This Midnight Motorist Theory Changes Everything...

[@VEE0034]

Bro came outta nowhere with a sore throat and drops the best fnaf theory in years

[@porcelainchips6061]

Afton the drunk --- I think it's very possible that Afton pre-meditates his actions and then drunks until he's "comfortable" with going through with it. Evil people can still be cowards; Afton might want to do horrible, terrible things but he might not have the nerve until he's drunk himself half to death.

[@Taro_Yanada]

You're right. Afton has been portrayed as a coward since the very beginning of the franchise.

[@CottonCandyBoi8]

even the name of "The one you should not have killed" like it was an accident, in his drunkenness he killed his own son

[@ZorusAgartha]

"We know who our friends are & your not one of them" That makes so much more sense now omg

[@toddmr]

Oh crap that makes so much sense! It’s like Dave’s telling William that he’s not fooled by his manipulation anymore. Dave being TOYSNHK makes UCN so much more satisfying

[@FNAFGamer_2023]

Holy shit you’re right!!

[@sugarfreeskull3008]

most understandable theory for midnight motorist ive ever seen

[@jaredleebarker]

It’s interesting, although I’m not completely sold on Jr’s being both a bar and a place for kids that William would assume Dave to go at the same time

[@blanktester]

@@jaredleebarker this is exactly my hesitation. I think the back half of this video is really compelling but I don't feel like it fully gels for me. I'm open to being convinced.

[@OlafKolff]

Agree, it felt the same!

[@AbsolXGuardian]

Especially in Utah. Back then you could only serve hard alcohol in private clubs, taverns which sold small beers couldn't permit children, and restaurants which could also sell small beers, couldn't advertise that they did so and you had to buy food with it. A dance hall is a specific early to mid 20th century establishment that was essentially the predecessor to a night club, not a family entertainment place.

[@blackgame5492]

@@jaredleebarker my personal theory is that after the bite of 83 fredbear family dinner closed and after some time a bar opened in its place and David (who is mentally ill) still thinks its still open and goes there constantly. This is the only thing that would make sense to me

[@Lockendrik2121]

I wouldnt be surprised if Dave drinks alcohol

[@typicalbacon4302]

Bro really has that "Number 15" ah voice

[@C0tt0n_Ey3d_J03]

When you dropped the bomb that Afton killed his own son and that he's an alcoholic it all made sense. This has gotta be one of the best fnaf theories I've heard in a long time

[@AngelTheory-M]

yeah, its make sense, but without a doubt there more to it, there must be a reason why william killed his son maybe the mimic backstory wasn't the mimic backstory, but the crying child backstory staffbot family, every staffbot have design, but the one without the head, its feel empty, like a missing a piece, like he didn't want to finished the mimic doesn't want to remember himself, he is afraid of it, just like william

[@yugold7133]

but willam has great review by people around him?

[@Paragon13]

I don’t think the TV scene is Dave, Mike and William. I think it’s Dave, Mike and Elizabeth. Two characters are clearly the same height, unlikely for child and teenage brothers. Plus Michael takes centre stage (assuming I’m right) and Michael is the only one associated with TV. After Michael stops bullying Dave, it’s likely that Dave forgave Michael before he died. Dave’s ideal happiest day is a happy family, though he probably thinks he can’t have a happy family if his dad is there (and let’s face it, that’s probably true). Dave’s happiest day is him and all the members of his family he loves spending time together doing what they love (and as a side note, it’s possible his mum died or left when he was a baby, hence her absence). This even ties into the theory that Michael is still alive in Security Breach as that has the only depiction of Mrs Afton we’ve ever seen, and only William and Michael would remember her.

[@angelicdonuts]

Right, like aside from that, I think this theory is GREAT, but i'm sold on candi bunnny's theory about where Golden Freddy is in fnaf 3. I do think the two theories could very nicely fit together either way, though, with a bit of cleanup here and there

[@common_skeleton]

Bro just offered a satisfying explanation for midnight motorist, the box, the mediocre melodies, and those weird fucking ucn cutscenes in 37 minutes

[@thatssobrunette]

Holy shit, dude. I don’t say this often, but this is it. You did it. This solves every gripe I’ve had with popular explanations for almost a decade now. Phenomenal theory! I cannot tell you how satisfying this was to watch!

[@Trontotario]

Yeah but his interpretation of the box isn’t right.

[@thatssobrunette]

@ and what’s ur objectively correct interpretation of the box, lol…

[@Trontotario]

@ I’ve been doing so much research on the box and for it to be interpreted as “crying child not dead” during the context of FNaF 4 is really absurd. Scott said it’s the pieces put together. Compare that to “I will put you back together, the pieces are in place for you” in FNaF world is an obvious hint towards ShatterVictim. The theory that the bite victim’s memories are shattered across all off Freddy’s.

[@andrewguerra2532]

12:00 I wasn’t completely sold on the chica being a metaphor for afton yet but DAMN this makes so much sense

[@drtx9800]

This is probably one of my favourite fnaf theories. It lines up so well with pizza sim and ucn. It’s really strange nobody thought of that before Congrats I hope you do more theories🔥

[@SC-ec8xe]

Actually some did. Dual Process Theory thought this 5 months ago. I believe there was at least one other person even before them but it didn't get seen by very many people.

[@RimHellworth]

This is pretty much just the the baby isn’t mine theory that’s been around since fnaf sl

[@sogmeister]

someone get this guy a cough drop

[@robg1680]

Nah the voice is perfect

[@violetpoppy91]

I love his voice so nice

[@ki11aqueen5]

@@violetpoppy91women do be weird

[@lemondollie]

@@ki11aqueen5this is why u freaks are gonna be lonely forever tbh

[@Littlebitz3211]

@@ki11aqueen5dude fr. This is the type of guy to have blacked out eyeliner

[@evillordbeerus2455]

I also think that its going to turn out that "the baby isn't mine". We find out the crying child is named Dave, and now it seems Afton is a kidnapper. And we're getting a prequel coworker of Afton with a young son named Dave. Seems to be lining up... watch, it won't.

[@toddmr]

Absolutely amazing. This might be the most satisfying take on midnight motorist that i’ve ever seen, and heck, i think this is what Scott intended! The only thing I don’t know is why William would put his own son through the experiments

[@Spartan2Orion]

Watch Candi Buunny's "What do you MEAN "The BABY isn't Mine???" theory video. It ties in very well to this theory in that dave is NOT William's biological son, but instead Henry's son, and William kidnapped him. Both this and Candi's theory isn't perfect in my opinion but I would bet you the reality of the story lies somewhere between the two of them.

[@toddmr]

Holy cow! Saw the video and yea, some things do really line up! Heck, William kidnapping Henry’s son lines up with the movie, and could even explain “The wound first inflicted on me”, if Charlie ends up not being the first victim (cause of Help Wanted 2). And yea I definitely agree that the truth lies somewhere in between these 2 videos

[@jeremymorris345]

I didn't by it at first, as I'm avid believe in Michael run away. However, you said why would Afton kidnap his own child, and I yelled out "He's Drunk!". I'd have to think on it some more as it changes Michael timeline a lot, but it's compelling.

[@holycat9609]

Okay but you gotta admit, William would have to be that good for him to be able to put the suit on while drunk😭

[@Skwish6952]

If he's an intense alcoholic, he probably feels more sober while drunk than sober. Him being able to put a suit, that he has worn for years, on drunk doesn't say much. Matter of fact him being a raging alcoholic makes a lot of sense.

[@TheGuy15-mw6hb]

This is actually a really good theory. I like how your main focus is the games and using the books as just a backup. There are parts where i disagree. The supporting evidence for the end of your theory in regards of the desth order and the balloons are the only ones i can think of. But, i love the narrative your telling 10/10

[@epiccodemage2947]

I was skeptical at first, particularly with the FNAF logbook and how Mike drew Nightmare Fredbear but MAN you convinced me! Having FNAF4 protagonist being Dave makes sense, the fnaf movie dream theory segments are a good parallel if true, and having Dave being the one you should not have killed is much more satisfying than it being a random child that is angry for being dead, because you could apply that to any of the other children including Charlotte. It also makes sense for Dave to be the one who references dialogue from FNAF4

[@gh0ry913]

this is an incredibly well put together and perfectly detailed video. the dots connected perfectly w the way you put it, nice job

[@kingkat7113]

I love this theory one of my favorites in a while. The only thing I think is a bit off is that Dave would constantly sneak out of his room to go to JR’s. JR’s while they may have the Mediocre Melodie’s, is a bar and I have no clue if they would allow random kids in (unless they know who he is which then brings up more questions). Also at the time of this escape he would have to be capable of sneaking out with a severe frontal lobe injury which I think would make Dave bedridden and not just able to sneak out whenever he wants. To give you credit the dialogue William says about Dave going to that place again could just be him misremembering things in his drunken state. Maybe he used to sneak out before the bite and since William doesn’t remember killing him that what his mind immediately goes to. Really awesome video overall hope to see more soon!

[@legoboy7107]

He wouldn't have a frontal lobe injury like that, the frontal lobe thing is the aftermath of the Bite of 87, not of 83, which was probably still done to Jeremy Fitzgerald in the FNAF 2 location or whatever. The Bite of 83 has no reference to any frontal lobes I'm pretty sure, all that's shown is that the kid was shoved in an animatronic's mouth and got crushed and injured, but that's it, what specific kind of injury we don't know.

[@kingkat7113]

@@legoboy7107 I thought the fandom found evidence that the bite we saw in FNAF 4 was actually the bite of 83'. Am I wrong? If so, could you clear that up or recommend me a video on it?

[@legoboy7107]

@@kingkat7113 No, you're right, the bite in FNAF 4 was in 1983, I never said anything disputing that, re-read my comment. I'm saying that the whole "frontal lobe" thing was the Bite of 87 as stated in FNAF 1, and NOT the FNAF 4 Bite of 83. The 1983 bite in FNAF 4 was never implied to have anything to do with any frontal lobe injuries, so I'm saying that Dave wouldn't have any frontal lobe injury because he was a victim of the 83 bite, and the "frontal lobe" was only ever stated with regards to the Bite of 87 which wasn't him. Nowhere was it implied that Dave had any frontal lobe damages from the Bite of 83, that's strictly what happened to Jeremy Fitzgerald in the Bite of 87.

[@ItIsSasha]

This might be spesific to my area, but a lot of places near me allow kids while also having bars without actually being bars. Boston Pizza being the first to come to mind for me, maybe Jr's is meant to be like that in this theory?

[@kingkat7113]

@@legoboy7107 Oh ok, I got the 2 confused. Thanks for clearing that up.

[@blackgame5492]

This theory gave me the same feelings as the "dave" theory, feelings of completion, satisfaction... You did it man, you solved midnight motorist...

[@Trontotario]

Yeah except that the technique used to find Dave makes absolutely no sense

[@NateHiggs69]

​@@Trontotariowhat about linking each response used by altered to a question asked by faded and then "reflecting" the result hinted on by the mirror and the constant repeating of the word "reflect" does not make sense to you?

[@Trontotario]

@ the mirror is for the question “what do you see” it’s supposed to give context to that question. As for the reflect part, it’s telling you to reflect on your happiest day, the happiest day is bite victim’s birthday but reflected. Also Dave is 4 letters, it’s unnecessary for Scott to reverse that name backwards because you can literally see Dave from Evad. I can hear Sounds doesn’t seem like a response to does he still talk to you I’m scared isn’t a response to do you have dreams? My interpretation is Cassidy asks first, “Do you remember your name?” The dead tend to forget so this goes unanswered “What do you see? Are any of these toys familiar to you?” BV would reply “I’m scared, I can’t see, but I can hear sounds. Cassidy knowing this asks “was your favourite childhood toy a plastic purple telephone?” This question always seemed off because it’s a lot more specific than “are any of these toys familiar to you?” But if we combine all of BV’s “replies” then it would fix everything

[@DiceGames]

Dang dude, this is such an amazing theory. My friend forwarded this to me recently, and I was just in awe of how many questions this answered. Definitely one of the best FNAF theories I’ve heard ever. As a long time veteran of the series and the semi-new lead director of the fangame “JR’s: Enter The Flipside”, thank you for shedding light on a new perspective for midnight motorist. It’s so cool to see people actually lean into elements of the original story that are somewhat ambiguous still, and make sense of it. It’s what the team and I are trying to do with “JR’s”, yet in our own AU of sorts. I still think midnight motorist and by extension FFPS offers some of the most fascinating lore content in the series. Very impressive work and I look forward to seeing more from you! Great work man, you’ve earned my sub. (Also side note, thank you for crediting me in the description for using my SL footage! It’s highly appreciated)!

[@lilaott6495]

this is such an amazing theory! i’m so glad i found your channel!! i love the way you were able to tie in mike seeing nightmare fredbear and the reverse phone call. i love the idea that william is so black out drunk he can’t remember his own murder spree and especially the idea that he failed to kidnap charlie dave being toysnhk is such a cool idea

[@rubix7277]

This theory actually blew my mind. Well done!

[@HarlandSanders-f7m]

Someone send this to fuhnaff and ryetoast

[@charleswolfe8896]

Better yet, someone send it to the horror Homestead.

[@kingnathannn207]

Subscribed, hope we can finally solve this game soon

[@mysteryman8236]

Great theory. Midnight Motorist truly is confusing lol FNAF theories in general is like going to court. I was truly confused with the Crying Child's (Dave) survival, and the Spring Bonnie suit. My personal belief is that the Crying Child didn't survive long for Midnight Motorist, I think it ruins the tragedy of the event. "The Week Before" plays back the '83 event, people shout and scream noticing the bullies activity. The imagery of "Curse of Dreadbear" hints of a fallfest in '83, William Afton's car on the back referencing Midnight Motorist makes me believe Charlie died at a Halloween/Fallfest event. (Charlie gets kidnapped at Halloween and her missing gets reported November 1st - Silver Eyes). Which would put Crying Child before Charlie. The dirt pile would still be the Crying Child. I also believe Michael was the experiment victim, as an effect of the bite. The Crying Child wouldn't see the flowers, pills and the IV drip. (As a reference to the final cutscene, Crying Child was in a void with the plushies.) Michael did saw that, and in the movie, Mike takes similar looking pills (Loprazolam). Michael hears Phone Guy and sees Fredbear due to his brother's presence, which he draws in the logbook. (In the FNAF 4 map, we see 4 transparent dots, the original four. Unless you could say Fredbear is present on the Plushtrap map, which there are 4 dots plus Plushtrap.)

[@mysteryman8236]

You brought up good points towards the Mediocre Melodies. I'm still bugged on why the masked children appear on the Happiest Day, so good one.

[@fanfywriter8727]

This sounds like it actually solved all the pieces. Congrats.

[@viral4983]

Someone get fuhnaff or ryetoast in here, i was super impressed halfway through before realizing it doesnt even have 1k views yet and you have 34 (now 35!) subs

[@gingershrimpale]

Ok but it makes Michael protecting Dave from William so sad He thought he was protecting his brother but Dave is already dead by that point..... Okay but I really like idea of Dave being that vengeful menace. And the fact that this theory makes every Afton kid directly or indirectly killed by Wiliam: Dave by William himself, Elizabeth because of him creating Baby and telling she's for her and Michael by sending him knowing that those bchs want to scoop him and that Mike looks like him

[@coburg3846]

Solid theory! Thegamesalmon did a video on the psychology of William Afton and this lines up pretty well with that! Midnight Motorist is my favorite of the theories and this may be my favorite yet!

[@AtenSol12]

Holy eff. This is an amazing read of the franchise !

[@1800JokesOnYou]

Very well done and in-depth video! 👏

[@wingedbluj1674]

I still believe Mike is who we play as during the FNAF 4 gameplay, because in the Survival Logbook, Mike (who writes with a red pen) draws a PERFECTLY ACCURATE Nightmare Fredbear. The only way he can do that is if he's seen it himself. However, I also believe William put both his sons through the experiments.

[@legoboy7107]

Well, in this theory Mike does somehow dream the FNAF4 sequences himself, so he DOES see that in his dream, which lines up with the phone call Easter Egg and the direct parallels between FNAF4's and FNAF1's gameplays and stuff, not to mention the prompt where he drew the picture was about dreams. So in this he saw Nightmare Fredbear while dreaming on the job in FNAF1. Now, WHY he would dream of the experiments his younger brother actually faced like that, I don't know.

[@blanktester]

It's definitely clear you think about this franchise a lot, just like I do. I really appreciate this video. Unconventional takes are valuable, and critical analysis like this is super important to the community, even if I don't agree with all your reasoning. I think you should consider speaking a little more quickly, like you're having a conversation. Your delivery is most confident at the end of each sentence, which is very normal when you're getting confident in front of a microphone. You might also consider turning individual moments in this video into shorts. Subbed, I look forward to your future work. ❤

[@Thunder17_-]

I read your comment as I’m watching the start of the video. Try listening to the video at playback speed of x1.5. It actually doesn’t sound bad

[@blanktester]

@Thunder17_- I'm only offering my opinion on that aspect of the video for their sake. I actually like the speed at which they speak but when I did a brief stint at a college radio station, the advice they gave was to focus on the speed of your delivery and you'll be too preoccupied to be nervous. It's good for practice but I had mixed results on the job, maybe it'll help this guy.

[@Thunder17_-]

@@blanktester I understand and it’s a great thing to try to give advice that can potentially help a new and upcoming speaker. I was simply just stating that for some reason at 1.5x speed it actually almost sounds like he is talking at a regular speed

[@blanktester]

@Thunder17_- Yeah true enough!

[@Piggehh]

yeah it sounds like hes speakign from the back of his mouth, with his throat, its very raspy

[@jhol2752]

i dont think it entirely adds up but i appreciate that this explores the idea of the split personality in william like we see in vanessa also. one personality purposely obscuring memories from the other. +2

[@ad4wave]

Damn bro i love these small channels that come from nowhere

[@Lozinlimbo]

This is awesome, very well done

[@I-Fail-A-Lotl]

Narrative satisfaction at last!

[@TheFreshestResh]

I've been in the community for a decade now and this video blows my mind. This perspective makes sense on a lot of angles and it's honestly just satisfying. Great job on the video!

[@icecreamsfluffychannel]

I have a mini theory, what if his alcoholism is the reason for the DCI. I mean think about it, the bodies were never hidden and he seemed pretty careless where he put them.

[@ein.]

This has to be one of the best videos I watched, the plot twists, the storytelling, and the theory being batshit crazy but still plausible has to be the peak of content creation

[@minidrew3]

Great theory! Im sure your channel will blow up if you keep making videos like this. Looking forward to the next one :)

[@eirou3539]

i know this is your first video, but this is genuinely huge and you deserve so much recognition for figuring this out. i hope this theory becomes more widespread in the community because its just pure genius!! genuinely like well done omg im like at a loss for words.

[@Trontotario]

It’s a solid theory which can be disproven by different interpretations of course. I’m pretty sure the box is supposed to reference ShatterVictim, the theory that Bite Victim’s memories are shattered across Freddy Fazbears. ShatterVictim gives us the meaning for “four games one story” “in the FNaF 4 minigame why would the tiny toy chica be missing her beak?” However no one at all solved what Scott was trying to tell us. He said himself at that time, before ShatterVictim was even considered. What’s in the box is supposed to relate with this theory. “What’s in the box are the pieces put together” this is Scott’s early attempt to hint us towards ShatterVictim but no one even understood it and so the story stays unsolved and Scott must use his new games to guide us to the right direction. “Would the community accept it that way?” Would the community accept that what’s in the box is currently undecided. FNaF world: “the pieces are in place for you” “I will put you back together” Sister location: “I put her back together” “I’m broken, I can’t be fixed” “there’s a little of me in every body” FNaF 6: this one involves MoltenMCI which Scott would also need to clarify alongside ShatterVictim. Having all the Fazbear memorabilia burnt in Fazbear frights would force the crying child to manifest the remaining parts of him left, Molten Freddy, the MCI. “One big happy family” “together again” What’s in the box is probably a watch or a toy but it was unimportant enough for Scott to deem undecided, probably because ShatterVictim finally exists as a theory thanks to Cuben Fancy

[@onthebay15]

man this is actually a satisfying conclusion that fits the pieces nicely

[@anthonygabelli7872]

Great work dude!

[@PubsDown]

I'M LOCKED IN. Thumbnail and title alone have me hooked

[@rambhuller]

bro came out of nowhere and released a banger

[@amyeckert3104]

This was amazingly well put together!

[@jackbelk]

потрясающая теория. она переворачивает многие версии, которые уже укоренились в фнаф-сообществе: во фнаф 4 мы играем за майкла, мстительный дух это кэссиди, и т. д. было бы классно, если вы рассмотрели некоторые другие теории, потому что они могут противоречить вашей. например, что fnaf world - это игра о том, как упокаивается душа дейва. кстати, ещё парочка моментов: в файлах игры midnight motorist называется "later that night" - все визуальные подсказки связаны именно с сегодняшним днём: следы были оставленны сегодня, в баре уильям напился сегодня, куча земли появилась сегодня, и чарли была убита сегодня. если предположить, что мстительный дух - это дейв, то тогда кажется логичным появление кошмарных аниматроников в ucn - кэссиди про них, вероятно, не знала (конечно, она могла видеть их в локбуке, но всё таки именно дейв знаком с ними не по наслышке)

[@owlhatch3812]

Depending on how much a person drinks, if that affects sleep that much as well, it can also mean that a person can dream when awake

[@Bonnieslullabybox]

This video is crazy.. im actually taken back.. wow this is so well done! :>

[@calcocat6851]

William being blackout drunk and killing dave himself actually makes so much sense. I already thought he was the one who finished him off after the bite/hospital stint but the drunk bit also tracks

[@Toaster003]

I don't see why CC could be the experiment victim if all of his bedroom furniture is in the experiment chamber. It only makes sense to me for William to move his things there after he died. Under this theory, CC's bedroom would still have furniture in it at the time of the experiments because he was in his room earlier on the day he was first experimented on.

[@tryhard4lyfe]

Ngl you got some solid points here, especially regarding UCN.

[@cykiloc]

Goddd this theory is so good!!

[@Paragon13]

My only question is why was Afton experimenting on Dave with the nightmares in the first place.

[@ImOkayDude]

Imo, you are taking a massive leap. It is almost like changing our already understanding of the lore.

[@chararaltacc]

That's the point. Our current understanding of lore may be the one incorrect in here.

[@supermario2044]

The first bit made a lot of sense until he brought up Afton killing Crying Child imo. That's what didn't make sense to me.

[@Artician]

@@chararaltacc But that can be applied to any part of the lore. FuhNaff claimed that the CC died twice (once in a vision and then for real) by the hands of Funtime Freddy disguised as Fredbear via an illusion and then somehow came back as a robot, despite the fact that FF and FB both have different toe counts + it wouldn't really make that much sense for the footprints to be from the illusion. While yes, it would shake up our understanding of the lore, but it's such a far stretch that it easily falls apart when analyzed.

[@Takejiro24]

Ah! So, this is the BlackoutMM theory I'd read about before (if memory serves correctly, it was on the FNAF Theories wiki). While I'm not really sold on it, this was a very interesting and different take on this mysterious minigame. Keep up the good work. 👍

[@Taifuo]

This is it bro, can’t wait to see you on the dawko level 🔥🔥

[@Taifuo]

Oh! It’s happening right now wake up dude 😂😂🎉

[@I_Pizza]

I dont necessarily agree with the idea, but the ending does go kinda hard. Nice to see BoV get some attention, I feel like everyone ignores it and just focuses on TCTHSY.

[@carolabranchess]

this is probably the best and my favorite theory about midnight motorist ever. great job, really!

[@princessadrigirl6774]

This is such a good video I feel like it’s going to blow up

[@gingershrimpale]

Oh, and also I saw a theory that Old Man Consequences is Mike (like, young man actions (making his brother's head go chomped) leads to old man consequences and that head kinda looks like Foxy's and stuff) and it makes lake scene so touching Mike asks his lil bro to finally calm down and get some rest, to finally get rid of William in his (after) life because even now his existence haunts lil guy, Dave just can't rest with William existing in the same world as him

[@kasey8060]

such a well-made video !!! very excited to see your videos in the future 🥳

[@whiskisimas6826]

i need to see other big theorists talk about yours. Amazing theory!!!!

[@mrghost545]

Love the video!, my only question is, why would afton start the experiments if Dave survived the bite and he hadn’t killed Charlie yet? That’s my only question with this theory, love it tho, I cannot wait till ur next video!

[@user-bu8my3jf7x]

Great theory but I have questions: why would an injured child who was afraid of the big costumes from the diner break at his window to follow William in a Springbonnie suit? Isn't he afraid of Springbonnie? And injured from the bite? Why would he even be lured if he was so scared? How did he get the strength to break a window? If Springbonnie broke his window, then wouldnt that just make the crying child even more scared?

[@dubblejinx]

Wow great theory dude!

[@mustardkrisame281]

THIS ACTUALLY MAKES SO MUCH SENSE!!!

[@PandaSlothProductions]

You actually convinced me here. This is crazy, especially considering its your first video. INCREDIBLE WORKKKK

[@Invalidcookie-bv4cx]

2:44 That is the way to do it. We have no Idea where MM fits into the events (before or after)

[@Niktune]

Well done. First video and pretty good theory.

[@hebbycakes]

This theory is NARRATIVELY satisfying. I still don't think JRs was also for kids, but it's likely that Dave was running off somewhere. Still, everything else is really good. And I like that Dave is no longer passive. Plus it makes sense with the other spirits. ALL the dead kids are represented as crying children who are PIIIISSED, it makes sense that Dave is also like THAT'S IT. "The one you should not have killed" also works as "Whoopsie Doopsie that was a mistake". I love it!! I like theories that remember that Scott is trying to tell a story, rather than trying to make a perfect puzzle. It also makes Gregory defeating Burntrap even better, NARRATIVELY speaking, even if it wasn't what Scott originally intended.

[@Albert._]

Showing support with a like and sub. Haven't watched the full video but am currently watching your summery, HUGELY appreciate and LOVE your animations of the events. Your work has been worth all it's effort I was only gonna watch like 2 minutes and keep doing what I was doing but I FELL into this video. I will be coming back to watch more of your stuff! Way better than my work. Actually been periodically stopping writing this to watch this. Excited for what you do next

[@Albert._]

Also I sent fanart in the comments but the comment might've been blocked cuz of the link

[@coleangelillo8147]

this is the best theory ive heard in years

[@ClownManJames]

you started to lose me when you said CC was the experiment victum, but you brought me back in near the end. Still iffy on the theory though

[@spaghettiiwithjuice9826]

i'm sorry but i *cannot* take any theory that says michael is the couch person and cc is the runaway seriously

[@bearlybusy]

Solid theory, loved it!

[@Guzmarkk]

bro sounds like summoning salt if he recorded at night in his parents house

[@Trontotario]

This theory is so dark and depressing

[@KirkSarahs-k2e]

Best midnight motorist theory I have seen. Dave makes so much more sense than some random girl ever could

[@L4z1l3ss]

This is like the renaissance of FNAF theories ngl

[@whiskisimas6826]

damn this is the hardest theory i've ever heard.

[@dwfan91-]

wonderful video loved it

[@chararaltacc]

jesus christ this NEEDS more views

[@nekololitrappostpunk]

Devil Satan this NEEDS more likes

[@C0tt0n_Ey3d_J03]

Agreed. This needs to go viral

[@lorddeathcloud_2153]

Bro was cooking

[@Paragon13]

JR’s as a bar and a restaurant with animatronics is genius. It could be implying how animatronics are like alcohol to William, a self destructive obsession.

[@blueroses4767]

I feel like the flatline might not be a cliché, but the sound of afton disconnecting his son from the machines. taking him off those would make the machine perceive him as dead, but he's just missing.

[@AngelTheory-M]

this was so beautiful, there nothing i can think its wrong, but isn't complete, thanks to jackie and moon existence

[@enolopanr9820]

This video is hands down the best theory made after 10 years. Floored

[@kkotheracountnstuff]

This needs more views

[@MaxCtPe]

i like this a lot, great job

[@a7c7q7]

this is a holy shot we solved fnaf moment

[@Jubumby]

Bear of vengance being the vengful spirit seems so on the nose, dont know how people couldn't put that together

[@hathorthecow7146]

Holy crap I never thought of chica n her messenger bag being the graveyard hill. I kept being skeptical and then being presented with strong evidence. I'm not fully convinced on the first listen through but I sure am convinced to subscribe!

[@Ralseio]

Bruh this even works with candi bunny's theory that Dave was kidnapped and wasn't originally in the Afton family. Yet ANOTHER reason he would want to torment him in the afterlife.