This Might Be The Most Realistic FIFA Save Ever! - Rating Your Careers

I’ve now made over 500 youtube videos recommending FIFA career mode save ideas. I’ve posted a few series of my own, including one with Reims and two Megacareers, but today, we’re turning the tables. In our second FC24 episode I'll be looking at another six of your career modes, and i’ll be rating them based on how good I think they are!
All of the saves posted in today's video were posted on my Discord server, so if you’re interested in being in a future video, make sure you join with the link in the description below! Don't forget to play along and post your ratings in the comments below, so we can find the best save of all time.
Help support the channel
-- Become a Channel Member - / @geografifa
-- Stream Donations - streamelements.com/geografifa...
Follow my other Media!:
-- Check out my written guides - www.geografifa.com/
-- Discord - / discord --
-- Twitter - / geografifa --
-- Tiktok - / geografifa --
-- Subscribe - / @geografifa
-- Business Enquiries - [e-mail]
#easportsfc #careermode #fc24

[@martinsloan3972]

I have an idea for an ultimate ‘1 club’ save. You start with player career mode, playing for one club. It should be a club that’s within touching distance of domestic greatness, but never quite gets there, perhaps 2nd tier club. If it gets to the top flight, it never stays there for very long. You stick with the club through thick and thin, refusing all transfer moves, except maybe loan moves, but not too many. throughout the save. And you have to play the entire 15 season run, no matter what, even if you’re regularly played out of position. Because it’s all about loyalty for you. When you retire, you’re tasked with coaching the club in a new save, hopefully to more sustained success, but you don’t realise that the board are working against success on the pitch, whether deliberately or as a by product of what they’re really doing. Eventually, you either resign or are sacked. Maybe it takes the full 15 seasons, maybe it takes a lot less. After you leave, the club goes into administration and is saved, but is remodelled in a way that the fans despise. The fans create a phoenix club and are admitted to the lowest division in the league, and they hire you as the only person, because of your loyalty to the club and your love for it, who can hopefully take them to the top of domestic football, especially beating the original, but despised club, whenever you get the chance. This is played out over 3 saves, in player career mode, manager career mode with an authentic club, then a manager career mode with create-a-club, which would be based in the same town as the original club, but with a slightly different name. The intention is to become as good as or better than the original club.

[@trevorphilips5252]

Sounds great

[@charliehaycock6816]

Bro took us on a one way trip to yapperville💀💀

[@benficademacaufan]

This has to be one of the best save ideas I’ve ever heard, sadly I play fm so it would be hard to recreate but great idea!

[@avfcjosh]

saves end after 15 seasons tho

[@martinsloan3972]

@@avfcjosh yes, I appreciate that. Perhaps, instead of calling it a 1 club save, I should have referred to the idea as a series of saves with a 1 club theme.

[@JoeyKM_999]

best fifa/fc24 youtuber

[@Radomjakis]

Naahhhhhh i like him but naahhhh

[@blondedlens5462]

YNWA❤

[@frezinnn]

Frfr

[@illyrian44]

​@@Radomjakis idk man he's pretty good

[@CG_Gaming007]

as good as Geo is, Barfieboy clears

[@TylerDavis-tn3hd]

How about this for a save idea: Because of an unresolved old treaty between England and Scotland… Doncaster is technically still apart of Scotland. How about sending Doncaster to the Scottish league and doing a rebuild there I think they would just about be good enough to compete with the lesser teams in the cinch prem.

[@DanoFSmith-yc9tg]

I usually do a Canada only, USA only, or CanUsa only team build using a lower tear club. It really handicaps the amount of usable players to pick from, making manager career mode much more challenging, and progressing much slower. But still offers some top teir players if you do advance quickly enough, before they retire or decline, such as Davies, David, Pulisic, etc.

[@mauricioarsenio8229]

I managed to get Casa Pia AC a club that was formed back in the day for an orphanage to a treble by mainly scouting players from the area. It was pretty fun

[@rubengoncalves9479]

Graaaande

[@dounky7777]

bro your fifa videos are different level, so joyable!!♥

[@Shelmer75]

I really should’ve taken screenshots and footage of my Melbourne Victory save. Fully followed the A League salary cap and local player rules and everything haha. Ended up with Balotelli as a marquee signing…was a terrible signing, then got Michael Antonio which was much better

[@ItsJustTac]

Another great video Geo! Can't wait to see more saves!

[@MAXfutbol8338]

I swear you keep putting Juventus in your thumbnails solely for me looool nice video though!

[@ZacEditzzz16]

These are Definitely my favourite videos that you do 🐐

[@CanadianTheGreat1]

When you mentioned the thing about aigner my jaw DROPPED

[@humbertomartinez4085]

Sebastian Cordova is really goated.

[@AngelH546]

Funny thing is irl he really isnt

[@omararias3472]

@@AngelH546he is

[@bigbendycarrot9021]

I’m sick of constantly getting sacked near to the end of the season because we “didn’t win the league” when I’m 2nd, 3 points off with about 7 games to go? Makes no sense

[@Rxst_plug]

It’s unplunplayable without mods really

[@tectonicflame9519]

When you do a realistic career do you sim it all or play some?

[@everybodygotthegoodones]

Please do a spurs career mode, your my favourite football and Fifa based content creator

[@otsilejeremiah5431]

Bochum now Nantes, I'm really honoured

[@Schabikx]

on which serwer you put saves?

[@otsilejeremiah5431]

@@Schabikx Career mode review

[@tictaquess]

Bruh your videos are goated!!!

[@sebj4384]

Geografifa, what makes the realism level a 10/10?

[@tonicinto4807]

Bit of a dumb question but how does the Nantes save keep changing the kits every new season?

[@chaceharris132]

can anyone tell me how the person who made the fc nantes career mode kept changing the kit because i know how to change it if youve created a club but do not know how when you takeover a real club

[@superconnor1054]

Can you use old saves like fifa 14

[@giyutomioka8563]

Yo can i share my fifa 23 save? I didnt buy fc 24 cuase my friends said it was ass

[@imagoofygoober298]

has someone that has did a arminia biefield career mode it was fun af

[@EugenesBackpack]

i did a only east europe with dresden it wasnt too fun tbh

[@ralphsjets]

Bielefeld is my favourite career that i’ve done🙂

[@michalprzenzak2522]

when i try enter your site i have error "connection is not private" do you maybe know why?

[@tyernix]

It's because his licence expired. For your website to show that it is safe, you have to pay for a license every year, and he probably hasn't paid for it yet. The website is still safe though

[@fishfinger7145]

Next vid I'll enter my career mode is so good right now

[@linconrogers6839]

how do u enter- like where in the discord

[@fishfinger7145]

​@@linconrogers6839 career mode review

[@dekattenheld1442]

i made a save in the portugee league where i can only sign people who speak portugese and when thye reach 89 i have to sell them

[@Tunkt.mp7]

Bros got beef with Juve for no reason

[@Bigspange]

I recommend Docks

[@bat_d]

I don't have discord but here's my save (only one season) With Jurgen Klop leaving Liverpool I've decided to send him to Salernitana(italy) the First thing i did was changing the module to a 5 2 1 2 and i bough Ethan Mbappe (For the COC role) Andrea Cambiaso, Reyes (my only freeagent) and Radu Dragusin on a loan. On the first half of the Serie A somehow i was second for 1 point under Juventus (only played against Napoli) but eliminated in the coppa Italia by Cremonese in the end i finish 5th (first time in the club's history in europe) but my 2th best striker Antonio Cadreva retires with Fazio (I hate him) grade for now?

[@Bowser111]

You can loan in dragusin in the start of a new career?

[@bat_d]

I get It at the end of the market because Tottenham bought an another CB

[@Bowser111]

@@bat_d k makes sense haha

[@BastiWeber]

Save Idea Rating 8/10 Realism:0/10 Fun:6/10

[@nahomabera48]

Plz can everyone tell me how to change club kits (real life teams)

[@faisooli6626]

How did some people make new kits?? There are so many things in fc24 I need to know how to do

[@otsilejeremiah5431]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/f2anmXiEbJhmeMU

[@BALHAM69]

Hello and welcome to my new comment 😮 Arminia Bielefeld one was good 😅

[@user-ug9lw7vm6x]

Amaz

[@JacobSauers]

Lol such an EA thing to have the game sack you from your own created club. Love it

[@SW-kr9fl]

Can people stop saying play FM please? I want to play actual games not just sim matches

[@terrierkid1099]

UTT

[@Snakehad95]

So it is realistic to boost a low club like Nantes like shit, but unrealistic to create an own club with an own story, where things went more realistic, because it was only lead very well and didn't got boosted. Perfect example, why your rating and your judgement skills are only made for the bin!

[@ghost.8836]

If you really want realism just play FM

[@CesarBarca]

Wait a minute Cordoba isn't a free agent he is with Tigres, realism should be lower.

[@otsilejeremiah5431]

EAFC needs to update their squads file, he is still a free agent even now

[@MemesNick]

The league is not on EAFC so I would imagine he is in the game via the National Team but listed as a free agent because his club is not on the game

[@trevorphilips5252]

@@MemesNickVega deserves to be on fifa

[@MemesNick]

@@trevorphilips5252 from what I saw he was, but with recent updates to the Mexico NT squad he is no longer in game

[@trevorphilips5252]

@@MemesNick luckily I started all my saves allocations before December so I don’t get an update

[@flvme.]

Save 1: Realism: 8/10 Save Idea: 10/10 Fun: 7/10 Overall: 8.3 Save 2: Realism: 9/10 Save Idea: 7/10 Fun: 9/10 Overall: 8.3 Save 3 Realism: 9/10 Save Idea: 8/10 Fun: 6/10 Overall: 7/10 Save 4 Realism: 9/10 Save Idea: 7/10 Fun: 10/10 Overall: 8.6 Ranked: Best to worst 1. Save 4 2. Save 1 3. Save 2 4. Save 3

[@Vepkho2]

nerd

[@VoidTG]

Quit crying

[@AyleidCraft]

Lame

[@VoidTG]

Prob a 5 year old stop crying bruv

[@Tam-hn7hb]

Can you invite me to your dc server, the link doesn’t seem to work?

[@Tam-hn7hb]

I have this 100% realism format for my saves with requires a lot of administration and I’d love to share

[@Mohamed_salah2]

Austrians and Germans? They got a very good relationship 🫡🫵

[@nahomabera48]

Plz can everyone tell me how to change club kits (real life teams)

[@nahomabera48]

Plz can everyone tell me how to change club kits (real life teams)

[@otsilejeremiah5431]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/f2anmXiEbJhmeMU