Three Hinged Circular Arches Structural Analysis

[@karthikpateladpa5524]

Sir how can we take V in Normal thrust and Radial Shear....?

[@Civillearningonline]

V = reaction at support A - udl X span I. E. ( V= 420-30X9) =150.

[@karthikpateladpa5524]

Is It taken as Shear Force till that point where we take moment at X...?

[@Civillearningonline]

Yes.

[@beautifulrecitationsofquran]

@@Civillearningonline sir daigram drwan is wrong read sttement adn then decide

[@beautifulrecitationsofquran]

@@Civillearningonline its written lesft springs but u used right spring when u r placing appplied loads

[@amosbanda9657]

Thank u for teaching in English, greatly appreciated ☺️. Most people taught in Hindi which a hard to follow if u aren't from India

[@Civillearningonline]

Thank you.

[@sulochanaoli5930]

Thank u so much sir

[@Sag_E_Makhdoom_Rabbani313]

Thank u so mch sir ❤

[@Nithin_186]

Explain How "V" is taken in normal thrust and radial shear ?

[@nihalrajbharti1532]

In the equation.of arch the value of x should be taken from crown point so it is not 9

[@Civillearningonline]

Why so? Will you elaborate?

[@nihalrajbharti1532]

Because equation had derived with that assumption where x was taken from crown, you may check the derivation

[@Civillearningonline]

@@nihalrajbharti1532 its already mentioned in the question. How to consider X.

[@nikhilnaik9303]

Yes... also in both the case finally it becomes 9 only so don't blame on sir pls @nihalrajbharti

[@manishasah4662]

While calculating horizontal reaction HA = HB will be there .......... negative sign won't be there......once check it plz sir and reply

[@Civillearningonline]

HA and HB are equal in magnitude but opposite in direction.

[@MADANMOHAN-ot6bp]

In step 3 how u get R=30 sir please reply me tomorrow I have exam

[@rajeevtiwari3038]

Is pr all types numerical aur Strain energy method sway non sway frame numerical bhi bta de, please

[@Civillearningonline]

Sure

[@adeepbirla3378]

V ?

[@furqaanalikhan4568]

How u got Ra+Rb=600 I think it is 480

[@Civillearningonline]

30*18+60 =600.

[@junierking2166]

It's 420

[@nikhil41823]

Bending moment diagram PLZZ

[@Civillearningonline]

I will provide you. Currently i am traveling.

[@sheetalsilswal]

Thnkuh sir

[@victory_potti4593]

Sir you speaking ward below continue not understand

[@basantsharma6844]

Sound to loud rkho

[@rajeevtiwari3038]

Sir iska bending moment diagram btaye

[@Civillearningonline]

Ok. I will send you on email.

[@mini_co-op]

Humko bhe dedo sir plz

[@mdirfanalam6882]

Sir please don't teach in English. Hindi will be better option

[@Civillearningonline]

Ok

[@chillstream9760]

english is better for us (not all indians speak english)