This Isn’t Who I Wanted, But…

[@Andreamom001]

I don’t see how she fits the theme, but she’s cute. Lobo would fit in better, imo. But I am sure you will make the island lovely and I’ll see how she fits once you are finished!

[@krissykins2010]

Olive is so cute! Maybe you could gift her some witchy clothes so she fits in more?

[@LexPlayy]

you’re RIGHT

[@mrsSeasunshine]

I love Olive ! My first normal villager back in 2020. Dear in my heart ♥️

[@humanrainestorm5506]

olive has cottagecore, a good witch vibes and I love it ❤

[@ardencrossing]

"Do I need a fourth cat?" Me who had an all cat witchy island: "YES"

[@rachelledeluccio4923]

Keep Olive. She can be like a nature witch!

[@winterfromwisthollow]

Muffy is sisterly, so you won't have a full normal island, don't worry :D

[@LexPlayy]

ooo nice!!

[@Laura-pk2fd]

Love Olive for this island!

[@verodg2820]

You should definitely keep Olive she does give witchy vibes! Cottagecore good witch vibes. Also, I can’t believe you found Lolly so quickly, I have never seen her on my hunts and she’s my ultimate dreamy!

[@johnminet9067]

I love your video, I just get back to my island to chill. And I also have a mysterious moover, meanwhile I was looking for the best one, but than the house was taken

[@Designer239]

I know what villagers that I would want for my island. But i jus don’t really have enough Nook Miles Tickets , so that way i can jus go and get the ones that i really wanted to be on my island.

[@cheneytardio]

I’m so glad you’re posting more this week Lex ❤ Olive is a newer addition to my (non-witchy) island and I love her so much!

[@Aerdran]

Olive is super cute! I approve. She'd make a good nature or hearth type witch.

[@melbapeach162]

Olive is my dogs name, so I can't help but love her AC counterpart 🌱 💕

[@direwolf_adventure]

Olive is totes adorbs, and there is something for sure spooky about her undead gray color

[@stellaluna.]

Olive is so cute! I agree that she has your type of witchy vibe. Lobo is a bit spooky but Olive fits, for sure in a witchy outfit/hat

[@arteemus]

I liked Lobo for your island, but maybe Olive will work. And the dress you're wearing is SO CUTE!

[@extraterrestrial.cherries]

i love olive so so much, she was on my first island as my first normal and i kept her until i reset

[@AnnaHetkinen]

Olive was one of the bear cubs I wanted for my forestcore island, I never found her, got Cheri instead :D

[@apaws2]

Olive is so witchy honestly great choice!

[@LexPlayy]

i’m so glad you see the vibes too!

[@Haou1828]

In all my villager hunts, Rodeo was the one that appeared the most and I really dislike him because of that lol I think I've never seen Olive before, she's cute tho. Lobo would have been more witchy imo

[@Sarbeararts]

Since she’s gray so looks a bit sickly. Maybe she can be the island Witch Doctor? 🧙🏻‍♀️

[@tori_scout]

Stu has somehow managed to show up for all four of the villager hunts on my newly reset island, sometimes multiple times! He wants to move in soooo bad lol

[@puffykitten31]

I love Olive! I think she’s a good pick.

[@ezrarose5922]

I think lobo was the right pick :(

[@johnminet9067]

Hoodoo Loly❤❤❤❤❤ she is sooo precious

[@carizmamaly525]

i get soooo many goats esp nan on my villager hunts. ive come to love them,,, sort of

[@DientjeDesjardins]

Marina is always showing in my fillager hunts😅 I love her but have her too freaking often😂

[@jennyjenn8716]

I love Olive. She’s super cute. You can make it work!

[@kinotocreates]

Olive is super cute!! 🥰

[@ghostlevelzero7446]

Nooo! You passed on Lobo?! Sad face.

[@tanyadiedrich7851]

She is adorable!! ❤

[@NaethanAster]

Olive has kind of a dark academia vibe so I can see how she works

[@redleafcrossing]

Yes!!!! 🙌🏼 I’m so happy you took olive 🫒 she’s so cute she’s on my island 🏝️ too 🥹😭🫶🏼

[@GQ45]

2:47 F in the chat , I looked for Lolly using 300 nook mile tickets & couldn’t find her 😭

[@medslarge]

I love Olive! Nice choice ❤

[@hannahbarton526]

Olive is my ultimate dreamie I have her one every island no matter then theme

[@avarner72]

I love Olive. Good choice!!

[@jadethekiller]

I think you should keep Olive she works so well

[@foxbuns]

Lex I love your channel! i sent you a handmade ACNH gift box to your PO box and never saw anything about it and honestly it was devastating 😭

[@LexPlayy]

omg what the heck??? my mom keeps up with my p.o. box as i moved to a different city, i’ll double check with her today :) thank you for being so kind!

[@LucyManning-b6i]

OLIVE MY DARLING!!! She's my ultimate dreamy, plus I share my birthday with her! Good choice for a witchy theme in my opinon😍

[@kileyd6362]

I support it

[@JustAndreaEdna]

I love Olive already.

[@SoliRhymesWithJulie]

Good choice! But I am more interested in the code for that dress.

[@susanworch6021]

Love olive she's so cute love her

[@mynameissami]

Naomi practically stalks me on my villager hunts.

[@Zharak]

Olive fits!

[@bibblesboo]

Is there a code for your dress? It's so cute ❤

[@sharonbiggs8061]

I have Muffy at my campsite right now if you want to come talk to her

[@JustAndreaEdna]

Muffy is sisterly

[@KatheD]

ummm yes, you should have kept Lobo, and then you should have kept Lolly, but ok, Olive works...

[@LexPlayy]

HAHAH i did see some very good villagers :’)

[@nicemarmotmc]

I was team Lobo 🙌

[@JustAndreaEdna]

❤❤❤

[@windenast]

Vesta 💜💜