THOMAS THE TANK ENGINE MOVIES RANKED (OUTDATED)

[@thecartoonmanist956]

Timemarks on the reviews: 1:30 Thomas and the Magic Railroad 3:08 Misty Island Rescue 5:47 Big World! Big Adventures! 8:27 Day of the Diesels 10:06 Calling All Engines! 11:12 The Great Race 12:13 Journey Beyond Sodor 14:06 King of the Railway 16:03 The Great Discovery 17:32 The Adventure Begins 19:28 Hero of the Rails 21:10 Tale of the Brave 22:41 Blue Mountain Mystery 24:57 Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure

[@EssexAggiegrad2011]

Thanks

[@joshuatewolde1837]

I believe the Thomas and the magic railroad with done a complete and total success in the box office, if they just stick to the directors cut.

[@luizhenriquesouzasilva970]

I Love the Thomas and the magic railroad

[@pukenmg284]

​@@luizhenriquesouzasilva970He doesn't say that he hate it anyway just don't know where to put it

[@edwardo6834]

I’m glad that I grew up watching the Magic Railroad, Calling all Engines, The Great Discovery Etc

[@ironhorsehistorian9871]

Funny story about me and the Great Discovery. So here goes: I used to have a blockbuster by a Jack in the Box less than 10 minutes away from home. Me, my mom, and my brother were their and I think it was right before blockbuster started liquidation. I visibly remember grabbing 2 films, the first How To Train Your Dragon and Thomas and the Great Discovery. The kicker, I could only take one home. While I’m happy I choose HTTYD, save a version of the film made with Hornby on KZbin, I’m pretty sure I haven’t seen Great Discovery in almost 11 years. A small part of me still misses Great Discovery. The former blockbuster is now a bank. Maybe one day for posterity, I’ll track down a copy of Great Discovery. It’d make my 7 year old self happy.

[@KaylynnFoster-xg9my]

Same, the new reboots are the scariest things alive

[@josesegura3669]

The worst crap of all Thomas's story: Big World, Big Adventures. The best of the best: Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure.

[@Mediafanboy]

I don’t know if it’s for nostalgia purposes as great discovery was the first Thomas film I watched because it came out when I was 2 but that’s my favorite Thomas film great discovery I used to watch it everyday as a wee lad

[@bluraynation5188]

I’m so glad I found this channel. You have a similar delivery to I Hate Everything but you’re also a huge Thomas fanboy. It’s amazing how many passionate Thomas fans there are on KZbin. Cheers!

[@Quinnifer]

Ending off the video with I Know How The Moon Must Feel was touching.

[@rayvenkman2087]

Someone should have pulled Britt aside when creating the Tragic Failroad and tell her that the story’s script makes little sense.

[@ianschwartz08]

@Joshua W56 what do those acronyms mean

[@dannythehipster5644]

@@ianschwartz08 Four Little Engines, A Bad Day for Sir Handel, and The Missing Coach.

[@MickeyMousePlushShow1928]

Blue Mountain Mystery is better than Sodor’s Legend Of The Lost Treasure in my opinion. Blue Mountain Mystery feels more like an actual Thomas And Friends movie, Sodor’s Legend Of The Lost Treasure feels more like an action film.

[@guilhermerossi807]

Great video, well done! One of my favourite movies is "The Great discovery" I love the movie and I don't know why people don't talk about it that much. Great Waterton is the best, I wish that it came back. The adventure scenes, like Thomas in the mine, are really fun, just like the songs! Stanley doesn't have much character like you said but his design is cool. But the narration is...you know 🚂🚃🚃🚃🚃 But unlike many fans I don't really like "Hero of the rails"

[@ek9509]

16:58: Oh, no, no, no, no, no. Thomas, You’re the Leader is THE best Thomas song I have ever heard.

[@thomaspanditfan2435]

Hearing your thoughts on TAB, I am really interested to hear why you think season 1 is better. If there are many reasons for that, I would love to see you make a video comparing The Adventure Begins with Season 1.

[@stopmotionartist4987]

Honestly, I think what makes S1 better is that it doesn’t have to deal with being one long continuous story. That way each episode can properly build up to an event. Edward and Gordon’s retelling was alright but it had weak build up, The Sad Story of Henry’s retelling is largely cut out and does a bad job of representing Henry imo, and Thomas and Gordon’s retelling feels more mean spirited since later in the movie we see consequences for Edward that were not in S1 so the film could’ve given consequences to Gordon. I think Thomas’s Train retelling is better and the breakdown episode’s retelling was on par with S1 imo

[@eddiethefriendlytenderengine]

9:15 That’s actually a quite biased point. Percy had nothing against Belle and Flynn, it was the fact that Thomas was ignoring him. Remember when Thomas first met Stanley? Percy did not at all treat Belle and Flynn like how Thomas treated Stanley. The biggest supporter of this point is when Percy sees Flynn in his berth at Tidmouth Sheds. He looks as if he’s on the verge of crying, but Thomas doesn’t give a sh*t, all he says is “Where have you been, Percy?” To sum it up, Thomas was more in the wrong than Percy was.

[@justsplotch]

Thomas was a dick to Percy. He treated him like he was just a normal engine. Thomas sucks balls..

[@SrMechaGojira93]

#14 - BWBA (one of my most *personal* hated films of all time!) #13 - TATMR #12 - TGR #11 - MIR #10 - DOTD #9 - JBS #8 - CAE #7 - HOTR #6 - KOTR #5 - TGD #4 - BMM #3 - SLOTLT #2 - TOTB (criminally *underrated!)* #1 - TAB

[@AbrahamBenno]

Finally someone who appreciates HotR and BMM.

[@liambiniares3182]

The Adventure Begins is probably my favourite mainly for Nostalgia Value. But obectively, Lost Treasure is definitely the most cinematic.

[@wil4540]

I really liked the great discovery, king of the railway, the adventure begins, sodors legend of the lost treasure and hero of the rails. My favorite character in sodors legend of the lost treasure is Ryan

[@vanessacelebry2183]

My Six Favorite Movies Winner Scole Places : First Place : Tell Of The Brave Second Place : King Of The Railway Third Place : Blue Mountain Mystery Fourth Place : Hero Of The Rails Fifth Place : Misty Island Rescue Sixth Place : Day Of The Diesels

[@SgtAJ218]

Honestly, I don't know to feel about Thomas and the Magic Railroad. I kind of like it but it does have a lot of issues. Back then if you asked me how I would’ve ranked it, It would’ve been in the top 5 or at the bottom. But it lands somewhere in the middle for me because of all the Thomas stuff and the fact that this was made by people who really cared about Thomas, unlike Big World Big Adventures, Misty Island Rescue, or Day of the Diesels. Also, I don't think this film killed Thomas. What I mean by this is TATMR changed the show forever, that is a fact, but the show was still alive after this and it still was Thomas. What really killed Thomas was Mattel's lack of internal communication and failure to market the brand properly. Combined with Big World Big Adventures that pretty much sealed Thomas' fate. Basically, to put it in Titanic terms, Britt Allcroft may have been the one who built the Thomas Ship, but it was Mattel who caused the ship to hit the iceberg. And BWBA was the ship splitting in half. Lastly, while I may not agree with her direction for TATMR, I still forgive Britt Allcroft because she cared about Thomas as much as Wibert Awadry and the fans did, and still do to this day. And that's something I can't imagine anyone saying about the CEOs of Mattel.

[@amberthesobbleproductions6019]

Good video but for The Adventure Begins you accidentally put 8 instead of 5

[@TonsOfTrackmasters]

Great video!! 10/10 Editing right on point!

[@bengillis2011YT]

I can’t make up my mind what The Best Movie Is Bc To Me Sodor Legend Of The Treasure And The Adventure Begins Are PERFECT

[@samking7955]

My Ranking: #1 Sodar Legend of the Lost Treasure #2 Blue Mountain Mystery #3 The Adventure Begins #4 The Great Discovery #5 Tale of the Brave #6 King of the Railway #7 Day of the Diesels #8 Big World Big Adventure #9 The Great Race #10 Misty Island Rescue #11 The Magic Railway #12 Journey Beyond Sodar #13 Hero of the Rails #14 Race for the Sodar Cup #15 Calling All Engines

[@littlewestern0969]

I couldn’t agree more with this list. Although Journey Beyond Sodor is my favourite, lost treasure is still one of my favourite films of all time. Great job on the video👍

[@thekidthatknowstomuch372]

Nice list dude but this is how I would rate the movies 14. Big world big adventures 13. Thomas and the magic railroad 12. Day of the diesels 11. Misty island rescue 10. Calling all engines 9. The great race 8. Journey beyond sodor 7. Hiro of the rails 6. The great Discovery 5. King of the railway 4. Blue mountain mystery 3. Tale of the brave 2. The adventure begins 1. Slotlt

[@highoctanegames]

I'm sorry, Thomas and the Magic Railroad and Misty Island Rescue was my childhood, sorry I'm ranking it way higher

[@joshk.2731]

The adventure begins is definitely better than Hero of the rails

[@darthzannah8900]

My List: 14. Misty Island Rescue 13. BWBA 12. Thomas and the magic Railroad 11. Day of the Diesels 10. King of the Railway 9. Calling all Engines/The great Race 8. The great Race/Calling all Engines 7. Journey Beyond Sodor 6. Hero of the Rails 5. Tale of the Brave 4. The Great Discovery 3. The Adventure Begins 2. Sodors Legend of the lost Treasure/Blue Mountain Mystery 1. Sodors Legend of the lost Treasure/Blue Mountain Mystery

[@therealyoshi375]

Here's my list 14:MIR 13:CAE 12:BWBA 11:TGD 10:TGR 9:SLOTLT 8:TATMR 7:DOTD 6:KOTR 5:JBS 4:HOTR 3:TOTB 2:TAB 1:BMM I like all of these movies though just saying which is the best to the least best

[@awesomeraf7851]

Are you copying the unlucky tug?

[@brendalenderman4876]

My List #14 Misty Island Rescue #13 Day Of The Diesels #12 Calling All Engines #11 The Great Race #10 Thomas and The Magic Railroad #9 King Of The Railway #8 Big World Big Adventures #7 The Great Discovery #6 Journey Behond Sodor #5 Hero Of The Rails #4 The Adventure Begins #3 Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure #2 Blue Mountain Mystery #1 Tale Of The Brave

[@buzzytrombone4353]

I personally felt that Tale of the Brave was better than SLOTLT because of how Thomas was more mature in it compared to the aforementioned film. SLOTLT would have fully won me over if the tension and falling out between him and The Fat Controller was brought on by an argument about Thomas overworking himself on his branch line and being too dedicated for his own good, briefly replacing him with Ryan to show him that he can’t take all the credit, with this pissing Thomas off and making him work at the quarry. Also building on Percy’s development from Tale of the Brave would have been nice, dealing with some repressed trauma from series 5 during the dynamite explosion and maybe the chase.

[@janko7778]

14-Misty Island Rescue 13-Big World, Big Adventures 12-Journey Beyond Sodor 11-Thomas and the Magic Railroad 10-The Great Race 9-King of the Railway 8-Hero of the Rails 7-Tale of the Brave 6-Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure 5-The Great Discovery 4-Blue Mountain Mystery 3-The Adventure Begins 2-Day of the Diesels 1-Calling All Engines

[@phantom5757]

Good video. Just some thoughts I've had is with the Sharon Miller movies angleis was back to his classic series style of narration. A quick question is what other Thomas stuff will you be ranking eg narration or seasons dubs? anyway good work

[@stuartbarclay7940]

My opinions and rankings: Thomas & The Magic Railroad (Number one favourite!) 10/10 Calling All Engines! (Nostalgic film, despise Diesel 10 as a good guy) 8.5/10 The Great Discovery (Awesome model series finale!) 10/10 Hero of The Rails (Rather great movie) 9/10 Misty Island Rescue (On the levels of bad, meh and decent) 6/10 Days of The Diesel (Guilty Pleasure) 7/10 Blue Mountain Mystery (Cool movie) 9/10 King of The Railway (Awesome start to the Brenner-Era) 10/10 Tale of the Brave (Great film) 9/10 The Adventure Begins (Amazing film!) 10/10 Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (Great Movie, Bad Topham) 8/10 The Great Race (Underrated film) 10/10 Journey Beyond Sodor (Great series finale movie despise the rushed ending) 9.5/10 Big World! Big Adventures! (So bad that it's not even funny...) 4/10 My Top Five Favourite Movies: 5. King of the Railway 4. The Adventure Begins 3. The Great Discovery 2. The Great Race 1. Thomas & the Magic Railroad

[@ajchristenson13]

It was ok the only problem with big world adventure that they replace Henry and Edward with Nia and Rebecca

[@asafjuarez1]

Yeah and going around the world as well

[@Sleepingguitah]

My favorite and what I consider the best is different for me. The best Thomas film is Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure but my favorite is The Great Discovery. Oh and you are 100% correct by saying hero of the rails is underrated.

[@liamconnollyst]

My Ranking: 14: Misty Island Rescue 13: Day of the Diesels 12: Big World! Big Adventures! 11: Thomas and the Magic Railroad/Tragic Failroad 10: Calling All Engines 9: The Great Race 8: Journey Beyond Sodor 7: The Great Discovery 6: King of the Railway 5: Hero of the Rails 4: Tale of the Brave 3: Blue Mountain Mystery 2: Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure 1: The Adventure Begins

[@thecartoonmanist956]

I love every Thomas movie! They are all nostalgic!

[@williambarnett8566]

How do you do like misty island rescue

[@Percy6]

@@williambarnett8566 Opinions exist.

[@T.Cwilson.Gunadi]

@@williambarnett8566 why not ? It's not that bad

[@s.a.8804]

Even BWBA?!

[@yuhaszvideotime763]

I agree with the cartoon Manist. My favorite is Calling All Engines.

[@frankgraham5211]

Just like you when I first watched The Adventure Begins, I thought it was pretty good. However I did prefer season 1

[@ryanfuller912]

There’s actually something that bugs me about the CGI movies. It’s that I wish there was a more gap of time between them and the season. You know like Magic Railroad came and then came 6 7 8 came and then Calling All Engine, uh something like that.

[@realchristian77010]

I liked TATMR, Misty Island Rescue, Day of The Diesels, Calling All Engines, and The Great Discovery for some reason, maybe because that movies was one of my sweet memories. But it would have been more times better if Splatter, Dodge, and Dennis could have been of Day of The Diesels..

[@tj_-vf7rw]

Sodors Legend of the Lost Treasure is my favorite Thomas Movie of All time

[@CivilisedThwomp]

Heres how i would rewrite day of the diesels: A: belle and flynn are really overconfident and proud. This gives percy a reason to be angry with thomas because hes spending all his time with them. B. Make percy end up in the dieselworks in a much more threatening way. Like den and dart pushing him in while hes pulling the mail at night. The diesels then force percy to create a huge accident at the steamworks. (The moral in this plot will be to tell someone if somethings wrong, as percy will be too scared to.) After percy causes an accident, the other engines get very angry, but then someone sees huge clouds of grey smoke coming from the diesels. C. The confrontation has something of a standoff feel. Then the tension is broken by diesel 10 using his claw to rip the funnel of someone of tobys roof off. This causes the engines to huff away asap. D. A fire breaks out after engineers attempt to start paxton but fail, igniting some sparks that set the dieselworks alight. The diesels eventually see this, and blame diesel 10, because they could have seen it sooner if it werent for his stupid plan. E. Flynn and belle are called out, and they proclaim their importantness along the way, and now thomas sees why percy didnt like them. However, they fail to put the fire out. Just as the building is going to collapse, diesel 10 reappears, gets paxton down and gets him out just in time, in a redeeming act. F. In a sombre scene, the diesels look at what has happened, and almost give up. Then however, when everything looks hopeless, a barrage of metal and bolts and everything else come to repair the dieselworks. The dieselworks is saved and Finally, the end. Your only gonna read this part

[@Joey15811]

I like lost treasure finally got Duck/Oliver/Donald/Douglas into a movie. So many smaller characters had appeared in others before yet they never did other than duck/Oliver got a couple cameos in the 2 beforehand. The GW engines are my 2 favourites characters

[@katebobperskypants2330]

I like TATMR as well, despite that it ‘killed’ Thomas, I love the Sodor sets.

[@pogo4739]

I remember getting The Great Discovery for christmas one year and I absolutely loved that film, definitely one of if not my favorite. I’m a little bummed Stanley didn’t get much character though because his design is beautiful in my opinion

[@JamesIsHere5]

That was amazing!

[@Thomasfan261]

Thank you very much mate! This is definitely one of my favourite videos I’ve made (:

[@arcadejaguar409]

I actually wish they did more with Stanley. Judging by his role in The Great Discovery; it looked like they had big plans for the character but they just ended up tossing him to the side. It could have been a new genuine rival for Thomas in the same way Spencer was for Gordon. It's too bad he wasn't given much of a character in his only big appearance. I would have made it so that it would take more than just that special to make Thomas truly respect Stanley, and I would write Stanley to act more like a rival. Or at least; a friendly rival. I'd love to see some episodes where they both try to one-up each other. Putting the number one tank engine up against someone who is better and more modern than he is sounds like an interesting concept, and I'm sure a competence writer would be able to write a bunch of interesting episodes based off of that concept.

[@Tugsboi47]

Well originally Stanley was gonna have a Main role in hero of the rajls

[@joshuadunn3198]

Excellent work and keep up the amazing work.

[@StoneTankEngine]

Great work Sean, a very long video but it was worth the watch although i disagree with some of your placements i respect them none the less

[@tre-engines]

The Great Discovery is my favorite Thomas movie! The narration is PERFECT and all the engines are in character!

[@legofan6595]

Good video. I like the Despicable Me 3 sentence for the Great Race.

[@renefigueroa6309]

I find it ironic that you say the voice cast is trash for TATMR but say Eddie Glen is one of the best Thomas voices

[@ThomastheGOAT1975]

yeah eddie glen is actually an excellent voice for thomas, long with gordons voice actor. the voices I do have a grudge with, are James' and Percy's as they both sound like girls

[@gamecubeboy9708]

I got a history lesson about my Thomas experience. As far as I can remember I’ve been collecting Thomas merch and DVDS I especially loved the classic Seasons I even watched the boring HiT era. Until 2011 I realized how shit the show became because of the Nitrogen Era even in 2010 I noticed that episodes were worse and I don’t even remember. Pop Goes Thomas was the dvd that made me quit the show and not come back to until Blue Mountain Mystery. Then I quit it again when The Great Race dropped. And now I’m back to watching Classic Thomas episodes. When I rewatched the Classic Series and the Brenner Era. I will always appreciate Sodor’s Legend Og The Lost Treasure for recapturing the Magic of why I loved this franchise

[@alfiebassett5658]

here's my ranking of the thomas movies 14 misty island rescue 13 big world big adventures 12 day of the disels 11 calling all engines 10 thomas the magic railroad 9 the great race 8 king of the railway 7 journey beyond sodor 6 the great discovery 5 blue mountain mystery 4 hero of the rails 3 tale of the brave 2 the adventure begins 1 sodor's legend of the lost treasure

[@Godeesg0editzplays]

Fun Fact: is the TATMR sky similar to the sky from season 12?

[@metalkidleo]

A thing I love about The Adventure Begins is Edward, he was like a guide, a mentor to Thomas, and also I just love green Thomas

[@nixienooo]

I genuinely love TOB, it’s a great movie but you can’t convince me that Percy and Gator definitely had some chemistry going on. Also SLOLT is just plain gorgeous, the only problem I have with it is the “Thomas gets mad/jealous at new engine” trope

[@21.tenzinsugata3]

Everyone.......i like misty island rescue :)

[@lukeslocomotives]

Big World Big Adventures Movie has a dark message behind it: it's ok to go somewhere without telling anyone. Anyone else think so?

[@lukeslocomotives]

And also Ace is a stranger to thomas, and thomas toodles off with him, implying to children it ok to go off with strangers

[@kylethedestroyer1117]

bwba has a dark message behind it? Wtf

[@ps7372]

I’m sorry but I hate the UK version of CGI Thomas, the characters just sounded so weird

[@reevemicallef]

18:27 18:23 18:19 7:09

[@jaxsterminator8634]

Personally, I thought BWBA killed Thomas, because I loved 6-12, and I thought 13-BWBA was alright at best.

[@arvidekelund9451]

I love BWBA

[@stopmotionartist4987]

This is the hottest take I’ll ever give: SLOTLT is alright, but it has wasted potential. Thomas is alright, but having him shift to blame to others feels really odd given just how in the past Thomas owns up or is aware of what he did. Thomas’ pairing with Sailor John was alright, but it felt too short and undeveloped. I didn’t really believe Thomas would be conflicted and it felt like so much more could’ve been done with them. The miniature engines and Ryan are alright, but I was kinda disappointed at the “Thomas gets jealous” cliche being used again and not as well as previous material, and Marion’s subplot was okay. Overall, it’s pretty good but it needed a lot more time to develop character relationships and it’s plot. I think the only films that work with its timing and feel more narratively satisfying are The Adventure Begins and Tale of the Brave

[@JoshProductions07]

This is still amazing though

[@thecartoonmanist956]

1:18 "These pieces of dog sh*t." XD 2:07 "Shut up! Just shut up, you idiot." XD 3:14 Well, I don't think it's bad. 6:00 My eyes!

[@ScrapyardStudios]

What app did you use for Thomas’ moving eyes in the intro?

[@JerrytheVideoGamer257]

6:53 STOP BEING SO MEAN TO JOSEPH MAY!😡

[@dariogonzalez5536]

My rankings 14. Thomas and the Magic Railroad 13.Big World! Big Adventures! 12.Misty Island Rescue 11. The Great Race 10. Day of the Diesels 9.Journey Beyond Sodors 👇. THE GOOD STUFF HERE 8.King of the Railway 7. Blue Mountain Mystery 6.Tale of the Brave 5.Hero of the Rails 4.The Adventure Begins 3.Calling All Engines 2.Sodors Legend of the Lost Tresure 1.The Great Discovery

[@tobyno7tramengine267]

My Top 14 Favorite Thomas & Friends Movies Special (Worst To Best) 1. T&F - Blue Mountains Mystery (2012) 2. T&F - Sodor Legend of The Lost Treasure (2015) 3. T&F - The Adventure Begins (2015) 4. T&F - Tale of The Brave (2014) 5. T&F - The Great Discovery (2008) 6. T&F - Hero Of The Rails (2009) 7. T&F - King Of The Railway (2013) 8. T&F - Journey Beyond Sodor (2017) 9. T&F - The Great Race (2016) 10. Thomas And The Magic Railroad/Railway (2000) 11. T&F - Calling All Engines!(2005) 12. T&F - Big World Big Adventure (2018) 13. T&F - Day Of The Diesels (2011) 14. T&F - Misty Island Rescue (2010) Only Best Part in This Movie is Diesel 10 The End of Song Credit Scene

[@ThomastheGOAT1975]

Interesting. Here's my rankings: MIR: fuck off G tier for GET IN THE GODAMN BIN DOTD: 0/10 a snorefest in movie form and Percy is an idiot Bwubah: 0.5/10 really crap and jesus christ why is the bouncing so tuned up compared to JBS CAE: 1.9/10 What an absolute CHORE to sit through TGR: 4.3/10 pretty boring but not as boring is the one above JBS/TATMR: 5/10 (JBS) this one is not bad, or good, its just there. (TATMR). ridiculously convoluted KOTR: 6/10 needed serious improvements but a brilliant way to start the Brenner era TGD: 7/10 while also having glaring problems, it is a fantastic way to send off the model era HOTR: 8/10 really good and horrifyingly underrated TAB: 9/10 apart from the mess-up with Henry, this one was ASTOUNDING TOTB: 9.5/10 A gem that is also a bit emotional at parts BMM: 9.7/10 Holy moly! For something that came in the Miller era, this was a great breath of fresh air SLOTLT: 10/10 Like you said, the closet thing to a theatrical film. the definitive G.O.A.T

[@gordonfangirl5185]

I feeling Day of The Diesel could be put in one episode

[@samsthebeztatstuff8885]

The only Thomas movie I truly hate is bwba because it’s even your childish and stupid than teen Titans go and it’s concept is done even worse than the great race

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

Well, the diesel antagonists have to resume their bad behavior in the show, even after Day of the Diesels. Part of continuing the rivalry which is part of the show and all.

[@PopsukFun]

6:00- 6:01 season 12 Thomas: smiles in a ridiculous way Thomasfan261: MY EYES!!!!!!

[@nicolasrubio8614]

6:00 what epsiode is that from?

[@colewatson4830]

Saved You!

[@miew6481]

27:34 Music name please I LOVE IT!!

[@s.a.8804]

I know how the moon must feel

[@jacobmussell7252]

Thomas and the magic railroad is my favourite thomas film

[@Mai_Su]

JBS Studio made a sodor journey beyond sodor how it shoulve been, it was good but... WE NEED A MISTY ISLAND RESCUE HOW IT SHOULDVE BEEN

[@dannythehipster5644]

So excited!

[@AdamStanleyCena]

6:17 , I saw it in cinemas and Legend of the lost treasure in 2015, the day it came out. (I find sodor's legend of the treasure the best movie of thomas)

[@jordenfilmz]

This was good!

[@KTRASAMFSTUDIOS]

16:02 W E L C O M E S T A N L Y

[@thejjshow4876]

I grew up with misty island rescue and say of the diesels why did I like these 😢

[@EtBEF_02]

1:55 That was when he knew, he was laughing (Edit) 3:15 This was from what I recall the first time Thomas did the “bouncing” on the screen

[@EtBEF_02]

I’m serious that was so funny I’m dying

[@memeking_5557]

2:24 Magic railroad is my childhood to

[@thecartoonmanist956]

17:32 Mistake: you accidentally kept the number 8 instead of putting a number 5.

[@angus80w]

6:42 I prefer the US version of that song

[@svsmodelling2857]

Why did the Adventure begins say 8 and then the next is 4? Anyway I agree with a lot of it and I’m very surprised how low you put TAB

[@ALekToRemember]

I thought big world big adventure is the worst

[@omnimonramone8459]

I just watched Calling All Engines and I thought it was okay. I'd put it higher on a list simply because I prefer the models over cgi.

[@joshk.2731]

Blue Mountain mystery gets way too much credit, its not that good

[@johnwright5610]

🤮 misty island rescue 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

[@spitefulvix7237]

For the most part, I agree with you! Lovely video!

[@jaydenmcglothin5111]

Bro the draft Version of a Special Day is my 2nd favorite Thomas song Streamlining is my # 1 and u can’t say no to that, it’s too catchy

[@deadsince2023]

Error: The Adventure Begins Was Number 5, Yet I Says Number 8

[@thomasfanthetrainman4152]

We’ll now wait a minute the royal Engine movie is pretty good

[@minecraftnickelodeonstudio774]

Thomas and the magic railroad is my favorite childhood memory movie of whole time

[@JustinStudiosYT]

I love TATMR

[@nicolasrubio9122]

Some Else who likes Tale Of The Brave. Finally!

[@coolalien8139]

To be honest, it's hard to rank all the movies. But, I would put Tale Of The Brave at the bottom of my ranking, and put The Great Discovery at the top of my ranking. I love Thomas and the Magic Railroad because it was one of my childhood movies, it was released in the U. S. the day before I was born, and I'll always enjoy it throughout my life. I know it's not the best one, but I still like it. I don't dislike Calling All Engines, but it's not my favorite Thomas movie. It's not a masterpiece, but it's not awful either. Remember, it's my opinion.

[@eliseorossiproductions6348]

Even Though BWBA wasn't Really the Best Thomas Movie, I Thought The Mine Crash Scene was Kinda Funny, My Favourite Films are TGD, SLOTLT, JBS, HOTR, TOTB, KOTR and BMQ

[@luizhenriquesouzasilva970]

I Love the Mistery Island Rescue