If you notice any inaccuracies with my theory, comment down below! PS, Credits to Wolfric Rogers for some of the SFX I used.
Пікірлер: 92
@JosefineKRespectfullyАй бұрын
Your theory is similar to James Cameron just not as high above the water. I think it’s pretty accurate. What is weird is that no one listened to the survivors who said she did break in half. It’s like they were the crazy people and no one believed them. Until Robert found it
@sushiplays8092Ай бұрын
I believe the reason couls have been that many people who said it broke in half said it broke at different parts of the ahip, and were not consistent, another contributor could have been that they refused that the pride of british ship-building could break in half, and many senior officers claimed she sank intact.
@JosefineKRespectfullyАй бұрын
@@sushiplays8092 That is true and that makes sense. I think a story was said that some survivors took back what they said and said she sank intact. I dunno if that's true or not.
@William_AftonReal-------Ай бұрын
Yeah, but one survivor drew it having a v-break
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
@@William_AftonReal-------No a survivor did not, a survivor described to someone the breakup, and that someone drew the picture. Not the survivor. The reason why that someone drew a v break is because he thought the breakup point would be underwater, and no one would see that it broke, so he made the bow a different angle from the stern. He wasn't sure how it broke.
@wheelie_1988Ай бұрын
@JosefineKRespectfully some was paid off and signed during recovery to say Titanic sank in one. That's why there's 2 report's saying she sank whole or split.
@lochlanmuir2291Ай бұрын
I personally think your theory is 100% accurate. Good job mate.
@Wolfric_RogersАй бұрын
That's not what Ballard's theory looks like... His theory showed the second funnel completely submerge still standing, as well as the third funnel almost fully-submerged when the breakup occurred. And about your theory, the bow section would sink immediately after the breakup, since it's full of water. It also does not explain multiple accounts of the ship being submerged past the third funnel and standing at a high angle when the breakup occurred. However, I do like the stern dipping back a bit after rising post-break - most people don't include that.
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Thank goodness a Titanic historian actually commented, and thank you for seeing that, and I will change it. Wait a minute, I used your sfx and I didn't credit you, I will be right back. EDIT: Alr I fixed the description.
@gamerbros4006 күн бұрын
By the way, the reason the stern dipped back was because the stern finally disconnected from the bow, but that theory is now outdated, I have a new theory, its in my newest video (Cold Atlantic)
@MrMarquepayneАй бұрын
Very impressive animation and information!!
@WhyIsJupiterInTheFridgeАй бұрын
Your theory seems really accurate.
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Glad you think so, and thank you so much for staying with this channel! Even though we barely post videos! Also here's a question I have always wondered whenever I saw your first comment, why IS Jupiter in the fridge?
@WhyIsJupiterInTheFridgeАй бұрын
@@gamerbros400I honestly don’t actually know, I saw this roblox rp game about the planets. There was a fridge with Jupiter in it, so that’s where I got it from really.
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Cool.
@Insurgent47Ай бұрын
There's no fucking middle piece in the ocean. It's inaccurate. It broke into 2, not 3.
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
@@Insurgent47Pls do your research before you comment.
@taigaspringtrapАй бұрын
None of the funnels collapsed in the 1953 film but this is cool
@lochlanmuir2291Ай бұрын
YOUR THEORY IS PERFECT
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
You know that means a lot to me, but I found out that it isn't so accurate, the bow was pulling the stern down in my animation, but a comment told me that wasn't the case, and the stern sunk all by itself.
@codiroberts7089Ай бұрын
The animation for this is superb & your theory makes sense!
@randomstuff138944 күн бұрын
with physics and other theories existing, yours is good, just mentioning the bow should go underwater during the breakup, the ship should list to a side and the stern probably shouldve not paused. what is another mistake is that there should be a top cant performed and the galley decks needs to fall. also, good job you got the fourth funnel collapsing correct and the third funnel collapses first, (even though it probably did not fall off)
@gamerbros4002 күн бұрын
This is outdated, I will make a new version soon. By the way, if you didn't know, I animated this.
@gothysballroomАй бұрын
The 2nd funnel didn't fall in the 1953 movie. You're mistook it with Raise the TItanic.
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Thank you for telling us, we will keep that in mind.
@gothysballroomАй бұрын
@TheAbnormalShrimp It's not. It's from deleted footage from Raise the Titanic which used clips from the 1953 film mixed with their own.
@ChickenUltraPro16 күн бұрын
@@gothysballroomwomp womp
@MasaboyUgon-do2otАй бұрын
At 15 min later the titanic split at 2:15 am
@MegaroGoji73Ай бұрын
wrong, she split at 2:17 am
@JohnPeterson-ib8suАй бұрын
my theory is that when the ships break in half the front funnel falls front and back kinda sideways
@MasaboyUgon-do2otАй бұрын
The stern list too
@user-te1ti7yj9fАй бұрын
This is sad 😔
@user-te1ti7yj9fАй бұрын
If you liked you dont have to but i thankful 🥹 but i dont have a channel
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Yeah I was the one who liked your comment.
@FigureStories-wg4qs13 күн бұрын
Good
@sahidulkhan9291Ай бұрын
WAIT THEY ADDED THE 1997 TITANIC MOVIE 1:17
@gamerbros4005 күн бұрын
I Finally realize what you mean by that, the breakup area is the same as 1997 film, is that what you mean?
@user-eu5eu7sc8bАй бұрын
Are you gonna make another video of all theories, Sagacity School?
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Maybe, maybe not. Oh by the way the reason I'm replying is because I animated this
@user-eu5eu7sc8bАй бұрын
@@gamerbros400 I was just saying options on part 2 of sinking theories or not.
@Moxie696913 күн бұрын
Actually non of the ships split or funnels fell cause the wreck was found in 1997 or whatever by James cameron
@deliveredfromroblox-nw4cvАй бұрын
the 1953 is wrong(according to the film),the 2nd funnel doesn't collapse,the fourth does
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
The fourth funnel doesn't collapse in 1953, you got it confused with a night to remember (1958)
@Japanesecatboi4723Ай бұрын
@@gamerbros400yeah I don’t think any funnels fell in 1953
@deliveredfromroblox-nw4cvАй бұрын
@@gamerbros400 *realize*sowwy
@deliveredfromroblox-nw4cvАй бұрын
@@Japanesecatboi4723 but it boom-ed
@haziqhakim59955 күн бұрын
Um the 2rd funnel doesn't fall in the 1953 film and so does the lights does not go off
@beccabehindthescenes28 күн бұрын
I personally believe how it sank in the titanic movies in 1997 or 1998 idk but yeah that’s how I believe it sank with the stern really high in the air the ship splits between the last and third funnel and the stern going up again and sitting there straight up then it goes down so yeah that’s how I believe it sank let me know how you think it sank
@MasaboyUgon-do2otАй бұрын
The titanic hit an iceberg and started to sinking at 0:00 am the bow is underwater
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
What the heck is 0:00 am!?
@lochlanmuir2291Ай бұрын
@@gamerbros400ikr
@karlitoxelmago19 күн бұрын
@@gamerbros4000:00 AM is basically the first minute of the day, 12:00 AM
@PolandIsgood-jq8xj27 күн бұрын
Why the La Hantise one Sanked so Fast and The funnels don't broke and It didn't split
@haziqhakim59954 күн бұрын
Is because when the lights turn off it was pitch dark and almost nobody could see it break in half but i don't really know why earlier Verisons of titanic didn't make the funnels break
@wheelie_1988Ай бұрын
If people knew about this. They would know that you used James Cameron's 2012 version.
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
No I didnt
@wheelie_1988Ай бұрын
@@gamerbros400 yes you did. If it wasn't. Why did it take you this long to figure this out?
@wheelie_1988Ай бұрын
@gamerbros400 the only little difference is you made it look like she split into three parts.
@lochlanmuir2291Ай бұрын
@@wheelie_1988she did
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
@@lochlanmuir2291Excuse me, did you just call me a she?
@SirRandolphIIАй бұрын
Your theory seems pretty accurate.
@William_AftonReal-------Ай бұрын
I think your theory is correct, but i think it split between the 3rd and 4th funnel. I also think the 3rd funnel collapsed because the split was almost completely underneath it. Then I think as the stern was going down, the 4th funnel collapsed.
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Wrong, the titanic DID break right in the middle many survivors saw.
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
HOLY CRAP ITS WILLIAM AFTON!!!
@William_AftonReal-------Ай бұрын
@@gamerbros400 lol
@William_AftonReal-------Ай бұрын
I just believe the Titanic Honor and Glory 2024 theory
@epiccoolguyLPАй бұрын
james cameron theory is from 1995, not 1997
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Yes but the theory is based on the 1997 movie not the 1995 animation. Notice how the second funnel falls a little late.
@rodolfonathanieljrangeles431626 күн бұрын
1:03 1997 split
@glutsa18 күн бұрын
вау круто!
@Tylerz_theman17 күн бұрын
The bow wasnt lit
@MasaboyUgon-do2otАй бұрын
At 1:00 am the frist funnel fell at 2:00 am the second funnel fell
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Wrong, they fell just a minute apart
@Wolfric_RogersАй бұрын
They fell less than a minute apart at 2:17 am and less than a minute before the breakup. Survivor statements indicate the two forward funnels fell simultaneously.
@German1990913 күн бұрын
The Mast Don't Fall In The Movie 0:32
@gamerbros40012 күн бұрын
Yeah it does, if you check out the side view scene after the bridge goes underwater, the mast is gone.
@TRIANGLE724Ай бұрын
You forgot 1943
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
I didn't include it because I found out it was made by nazis
@spaceguy20_12Ай бұрын
i feel like the 4th funnel would collapse when the ship split
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
However that's innacurate. The 3rd funnel collapsed because stress from the breakup was right under it, and it collapsed. The 4th funnel didn't have as much stress. Th 4th funnel broke because the sinking was so fast after the breakup that the 4th funnel fell backwards as water pushed it aft.
@lochlanmuir2291Ай бұрын
@@gamerbros400you are correct. It collapsed when his theory said it did
@MasaboyUgon-do2otАй бұрын
My 2024 teory the titanic split front of her 3rd funnel went water reach the base of the 3rd funnel the keel fails to hold the stern fell back with the 3rd funnel fell
@Sidecharacter191223 күн бұрын
The '97 movie kinda sucks comepared to antr
@user-wg8bh2mp9wАй бұрын
And who the fuck are you to have a theory??
@gamerbros400Ай бұрын
Someone who studies every day about the titanic for about a year. So if I had a theory, I could share it with everyone so I could know if I'm researching right. By the way, I animated this.
@user-wg8bh2mp9wАй бұрын
@@gamerbros400 right so if you're a serious titanic expert, why not use your face and name instead of a weird animation and even weirder name?
@LSF17Ай бұрын
He’s just hating because he couldn’t come up with one on his own
@user-wg8bh2mp9wАй бұрын
@@LSF17 nah.....I ain't gonna pretend I'm an expert after a few months reading and animation :)