Tibet uprising 1959 - Cold War DOCUMENTARY

Claim your SPECIAL OFFER for MagellanTV here: try.magellantv.com/thecoldwar. Start your free trial TODAY so you can watch the First Emperor: The Man who Made China and the rest of MagellanTV’s history collection: www.magellantv.com/video/firs...
Our historical documentary series on the history of the Cold War continues with a video on the Tibet Uprising of 1959, and in the aftermath of the takeover of Tibet by China ( • How China Annexed Tibe... ), various groups rise to fight the PLA troops off.
How China Annexed Tibet: • How China Annexed Tibe...
Taiwan Under the Kuomintang Dictatorship: • Taiwan Under the Kuomi...
What Happened to the German and Japanese POWs?: • What Happened to the G...
Operation Paperclip: • Operation Paperclip - ...
German Expulsions: • German Expulsions Afte...
Soviet Education System: • Soviet Education Syste...
How Khrushchev Fed the Soviet People: • How Khrushchev Fed the...
Novocherkassk Massacre 1962: • Novocherkassk Massacre...
Soviet Tourism: • Soviet Tourism: How di...
Soviet Passport System: New Serfdom or Reform?: • Soviet Passport System...
Kaliningrad: How Russia Got a Stronghold in Europe: • Kaliningrad: How Russi...
How the Soviets Won the Early Space Race: • How the Soviets Won th...
Soviet Television and Radio: • Soviet Television and ...
Top-5 Myths About the Soviet Union: • Top-5 Myths About the ...
Support us on Patreon: / thecoldwar
KZbin membership / @thecoldwartv
✔ Merch store ► teespring.com/stores/thecoldwar
✔ Patreon ► / thecoldwar
✔ Facebook ► / thecoldwartv
✔ Instagram ► / thecoldwartv
#ColdWar #Tibet #China #Uprising

[@dreamadventure8220]

Oh Tibet, my ancestoral land, even though we crossed the Himalaya and settled in this new land centuries ago, we never forgot you. The tibetic language is still in our lips and warmth of "Chupa" Still is the best comfort for us. What an tragedy has fall upon you my mother Tibet, we will keep you alive in our memories, lips and heart like we did for centuries. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@kenbolder4688]

A tragedy indeed, and bad luck for all the people who have to remain there and live under Chinese dictators.

[@fzmoifzmoi2575]

@@kenbolder4688 Is that why the dalai lama was a representative of China's highest law making body????? Get informed before speaking. And i bet the person above isn't a descendant of serfs!!!!🤣

[@kenbolder4688]

@@fzmoifzmoi2575 ambassodor of the CCP talks like radio Peking 🤡🤡🐒🐒

[@ekmalsukarno2302]

The Cold War, can you please make a video on Françafrique, which is basically France's Monroe Doctrine approach towards Africa. I want you to make a video on this topic, since the concept of Françafrique dates back to the Cold War era.

[@Game_Hero]

or to quote actuality "sphere of influence" which sucks around the world and militarily invaded countries knows this well.

[@magellantv]

We were waiting for this one! Well done, as always 👏

[@skyhappy]

"We", bruh why do company marketing people act like they are not just one person speaking

[@edwardsnowden8821]

My God the rewriting of history in this video is beyond me. Political Tibet had absolutely nothing to do with Qinghai province or western Sichuan after the fall of the Qing dynasty. The map of tibet you used is false, as Qinghai and Tibet border was the ROC tibet border then. Jesus the lies in your video gives me migrane.

[@tonysia6474]

I loved to watch your channel. It's informative and I learned more. Thank you.

[@elvinsmatthew]

The Australians had some interesting small cold war actions and big ones like Korea and Vietnam. Small ones include the maylasian emergency, Indonesian confrontation and a action in Borneo. Would be good to see videos on them.

[@shanshajahan8160]

I love the host of this show and the way of presentation.. Absolutely, amazing 🎉❤

[@Numba003]

Thank you for another interesting episode! I know very little about Tibetan history in general, but specifically about before the Chinese annexation. Does anyone have any good resources they might recommend for further viewing / reading? Thank you in advance! God be with you out there everybody. ✝️ :)

[@meadc6754]

Look up interviews with former serfs. Their view is totally opposed to the view of the ruling classes, Monks and Nobility.

[@Gompotashikham]

You can read "The noodle maker of kalimpong". It displays the story of Tibet before, during and after the illegal occupation of Tibet in a very beautiful way.

[@raysky2000]

入侵？你没病吧？西藏在元朝就是中国的一部分，而且是西藏主动要求加入的。离今天有1600年之久了！

[@NukeWalker]

What is the name of the track playing at the very end of each video? I've been trying to find it for ages, but can't even Shazam it because the app gets thrown off by the voice in the foreground.

[@taf-apn]

"Heroes Will Fall" by Bonnie Grace.

[@NukeWalker]

@@taf-apn Thank you so much!

[@BeGunNer]

Wow I had no idea this happened. Crazy.

[@sld1776]

What's the name of the autro song? It's so iconic.

[@meejinhuang]

Then the PLA came in to commit atrocities against the monks to quell the uprising much like the Uyghur uprising.

[@edwardsnowden8821]

this video is propaganda bs

[@denvergamingzone9766]

​@@edwardsnowden8821🐷

[@tianlezheng6829]

胡说八道 藏独分子才是搞暴乱和奴隶制的

[@ouyangon5711]

In a theocratic country, monks are the aristocratic privileged class. In a communist society, they are not willing to have their interests and rule deprived of them, and of course they will choose to resist.

[@fzmoifzmoi2575]

You mean the monks that had all disregard of the treatment of serfs? LOL You're absolutely b-washed. These uprisings 100% percent guaranteed were not by the serfs, it was and always still is the elites that loved the theocratic caste system. This C👁️‍🗨️A lamma is a disgrace to humanity!

[@user-nd4qz4dh1n]

By the way, in 1956 the Khamba Tibetans were already launched a rebellion. The PLA had send their Tu-4 bomber to strike Tibetans during the rebellion. The rebellion directly led to the rupture of the relationship between the CCP and Tibetans, which in turn led to the great suppression of Tibet in 1959. To give an example to illustrate why the Tibetans in the Khampa area launched a rebellion: In 1949, the Kangding area, the capital of Khampa during the Kuomintang rule, had to collect about 35 tons of grain tax a year. By 1955, the total amount of grain tax collected by the CCP in Kangding reached 325 tons (In just six years, the grain tax has increased nearly tenfold! ). The total grain output and population of Kangding area (the county's population is only about 100,000) have not increased significantly in these years, but the grain tax increased enormously that led to a great famine. Absolutely, the rebellion caused by heavy taxation by CCP. If the Tibetans did not want to starve to death, they had no choice but to rebel. The insurgency led to a crackdown to all Tibetans not only Khampa but also Amdo and U-Tsang by the CCP. For example, Gao Feng, the Secretary of the Qinghai Provincial Party Committee of CCP, was calling for "Smothering the rebellion before Tibetans premeditated" in 1959 - we all know what that means. Judging from the results, the 1959-1962 repression was extremely cruel. One county lost 60% of its population in the most brutal area of the crackdown - including executions, forced migration, etc. To be honest, the efficiency of killing is much higher than Pol Pot's(well, Elon Musk) Khmer Rouge. Repression in some areas has resulted in a 2:8 male-to-female ratio in Tibet (Then came the influx of Chinese male immigrants and intermarriage with these Tibetan women who had lost their fathers and husbands to "promote ethnic integration" - we have to recall the brutal story of the slaughter of men and the ravages of women during Genghis Khan's conquest). According to some internal battle reports of the PLA, when the "rebels" were suppressed, a "rebel army" of more than 10,000 fighters had only more than 3,000 knives, spears and firearms combined - it is not difficult to imagine that most "Rebels" are unarmed farmers and herdsmen. The so-called "liberating serfs and overthrowing serf owners" is even more ironic. In order to suppress the Tibetan people, the Tibetan people are generally designated as "serf owners". In the most exaggerated part of Hainan Prefecture, Qinghai Province, 90% of the population is classified as "serf owners"-- It is completely unimaginable how 90% of the slave owners enslaved 10% of the serfs! Under the bloody repression, Tibet achieved "complete liberation". But we must admit that not all Chinese are bad people. A senior commander of the VFF appearing in the video is a PLA Major. He was unwilling to implement the CCP's policy of suppressing the Tibetans and chose to join in VFF. Also, these information above is from the book "When The Iron Bird Flies" by Li Jianglin, who is a daughter of a senior CCP official. Its information is derived from the CCP's internal reports, statistics, official confidential documents, etc. She hopes to let the world know CCP's persecution of Tibetans.

[@user-nd4qz4dh1n]

Well guys, I know the Ganden Phodrang regime in Tibet is a very pre-modern brutal theocracy, but after we saw the CCP's genocide in Tibet, I have to say that the land suffered so many fucking disasters that you can't argue that the CCP's genocidal rule of Tibet is "modern" and "progressive" in order to oppose the barbaric and badass rule of Ganden Phodrang. In the eyes of any Tibetan, the only difference between the theocracy of Ganden Phodrang and the rule of the CCP is that one is skinning you from the top of your head to the bottom of your feet, and the other is skinning you from the bottom of your feet to the top of your head. The barbarism of the theocratic government cannot be used as an excuse to defend the CCP, nor can the CCP's genocide atrocities be used to cheer for the "defense of our theocracy in Tibet."

[@edwardsnowden8821]

Qinghai province has being its own entity for ages before the fall of the qing dynasty, it was officially made a province by the government of the Republic of China in 1923 with Ma bufang as its governor. Qinghai province even went to war with the unrecognized Tibet at thier border several times with the Qinghainese crushing them on several occasions, then how the heck is Qinghainese territory shown as part of Tibet territory in your video with you claiming Qinghai Gansu boundary as the Tibet china official boundary? my God your propaganda is tooo much😂😂 i remove my hat for you.

[@user-nd4qz4dh1n]

​@@edwardsnowden8821 I must remind you that Qinghai's establishment as a province does not mean that it is a region with the Han as the main population before the 1960s led by Mao Zedong's large -scale population immigration (and catastrophic ecological destruction). Qinghai's must Most people are Tibetans, followed by various Muslims before 1949. Althrough, the Tibetans and Hui muslims had many wars and massacres. The situation of Khampas was same with Qinghai (or Amdo in Tibetan language), the most population in Kham(or Xikang in Chinese language) are Tibetan, but it's a 'province' of China while there are considerable number of Tibetan uprising during 1956-1965. Under your logic, I think the suppression of CCP to Khampas in Xikang Province (and later Sichuan Province) is not "the suppression of the Tibetans", but "the suppression of the Tibetans in China" -ridiculous! Are there any difference? Can they be suppressed because they have Chinese nationality instead of Tibetan nationality?

[@edwardsnowden8821]

@@user-nd4qz4dh1n the maker of this video is a propaganda expert. Qinghai has been a separate region from Tibet for ages. the republic of china only officially made that known in 1923 with its then government led by Governor/warlord Ma Qi. He falsely shows the Qinghainese territory as being Tibet, while lying and saying the political map of china when the PRC won against the ROC did not include Qinghai province, thereby removing the ma click from history altogether. its like showing the political map of Mexico and USA in 1957 with Texas, California and New Mexico shown as Mexican territory on the map. The map he used is wrong and only serves his propaganda and rewritting of history. other channels 10000 times better than this will show the actual reality on the ground.

[@edwardsnowden8821]

@@user-nd4qz4dh1n Genocide my butt. what was the population of political Tibet after the prc crossed the de facto border at chamdo vs now.

[@mohammedsaysrashid3587]

Super informative documentary coverage about Tibet issues during cold War 🥶 period

[@edwardsnowden8821]

Qinghai province has being its own entity for ages before the fall of the qing dynasty, it was officially made a province by the government of the Republic of China in 1923 with Ma bufang as its governor. Qinghai province even went to war with the unrecognized Tibet at thier border several times with the Qinghainese crushing them on several occasions, then how the heck is Qinghainese territory shown as part of Tibet territory in your video with you claiming Qinghai Gansu boundary as the Tibet china official boundary? my God your propaganda is tooo much😂😂 i remove my hat for you.

[@m.a.9571]

Would love to see you cover the Philippines in some way in the future ❤

[@Redneck2393]

He did a video on the Huk Rebellion about 3 years ago. Definitely an interesting part of history.

[@SamVillano]

David, excellent video again. I would really like to have you include sources in the description for further reading. Also, you’re clearly an expert on these topics. Any chance we could get a bio in the video/channel description?

[@jackcross4895]

Do the work yourself, this is clearly an introductory work. You clearly are smart so go read for yourself.

[@SamVillano]

@@jackcross4895 maybe you should do the work and not write run on sentences since you’re so smart.

[@TheSKAB]

Dragon in the land of snows by Tsering Shakya is probably the most comprehensive history of modern Tibet.

[@jamesurever3569]

@@kaligibbs3633 very hard to believe some random kiddy from the internet having doubts because he always has doubts

[@skyhappy]

​@@kaligibbs3633 KZbin is rife with this. Is dumb

[@tyq5775]

Despite its flaws, this video maker's explanation of Tibetan history is the most fair explanation I have seen so far. The author of the video breaks away from the standpoint of ideology and social systems, and his research on historical details is very thorough!

[@Seouldrift7]

I think something similar also occurred back in the 80's.

[@randomchannel-px6ho]

Damn you all have been covering some good topics. As of late. I'd love to see more videos on things like this were the likely western audience watching it will not be very familiar which the circumstances or possibly even the occurrence at all.

[@edwardsnowden8821]

Qinghai province has being its own entity for ages before the fall of the qing dynasty, it was officially made a province by the government of the Republic of China in 1923 with Ma bufang as its governor. Qinghai province even went to war with the unrecognized Tibet at thier border several times with the Qinghainese crushing them on several occasions, then how the heck is Qinghainese territory shown as part of Tibet territory in your video with you claiming Qinghai Gansu boundary as the Tibet china official boundary? my God your propaganda is tooo much😂😂 i remove my hat for you.

[@randomchannel-px6ho]

@Edward Snowden Perhaps you're replying to the wrong comment. I took no stance on any issues addressed in this video in my comment so I'm confused.

[@gaga-fp9hn]

PRC claims of liberating Tibet during invasion was absolutely ridiculous

[@fzmoifzmoi2575]

Ask the serfs! Lol unless you love the history of their abuse! Try paying taxes to those elite clowns because you had a child or getting beat, killed and even having your limbs hacked off!

[@icebaby6714]

I always like to watch your channel as you are telling the truth in history, not propaganda driven by ideology and not biased at all.😄👍

[@edwardsnowden8821]

Qinghai province has being its own entity for ages before the fall of the qing dynasty, it was officially made a province by the government of the Republic of China in 1923 with Ma bufang as its governor. Qinghai province even went to war with the unrecognized Tibet at thier border several times with the Qinghainese crushing them on several occasions, then how the heck is Qinghainese territory shown as part of Tibet territory in your video with you claiming Qinghai Gansu boundary as the Tibet china official boundary? my God your propaganda is tooo much😂😂 i remove my hat for you.

[@user-ft4lh1fw8l]

呵呵，你可以自己去西藏看看。就知道他说的完全是一派胡言

[@NYATRI]

@@edwardsnowden8821 you sound like every key board i have seen on this platform, your copying and pasting consistently the same thing instead of making your own comment you reply to others, and the funniest thing about your copy and paste is that it was " my god your propaganda is to much" that made me die laughing, a swell as your yt accounts description "A world student, who seeks understanding." like many other mass produced poster accounts , you have a half backed description that sounds like it was made using google translate - a world student ..... bro cringe , recommendations : international student, , who seeks understanding , you could have chosen an educator and scholar wishing to understand or what not , but no half baked acc, no pfp of any choice because that would be to much effort - no sources that you can site other then those directly linked to the ccp / roc and or their outlits

[@edwardsnowden8821]

@@NYATRI and "i love anime" take is not cringe 😬. my guy take a look in the mirror before writing a novel because you want to criticize someone. you talk about keyboard warrior yet your reply is the best representation of what a keyboard warrior does, i.e go after others for writing things you don't like. The map used in this video is wrong and better videos about the topic on KZbin and in sny academic records clearly shows this. if you cant do your own research but your instincts is to go all keyboard warrior on me then bring it on.

[@JesseJoyce-cj2xg]

@edwardsnowden8821 Not only are your posts heavily biased and misleading, but you repetitively copy and paste the same nonsense over and over until you are called out on it. I’m assuming that you don’t have a problem with what happened in Tiananmen Square in 1989, or with the genocide being carried out against the Uyghurs in East Turkestan, do you?

[@CARL_093]

i had watched that drama documentary i recommend fo you all to watched it

[@gedengcuo9260]

Tibet and Uyghurs will be free together as brothers in arms.Inshallah

[@GeneralGayJay]

Tibet needs to become indipendent again.

[@ouyangon5711]

Do you think the Tibetan people would like a theocratic country with serfdom? At the same time, Tibet, as a place with an average altitude of 4,000 meters, basically lost its modern foundation after independence. What awaits it will only be cold and hunger.

[@GeneralGayJay]

@@ouyangon5711 Let the people of Tibet take that decision and not force them to talk Chinese and supress their religion.

[@ouyangon5711]

You don’t understand Tibet at all. Don’t just listen to what the Western media says. If you have the opportunity, come and see Tibet for yourself.@@GeneralGayJay

[@Mrgunsngear]

Thanks

[@Nathan-jh1ho]

You're here

[@gangwu4541]

Wait a minute. Before the PRC took power in mainland china, the ROC aka Taiwan, already included Tibet in their territories officially. It even included ‘Outer Mongolia’ since it is the legal successor of the Qing empire which ruled over these territories. So what if PRC didn’t win the Chinese civil war in 1949, would the west still insist that ROC to release Tibet as an independent country? Very unlikely if you ask me.

[@Spacemongerr]

"The west" has never insisted that Tibet be released as an independent country, so you ask on false premises. It is just some regular citizens who want that, no western government has said this, they all recognize Tibet as a part of China.

[@jamesrussell5196]

You guys are such nerds

[@sansan2591]

Long live Tibet

[@easonhuang7117]

Tibet province

[@kionmkionm]

@@easonhuang7117 tibet is a country,just like taiwan

[@edwardsnowden8821]

@@kionmkionm and Hawaii

[@sansan2591]

@@edwardsnowden8821 and Wadiya

[@sansan2591]

@@easonhuang7117 only for now

[@IrtizaNadeem-jt8cn]

The Chinese in the comments are offended.

[@manos5782]

fax

[@ZZ-oc2eb]

Plz make a video about the Portuguese colonies fight for independence that surged during Portugal’s own independence war and down of their dictatorship which ended up helping the former colonies to get their freedom.

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

The justification i see from some pro prc people for tibet annexation is ridiculous. They would be first to remind usa and europe for its imperialism while justifying china imperialism in similar way. When coloniser used to say white man burdern it was seen as racist but when prc do its liberation

[@insaneclownponies9599]

Fr, people act like colonialism is different when the person doing it isn't white.

[@HoZk-qy5iv]

Wow if your comment was made by other that would be different thing but look indian making this comment haha . You said China imperialism would be first to talk about who , USA and Europe lol I think you mistakely put China instead of India because India always bring up this topic to blame Europe. When we talk about kalistan , Sikkim , north east . Haha so is it ok for indian to hold this annexation part but why you are so fast to point finger at china and feel ok when your nation annexation and as soon as some one point out it’s turn out to be racist

[@jamesurever3569]

Exactly, killing Chinese, Tibetans and others by the Chinese and by the millions seem to be not important for such Peking brains.

[@astroch]

Not even near the same. Tibet is nearby. Makes all the difference. Nobody says Scotland is a colony of UK, but HK was a colony of UK.

[@discospaghetti6744]

​@@astroch Scotland was not a colony because Scotland voluntarily formed the Union and their dynasty ruled both England and Scotland.

[@taidelek9994]

May the Dreams and Aspiration of Tibetans come True

[@95ellington]

Not a chance

[@ngawang4121]

​@@95ellingtoneverything is impermanence 🙏

[@dhondupgyatso7603]

👍👍🙏🏻❤️

[@drazen1529]

MSS has entered chat

[@victera]

#FreeTibet

[@OneSocaJumbie]

Wait a sec... Lake Laogai... it all makes sense now lol #atla

[@beepboop204]

🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂

[@fixolas7761]

How have you not done a vídeo on Portugal, it was one of the 2 dictatorships that survived ww2, had a colonial war in 3 different fronts (portuguse guinea, Angola and Moçambique) and it was a higly anti comunist state

[@_nmcp_]

Whips were used...

[@FinUgShiet]

It's pronounced Qin Shrr Huangdi :D

[@derek7762]

“It’s reductive to call it a feudal slave society” *describes one*

[@williamthebonquerer9181]

So was Ethiopia when fascist Italy invaded

[@dr.woozie7500]

60% serfs… and the 14th Dalai Lama owned multiple manors and 3000 personal serfs. Did I mention this is the same 14th Dalai Lama who recently attempted to tongue kiss a boy?

[@williamthebonquerer9181]

@@dr.woozie7500 you act like Maoist china was better, great leap forward, need I say more

[@dr.woozie7500]

@@williamthebonquerer9181did I ever say it was better? I’m just saying Tibet was not a spiritual “peaceful” society the west makes it out to be. Pro-Tibet people seem to have no counterpoint to slavery in Tibet…

[@williamthebonquerer9181]

@@dr.woozie7500 no one talks about Ethiopia's slavery and feudalism in the context of the Italian invasion

[@-JA-]

👍👏

[@caseclosed9342]

“Well Tibet was considered pretty independent, how’d that work out?” -the Simpsons

[@ouyangon5711]

结果就是西藏变成以前一样的农奴制神权国家

[@meadc6754]

Thank goodness there are videos interviewing former serfs who’s lives greatly improved after the Chinese invasion. It’s not surprising because what person would choose to be a slave?

[@guangyifu7517]

Now I know why 1962 China and India war .

[@prateeksharma6706]

It was chinese cowardly attack our pm was thinking china is some civilizational friend and then u cowards attacked our pm held back the army for 2 weeks in thoughts that there is some misunderstanding else u would have been 👢💨

[@therminust4]

​@@prateeksharma6706 India are commonwealth puppet, in 1955 Chartered Air India sabotage to suicide bomb to kill China's PM Zhou Enlai but failed Then India being British & ClA proxy to training Tibetan separatist & give asylum to Tibetan rebels India illegaly overlap claim China (Qing) border dispute, by following British man lines (McMahon, MacDonald, McCartney lines)

[@russelfang7434]

No that's another story full of India's dream of Imperialism.

[@aAverageFan]

​@@russelfang7434 China's territorial claims are literally based on the Imperialist Manchu Qing Dynasty.

[@Tsungmey]

My grandfather fought with chushi gangdruk

[@jamesrussell5196]

Was there anything good going on in China during this time? YOW

[@shoshonewarrior828]

Surely make a video on the Sikh Genocide in 1984 by the Indian state

[@mat3714]

Algorithm

[@rosswebster7877]

I hope for a multi-part special on the Cultural Revolution, including the one in Tibet when the PRC turned ironically on Tibetan party cadres.

[@ThugShakers4Christ]

The PRC was just jealous of Tiberians' superior skull shape

[@juamu1132]

riiiight

[@KinLee919]

And tongue kissing skill

[@bennygoodmanisgod]

Long Live His Holiness! Free Tibet ☸️♥️

[@gedengcuo9260]

problem is China says Tibet has already been part of their dynasty since old ages when you look history you clearly see tibet has been catptured 2 times by Mongols and then 1 time by Chinese dynasty.All the other times Tibet was independent and especially 6-10th century AD when Tibetan Empire was at it's prime.After that Tibet didn't bother with outsiders and remained silent and as mentioned in video refused modernisation.Slavery never existed in Tibet as they they didn't have lot of wars after fall of Tibetan Empire.Tibetans were most if not all farmers.

[@jianyang6281]

2:40 put is simple, it was slavery.

[@tiram12]

Says Beijing wumao

[@CarlZha]

TIL many Tibetans today use iPhone in Tibet because Apple has much better Tibetan language support than Android.

[@alanwu2213]

Lol I have a chinese tibetan friend who works at apple, he probably is involved in development of that.

[@rosswebster7877]

Great video, as always, Cold War Channel! Too bad due to the recent Dalai Lama news, the tankies are flooding the comments section.

[@Game_Hero]

the tankies would be flooding the comments sections regardless, it is the Cold War after all.

[@rosswebster7877]

@@Game_Hero True that.

[@leroy5743]

Farcry 4 in real life

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

Nepal dude wrong country

[@leroy5743]

@@dhondupgonpo4578 Nepal/ Tibet almost the same hahaha but yeah good to know

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

@@leroy5743 xD great game tho

[@sonamtsomo1855]

FREE TIBET!

[@fzmoifzmoi2575]

Tibet has been free ever since the slave owners fled!

[@kenbolder4688]

@@fzmoifzmoi2575 Are you a Chinese CCP slave?

[@isaacasunciongallardo9781]

​@@kenbolder4688your naive lack of thinking

[@rg-dz4rm]

The Chinese did a favor to tibeten people .the Tibeten people were serfs (slaves)to a few Tibeten religious people.they treated their people like crap

[@papazataklaattiranimam]

#freetibet

[@MuddieRain]

For all classes? Or just the elite monk class.

[@bullpupgaming708]

​@@MuddieRain for all of Tibet. Full removal of the PLA and any CCP elements

[@jackcross4895]

Who would pay for the removal of Chinese elements such as roads, cameras or citizens? Tibet?? Or maybe india would :)

[@therminust4]

Tibet are Destined to be part of China, British Anglos to ClA tried hard to separate it into Geopolics conflict like the other Commonwealth nations, after tear down Qing Dynasty by Opium till Boxer Rebellion war - in 8th Century 1st Tibet Buddhist King, Songtsen Gampo are son-in-law of Chinese Tang Emperor Taizong, Tibetan Buddhism cultures influence by Chinese Mahayana Buddhism & Confusianism rather than Indian Buddhism (Indian Buddhism failed accepted & bloody conflict with Tibetan Shamanic Bon before), until King Songtsen Gampo successful unified them - in 13th Century Mongol Kubilai Khan merge China & Tibet became Yuan Dynasty, and create first title of Dalai Lama - in 18th Century Qing Dynasty create Golden Urn system for choosing 8th to 14th Dalai Lama, Tibetan Monks loyal and often invited to be religious ceremony in Forbidden Palace

[@berserkhorimiya]

@@MuddieRain You do realize that even the most poor peasant values his/her freedom right ? The 2 cent army failure to recognize sovereignty of everyone but China is amusing.

[@saturnalia2567]

Ni Hao,Wu Maos, If Tibet was a part of China in 1914, how were they able to delineate the McMahan line which is still largely the recognized North Eastern boundary between India and (Chinese Occupied) Tibet? Ni Hao, Wu Maos, 如果西藏在 1914 年是中国的一部分，他们如何能够划定麦克马汉线，这条线在很大程度上仍然是印度和（中国占领的）西藏之间公认的东北边界？

[@fzmoifzmoi2575]

Lol Who made up this Mcmahan line??? Go get some true knowledge instead of bringing up these western invented lines!

[@kenbolder4688]

@@fzmoifzmoi2575 Who made this invasion of Tibet by CCP rapists? Read some books.

[@jinghe5802]

Just an inconvenient fact. The Chamdo area hasn't been under the control of Dalai Lamas since the 18th century. Same as Amdo, the birthplace of the current Dalai Lama. Technically, the CCP was still honouring the agreement respecting Tibetan social structure in 1959. Land reform movements were carried out in the Amdo and Kham areas, just as in the rest of China.

[@hughanquetil2567]

NIce try. Amdo and Kham also weren't under the control of Beijing and it's doubtful whether they ever were. You do realize that the whole "those people don't have a 'real state" (often used variations of "they aren't unified") is a colonialist trope used to justify occupation and annexation, right? Beijing's territorial claims in the region are dubious even according to the corrupt Q'ing dynasty records' standards they used to make their claims. Beijing's modern take on colonialism adds the Marxist "We are all ethnicities of the same people" idea, but otherwise it's just naked colonialism, just like most of the West once practiced.

[@kenbolder4688]

Chinese fairy tales have only believers in CCP China

[@aperson22222]

4:22 I’m not a pro-PRC source, but “oppressive and backward” meshes quite well with my understanding of the country.

[@user-so5tb1hy8r]

Hey guys the DL might be a creep, but don't go all ProChina on this issue cause of it.

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

Thanks and not thanks. Iguess

[@KinLee919]

cia: he might be a creep, but he's our creep

[@ruwiki]

free tibe

[@bold810]

Soo.. I generally only comment on the thumbnail picture, so- hey did that white guy from the movie free tibet, already? Had alla that gear ready after the last dharmic KarmaKomeleonQuake? He made a lot of money that rich white amrikan. Stealing money from Sherla. Sherla Chopra-Vote Daal- harhar made youblook .

[@gyadre]

Every Asian country was no different in social structures than Tibet. Tibetans never bound their women's feet or women treated as second class as Chinese did.

[@erwinlee2842]

It is not a surprise if you are on the side with the Tibetan ruler and slave owners

[@colinmacdonald5732]

Back to your kannel, Wolf Warrior!

[@jamesurever3569]

peking lee watching KZbin

[@prateeksharma6706]

Dude make some videos about indo pak wars 😭 🤧 u made just one and now u have stopped pls make one on 1971 or 1965 war

[@ThugShakers4Christ]

It can be summed up quickly: two shithole countries who have never fought a real war fail at it again

[@premchopra6521]

Abe kayarta Pak war ke phikar chhodo pehle tibat azaadi ke liyeh socho kyun ki tibat ke yeh halaat ham kayar sadiyon ka gulami Bharat ne banaya hai jo tibat par pit pichhe chhal aur kapat karke aur cheen ko bar bar chitti bejha tibat par hamla karne ke liyeh yaha tak ki cheen tibat par hamle ke dauran hamne cheen ko dal chawal tak supply kiya

[@prateeksharma6706]

@@premchopra6521 india must stay south of himalyas and china can stay north of Himalayas tibet is in Chinese area tibet has no freedom and india should not waste its resources on such as well

[@premchopra6521]

@@prateeksharma6706 oi matlabi dusht insaan, tujhe kya lagta hai ladakh, upper Himachal, upper Uttarakhand, Sikkim, Darjeeling aur arunachal hamara Bharat ka hissa hamesha ke liyeh hai samjhta hai kya lekin bilkul nahi rahega

[@Abdal-RahmanI]

The fact that we will never have a "The Troubles" style movie about the Tibetan occupation is sad.

[@ianhomerpura8937]

"Kundun" was near enough.

[@ShengYu1995]

"From the 1951 Seventeen Point Agreement to 2003, life expectancy in Tibet increased from thirty-six years to sixty-seven years with infant mortality and absolute poverty declining steadily" The Tibetans traditionally depended upon agriculture for survival. Since the 1980s, however, other jobs such as taxi-driving and hotel retail work have become available in the wake of Chinese economic reform. In 2011, Tibet's nominal GDP topped 60.5 billion yuan (US$9.60 billion), nearly more than seven times as big as the 11.78 billion yuan (US$1.47 billion) in 2000. Economic growth since the beginning of the 21st century has averaged over 10 percent a year. By 2020 the GDP of the region surpassed 190 billion yuan (US$29.2 billion)

[@greyfells2829]

There's nothing wrong with agriculture, and life expectancy doesn't account for happiness. Chinese should go home.

[@davidw.2791]

Yup. The biggest question is whether such development could possibly harm the plateau ecosystem of Tibet, and not about what it does to the people.

[@williamthebonquerer9181]

Oh boy we aren't doing the "railway lines" defence of imperialism.

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

Is this comment justifying annexation by using economy as excuse? Reminds me of but we built railway, judiciary etc you should be happy

[@dr.woozie7500]

@@ShubhamMishrabrothey ended centuries of brutal torture and slavery. The current Dalai Lama himself owned 3000 serfs before he fled in the 50s. We definitely should be happy for that at least.

[@morewi]

Hello Chinese prisoners forced to spread CCP propaganda

[@ethanmcfarland8240]

But everything changed when the CCP attacked

[@juamu1132]

no more pedophiles

[@CannibaLouiST]

@@juamu1132 how childish.

[@juamu1132]

@@CannibaLouiST and the dalai lama love kissing young boys

[@user-ov2zb4sz1n]

不知道为什么西方总是把中国在西藏的统治归为负面，西藏这60年的发展是有目共睹。人均寿命提升超过100%，修建了数千公里的铁路和数万公里的公路，经济与社会实现了大发展，这些难道是错误吗？

[@tianlezheng6829]

西方就是见不得中国好

[@01Durhamguy]

Oh boy your losing some social credit score for this video bud!

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

The truth is worth it for some people.

[@fzmoifzmoi2575]

​@@dhondupgonpo4578truth? You're delusional

[@bl5608]

Most people in tibet don't care about independence. There are 50 something ethic groups in china. India 400+. Should all of them have their own country? Tibet and china today is 100x better than 50 years ago. Tibet pays only 10% tax to china, all the schools Universities bullet trains airport are free from china. Tibet people are the same as chinese people. They go to school together, work together live together. Some became doctors , celebrities, singers,teachers, scientists, government officials. Most people in china speaks mandarin + 1 mother language. Tibetian, uyghur, hui， han ,Manchu,，mong,Mongolian do have a country call China. US has 10x more ethic groups, Why don't they have their own country? Because they do call USA

[@icebaby6714]

Dalai Lama is no longer seeking for Tibet independence…on his way to Tawang he said, “We are not seeking independence. We want China to give us meaningful autonomy. We want to remain with the People’s Republic of China.” as reported by the Times of India on 17 April 2017.

[@cwhcwh1770]

Too late.

[@HellishPestilence]

The key problem for Tibetan independence is that Tibet didn't become a sovereign nation in 1911. They declared independence but it wasn't recognised by anyone, certainly not by the Chinese government. As a historian you should know that it therefore wasn't technically an annexation, which describes taking another sovereign nation's territory. It was a failed war of independence. You don't become a sovereign country by declaring it. Tibet needs permission from the central government or it needs to win a second war of independence

[@realpolitiksanta5980]

A Chinese invasion of Tibet does not make Tibet Chinese.

[@HellishPestilence]

@@xunqianbaidu6917 Catalonia, Scotland, Quebec etc. Only allowed an independence referendum with permission from the central government. Self determination only applies to freed colonies

[@edwardsnowden8821]

My God the rewriting of history in this video is beyond me. Political Tibet had absolutely nothing to do with Qinghai province or western Sichuan after the fall of the Qing dynasty. The map of tibet you used is false, as Qinghai and Tibet border was the ROC tibet border then. Jesus the lies in your video gives me migrane.

[@edwardsnowden8821]

Qinghai province has being its own entity for ages before the fall of the qing dynasty, it was officially made a province by the government of the Republic of China in 1923 with Ma bufang as its governor. Qinghai province even went to war with the unrecognized Tibet at thier border several times with the Qinghainese crushing them on several occasions, then how the heck is Qinghainese territory shown as part of Tibet territory in your video with you claiming Qinghai Gansu boundary as the Tibet china official boundary? my God your propaganda is tooo much😂😂 i remove my hat for you.

[@pumitriii6160]

@edwardsnowden8821 how much are you paid by the CCP to spend your days copy pasting pro communist replies on KZbin videos?

[@shauryasinghrathore3316]

India 🇮🇳 Stands with Tibet

[@OaklandTownship]

Then return the occupied South Tibet

[@ProletarianNuklearWarrior]

those priests and monks had it coming.

[@Tenzing91]

Free Tibet !! ✊🏼 China shame on you !

[@StephenLuke]

Down with the PRC! 🇨🇳🚫

[@vilx1308]

Free that boyyy

[@AbuShivaToyib]

Free your tongue

[@Tenzing91]

@@AbuShivaToyib free your mom.

[@Tenzing91]

@@vilx1308 free your Ass boy ..

[@zw1840]

It's good to understand The Cord War from western perspective

[@Game_Hero]

*the tibetan perspective.

[@facebookmary7502]

​@@Game_HeroIf your Blatantly false propaganda maps are to be belived the Ma click which consisted of Qinghai, Gansu, ninxia are none existent in your alternative version of history. keep up the propaganda.

[@Game_Hero]

@@facebookmary7502 keep up the imperialism

[@texassabre7214]

CIA :-)

[@ThisNinjaSays_]

When your way of life is serdom aka "slavery with extra steps" 👀. After the Daila Lama's TongueGate...I'm not so sure about the Tibetans old traditions honestly.

[@ThisNinjaSays_]

The Chinese should have left them alone so that Tibetan serfs can struggle for their own liberation on their own terms. The whole thing of "liberating" people who have not asked to be liberated leads to bitter resentment. Communist values are not universal and should never be forced on people.

[@fzmoifzmoi2575]

​@@ThisNinjaSays_in opposed to US "liberating" countries that never asked? 🤣

[@kenbolder4688]

@@fzmoifzmoi2575 nobody asked you about your support for Mao and Pol Pot 🤡

[@010Jordi]

After seeing the lama recently people should understand we don't want people like that in charge of a country

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

we? u Tibetan? don't think so. go ahead ask any tibetan that. I'm not even gonna explain the misunderstanding of our culture to u.

[@KinLee919]

​​​​@@dhondupgonpo4578 go ask a Tibetan who LIVING IN tibet, will they wanna go back to be a slave for the lamas. Go ask them.

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

​@@KinLee919 Slave? didnt u listing to the video. there is a lot a fake news about slavery in Tibet. and u are saying that to a Tibetan. tsewang norbu self immolated. back in 2022 infront of potala palace. so u tell me i they are happy in Tibet? only 26 year old. He wasn't even the only one. more then 160+.

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

@@KinLee919 do u really think there is free speech? Are you that mentally enslaved and intellectually subservient and intellectually molested and ideologically molested??!!

[@lonestar4137]

Full of lies.

[@CarlZha]

The Cold War channel cashing in on the latest Dalai Lama sucking tongue scandal👍

[@TheColdWarTV]

The script was written 2 months ago and was planned to be released in April.

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

@@CarlZha what about it?

[@peasantmob1712]

@@CarlZha My comment shows only when I'm in my own account. If I log out the comment doesn't show.

[@CarlZha]

@@peasantmob1712 Apparently KZbin hide links by default to limit spam. it goes into moderation queue of the channel owner

[@peasantmob1712]

@@CarlZha That's unfortunate when you want to give sources so viewers don't have to take your word for it.

[@strassler98]

Could you make a video about the Tibetan political, social, and economic situation and issues between the late imperial age and the annexation by PRC

[@Jay-ho9io]

That's not part of the Cold war.

[@davidw.2791]

Just like how Japan’s colonial rule on Korea for 35+ years isn’t important to the cold war either. ;)

[@strassler98]

@@davidw.2791 or how American imperialism in the Caribbean and Pacific for +45 years didn’t impact world geopolitics during and after the cold war lols

[@davidw.2791]

@@strassler98 Yup. Cuba got on everyone’s nerves cuz they are SO CLOSE to the USA, but even if, let’s say, Tierra Del Fuego had become a socialist republic, it would still be Red Alert to the USA, because of the whole Monroe Doctrine thing covering ALL of the Americas.

[@Jay-ho9io]

@@strassler98 The Mongol invasions were fundamental to the eventual structures that would lead to the structures that would lead to the structures that created the Cold war. As were the Crusades, The triangle trade and the invention of fire. Put the series is called the Cold war, not things that contributed to it.

[@vilx1308]

Such good timing especially the tongue sucking scandal and the real slavery system of old Tibet been exposed

[@willumpfirst904]

Still don’t justify invasion, it just insane to believe that the communist invaded out of good faith to “liberate” Tibet, but more like a imperialist justification to get land…

[@UAuaUAuaUA]

such good timing with xi dictator as your advisor

[@joshuawindsor895]

​@@UAuaUAuaUA okay boomer if you ever been to Tibet before.

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

China accuses Tibet of feudalism. Mao proceeds to enslave 10s of millions in the Laogai system and kills 300,000 Tibets with starvation and at least 30 million Chinese.

[@UAuaUAuaUA]

@@joshuawindsor895 ok windsor baby if you have been anywhere

[@prateeksharma6706]

Very soon PRC's commanders of keyboard forces will see this video and come to suppress rebellion on KZbin aswell 😂

[@jackcross4895]

Making anti wumao comments in 2023 is laughable. They control western social media algorithms nearly nobody knows about this stuff.

[@AbuShivaToyib]

Yes your mom said so too

[@craiglesher6172]

-1000000 social credit with uncle pooh. [phone] for this important info

[@michealoflaherty1265]

When it comes to the "People's Liberation army", liberation tends to look a lot like repression

[@leexingha]

and democracy is destroying middle-east, Vietnam, Korea, Venezuela, Afghanistan, Hawaii & countless more 😁

[@yudiji1596]

Think about all the information you could got is from its Hostile factions' source, though they all claim their research's "Objective"&"Neutral"

[@jackcross4895]

Well it was named when they didn't have control of china and wanted to advertise to rural elements. Liberation generally meant massacres of landlords which was nominally appreciated.

[@lakshaysingh2160]

Lol

[@vilx1308]

Of course u will think that when u believe in propaganda of what ROC is a “democratic China”

[@user-uh8fu3mb9l]

The People's Republic had every right to put down this Chinese Vendée.

[@WarLionsofGesar]

The uprising of Tibetan slave owners

[@HWDragonborn]

Perfect timing at the Dalai Lama's tongue scandal

[@dhondupgonpo4578]

#istandwithdalailama Hundreds of explanation. pls share Thanks

[@the_feedle]

Free Tibet

[@StephenLuke]

Free Tibet!

[@AbuShivaToyib]

Free your mom

[@tianlezheng6829]

free your mom

[@edwardsnowden8821]

Qinghai province has being its own entity for ages before the fall of the qing dynasty, it was officially made a province by the government of the Republic of China in 1923 with Ma bufang as its governor. Qinghai province even went to war with the unrecognized Tibet at thier border several times with the Qinghainese crushing them on several occasions, then how the heck is Qinghainese territory shown as part of Tibet territory in your video with you claiming Qinghai Gansu boundary as the Tibet china official boundary? my God your propaganda is tooo much😂😂 i remove my hat for you.

[@prateeksharma6706]

Very soon PLA's commanders of keyboard forces will see this video and come to suppress rebellion on KZbin aswell 😂

[@chenyaolu4213]

1. China has speech censor, but US has much more censor than China. 2. KZbin, Facebook, Twitter, etc. are all tools of CIA to make color revolutions. 3. You say China is unequal? US is a very unequal society! 4. Media is the 4th power. US presidential election is the competition between media hegemony. 5. You dare to have discontent for the inequality in China? China do have inequality, but you want to live in Syria?

[@juamu1132]

so support the pederast dalai lama?

[@colinmacdonald5732]

The bots are out in force, we hear a lot about DL kissing, though less about Mao's sexual degeneracy.

[@prateeksharma6706]

@@colinmacdonald5732 yeah god knows how these people are comming here in so much numbers even though youtube is blocked like how can so many people use vpn and communist party do nothing 😒

[@joshuawindsor895]

​@@colinmacdonald5732 dalai Lama's slavery.

[@AlternityGM]

Imperial archives from Yuan, Ming & Qing Dynasties show that Tibet was never part of China. The Mongol Yuan did conquer China & incorporated Tibet into their empire but administered Tibet separate from China. There was almost no contact between Tibet & Ming Dynasty. The Manchu Qing conquered China in 1644. In 1720 Qing troops did enter Tibet to help Tibet defeat Nepalese invaders and Qing Emperor sent an Amban to Lhasa but the Amban was not a governor. The Qing called Tibet a vassal state (along with Mongolia & Russia) but never considered Tibet to be part of China. When Qing Dynasty fell in 1911-12 the 13th Dalai Lama declared Tibet’s independence from the Qing. Tibet signed its own treaties with Nepal (1856), Britain (1904/1914), Mongolia (1913) and Republic of China (1918). Tibet was unequivocally independent until forced to sign the 1951 17-Point Agreement.

[@pyeitme508]

Ok.

[@ckwaiutube]

please make video of US and Western intervention other countries politic.

[@jamesurever3569]

please make videos about Chinese invasions of India and Vietnam

[@fzmoifzmoi2575]

​@@jamesurever3569Please make videos on how they b-wash people like you!

[@UAuaUAuaUA]

@@fzmoifzmoi2575 get a haircut and forget about CCP crap

[@edwardsnowden8821]

My God the rewriting of history in this video is beyond me. Political Tibet had absolutely nothing to do with Qinghai province or western Sichuan after the fall of the Qing dynasty. The map of tibet you used is false, as Qinghai and Tibet border was the ROC tibet border then. Jesus the lies in your video gives me migrane.