I think for a young artists orchestra its actually pretty stunning. The only bad part is 04:42 the transition from Throne room theme to end Credits.
@PatoChu Жыл бұрын
oh come on, somebody made a mistake there during the transition, but these people are VERY young and that single mistake doesn't make it bad
@Marcus_Berger1701 Жыл бұрын
@@PatoChu When you like something (i said they are stunning), you criticize it so it becomes even better. They are old enough to take criticism and improve through it.
@PatoChu Жыл бұрын
@@Marcus_Berger1701 I went to John Williams and Gustavo Dudamell’s concert and not even the orchestra in there was perfect. Who cares if there’s a tiny mistake, nobody is perfect and that’d be inhuman
@Marcus_Berger1701 Жыл бұрын
@@PatoChu I care if there is a tiny mistake at a transition which is the highlight of a composition. Haven't you read my comments. Its so typical. Either you are 100% for something or you are declared as being 100% against it by others. I already stated that i like this youth orchestra. I listened to over 25 performances of "Throne room" and already said that this one is one of the better performances. But i really would like to see those young musicians to improve even further.
@PatoChu Жыл бұрын
@@Marcus_Berger1701 You should be constructively criticizing then. But you are basically saying "I DONT LIKE THAT" as if you were hating on them for making a mistake as we all do. You could instead rephrase your original comment to say something more like "This part could definitely be improved" or 'This part is almost perfect if it weren't by this or that"