Three Men Lost in Space - The Apollo 13 Disaster

[@MyReviews_karkan]

I was sweating watching this and my heart was going crazy even though it happened 50 years ago. Imagine what the crew was feeling during that time.

[@geofox9484]

Well I read your comment, so you changed my world a little a bit today.

[@CultofThings]

I think failure is fascinating and I love the idea of a successful failure.

[@MyReviews_karkan]

@@geofox9484 the idea of getting lost in space absolutely terrifies me. I remember watching the movie "gravity" and it was very difficult to watch. I hope your world has changed to the better btw :)

[@MyReviews_karkan]

@@CultofThings failure is what makes a person very successful, my friend.

[@isspartanlockealivehaloinf1963]

@@MyReviews_karkan I have the opposite phobia, but for getting lost in dark oceans. I dont mind space, as long as i can get out in the space suit. and if i had all the things i needed. if I was them, I would be terrified since they also were running out of oxygen

[@Roach_Dogg_JR]

Imagine being one of the people on earth trying to save these guys and how stressed you would be that you missed a decimal or something.

[@MiaMya396]

I wonder if any of them developed shingles or heart problems because maannnnn….

[@avi10000]

I think the fabric of people was stronger

[@CodenameHaswelly]

@@avi10000 stronger than you definitely

[@GuRuGeorge03]

the word DEADLine is really fitting in this case

[@bayralysis]

@@CodenameHaswelly That wasnt needed, nor was it funny.

[@josephdarkpride8344]

I know they all survived but this is absolutely terrifying to listen to. Imagine how they must've felt being all alone out there in the empty vast darkness of space

[@butterybangtan3640]

They survived? How?

[@Marcesko]

@@butterybangtan3640 watch the movie "apollo 13"

[@Marinlss]

I didn't know they survived and watching this gave me a small panic attack, I had to stop and google and couldn't believe they actually survived

[@pleasecontactme4274]

oh they lived? damn the title's scary misleading

[@ArmedandDangerous918]

I mean we are in still in the vast darkness of space. Just kinda less empty on earth lol

[@tshirt9]

The thought of aimlessly floating through space until your oxygen runs out with no outside contact gives me crazy anxiety.

[@PerfectLeeAdventures]

Wouldn't be too bad, you would just fall asleep

[@Habzo421]

@@PerfectLeeAdventures and never wake up...

[@mftripz8445]

I’d doubt you’d be freaking out for long, knowing your fate is 100% sealed..

[@blushchuu]

@@mftripz8445 I’d freak out even more knowing that, knowing I’m going to die and nothing I can do will change that

[@mftripz8445]

@@blushchuu really? I think i’d be at peace or atleast come to terms. There really isn’t much use in fighting the wind, and i think i would rather just spend my time looking back at my life. But to each their own, Im grounded and levelheaded even through some of the situations ive been in..

[@borisfenestra]

My grandfather was working at JSC during 13. He and the entire crew at Mission Control didn't go home until the astronauts were safe on the ground. He was one if the people who worked on the jerry rig for the co2 scrubbers. After that, he got a picture of Fred Haise floating next to it, signed by Jim Lovell. I'm so glad that people are still telling this story, as it's one of the greatest examples of engineering and problem solving of all time.

[@IdoZatTimeInaVan]

Please thank him for me. Astonishing achievement. 😍😍😍

[@thomasroddis2270]

I smell BS

[@ChayaHampton]

@@thomasroddis2270lol

[@soupopera09]

​@@thomasroddis2270genuinely asking - what would lying about their grandfather's workplace accomplish? he didn't even seem to be a higher up so there's literally nothing op could brag about. just a story and a small message about how apollo 13 is a great example of problem solving and engineering. just that

[@cuauhtemocmorisco3493]

"They had no choice but too try"- these words is what defines human existence and the ability to keep going no matter what

[@rl_jfc]

@Harald Baldr's camera you ruined the moment smh

[@gero3015]

Human ingenuity

[@gero3015]

@Mulalo AOT sux

[@Kain1805]

@@gero3015 no u

[@keetahbrough]

JUST BECAUSE YOU CAN DOESN’T MEAN YOU SHOULD

[@chloepaperd9758]

Absolute chills. I can’t imagine what it feels like to have to accept that you’re probably going to die but try your hardest to get home anyways.

[@theokguy9837]

Ok

[@noahlemieux1983]

Ok

[@soph5026]

they survived tho

[@theokguy9837]

@@soph5026 you’re dirtyyy

[@redcubegamer7716]

@@theokguy9837 tf

[@catpat4754]

I don't know why but the smiles on people faces when they realised that everyone had survived made me emotional

[@lonelady5903]

This is humanity 💜

[@boxingwatcher9924]

Because you’re soft

[@jaimestardust8555]

@@boxingwatcher9924 and you cringe af

[@catpat4754]

@@boxingwatcher9924 Nah you're just used to toxic masculinity and blocked all emotions to look more *male*. I'm sorry you were raised that way

[@alesha397]

@@boxingwatcher9924 💀

[@Themischievousmuffin]

“A rookie, who left his wife and three kids” WHAT “… on earth”

[@VinceBlack536]

Don’t you mean what on moon

[@killianyinstitut]

The nerve!

[@OpalLeigh]

Right 😂 like “oh, that’s ok then” 🙊

[@yan-rayiller-may8443]

It's still a weird sentence even with the Earth. Like no shit everyone else is on earth. He's not leaving forever.

[@GantsilyoBaguio]

Yeah, that was some poor writing there.

[@reign225]

The fact that they pulled this off almost 50 years ago , got them all safe back home , without any loss of life is truly incredible.

[@Reginald_Harrison]

Apollo 13 happened in 1970. That's 52 years ago.

[@ObliqueVisualsNz]

I don't believe it to be true.

[@TheHogMan]

@@ObliqueVisualsNz May I ask why? Theres video evidence of the whole ordeal. No sarcasm, I'm truly interested in your thoughts on the matter

[@ObliqueVisualsNz]

I just find it hard to believe they sent men to the moon,failed and somehow managed to find there way back to earth with malfunctioning equipment with a computer less powerful than a early 90s cellphone and the somewhat primitive technology back then.

[@TheHogMan]

@@ObliqueVisualsNz Fair enough man, I totally understand your skepticism, but you can never underestimate humans. Most of the calculations were done by hand. I always just think of the Sphynx or the Colossus of Rhodes, and those were built before we had modern technology, all by hand, designed by insanely intelligent people. Or how from 1900-2000 we went from land based monkeys, to conquering the sky, to exploring space. It's not far fetched to think it's not real, but also it's easy to see how it could be done with what they had at the time, you always just make do with what you got.

[@infernal..]

I cant imagine being as smart as these NASA workers. The amount of math they deal with in such little time

[@infernal..]

@@beansontoast5931 ?

[@johnrauscher8805]

And they did it on slide rules.

[@johnrauscher8805]

I’m not putting them down they mastered the tools that were available as did the Egyptians

[@revparravager3184]

@Sprjte ...or BARELY write a single sentence without a misspelling. ;) Just poking a little fun, don't be angry.

[@curtisdale2791]

I just love it when these brave American Heroes pretend to go into outer space.

[@imicca]

Imagine doing maths on the broken spaceship to get back to home this is insane

[@gandugamer2317]

Now I know why I will never be in spaceship any time soon.

[@varunjaihind3904]

Luckily they must have loved math, physics and science.

[@Zero11s]

spaceships are airships

[@eeka_droid]

lesson taken out of it: never fly a spaceship if you suck at math

[@Zero11s]

@@eeka_droid the black world with balls is a fantasy universe

[@YoungBuddha954]

This hits because for a little bit of time humanity was together and worked with one another regardless of the differences. Nowadays we fight so much that we forget what we as humans are capable of as a collective.

[@MarsEdition]

This!!

[@denigrator6399]

I have a dream headass

[@dahliacheung6020]

You're right, and we do, but let me hopefully make you feel just a little bit better with another space related piece of information. The international space station has existed for the last 25 years and despite Russia threatening to pull out during the current war, they didn't actually do so. That makes the ISS a combined work of the space agencies of America, Canada, Europe(as a whole with most major countries), Japan, and Russia. In those 23 years, 279 people from 22 countries- different genders, religions and ethnicities- have lived and worked on this space station (8 people at a time, with others coming to replace them when they leave) and continue to do so to this day.

[@portobeIIa]

adorable how you say that when the moon landing was a direct byproduct of the cold war?? which was, you know.. a conflict of people BASED ON their differences??? youre either american OR too young to have this much naivite... not saying that the moon landing isnt a feat we can all awe at, regardless of where we're from. but cmon. come on. "nowadays we fight so much" when youre comparing nowadays to an active cold war situation where people would call eachother communists and spies is hysterical man

[@PaulKulha]

Russia was happy and we know it

[@abie4230]

I feel like in order to even go through with this mission, you’d already have to accept your death because of the likelihood. That mental strength is profound!

[@lapeez2277]

@@Iride505 .

[@shrewd1245]

@@Iride505 But without the stoplights and drive-thru restaurants.

[@abie4230]

@@Iride505 you’re right

[@CodenameHaswelly]

@@abie4230 no hes not lol how stupid

[@cookie_monster6933]

@@CodenameHaswelly r/woooosh

[@mtrshlh]

Watching this on my bed with good electricity and unlimited oxygen. Can't imagine what those gentlemen felt at that time

[@itslizziguys]

Same 😔

[@swaayinn9376]

Hey dude, thats what they get for trying somthing like thay

[@gurmant4r]

Swaayinn like what ?

[@Rebornn_ck]

Fr

[@jan_dal]

@@swaayinn9376 its space travel what do you mean

[@IamCec]

"they wrapped their bodies around him to keep him warm." What a sad and moving image. Agh 😢 The amount of sheer willpower, ingenuity, and camaraderie to stay alive and use every available resource is awe-inspiring.

[@aIkaIi]

This took everything the human body had to offer, mentally and physically, and in intelligence. Amazing and scary to watch unfold.

[@dudemusicofficial]

I can't even imagine how scared they must've been

[@OninDynamics]

intelligencely

[@dayra6425]

those astronauts were braver then i could ever imagine to be .. they were the peak of what America stood for ..

[@Isnotreal42]

@@OninDynamics intellectually

[@DiegoBurgosH]

Look for the man who survived 9 days in the Sahara desert, it’s quite similar

[@SniffyTugBoat]

this fascinated my dad. he was born in 1959, so he got to see the moon landing on TV as a kid. when the Columbia broke apart on reentry in 2003, he got really somber and told me about the Apollo 1, 13, and Challenger disasters. when he saw the first successful SpaceX relanding, it brought him to tears. space fascinated him in a way I still don't quite understand. edit: thanks for all the kind words. my dad passed away about 3 years ago now, but he would've loved to talk about his fascination with space and our explorations of it so far.

[@SuperShortAndSweet]

Moon landing>space X relanding

[@nabilmiah4428]

@@SuperShortAndSweet Uhhh obviously? No body is doubting the fact that the moon landing is cooler than the SpaceX relanding.

[@jerry3790]

@@nabilmiah4428 both are cool. One is for the young generations, one for the older

[@fonsbruls795]

But I do understand your dad very well.....

[@enigmaticfacts6898]

i would just like to say,some person are so deep in the feelings for some topic. one of them is your dad. say my hello to him

[@s52pana]

I remember in 6th grade we had an experiment based on this mission. How they had to listen to build something exactly the way it was being described to them. They gave us some building blocks, a big cardboard shield, and we were split into groups of 4. One person had a diagram that she had to describe to us while being being behind the piece of cardboard. The rest of us had to listen to her instructions, use the blocks, and build what she was describing. I dont think any of the groups managed to successfully do it. I think the teacher did it to show us how difficult the astronaut's task was.

[@itslizziguys]

That’s awesome! I wish my teacher would have done something similar with my class! I totally wanna do this with my kids now! 🤩

[@s52pana]

@@itslizziguys it's definitely fun for the kids 👍👍

[@QRaine]

Okay but whoever got that Diagram sounds like a MVP

[@gerardjagroo]

You went to a good school

[@joeg5414]

I used to hate group assignments in school with a passion. This actually sounds like fun though

[@Puff_Puff_Packs]

This is one of the most resilient stories I've ever heard. They are amazing. They solved a problem bigger than the world in a couple days. I would have accepted my fate the second the tank blew. I don't even think I would try to take on THAT kind of a problem. I guess that's why I'm not an astronaut. Soooo many different dynamics to be taken into consideration and they conquered every single one of them! Truly truly an amazing story. Just plain incredible.

[@Mayrows]

They most likely factored anomalies in

[@Fiatluc]

The amount of engineering challenges in order to save these great men is unfathomable, meanwhile flat earthers still exist.

[@ramuthra1]

Please don't use the 'f word' here...

[@suekennedy8917]

Name just 1 engineering challenge and a circa 1970s digital or analog control system and computer to handle it.

[@channelname4331]

@Madulas pag Basa unfunny

[@HaloForgeUltra]

The Earth doesn't exist morons.

[@bodombeastmode]

I'm pretty nearly convinced that people who genuinely believe the earth is flat should be put into a mental institution.

[@cyclez6317]

The thought of endlessly floating in space and moving further and further away from the earth losing oxygen and suffocating is just scary these men were brave and somehow managed to be calm

[@itszoe2913]

Unrelated but Jesus loves you Have an amazing day

[@diorj4ne]

@@itszoe2913 back to you 🤍

[@awildcat3592]

@@coldfire6679 Let's support religions no matter you believe them or not.

[@awildcat3592]

@@coldfire6679 I respect your opinion and thank you.

[@mouthman1335]

@@coldfire6679 I support French bread 🥖

[@literallyshaking8019]

This was NASA’s finest hour. To me, getting those men home using minute to minute solutions, and cob-job methods calculated on paper with slide rules and human brain power is more impressive than a flawless mission landing on the moon. It goes beyond a step-by-step itinerary, it’s humanity trying to rescue humanity from a frontier dangerous to all living creatures. NASA took on the primal forces of nature and won.

[@brotomwang8218]

right, a moon landing is very precise and risky but this just has layers upon layers of shit that couldve gone wrong

[@literallyshaking8019]

@Xx BigBoss xX you read a lot of gay stuff? Not judging, because there’s nothing wrong with that.

[@MailmanRicky]

This shit isn’t real lmao

[@vefge]

@@MailmanRicky is your head a flat earth too?

[@MailmanRicky]

@@vefge sure

[@paragua79za]

The intelligence of everyone involved is just jaw dropping 😮

[@user-ez3ho7qp3i]

I can imagine being lost in the woods or lost in the desert but lost in space in the dark all alone..... Now that´s scary... I have respect for you guys. What a good plan, and it worked perfectly.

[@somerandomguy9125]

There's just a couple inches thick aluminium between you and literally anything for hundreds of thousands of miles away.

[@theokguy9837]

I don’t think they will ever see your comment 🤦🏻‍♂️🤣🤡

[@Wjjsndhao]

Being lost on earth has some chances of getting rescued or surviving a bit but in space. No way home

[@jonathanjoestar5724]

@@theokguy9837 ok

[@AkitsuSensuu]

i'd probably just give up and die in space if that happened to me

[@binneboi5458]

Imagine being in for one of humankind's most epic stories, just to be hit by measles and have to skip the mission. Though in a way, he was the lucky one.

[@Cold_1995]

A blessing in disguise for sure.

[@absolutedumbass5337]

@Solitudence look in the description

[@absolutedumbass5337]

@Solitudence well fiddlesticks

[@gloriakummer5357]

He contributed to saving them by helping them come to a solution on earth

[@LPOband]

“this measles got me stuck at home when i should be in space. wonder how the mission’s going” “there was an explosion, they’ve lost all power, oxygen, and water” “measles ain’t so bad i guess”

[@scarfacebug3663]

If i came home after this shit, id never wanna leave the comfort of my house.

[@kai.82]

*sees anything black or anything resembling space* *has mental breakdown*

[@unclejimbo1301]

Stay home and getcha' pull

[@SumanYadav-qv4so]

Haha same .

[@BoscoLe]

@@kai.82 lol

[@Opr8rKaz]

Wait we can leave our homes?

[@CharlieApples]

It’s always amazing to me how often astronauts end up having to improvise with their equipment in space, and how often it actually works

[@Ro-68]

Almost like something scripted, eh😂

[@sneakyninjastreef3549]

@@Ro-68almost like it’s not just your average Joe heading into space, but brilliant scientists/engineers.

[@doraychannel1179]

Yeah tru it is not true ​@@Ro-68

[@mariekekito3998]

@@Ro-68almost like you’re too dumb to understand how smart astronauts are and how well they’re trained.

[@KanielOutis147]

Amazing. Engineers and mathematicians are so intelligent, I could never

[@hall0ween138]

The whole culture of BLM and Antifa don’t think you need Math and Engineering, just artists being told they’re great at everything. Math is now part of the racist narrative being told by leftists.

[@PursuedByAMemory]

@@hall0ween138 My goodness gracious you found a way to develop a hockie political narrative around Maths. You have a wild imagination. Consider writing fiction.

[@hall0ween138]

@@PursuedByAMemory I wish I was that creative. I’m pulling this straight from their own marketing materials friend.

[@itsonlyagame4033]

@@hall0ween138 Argument: Some people of this group think this way from your unsourced material = everybody in this group feels this way and is not just my inability to separate political matters from what they do in their own time and what they focus on when they are protesting. I'm sure you are very hurt by everybody in this group since everybody in it is so damn racist. Stop putting politics into everything you are consumed by it.

[@hall0ween138]

@@itsonlyagame4033 irony: you making a generalization about me making a generalization. The best of KZbin comments right before our eyes. What would you like me to comment since you want to be the moderator?

[@sazcxieo]

Imagine being unable to join the mission to the moon because of contracting measles. Then realizing that darn measle saved your life from perililous disaster.

[@dreamcore]

It may have saved all their lives as from the ground he contributed to getting them all back

[@madirishgirl76]

He didn't get measles in the end

[@ssherrierable]

He didnt contract measles he was only exposed to them.

[@madirishgirl76]

@@ssherrierable I never said he got measles did I? That be a no I did not I said he did not get measles in the end read my comment again

[@swettispaghetti4310]

@@madirishgirl76 I dont think he was talking to u ding dong

[@jefftsalote9213]

Wow, so despite the luck, engineering and mathematic calculations, if it wasn't for duct tape these guys probably wouldn't have made it home. Duct tape..you are the true hero!

[@chigmeister2977]

Ya know what they say... If you cant duct it, fuck it

[@jefftsalote9213]

Haaha For sure.

[@PrometheusV]

@@chigmeister2977 Well, if you cant solve a problem with duct tape.. you arent using enough duct tape. Duct Tape and WD-40 are the most useful gifts humanity has ever gotten from Aliens

[@durasuki6357]

@@PrometheusV Aliens be like "Ayo homie whats up homes take this sticky shit"

[@NANotApplicable]

Like the "Inanimate Carbon Rod" in the Simpsons when Homer went to space.

[@dahliacheung6020]

After watching videos about the devastating tragedies of the Challenger and the Columbia I decided to watch this to make myself feel better because the negligence of those disasters makes me so damn upset. The Apollo 13 story is such a triumph of human endurance, bravery, and cooperation. It's almost unbelievable even all these years later, that they survived this.

[@Samuelon552]

Even though Apollo 13 was a disaster, I think it shows the absolute best of humanity. What an incredible story of survival.

[@colaperture]

As he said, a "Successful Disaster."

[@Samuelon552]

@R Voit yes I suppose so

[@heyxanman6262]

what

[@rowdyyates4273]

@R Voit hoax!

[@Raihan__4535]

​@rvoitrelax.what does he say wrong

[@ThatOneRat1991]

What hit my heart the most, was the fact that the entire world were on stand by for the 3 men. That truly is a beautiful thing.

[@rowdyyates4273]

Yes a clever lie to get peoples attention again!

[@ThatOneRat1991]

@@rowdyyates4273 what the hell is that supposed to mean 💀

[@rowdyyates4273]

@@ThatOneRat1991 people were losing interest in space exploration- and to keep them interested and the money coming they concocted a story to rekindle the publics interest such as the this mission which was a hoax- also made money as a film-

[@rowdyyates4273]

Mind control at its best !

[@Atomz09]

@@rowdyyates4273 lol

[@TheGamingBun]

Props to everyone for being quick and finding solutions on the disasters.

[@XUIW]

no u

[@delilah2030]

@@XUIW ?

[@XUIW]

@@delilah2030 ¿

[@user-jw5682]

@@XUIW OP was involved?

[@aro4322]

@@user-jw5682 apparently yes

[@RobertJones-ux6nc]

I am 65 now and was watching this on the news the whole time it was happening from the liftoff to splashdown when the news permitted it to show on TV with my friend who dad in Houston worked for NASA as a electrical engineer there.

[@Sh4tterdL0g1c]

I can’t even begin to imagine the math and engineering it took to overcome this. This isn’t your phone freezing and having to reset it. There are some amazing minds in this world

[@user-pq4hg1bc2s]

Truly

[@Ms_Tania]

Not even a bag of rice would have helped! @''This isn’t your phone freezing and having to reset it''

[@theokguy9837]

Stolen comment

[@theokguy9837]

*THEY FAILED THEIR MISSION. THEIR MISSION WAS TO BE ON MARS* 👎🗑

[@Sh4tterdL0g1c]

@@theokguy9837 if it is, I’m truly unaware haha but good for you for living in the comment section

[@yueprime1411]

the people who calculated all that hand to hand. theyre amazing. its not that simple math

[@JuCarlos-ex8ip]

Very true 👍

[@mahiramajeed359]

its LITERALLY rocket science

[@TheBrownCoyote]

They were quite literally called computers back then

[@lovepaws9771]

Hidden figures

[@marya5931]

Calculating? They’re building formulas my man and just inputting digits. That’s simple my friend..

[@larrycooper7261]

I'm old enough to have watched this in real time. My 9th grade science teacher brought a television into the classroom, and we watched the splash down as it happened. The room was packed with people from other classes watching with us. The tension was beyond belief. There were more than a few of us saying prayers. We erupted in cheers and applause when we saw the astronauts. I'll never forget that feeling of pride mixed with relief! It truly was a successful failure.

[@francisjimenez6367]

i laughed while my heart is aching... the mixed emotions of knowing they lived after their suffering. maybe my first time. and that ending statement is perfect. the "succesful failure" is what got me.

[@thegrimsleeper7312]

Mission failed successfully

[@andrewprofilet2541]

How did it feel when you found out nasa was fake

[@graygravity3856]

@@andrewprofilet2541 ?

[@Deadinsidebutalive]

@@andrewprofilet2541 mindfucked tbh 🫠

[@karenrisler7400]

Thanks!

[@chetanhiwrale2220]

Moral of the story is "never give up even if it seems impossible"

[@muhammadhafizbinmahadzir8732]

@@guywhoasked6046 "seems impossible" and theoretically impossible is different things kid.

[@muhammadhafizbinmahadzir8732]

@@guywhoasked6046 joke and serious is different karen

[@2validvtxpn254]

@@guywhoasked6046 imagine arguing over a video that’s supposed to be good lmao generation alpha is fucked 😂

[@big4head381]

So I am supposed to never give y- me up?

[@krishnia764]

@@guywhoasked6046 your joke was lame so u r,

[@45k-u7d]

There’s a reason you have to go through extreme schooling and education to be apart of nasa.. for situations like this. Much respect

[@deidremsibi571]

I don’t think God created space so that mankind could go and explore! I think from now on mankind should just STAY ON EARTH! we have no business going to space

[@PizzaBox653]

why though, I get Earth being beautiful and hosting us, but I think to progress as a species, we should start advancing towards space colonization.

[@borncomatose]

@@deidremsibi571 while I personally don't believe in any deity or god of any kind, we'll need another planet to move to someday wayyyy later into the future if we humans want to continue living. Exploring space as of right now? Maybe that's not completely needed but the more information we gather the more we'll have years down the line

@@deidremsibi571 I mugged a homeless woman and sent her to the hospital and gave her a bed #godsplan

[@Sinnohy]

@@deidremsibi571 cringe

[@lindanoakes9170]

I was 13 years old and watched this, it was 3 months after my Dad had died. I can't believe that this year it will be 52 years ago.

[@leeroyjenkins3474]

@kiran seth obviously north American

[@sacrilege8943]

sorry for you loss

[@jeffscully5043]

@kiran seth Ireland

[@rodolfoflores4307]

I was born in 2013 but my mom died on the September 11 attacks, I like equals one prayer 🙏 .

[@rodolfoflores4307]

I have another one...

[@Link-ik4ww]

The fact that we got them home is easily one of the greatest feats humanity has accomplished. The hero’s on the ground and in the spacecraft are insane amounts of brave, smart and focused. What a genuine amazement.

[@alchemY.420]

🐑

[@devynguyette9365]

I can only imagine how scary that is but astronauts are literally a different breed to be able to stay calm and not have a panic attack is literally mind blowing good job apollo 13

[@RyanlovesTh]

The good effect of months (or years ) of training

[@aravinds3846]

That's why they are astronauts. You have to be the best of the best at science, you have to be calm and collected under stress, and you have to think fast.

[@Bung22]

Wtf is your pfp it’s 3 am 🥲

[@kikisoyoga6082]

I can only imagine what it must’ve been like to enter earths atmosphere and finally breathe natural air and see the ocean. I would’ve cried tbh

[@KhushiSingh-xx8zr]

Cried ai would've prayed to God everyday thanking Him and all those engineers for saving me

[@NiSiochainGanSaoirse]

I'm sure they did. That was a truly unprecedented event, and they survived the closest thing to impossible that human brains can comprehend. Nobody else had been ina situation anything remotely like this ever before.. I'm sure they shed a few tears when the capsule opened.

[@pqr6614]

Coming home

[@shb5169]

What do u mean by natural air? 🧘‍♂️

[@Dont-Refer-to-me]

@@shb5169Air not being given through air tanks Edit: i’m stupid. Air isnt given through tanks on a spaceship.

[@amsy-q4y]

It's so impressive that none of them panicked. I'm sure they were absolutely horrified and thought they were going to die, but they kept calm and powered through. It cut very close, them surviving is one of the most lucky things I have seen. It would be so scary, especially getting to the atmosphere knowing that you make it that far just to burn up in the atmosphere of the earth. They showed incredible determination, mental strength and intelligence.

[@Justin-qe6gj]

noob

[@kinglugus90]

@@Justin-qe6gj you normal?

[@evo2542]

it seemed they weren't because at the end of the talk he said it really was fun because by the time they were there they had already practiced everything 1000s of times.

[@starrcompany3275]

Couldn't of said it better myself👍🏿😉

[@christinemusselman5499]

No panicking. Because, like the Mercury astronauts, they had the Right Stuff.

[@sat_37]

This gave me chills! We truly live on the giant shoulders of thousands of predecessors and their collective goodness. Never stop being grateful. ❤

[@peterwilliams2152]

I've heard the story of Apollo 13 from the Soviet side, my wife's uncle was the GRU interpreter when things went wrong, and he was watch on, stop on, until they landed. The Soviets offered any and all help to bring them home, and apparently checked all of NASA's calculations for possible errors. They probably had their own reasons for a successful recovery, but the USA and USSR could work together. My wife's uncle changed his attitude to the USA when he heard the genuine anguish and concern of Mission Control.

[@israelisjeshuas7009]

That’s very nice to hear. Thanks Peter.

[@Melvin-14]

@@CalebBerman bro wrote the decleration of independence about something that doesnt exist

[@collectiusindefinitus6935]

@Caleb Berman To everyone reading this , quick question to ask you. Has anyone ever told you that the universe is indifferent to you and has no plan in particular for your life, and if you were to die right now , do you know for a fact your matter would decompose and put back into the earth? I want to tell you that general scientific consensus says that all have formed from evolution and thermodynamics may mean that death of anything that creates or consumes energy is inevitable through the constant loss of energy. But mass conservation is absolute , and the universe will continue without you. There is no confession , no decision , no belief , no prayer that will alter this outcome. Well, that is unless I’m wrong.

[@silverbowftw5225]

Awww

[@dreamkitty]

stop lying.

[@Pancakegr8]

Jeeze stories like this make me realize how little I’ve been challenged and how little I’ve accomplished.

[@jangxx]

Maybe try to find interesting challenges for yourself? That's what I'm often doing when I'm bored and over time you can gather a lot of experience in a variety of topics.

[@Soraviel]

Lol, it's called coming out of your comfort zone

[@3lrancho]

Been bullshiting too much on fb and youtube

[@fluxypoo]

Sure you have, it's just been a different set of life challenges.

[@warsin8641]

Just do what you want. Many people were also not doing anything at the time this mission was going on. You’ve probably already done more than most people back then

[@LanceHarbor_]

I get scared if my check engine light pops on while I’m driving. How the hell could these guys keep their composure? Truly incredible

[@B711HD]

U get scared for a check engine light? I been driving with them for years

[@jordysrevenge]

i get absolutely terrified when i see the oil light 💀

[@ginnundso]

This reminds me of Sheldon Cooper

[@tiara5118]

@@jordysrevenge I will have them to you tomorrow for you

[@Menibor1]

I've never owned a car that didn't have the check engine light on

[@Djbrink]

Basically the moral of the story is don’t panic because that doesn’t solve anything

[@Grimnir_x]

The fact we got them back safe and alive is more impressive than it would have been to see them land on the Moon.

[@jetlay-fl6so]

Who is we 😂

[@rowdyyates4273]

The fact that people are easily fooled believing this obvious hoax to keep people interested in space travel is kinda sad!

[@rowdyyates4273]

No proof of this so called event ever happening? Usual fake news from NASA! Still no one has gone anywhere near the moon Recently NASA told the world to keep away from the “Landing sites” really why? Could it be that they are not there?

[@AndreuszVII]

​@@jetlay-fl6so Humanity.. duh

[@max1milli96]

@@jetlay-fl6sowe meaning humanity. It was an incredible feat for humanity.

[@D_Lion96]

Humans working alongside each other with only 1 goal in mind, to bring 3 men back home safely. Apollo 13 wasn't a disaster, it was a lesson.

[@silentmonk7338]

Or a miracle

[@Stonktradomus]

It was a disastrous lesson.

[@zeverly6802]

@It doesn’t matter What your name is a lesson to never give up and always d try when you feel at a loss.

[@hwangraphy5]

@It doesn’t matter What your name is The lesson: Giving up is a guarantee way to failure.

[@johnnyapoliyo421]

that's so communist. An un-american thing.

[@samirangogoi7742]

Who else thought that these three men had perished in space untill one of the crew's older version started speaking..

[@heb1cleoo]

Classic ! That's what I thought

[@bbillyddave]

Yeah me !! Hhhah that Lovell guy spoke I was like but the video sais 3 men lost in space wtf

[@AneeshChowdhury]

Watch the movie Apollo 13 staring Tom Hanks

[@appointmentnow6255]

I had the most pleasant surprise, I was in awe of what was happening and didn't read the name subtitle.of the person speaking, I thought it was a nasa employee on earth assisting with the flight coordination, I didn't know these men survived until I saw the most experienced of the three walking in with a smile. Wow what an amazing feat. If anyone needs more inspiration than this, there think box isn't working.

[@jonathanodude6660]

damn people are really starting to forget what happened

[@ceerstar851]

It's actually amazing how smart some humans are. Especially what can be done with a very large number of very intellegent people.

[@sabeenjafri3440]

These are the types of stories you don’t wanna hear before going to space

[@thatguykai479]

Jeff bezos would have been shitting bricks if he was showed this before space

[@mason5013]

yeah because everyone goes to space on a daily basis

[@YouTuber-2077]

Share this to Jeff Bezos

[@thatguykai479]

@@KZbinr-2077 like he really would giv a fuck about what we have to say

[@syNdaking]

@@mason5013 you don’t?

[@amizzy55]

Mission Control: "We're bored to tears down here." Command module: Bet.

[@hahqhrhdwi9520]

😭😭

[@glovepro1256]

There would be the least amount of boredom physically possible for 3 days after that quote

[@SophisticatedDogCat]

Lmao.

[@juniorsir9521]

Was this the incident that inspired the movie Armageddon?

[@Maso777]

Literally 🤣

[@KingJerbear]

This is a miraculous story... I can't believe they don't teach us about stuff like this in school. Surely some incredible young scientists' passion would awaken hearing about this at a young age. Thanks for much for sharing

[@_.ndfwuuu_]

Exactly. They teach us about all things we don’t need but won’t about things we need to look out for

[@yourlocalfairy4244]

@@_.ndfwuuu_ fr

[@Nothing-kz9pj]

Mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell

[@thatrandomcat3479]

-b ± the square route to b² -4ac over 2a

[@yourlocalfairy4244]

@@thatrandomcat3479 THEY USED TO TEACH US THAT SONGGG ONG

[@darcyrosewilson]

This is far from a disaster. This is a miracle! Something horrible happened but these people survived in the most stressful situation I could imagine.

[@attilakovacs5803]

Bringing these guys back home was a bigger feat than putting them on the moon would've been. And all that 50 years ago, without a decent computer! Really an incredible rescue!👍❤️

[@donmunro144]

Amazing to think that our cell phones today have more computing power than the computer controlling that ship. Yet they over came and conquered. Nothing but respect for all involved.

[@charlestdennis2797]

They had to throw away the flight manual mid flight and create a new flight manual during the flight to get them home. They had to design, initiate, and run a completely new program to get them home alive.

[@ImmortalChanger]

@R Voit not compared to our newer ones, or even those that came out a few days later

[@ImmortalChanger]

Years, not days. I can’t edit the comment on KZbin web for some reason

[@rowdyyates4273]

The sheep are easily fooled on this hoax😂

[@omgurheadsgone]

Wowzers that was an intense watch.

[@burtonafonja1740]

Sure was..

[@iitsLuminous]

This man just said wowzers

[@omgurheadsgone]

@@iitsLuminous wowzers

[@Hjshssuii]

U have more than 100k subs why are u not vertived

[@omgurheadsgone]

@@Hjshssuii wasn’t as easy to get verified back when I was an active KZbinr

[@srishtttiii]

Imagine doing such a complicated and complex calculation without failing under so much stress and pressure !🤯

[@srishtttiii]

@John Smith Much easier In that case they need not do any calculation they just have to pretend

[@raquelrock9132]

*Daft punk's "Human after all" begins to play*

[@HrishikeshDas17]

@John Smith flat earther spotted oh hoo...

[@T00-f2g]

@John Smith what

[@animeguy4640]

Look if you think the moon landing is fake you better get an iq test. Do you think 400 thousand people have the will to lie to the world? Or the stuff left in the moon like the light reflectors, with the right equipment you can see it too. And if you think the iss isnt real get a telescope and search google on when will the iss will appear on the sky

[@nuclear_nkr]

Excellent narration. Your voice truley conveyed the weight and the imminence of every moment. The story telling was always consistent and it had me on the edge of my seat. You simplified the recordings and made the message clear. Truly well made! Great video u got yourself a new sub🙏🏻

[@goldengriffon]

Ironically, if he hadn't done his little "joke" of stirring the oxygen tanks when he did, they may have exploded later into the mission...at a point that could have made recovery impossible.

[@Mat-in6gy]

time?

[@fathur2563]

@@Mat-in6gy it's 3.39 pm here in Indonesia

[@SageXVIX]

@@fathur2563 lmao

[@znotchill]

@@fathur2563 lool

[@tony3900able]

🤣🤣

[@Lanathecoquetteembodiment]

The literal embodiment of "Mission failed successfully"

[@trevorbeatz5741]

Yes

[@succhar1161]

Indeed

[@mcnub7379]

Lmao yes

[@cadensauerbrey9005]

This is still the single greatest feat of engineering ever. It's incredible how the guys on the ground were able to problem solve so quickly and so well.

[@iitzfizz]

Oh definitely. The engineering is the amazing thing for me. Imo that's the hard part...the rocket science is comparatively easy.

[@bsharwill]

It’s truly unbelievable. I think all engineers are brilliant. They have to be to think of inventions/ solutions like this🤯

[@amazingflavour]

The amount of balls this takes for every single person involved is crazy. Real bad asses

[@seleneoana]

Never underestimate the power of plastic bags, cardboard and duct tape!

[@NIkki-ox1ej]

This is why my purse is always heavy, I have things in case of emergency. My husband still doesn't get this though...

[@eunwoovrs1715]

it’s always good to be prepared!

[@mohiththiyagu6217]

@John Smith shut up man

[@nicerecruit4216]

@John Smith Let's send you up to space and see how you do lol. Oh wait they don't send idiots up there.

[@thomasd1793]

@@NIkki-ox1ej it's heavy and everything you need is always somewhere at the bottom lol

[@jamzee_]

Ive met and talked with Fred Haise several times, and we’ve almost always talked about the flight. Nowadays he says he’s thought of the whole incident as a learning lesson. He’s mentioned at least twice that he was disappointed that he never made it to the moon, but the man always has a smile on his face when discussing it. Personally, i think he’s just happy to have been part of 13 and a part of history. Got a few photos of me hugging him. Man is the most interesting person I’ve ever met. And theres no words to describe how much respect I have for the man. Altho his lil prank was what made them notice they had a problem. Yknow… after creating one…

[@jojstar4]

🤡

[@shebahammy]

🤡

[@joshuaking8512]

🤡

[@proteg30]

🤡

[@someguythatplaysgd5482]

🤡

[@flashh112362]

I cant imagine the feeling of being hundreds of thousands of miles away from home in the vacuum of space knowing that you may not make it back. Insane.

[@gregoryhauserman5927]

Sounds fun

[@mywifesboyfriend5741]

The astronauts knew there were risks. They acted professionally in a terrible situation, and survived.

[@Kongobongoes2007]

@@gregoryhauserman5927 Yeah you're so cool aren't you.

[@gregoryhauserman5927]

@@Kongobongoes2007 2kewl

[@gregoryhauserman5927]

@@beerad9073 I said it sounds fun and now you’re threatening physical assault. Gee Willikers!

[@melanieedwards1124]

Phenomenal! The anxiety I experienced while watching this reviting video was sky high. Such an amazing story, and such a blessing their team was able to help them get back home safely.

[@SerPapus]

Another free video by the GOAT ColdFusion keep it up man. These videos are just so well put together.

[@darshitdesai]

What does GOAT stand for?

[@SerPapus]

@@darshitdesai greatest of all time

[@rollover36]

@@dionricky 'cause its 2021?

[@PP-xs7hu]

Try boofing

[@PP-xs7hu]

@@dionricky shur up kid

[@somedude3887]

The amount of stress the engineers must have experienced surely wasn’t healthy for them, like I can’t imagine having to do the calculations right pretty much first try and knowing that if I get a number wrong it could cause someone to lose their life

[@MangelBanselmo]

@It doesn’t matter What your name is 😂😂😂

[@somipax]

well, that s the reason why not anyone can go to space

[@myuudee]

Aside from engineers, there were people they call "calculators" back then.

[@bobsmith6538]

A few of the engineers became alcoholics and I understand one committed suicide by driving on to railroad tracks in front of a train. But this was after Apollo 1 burned up on the launch pad.

[@assersheuyange1190]

And their chance of surving was utterly uncertain for three looooooooong days. So stressful!

[@eliemrad7]

i am an engineer and I am amazed of the exact calculations, communication and the whole accident. this is a great real film

[@thepizzaman2013]

because it happened

[@iplayzthegames6968]

Same, I studied mathematics I can't fathom making calculations for such a precise margin on such a massive scale

[@hugoland9027]

yeah that’s why there is the saying “it’s not rocket science”

[@diadem03destiny29]

There’s 3 people in a room and 1 of them is an engineer. How do you know which is the engineer?? ????????? How??? == he will tell you lol

[@itszoe2913]

@Abran Atmos Unrelated but Jesus loves you Have an amazing day

[@kristannestone1748]

This proves that the whole world CAN come together. We can do it again.

[@Jerrycourtney]

We certainly _can,_ but considering World War 3 and civil warn in the US and Western Europe are looming, I don’t think coming together is in anyone’s interest- at least in our lifetimes.

[@never_give_up90]

The issue is a few ppl in power. We have some pretty bad people in power right now. The right people make a big difference. It's not humanity, it's the people who are given the power to control large populations.

[@dannyz4232]

I legit cried they touched down. Life-saving engineering feat by both the astronauts and the mission control.

[@lydiamaria6249]

I cried too

[@abbytheredwolf174]

The fact that the computer was basically less then a Nokia phone is crazy to think it made it into space and to think how far we’ve come sense then

[@Dergable]

"Task failed successfully" - An Apollo story.

[@ALLCAPS]

In programming we call that a try catch or an exception

[@trevorbeatz5741]

lol

[@davixoxo4227]

To stay calm and think logically in such a situation is commendable. Humans can be incredible sometimes. The will to live is so strong it's actually incredible, so glad they got home ❤

[@the_primal_instinct]

- A rookie, who left his wife and 3 kids... - oO - ... on Earth. - Jesus, ColdFusion.

[@arisoda]

Definitely cold

[@1_visje34]

@@arisoda oh god...

[@jasonjones5009]

Yeah I was like wtf lol

[@PORRRIDGE_GUN]

Well he couldn't fucking take them along for the ride, could he!

[@brianarbenz1329]

Nixon cut the NASA budget to prevent adding four seats to the Command Module for the Haise family.

[@mlee81]

Imagine being thousands of miles from earth with three guys floating in a tin can cold low on water and oxygen and thinking "did we bring the duct tape"?

[@brcleaningcompany2566]

Not the place for anything close to funny or a joke but that’s just me,, i hope you have a blessed day

[@tinor9591]

@@brcleaningcompany2566 go and touch some grass

[@brcleaningcompany2566]

@@tinor9591 ha! Funny you said that, let’s not get into who you’ve been Touching,,,,,,,,,,,,

[@gummi1203]

@@yoyovlogs5229 you must be real fun at parties huh

[@shadow.4997]

@@gummi1203 they just party poopers lmao

[@miss__atomic__bomb]

I’m in awe at the bravery, composure and brilliance of these men and everyone else who helped them. WOW

[@needlethread4715]

you never know how brave you are, until being brave is your only choice.

[@rickysukhi]

wow, I never thought they'd make it back but they did. Incredible engineering.

[@maxsmith695]

lol, sure.

[@sushantchopra01]

This deserves an Oscar in storytelling.

[@austintinoC00l]

It won 2 Oscars

[@mrsoshadabaadman]

@@austintinoC00l Perhaps young master Shushant wasn't aware it was a big budged drama.

[@SakshiSingh-vu6bt]

@@austintinoC00l perhaps he intended to laurel ColdFusion

[@TheIdiotDonut]

@@austintinoC00l yup. It even got Woody to act in it.

[@TheIdiotDonut]

@@austintinoC00l *B A H*

[@ClownWorldRebel]

One of the most incredible survival stories ever told. Thank God those men made it back.

[@Justachillguuyyyyyyy]

Is there really a survival story better than this one? Lol

[@debragentry1601]

They were in God's hands!

[@erikarobinson3557]

@@debragentry1601 NO DOUBT ABOUT THAT!

[@langleybeliever7789]

No Gods hands are not on deceivers, God ( THE LORD JESUS CHRIST) still provides and is a very patient GOD. But the Judgements are coming.

[@Treemeadow]

​@@Justachillguuyyyyyyy the Andes Plane Crash survival is pretty impressive oh and that guy who was left, thought dead after falling into a glacier, and dragged himself out and down with two broken legs oh and Aron Ralston! oh and Thai football team of boys, 10 days stranded in pitch black cave, foubd alive ..that rescue pt process United the world

[@John_Notmylastname]

One of the most incredible accomplishments in science and engineering ever in my opinion.

[@elijahstuffs]

I legit thought that they would have died in the debris of space. Instead they made it back. Now that's an epic win. Yeah landing on the moon is all cool and everything, but bringing these peoplehome back safely, against all the odds is epic.

[@brega6286]

These three are true heros ! And all the ground crew too ! Also, all the prayers definitely helped because so much went wrong and so many lethal things were looming.

[@knight764]

a nice detail was that Russia said that they would help the crew if they found them after splash down.

[@norfolksouthernrailfan5136]

That’s a new one.

[@nabawi7]

Only to steal the command module and NASA technology

[@youraverageyoutubecommente5988]

@@nabawi7 can’t something be nice for what

[@paultom8905]

@@nabawi7 just remind who was pioneer in space….

[@castle_novelist]

@@nabawi7 NASA started with Hitler's Nazi, so Russians aren't stealing anything since Americans stole it from Germans. **Werner von Braun

[@skullzalliances]

It's crazy times of strife like these people around the world forget about boundaries, race and religion and just have one common hope and goal

[@r_quiem6288]

@Hi twitter: *anger*

[@jacobhqgaming6262]

@Hi aaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy very noice

[@rabbid3433]

@@jacobhqgaming6262 soldier, what are you doing here? push the fucking payload!

[@jacobhqgaming6262]

@Hi yes I also avoid and don't have twitter

[@cremapastelera00]

humans are the only species that care about dumb things like religion and another human's skin color or features anyway

[@Thundersnowy]

This was captivating! This story shows how badly the world needs good engineers. The movie 'Apollo 13' with Tom Hanks is so worth the watch if you haven't seen it. I feel like I was with them. Also, as they sling shotted themselves around the dark side of the moon, they had to calculate the trajectory. There was no communication with Houston during that time. Those were long hours. That minute while they were reentering the atmosphere, and they said nothing, was an eternity.

[@doreenlloyd4885]

I have watched that film many times. I could probable recite it, but I still hold my breath at the end.

[@ironkebabyes7974]

@@doreenlloyd4885 is it on Netflix?

[@Maxel53]

@@ironkebabyes7974 it is!

[@theokguy9837]

*THEY FAILED THEIR MISSION. THEIR MISSION WAS TO BE ON MARS* 👎🗑

[@lichi_aries]

@@theokguy9837If you r going to be here to hate on them, u have no reason to be here

[@beckycoe7997]

I remember when this happened. Going to the moon on this particular trip wasn't even broadcast on TV. People seemed to not care about it anymore. I never heard about it til it came on TV that three men on a trip to the moon might very well be lost in space. This got the attention of the whole world. I remember watching with anticipation for their reentry. All eyes around the world on the TV. And oh the happy relief of their safe landing. God answered everyone's prayers 🙏

[@Pat315]

God didn't do shit. It was the men at NASA who saved them.

[@ironman20150]

No, the people at NASA saved them. Not god. God isn’t real.

[@thatsjustthegame9175]

Being lost in space would be terrifying. These 3 men are incredible human beings.

[@extrm161]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aniZlmeKlq-roas 1:09..

[@obaid.h]

"It is not possible. No, it's necessary." This dialogue originally belongs here.

[@rociodelgado6914]

"Do not go gentle into that good night...

[@somipax]

?

[@rociodelgado6914]

@@somipax it's A quote

[@ikli7710]

@@somipax watch Interstellar

[@APRBaller]

Literally one of my favorite movie quotes of all time 👌🏽

[@yearight5303]

"Left his wife and 3 kids on earth" Where was he supposed to leave them?

[@ArtbySheeHenna]

Hahah true

[@lilizaman]

Lol seriously

[@alex2005z]

On the moon obviously

[@cheapishlyexpensive3476]

He was supposed to bring them to heaven, just as he has promised.

[@JennWest-Liberty]

Lol!

[@PENITENT1991]

Verry emotional after watching this well put together content left me with tears

[@gregharbin3531]

A Successful Failure? More like a prime example of "Improvisation, Adaptation and Overcoming Adversity " through teamwork and rational thought when things go wrong. Sincere respect and admiration to both the Apollo 13 flight crew and the Houston ground crews that "worked the problem" and successfully got those brave men home.

[@Sanctus_Manifesto]

Propaganda,it never happened.

[@gmg6863]

@@Sanctus_Manifesto good that you know, but the USSR would have would have pointed it out

[@ImmortalChanger]

A successful failure is a failure that we respond to correctly, and is a very important lesson

[@confuseddog6746]

@@Sanctus_Manifesto propaganda for who? literally, even the enemies of america helped.

[@sadhu7191]

They literally went farther then planned. Succes.

[@pragashgnana597]

Honestly I have so much respect for rocket scientists and the crew members. At a time where we didn't have to computational capacity to run all those calculations they did it by hand. This amazes me and gives me a profound interest in physics

[@rowdyyates4273]

Hoax I’m afraid 😱

[@KhushiSingh-xx8zr]

They are superhuman to me

[@rowdyyates4273]

Maybe it should give you a profound interest in science fiction!

[@rowdyyates4273]

@@KhushiSingh-xx8zrit’s all in your mind!

[@rowdyyates4273]

@@KhushiSingh-xx8zr super cunning?

[@vma1030]

just imagine, at the heat of the moment, you miss out on a single digit in the computation.. Damn the anxiety level is unimaginable..

[@johnoneill2661]

Calculations were being done by many, and checked for the same answers.

[@yourlocalflatiron6124]

Damn

[@ricoy.9258]

Yeah, but I'm sure that they checked those calculations hundreds of times, and had others look over them as well. After all, they are rocket scientist.

[@blancspaze]

@@ricoy.9258 yeah but still the anxiety level would be high as fk

[@reality5199]

What? You miss out on a single digit? Well Viktor who doesn't care or know who you are; What digit are you talking about that's missing??????????????????? You guessing or what? This comment feels like he knows to much but sadly he's a nobody and he should stop pretending he knows about space and shit. damn failure

[@douggaudiosi14]

The parallels to the situation that is happening right now with the boeing men stranded in space is palpable