He was saying goodbye. When hearing the song his daughter said to him "It sounds like you're saying goodbye." He told her "I am." This was his goodbye letter to all his fans. That one last swan song.
@saintdon44612 ай бұрын
i see what you did there.. cash's great columbo episode 'swan song'
@Tampahop2 ай бұрын
His song for everyone else was God's Gonna Cut You Down.
@gminusmark3 ай бұрын
In 1983 I went to see Johnny play, it was a small theatre, I got there early hoping for an autograph, I wondered around a deserted parking lot waiting to see if he would arrive, I paused for a while to look at the view, I turned around & he was stood in front of me, Just me & Johnny Cash! I stuttered Mr Cash! He asked "Are You A Rockabilly Boy?" I was dressed like 1956 Johnny, "Yes Sir!" I said, He asked what I had in my bag, I took out the records, he signed them, Then he put his hand on my shoulder and asked "Do you have a ticket to get in Son?" Yes sir Mr. Cash I answered, & with that he was gone, The tour bus had been parked nearby & I guess he saw me walking around, Just a short meeting, I think about it often decades later
@bumperu3 ай бұрын
You were hoping for an autograph. He was looking for a friend.
@tuijakarttunen91643 ай бұрын
Thank you for sharing your experience with us.
@janiceN4Nugs2 ай бұрын
That's a great story 😊
@sarahirwin89122 ай бұрын
I'm willing to bet he remembered you and thought about you periodically too. It was a sincere interaction. People don't forget those. A celebrity remembered me 10+ years later when I got to see them again and ask (they even helped fill in the holes in the story of our interaction). We think we're insignificant to them. We're not.
@ffjsb3 ай бұрын
Johnny Cash is in SIX Halls of Fame. Rock and Roll, Country Music, Nashville Songwriters, Gospel Music, Memphis Music, and the Rockabilly Hall of Fames.
@angelskunk22063 ай бұрын
I believe the picture was actually his mom. His wife is in the video. She passed about 4 months later and then within months, he passed.
@ericberg92663 ай бұрын
That is his mom in the picture. And yes, that is his wife in the video, but she passed before he did.
@dailyflash2 ай бұрын
The piano lid coming down at the end is like a coffin closing.
@p.j.morris2 ай бұрын
exactly.
@renee57483 ай бұрын
When Johnny played this song for his daughter Roseanne, who is also a famous musician, he asked her what she thought. She said, “it sounds like you’re saying goodbye, dad.” He said, maybe I am.
@texantompaine45092 ай бұрын
The most touching part to me personally...at the very very end...when he closes the piano, the way he runs his hand over the lid gets me every time. That's a man saying goodbye to something he spent a lifetime loving dearly.
@davedave86022 ай бұрын
Yes! Reminds me of someone touching a casket/coffin.
@p.j.morris2 ай бұрын
This hits you right in the feels. This is the best cover. Trent knew it new respect for Trent i was never a fan of Trent but when Johnny's cover was heard by Trent he gave it to Johnny.
@TheOnespeedbiker3 ай бұрын
By the time JC recorded this song we was nearly blind from cataracts and in considerable pain from complications from diabetes, but due to a life long struggle with prescription medication, even though he knew he was near death he refused to take any pain medication for fear of becoming addicted again. In his lifetime he sold over 90 million albums. His song, "I walk the Line", is rated #1 of the top 100 Country songs and #30 of Rolling Stones 500 most influential Rock songs of all time.
@creinicke10002 ай бұрын
Didn't he overcome additions.. so very understandable why he wouldn't want to go back to that.
@TheOnespeedbikerАй бұрын
@@creinicke1000 As any addicted person knows you never overcome addiction, you are simply in a state of recovery for the rest of your life. The point being even at the end of his life, when using pain killers would have likely improved his quality of life, he stayed true to his sobriety. It's a testament to what he had become.
@jessisanchez81503 ай бұрын
Trent Reznor (NIN) cried when he heard Johnny's rendition, that's how powerful this song is
@francismcknight7243 ай бұрын
Trent also stated it wasn't his song anymore
@ShortyRock8013 ай бұрын
And Trent said. “This is no longer our song”
@xheralt3 ай бұрын
@@francismcknight724 AR said as much in the video.
@robertbootier82232 ай бұрын
Naa, he thought it was weird. kzbin.infoFJvH7NPfu9w
@jaydouglas88452 ай бұрын
@@robertbootier8223 No. You missed the point. That was his original response. However, what others posted were his longer, reflected thoughts.
@757optim3 ай бұрын
You might enjoy watching the movie "Walk The Line", based on two Johnny Cash autobiographies. A great JC video is one of Johnny Performing "Man In Black" live. Johnny had spent time talking with students at Vanderbilt University and wrote the song as a result of those conversations. In fact, Johnny had just finished the last rewrite of the song, which Johnny explains in the opening of the video.
@dianenewcomb47653 ай бұрын
That man went thru hell and back during his lifetime but came out on the other side at peace...❤😢
@Ancient_Drummer2 ай бұрын
Absolute greatest cover song of all time. I've lost both parents and an older brother and I'm 53 now. Your perspective changes when you and your siblings are now at the top of the family and knowing that we are on deck. Definitely reflect much more than I used to and have several regrets, but you cannot change them, you can only try to be better. While you push on as a man and try to be an example, you really start to understand your mortality in a way you never did before. This song gets me every time.
@Steven-q6x5h2 ай бұрын
Feel ya. Lost mom/dad/sister in about 4 years. So fucking hard being alone
@garrymoore21612 ай бұрын
God's Gonna Cut You Down was recorded by Johnny before he did Hurt. He never touched a piano or guitar after you see him close the cover at the end of Hurt. They had a good idea of how to produce Hurt but he was not sure of what kind of video for God's Gonna Cut You Down. June died four months after they finished up Hurt, Johnny died seven months after Hurt was produced. After he passed, a group of true music stars got together to pay tribute to Johnny. It was produced and released after Johnny died.
@knitswithhorses22852 ай бұрын
Many watching this video don't realize all those cute scenes were from movies that he did. He was such a multi talented man.
@annemaclean66343 ай бұрын
This has to be one of the most emotionally charged songs ever, in my opinion. I always get emotional listening to it and watching the video, one line always gets to me 'everyone I know goes away in the end', it's so heartrending. It's a beautiful song and he does it so well.
@katrinacash63933 ай бұрын
Johnny's wife, June Carter Cash, was a country artist from a family dynasty in country music. June appears in the video on the stairs behind him.
@themightybuzzard30883 ай бұрын
She was funnier than him too.
@ElizasGrammy3 ай бұрын
My best friend ( a cast member from Hee Haw and a good friend of Johnny's) was at his wife June's funeral. She knelt down by Johnny at the funeral and said, "Darlin', how are you holding up?" He said, "Lu, I'll be gone in six months." He was gone in four.
@oregonchick762 ай бұрын
June was clearly the center of his soul and gave him balance and solace, not just love and passion. He once was asked his definition of paradise. Johnny replied, "This morning, with her, having coffee."
@dcbs86913 ай бұрын
The man is a legend for a reason. Checkout his catalog and his bio. Started life with next to nothing and gained everything one could want for only realize in the end we all return to the earth. Worldly possessions mean nothing in the end.
@EdithMaxim3 ай бұрын
picture was of his mother.
@creinicke10002 ай бұрын
His wife is standing on steps, and you see her in clips. They were both icons in country music.
@beauwoodland23742 ай бұрын
I thought the picture was of his wife and the lady on the stairs was his daughter?
@jeffatha32962 ай бұрын
June Carter cash.his wife
@jeffatha32962 ай бұрын
Oh yes, the frame picture with Mrs Carrie.. , she is in the red shirt, yes mam
@Jules-um4yy3 ай бұрын
Such an emotional song. I have heard it described as "a valentine to sufferers" whether about addiction, depression, death or wars etc. it checks all the boxes. I don't think anyone could perform this as well as Cash and pack the same punch. Thanks guys for your reaction and comments. Very moving💔
@flyingardilla1433 ай бұрын
Thanks to Rick Rubin for repeatedly pushing this song on Johnny.
@henrysmiley58782 ай бұрын
I'm a native Arkansan, and Johnny Cash grew up in eastern Arkansas, not far from where I was born. I was very familiar with him, having grown up in a family that loved country music. For several years, I worked at a small country radio station. This video is profoundly moving; to see Johnny nearing the end of his life, covering a NIN song and absolutely owning it, is one of most melancholy moments in popular music history. It has moved me to tears more than once.
@browniewin41213 ай бұрын
He took and already good song and gave it more depth from an old man at the end of his life. He made it his own and the composed Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails, did not mind after hearing it. Do listen to the original from the album The Downward Spiral. The photo was of his mother, his wife June Carter cash is seen walking with him in the video filmed in February 2003 and she died on May 15 of that year and Jonny followed 7 months later on September 12th at age 71.
@karenfryberger42603 ай бұрын
These are the facts, thanks.
@stephengilbert-p7z3 ай бұрын
the picture was of his mother, his wife is later on the stairs.
@NonyaBizniz-yg2id3 ай бұрын
I don't know for sure, but the story goes: Trent Reznor, nine inch nails lead singer, was mad when he heard someone coveted this, then he hears it and said "it's his now'
@CavHDeu3 ай бұрын
The song hits more and more every time you hear it.
@TheRokjok3 ай бұрын
Props to Rick Rubin who said Johnny wanted me to "run tape" on every song and conversations, he and Rick had during this time. Rubin went on to say that Johnny felt if he wasn't recording, he was going to die. In this video Rubin captured Cash's true essence. By this time Cash's diabetes had ravenged his eye sight and many internal organs.
@tuijakarttunen91643 ай бұрын
I just discovered this cover a couple of years ago. It is one of the deepest songs I have ever heard. His voice is everything. He really said goodbye to everyone. Sad and beautiful.
@pams13243 ай бұрын
Oh man. This song gets me every time. I am the age where I knew of his fame in awards, songs and movies. In the end after all the fame & money and he would rather have nothing than have his wife die. He loved his wife June Carter very much. He died soon after she did.
@luxleather26163 ай бұрын
the picture was his mother....his wife is in the video with him though....this was his last music video & his album got nominated for awards....Johnny & June passed away very close to each other....his daughter actually made that comment to him about it sounding like he was saying goodbye & he said yes it is
@nathanclarke27773 ай бұрын
This is such an amazing cover to a great song! Trent to this day plays this song with the lyrics that Johnny altered! It's become like a tribute to Johnny!
@MutterallerDrachen20879 күн бұрын
There’s such a different feel when a younger person sings “I hurt myself today to see if I still feel” and when someone in Mr. Cash’s age sings it. He owned it. And almost every time he covered someone’s song? It became his. He is my standard of a voice.
@veronicamorgan90293 ай бұрын
I remember when this was released. We were all mourning his death, and hearing him say goodbye
@mothersolaris183 ай бұрын
I was crying before even starting the video back then when it came out.
@theismish64483 ай бұрын
It is amazing to watch people discover Johnny Cash. Hurt, hurts
@Uriahjw3 ай бұрын
He was best friends with other superstars that had passed before him. Losing everyone around you or in your circle can leave you lost. I know this feeling. All the friends I grew up with except for 2 have all passed. There used to be 11 of us on the block. It's devastating, and I can't imagine how hard it is for those people who live to their 100s.
@cindyphifer9703 ай бұрын
This was his last album before his death. Great album. Elvis recorded Run On first, if I am not mistaken. Elvis's is great and always my favorite but Johnny was great also. R.I.P to both
@pams13243 ай бұрын
Rosanne Cash is his daughter with first wife. Listen to her song “Seven Year Ache”. It is beautiful.
@Howie-du7ov3 ай бұрын
I always liked Tennessee flat top box!.
@aura812953 ай бұрын
Watched you guys react to this on BP's channel awhile back. Good to re-watch here and now. It is an emotional powerful performance for sure. Having two of my favorite KZbin reactors sitting next to each other for the experience - sweet! If you haven't already done it, "A Boy Named Sue" is a Johnny Cash song you might really enjoy. Hits a bit on what it means to be a man and a dad. 😉
@jeffrichards15372 ай бұрын
When shuts the piano and runs his hands across it. If you listened to him and loved his music it should make you shed a tear.
@aliselynch2 ай бұрын
Both of you are right and both of you MUST listen to much more Johnny. Try Personal Jesus and One as other amazing covers he did. Folsom Prison Blues, Delia, Man in Black, Boy Named Sue, I've Been Everywhere, etc
@MommaBird523 ай бұрын
Johnny looked much older than his 71 years! You need to listen to the lyrics of Man in Black. Why is it okay to laugh when you are happy but not OK to cry when you are down?
@artfisk33 ай бұрын
older stuff of his "sunday morning coming down ", "boy named sue"," ballad of ira hayes " just to start
@neighbourlady3 ай бұрын
Beautiful reaction to an amazing song. Johnny Cash is amazing. So much of his work is just so good. BP - you need to react to AR's suggestion of God's Gonna Cut you down.. of you goth react to it together. great song and so many big stars have camos.. great stuff..
@93kingu3 ай бұрын
Yes, the original to give this one context!
@JDogg19713 ай бұрын
“You’re bucket is full. So just let it out so you can fill it back up again.” Brilliant.
@johncampbell7562 ай бұрын
Recorded in late 2002. The video was filmed in February 2003. It was released on March 2003. His wife, seen watching onnthe stairs, died on May 15, 2003. He followed on September 12, 2003. Producer Rick Rubin introduced him to the song. Johnny was 71. His wife, June Carter is also a country music legend. Trent wasn't originally happy about him doing a cover of his most petsonal song. Then he watched the video.
@Brenda707072 ай бұрын
Johnny had so many songs: Folsom Prison Blues, A Boy Named Sue, Ira Hayes, Sunday Morning Coming Down, 5 Feet High and Rising, Delia, Pickin' Time, Big River, The Long Black Veil, Bad News, One Piece at a Time, Jackson, I've Been Everywhere, Ring of Fire, The Legend of John Henry, Casey Jones, and Frankie and Johnny.
@RockPowerUSA2 ай бұрын
2 strong men sharing here how they feel about one of the most iconic stars of our century singing a goodbye song, relating it on how it ties in to their lives today. It was very connecting. Thanks.
@GregDunne-zf2ep2 ай бұрын
From what i remember his wife had just passed it is such a beautiful song it reminds me of my grandmother just before she died at 97 all her friends had died her 2 husbands had passed and she was tired of life
@CloudslnMyCoffee2 ай бұрын
i love that BP is always showing people the amazingness of Cash but doesn’t know his most famous song 😂😂 Sunday Morning Coming Down is my favorite
@robertvroom3 ай бұрын
This was a goodbye song. His wife died about three months after the song was sung and he died about three months later. From what I have heard, he wanted to outlive his wife so that she wouldn't feel the pain of losing him. In my opinion, this version is far better than the original. I have heard that when he closed the piano at the end of this song, he never opened it again. It was the last song on his last album.
@boroblueyes3 ай бұрын
Yes, for the original.
@Gort-Marvin0Martian3 ай бұрын
Had the privilege of seeing him in concert, not long after he had taken June Carter as his wife. Of course she and the Carter Family were there in the same concert. This song really hits hard. It is clear that he was saying goodbye. You guys are amazing. It was great tuning in. Glad I came by to watch. As for that concert, my new wife and our new baby boy were there with me. A joyous occasion. As we say in Texas; y'all be safe.
@williamdread3912 ай бұрын
That man was a force of nature. He took what was throne at him, and stood proud. Different kind of being from what we now have.
@timbertime78232 ай бұрын
The entire album (When The Man Comes Around) this song is from is a masterpiece and a perfect finale to Cash's legendary career. It is also part the resurgence he had in the later years of his life that started in 1994 when he started working with legendary producer Rick Rubin.
@marknicholes85593 ай бұрын
First picture shown was his mother.
@TheColdrush222 ай бұрын
Love you guys. Also the Westside Connection(Ice Cube, WC, and Mack 10) song "The Gangsta, The Killa, and the Dope Dealer" uses the Nine Inch Nails sample.
@leighkamp94573 ай бұрын
yes, check on the original
@AdamMcLennan-tl7kg3 ай бұрын
We all know that thing that brings "man" tears. For me it's honestly! I have shed a tear or 10 with this song at different times. Without any shame!
@JohnMorris-c5v2 ай бұрын
This is like starting with the last page of a book. You guys need to go back to the beginning to fully understand the emotion behind this version of this song
@davidtullis28103 ай бұрын
His daughter said it sounds like your eulogy he said it is
@davidberesford70093 ай бұрын
Great reaction you 2, to a very effective performance from The Man In Black. To break up the sombre mood, another great one of of JC's songs was "Ring Of Fire" He refused to allow it to be used to advertise a hemorrhoid treatment. Keep Reacting!
@piplevett47832 ай бұрын
This is so weird, this week I went back to mybold favorites Sound of Silence and Hurt, and now I see you're also doing them
@llschnitz3 ай бұрын
Johnny struggled with drugs in the Sixties. In the Seventies, he would come on stage towards the end of the Billy Graham crusades and do a gospel song or two and speak for a minute.
@llschnitz3 ай бұрын
Johnny Cash together with Roy Orbison, Jerry Lee Lewis, and Carl Perkins singing "This Train" as a tribute to Elvis on the Johnny Cash show in 1977. Please react to it. Or Johnny on Sesame Street doing a duet with Oscar the Grouch singing "Dirty Dan".
@xxMelaniexx3 ай бұрын
I jear the opening and tears. Such a beautiful piece of art to have left behind to touch on such a human experience. 💯 yes to the original
@terryallen73562 ай бұрын
This song gets me every time. It's beautifully sad.
@ashleyholmes3 ай бұрын
yes to the original
@donnaritch4934Ай бұрын
FYI, he was born/raised in Arkansas. I have a relation to him distantly in my family tree as a matter of fact and yes, both my parents were born/raised in Arkansas as well. Glen Campbell also hails from the same state too, and also Jim Ed Brown, who btw is my Dad's 1st cousin. All are in the Country Music Hall of Fame.
@scramblesish2 ай бұрын
I’m still hearing this song through the prism of addiction… may god help me hear it as an old man 🙏
@king_uber_milwaukee30343 ай бұрын
That is the house he grew up in. It went under water with the building of a dam.
@sixpakshaker882 ай бұрын
"Nashville" demanded that their artists have a museum. So Johnny made one that was not open to the public.
@warpspasm66523 ай бұрын
Johnny Cash gives this song a depth and deeper meaning than Trent could have at the time he wrote it. The lines which refer 'my sweetest friend' take on a second meaning when you consider that for every country album Johnny Cash released he also released a gospel album, for him his god was his sweetest friend. Also worth noting is that the original version has the lyrics 'my empire of sh*t' but Johnny changed it to 'my empire of dirt' because he didn't feel the need to cuss/curse to get the point across.
@edreiser3 ай бұрын
The closins the piano resembles closing a coffin.
@robertbootier82232 ай бұрын
Hhahahajajahaha.
@JustMe-vk4fn3 ай бұрын
Like everyone else, Mr. Cash has made mistakes. Unlike most other people, he's shared that *fact* with the world through this song and hasn't attempted to *hide* his mistakes. "Everyone I know goes away in the end." :D Everyone you *don't* know goes away in the end too. To me there's nothing depressing about this song - I think it's very useful to learn while you're young that "Good health simply means that you're dying at the slowest rate possible".
@stingray13833 ай бұрын
I believe his wife passed right before he did.
@galerios13 ай бұрын
About a week after, I think. Johnny died and then I think June died about a week later.
@GotWag3 ай бұрын
about 4 months before him, during heart surgery.
@GotWag3 ай бұрын
@@galerios1 June died about 4 months before JC, during heart surgery.
@vickyknight44613 ай бұрын
I believe June died just after filming this video… Such a powerful performance and song. It can’t have been easy to do. 🔥🔥🔥🔥 Thank you for doing this together. 🙏😊
@IamGrootOG2 ай бұрын
Well I wasn't aware of this channel but I love both you guys 🎉🎉 Subbed
@jettechdonatkins3 ай бұрын
Doesn't matter what type of music you like,most people loved and respected Johnny and his wife June Carter Cash,It is well worth checking out more from Johnny.I would like to see the original of this song.
@michellemiller56203 ай бұрын
This song me ball like a baby. Not gonna hide it. It was emotional. Knowing his life and then he died actually before it was released. Hatd to see him sonilf and shakey. He was a mans man
@victorbradshaw73593 ай бұрын
Yes the original is a must
@sst3d3 ай бұрын
Right before he died….he was saying goodbye….watch him close the piano like a casket and touch it for the last time. That was his mom in the picture , his wife on the stairs.. Tough old man saying goodbye
@leeyaferguson90192 ай бұрын
He had a rough life.😪 Miss him ❤ Johnny ❤.
@objectiveobserver42782 ай бұрын
Johnny Cash did indeed have a song called Ring of Fire. It was written by June Carter and Merle Kilgore and got its influence from a poem. The song was originally released by June Carter's sister, but later, Johnny released his rendition of the song. The song was written around the time that Johnny and June Carter were becoming smitten with each other. They both divorced and then married each other. The song was a huge hit for Johnny. kzbin.info/www/bejne/a4jcfZutjquao80si=p9kiQqV5jbP2r1lo Home Free, the a Capella group also did a cover of Ring of Fire (featuring Avi Kaplan from Pentatonix fame) that became a huge hit for them as well. Both Avi and Tim Faust are arguably two of the deepest bass singers out there. They have sort of a battle of the bass going on. The song is amazing and is definitely worth a listen. kzbin.info/www/bejne/Zp2WlaZ-eLiWrrcsi=tVJ4wNqxltMYeMGU Enjoy!
@jelliott36042 ай бұрын
Elvis Presley was only the 2nd person to be inducted into both the Rock n' Roll Hall of Fame and the Country music Hall of Fame. Johnny Cash was the first. The "American Recordings" 1-4 series of albums, produced by Rick Rubin (watch Rick Rubin talk about Cash and making those albums with him), are absolutely stunning
@janetdonnelly34343 ай бұрын
It's always good to watch the original for comparison/ contrast!
@charlenemorris55162 ай бұрын
I cry every time I watch this…..
@Sonny-r1y2 ай бұрын
This is nine inch nails. Trent tensor my spelling sucks but he said Johnny truly sang it. He had lost is wife a yr before and his heart ache shows. He died shortly after. Best cover ever
@shanegooding48392 ай бұрын
You and BP need to check out way more of Johnny. Man's a legend for a reason.😊
@josephmontgomery42542 ай бұрын
When you see him close the piano at the end, it was the last time he played.
@robblack50242 ай бұрын
I love how y'all take it straight to your family relationships as it should be implied 😢
@king_uber_milwaukee30343 ай бұрын
At one point in the 70s, 1 out of 5 records sold in the US was a Johnny Cash record. ❤️💔
@dgodfrey89533 ай бұрын
The manifestation of a lifetime of joy and pain.
@lokithecat72253 ай бұрын
Some might call it old school, but "Keeping it Together" or being "Professional" was the ideal.
@chriscavanaugh1002 ай бұрын
Trent painted the picture and is more than worth a listen. Its raw and an experience. I love both versions,
@michellemiller56203 ай бұрын
Trent Resnor said it was now his song
@Crimethoughtfull2 ай бұрын
I saw this back in the day, when Cash first released it. It was clear it was his funeral song...and for a few years I couldn't listen to it or else I might have done the thing...full of broken thoughts I could not repair...this was when? 2003 or something? I was driving Suburbans for a Mortuary Service Company, saw this music vid on the Country Music Television channel that was always playing in the embalming room. The chief embalmer was a big country fan. And I was like 19. Magnificent piece of music, but a bit too real. Otherwisee, I only knew Cash from the Sarah Connor Chronicles "The man Comes to Town".
@amyl.converse96002 ай бұрын
His mom in photo (he was extremely close with her), wife June standing on stairs behind (his best friend). His wife died 3 months after this recording, he followed her just a few months later. So, I think he passed away about 7 months after doing this (so I've read). Yes, it's his goodbye. ❤❤❤🙏 FYI Joaquim Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon made a movie about him and his wife which I recommend, called Walk the Line.
@8491C2 ай бұрын
Guys legendary Hip Hop Producer talked Johnny into recording this song… they had recorded the American Series over the last few years of Johnny’s life… Full Circle and 1 Degree of Separation from what y’all do. God Bless
@8491C2 ай бұрын
Rick Ruben
@TananJess2 ай бұрын
Johnny Cash covered this it was originally done by Nin inch nails. That's also very good but I love a bunch of his songs and his story getting into music.