Timothy Snyder, Marci Shore, and Volodymyr Yermolenko at Yale

[@serhiikhomenko3821]

Чудова розмова. Дякую, що несете українську думку на англомовну аудиторію

[@thomassparrevohn8577]

Very good and enlightening conversation thank you all❤

[@inzhener2007]

Thank you 🙏

[@aisteniko4982]

Thank you 🇱🇹 ❤ 🇺🇦

[@cmbergersct3492]

Thank you for introducing the word "liminality" to me. I've been aware of the concept but I didn't know it had a word. I love your podcast, especially the ones where you talk to people. My sister and I both have become very interested in Ukraine from a place where we really knew nothing about it - even though some of our great grandparents probably came from Belarus. I enjoy learning about the intellectual, spiritual and philosophical depths

[@hablemosdepolitica-i2q]

Great. Thanks.

[@minoramare5829]

Thanks a lot. Great conversation ❤

[@MarcosElMalo2]

Why am I only discovering this channel now?

[@proshacot]

Better late than never, right?

[@petermallm149]

If You are curious, You'll find new sources as we move on. I have made your experience since years and I have to admit, it is pretty difficult to find trustful platforms cause the choice is vast and it takes quite some time to validate if you are on the right path or mislead. I do follow Timothy Snyder & others, check these groups and individuals they meet just as a staring point. It is a lifelong journey you embarked on and it will never end......stay curious 🏁🏁🏁

[@OrcFromTheFog]

Very interesting conversation. Thanks.

[@nicolaebulgaru]

good, deep conversation not only about ukraine. timothy snider is an exceedingly deep thinker.

[@jljones6343]

Professor Yermolenko's description made me think of the siege of Sarajevo; so stark a memory of evil and here it is again.

[@hannarpenko2520]

Skovoroda ✨️ *** 33:50 - loved the part about authenticity. It might also explain why Ukrainians who, for various reasons, don't return to Ukraine, feel often more desperate than the ones living in Ukraine all this time.

[@larysarowland2958]

great..

[@christopherj.osheav5807]

DATELINE KYIV OBLAST A good, timely, and informative conversation. Keep up the good fight. Thank you one and all. V/r - IB An American in Ukraine (2019 - Present) GLORY TO THOSE WHO POSSESS THE COURAGE TO #STANDWITHUKRAINE!

[@albertusman]

Am I right hearing the recognisible czech accent by the first student asking, Ondrej? Czech is my mother tongue so that a native english speaker experienced how various english accents sound could prove me right or wrong... Just curious.

[@randomdude7384]

40:00 Tim sums up Russia in a few sentences.

[@mlight7402]

I followed the war until ~Thanksgiving 2023 when American sentiment switched from pro-Ukrainian to pro-Gazan and anti-Ukrainian. It was heartbreaking to see the valiant Ukrainians defending their home to start losing to Putin's attacks.

[@pcopeland15]

They are not losing.

[@pcopeland15]

You quit following. Ukrainians are not losing.

[@LacRagem]

Months after this switch, you claim happened the US gave 60 billion dollars. That's not anti ukraine just an ability to focus on more than one thing. I'm sorry you can't do that

[@arthurarthur6083]

Top

[@mainschannel]

DEMOCRACY - Respect for each other, and Governance by Consensus?

[@thedoctor.a.s1401]

What timothy said about Gaza and critiquing Israeli gov policy was extremely mild but its better than genocide joe, so I'll take it. he's right on the point that there is no military solution in Gaza but Ukraine can win the war. Free Palestine, Free Ukraine !

[@mainschannel]

FEAR - Feeling Excited And Ready FEAR - False Entities Appearing Real

[@randomdude7384]

47:00 More on the way Russia operates.

[@PremjitTalwar]

Too looooooog an introduction by Marci.

[@zipperpillow]

Who else has a book to write?

[@max_skim-pontoon-cough]

Slava Ukrainians kak chast Rossye 😍

[@randomdude7384]

40:30 Russia in a nutshell.

[@alko_xo]

So sorry for a good American professor who became a bad Ukrainian propagandist.

[@cliveengel5744]

Ukraine is paying Prof Snyder to rewrite the History of Ukraine by Zalenskyy; he uses word splicing to apply different meanings. For example, “Ukrainians Cossacks helped lift the siege of Vienna in 1863; no, it was the Zaporizhzian Cossacks fighting for the Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth.” The Crimean Tatars were on the Ottoman side; would they be Ukrainian Tatars in his mind? Ukraine was founded in 1922 and never existed in 1863; they were Polish and Lithuanian; the Cossacks were a Tukric-speaking tribe living in the Dinipro Delta and neither Polish nor Russian. Snyder is more like Politics Cal Commisar Nikkta Khrushchev than a Historian.

[@siweiss9214]

so much superficial conversation in introduction. they like to listen to themselves talk

[@siweiss9214]

I can't continue to listen to this irritating woman

[@zipperpillow]

She is annoying to endure, and contributes nothing. That's how you lose listeners.

[@proshacot]

This is an academic discussion. Not a discussion about some random stuff in your kitchen while having a dinner

[@zipperpillow]

@@proshacot This "conversation" goes nowhere.

[@HomeFromFarAway]

I enjoyed it. I listen while I work and appreciate different perspectives and a slower pace

[@jakebarnes28]

Can a person, moderator(?) point us in the direction of civil society building in Ukraine. Civil society seems a potential Achilles heel for the fascists?

[@Beretta249]

Any church. Any brewery. Any shopping mall. Any public plaza. Any place people gather to relax and bond and form a community. Ukraine is fantastically wealthy in civil society. I saw it when I was there.

[@sobmogx]

Only a Russian bot or paid employee would make such a ridiculous statement. 🇺🇦🇺🇲

[@proshacot]

@ jakenarnes28 you have been hibernating in you cave for too long. You should go and travel the world, including Ukraine, to see some civilization.

[@maryanngermaine2561]

Kudos, Jason Stanley, for making sure (at min 59 of 1hr 21) someone asked about Gaza. Unfortunate that Tim Snyder, with his extensive background on genocide, did not see fit to include this existential consideration in his answer to you. The only moral position is support for BOTH peoples facing genocide: the Ukrainians AND the Palestinians. Unforgivable that the US is only halfheartedly supporting Ukraine in its struggle against Ruzzia, but is actively funding and DEFENDING Israel's genocide against Palestinians. Which makes Snyder's talk of fear, Trump, and an end of democracy quite disingenuous.

[@chrisukr9996]

What is your proof of genocide in Gaza? Reading Hamas‘s charter I am sure about their intent to commit genocide against Israelis. That they did not succeed in the last 20 years is due to Israel‘s capacity to defend itself.

[@motv1765]

Because hamas is supported by iran and russia. Palestinians are in trap with their hamas leadership.

[@Kirstinevad]

Hamas is an abhorrent terrororganisation. I fully understand why Israel wants to eradicate it. The civillians in Gaza are not. Homes being eradicated, people fleeing from one "safe" place to another and being bombed again and again. People, kids being killed or cripled for the rest of their lives. Destruction of hospitals and making it impossible to get a fraction of the needed food and suply in. Starving sick kids to death. Keeping an entire population with kids, women, men and elderly people on the brink of starvation. That certainly compares to the severity of what Russia is doing. I dont mind jews at all, but I do mind the actions of Netanyahue and IDF in Gaza. So do a lot of people in Israel. It has to stop. How can so many americans keep supporting this? I dont understand. In Denmark newscannels show both sides. Does it not in the US?

[@zipperpillow]

This is not a conversation about the Palestinians. It's supposed to be about Ukraine. Palestine is hogging bandwidth.

[@proshacot]

Unlike Palestinians in Gaza, Ukrainians didn't attack Russia. Ukrainians didn't kill, rape, torture or took russians hostages. So there are no valid reasons to put Ukraine and Gaza on the same scale.