrances on my skin

[@paul_henderson]

I still love them but I'm pretty sure they're not as good as they used to be anymore (and I always buy the "old" zippo lighter version). They're not as intensive as they were back in the day and either I always happened to buy (not on purpose) fake ones or the fragrance never lasted long, Hell, nowadays even bold fake weird named bottles smell better sometimes and last longer for some reason. That's why I pursue the perfect alternative I still haven't found yet. Recently heard Davidoff Zino is pretty close while the ingredients aren't exactly the same (and I hate sandalwood scent whether it's a perfume or some essential oils and home refreshers. In general avoid typical funeral/casket fragrances - wood/root if you will. I'm a semi-sweet/sweet wine fan and despise dry/semi dry if you get an idea. To me XS Is defo a sweet wine style fragrance. In general I I can confirm there are strawberries in it (XS) even though they won't say there's such scent. Or coke? Haven't thought about that, sounds valid tho. Wish Black XS was a perfume, not eau de toilette. Basically I find perfumes and toilet waters pretty rare ish and interesting in terms of tolu balm and kalamansi lemon. I think those are what makes XS great and unique.

[@Rayallwayz]

Thanks for letting me know. I love the original. Because of the strawberry smell. Since you say the strawberry smell is weak on the new one. I won't get the new one.

[@sotiris6116]

What year's batch do you have?? How does it perform ??

[@Rayallwayz]

@@sotiris6116 mines is before it got reformulated. It doesn't have the year on the Bottle. But the smell is good. Unless someone is near you on a hot day. Then they can smell it on you. The smell stays on your clothes forever. But on the skin it doesn't perform for long.

[@lukhololatha667]

I was looking for the original and unfortunately can't find it. I wish Paco Rabanne would go back to the old formulation. The new one is weak.

[@rayhanes1347]

Just cracked open a box of the new xs I didn't even know I had. The velvet box caught me off guard. I wouldn't know the difference because I love this so called new formula that's sweet, creamy and a bit citrus. Now I gotta go hunt for the original 🙁 Edit: Just found it online for $50 in the tall bottle. That should be the old formula. Glad I saw this vid 👍🏿✌🏿

[@yigitcanyoruk561]

where did you find it?

[@davidodonovan2142]

Brother can I ask you in your new bottle does the lid come totally off or is it still a flip lid like the one in the video? Bought one today and it's 2021 batch and the lid comes completely off

[@davidrobert4246]

Used to love this stuff, It had a great smell. Felt ripped off when I bought the new formula version.

[@AussieMarcel]

You and I both, mate. They’re two different fragrances now, unfortunately.

[@rickymemeti1826]

After 2012 or so it wasn’t the same anymore 😑 such a bummer. And the new black xs is just a SCAM to me, it’s an embarrassment

[@karil6461]

Could this be unisex?

[@patrickbateman4541]

Any idea when your older bottle was made? I could get a 2010 if I wanted to.

[@AussieMarcel]

Good morning and happy Easter. I just checked the batch number, it’s a little worn out, so I can’t make out if it’s 21240 (released in 2012) or 71240 (released in 2017).

[@patrickbateman4541]

@@AussieMarcel ah thank you that's enough info though! I'll get a 2010 50ml cause I realized I really like this scent but need better longevity.

[@gtiak274]

I have buy a old bottle which batch Code says, that is made June 2020 made in Spain... Do they change the bottle again???

[@AussieMarcel]

Maybe they’re still producing the older formulation in some countries? Or it could be relabelled older stock?

[@tepposarjonen]

Batch codes are reused every 10 years, that i have heard. I have also a old bottle, made in Spain and batch code says 2020 something.

[@rickymemeti1826]

Gotta be Made in France especially before 2010,everything else is BS

[@uriels4097]

When I was in middle school, this was the perfume every fboy was rocking, I remember it was very fruity

[@AussieMarcel]

One of those cases where it’s popular for good reason. Although when I was younger and purchased this I thought it was going to be a much darker fragrance given the name, haha.

[@Serander]

I’ve been using this parfume since 2010 but i wonder if it’s possible to find the older bottle in 2023 ?

[@AussieMarcel]

You can still find the older bottles on eBay but they can be pretty pricey, unfortunately.

[@drpow6244]

​​@@AussieMarcelbought one on ebay for 51 euros 100m. Is that good?l

[@ashdavidowen]

Just bought the old black xs, and just wondering have many sprays would typically use so it’s still out there but not over bearing?

[@AussieMarcel]

Two sprays is fine. One on the left side of the neck and one on the right.

[@akuma4u]

I use 4 to 6 sprays and it works well

[@Kumari_44]

The og formulation, even just three sprays way nuclear!

[@brianbdawg3059]

I bought the OG in Mexico it was a beast

[@phillipbazan5222]

Where could I find the Black xs?

[@AussieMarcel]

Which formulation? The original can still be found in certain stores and eBay, if you’re lucky and don’t mind paying a premium, although the newer formulation is readily available at almost all retailers that stock designer fragrances.

[@mustafabelal38]

Would you please make a video about the black xs l'exces flanker?

[@AussieMarcel]

Sure. I’ll find a bottle and film a review.

[@Loki-sk7bi]

That one is my absolute fav but it’s discontinued. IMO, it’s way superior to the original Black XS. The pineapple note is just damn beautiful! They need to bring it back

[@Kumari_44]

They have secretly reformulated the scent many times. Even as far back as the old bottle. I know cos the og scent was my favorite cologne. Was rocking it when it wasnt even as well known as it soon became afterwards. Roughly about 7ish years ago is when they started changing the scent. Waaay before the new bottle design. So you could have the old bottle, but it would still be pisswater inside, making it literally impossible to know whether you got the nice old scent or the shit new one cos the bottles were identical. Best advice, hit up discount stores. They’ll likely have the closest thing to the og scent. Dont fully trust ebay as its literally 50/50 with no gurantee you’ll get the og scent. People are charging hundreds yet whats in the bottle isnt actually the original scent. You’ll basicly be wasting your money on dog urine. Discounts stores are the way to go.

[@patrickbateman4541]

Wearing the new one and I can't smell it past an hour 😰 Smells lovely though up close

[@Frank-DuxVanDamme]

They totally ruined a great parfume.

[@BoxyTheSpaceDog]

Because your nose adjusts to the smell,it's with every fragrance.This is also cold weather fragrance so anything above 20 degree C will ruin performance.How to test lasting?Get sample in store,bring the paper home,place it on coffee or PC table and leave it throughout the day(make sure it's right season,cold weather isn't same as warm one).Than check from time to time if you smell the sample projecting scent from distance of 1m or so,if yes that's what people around you would smell.It's only way to test,def never blind buy or first impression buy,that don't mean anything.

[@babylonreviews9827]

By purchasing the old bottle i get the original formulation?...i mean they exist old reformulated bottles?

[@Kumari_44]

Not guranteed. The rubbish piss water reformulated also comes in the old bottles, fooling potential customers. Before they reformulated it again in their new bottle design, they still put the crap in the old bottles.

[@killuminatii1]

So does the longer bottle thats procuded today, still has the same formula as back in 2005?

[@AussieMarcel]

The new Black XS does not have the original formulation. If you manage to find the longer bottle from about 2012 onwards that was a reformulation to, up until they stopped producing it in 2018 (and then gave it a complete redesign).

[@killuminatii1]

So is there any other perfume that comes close to the 2005 XS? I read something abouy Himalaya but those are very pricy

[@janosgyorgy8439]

No,is not so good

[@janosgyorgy8439]

The old Version Made in Franc,and the same bottle old Version Made in Spanien,and Not so good. Same bottle,but different. I used long Time the old Version 2005.

[@URKA1988]

Hello , bro can you tell me new version and old version have at the same smell?thanks

[@AussieMarcel]

90% similar. The missing ten percent is in the praline and strawberry notes that’ve lost potency.

[@URKA1988]

@@AussieMarcel thanks

[@Strife773]

i just got a bottle of the original tall version with the rose on it from fragranceX, cost me twice what the new bottle would but after hearing good things about the original i wanted to get it. i looked up the manufacture date and it says april 2022 so either i got a fake bottle with a fake batch code or they are still making it in the original bottle?

[@el.palabrero]

x2 mine is also an old bottle design but a 2021 batch

[@Kumari_44]

They have secretly reformulated the scent many times. Even as far back as the old bottle. I know cos the og scent was my favorite cologne. Was rocking it when it wasnt even as well known as it soon became afterwards. I was a club promoter and this scent used to blow girls minds. Roughly about 7ish years ago is when they started changing the scent. Waaay before the new bottle design. So you could have the old bottle, but it would be expired pisswater inside, making it literally impossible to know whether you got the nice old scent or the shit new one cos the bottles were identical. Best advice, hit up discount stores. They’ll likely have the closest thing to the og scent. Dont trust ebay as its literally 50/50 with no gurantee you’ll get the og scent. People are charging hundreds yet whats in the bottle isnt actually the original scent. You’ll basicly be wasting your money on dog urine. Discounts stores are the way to go.

[@sotiris6116]

Thinking of getting the old bottle. Does it worth it in 2021 ?? Does it still have decent longevity/projection??

[@AussieMarcel]

The older formulation of Black XS is still a great performer. It’s far and away the better scent of the two.

[@Kumari_44]

They reformulated it more than once. Even if you get the old bottle you might still get duped and get the rubbish liquid that came even before the new bottles even worse reformulation. If you get the og 2005 to say 2018 scent. Thats what youre after. But Tbh though its a blind risk regardless because the bottle may be the old one, but whats inside may not be what should be inside. Theres no certified way of knowing unfortunately. I’ve found that the discount stores have the closest thing to the og fragrance. Ebay too sometimes. But ebay can be super dodgy and sell you the right bottle, but the shit scent. Discount stores are the way to go.

[@aminasesayaminata1322]

And I just bought it today,it nice tho 😅

[@norelmilihov2941]

May I ask where did you get the original XS? , I just can't find it nowhere

[@AussieMarcel]

I got the original bottle at Priceline. It went on sale for about $60-$70 AUD.

[@claudiaventimiglia579]

hi, could a woman use this perfume?

[@KhaiFirst]

Thanks

[@user_ghdq3]

For all those that loved the original, try Ajmal amber wood

[@grapesofwrath1984]

They’re definitely not the same. I hate that they had to change the formulation. They should have just created a new one if they had to, and retained the old one.

[@sophfragrant1521]

I miss the original I haven’t tried the new formulation I’m nervous lol

[@AussieMarcel]

It isn’t bad. I’d still recommend it.

[@kekecom]

I think Black XS Potion is the most similar to the original

[@Kumari_44]

The new one is the absolute worst of all the secret reformulations. Pisswater.

[@lewdude2k8]

Have you ever found anything similar? I honestly think the new one is terrible compared to the old one! Very disappointing. EBay no longer sell the old formulation. The old style bottle now also put the reformulation in so the only way to tell before you buy is to ask for the batch number. The thing that gives me the similar vibes of sweetness and luxury smell is invictus victory exlixir by paco rabanne

[@AussieMarcel]

Nike Man Green! Smells remarkably close to the older formulation and only costs $10!

[@lewdude2k8]

@@AussieMarcel Ill check it out thanks

[@lewdude2k8]

@@AussieMarcel is it called Nike man ultra green?

[@AussieMarcel]

Nah Ultra Green smells like 1 Million. It’s just Nike Man Green🤘🏼

[@lewdude2k8]

@@AussieMarcel sweet I’ve just ordered it. Hoping it’s a close to it as you say 👌

[@slisyd]

Saw some of the old bottles at priceline not cheap though $130aud.

[@patrickbateman4541]

They're decently priced on European eBay. 50 to 80€. I thinkhink they'll ship to you! Give this frag a shot it's unique honestly

[@BoxyTheSpaceDog]

Priceline is ripoff along with Myer,D.Jones etc...Buy online from private sellers in Aust,just check batch code,to be original and maybe test it on the spot if still unsure,got mine for 50$.Be careful though,there are a lot of fakes out there so best is to try it in store and than from private seller.I always buy online,never had problems so far.

[@ihsantelicom1644]

how much price this monster

[@Frank-DuxVanDamme]

Until I watch the video ... New one is what a call "gone with a wind" parfume. Failed! Old one "original" was almost beast. Why they do that? Don't fix it if it's not broken.

[@JMM440xi]

Always the same story about old formulations vs new. Just bought the new one for 50 bucks, how bad can it be when 2 young attractive ladies on You Tube were blown away by the new one. One said it smelled liked something a rock star would wear.

[@markelric6854]

Just bought a old tester bottle at chem warehouse for $15 AUD,😆

[@AussieMarcel]

Amazing price!

[@bobhunt1121]

This is a lovely smell... But i find if you use 2 sprays you offend yourself and others... I get woman following me when I use it

[@dodoevin1294]

I absolutely agree with u .i was very disapointed with the new one .

[@Elgato1989]

Its differents perfumes

[@danpanther]

It’s a bit yawn when people get outraged about reformulations. Either you like it or you don’t. Plus the old bottle looks old!!

[@rainofthepast]

Getting rare $

[@darlinggarcia8544]

bad, now damage EARLY ALWAYS BETTER¡¡¡¡¡

[@BoxyTheSpaceDog]

If you want something as old version of Black XS buy 1 Million Perfume.It's basically same thing(strawberry smell,spicy,lasts long,also worn in cold weather).AVOID reformulated Black XS!Longevity is just terrible,it's def watered down version with approx 1/3 of the strength of original!Also never buy perfumes based on first impressions and wear it not on skin but spray up to 4 pumps inside of clothes,lasts far longer,doesn't mix with body sweat,stays on as intended.Why inside of clothes?Some fragrances leave stains(especially autumn/winter ones).

[@Kumari_44]

They dont smell even remotely the same. But 1million is amazing. The best cologne next to the original black xs. The new black xs is basicly expired pisswater… and thats even insulting to the pisswater lol.

[@BoxyTheSpaceDog]

@@Kumari_44 1 milion Perfume version,not edt!and I said something like original Black XS(old version)which is basically strawberry smell.

[@nicuadrian7073]

New one is rubbish ! Old one the best!

[@AussieMarcel]

I completely agree!

[@igormarinkovic1531]

is this new or old?