We've Just Found a New Type of Star and It's Terrifying

[@michaelkalal8735]

Before it gets renamed: We've just found a new type of star and it's terrifying

[@georgflermoen7430]

lol

[@SAMIAMFNX]

fr

[@bartterp88]

Get a life

[@Discount_Friendly]

43 minutes in and it's still called that

[@MrKanibaal]

Thanks, needed this. Only noticed later on that all the titles changed an hour or two later from release.

[@kxra999]

0:12 - "..MUSED upon supermassive black holes" hahah that was a good one

[@himwiththehair8118]

I thought I was the only one ancient enough to get that reference 😂

[@Al8minium]

@@himwiththehair8118 You must be older than me(63), that went straight over my head.😕

[@AdamEarl2]

@@Al8miniumwhoosh

[@jessestaggs2136]

Glad I'm not the only one who caught that!

[@resurrection1174]

For those wondering Muse is a band that made the song "supermassive black hole" they got a lot of good music you should look it up.

[@polygonalmasonary]

Another unexplained black hole is our Government’s use of our tax money 🤔🇬🇧🙏♥️

[@code.design]

I am positive you have been following England right? I am sure you know of William the Conqueror in the Norman dynasty? So next time you wave your flag, understand *that* is your black hole.

[@sevenstars004]

"Black" or secret projects. A government isn't going to put, "black projects" or "black operations" in the budget or list them in expenses, they get buried. That's why people find things like $50k hammers or £30k screwdrivers. Or it was just embezzled. Simple 🙂

[@dmo848]

I jus wanna know where the road money goes🤷 or toll booths. Where is that money

[@areaxisthegurkha]

Not in your country though 😂

[@eelcostuy4641]

It seems like for every problem we encounter in space scientists are like : "Ah! Dark Matter" 😅

[@Ancientreapers]

Or a bunch of strings

[@Makem12]

It really does feel like a cop out some days

[@KevTechNewb]

Same with "Nano technology" in movies?

[@vampr20ranger]

It once was thought it must be God. When scientist would reach a point they can't figure out. I assume we'll figure it out before 2050... Least I hope.

[@williammatthews7735]

​@@vampr20ranger don't hold your breathe, humans only have 5 senses as the basis to understand existence

[@djt08031996]

4:46 to skip the sponsor read

[@gifzilla1818]

Lmao found this while scrolling perfect timing thanks

[@dimelifetwon8736]

Thanks

[@stephenbeck6410]

So basically, we really don’t know squat about the universe.

[@oddsavage]

Yep. We really don't know much beyond apples and gravity. Ask a quantum physicist what we know about the quantum world, they'll tell you we know very little. We might know what we don't know, which is a great start, but we truly, honestly, and demonstrably know very little in regards.to the very big and the very little.

[@ValidatingUsername]

I do, but I wouldn’t solve Nobel prize worthy shit for my undergrad or a phd to be able to claim an appeal to authority; but they might just give me an honorary degree yet 🥱🧐🤣

[@RealKlausSchwab]

Exactly. We just be guessing yo.

[@amylarson3958]

Pretty much

[@righty-o3585]

We are learning new information about the universe by leaps and bounds , though relatively we know very little . We know a lot more than we did just a few decades ago .

[@MalikBarrow16]

"This idea, while still speculative" is a far cry from "found a new type of star"

[@johnopalko5223]

Yeah, and I don't know why they would be "terrifying" anyway.

[@jimmcdougall9973]

Science is speculative.

[@Makem12]

​@@jimmcdougall9973Science fundamentally is observational. It grinds my gears when people don't actually understand what science and the scientific method are.

[@jimmcdougall9973]

@@Makem12 I work for NASA. All theories are speculative, irrespective of the “facts” used to back them up. As it happens, many “sound” theories cannot be tested.

[@VestedUTuber]

@@jimmcdougall9973 Replace that last "theory" in your comment with "hypothesis". By definition a theory must be tested in some way, if it hasn't it's a hypothesis.

[@MultiSteveB]

0:28 "Their unfathomable gravitational pull literally holds galaxies together." Um, no. The two masses can have a correlation, but the galaxy almost always outweighs the central SMB (in the Milky Way) by a large factor. The SMB Sagittarius A* being only 0.00037 *percent* of the Milky Way's total mass.

[@Makem12]

I'm still undecided on whether Dark Matter truly exists or not. Dark matter has never been observed. There is strong evidence for it to account for gravitational observations, but we could just need better equations for gravity on galaxy wide scales. It makes sense to me for it to exist, but without observing it, I don't like just assuming it exists.

[@darthsilversith667]

Kind of like the “modern audience” and Hollyweird lol

[@Axiomatic75]

Dark Matter and Dark Energy is just physicists way of saying they have no clue what's going on.

[@hbhkennel918]

I thought that there was a new theory of an electric universe instead of gravity holding the universe together electrical force is the glue.

[@seriousbutfunny2]

When all else fails blame it on the "black guy." LOL 🤣🤣🤣

[@solacedagony1234]

Dark matter is a placeholder description for a problem that hasn't been solved yet.

[@coderttpo2]

0:29 - Black holes do NOT hold galaxies together. Even if a black hole is one billion solar masses, the Milky Way galaxy (and many others) have an average of one trillion stars across 100,000 light years. No black hole that we know of actually keeps more than a few stars in orbit around it, and certainly not anywhere near a whole galaxy. The reason a galaxy appears to rotate about is center is because the center is so densely packed with celestial object, the galaxy's center of gravity is very close to the center of the galaxy. The individual objects in each galaxy revolve around the center of gravity of the system.

[@thefacelessone74]

yeah they do its like a chain reaction... ( ( ( ( ) ) ) )

[@b3n5-ck7fs]

@@thefacelessone74 no...although also kind of yes...depending on what you mean exactly...the galaxy is held together by the cumulative effect of all the mass within it, with the black hole happening to be at the center of that mass, likely forming due to the high density of matter

[@fuffoon]

Maybe. But I appreciate your confidence.

[@pi3man252]

​@b3n5-ck7fs supermassive blackholes are the central mass. That's just a fact. How much their gravity holds the galaxy together idk the math on that man it's probably not even accurate.

[@hogandromgool2062]

@@b3n5-ck7fs indeed, that's what they said. the initial starts are held in place by the black hole. The overall gravitational affect is brought about by the slow collection of stellar objects and the mass those onjects add to the whole system rather than the black hole being the gravitational center.

[@VoiceOfTheEmperor]

Let's call it "Death Star-Class Star", maybe?

[@RealKlausSchwab]

I'm down with that.

[@Bootchair]

Yngwie class star. Black Star solo. I’ll see myself out

[@scottishcelts2040]

Agreed 👍

[@bertram-raven]

The problem is the name will not stand the test of time. Black Hole -> Massive BH -> Super Massive BH -> Hyper Massive BH -> Chuck Norris BH.

[@parsoniareigns]

Well, we do you that it's no moon..😂

[@johnopalko5223]

"When WIMPs Collide" could be the title of a 1950s science fiction movie.

[@tinkerstrade3553]

Or a news story of two nerd gangs in Silicone Valley about to pull slide rules on each other.🤣

[@tjwadsworth6967]

Or the name of a hit song from a powerman 5000 cover band

[@hobowithawaterpistol9070]

“Willie the wimp and his Cadillac coffin!”

[@kevincockburn2228]

Or to illustrate the difference of "When Two Tribes Go To War"

[@Dark78Sabre]

There's a problem with your train of thought ... Thoughty2. The reason that exceptionally large stars will collapse down into black holes is because the accumulation of iron building up in the cores of these large stars also build up gravitational force inside the core. For those who are not big into astrophysics every fusion reaction upto iron produces more energy than the reaction consumes. When you try to fuse iron it takes energy from the system so it's basically the end of the line as far as star fusion goes. Now as the core gets larger and larger it will eventually reach a point where the gravity of the core exceeds two specific pressure points. If the gravitational force exceeds electron degeneracy pressure then the electrons of atoms get forced into the nucleus and you end up with a neutron star. However, if the gravitational force builds fast enough and it also exceeds neutron degeneracy pressure then the neutrons in the core get ripped apart and the entire thing collapses down into a black hole. In your example of dark stars undergoing WIMP annihilation there is energy produced but there isn't a concentration of mass. So the is no gravitational build up. So a black hole won't form because there isn't a way for matter (or dark matter) to exceed neutron degeneracy pressure and collapse. I don't argue that dark stars couldn't exist. I'm just saying that the mechanism you described isn't going to compress matter to the point it will collapse down on itself. So if these 'dark stars' behave according to how you describe them then they are not the source of supermassive black holes.

[@robertbihn3005]

you have the best description, but I'm no expert

[@Lord.alucarD]

He is no scientist, making these types of videos with scraps in terms of knowledge, just for money.

[@chchchahahah]

When I fart it forces neutrons into electrons and sparks like lightning ⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡

[@h.h.c466]

so the annihilation is not generating anything that could count towards building mass? .. really wimpy..

[@iRossco]

Q. Re gas cloud collapse, the video stated that for the gas cloud to collapse it needed to cool, this struck me as odd. Surely, yes to a point a cooling gas will 'collapse' until gravity takes over & then on it's collapsing it's getting hotter due to being compressed & friction. I also don't understand why stars are not all relatively similar sized initially as they presumably all achieve fusion at similar conditions then blow off excess gas so how do high mass stars exist.

[@freezeburn1]

0:49 I just didn't see this coming lol

[@ericwiesel89]

Muse reference ftw 😎🤘

[@RealKlausSchwab]

I'm a metal guy, been to hundreds of concerts.... but Muse live is the best show I've ever seen.

[@PEGGLORE]

I saw Muse live in 2002 with 2 support bands for £15. Origin of Symmetry tour. I got a backstage pass during it. Went backstage. Was told Matt Bellamy was too wasted to come backstage though, and was passed out on the tour bus. I drank one free can of beer, then went home..

[@JenniferHarrisre]

4:46 to omit the sponsor's statement

[@LegoBubbleGum]

(Lyrics) Ooh baby, don't you know I suffer? Ooh baby, can you hear me moan? You caught me under false pretenses How long before you let me go? Ooh You set my soul alight Ooh You set my soul alight Glaciers melting in the dead of night (ooh) And the superstars sucked into the supermassive (you set my soul alight) Glaciers melting in the dead of night And the superstars sucked into the (you set my soul) (Into the supermassive) I thought I was a fool for no one Ooh baby, I'm a fool for you You're the queen of the superficial And how long before you tell the truth? Ooh You set my soul alight Ooh You set my soul alight Glaciers melting in the dead of night (ooh) And the superstars sucked into the supermassive (you set my soul alight) Glaciers melting in the dead of night And the superstars sucked into the (you set my soul) (Into the supermassive) Supermassive black hole Supermassive black hole Supermassive black hole Supermassive black hole Glaciers melting in the dead of night And the superstars sucked into the supermassive Glaciers melting in the dead of night And the superstars sucked into the supermassive Glaciers melting in the dead of night (ooh) And the superstars sucked into the supermassive (you set my soul alight) Glaciers melting in the dead of night And the superstars sucked into the (you set my soul) (Into the supermassive) Supermassive black hole Supermassive black hole Supermassive black hole Supermassive black hole (Muse)

[@t.m.p8187]

VERy much needed!!

[@The_Ragequit_Cannon]

Uh...

[@susanandrews2294]

Yep glad to see he's on his game, barely a few seconds in and there's the Muse ref! LOL!

[@sgholt]

LOL you made science nasty :p

[@vineousvondrake2456]

someone has WAY too much time on their hands lol

[@carolinegray6984]

Thought2! How do I give you details of a mystery that needs solving? There is a street in a town called Knutsford and the houses number from 40 - 44 missing the number…42!! No one seems to know why, not even the council. Could you please find out? I am a huge fan by the way!! Xxxxx

[@PMA65537]

They had different team members stick up the house numbers and the one with 2 was off sick that day.

[@crunchynetto6979]

40 took half of 42 and 44 took another half~

[@michaelooi9848]

Nope, 42 was assigned, to thoughty2 here

[@crunchynetto6979]

@@michaelooi9848 damn that flew over my head 😂😂

[@iRossco]

The meaning of the Universe

[@eschizas]

That bit about supermassive black holes holding galaxies together is almost certainly not true. the mainstream view is that dark matter is what actually holds galaxies together. Even if you aren't convinced by that, supermassive black holes are typically not massive enough relative to their host galaxies to play the role implied here.

[@hobowithawaterpistol9070]

NASA has secretly been traveling in and out of black homes for years! That’s how we got Super glue!

[@jordanjackman1537]

Cool idea: supermassive black holes collect more mass via gravitational pull

[@amylarson3958]

You think it's strong enough to pull in our current Democratic hopeful?

[@ECWscorpion209]

​@@amylarson3958what

[@sgholt]

My thoughts exactly....its all gravity, they always talk about the Great Attractor, what about the infinite amount of galaxies/black holes/and matter way out there pulling everything.....

[@Silkyfin_]

@@amylarson3958 DEMOCRACY?

[@lyleswanson7557]

Crosby, Still and Nash discovered dark stars back in the 1970's.

[@asksearchknock]

🎶 Let the memory of the evening Be the first thing that you think of When you open up your smile and see me, dark star

[@thembadube9589]

And they published their work under the title "Suite: Judy Blue Eyes".

[@Ataco2eat]

what about quasi stars

[@qman1434]

I love the way you added a picture of propagandist extravagant Neil deGrasse Tyson. As close-minded in individual as I've ever heard.

[@raidermaxx2324]

what are you talking about? You are a moron lol

[@Geheimnis-c2e]

how close-minded is he compared to your average flat earther or moon landing denier?

[@Mr1nv1s1ble]

Damn, the universe continues and always will continue to amaze us beyond our imagination

[@tqrules01]

Dark stars don't exsist, The composition of elements where different in the early universe. So the amount of hydrogen and Helium was different, it also meant they where massive and the amount of energy they could generate is probably also no longer very common, So these early stars if clustered together could create very large blackholes surrounded by other corpses of supernova, and when they merged they probably created SMBH, with enough stellar gas surrounding it, that is probably how early galaxies where formed as well.

[@NevG27]

Well I'm glad we have such an esteemed astrophysicist here to clear that up in a KZbin comment section. Who knew all those other scientists could be so wrong.

[@TheVoidAscensionist]

Grammar please and don't act like that is a fact because it's only theoretical just like all the content of this video.

[@tqrules01]

​@@NevG27 I follow other scientific channels as well, this is a theory that is not that unknown...

[@zephyr733]

1 of what feels like millions of models

[@sgholt]

or maybe they got so big they exploded....seeding the infinite universe with all the materials to form more

[@FEJK82]

Hey, Thoughty2 - I turn 42 tomorrow! I've watched you since the original RIF videos, and still get a little jolt of dopamine when I see you're posted something. Cheers from the Pocono Mountains, Pennsylvania, USA!

[@missteeshemah580]

Happy Birthday 🎉❤

[@FEJK82]

@@missteeshemah580 Thank you... that's nice to hear.

[@sicfxmusic]

Fun fact: If you were instantly thrown away at the speed of light the day you're born, you would've reached Capella (Alpha Aurigae) star by now.

[@QuestishBen]

Love the poconos! Northern Pa is so beautiful and different from southern pa

[@FEJK82]

@@QuestishBen Yeah, had a black bear come up next to me on the porch last week.

[@MewPurPur]

0:28 Random mistake here, supermassive black holes don't hold galaxies together, their mass is usually tiny compared to all the stars. Haven't watched the rest of the video to look for more mistakes, a simple one like that at the beginning is damning.

[@danielhicks1824]

The title should have given it away tbh lol. Really finding a new type of star that is "terrifying" would be something you'd hear about from more than just this dumbass. Hence, he talks about nothing related to the title for the first 5m lol

[@raidermaxx2324]

true!!

[@raidermaxx2324]

but iw wouldnt hold this channel to any sort of respectable "science knowledge" in the first place, this youtube content creator is not a phd in astronomy or even an astrophysicst student. they are just making money on youtube

[@LittleSparklingStars]

But they're at the center of galaxies, right?

[@SvoenDiccr]

Dark stars were found in the 1970s by Crosby, Still, and Nash.

[@abhimatick]

The real star is my father for me..

[@TheKalaxis]

Fathers are great. Mine just turned 72 today 😃

[@Kjubanator]

They sure are. Mine just turned like twelve beer bottles empty today evening.

[@Vermiliongod22]

I'll make sure to tell him that for you

[@runescapeppl41]

​@@Kjubanator -Wine into water?- Your father: Beer into glass.

[@FromThe3021]

Is that a rapper?

[@xinixini1826]

New Super villain with power over gravity: "My name is Super MAssHole" Justice League: "Name checks out"

[@fredflintstoner596]

Mrs Richards: "I paid for a room with a view !" Basil: (pointing to the lovely view) "That is Torquay, Madam ." Mrs Richards: "It's not good enough!" Basil: "May I ask what you were expecting to see out of a Torquay hotel bedroom window ? Sydney Opera House, perhaps? the Hanging Gardens of Babylon? Herds of wildebeest sweeping majestically across the plains?..." Mrs Richards: "Don't be silly! I expect to be able to see the sea!" Basil: "You can see the sea, it's over there between the land and the sky." Mrs Richards: "I'm not satisfied. But I shall stay. But I expect a reduction." Basil: "Why?! Because Krakatoa's not erupting at the moment ?"

[@Charlie-f4q4o]

You have a beautiful ai voice Dr bot

[@fredflintstoner596]

@@Charlie-f4q4o THANKS YOU MUST BE THE VILLAGE IDIOT I'VE HEARD SO MUCH ABOUT IF YOU THINK I'M A BOT OR YOU HEARD A VOICE OF ANY KIND YOU FRIED FISH !

[@fredflintstoner596]

@@Charlie-f4q4o YOU MUST BE THE VILLAGE IDIOT IF YOU THINK I'M A BOT OR YOU HEARD MY VOICE WHILE READING A COMMENT !

[@fredflintstoner596]

@@Charlie-f4q4o YOU MUST BE THE VILLAGE IDIOT IF YOU THINK I'M A BOT OR YOU HEARD MY VOICE WHILE READING A COMMENT !

[@fredflintstoner596]

WELL SAID FRED !YOU MUST BE THE VILLAGE IDIOT IF YOU THINK I'M A BOT OR YOU HEARD MY VOICE WHILE READING A COMMENT !

[@thenephilim9819]

"We just found a new type of star" "The concept of dark stars is mere speculation"... So we HAVEN'T found a new type of star 👀

[@orionking420]

Thoughty2? New stars?? Count me in dude 🤙🏻

[@clareharrison3361]

'Denser than Amber Heards dog" 😂😂😂 Brilliant.

[@0wl999]

So, dark matter is antimatter? I want my warp drive dammit! 😂

[@asksearchknock]

Make it so

[@Wolfie54545]

Dark matter is not antimatter. Antimatter is just matter particles with the opposite charge.

[@danielvermeer3363]

You should also mention that a dog's intellectual abilities are a representation of their owner😂😂😂 0:45

[@eadweard.]

🤢

[@aPandaInSpace]

Not saying: "Without further Odoo, lets get back to the video" should be a crime.

[@simonholyoak8869]

It’s spelt ADO

[@Fryzzi]

100% agree

[@simonholyoak8869]

@@Fryzzi thanks. Unfortunately, I’m a bit of a grammar Nazi

[@Jaboukii]

This sounds like an essay written 5minutes before presentation

[@HuierWone]

Supermassive black holes have a great idea: they attract more mass through gravity

[@Vicki_Benji]

Timestamp 1:02, you should have had Brian May there too.

[@katekrylov]

The first thought: Muse... Funny! The conclusion: we know nothing about anything. Also funny... And a"sexy" gold-plated telescope to crown that all, ha!

[@BillGorman]

Perhaps Black Holes are Dark Matter!

[@SilentKnightXXVI]

Black holes aren't dark matter because they're made of regular matter that's been compressed way beyond anything we can normally imagine. Like if the Moon suddenly turned into a black hole, it would shrink to just 0.22 millimeters in diameter, but it would still be the same Moon - just squished down to an insane level. That’s why its gravity is so strong. Think of it like this: Moon turns into a black hole -> now it's 0.22 millimeters in diameter but with the same mass as the Moon, except now all that gravity is focused in that tiny space, making it way more intense. Dark matter, though, is something totally different. We can’t see it, and it doesn’t act like normal matter - it only shows up through its gravity. Black holes are still regular matter, just super dense, and we can actually detect them by how they mess with light and stuff around them. The light gets warped around the black hole because of its intense gravity, and the event horizon is the point of no return where nothing, not even light, can escape.

[@hobowithawaterpistol9070]

@@SilentKnightXXVIIs that a matter of fact?

[@DarrenCornelius-t3q]

@@hobowithawaterpistol9070it’s true, dark matter acts very differently to black holes. Dark matter is practically everywhere, and adds to the gravity balance needed to keep galaxies together otherwise things would fly apart. Like spinning on a roundabouts super fast. Your body wants to fly off of it.

[@Wolfie54545]

It’s a quark star.

[@Epicmonk117]

That pun at the beginning hit me right in the childhood.

[@vasildimov9938]

Black holes aren't "objects", they are regions with extreme gravity and space/time distortion.

[@Wolfie54545]

There is in fact an object creating the gravitational pull.

[@Silverphoenix36912]

Supernova, & it's a dark star afterwards. Just saved everybody about 15 minutes

[@Matthew-pn1ct]

Everytime I watch a video about space I realise just how small and insignificant I am lol

[@bobsteele9581]

Great video Callum. Watson was one of football's earliest superstars and it's great that he's been getting more of the recognition he deserves in recent years. Here are some ideas ideas for similar player profile videos I would like to see, if you don't mind me making the suggestions. Walter Tull - early black player who played for Spurs and Northampton. Yes he's English, but his Scottish connection is that he signed for Rangers in 1917, but was killed in WW1 before he could play. His life story is fascinating. Then there's Austrian goalkeeper Karl Pekarna, the first foreign player ever to sign for a UK team, who signed for Rangers in 1905. Another possibility for a vid is Mohamed Latif, the first African player ever to play for a UK team. He signed from Egyptian outfit Zamalek in 1935, and yes, again it was Rangers he signed for.

[@Dommer810]

I love the dog joke. Totally get it!!!

[@rongerongin]

There is another explanation for super massive blackhole. The Blackhole Star. In a nutshell, it is a star, with blackhole inside it.

[@mandy5313]

“My dog stepped on a bee”😂

[@sauceboss8999]

Thoughty2 space videos are a gift

[@ucan1]

I think understanding quantum physics is more easier than understanding what the goal of this video is this all about😡

[@timothyeichinger3592]

More easier?

[@mattsmith5421]

​@@timothyeichinger3592Yes, very more easier.

[@rafakordaczek3275]

The sheer amount of editing put in this video is insane.

[@johnhause7150]

0:26 . Key word here.."CREATED".

[@asksearchknock]

Yes! When mighty Odin the all-father gave life to our universe

[@thespalek1]

Love how Thoughty's "Dark Matter" kinda sounds like "Dog Matter" 😁 (I seriously mean it well, these videos are unbelievably steady quality for so long now! ❤)

[@Astrohhh]

God is great ❤

[@PurposefullyIneloquent]

Hah! XD

[@violindylan]

I don’t know her

[@nevimH]

Nah, he couldn't make this up, maybe it was Santa Claus.

[@QapNPoo]

Usually made up things are great. This God thing is a sick twisted imaginary friend.

[@masterpepe3641]

Is it racist to say that sounds better in arabic?

[@DaveEtchells]

“When WIMPs Collide” - sounds like the latest Disney movie 😂

[@SOCCER_BUNNY]

1:19 yea because god layed the answer out for EVERYONE and most people wouldn’t believe it no matter what. He’s got EVERYTHING you don’t know because he created EVERYTHING including the holes it’s super obvious

[@myheadhurtstho]

wow you're schizophrenic. get help.

[@chrisfox7393]

Yeah it’s easy god did it 😂

[@diegon3045]

Of course God did it, but as with all things god created, there is a scientific explanation for it. We just have to find one for supermassive black holes.

[@Geheimnis-c2e]

"God laid out the answer for everyone" bastard doesn't answer anything. everything he says and does is cryptic and he's too "special" to talk to you directly.

[@NoDrizzy630]

Saying god did something doesn’t actually answer the question.

[@BlackWolf-uk2yb]

'Invisible Stars' LMAO

[@JenniferHarrisre]

0:49 I simply didn't anticipate this, lol.

[@Queenie-the-genie]

Just what we need a new terrifying star. Are not the republicans and their dear leader terrifying enough?

[@AaronP220]

Jesus. People will literally drop politics in ANYTHING.

[@roninj8205]

😂😂😂😂

[@roninj8205]

​@AaronPits still funny though...Great to get a laugh in on a crappy day

[@huntercoxpersonal]

🤮

[@danbh84]

Oh zip it

[@SoapEater-a]

0:49 "They are denser than Amber Heard's dog." Probably based on "My dog stepped on a bee" 😂

[@foolish3art]

Creator: *Defines gravity* Also Creator: "We don't know of such a force" Gravity: "Ummm, bro, you just defined me a second ago"

[@bulkzorage]

This video is really high quality , I noticed alot of the improvements you have made from previous earlier work. Congrats on the finished product, you should be proud 👍

[@TheScottyDoList]

Don’t worry lil buddy, it’s not that terrifying. Humans on the other hand, are extremely terrifying.

[@andrewdreasler428]

"The Universe is not only stranger than we imagine, it is stranger than we CAN imagine."

[@cee8mee]

From the first time he said "dark star" the CSN song Dark Star never left my brain.

[@michaelolarewajupodprof9012]

Thank you Thoughty2, I found you while I was looking through the Milky Way galaxy during COVID and you’re still shinning as the brightest star in both the observable and unobservable cosmos. You’re amazing.

[@jedstanaland2897]

The amount of insane energy that one of the proposed dark stars would be producing would be so high that it might be able to severely damage or even rip a galaxy apart when/ if it goes nova.

[@jdmaine51084]

"Dark matter" and "dark energy" feel like things that were invented in order to make the model work.

[@Geheimnis-c2e]

Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. If gravity pulls things together then there should be something that repels things apart that is opposite to gravity but isn't electromagnetism. This is where dark matter and dark energy come in. If gravity pulls things together then why is the universe expanding? dark energy. why are the masses of universes spherical? dark matter.

[@phillipburroughs146]

Of all the shows you ever done this is the most interesting and gave me an epiphany. You’re onto something here, but let me expand it a bit further from what I was thinking. What if stars create shadows caused by other dimensions resulting in those dark stars. The power transitions from one to the other dimension thus creating black holes?

[@The_Nonchalant_Shallot]

0:14 I was under the impression we already had a theory about how they were created. Something about supermassive stars forming at the beginning of the universe who's immensely dense cores collapsed into black holes, but the nuclear fusion of the star kept most of the fuel out of the black hole as it slowly ate away at it? After their deaths the stellar debris turned into proto galaxies? Is that not the prevailing theory?

[@kyrrziel]

Basically yeah, except that it was the matter falling in and superheating in the accretion disk that apparently would create pressure pushing matter back away from the blackhole and balance the whole thing iirc.

[@The_Nonchalant_Shallot]

@@kyrrziel I appreciate the correction there. It was a while ago I'd heard this theory. Weird that nobody mentions it in videos these days. I guess someone found evidence to the contrary?

[@roybatty2030]

Dark Star is the name of a hilarious sci fi spoof film.

[@ThatTieDyeGuy]

Thx, Thoughty and Crew!!!!! You folks are great :D

[@Kameeho]

The most terrifying thing i learned is that Thoughty2 shaved his magnifiscent mustache

[@CheezeBreaux]

So the ship from Planet Express making a visible combustion after ¨burning¨ the dark matter was actually accurate.

[@YusufGinnah]

Giving me PTSD every time he says *'Super Massive Black Hole'* Reminding me of the 'Super Massive Black Holes' I've encountered over the years... 😶

[@Rockgod17]

Whenever a theory is finally thrown out about our univers I always wonder how terrifying the results of the theory would be if they were true.

[@ryanbrown982]

Me: No idea how super massive black holes form... Hrm, dark matter stars? Video: Dark Matter Stars! Me: Yeah, thought so.

[@earthbound9381]

Very good video Arran. Fascinating stuff about so-called dark stars.

[@jessemasters1446]

Mused at supermassive black holes is a fantastic joke.

[@CLipka2373]

"As a gas cloud collapses, it rapidly cools" ... uh, sure? Isn't it HEATING UP due to converting potential to (random) kinetic energy?? And isn't HEATING the problem that eventually stops the collapse, due to radiation pressure?

[@amir.rodz3]

4 yrs. viewing and I never get enough of the content. Kudos!

[@Stess-ky4gn]

Question: Could the very early dark stars be a reason for the prevalence of matter over anti-matter? Could most of the anti-matter be inside black holes?

[@chonitobonito6158]

Thank you for all your hard work throughout all these years of interesting topics

[@dennisanderson3895]

I am NOT knocking scientists, but it amazes me how confidently and absolutely *some* speak when - to no fault of their own, really - they ARE simply presenting assumptions and guesses [rather than simply saying, "Well, based on we think we know, this is our best hypothesis right now"].

[@VinnyMartello]

Science can’t solve for origins. You can philosophize all you want, but unless you’re Jim Croce, you can’t put time in a bottle.

[@stevekirkpatrick1612]

13:37 "The idea that dark stars could be the engine behind the creation of super massive black holes challenges" nothing we thought we knew, because it is an idea that directly supposes that all previous speculation about the universe is 100% true. Then they spotted a thing nobody would identify, because it didn't exactly match "everything we thought we knew" about the universe. So they reached into a scientistic grab bag of celestial words to give that thing a name tag. And what do you know, now suddenly those things are all over the place.

[@ryouarozado1350]

I thought you were going to be Talking about Quasi Stars💀.

[@annabarela4105]

‘The big bang’ concept cracks me up. If there was a ‘big bang’ what came before that?

[@WeToddEd-r3g]

How does that even matter?? The evidence is pretty strong that the universe is expanding outward from a condensed point. How does "what happened before" make it not something happening?

[@exittragedy1436]

That thumbnail is fire though, looks like album art

[@picknowell]

The real elephan . Why are galaxies accelerating away from eachother?

[@sophustranquillitastv4468]

The world Dark Star feel like a contradiction (because stars have never been dark of course), but if it did existed then we can only accept it.

[@raka9220]

Bright galaxy in early years of universe "And let there be light" What a coincidence

[@alicevoidspeaker2100]

Dark Matter and Dark Energy is clearly just Void Magic from World of Warcraft

[@AFishNamedBob]

The Muse ref made me happy in my soul.

[@Strype13]

But... if the incredible gravitational force of these supermassive black holes is creating the conditions for clumps of dark matter large enough to form these "dark stars," and these "dark stars" are bright enough to outshine entire galaxies... it seems like it would be pretty easy to spot them around the supermassive black holes... yet, we don't see any. What gives?

[@paulb8603]

It’s a really nice explanation for things no one actually knows it’s all just opinions sometimes here on planet earth

[@kittywampusdrums4963]

If WiMPs do not interact with the rest of matter but release gamma radiation when they collide into each other that means they are made from the same things which regular matter is made of. That doesn't work.

[@VestedUTuber]

"A supermassive black hole's gravity holds galaxies together" Actually, it doesn't. It contributes a significant amount to the total gravity of the galaxy, but it's the total mass of all matter in a galaxy, including dark matter, that holds galaxies together.

[@Gradius2]

We'll *NEVER* see the "beginning" of Universe. *NEVER*

[@AaronWolfenbarger]

Electromagnetism does more to hold galaxies together than gravity.

[@DanielWatson-vv7cd]

From what I seen in books, all stars are Dark Stars. Since all stars are burning extremely hot, the material inside them would be burnt to a color as black as soot. It's the hot glow coming off the star that gives it the unique coloration. As far as the formation of Super Massive Black Balls,m. They probably form the collision of smaller black balls in the galactic center, merging together due to gravity.